Butt Talk with Kenny
Journey to Babel (Star Trek: TOS) vs. Gone With The Mimphs / The First Apprentice (Star Wars: Ewoks)
The word "iconic" gets thrown liberally. We talk about Linda Woolverton and D.C. Fontana. Kenny talks about Spock as a reflection of post-WWII...
The word "iconic" gets thrown liberally. We talk about Linda Woolverton and D.C. Fontana. Kenny talks about Spock as a reflection of post-WWII masculinity. Aspen talks about how amazing the Mimphs are. And we get silly.
__________________________
Get early, extended episodes on our Patreon at https://www.patreon.com/trekwarspod
Theme by Tosin Awofeso
Social Media:
https://www.instagram.com/trekwarspod
https://bsky.app/profile/trekwarspod.bsky.social
Want to ask us questions? Email us at trekwarspod@gmail.com .
And leave us a review! https://bit.ly/leave-a-review-trek-wars
0:27 The later it gets, the more you get weirdo assmen. And on that note, Welcome to the Track Wars podcast, the one podcast on the online Internet that dares to answer the question which is better Star Trek or Star Wars by going through both franchises and chronological release order. I am Kenny Madison, the Star Trek contingent, and with me as my co host, with the my host, I'm Aspen Webster. I am not on the online Internet. I am on the intranet offline. I've set my work to be offline available and when I reconnect to the Internet, it will sync. I am in support of Star Wars. He sends to me online Internet, and it was so funny to me. Yeah, that's right. And speaking of reconnections, still too, is this episode of track Wars about reconnections? As we watch some at least one iconic episode hadn't watched the other Ewok episodes before. But we're watching Journey to Babel versus Gone with the Nymphs versus The First Apprentice, My dude, my guy, my brow, my friend, Yessen. What a night, What a night, What a night of television, What a night of premiere television. This was on loves not seen since I don't know
2:05 built my mother the car. No, it's actually a really good ship. It was great. This is the TV we watched some good TV. Did you know two of the episode? You do know this because you're the researcher. I like the research the episode. Oh, we'll talk about this. Gone with the Nymphs written by Linda Wolverton. We'll talk about that. And then, of course, uh, the I got it. I gotta clarify, not Gone with the Nymphs, Gone with the Nymphs, Nymphs, Nymphs, radically different episode if it was Gone with nips, especially children Star Wars TV show, Gone with the Wood Nymphs, naked in the woods, naked, Mike turning into trees because they're trying to get away from Dionysus, Gone with the Nymphs, Gone with the Memphs. My favorite Lily Lily Putiens.
3:05 Uh yeah, written by a woman, Linda Wolverton. And then Journey to Babel written by DC Fontana, who I'm realizing is my girl my girl? So interesting. Yeah, otherwise that's yeah, not that, and we almost got we almost got across the boarder. But then that's stupid. Paul Deini get out of her pall. I don't need the p Yeah. Well, let's be real. Diversity shouldn't just include white women. But I am looking for anything I can get here, and I could feel, uh, we'll get into this. But I just have to tell you that I was thrillly thrilled to see, not to take not to take your research away from you, that Linda Wolverton was a screenwriter for Beauty and the Beast and the Lion King. WHOA, I didn't know that, and the reason and I was like, who the fuck wrote this? Is because I was watching that episode and the second episode also really great, but I was watching it, I was like, this is distinctly interesting and funny. Like it it's funny and it's weird and it's dynamic and strange, and I was like, I just really enjoyed it. And then I looked that up and I went oh, and then I also loved the other one. But then I was also watching the Journey to Babel and I was like, why is every moment of this interesting? Why is this all about feelings and parental familial relationships and what do we mean to each other? And I was like, DC, my girl,
4:36 Well, ask when, before we get too much into the wonderful themes that are presented by the writers of these episodes, why don't we present some synopsies for folks that are playing the home game at home on the online internet. Yes, on the online internet. A yes, oh yes, I'm low gray tiny storm that is in Aspen's room. Wow, this storm. That's funny, funny bunny. Okay, I got you, I got you first. So of course we're back to their two whips to make up the fall, gone with this two whips, this step reverse, gone with the mid slash the first apprentice. Of course, this is Star Wars ewoks a reminder to everyone. I think Star Wars is better than Star Trek because art is a binary and this cartoon is better than an iconic episode. But I was like, that sounds great anyway. Released October eighteenth, nineteen eighty six.
5:55 Like we just said, we got Linda Wilverson for the first one, Pauldine as the Ready for the second one. I guess both of them are directed by Dale Shot. Yes, so let's see. For the first, Chief Chirpa gathers the warriors to defend against a rampaging Hannah Deck and Wicket gets lost. Yeah, I just wanted to make sure because I only hear it, and I was just like, is that what was said? And I wrote Hannah Deck, so I think that is how it was said. That's how I wrote Hannah Deck. In my own notes, I was like, I wrote, why are we hunting it? What's the point of this? Anyway, we'll get into it. Basically what happens is, yeah, Wicket tries to go off and hunt it himself, and in the process he ends up in a river, goes over a waterfall. My greatest childhood and adult fear, ends up with his little head bonked, and then getting tied up by the Memphs and forced to perform. And the MEPs had the funniest voice I've ever heard. He's mostly just annoyed with them. It deeply very Gulliver's travels. I'm sure there's some commentary here on the English system of government if you look hard. So fabulous. His friends think he's dead. It's super funny. I loved it. It's great. Second episode. Sorry, I was like, is there more? There's more? Second episode? Uh?
7:27 The what we say? It was the first Apprentice and this one after Zaric. Oh my God, it starts at the wrong spot. There's this guy Zaric. I'm doing a better description than IMDb. Zeric was low Gray's first apprentice. Uh, but he was kicked out because he wanted to do bad, mischievous magic. Low Gray wouldn't teach him, and he just seemed like a bad guy. Whereas low Gray said, he was what did he say? He said? He said, I I'm not doing this right, but it was just very funny to me. He said, impatience turns you evil, basically, So remember that children. After Zaric tries to teach Tibo his dark secrets, Wicked and his friends come to the rescue, Tebow musters enough magic to defeat Zeric. It's true. Sarah looks in his little pool like the snow white switch and like may or Mirror, who will defeat me?
8:30 And they're like dobow and He's like the fuck anyway. That is such a good job. Yeah, probably the best job that you've ever done. Thank you so much. I'm just always there's never there's never a good medium. There's either the two like it's not descriptive enough on IMDb or it's like an entire Wikipedia article. Look, whenever we get back into more walked territory versus star wars he walks. I have a sneaky suspicion that the synopsies you get better. Yeah, okay, thank you so much. In the meantime, uh, I will do the recap for Journey to Babel, first aired November seventeenth, nineteen sixty seven, written by D. C. Fontana pretty much all her own and directed by Joseph Eviny from Judy Crosby at the Saint Petersburg Time in Saint Petersburg, Florida to Florida. I just wanted to get this done. Oh my gosh, sorry that you have to adjust that laugh cough right there. Uh. The fans of Stern Trek's weird, wise and unworldly Doctor Spock are in for a first rate episode tonight is. The story closely examines his unusual breeding and his relationship with his mother, an earthly and his father, a vulcan. Jane Wyatt makes a rare TV appearance as his mother,
10:01 with Mark Leonard as Ambassador Saric his father. The story takes place on a space journey that is besieged with emergencies, including a murder. Father is accused, which gives the story the necessary excuse for digging into the unusual Father's connection. There's also a very unique sequence aboard the Enterprise featuring several outer space types, which gives the makeup and costing people a big challenge. Pretty true, I would say, who wrote that? From Saint Petersburg, Judy Grosby at the Saint Petersburg Time. Judy, you were right. You could have read that. Uh November seventeenth, nineteen sixty seven. Incredible quick Q for you qq qq. The guy who played Sarah did he also play the Romulan from Okay okay? Yeah? The TV great where they are just like we like this guy was just give them another role. It's great. I love it. What was it? Was it murdered? No, I told you this already. I was about to repeat a story I've told you before.
11:15 But it's that on, not murder, she wrote. But Perry Mason that they use it as an as an opportunity to employ a lot of maybe older actors who still wanted to work, but you know, maybe weren't getting as much as many jobs as they were, and they'd be like, yeah, fuck you, I'll put you in. Yeah. And you know how I realized that in this moment. It's because I was reflecting on the performance that he gave, which is deep beat. Dare I say, I feel like it has a lot of gravitas, and I think it's very emotional. Oh, which is so funny. I know, how dare I, He's a vulcan, but it This is the great thing about vulcans, right where uh an eighth of a smile suddenly has folks that are watching this episode just pumping their fists of being like, what an explosive emotion. It is a brilliant exercise and acting of just never showing your top, so whenever you finally do show your top, it becomes showing your top, no showing show the top.
12:26 I'm stealing this from showing your shirt. Star Trek two The Wrath of Khan, where Ricardo Montalban shows up on set and he's stuck in Fantasy Island acting mode. Nicholas Meyer goes over and says something along the lines of you never want to show your top because once you go there, the audience knows there's nowhere else to go. Oh oh, And after that, Ricardo Montalban goes, oh, great, I'm going to get directed. How wonderful, and then he brought it down pulls back. So his performance in that movie then has a beautiful emotional arc that will get to he's also a top in that film, I would say pretty much, Yeah, agreed, I yeah, but there there is a very similar sort of oh deep humanity, what's the what's the episode again? With the oh fuck? What is it?
13:31 Balance of terror? Balance of terror? Because in that one, that character he's playing, there's a lot it feels like, just like a lot of world weary sadness. Yeah, like and you do what you have to do as part of the system, you're part of and we're just we're just getting by through the universe. And there is the same sort of feeling in this one, despite it being a very different character in a very different kind of situation. I feel like there's a lot of it feels like sadness, like weariness and sadness, and also like the sweetest little moments of love, which is just so funny because the whole point of it is is just there's a I mean, I don't know if if it's okay to dive into it already, but I guess we can make out. We're making our rules at tire bagas. Yeah, we're just in our first impressions. We're talking about stuff that we like and stuff Kenny by following the rules? Am I fathering it?
14:33 Not to again overuse that? But also this is well the formative episode. We meet Spock's mom and dad, and I will tell you I realized, I don't think I've ever seen this episode before. So it was a real mind fuck you because I have seen strange in New Worlds and so I was like, I've seen his mom, and I was like, you haven't not ans, you know. And when they first introduce his dad, his father comes, he gets by the way coolest. They do this really great shot where they like push through the door and then there's just a line of officers and then he they gets off the shuttle. They don't push through the door though, they just stay on the other side of the door. Yeah, they don't. They don't push through it entirely. It's just like the door frames them and it's fabulous. And he starts walking down and the look he gave them immediately was like, is that his dad? Because if I there's anyone who knows complicated familiar relations, it is me. And then as soon as like he was like, this is my wife and I saw she was human. I was like, that's his dad, that's his mom and dad. Yeah, but it's just uh, there's a point in the end episode where his mom is like this, the fact that they are vulcan is the reason they couldn't be father and son for like all this time. And I put this to you, Kenny that much. I feel like we always
16:03 see this with Spock and we're talking about it right now, like the smallest bits of emotion. The story of Spock, the reason he's so compelling is because he shows us what it is to be human, and his moments of humanity feel so overwhelmingly human that like overwhelmingly so right, And something about that relationship, despite being framed as vulcan, is so human to me. It felt so much just like anyone who's ever been like, yeah, I cannot emotionally connect with my father. What does it mean? He's not proud of me. It's just expected of me, you know, or you know, I have to serve a purpose and I must you know, follow him, and if I don't, there's disappointment. But I just was like a lie allay walk with me on this one asmen television. No, No, I'm just making I'm just making noises. Yeah, move on. No, I didn't say no, I said, you know, I meant to sing.
17:07 I want to walk with you please. So TV at this time is still kind of playing more to the cheap seats. We have yet to hit the Hollywood tendency that will come about in the late nineteen sixties thanks to movies like BII and Clyde Easy Writer, where we hit upon a more naturalistic rhythm of acting, more subtle, more subdued. And so we've got folks like William Shanner establishing the archetype of what it means to be a barrel chested captain, a hero, rough and tumble American man, even though he's Canadian Jew.
17:48 And then he's expressive McCoy, expressive Southern doctor Spock. There is a canonical reason, there's a textual reason for him to act, I think the way that humans might act more in real life, not being direct, kind of just trying to adhere to the job because this is the American experience. Oh but because the language had not evolved necessarily in television to it's still a more theatrical acting style. And I'm just talking out of my button, just kind of uh, because I have anything the TV and film history that I know, But talk with Kenny talking out my butt, I'm kiddy, I'm kiddy, chugging out my I'm kiddy. I mean the spots main conflict here is duty talk about your butt? Speaking of talk uh towards towards the end of the episode, what is my duty to Starfleet? What is my duty to the enterprise? What is my duty to my family? As that conflict?
19:12 Yeah, and how many, especially how many Here's going to be some grand standing right now about how many UH men and women, But this is a show written by Jean Roddenberry, who's a boy by boy. How many men UH served in World War Two and then came home and never had never were able to talk about their feelings because they hosted them exactly. And so we have this pervasive sense of toxic masculinity that reaches its unruly tendrils throughout the fabric of society. And Spock is kind of the emblematic of that, where he you cannot talk because his emotions are so potent. A wonderful thing about the freaking editing where you're just cutting around to reaction shots and then you just cut to a neutral Niemoy and you project all of the emotions onto it because you're just like, oh, Spock, no, Spock no, but his face is just completely unmoving. It's it's an impossible task to ask him, an actor, to so underplay it, and what a gift because you have to do so little, which I also feel so weird whenever you see Nimoy and non vulcany rolls, and then also later when you see Brent Spiner and non data roles, also feeling that because Brent Speiner is really great at data because
20:48 he's such an emotional actor everywhere else. This this says something to me about there's a lot of stuff here because I like, like thematically, it would make sense. I am always here to explore the toxic masculinity of not being able to explore your emotions. Having come out pretty directly of deeply traumatic event that before you had only just you know, okay, forties twenties eight, you know, just before the twenties of the years before another deeply traumatic event, and that people were experiencing shell shock which was trauma and PTSD ongoing trauma and the experience of that, the trauma felt in their bodies that was never able to be expressed, to be discussed, to have anywhere to go, manifested in a lot of anger and rage and misplaced duty and a lot of hurt to the children that came from them. And then you see that through intergenerational trauma. And even now we still you know, we've got boomer parents who had silent generation, parents who had greatest generation. You know, like we had these this kind of line of trauma, and we're trying our best to interrupt it. And I do wonder, Yeah, I think then about
22:22 those moments of Spock. It almost feels like a triumph when Spock expresses it, like when in that episode where he thought truly that uh, that Kirk was dead and then he came and he turns out he was alive. And when Spock truly not because he had spores, not because of anything weird, but he was genuinely so joyful to see his best friend and his boyfriend alive, and he like, like that that smile on his face like could light a billion suns, you know what I mean? And maybe, yeah, it's just there's moment of where it feels hopeful. I I love it when Spock gets into emotion because you know that he's so That's the whole point is that they're so so badly. But it's just not the way, It's just not how you do it. It's not appropriate. Asen I'm so excited for you to go through the arc of Leonard nimoy as Spot because he goes on a fabulous journey. The other to just talk about this episode just being filled with weighty uh looks at masculinity because we've also got a rip roar and h we've got a murder mystery, We've got ship fights. This episode is just it's it's chock full of great stuff. Being a freaking bottle episode. The whole thing takes place on the ship. This episode has everything a murder mystery,
24:00 ship at warped ten, little gold boys, drinking colored melons, knife fights, fake and Dorian's upside down boys, daddy son issues, and naturally a guy with a broken antenna. It is tremendous. It also has one of the funniest William Shatner performances I've seen, which is him trying to pretend like he is not still hurt from being stabbed by fake and Urian Enduran and Durian and and Dorian and Dorian and and and from and Or and from Casi and Andor. And he's like trying to convince Spock that he is okay enough to to helm the ship or held the ship, but you know, direct the show, so he'll go and do this surgery. It's also a medical drama Jesus Christ, Oh my gosh, where he does like a transfusion with his father and he comes in and the way he's playing it, he's just like, I'm great, I'm doing down here. How are you. He's like he is so close to finger guns in it, He's just like, stock, get out of here, just go You're great. It's so good.
25:33 Shanner's funny. Shanner is very funny. He's so funny. Sorry to just keep going on and on. No, it's a good episode. Uh. But also, you know we're speaking about generational gaps, Yes we are, and we get a little bit of that in our in our in our episodes that You Walk, we do not to just skip to the thematic connections, but I'm just you know, segueing to our first impressions that You Walk. I love it You're right, go on, I just feel like I've talked a lot. No much like but unlike Star Trek Star Wars as what to do, it's frequently involved in trying to get reproir and adventures going on, and where these two, well, the First Apprentice is more involved with trying to teach the lesson of don't rush, we gotta be patient, as opposed to Linda Wolverton's episode. And I just I just collected Linda Wolverton.
26:37 I'm so glad that you did the research on who the heck she is because I was just like, this is not Paul Deini, this is this is not well, I've only been covering this other writer for the past year or so. I mean both of them, both of the Walks episodes. I mean the First Apprentice deals much more in the generational gaps that what I would call a little bit of perhaps trauma. But what do we? I think both do also a deal in what do we owe each other? Oh?
27:18 Does that make sense? Not yet? No, I'll find it. I'll find it. It's also fun to watch this show again through the Kids on Bike's lens, which I am going to keep returning to, and exercising that trope of you're a kid, kids can't do shit, yeah, and they're like watch me yeah, in both of them, and I'm wondering, also, not to interrupt you, but I'm please, going to please how often that trope has been deployed of an adult going, well, you WoT you can't do that? You're timy yell bub bub. I think a lot.
28:06 I think it's on bikes comes up a lot because I which, and it is so as you've said before, so identifiable, so like understandable even as an adult, because the reason kids on bikes feel so engaging is because you know, even as an adult, what it's like to not have agency and to fight back against something, or to fight back against a structure that says that it knows more than you, and you're like, I don't think, so I have to five for what I think is just. And I might be thirty four, but like sometimes I still feel the way I might have felt when I was nine and I didn't have power. But at least now I have money so and a car, not just a bike. So instead of kids on bike, you are adult. I'm an adult in car with paycheck but no real institutional power in I mean, this happens a lot in Ewoks, and it is the it's never one of us, it's always all of us together. So one of us might be the one to try to capture the Hannah deck and then we find ourselves in a weird situation, but like our friends will come to find us to be with us, to save us because they love us. And in the second one, too, there is this funny bit because Zarak does this thing where he's like, will defeat me, and it's he sees t Bow and this little reflection and so he's
29:38 like, cool, I'll trick him, right, And then he's like this little doufis this is the one that defeats me, and he's just like a bur I'm a little body. And then it's like almost the sort of but it's like he Harry Potter, is it. It's like Harry Potter's power is he has friends and it's really good at expelliarmis like basically like he's like, it's not just that it's te Bow, it's that it's t Bow supported by the people who love him, plus low Gray and a little simple trick.
30:25 Yeah, Nissa, who is Hermione for sure. Uh, and requisite fucked joe In, but it's just very very Harry Potter of it all, and that's why he defeats him like with just like the simple magic and friendship, you know. And I just so I think that there is a real commitment of like we've got each other's backs, and we owe what do we owe each other? And we owe each other love and support and that I will be there for you even if I'm making fun of you. I love you so much I will try to save you. Speaking of commitment, Kathleen Kennedy, Yeah, Lucasfilm. Yeah, look, yeah, her her tenure in charge of Star Wars mixed, but okay, if she had honest to God courage, yeah, she would bring the miphs back. Fucking love the mephs.
31:26 We stand a mimph. I what are they? Mice? Little mice creatures. No, they're little boys, like little tiny mice boys, little tiny mice boys. Their voices. Have you ever seen that guy on TikTok who like voices his cats, And he's got like four cats and they're all like hey, dad, dad, and one of them is like dad. One of them just says that voice. That's what they reminded me of I realized that's why I could not stop laughing at them. The Myphs love chanting almost as much as me. Whenever Wicket says cavark, they're like, oh, yeah, that sounds good. Comark, come on, come on, come Barck, co work, come Bark. And then later when they're like trying to get them to perform, don't they yell something else? Probably I didn't write that part down. I did write down that one of their names is uh Thrasher Thrasher, the Mimph Thrasher than Memph. There's also Smasher.
32:24 There's also Smasher than Memph Crasher Smasher. They are a little mouse boys. They're a little mouse boys. I like the pitch was, what if there was something smaller than hewaks. I fucking love them. And then there's you know, Wicket's chasing something that's bigger than he walks, so there's even big bigger honker, just a bigger honker. There's a bigger honker chasing the little boys. It's like an always a bigger fish kind of situation. I don't get. In the film Star Wars, episode one of the Phantom Menace, they're in the core of Naboo, and they're almost eaten by a sea creature, and that sea creatures eat by another sea creature, and then Qui gon Din goes there's always a big a fish. That's where the phrase originated.
33:21 I don't know. I don't go into the deep sea much. We should set that as a patreongle. Oh my god, I really don't want to. It's so scary. I don't want to go to the deeper sea. Sometimes I'll watch a lot of really scary like videos of like people like under sea stuff or like there's like a phobia of this that's like deep ocean or like the ocean stuff, and I will watch it. Or I'll watch like boats out on just like the open sea on big waves. Like it's so much and I hate it so much. Speaking of hating so much, I think we our best villain in e Walk's yet the evil e Walk sorce or is Eric? Okay, well, don't you ever forget about more Rag?
34:09 But yes, go on? What if it? What if there was an evil you walk? You walk this evil? Oh that's true. Morag wasn't any walk. He was. He's evil. He wants he wants to take the quick and easy path, lifting big rocks and throwing them it. Yeah, his plan was weird, Like I was not sure. I guess he was trying to see what Tibo was capable of. Oh, I'm just I'm just drawing more parallels from oh Star Wars in general. Oh, I did not realize, that's what I feel like that. And then the previous episode where Logray used the force. Oh my god, Kenny, I didn't realize.
35:00 I thought that you were just saying stuff. But I was like, yeah, Kenny, you know that's right, the thing that you're on this podcast to champion. Okay, you see right, I forgot never seen the original trilogy. You just watched episode one sixty four times. I've watched it so many times, and every time there's a bigger fish. Yes, yes, he takes the quick and easy pet. Well, okay, I'm sorry. Are you saying that's like Luke? I'm saying that Tebow is more like Luke Tebow being like, I mean, yeah, I guess he is a little bit like. And then Zaric, Yes, you know, Zaric is the tortured apprentice that is Chief low Gray. You know what, You're right?
35:53 And also Tebow has friends I love him. Yeah, and while he is hanging from an antenna in below Cloud City, his friends will come back to get him and save him. Yeah, that is kind of funny. You're right, Like it does feel like you walks whether we're pulling it or not, like it's wait a second, yeah, Skywalker, Uh huh uh what the Wicked would be the Han and Lataro would obviously be the Chewbacca.
36:34 I think latar is C three p O but with more power. You know, she's got like she's got the like mean sass kind of thing. She's pretty Judge can be pretty, sassy, pretty judging. That's true. You're right. And they have fabulous fur. Yeah they do. I forgot that. We're both of them have great style. Have you ever seen someone pull off a b and lea letroubaka camp No? No, And it's true. He walks out really good style. Latara is a really good style. She's always wearing jewels. Yeah, no, you know what, You're not wrong. You're not wrong. Is this funny because if we go by like that?
37:15 Yeah, yeah, yeah, I think I think you're right. I think in this way, I guess Wicked could also. I think I think you're right that Wicked does match more with Han than he does with Luke in terms of vibes. He's it does have a similar like because it doesn't have to match like if Wicked is your like, he's not our soul, like Hero's journey, child like they all are like they all have focus in something they're trying to achieve. So and he has that kind of roguish charm and quality to him. I think you're right. I love that isn't that fun and much like unlike Anakin, but like the Emperor, Sarah does fall into a big hole with a weird sort of like well thing at the bottom.
38:08 So I didn't even think of that while I was watching it. Kenny, what are you writing down? Writing down notes for the episode notes for whenever episode? Oh? Are you writing them by hand instead of on the on the on the online internet? I am, well, because I'm recording at the closet that's supposed to my usual setup. It's really how many closets are there that one doesn't have any clothes in it? Uh. I would love to take you around all of the closets that are here. There's a closet that's so big you could put a bad in It's great for real, for real, this is a closet talk. I mean it could be closet talk.
38:53 We could start closet talk. Here's what both of these episodes happen. Comic episodes have a character named Eric, but ones with the Z sure say it. If we were saying it in Spanish, one would be Serrik, one would be Sarah in Spain Spanish. Did you know that that lisp came because like some king spoke with this lisp and then it became fashionable to speak it with like it's like either the Z or That's how weird is it that both of these episodes have a character? Sorry I did Sarah once Sarah Sarah Sarah Sarah Sarah Sarah two very different characters. And if you don't watching the Bastille Day episode of Battlestar Galactica, we'd be watching an episode with a character named Tom's Eric or not. I Love I Love anyway. Yes, I didn't even think, Kenny, you're out here no things. I am so preoccupied with thinking about the relationship with my father. I didn't even think about that. There is a well, I mean obviously I've talked about it before.
40:13 Well, we'll bring it to the four both of the All of these episodes are about in some way the generation gap, the generation gap being a motivating factor in our first episode, Gone with the memphs Our second episode the First Apprentice, the generation gap the failure to communicate with the first Apprentice and leading them accidentally down towards a dark path. And the later generation kind of or the newer generation being a bit more impatient versus the older generation sticking with traditions and whatnot. And then yeah, with Journey Debabo. According to DC Fontana, she wanted to write about the lack of communication and this new you in vogue phrase in the nineteen sixties called the generational gap. Holy fuck okay, DC, my girl. It was also interesting reading these are the voyages this episode was we've talked about in previous episodes. Not all of these episodes are pretty much are like fully one person. But according to that according to this chapter, basically a DC Fontana episode from page one to end. One scene that roden Berry added some light rewrites from Genekoon, but other than that, this episode full Fontana. It's interesting. I'm always agreed, Yes,
41:45 it is interesting. One of the best parts of the episode is when something terrible happens and Spock's like interesting and then Sarah finds out and he goes interesting, which is so what I find to be always fun in these moments is to hear from these are the voyages, what the what like the author's intent was, and then what we got out of it. Yeah, because sometimes it's not the same. Sometimes I have a different kind of impression from it. But hearing that is you know, like sometimes they're like, this is about interracial relationships and you're like, you failed. Yeah, it was. It was weird for a Menagerie episode where you were just like, I think the takeaway is that zoos are fun. Mm hmm. That is what I said. I'm on you can hear me. You can go back and find that recording and in that I say, Jews are great, zoos are great.
42:42 That's so gets exactly how I sounded. I was just like, lock those penguins up. Leah doesn't like, I want to redo that. Yeah, Girafts don't deserve to be brave. Yeah, because in this case, it is so much is happening in this episode in a way where everything does feel like is logically leading to something, though it should come off the rails. This episode is doing so much. There's so much plot. Yes, in this episode, there's so many events happening. I feel like all of the characters, and by all of the characters, I mean Kirk, Spock and McCoy, never Ahura Oh Bair have something meaningful to do and to contribute.
43:35 I mean there's the A plot with spots Seric and Amanda, and there's the B plot with the diplomatic conference. There's the C plot with the ship that's buzzing around, and then there's the D plot with Sarah and Is waltering Hell, well, but you're exactly right, and like there's so of course we start with the diplomats are all here because we're trying to see if we should let Corydon into the generation. Uh yeah, you believe I've done this long without saying yeah, favorite Star Trek Trope. Yeah, diplomats arguing, I yeah, there's a lot of this. There's a lot of it on this one. I'm so excited to get to Star Trek four just so we can meet my favorite diplomat. I'm also thrilled. So there's all these diplomats on the ship together, which is Wisebox Dad is there. Yeah, there's a purple girl. H Yeah, there's some little people. There are some gold little people, one of which was the mayor of munchkin Land. Oh cool, it's fun. There's a lot girl. There's some white boys with big white wigs. Yeah. And then also we get Neandorians and the Taller Rids. It's pretty fun Taller Ride. Yeah. So they're all there and they're all fun. And then but they're there so that you can have the tension of having Spock's parents there for a reason. But then there's this murder
45:08 plot. So TELLERI dies or pig Guy as I called him, uh, right after having this fight with Sarah. So he is suspected. But then yeah, like so at first I was like what is going on? And then so now it's like, okay, Well then he's like, oh, turns out he has heart problems, and I was like Jesus Christ. Uh and but the only way to help him is so it Spock can help him, and I'm like okay. So there's like a tension there. But then suddenly there's a knife fight with the Sandorian and Douran and and and and Kirk, and I'm like, why is this happening, and then it occurs to me, Oh, it's so that he cannot now man the ship, and now Spock has to make a choice between saving his father and protecting the ship while there is an actual threat against it. So even though there's so much happening, it all makes sense when they slot them all together and all has a logical flow, while we also still being true to an emotional core and that's why it works. And then to read that basically from the first draft, this episode is unchanged cool. That's crazy. This episode should not work.
46:14 And the fact that DC Fontiana Dorothy Fontana just bang this out, She's just like, Okay, great, I'll just fart out an iconic episode of Star Trek yep. And also she just I mean, she is the person that codifies whose Spock is the best and really understands repressed masculinity in such a profound way and understands what is attractive about that on a dramatic level. Jesus Christ. It and also you know, uh makes Leonard Nimoy into a star that then helps kickstart the Kirk slash Spock genre and slash fiction in general.
47:00 Yeah, thank you, DC. Yeah, I mean there is there's a reason why it is a trope to have an emotionally withholding person, typically a man, and to like be excited about the idea of like fixing that person or like that is attractive because it's like these like these like especially that it's almost like I like to call it the black cat like golden retriever dynamic of like if that is always a fun pairing because you have a sort of like ugh. So then when you do start to get the emotionality, it feels so good, like a little treat like it just gained you cheat and did I get it out of treats? Because then at on a certain point you're like, wow, okay, that's not a healthy relationship. We have to start working on our feelings and doing a lot more therapeutic work. But it's until then, great, great job out. Yeah. Speaking of great job, you're telling me that I'm doing great connections in great research. Meanwhile, you're able to connect the fact that we got DC Fontan and Linda Wolverton writing episodes this week, and you said that you've got a tank and a perspective on that. Oh no, I mean yeah, So I don't have a particularly well thought out one. I think I was just delighted to see that it was not just like three cis white men as always you give us your thesis, why are women better? They're not. They're certainly not, especially
48:34 not white women, because they're still often reinforcing the toxic, masculine, white supremacist views of the world due to a lack of resources and anyway, I do not think that inherently having women writers is better, but I do think within this context it is very much a relief and it does introduce what I imagine our different person actives, especially at this point when basically you are seeing our white men as writers and directors. So and I thought, I just feel like I was watching that Ewoks episode and I could I could feel that it was a little different, Like the style of it felt like it was going. It was being it was taking more risks, like a lot more with humor. That was interesting. And I could tell before even realizing it was DC Fontana. I was like, every time something feels fundamentally more like tied into the emotionality of a character and truly loving the interiority of them, I'm like, oh, it's DC, you know, like it's you again, Hey, so that's that's the thesis. The thesis is obviously more diversity like white women does not diversity make but think fuck. That's my thesis.
49:50 Speaking of think fuck, I think it's time to go to our favorite fuckable pairings in our special segments? What do we call it? I started ship it so a long time ago. Start dating this week. I quoted a boat, I dated a geek, but none of them could warp my drive into hyper space. The best of both worlds kept me in the second place.
50:30 Captain's log on a halla kron. I wanted anog. I penned a song seventeen more minutes advise in super high def aboard the USS Enterprise dt' don't you take my walk lighter and clip it? Don't you take my wretchered buddy and nip it spill the tea. I'm gonna sip bit a starship. Okay, let me think? Okay, wait wait wait wait wait wait. Of course, of course we will pick our favorite vehicles slash ships as well as our favorite romantic ships. So I will tell you I do have a favorite vehicle that might be your same favorite vehicle from Ewoks? All right, from uh from Ewoks? I know there were some fabulous ships in the Star Trek episode incredible. There was shuttles, and I know your beautiful take on shuttles.
51:32 There's like the Columbus, so good. Uh, fabulous stuff, right. I fucking loved Xeric's like bat wings. Yes, they were extraordinary. Uh, they like came down. It wasn't like their typical sort of like skin gliders things. It was like they came to him like he was Batman and and and sort of like fit on him and then swooped away as if he could truly fly. It's not even like he jumped off a cliff. It's just like they can fly. And I guess he's magic, so maybe that's why. But it was great. I think I wrote I love that.
52:19 I did write a lot of oh my god, I love this battie. Oh my god, his kite thing. So it's fabulous. So that's mine. That is my friend me Walks fucking loved it. I you already did mention the Columbus. I was going to go with that one, but also I wasn't. I'm not ending up going with that. I am going with the Ryan Ship, as featured in the remastered Star Trek The original series episode Journey to Babel and I'll tell you why. Yeah, yes, please, it's a rain ship. What it's got a little ring? Oh, it is a ring ship. Yes, it's a little ring. And that that kind of design etho, hearkens back to original designs of the Enterprise that Matt Jeffres did in sketching what the heck Enterprise was going to look like.
53:17 That wasn't a rocket ship and wasn't looking like anything else. That he knew that the engines had to just look different, couldn't look like anything. And not only that, but he understood that something with that amount of power had to be way far away from the fuselage because it would be extremely dangerous. Which is why there's a big ring, fabulous, and it's extending away from the habitable area. And that's why the new cells on the Enterprise or positioned that way, because they're supposed to be like in the event that bad stuff happens, you can just pop the new cells off and just to use auxiliary power to just kind of get away from them. Oh my god, I love that. And then I believe I'm remembering correctly. It's incorporating some elements from probably the animated series and maybe enterprised at this point because the remastered version did come out after all of those things, where there were some Orion designs.
54:21 The original version of Death, because I did watch the remastered version on Paramount Plus, didn't pop in my blue rays. The original version I think was just a big ball of light, which a big face. Oh so great. I have seen I've seen a lot of ring designs in things like space stations like two thousand and one, and a lot of that is like generation of gravity, is it like kind of that, So I've seen that before, but not much for a ship. Also, we didn't even mention it that it turns out that it wasn't an Andorian, It was an Orion who had been genetically altered to look like an Durian yea, which I don't know if we've talked about orions, yeah, but we have in we have, I mean Azerie, and we talked about the fact that the green woman couldn't necessarily be a blue woman because it was co opting uh vaguely Middle Eastern.
55:13 Oh. I forgot that we had already design and they couldn't make it blue because that was already a trope. But no, got blue. Yeah, I've I don't know everything about orions because of lower decks. So that's great. Fuck, it's so good. It's so it's a great ship and I love that kind of stuff. Is it as good as bat wings? Probably not? No, no, no, no, okay, favorite romantic ships. I'm going to go pretty straightforward on this and say Sarah and Amanda beat the classics. It's a classic. And I don't really like the dynamic of like Vulcan marriage stuff. And there's a bit of a like, well you know, he says it, that's what it is. But they have this cute little two finger thing that they do and they go two finger to two two finger, and there's just so many moments of like gentleness and love.
56:22 Yeah, if I remember this correctly, that was developed with Mark Leonard and Jane Wyatt and understanding that Vulcans are cold and distant people, so even two finger touch would be electric. And it is something something that sparse can feel alien and very intimate. It's like a regency era thing. It's like sexy just to see a heel or like or an ankle or it's a like brush fingertips like something about it. Yeah, is electric, and like there is a moment where Amanda is really just letting it out, like she is like fuck this like Jesus Christ. And you can kind of see him like it's just you see them gently sort of like he's kind of like, oh, you know, and like they touch fingers and she kind of laughs, and it's just so like marriage is so many things, and I think there's just a lot of like, you know, you you are like people are people, and we are always going to be like fucking trying hard and just who we are. And it's just about a lot of forgiveness and compassion for yourself and for each other and like the humanity of one another. And I just feel like that's what I saw in that a lot of So that's great.
57:50 My ship is seric in a Bastard Gab crying over here. Don't tell me that Ambassadard Gab isn't bringing real friends to lovers, dynamic enemies to lovers, you do know. I love that he is mad at Sarah because he's voting for Cordan to get accepted, because Corydan needs diplomatic protection so pirates don't just steal their unlimited dialeteum. While Gab is just like, but there's a reason. Look, there's a reason that Gab keeps bothering Sarah because you've got to know his opinion. Gab's so interested, probably because Sarah is a little bit I don't know. There's just something about the golden glisten of his skin that's probably activating gas, a little snoop glisten that comes from heart failure, sweating because he's dying. Gab's like hot and then he himself died. This little pay wants to go to market. I was like, I can tell Sarah is probably gonna die, so I'll die first. That's love, baby, That is love, And obviously we love both. We love all three of these episodes this week, but there can only be one victor because of
59:22 course, Aspen, what do we say, Art is a binary? Art is a binary and Star Wars is better than Star Trek. Well, Star Trek is better than Star Wars, and so let's answer the question once overall, which is better this week? Star Trek versus Star Wars? Once again? The episodes are a journey to Babel versus Gone with the Mimphs and the first Apprentice who went last time asmen, I'm gonna ask you for your ranking first, starting with Gone with the Memphs and the First Apprentice. I'm gonna give him a seven point seven seven point Wow, that's pretty robust, aspen you think so? Is that too robust? I don't know. Nothing is real anymore. Nothing is real. Ranking is like completely arbitrary, and it's just a numerical value that you're placing on a piece of art within the moment.
1:00:10 Although I will say that it's higher than the last episodes's Night of the Stranger. Oh, that was a really good episode. Yeah, but you liked us better. I'm playing with it, but I really did like these episodes. Yeah, they're great. Yeah, I'm gonna I'm gonna stick with it because what nothing is real? Nothing is real. I'm gonna I'm also gonna put a seven. Nice. No, I'm gonna do a six point eight. Oh because a because I'm in charge of the spreadsheet, so I could adjust it now. Yeah. Uh, and the I did find my attention to wandering just a little bit. But still strong apps, strong conflicts, that's it, that's it. Hot apps, Hot apps. Yeah, journey to Bable though, what are we rank this legend? Eight point five eight point five any particular reason. I fucking loved it. I think really strong, a lot of great shit. I will say I'm docking it slightly for the fact that it was there's a lot of plot. I know.
1:01:16 I said that I think it all worked really well, and it did, but there were a couple of moments where I was just like, what's going on? But still fabulous, always always uh centered on humanity and humor and relationship. Also ends with h McCoy almost looking right down the barrel of the camera almost and being like, is I finally get the last word? Which, honestly, it could have been like down to a five, and that would have pulled it up to an eight point five. So that's why we're gonna rank this in nine point one. This is an incredible episode. I mean, aside from the fact that it's a great episode of Star Trek, just looking at this mechanically from a stream writing perspective, I don't understand how all of this feels so cohesive. Yet it does. And just like you said, it all feeds into one another. It should feel disjointed, but it all really dovetails into each other really nicely in an economical wing. Because again, all of this takes place on the USS Enterprise on all pre existing sets. It's it's extraordinary, strong drama, strong character work, and McCoy gets the last word. That's great. That's good, that's great. That means that gone with the Memsen. The First Apprentice has a paltry seven point
1:02:50 two five this week combined average versus Your Journey to Babels robust strong eight point eight, just busting out of its button down shirt, these muscles rippling out good grief. I means that means that Star Trek wins the week, and I for one, and please just Podjaspin, I'm okay with that. I am. I mean, I still think overall, I have to stick to my bit. But if fucking love this, I just love Star Trek, let's be real. Yeah, and I love Star Wars, which is and you know who else we love asmen me well, yeah, of course, but I was gonna say more directly our listeners, Okay, listening to this podcast. Thank you so much for listening. If you love this podcast so much and just want to help us out a little bit, why not leave a review trek warspod dot com click on the reviews tab. We've made it very easy, and just leave a review either on the website or go to the podcast over your choice. Hopefully leave us a five star review. We love to hear feedback, like on our social media channels. Follow us on blue Sky or Instagram on also I guess Twitter, at track Wars Pod or blue Sky just crossed one hundred followers. Pretty proud of that. And then also, if you don't want to use social media, we understand, send
1:04:20 us an email trek Wars Pod at gmail dot com. Finally, if you want to help us keep the lights on, hop over to our Patreon Patreon dot com slash track Wars Pod. You can help us pay the bills with your five dollars a month pledge and in return we give you extended episodes. This week we talked about Ghostbusters, Frozen, Empire, Oh Bur So Cold, and also did James a Cast impressions for a while. So again Patreon dot com Slushtrack Wars Pod, and you too could join the five bulous auspices of folks like Timpa De Sosa and Olie Brice, Love Honey Rogers, Kevin Miller, Mark Webber. We love you, buddy, We know you're going through a hard Time, you love the heck out of you, Ryan Hill.
1:05:06 And finally, the writer of the fabulous I starship song Jaulty Partner, thank you. Oh while I'm at it, freaking shout out to the person who wrote our theme song, please go visit his work in the show notes. Check out the show notes and tap on that link that's in there. And he missed us. I didn't mention that Joel and I got into a heated argument during Journey the Babel. I was trying to just really quick because you mentioned them and I love him. Sorry, this is important, It is important final content. I was trying to argue that, so this podcast is choose between taking over now that Kirk is injured versus like helping his father by giving him a transfusion. And I was like, I I think that Scottie could handle this. Yes, absolutely, one thousand percent. Thank you.
1:06:06 The spot is being purposely obtubes. It's using duty as duty as a means to escape. That's what I said. But I think Spock is so repressed that he doesn't even realize that. And I say this because I feel that in my bones, I feel that I have done not necessarily that exact same things, but I feel like I have used duty as an excuse to get out of really important things. Justified Okay, that's great, thank you, Trek. Sorry, validated, vindicated. I am selfish, I am wrong, right, I swear I'm right. Oh. Speaking of dashboard confessionals, I have one more confession, Aspen. Okay, okay, I love you. I love you too. Listeners, we love you. Uh.
1:06:56 May the Force be with you and live long and prosper Also with you, Pepi beer m
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Spreaker
RSS Feed