April 5, 2024

Clone Wars Volume 2 vs. The Ultimate Computer

Clone Wars Volume 2 vs. The Ultimate Computer
Clone Wars Volume 2 vs. The Ultimate Computer
Trek Wars Podcast
Clone Wars Volume 2 vs. The Ultimate Computer

Great! Star Trek predicted tech bros taking over everything in 1968!

The Ultimate Computer rips up everything thanks to Dorothy Fontana. Meanwhile, Clone Wars expands to 12 minutes an episode and we're all the better for it. Aspen talks about how...

Great! Star Trek predicted tech bros taking over everything in 1968!

The Ultimate Computer rips up everything thanks to Dorothy Fontana. Meanwhile, Clone Wars expands to 12 minutes an episode and we're all the better for it. Aspen talks about how Grievous rules. And Kenny hates Grand Admiral Thrawn (a tangent).

_________________


Get early, extended episodes on our Patreon at https://www.patreon.com/trekwarspod

Theme by Tosin Awofeso

Social Media:
https://www.instagram.com/trekwarspod
https://bsky.app/profile/trekwarspod.bsky.social

Want to ask us questions? Email us at trekwarspod@gmail.com .

And leave us a review! https://bit.ly/leave-a-review-trek-wars

0:28 Welcome to the Track Wars Podcast, the Internet's exclusive outlet to try and answer the ultimate question and fandom, which is better Star Trek or Star Wars by going through both franchises in chronological release order. I am Kenny Madison, the Star Trek contingent, and with me as Per Always, the co host, with the my host, it's being Aspen Webster. You're a Star Wars friend forever and ever despite it all, I don't know why I said it like that. Star Wars. Yeah, not only that, We've got some excellent Star Wars to talk about today as we review Clone Wars Volume two versus The Ultimate Computer Star Trek Season the original series season two. I'm sorry, I love it so much. It's it's fab. We're We're in for an extremely good time today. Actually both they are so good. What a nice week?

1:23 What a nice week this was? It was a very nice week, because sometimes we don't have nice weeks. Sometimes we don't. Yeah. Sometimes I'm like, what are we doing? And you're like, I made a spreadsheet? I was pard and I'm like, thanks for making a spreadsheet, Kenny, why are we here? And you're like, thanks for doing this, and I'm like you're lucky. I love you and that you're a cutity, but duty aw I kiss your little forehead. Thank you. I need that moisture. Yeah yeah, drive scale. That's right, griss very gross. But you know what is gross? Uh? These two things? That was no, no, no if they are great? Uh beautiful, glorious, gorgeous, wonderful, everything is nice. I also watched like a billion Community episodes too. This has been a week of me just being like, the looks some nice things. What if I had been like, I've been having a sad week. What if I had been like, Okay, I'm having a sad week. Time to sit down and watch some Star Trek and it was like, oh it was I was like, give me a ship one the alternative factor. It was the alternative factor obsession. It was the Gamesters of Triskellian, like you know, or that one with the fucking white blonde people. Yeah, Like imagine if that had been the case, I

2:57 would have been like, Kenny, I'm so mad at you. Personally has nothing to do with this or Chance. I just feel like, h no. Instead, instead, Chance has brought us here to this glorious moment of making a bad week just a little bit better. I'm speaking. This is the vibe, This will be the vibe, speaking of sinking to the deep dark depression. Why don't we go ahead and try and lift people that are playing the home game and we're able to watch these things with us aspen, shall we Let's do it. No more depression for you, No more depression unless that's what you want, in which case we fully support you. And if you're having problems, Google low fee therapy or Duck duck, go it.

3:49 But we're not talking about therapy. We're talking about the Ultimate Computer, and we Colonell's William too. Here's the synopsis for The Ultimate Computer, aired March eighth, nineteen sixty eight. Story by Lawrence M. Wolf telplay by DC Fontana and directed by John Meredith Lucas from Steven ain't Shauer, reviewing this for the Tvkey previews Ultimate Computer, using as its focal point that the debate today about man being replaced by computers will still be a pertinent issue in the time of the Enterprise. This drama illustrates what happens when a machine purported to be perfect is given absolute control of the spaceship as usual in Star Trek, the problem post here is more exciting than its conclusion. In this case, the computer has been programmed by an in bitter genius, but the attitude of the regulars toward the machine's potential remains fascinating, and the actions of the starship under the computer's command will sustain your interest throughout this story. Thank you, Steven Ate Sure, thanks Steven, Thanks buddy. I don't know, I don't know. It's funny. I also saw some people being like the end of this. I'm like, listen, I've seen Kirk argue with a lot of computers. This was the best version of it. So anyway, ah, is it time for me? It is time for you? Ask them?

5:09 Ah? Yes, okay, So last week it's the same because we're watching Star Wars Clone Wars, the second volume. Yes, same folks. But I'll just say it again, which is that it was released, uh November seventh, two thousand and three, and it is of course created by Jendy Tartakowski as main director and writer. There's a few other folks who are part of the story in writing as well. There are, indeed, but who cares? Am I right? Just kidding? Those people really matter? Sh I say all their names I'll find I'll find them. You keep doing no, no, no, no, no, listen, listen, I'm gonna say it. Brian Andrews, Derek Bachman, Paul Reddish. Okay, just those guys, Andy and Gendy. Of course, Gandy, Gandyy.

5:59 They keep saying gend His name should be Gendy. Ah. No, we should pronounce people's names correctly. Ass been Okay. I'm gonna read the summary from Wikipedia for this volume two because it's not too long. The five chapters lasting twelve to fifteen minutes each to give the audience a look at Obi Wan Kenobi and Anakin skyworkers adventures in the Outer Rimed Territories. Anakin is Knight is a Jedi Knight, and Corossont comes under attack by the Confederacy of Independent Systems. This theen serves as a diversion for General Grievous and the Droid Army to sneak in and capture Supreme Chancellor Palpatine from Corussant season three. I guess that's what they're calling it. Kind of like the ending part of it delves deeply into and focuses mostly on Anakin's story and the relationship between him and Obi Wan Kenobi, while also showing their struggles during the war. It builds up many of the events leading to Revenge of the Sith as it takes place closer to the to the film's time frame. It's also an immediate lead and to Revenge the Sith, the opening scene of which takes place only minutes after the end of chapter twenty five. Although the season three chapters are still action oriented, the longer running time allot for more dialogue between characters. Sure did. I did notice that there's a lot more longer, kind of like conversational pieces in this one that there was in Volume one, which was a lot more kind of like shorter, faster action, which is beautiful and brilliant in terms of like structure and shape of show. So god, it was so good.

7:33 God, it was great. We had two dare I say gonna say it, dear Dare, like these are just perfect pieces of these franchises, perfect beautiful like this is this is, Dare I say, the ultimate week of trek Wars dere dere. Yeah, I don't think it's as often And it's not like we had like City on the Edge of Forever with like Empire, you know, which would have been a perfect week kind of thing. You know, that would have been my ten and my ten, right, this is like my nine and my nine. Not to give it away. Yeah, I mean sometimes like Star Wars is really good. Sometimes Star Trek is really good, very rarely unless like there's a purposeful pairing like Empire versus Star Trek two, Right, are there like two Juggernauts? And this week the question of which is better Star Trek or Star Wars is going to be an extremely fun question to answer. I don't even know. Yeah, we'll get to it. I mean I think I do know, but it's like barely barely only by like small tiny point one. Yes, yeah, like we're getting into granularity. That's stupid, truly truly ultimate computer. I think an episode which was probably at least according to these are The Voyage season two by

9:03 Mark Cushman, a highly regarded episode that I think in our twenty twenty four context has just gotten the most relevant. I'm so glad that you loved it too. Like, I don't know, is it as beloved as we are talking about it, because I've never really heard it talked about like I've heard other episodes talked about. Yeah, I think This is also regarded as one of the iconic episodes good. I think that says a lot for my taste in a vacuum. Yeah, because you know, I mean, sometimes you're like, well, this is an iconic episode, it must be good, Whereas I genuinely canny to answer the question you're going to ask me, I'd never seen this episode. Had you seen this episode before? I had not only never seen this episode before, I had just like I just said, never heard of this episode. Yeah, And so I sat down and I literally thought to myself, my goodness, another versus the machine episode blah blah blah or like smart creatures in machines or in balls or brains or something.

10:05 And I was like, and then I was like, it just absolutely entranced by it every moment. It's as opposed to look, Kirk talking a computer to death has happened, at least according to Mark Cushman, three other times in Return of the Arkans where he talks Lander to death, the Changeling where he talks moment to death, and then in Eyemud where the crew of the Enterprise talks to the robots to death. Robots and you know, Kirk versus technology Kirk versus industrialization certainly is a new theme, which is also ironic considering that they're going around in a spaceship, which is just the absolute embodiment of its mechanization and action, because you're literally in space. But there is a far more existential question that is being asked at the heart of the ultimate Computer that feels so real it now. And then not only that, but anchored by a marvelous performance, Oh my God, by our guy Richard Daystrom Blacula himself, Blacula himself. There are a couple of moments where I was like, what's this guy from William Marshall, and I only I haven't seen Blacula.

11:22 It is a blind spot before me, and I mean that with sincerity. I have not seen it. The only other performance that I recall having seen William Marshall in is a marvelous exer like a genuinely great Exorcist rip off called Abby, which you can find in its entirety on YouTube. Highly recommend it. He plays the Exorcist. It's right, it's great, it rules. I love it. It's a good time, you know. One of the first thoughts I had was, well, I'm glad we have another prominent black man who's not just a doctor this time. Yeah, because I was thinking, I was thinking very particularly. I was like, this is especially since oh god, what's the doctor's name? What are is doctor? But banga? Yeah yeah, And I was like the conversation we had around that where the actor was like, you know, I I what are we doing here? And I think that there's a real Like I was like, this is good. More of this of you know, different types of people.

12:24 Uh, Like you get to be a varied individual, Like you're a black man who's in this space, is being complex, you are a valued part of this community. And also you are like many things in a nuanced character, so you more than one line of dialogue, and you're not just a doctor, right. William Marshall has so much gravitas. Oh god, and then not only that, but gets to play I mean it's just a great character. Yeah, I mean, it's just a really it's just a character that uh can seem hand fisted at the time maybe, but then again you look at it now and you're just like they the only thing that they I would have changed is that this character would be less earnest, right, I mean, there's I know, right, like now, I'm like, wow, this is really the poptimistic version of this, which is the idea of a person who I guess yeah, for for more clarification for people, he creates this, I mean you said it in the summary, but he creates this AI to run ships, a true artificial intelligence, that's true intelligence that thinks yes and is able to is able to generate original thought and like, although his own that is into a debate which they have in the episode.

13:50 Yeah, I mean, I think it's just very very thoughtful about what it's presenting and his idea, his original concept. I mean, it's it's very much base in his own pride, as it is to be human, which is to be like look, I'm actually like valuable. Look what I can provide to the world, to the galaxy, to humankind. But also it is based in a desire to prevent death, like he out louds like he explicitly says, I want to be able to use AI to reduce the number of crewmen on a ship so that we have less fewer casualties. He recognizes the danger of the premise of Star Trek, which is sending four hundred and thirty souls out into the nothingness and it's it is a ludicrous notion that is inherently dangerous. But the difference is that those four hundred and thirty souls chose it. Yes, they chose the danger. It did drive me to ask, uh, well, what it's the point the enterprise? Like, what is the point? And I think which is the question of the episode?

15:03 Yes, such a good question. It is a good question. But you know what, it's a good question that they never they never like explicitly asked, but they are asking the whole time. Yes, like, which I think is that what makes it very special? Is I mean, I'm here for obviousness, be obvious as much as possible, But I think it's subtle Ty is for cowards. Subtlety is for cowards. However, they own the matrix resurrections. Oh my god, get out of here. It's not it's on steel book. Look at that aspen. Some some properties could stand to be a little more subtle. No, not that black cat. There's a black cat on the back of my steel book. So it's not being subtle, but nor is it being obvious in the like it's doing that thing where it's asking a lot of questions but it's never like, what is it to be a exploring the cosmos? Like, yeah, we know we're here.

16:04 We've been watching Star Trek for years now, right. It's asking that question, but it's like doing it. It's asking lots of questions to around it, and like, I just find it. Shatner. First off, we left Shatner. We stand a legend. We we are weirdly fucking standing Kirk and I don't understand what's here's my captain's collection of all of the documentaries that Shatner's directed. Huh, or at least he said that he directed. I don't know if that's actually true, because Shatner is a twerp. He's a twerp. We don't stand Shatner, but we stand Shatner. We stand, We stand Shatner, but we hate him. Seriously, beautiful scene so complex of Commodore Wesley has just pronounced him as Captain dunzill O God because because the M five has performed perfectly, Commodore Wesley calls him Captain dunzil Shatner does about face walks off the bridge. They explain that duncil is a redundant piece of equipment, and then the scene between McCoy and Kirk after that, where McCoy brings some drinks and Kirk is like, I have never felt this way.

17:12 Yes, And it's not played with dread. It's played with this weird mixture of delight and fear. It is it's such an unusual choice to make there, but it's perfect. And it raises even more questions because who Kirk is now asking who can he be? Right? What is what is not? Just who who am I? If I am not the captain of the Enterprise? But who can I be? If not the captain of the enterprise? If that job is done? What else is out there for me? Like? There there is an adventuring tone asked to it, which is so? Which is so? It's so interesting, It's so interesting. Oh man, the more that I talk about this episode and I'm just like, what if we just nominate it for Best Picture? Yeah? Right now? It Actually I totally agree the way that he plays his fear in sadness, his trepidation, or his like curiosity, Like, it's very fascinating. It's very interesting.

18:15 I am with you, and it makes me curious because I do think, oh god, I mean, I think I've often questioned, makes sense. Yeah, like what drives in a world where you don't have to work? Like it's a true utopia. Yeah, you don't have to if you don't want to. We're not there yet, oh okay, but those ideas of we fix the problems are still kind of percolating there, I think. I mean, the rules of Star Trek are nebulous, but the thing that we understand as a baseline is that things are much better. So this this show has so far original series has so far claimed that work is essential to being a human being, Yes, very much so, which I disagree with.

19:14 I do not think work is essential to being a human being. I think connection and purpose are I think naps are essential defining a human connection and purpose and naps and ice cream and kissing and kippy kits. Okay, there's lots of things that are essential. And but yeah, because there's a difference to me, I remember, it always goes all the way back to the like what was it the side of Paradise maybe, or but it's just like the ones that are like, well you just stopped speaking, you stopped your manifest destiny, which I actively disagree with, but I do not disagree with the idea that it is inspiring and extraordinary to explore, not to take over, but to learn, to continually learn, because learning means we're always expanding, we're always growing, and that cannot be replicated. Like that is a human or in this case of you know, Star Trek, not just human, but like that is a something that is defining of who we are, Spock being on the side of the M five and on the side of doctor

20:44 Dastrom. Yeah, a thing very much being like this is an efficient tool that is exceeding all specifications. But at the same time, Kirk is explaining his anxiety as any and goes, it is an efficient machine, but I have no desire to serve serve it. I don't want to serve. I want a starship runs on loyalty to one man, which also was like I was like an interesting I don't think this is a great man thing, but I do think it. Also I started thinking about this is what a good Startork episode does. I like start thinking about a whole bunch of themes, and I'm like, yes, Kirk is often like presented as a great man, but also it does go to show like what a true leader can be in terms of inspiration for others. Yes, and a good leader of course helps others to be the best they can be, to become, you know, to do what they need to do, whether it's to become their own leader or with like you know, but to feel empowered. And I think that is the difference here of like other ways that I've heard this presentage of like Kirk being special, Kirk is not special. No, And I think that's something that is fun well, even the franchise misinterprets it itself. But the thing that makes Star Trek so exciting for me is that these are supposed to be normal schmoked well, and I don't think the show. I don't think it's been misinterpreted. I think the show has said that he is not

22:14 a normal schmo like I think the show has. And I think that's what makes this episode actually better is that it's not reckconing any of that of course by any means, but it is like making more space for space, God is making more space for like. It's not like he's special, he's he is deeply charismatic, and he is smart, but he also has worked hard and has done like he has all of his commendations because of his commitment and people like that that have like he doesn't just have followers, he has friends and that's important, Like he has people that love him because he is trustworthy, because he is ethical, because he is kind and you know, and so I think that is a differentiation point for me of ways that I've felt like, I think and lesser with lesser writing, you know, like lesser writing what you could just be very like a total lack of nuance about who is Kirk? What is his relationship to fuck? And maybe that's like, ultimately why this episode feels so exceptional, because it's being thoughtful about fucking everything, my dude, Like nothing is ever like it's just this one thing.

23:34 It's like, well it could be this and this, which to me is ultimately And do we think it's because of my girl? Do I think that's why it's so good? One percent? Oh my god, one thousand percent, one thousand percent. Yes, And of course my girl being Gisy there's only really one girl that could be unfortunately, yes, Like I feel like her work sometimes she's had these like little Black episodes, but I feel like it's because other people came in and fucked with her writing. But this time she fucked with someone else's writing and I can only assume made it better.

24:18 Yeah. Uh, let's let's do a little bit of deep dive. Well we haven't talked about our first time. I understand, but like this is this is important. Okay, it's okay, we'll talk about Star Wars. Uh. Okay, So DC Fontana, DC Fontana, Dorothy Fontana. Uh, here we go. Fontana proved herself from of course, these are the Voyage season two from Mark Cushman. Uh. Dorothy Fontana proved herself to be a good stand in for the departed Gene Coon when it came to keeping the intrinsic humor in place in Star Trek, especially in respect to the teasing between McCoy and Spot. Uh. And then not only that. Uh oh actually sorry, can I interrupt you? Absolutely? You can just to quote to quote McCoy. Yeah, man, did you see the love light in Spock's eye? The right computer finally came along? McCoy. Do you know what McCoy's first line is in this episode? Well? Was it? I can't remember. I will just give you three guesses. Think about who McCoy is and what is that stake in terms of technology kind of eliminating the rules.

25:30 It is a perfect McCoy line that is just really simple. It's not like anything special, but like it is McCoy his relationship to Kirk, relationship to Star Trek in one line, I literally watched this. Sure, Kirk, you can't let a computer run the ship. You're so close. Simplify it, Kirk, a computer, Jim a computer. No, oh, you're so close, Aspen, you're so close. Guess number three. Here we go, simplify it, Kirk. Nope, take it back, Jim, No, Aspen, you're so close. His first line is I don't like it. Jim, all right, she said that. Let's see right, it's very simple. Doesn't even you just put that line in any episode of Star Trek. Have that be McCoy's first line. You're like, yeah, of course he's against whatever the central conceit is because he's full of emotion and he wants people to love each other. So it is funny. This episode chicily does call out the fact that like McCoy gets included in things and it's like, why is McCoy here. It's because he's my friend, our girl.

26:47 DC did a page one rewrite. Here we go because this episode, the story credit was by Lawrence and Woolf. Lawrence and Wolf had never saw the screenplay. He was a mathematician with an interest in computers. But what he did have is that he knew Ray Bradberry. Ray Bradberry was friendly with Gene rodden Berry, so as a favor to Lawrence Wolf, Ray Bradberry passed the script onto Star Trek uh and then as a favorite of Ray Bradberry Roddenberry Reddit roden Berry wants Ray Bradberry to write for a Star Truck because that just gives him more credit. Because Roddenberry is playing like six dimensional chests and being like, if I get this science fiction author on this, then this will make Star Trek even more popular, which means that I will have a job even longer. Wait getting yeah, boss, the mathematician whose name is Lawrence Lawrence, Lawrence and Wolf, I too did slight research right right. It was basically, oh gosh, no, God, damn it. Ah.

27:56 Can you think if I didn't what would have happened? If I didn't find that a clause button in time I was, it would have been fine. That's what it was. Based on his fascination with computers, So question did he just write a script or did he write a Star Trek script? Hmm, that's an excellent question. I don't rightly know because a part of me, you know how, there's this kind of conversation around Star Wars and the Acolyte we've talked about, which is like there's at least there's a couple of writers who aren't really that familiar with Star Wars that are working on it. People are like, oh, it's like, well, I mean it's it's very helpful. Well that's a good thing. Like you get to get and I want and I wonder if part of like the magic of this is that it's not necessarily someone being like I'm writing a Star Trek story and like getting kind of up your own butt about it. But it's like someone who wrote a story and then like I know you're about to read more, but like DC coming in and like making it a good Star Trek story. Oh so yeah, sorry, continue. Uh. They asked Wolf to do some rewrites.

29:07 He didn't exactly carry them out because like somebody, like so many writers are like, well this is you know, this is mine. I wanted to be my way right here we go. It truly is a thing all right from the book. John Meredith Lucas was in a hurry to find something worth shooting. Bob Jusman, supervising producer, needed something that could be produced easily. All of this stuff happens on the ship, and even whenever it cuts to a different ships still the enterprise and Roddenberry was still hoping to convince Ray Bradberry to try his hand at writing for Star Trek. Wolf happened to be in the right place, at the right time, the right material, and then John Meredith Lucas had, because they needed episodes, had Fontana begin her page one rewrite of The Ultimate Computer during the final days of November, with production slated to begin in little more than a week. So not only did DC carry this out, she delivered Star Trek Scripts Operate with five acts, the teas are An, Act one, the first two acts delivered on a Friday, the digital act written each day over the weekend, finishing on Monday. NBC received the teas are An Act on a Friday, and Acts two and three on Monday, followed by Act four on Tuesday, December fifth, and I believe they went into production on December seventh. Wow, a rush job. Wow, that's like some of George lucashit right there. That's not no, it's like this like Tyakowski ship writing Clone Wars in two weeks.

30:44 Oh god, So not only are you a student being like my girl, Dorothy delivered, yeah, over delivered, classic, classic, and you know what, we should give her so much credit for it, true, give her an oscar because Roddenberry is doing his a great man politicking and gene Kun is exhausted working on Star Trek because he doesn't want to deal with all the politics, and it's an extremely hard job because no one's ever made a Star Trek before they're Star Track, So he's having to answer a whole bunch of existential questions in terms of production and being like how do we make this stuff work? And then not only all of this, John Meredith Lucas was the director of this episode. They allocated seven days and he used six so like, oh my god, it's all of these elements. It's the weird things in art where just all these elements came along at the exact right time to make something that is truly special. I love it. Isn't that incredible?

31:53 I love it so much. I want to rewatch it very rarely saying that we can't rewatch it because we still have to talk about Clone Wars. Let's just watch it right now. Then let's watch Clone Wars together. Let's just do it. Let's just watch things together, more watching together. If you we could just hang out more? Do you want to just hang out more? Yea assassment? I mean, wait, hang out a lot. Do you wanna do you want to come to Plano with me and watch all the Star Wars? Oh? Fuck? Gross? How are you going to plane ow? That's the closest place of where this Skywalkers out goes playing.

32:35 Oh ooh sorry, oh god, I'm so sorry. Clone Wars Volume two again again, beats back, the whole team's back. I love it. George Lucas loved it even better. George Lucas's son loved it and was just like, I need to see what happens next. I need to see what happens next. Maybe it was always from archives. Gdy Tartakovski is like, Gy is like that was really hard. I don't really want to do it again, and he's like, do it again. But then Lucas is like, there's a battle of couruseant. Would you like to animate the opening crawl of Star Wars episode three, Oh, Kenny, and I have to tell you something about that battle. Of course, Lant Mace Wind do Mace Wind pops in and goes the city is under attack, and I said the hall plan. I yes, like poetry. So if they rhyme. I was like, what part Mace the other side of the planet where it's still a city, more specific out neighborhood, and Mace busts and he's like, uptown is under siege. He's just like, Wow, Riottville, little Italy's under

34:14 a try it sound what if it's like tiny Cao's gonna be like mon Calomar the neighborhood. Yeah, so good, mon Calamito because it's small moo yeah yeah yeah yeah dude. By the way, have I told you much? I love Coraissant. There's this like bit where uh Anakin is like walking through the streets of Corassant. It's beautiful. There's all these different characters around him. And I mean that in the terms of like their characters. It's like it's been look rough, like you know, it's like, oh, what's that? Who's that? And there's like a figure fallollowing him. And though I love the depths of Chorissant with all of my heart. So Anakin's walking your choruson and uh, not only that, there's a shaft of light ah that is shining on him because Gendhi is not afraid to beat expressionistic, expressionistic where's the light coming from, the same place music is coming from? Worry about it? Don't worry about it. Who goes a shit? You?

35:24 I don't. Oh no, it's a funny way. Believe it in a funny way. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, you fucking fascist. Don't bleed me out because I'm nasty. Yeah no, I leave you unbleed. I'm nasty. Oh, but then the hooded figure is bad. Man. They kiss, They kiss so much. They kiss more than they kiss in all of the actual like not the actual the live action films. They kiss so much, Kenny, I loved it, Yeah, because I buy this relationship in Colne Wars more than I buy it was two in three. Because understands human emotions, right then, George Lucas does. There's so much that happens, and I so, I guess because I clearly did. I was. You've never seen this before. I've never seen this before. Also, sad. So I was like, I'm just going to watch some stuff, but I'm not going to do my research. No, I did some research. What I was I gonna say, I fuck you, fuck yeah, fuck yeah. I didn't realize that this second volume was released, that was it was like released step like after because I remember I was like, oh, yes, that was his first one. In these like more three minutes shorter like action packed ones, and then it is significant. I mean, we can't tell this though, right because it's like you're watching it all is all one big volume too, but I could tell the whole story is

36:58 one big volume. Yeah, there was there was long or stretches of things with a lot more dialogue, and so I was like, is this still all three minutes? And I didn't look it up now, so that makes more sense to me. They were instill three minute episodes. They were twelp mint episodes, and you can you can feel it it's getting into more stuff. There's it's actually it's fascinating too because there's so many things that speaking of expressionistic like it's one of the best uses of like like montage type of peace I've ever seen of like just showing the extent of the war because you have to show so many battles, you have to show this growth of character and like this characterization just through a lot of visuals. Coming back seeing Padme again, the sadness of it when he gets his scar and the way she touches his scar, like ooh, there's like no words at all, It's just shadows and expressions and touches. Help me. He understands visual filmmaking. It's great. Am I turned on by a cartoon? Yes, yes you are, Okay, it's great. Also also it has oh, it has that entire sequence, that entire story where they are on that planet and they run into like but it's effectively kind of like these indigenous people's the planet species Nelvon

38:32 nel Von, and I assume these Nelons like this indigenous species to the planet, and he effectively has to because he's been you know, he's been made Jedi master in a hilarious ceremony. Hilarious, what what I'm talking about? It was very silly. It's so cool. He nighted him. They literally knighted him, and I was just like that, I say, so close to his he literally okay, you know what I did? Love? They chop off his little Padawan braid. Yeah, I guess, I guess it makes sense. It just I was like very much like that's so close to your face anyway, which is also because the weird thing about this Clone Wars is Lucas comes in sometimes it's like can you do this? Can you do this? And then other things like talk. I listened to the commentary and Gandy was like, surely you've got ideas for like what the nighting ceremony would be, like George, and he's like, yeah, do whatever you want.

39:32 Oh wow, that's nice. That's it was. It's so it's so it's so bizarre. They they were just all in their little cloaks with our little lightsabers. The room lights up just by lightsabers. That is very cool. It's fine. It was fun. It was very fun. Unbelievable. He's now a Jedi Knight, so he never actually kind of went through the full process of it, and he effectively goes through this sort of final trial just like because I suppose there is a sort of like inevitability to it, right like, even if he didn't do it officially, he's going to end up in this space just kind of there are nebulous rules to the trials, because right, there's like, I don't know, there's not time. They kind of say that he's done a whole bunch of things that are similar to the trials, and the one trial that he still has to face is the trial of the Mirror, right right, of course, as as always got to go in that cave over there, and we'll be weirdly cagey about it, Yoda. Sorry, so he yeah, it goes off to basically like find like kind of follows this path and finds the cave. Well, it's because they obi Wan and Akin are sent to the planet now Van because they're looking for general Greed this, yes, and the Chancellor is like intelligence that

41:05 we've got to talk about. Sorry, we gotta talk about Well we got so sorry, go on, And so they're sent to nel Vaugh and they're looking for Grievous and Anakin being Anakin Stous, a big honkin monster, which was actually a right of maturity for this group of neil Bondians. Yeah, yeah, right, And and they find as they go back that all of your warriors have disappeared. Yes, and so there's like clearly some sort of tail that they have about this ghost hand and he of course, has his arm chopped off, so he has a robot kind of looks like a little ghost hand. It's like a little ghost hand, and Obi Wan's like wait and seizes upon that. So he goes off to you know hes Sustensibly he's going to find he's going to find these lost warriors, but it is his own trial, it is his own experience of self. And when he goes into this cave, he sees a vision and it is one of the coolest sequences I've ever seen. It's so cool, Like basically as like the steam rises up and there's like lights changing, these paintings on the wall start to come to life, and I know you obviously watch I'm saying this for the listeners who should watch this immediately. And it's the story of like this warrior who saved them had his hand bitten off and then kind of grew this ghost

42:37 hand and saved everybody. But then as he's saving everyone, the ghost hand like it starts to consume them, and he consumes them and becomes this otherworldly creature, this this terror himself, and it's just like thank you, this is perfection. This is it? Like fuck yes, and like you know it pushes the visual language of Star Wars two. Oh God, it's glorious. Like it's kind of a stop motiony type of thing because it's it's paintings on the wall that it's almost like you know that like the little like shadow spinny thing that like it's like there's there's static pictures, but when there's a light inside of it and it sort of like goes, it like moves it like looks like it's moving. It's it's like that, and it's so it's kind of a little bit creepy, but so beautiful and so cool and so like the hand kind of movement almost like snake like you remember it used to play Snake on your Nokia yep, like like, oh my god. And then he ends up finding out that these warriors have been taken a zoo trope.

43:44 Yes, it's like a zoo trope, like American zoo trope from Francis for Coplo, who's best friends with George Lucas. Yes, we did it. Hey, Hey, it's just like horrifying because the I forgot which group takes them, but the ones that are like oos, you know, I'm turning the knobs on my my bodys the guilt, the guilt that some sort of guild girl is with you, you know those guys. That is established in episode two. But because it's nothing, I'm happy difficulties working because I'm not obsessed with the minutia of Star Wars. Please uh sign up on our Patreon Patreon dot com substructors Pod at five dollars a month so you can yell at us because we don't know what the robots are. A mining guild.

44:40 It might be the mining Guild, because there's the of course, the Banking Guild with their like weird face banking clan, the blanking banking clan, right is sorry, the banking clan. Of course, the Trade Federation. It must be the mining Guild. But they've been like taking these warriors and like fucking grotesquely turning them in to these creatures. Oh my gosh, it's truly unsettling real design. Yeah, they look like giant scary rats, like massive muscle muscle rats, massive muscle rats like beaver face out. It's just like horrifying. And but he rescues them and they're able, he's able to bring them home. It's like probably one of the coolest stories I've seen well, you're forgetting he brings them home, but uh, the I suppose the lead monster, once Anakin has successfully saved them, conveys through his language, which I learned as like a modified Hungarian, which is based off of like his wife's in laws, because Gandhya's wife, I guess it's of Hungarian descent, and so he's using Hungarian as the language of the aliens. This giant monster is communicating to Anakin, here's how to save the day. Yes, points to like some crystal in a globe, and then I understand, And then we get an extraordinary action sequence of Anakin lowering himself onto this electric globe and then puts his robot hand within the force field and begins screaming in such agony

46:16 that you're not really familiar with in Star Wars. It's uncomfortable. Oh it's oh that's right, because yeah, he's here, right, howould I e just gip this sticks in in, gets the crystal out of there, destroys the entire facility, and so that his robot arm is like blasted away. But they also have like lost to their arms too, like or their arms have been replaced themselves and with like weaponry. So they then because he comes out and he is now this vision to them of like, well, he's a reflection of the vision that he sees by crushing all of the mining guild. Yes, people crushes then, and then in tribute to Anakin, all all of the Nelvanians that been transformed rip off their robot appendages. Yes, to match. But I mean it felt very it's very interesting coming off of Dune. It does have a touch of a kind of like he is.

47:16 I mean, they're like, all of a sudden, there's a bunch of still guards being like more deep. Lucas is of course influenced by Dune for sure. I mean, aren't we all. I mean I'm not saying that's a bad thing by any means. It's like it was, it was fresh in my brain. I was just like, look at this, like deeply. I mean that is like he's exceptional, right, Like this's the whole thing, is that, Like he's so talented, he's exceptional, and this is like and you can see these like moments of absolute horror of like but also he brings them back. But like it is a danger to be this kind of figure. It's a dangerous space to be in. But yeah, it brings them back. It's incredible, matched only yeah, only by hell about how by terrifying Grievous. What's why this that the Anakin obi Wan stuff is really kind of the b story. It's true. The age story is Grievous trying to abduct Palpatine. Well shocked, TA has the egg story basically shak tie my girl. They're yeah, basically they're just running away with Palpatine while Grievous tracks them like a terrifying predator. Yes, what's fabulous is that Yoda is meditating. This truly is just us recapping just how great this is.

48:35 We like never do It's just it's just truly, we never do this. It's just like, I just look, there are so many because I mean again, I pulled my twenty year DVD off of my shell and put it in and there are just so many visuals that are stuck in my mind. The visual of Yoda being in meditation, his eyes pop open, pulls up the blinds and there are hundreds of Droid ships ah ah ah, achieving a scale that uh, we children of watching Star Wars since we're well me since since literally before I had memories you wanting to see all of these things that you know, you know are there, and and Gandhi's Clone Wars achieves it in a way that the prequels don't. There's that beauty. There's that marvelous shot of you're in space over Chorussant and you're pushing in to what you think are the stars, and the closer that you're pushing into the stars, you realize those aren't stars that are filling the sky. They're all ships.

49:52 That's no star. Oh. I love that shit. There's so much visual wit. There is a pirate boarding sequence where I don't remember what the Jedi is. He's got big honking horns. Doesn't really matter because it's an action sequence leads an army of Clones over to a separative ship on the outside of the separative operating in zero G. It's extraordinary. And not to mention General Grievous, did you know that General Grievous wasn't really locked down as Lucas was like, I'm not entirely sure who General Grievous is. Well, it's pretty clear I did it now I might because we met Grievous at the end of Clone Wars Volume one. Yeah, or also Clone Wars season two and he's a badass Jedi killing machine and then you meet him at episode three and it's kind of like a sniffling twarp, which is also cool. So Volume two season three has to wrench the gap between it all and find and split the difference. And because Gendiga is amazing and his team he's cool, grievous rules?

51:10 Did I? So? Am I misunderstanding? Where? Where? Okay I need to we happened? No? Where does this happen? In time? I'm because I think again? See? Okay, Volume two happened. Okay, this was December's I so I got this wrong to start. Sorry. Volume two is December six, two thousand and five. Volume one is Nonber seven, two thousand and three. That's probably that's going to be the DVD release. Oh that's the DVD. You're right, you're right, you're right. This time I'm assuming I am imagining because aired Sorry, March two thousand and five is when the chapters were aired. So this is two years later nowe Revenge of the Fifth came out. Yeah no, this is two years after the first set Volume one. Oh wow, oh yeah. In my mind I was like, oh yeah, so I I was like missing, missing this entirely. So what you were saying now makes sense to me that this came out after Revenge of the Sith. The episodes themselves aired before Revenge of the Sith. This okay in one big honking as a movie, and it needs to they now, and then they he now understands who Grievous is because he has made it and has like written Grievous into the film, So he needs this piece to lead into what Grievous is is in the film.

52:28 Yeah, got it, Thank you, thank you. It makes sense. I was like, because when they wanted to introduce Grievous, obviously at the end of what is known as Clone Wars Volume one, he's a badass, right, and Lucas was like, he's a cool guy. And then while they're making this next chunk of episodes, he's like, actually, Grievous is like this, which is what I held. It is kind of funny because he is still terrifying and he is like he just shows up, like there's at one point, there's one point where they finally get like Palpatine. They've been like Russian Palpatine to this safe house basically, which is so cool. There's like underground this like ship that moves like, oh, the way it moves like through Ah, this might be my ship, but it's like not a ship. It's like a subway, but it's like a ship subway.

53:13 It's so cool the way it moves and goes through this underground tunnels. And they finally finally get into the safe house room and the lights started on and he's fucking there. It's so great, but but and shocked. He's like fuck wait because she had like stayed behind to try to like defend off and she ends up getting there and so he's like terrifying. It's scary and yet and yet she's doing this thing where he's like, now you'll die, but she has force tied escape just to this like car and it starts moving and he just goes. It's so funny, and it's like it's so this is this makes sense and it's like, Okay, he's terrifying, but he's also a little dirby. Yeah yeah, when it happened, I was like joking, Guindy is able. Let's put the difference. It's great. And they do find that thing of like, well where does this cough come from?

54:09 And I think it's is it Mace who crushed Mace crushes crushes his rib cage, his ribcage, and of course yeah, because he is like Grievous, is like his The story of Grievous, by the way, as I recall, I don't remember what species he was, but he was a living not man, but like like he got a harf, he's a well, he was a full person. Uh. That's his like backstory on General Grievous and I And it has been while actually since I looked it up, So it's been a while. I'm gonna do this because I think this is important because I fucking love Grievous. I even like him and revenge, Like I think that he is a silly goose and I think his little cough is dumb, and I love him so much. A native of Khli, a planet within Wild Space Chili, the same as Shiliol, grew to become a fearsome warrior of his people and gain an aptitude for warfare and battle tactics when he led his people during Colice's War against their technologically advanced enemies blah blah blah.

55:13 He eventually took the name Grievous, contained his conquest, quickly becoming a war lord and earning a bloody reputation. So he kind of moved through that, and then he was that potential is seen by the Sith lords, and as he led his people in merciless war, and then let's see it. So I think, like, then what happened was give me a second okay, oh yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, okay conspired Okay, So sometime later, members of the executive Separatist Council of the newly formed Confederacy of Independent Systems, led by Duke, who conspired to mortally wound Grievous in a bid to convert him into a super cyborg subservient to their cause. I now Duca's agents sabotaged his shuttle, which resulted in a gruesome crash left the man on the brink of death. He was offered conversion into an enhanced cybernetic being by the Sith, who were interested in experimenting with technologically advanced beings.

56:15 His remaining vital organs implanted into a powerful robotic body after the majority of his organic body was destroyed, but over time he gradually started to make considerable improvements to a cybernetic body so that's the story. I'd forgotten that they actually did it on purpose to fucking like bring him in. So that's actually partly why I find Grieves to be very interesting, because I remembered that that he I do like the idea of this like some kind of frailty in it, But he's fucking scariest shit, Like there is something about his like real eyes within this like terrifying, like spider body. Oh goodness, gracious nanks to letting me read that. Absolutely. I mean, that's why you're the co host with the mother, because there's there's so much ancillarious Star Wars materials that I'm not familiar with I and that's I learned this. I'm going to get this on the record. Yes, so star like Star Wars fandom likes to clown on Luke. You're familiar with Luke Luke? Yes, the clone Luke Skywalker that's got to us in his name Luke. Yeah, he lives in Sweden.

57:28 Yeah, are you familiar with this? People like to clown on him, Yeah, because it's stupid. He's his name, there's Luke Skywalker and this clone Luke Skywalker. His name is l u u k E Okay, no, you're not you're not familiar. Okay, well, I know that this exists. And then I learned that he exists in like the Throng trilogy, which is like supposed to be the best Star Wars tie in fiction period, and I've read the first two thirds of it, and I'm like, this is bad. This is bad, and I don't like, Wait, sorry, I missed your I missed your bit is Luke and Thron Wait what are you sorry? What are you getting at this? I mean, this is hard considering that you don't have context for this person that I'm talking about.

58:12 You're talking about Oh, I see what you're saying. Sorry, let me explain the joke I'm you're telling, which is that because it's not canon anymore, Luke Skywalker is in these Throng books, but it's not canon. No, it's this, it's this. I'm I'm airing. I'm airing your a grievance. This is me airing your a grievance. And I'm probably going to cut this. I probably got cut this out of the final episode because it's stopping everything cold, but I'm gonna marry it anyways. Okay, so patrons, listen, to this. Okay, So the Throng trilogy, all these toxic Star Wars fans that are stupid and vote for Holiday Special over Last Jedi and being period of market, they're like, you know, what should have been done the Throng trilogy. Thron is a badass air. The Empire is amazing. It's like, that's what they should have done. And I'm over here having no like preciousness to that source material, and I'm like, no, it's because bad because they're like, oh, there's this magic squirrel.

59:09 You know, the Force is the greatest thing. And so of course the way that they defeat Luke Skywalker, they immediately depower Luke Skywalker by putting him around a whole bunch of magic squirrels. What there are these magic squirrels that just invalidate the force? What it just invalidates the Force? And so Luke Skywalker is now and so no what So Throng, this master strategist that was constantly just like offscreen, followed you, following you, following you in order to in order to because Zon is like, how do I write Luke Skywalker? He's so powerful? What do I do? I know what, I'll invent these magic squirrels that invalidate the Force just cancels out the Force, and so Thron is like, let's get a whole bunch of these squirrels, okay, And then Luke Skywalker spends the majority of air to the Empire in this jungle that is surrounded with all of these magic squirrels. No, I got you. So he can be put in genuine peril again because An is like, well, if a character has the Force, there's no drama.

1:00:20 It's super boring. He's not fucking Superman. No oh. Also, Superman's cool because he has emotions, because he's a decent guy, right, And Luke's cool because he also has it. He has character motivations that he's not perfect or superhero. I mean, he is a superhero, but he's not perfect. Yeah, Because there are existential questions so that you can ask within a piece that feels like an epilogue, because you're questioning the fundamental focus of what the heck do you do afterwards? Whenever you think that your story is done and the Empire is done, there are excidential questions of being like what next. That's and that's if your go to fucking write more to your original story. Yeah, but the dialogue. But it isn't it that it doesn't at least the two thirds that I've read of the Thron trilogy. And I'm sure because I am a completest and an a statist, as you can confirm.

1:01:07 Yeah, I want to finish everything right, so I will go back to it, even though I found it just like, Okay, so the best I understand, there's a whole bunch of ancillary materials that makes Thron the best guy ever that's ever existed. You can confirm this. There's a lot of good I haven't read them. Joel, my dear sweet partner has read. Yeah, you can do it for him. That's good. I think there are some actual Cannon. There are Cannon Thron books now or they're not considered legends. And he says they're really good. I really like them. I think they include I think Thron is a very good character. He's in Rebels and I was like, Okay, this is fine. He's really good.

1:01:52 He's a good villain in Rebels. He's great. But then and he's good in a Soka. I think too. I mean it's I think he's less impactful. He's less impactful in Ahsoka because everyone is performing like this, and yeah, it's it's different. Yeah, but yeah, but his because Rebels is dealing with a kind of a certain period of time where he is he's above middle management clearly, his Grand Admiral Thraun. But it's still interesting to be dealing with a certain kind of evil that I guess, like almost from an alignment perspective, is like this lawful evil. To have someone who's just not just the fucking emperor, who like has a certain perspective on things and a sort of deliberation that's very terrifying. He's a very interesting character.

1:02:45 So like we got good thron Yeah, it's good, that's fun. But whenever I read to Air to the Empire, the fundamental question that I'm asking the whole time is that is not I know that it's answered in later books, but I'm worried about Now you're telling to cut this, by the way, this is a good conversation. Disagree, No, it's good. Why because it's cutting the flow? Is stopping the flow? Stopping the flow. I'm gonna cut it. This is great, it'll be in the patrenon Oh whatever, you okay, you listen to it, Okay, I had Thron's Stupidron's stupid. You're telling me, you're telling me, and I've aired this green support and I'll keep airing it. You're telling me the best strategist in the Empire was conveniently off screen the entire time your ship to do. You had things to do, he had errands to run. Well, yeah, I mean, I guess for what it's worth front and that's I have no concept of him in that original like setting. I think him in Rebels makes a lot of sense. That's fine because that's a newish character because full is like, how do we emerge this to make sense? Right? Oh, it sounds stupid. You're precious air to the Empire and Zoon makes the fundamental miscalculation for for me, I guess I'm wrong because every other star wars wrong.

1:04:12 They're wrong. Is just like, let's reset the status quo and immediately make the new Republic corrupt. Kenny. I'm just like, this is not Kenny. I I do want to just say I I a lot of people, myself included, often like they've read something and then they are seen something and they are more influenced by like the way I made them feel. They're nostalgia, but better the quality of the idea of it. So you know, I mean, I know I star Trek five. It's hard for it. You know, there's a lot of things that it's hard to be objective about. I myself said, wow, am I enjoying Attack of the Clones? I understand, but so but also people are wrong. Don't worry about it. I'm with you. It's just with you. You need to you can't just immediately. I know I hate the Empire on record hating Air to the Empire. Fuck, yes, preach it. I might leave this in.

1:05:12 I don't know, Alliston, I like it. Let's do it. What are we talking about? I like Star Wars. Look at that. It's a custom DVD. That's custom. What how was it? Like? Did you design it? No? These are no. I printed out this cover and it's the Star Wars specialized editions from Harmony. You can find all what because I like physical media and I wanted to own it. You should wait. You know, we're moving in a few months, and we were thinking about things that we wanted to Oh that's fun. I like that, and we're talking about like, oh, what are the things we might want to like call and stuff, and I was like, let's not get rid of any of our CDs or DVDs. Like originally years like a few just a few years ago, I might have been like, we don't need these DVDs, like we've got streaming services or whatever. And now I'm just like, don't let them go. What if they disappear? Yeah, absolutely not.

1:06:04 That's so I bought my friend Carter Creek by Carter Uh their album released last week, Oh genuinely just a promo, a promo for them, and I bought their physical CD. And because I still have CD player in my car. Good. Cool. There's like something so magical about being like, oh, I'm not like looking on Spotify and like physically have my CD. And I'm just like, yes, there's something that makes it your media consumption a lot more purposeful whenever you take a physical object place it somewhere else, as opposed to h what companies want from us, which is passive consumerism.

1:06:45 Yeah, and then I like listen to the full album, you know, I like start from the beginning, and like I listen to the way that the songs hit each other, oh so good, and how they fit together. Yeah. Yeah, anyway, what are we talking about cravous. We haven't even talked about well commonalities. We allright, here are commonalities, There are commonalities, Here are commonalities. Both of these pieces of media are fire. Yes, that's the biggest commonality. I feel great. We're sad, but I feel better thinking about them. Clone Wars is raising a lot of thematic questions in much more subtle weight as opposed to Star Trek, which the great thing about Star Trek is whenever it talks about its themes, it loads it in a T shirt cannon and fires it at you. I mean in this one, yes, but also at the same time a little more subtle in other ways, like like good subtle. Everything within The Ultimate Computer relates to the basic themes. Every question that every character is asking is related to the central question, which is for me just some of my most It is looking at the theme in so many complex ways. We haven't even talked about the N five computer and in the sixties them clocking what the heck we're going through with AI and the inherent biases with ANI, which is that it's just a reflection of the data that is put into it. But these companies are

1:08:17 and startfuleet within Ultimate Computer as being like the computer. The computer is unbiased. There is nothing better than the computer. But of course anything that is made by a human being is at the service of the limits of that human right. And specifically he has like given it the ability to sort of logic through, but it's based on his own thought patterns, so and it does. It comes back to like what I feel like my biggest opinion on AI is it's not that I'm necessarily, like inherently frightened of the thing. What I am always worried about is well, what it is is I am frightened of power run amook like the concept here being that he wants this to relieve the pressures so that people like literally don't die, so that we're creating safety.

1:09:13 Right, Like that might be the most altruistic or optimistic perspective on a thing. Maybe we have the development of technologies and ultimately our greatest hope is so that it's say, relieves and provides us with the opportunity to have more leisure time, to have more safety in our everyday lives. But that's not how it works. We don't have like our the future that we are heading toward as not Star Trek. It is you know, it's like Blade Runner. It's like it's a far more dystopian type of perspective where money to interests are the ones that dictate how something is run. So it's Elon Musk coming in and like sending himself to space as opposed to like actually creating social goods through wealth. Right, it's using these tools for ill because they are, like you said, ultimately coming from their's still imprinted with the bullshit of the creators, and they're saying this is sixty eight. Yeah, technically sixty seven, but I and I and I think again, it's it's far. It is wild that it's like again, this episode, more than others, is like by no means simplistic about it, Like it's actually very thoughtful. It's not like it's a computar. I think it fundamentally comes down to that post Captain Duncil scene where Kirk is like, I'm free, yeah, is this Dorothy yes? Or I'm I think it also helps this. This isn't always the best case, but sometimes so there are those perfect scenarios where sometimes you have to go first thought, best thought. Yep, And she's got the

1:10:45 base bones pun intended of what Lawrence Wolf has supplied it's got those ideas, and then she's got no time because they're filming next week, so you just go. It's the same way with the finale of Next Generation, because the writers of All Good Things Ronald Deemore and Brandon Brago Ronald dey Moore create a battle Starchalactica wrote the finale of Next Generation and they wrote Star Trek Generations at the exact same time. But All Good Things they had to write in a week and a half. Jesus. In Star Trek Generations they had months to work on, and All Good Things is by far the superior. Yeah, those things, well, I mean I think there is something too of like sort of we have patterns of history, right, and I imagine there's a fear at that time of automation replacing is the thing that Star Trek has asked multiple times about what what is a human? What is a human? Because, as I talked about, Star Trek is propaganda for humans and the human experience, humans rule. Yeah, yeah, what is a humor? Like, what is the value of a human? And and now we've got a question of here is a machine that within the purposes of Star Trek is able to perfectly mimic human capabilities. So if this machine can mimic what a human,

1:12:15 we we within this value system what a human does, right, so what is your function? What a human wants, what a human needs? But there makes him happy, sets them free, And I'm thanking you for showing exactly exactly. Yeah, and it's like, yeah, I mean, I'll beous like that. We do get a pretty obvious like, well, it interprets something as a threat because it doesn't have the capacity, say to really think critically about it. And we see this. I mean it also ten twenty years ago you might look at that and be like, that's a little convenient because of course we have to reset to this this quote. But now alas running over children, Yes, and they're yeah, exactly. We have these algorithms that are dictating what our life is and instead of relying on human intuition, c suite boards are looking at that and being like, we need to be at the behest of mechanization because we trust mechanization over humans.

1:13:24 Humans are variable. Humans need things. Machines don't. They have more value, right, And we are And that's why General Grievious is put in charge of the droid army. Well, I mean it's why they turn him into a cyborg that MA can control. Yeah, yeah, exactly. I mean there is obviously a I just want to just call out real quick, just to like finish that thought of Like, I do think there is a strong pattern, of course, there's a strong pattern of the same fears of the sixties coming back into play now, but in just in different ways. Yes, and I do think there is there's something awful and beautiful about it. I mean, this is an extension of the fears of industrialization, right right, right, We're losing something. But I don't think anyone in the nineteen sixties could have fathomed that it would have made art irrelevant, yeah, artists orlean yet rather and the true lack of like the like valuing profit over humanity, which just today, as I was talking about some stuff that I was angry about with the way businesses are, it's like you cannot, like some people, exclusively look at business in terms of say profit. And I've said this before, I m say it again. My favorite comparison example is so sorry for repeating myself, but when the pandemic was going and there are all these thin pieces about well, if we keep being locked down, the economy will suffer. And Paul Krugerman is, like humans are the economy. If

1:14:55 millions upon millions of people of humans die, you don't have an economy. And that's I think of that all the time, and I feel like that's what's what it is. It's like mechanization, the idea of like humans as disposable and unnecessary, as opposed to understanding that like humans are what make art. Humans are what make these like leadership, that's what makes decisions, what makes connection. Oh boy, anyway, and that is why Grievous has a cough. Oh geez, a little fucking weeze m. I mean obviously, Star Trek and Star Wars are often concerned I mean, Star Wars is often concerned with right, like what is human as well? Right? The sort of like mechanization of Darth Vader, of like Anakin falling more toward like becoming more robotic droid esque, like having these different parts of what that makes him and asking what does it mean to be a human? Anakin is being faced with what does it mean to be a hero? Truly self sacrificing, And the answer is that it's pain yeah, suffering, it is being fundamentally uncomfortable, and ultimately he can't deal. He can't deal. And I think what's also that's making me think of is also like the kind of the question of if we're to do like a compare of Jim Kirk and Anakin Skywalker leadership.

1:16:28 Finally, I mean, I think without a doubt Kirk is a good leader, a good friend. I think there are sometimes where yeah, I mean for the purpose of like, like, if we take it at face value, like he does make some questionable choices of who goes down to the planet with Yeah, of course, but he's there wouldn't be a TV show exactly. But he is a good leader, right, whereas Anakin is actually Anakin's a doer. He And the thing is that when you get into the Clone Wars, he is actually perceived as being an extraordinary person to follow as a general in this last So so I want to take this on face value, because yeah, the Clone Wars, so much of what he does is so deeply individualistic, like you've mentioned, and there is a sort of simplicity almost in the power of being like a war general as opposed to like doing the more complex work of leading like a country or or galax or whatever that looks like a republic or a crew of four hundred people. When you're not looking for conflict, you're looking for exploration. It's two very different types of leadership.

1:17:43 And yeah, I think I and as deeply trusted, but is ultimately very dangerous because of his true individualistic perspective. No, you do. I love this discussion. I love this discussion. Yeah, how interesting? What about you, Aspen? Well? What do you love? What do I love? A lot of stuff? I love starships? Take my walk lighter and clip it. Don't you take my writchard buddy and nip it. If you spill the tea, I'm gonna snip it. A starship it exactly.

1:18:32 Ask him? What the heck are we doing right now? Gotta name my favorite vehicle slash ships from either and our favorite kissy kissy ships. We've got to got to we absolutely must. Boy, what an embarrassment of riches this? I So before we start, though, I have to show you something. Of course, Joel and I have gifts for you. I will give them to you in physical form, but first I will show shut the door. Look at this one of them. We have the Delta seven Ether Sprite, which is one of the ships that you have named as your favorite ships.

1:19:15 Uh, so that is one and then the other. We're gonna give you this little mint, the Nabu Royal and one star Fighter. So next time I see you on you tim t you and so sweet, thank you so much. Yeah, we can. I can't wait to hold them and put them next to the rest of my Yes, you've been to my apartment. I've got a little a tiny shelf with all of my tiny ships on it, and I am very excited to put it on the shelf of ship. I've got a little shelves at the ship shelf. Yeah, a new tiny ships and Falcon Gollo enterprise. Right. Uh do I have a little I have several enterprises up up there on my on top of my Blue Rain show. I got the NXO one. I've got the Kelvin Versus enterprise that is also a Blu Ray container. I have an enterprise that was made by I don't know, my my grandfather's wife got me this and it's it's great.

1:20:19 Well know you got more, Yes, just got some little guys. Yes, but we're not here to talk about the little guys. That, yes, we're talking about the big guys. And here here is what I'm going to pick. I'm picking the Woden from The Ultimate Computer, the cargo ship, the one it blows up. Yes, And here's here's what's fascinating. We get multiple ships in this one, which we don't often get right because I was like, no, we didn't even talk about how like they were set up to war games. It was like, oh my god, we didn't even talk talk about how I genuinely sat there, like the stakes of this episode are terrifyingly high. Yes, but if they don't stop this thing, it's going it's already murdered people, and it's going to murder more people. Oh, terrifying. But yes, so many additional ships, yes, And so we're going to get into more of this later on. But the Woden as not just in The Ultimate Computer, but in the remastered version of The Ultimate Computer, because in the original version it's just the Botany Bay from Space Seed, because again, this was an episode I needed to save Buddy. So they're using stock footage. But at the remastered version they pull a design from the animated series that we will see and I believe this is

1:21:53 if you're watching this on Paramount Plus. I did. This is probably the first time that we have seen a Starfleet ship that is not just an enterprise type ship. It's a weird, wild design where it has a massive nittle section because I guess it's mostly a cargo ship something along those lines. I forget exactly. Oh, I guess this model was first featured in Charlie X, at least some of the remastered stuff. But that's so interesting. But anyways, there they're stealing. Ah. Yes, of course this is used in the Trouble with Treble SQL that we'll get to in the animated series.

1:22:43 But I absolutely it's such a weird, lopsided, funky design where there's so many starships in Star Trek that look cool, sleek and stuff. It's big and chonky and it doesn't really make sense. And I really enjoy that. I love it. That. Oh that's great, so mine, I've already named it and I don't, but I don't know what it's if it has an official name at all, but it is. It's not necessarily a ship because it is more of a like underground type of subway. But when the Jedi who led by shok t are trying to get Palpatine to safety, get him to like this kind of safety room. They're effectively they're underground and they're getting him to this. Like as I'm remembering, there's so many visuals in this. It's like a just a giant sphere, right, it's a giant sphere, but it's like the walls of the tunnel have like grooves in them, like horizontal grooves, yes, and they have like these blades out to the side of this like sphere. And then it just goes through, like it just shoots through the tunnel and it goes and it does that thing where it's not just going straight the entire time. It's in like shooting up and around like like the kind of like the elevator and Willy Wonka it can go in like all directions kind of thing. But again it's not like it's hovering.

1:24:05 It's actually kind of it's like connected. It's like in the walls, but it's the sphere itself, and it's just so fucking it's so cool. I love it so many cool ough just just devolved into us yelling in the microphones thing it's sod and if it's you know, and if it weren't wouldn't be for that. This is not this is one of those like it's not a ship. It's not even like a vehicle vehicle, it's an animal. But I really do fucking love that. I don't even know what it is that Yoda rise. He wrote it in the first like the very first like scene basically a Volume one as well. But it like looks like it's like a tontin, but it's not. It's not like it's a cousin of an According to the commentary of Volume two, Okay, it's a ton it looks like it, but it like not on a on a snowy planet, and it just fucking rolls. I love that one. But I'm gonna go with Giants Spirit Subway in terms of relation ships Aspen. I'm gonna I'm gonna pull this card. I'm having a hard time, dude, because I can't.

1:25:10 I can't use Anakin patne I know, which is like this would be the time to actually do it right because they rule in this Yeah, I should have thought this one through too. I'm always always waiting until last second time. I could be disingenuous and say Daystream in the N five, but it's it's not a ship more than a father son relationship. It is, which is its own kind of thing, right, and it's like radiating sexual chemistry off the screen. No, unless you go for who's that other guy? O? They're kind of shitty? Was he a Captain Bob Wesley, Admiral what was it? Commodore? Commodore Bob Wesley? Again, gotta point out my fate. Oh man, it's one of my favorite Star Trek tropes.

1:25:56 You have a high falutant officer in these extraordinary circumstance in their names like Bob or Bill yeah, common or Wesley's commodore Bob Wesley, Commodore Wesley. I guess if you're if you want agree also a little distant genuous, you go for like a commodore Wesley Captain Kirk kind of vibe because it's not nice and so you can kind of see it being like a little bit of a like sexy undermining like that kind of thing. Why don't you go I'm going to keep mulling over it and then I will provide an answer. I promise you. I'm going to go with what's the name of that planet that they go to that's snowy nel VNLVN, which is important. Got to point this out, and I'm pretty sure you planted this out in the last episode. It's called nel Von as a homage to the animation company that made the holiday special cartoon Androids an Ewoks now Von. Okay, animators recognize animators, Yes, nel Von, I'm gonna go with this is just a sweet little ship.

1:27:05 The main warrior who like the main warrior who was able to like he was the one who was able to like lead the charge and help Anakin and direct him to like how to turn this off. He and his partner. There's this moment when he's brought back and all of these like these partners, these women, the children are seeing these like grotesque creatures come back, and these are all like the loves, like their loves right and like their their fathers, and there's something gentle about Yeah, the main kind of like the leader warrior kind of coming in and his child coming to him. And then so I'm gonna go for him and his partner and they're gentle accepting love. Okay, I got a ship. Okay. This is based off the commentary where they said it as a bit, but I'm making it Cannon okay, ked Mooney Mondy and and Ala Sekira and maybe shock to you too, just like as a cool little throuble. Yeah, because love it. Here's here's what happens at the beginning of the thing. You know, they're literally starting where the previous DVD left off or the thing on Disney Plus went right right.

1:28:28 Uh. And then key D Monday, very Unjedi like whenever all the Clones come in to save them, says no, we must pursue, and the Clones have to. The Clones are the more even keeled once through the normally even killed right. And then yes, Monday finds out that a Len shocked to You're alive. Yeah, I so key D. Monday wants revenge because secret throuple it. Love it. I think that's great. Kitty Mondy, that's a good shift that I found. Yeah, that was given to me on the DVD commentary of Clone Wars Volume two. That's what we gotta do.

1:29:11 That's what we gotta do. Well, that's not all we gotta do, actually, aspen, because we have to come to the conceit of the podcast, we finally, numerically objectively have to answer which is better Star Trek or Star Wars by ranking the Ultimate Computer versus Star Wars, Clone Wars Volume two against each other. And remember, Aspen, art is objective. Art is a binary. You can rank this stuff objectively. God, there's no quality. You can't just enjoy it both. One is better never never, absolutely foolish to think foolish. And I'm going to go, I'm going to start you off with the Ultimate Computer from zero to ten. Whether you rank the Ultimate Computer nine point one. Oh, you do love to see it?

1:30:00 M h m hmm, outstanding, ten, ten, being sitting on the edge forever. Yeah, which is nice. I love it's you know what, Aspen Tennis also my empire, so Aspen I'm feeling it. Yeah, I'm feeling it. Yeah, I think it's a nine point five. There you go. I think it's an there you go. And I am doing that and I'm putting that in the spreadsheet and I'm a little scared of using it because it feels too good and that's why I have to do it. Okay, Wow, you're gonna love this. Here we go Clone Wars Volume two as Clone Wars Volume two nine point five. Hell, yeah, you do love to see it. Fucking love it. It's so good, so good. How about you? I'm gonna give it a nine point one.

1:30:55 Okay, we just did eat it in a historic first for our podcast. We can we cannot answer the question of which is better Start or Star Wars. It is. It is a tie. Oh there, fall It is a tie. Two beautiful episodes. What wonderful serendipity good great, great job. We did it againess like poetry, so that they ride. That's the let's Pittarny one in nine point three is the is the Yeah? Nine point three, both of them. Clone Wars Volume two, nine point three, the Ultimate Computer nine point three. I think the real winner is us.

1:31:55 It is us. Again. If you're having a bad week like my, watch these things, watch Clone Wars, watch this episode Star Trek. Feel so happy, feels so good, so good, listen and you're not the only one that feels good aspen as we hop over and talk about patrons over at patreon dot com slash track Wars pod, where you too could subscribe for five dollars a month and get early versions of these episodes and extended version of the episodes. Again. Also, I mean, you can just send us an email too, but you can correspond with us as well, such as the messages that we have here useer feel yet in regards to our Patreon discussion of Dune on the Star Wars episode two Attack the Clones versus by any other name, where you talked about Dune feeling at comments, dunk and Idaho is the key to all of this. Oh, probably because he's a funnier character than we've ever had. Duncan Idaho. What kind of space name is Don gern Ido? And then also canonically we have Arizona Mark commenting on that episode, American graffiti and space for the opening of Attack of the Clones.

1:33:15 Highly enjoyable, love it. And then also this is really fun. Tiffany L. No, PhD, Associate teaching professor at the Department of Popular Culture at Bowling Green State University, because I used her essay in regards to Clone Wars as research for our podcast what and she says, Dear Kenny, thank you for the kind words about my chapter. I'd love to talk further. So let's do this. Oh my gosh, take care. Tiffany rules. So we got to get her on the podcast. She has an essay in regards to the two d Clone War in regards to its plays in specifically superhero cartoon culture. Uh and it's it's pretty interesting. So thank you Tiffany for that. I got to read that now, so Tiffany thinks highly of me as well. I need to impress Tiffany now, Oh boy, Well, she's not the only one we need to impress, because we need to impress fine folks and our patrons find faults such as Timbo De Sosa, Emily Brice, Love, Heidi Rogers, Kevin Millier, Mark Vipper, Aaron Science and lastly, but certainly not leastly joelt Partner, who also wrote our fabulous I Starship theme song. Our theme song is by mister tossin Awa Fesso. Please go give him some business by clicking on the link in the show notes for his services. He is absolutely wonderful. If you want to just email us

1:34:51 in general, you can follow the offices of our friend Tiffany Nole and just send us an email at treck Woards Pod at gmail dot com. And finally, you can also follow us on the socials at Blue Sky and Instagram. We technically have a Twitter, but I would like to stay off of that because Elon Musk is a criminal. I'm sure. Yeah, it's been getting worse and worse. Absolutely, but you know it hasn't been getting worse and worse. Our love, our love, Aspen. I freaking love you. I love talking with you so much, and I'm so glad that you're my friend. I'm glad you're my friend. That's so nice of you to say I had a bad week and you made my day better. Uh. And because we have a tie, I can't usually I can't do our normal sign off because you haven't put this together. But usually I put the winner first of either live long and prosper and may the Force be with your Star Wars wins, May the Force be with you, and live long and prosper But I've never noticed. Yeah, of course, Aspen, if you could say the Star Wars component and I could say the Star Trek component, and we could wrap it at the exact same time. Okay, here we go, Ready, here we here we go, Man and prosperous. I genuinely was like, am I saying it