Downfall of a Droid vs. Spectre of the Gun
IS STAR WARS A WESTERN?
Aspen dives deep on Gunfight at the OK Corral. They try to explain the weird law structure in Tombstone, AZ when the shootout happened.
Kenny gets on his usual BS, talking aobut Spectre of the Gun as a satire of Western...
IS STAR WARS A WESTERN?
Aspen dives deep on Gunfight at the OK Corral. They try to explain the weird law structure in Tombstone, AZ when the shootout happened.
Kenny gets on his usual BS, talking aobut Spectre of the Gun as a satire of Western attitudes circa 1968.
Aspen and Kenny talk about collective action in Star Trek versus the lone gunslinger 'tude in this week's Clone Wars.
Eat Bad. Watch Star Wars.
_________________
Get early, extended episodes on our Patreon at https://www.patreon.com/trekwarspod
Watch us!
https://www.youtube.com/@trekwarspod
Theme by Tosin Awofeso
Social Media:
https://www.instagram.com/trekwarspod
https://bsky.app/profile/trekwarspod.bsky.social
Want to ask us questions? Email us at trekwarspod@gmail.com .
And leave us a review! https://bit.ly/leave-a-review-trek-wars
0:27 Welcome to the Track Wars podcast, the Internet's exclusive vallet for trying to answer the one question, the most important question in fandom, which is better Star Trek or Star Wars. And we're going through both franchises in chronological release order. Today is certainly no exception, Aspen, Aspen, I know that you were hoping that today would be an exception. I always think that perhaps today's the day that we finally start comparing Xena. It's a Hercules, But it's not. It's not that's what we always do. It's a different kind of legendary journey that we trek on. Speaking of Trek, I am Kenny Madison of the Star Trek contingent, and with me as for always is, it's me Aspen Webster. And hold on, do you waiter? Star what?
1:15 What do you hear that in the distance? Oh my gosh, Oh my gosh. Oh no, that drud just done got shot down. Oh no, Kenny, we got ourselves. We got ourselves a western We're down to have a root and to it in time. Here as we review Downfall of Adroid from Star Wars. The Clone Wars first aired November seventh, two thousand and eight. Versus Specter of the Gun first aired October twenty fifth, nineteen sixty eight. Oh, Kenny Kendall, my dear friend. I did not know it was going to be a Western and I was excited and it was great. Would you say that you were hooting and holler and doing all kinds of shenanigans. I was. I was square dancing down by the lake where the cows drink, and I was turning butter and I was thinking about how does the system of law enforcement work in Old West America. Yeah, there's a lot of questions that I did not dig further into the legend of the gunfight at the ok Corral. I just am grabbing what I've did from Oh thank goodness. I was about to come out and be like, I like totally forgot to watch my Felony Zone and do any research on Clone Wars.
2:45 But I gotta tell you, I one down that Wikipedia rabbit hole of the Okay Corral shootout. Excellent, wonderful. I'm glad because I did go down the colonial zone. What was surprising is that I did not expect an episode that was dealing with Anakin Skywalker's attachment disorder. Oh my god, my dude, my dude, you know it's really good. We'll get into this War Wars. It's so good. And I appreciate a Star Trek episode that's old Western themed, surrealist, old Western, compared to Star Wars, which to me is just Western in space. Is it a Western in space? Yes? And why are you talking about why it's a space Western? Right?
3:29 But why is it a space Western? Well? I guess Clone Wars. Okay, you make me explain myself. No, I'm not, Oh, Kenny, you're questioning. I think the label is apt. I think it's appropriate. I'm just wondering. What are you don't trust me, I get it. Yeah, I don't trust you to talk. I don't want it. No, I'll have none of it. No. I guess vigil ante justice go hand in hand with what we scribe to the Western genre as a whole. That's one of those stereotypes, you know, I for for what it's worth, I think at space space Western a lot of Yeah, it's vigilante justice, but it's a lot of sort of I think we see it with like outer rim planets, there's a lot of what's the lawlessness of the place, or you know that it's there might be a center, a legal center, but there's sort of the vastness of space and who knows what might be going on out there, and some places have syndicates that are actually in charge of it, and and the gangsters they I guess effectively the kind of like it's not just the I think that's why, Like the imagery of Tattooine is like that kind of desolate desert is very evocative of it. But then you have certain characters, like you've got a Han Solo that's kind of a rogue who I feel like is a very Western type persona a gun he's,
5:00 you know, he's kind of like a Devil make Care type of character with the you know, the road with a heart of gold, which kind of is a cross genre. But I feel like you see a lot in Westerns. But I do think you're right that like Star Wars, because it is deeply fleshed out, has different levels of I feel like in different ways it can be reflective of. While I didn't watch all twenty seasons of Gun Smoke, I have a sneaky suspicion that Gun Smoke did not interrogate the larger political spectrum the way that Star Wars has in chronicling the rise and fall and rise of fascism. Kenny, can we just pause, okay, and let's just like think back a year ago, not really pause, just like a pause.
5:49 Already put it in the footnotes. Oh my god, take an out of the foot I can't take it out of the footnotes. It's already in the footnotes. There's no delete button. Okay, there's no totally button on the computer. None. Let's just pause and think about your perspective on Star Wars just a year ago. Would you have said the sentence you just said then Yes, Ah, I hope I had brought you to a place of true understanding. No, because it was the last Jedi that helped everything click into pay in place, because it bothered to I mean, I'd see the arguments that Lucas was exercising. What is it circle theory? And I mean he said it it's like poetry at rhymes, and so all of these things structurally within the prequels are just like repeating, which has the oh right, right, we're right. He's doing it because it will make fans excited to see the thing that they recognize. And also he's looking at repeating loops and how you have to break the loops. And then last Jedi, it was the first one to textually say this stuff keeps happening, and we did talk a lot about it with like the was it the Fall the Monomith, the Jesse Gender six hour video that really talks about that and that kind of meta conversation around actually keeping the perpetuation of like the kind of corporate corporate fascism alive.
7:16 Yeah, I like the repetition of the thing. I just listen. I just was like, man as the Star Wars contingent, I was like, man, Kenny's sounds like he's on my side. Here's here's where you have changed me a deeper friendship. Oh my god, look it us like it is be awakning my eyes to the political intricacies of what is in the textual script of the three prequels that I guess was also explained by Felony and expanded on because it's there. You just really really have to look for it and completely divorced the direction in the acting from the script. There. It's truly there. That's not like Star Wars fan theories, which, making no mistake, every single fan theory is terrible, including anything that I say to me too, biggest fan theory Anakin Skywalker secret hut. I would say, there's so much evidence for that. How have I changed you as Star Trek though, Ah, I like it a lot more than I used to.
8:50 Nope, that's not true. I've always liked Star Trek, but I feel like I respected a heck of a lot more. Is that true. I think that you have deepened my appreciation of it pretty sincerely. I think that is very true, getting to like really talk about it frankly, you know, being able to contextualize it, like the reminder of contextualization. I feel like it's very important for me. What I've seen something very recently about gosh something thinks, Oh it was we were just talking about this in the Patreon, like this Doctor Who episode, which is just a patreon dot com slash truck horse Pod joined the Patreon for five dollars a month. Someone talking about that most recent episode Dott and Bubble as being probably feelings Delton Race for just talking about being as kind of forward as Star Trek happening in the sixties for the first time, and it was just that reminders me that I was just like, yeah, I might sit here and be like I'm a grum at the rioting of these women, or how clunky this is, but like howmkunky this is, but kunky but truly for sixty seven sixty eight, like so much of it holy shit, and it is very I think there is a lot of like being present with that context I think has been is super important.
10:09 You can simultaneously marvel out the things that they were able to get on TV and at the same time demand that they should have done better. Yeah, you've also given me the freedom to say, I know this is a good episode, but if I'm mad at it, so I'm gonna give it a one. Yeah. All of this is subjective, objective criticism of art. I'm not for it. I'm sure that there's someone out there who will be able to give a good argument for it. But like every single one of us as people, and so if you are just kind of being like, well, let's look at this performance objectively, is it good? But even that objective criticism that you are assigning to is still at the whims of socialized acceptance. Yes, oh yes, John Travolta's terrible performance in Battlefield Earth might have been good on the sat Who knows might have been good to a scientologist who knows. Can you imagine someone is like deeply scientologists is like watching and they're like an extraordinary perform breaking the words desire Hubbard. Hubbard would be so proud speaking of appreciating context, Why don't we give some context for folks that didn't necessarily watch these episodes? What are you doing? We're playing the home game right now. What are they doing? We're playing the home game
11:41 right now? What are they doing? Why aren't they watching, taking care of their kids, washing dishes, taking out the garbage, trying to connect with their bodies, connect with their emotional state, and maybe they're on their walk right now, and cut it all off. Eat Bad, Eat Bad Watch Star Wars. I gotta write that down, dude, Eat Bad Watch Star Wars as someone who just finally did the dishes. Listen, engage with your executive dysfunction. Let it win. So, man, I don't know what are we doing. I know that we don't have any merchandise, but it would be fabulous to the a lesion of Trak Wars fans wearing Eat Bad Watch Star Wars t shirts everywhere. Let's get to the plots. Napsis though, showing. I'll start with spect of the Gun once again, aired October twenty fifth, nineteen sixty eight, director Vincent mcavidi, and read lye kron It. I think I've heard that name before somewhere, Lee Kronin. Where am I? That's that's that's uh, gene Kune can't believe, Aspen, what you know a writer of Star Trek, You know, a writer of Star Trek's pseudonym. You wouldn't have known that like a year ago. You do. Get that to me from New York Entertainment column is Joan Crosby,
13:16 who previous Specter of the Gun for her syndicated TV scout com. The review goes tonight, the writers of Star Trek gave the ball to the costume and scenic designers with a far away plot that didn't really require them. The men of the Enterprise are due for execution for trespassing, and their form of capital punishment is quite unique. They are transported to the Old West and to the site of the eighteen eighty one OK Corral battle. They are given the identities of the Clanton Gang, and if you recall your history, the herps did quite a job on those Batti's battis. Uh, thank you, Joan Crosby. We salute you. That's a good That was a good description, Joan, if you're still alive. Oh my gosh, wait, I completely forgot we have correspondence. Oh my god, oh shit, okay, we gotta do that before we get into this. Joan, calm down and wait.
14:09 Oh my gosh, I'm so sorry. From our YouTube channel, which you can search by going into the show notes below, because we are still building up that presence, from the Holdover Maneuver podcast in terms of our recent effort episode Rookies Versus is there in truth? No beauty, hold Maneuver podcast. That's hold Up Boys Approved cute. And then another YouTube channel, vector Verse from YouTuber factor I believe goes this, I like look at that. That's fun. That's fun. It's really fun. That's I like it. I like it too. Oh my god, I like you. I like you.
14:52 And finally from patreon dot com slash Truck Wars pod from user feel Yet, the subject goes ree two voyagers. Oh yeah, oh okay, clarifying, got it? Did I get this wrong? Here we go, okay, episode shattered. I think I got this wrong. If that's what it is. I have yet to read this comment fully. Episode Shattered that you mentioned Prince is one of my favorites, and Princes has the temporal distortion where different parts of the ship are in different alternate timelines. It's all being experienced as one ship by the protag Chakote assmen's favorite character. Though, episode Deadlock is likely the one you're thinking of, where two Voyagers are created by the Plebotenum of the Week and they accidentally start injuring each other parentheses, a lot like that TOS episode y'all talked about some months ago, where the one guy is Anty Matter Twitter trying to hunt each other down the alternative factor, right, this episode is not really a favorite of mine too quote unquote enjoy as such, but it's not a fantastic factoid to bring up that Harry Kim and Naomi Wilde from end of season two onward are replacements for the ones who died on the Voyager episode. Of course, Oblivion also fits the bill for having two Voyagers, although it's less likely that you were thinking of this one, Editors. No a devastating episode of television, truly, It's just a good horror slash Twilight Zone type app where everyone on the ship is mysteriously ill and diying. They find out halfway through that they are all a bunch of silver
16:26 Blood duplicates from the Demon class planet earlier in the season. They all just forgot, but this time silver Blood Harry Kim doesn't make it, not even to set a time capsule out from the blowing up Void. Uh, from the blowing up Voyager Janeway Pryan just shows up to a bunch of space dust. At the end of the episode, It's like, I guess I'll put in my logs. I saw some strange, sad space stuff. Oh, I don't think i've seen that episode Asman, if you're ever just bopping along and you're like, I'm ready to just feel devastated but on course oblivion written by Pushing Daisy's own Brian Fuller, Holy shit, I don't think I yeah, because I didn't quite finish Voyager. I watched all of DS and I, oh, we'll get to it, okay, whenever we are alternating DS nine A Voyager episodes. Fun fun, fun fun fun. Anyways, I gave this prospector of the Gun as well as of Correspondent's Oh yes, my turn, My turn, Clone Wars Star Wars the Clone Wars episode Downfall of a Droid you already named the date. Just want to call out November seventh, two thousand and eight, right after a presidential election. Wild, Am I right? No wonder? This episode felt so hopeful to me. It's funny, you know, when Obama got elect the first time, Barack Obama, Barack Obama specifically that person as opposed to the other Obama. I saw a December's concert December's are my favorite band up in Boston. At the very
17:56 end of it, they played the song that I really love called Suns and Dot and they brought out this cardboard cutout of Obama and the entire audience was like, it was electric. So yeah, hopefulness, Am I right? Anyway? Director Rob Coleman, writer George Christick, who was different. We've had like kind of the same writer for the rest of them. This is the first. This is episode one of a two parter. It does, in fact end on a bit of a on a bit of a cliffhanger that does leave you terrified. The ending. The end, it just kind of it's like what happens? Yeah, well, there's no thematic closure now.
18:38 And I was just like this is unsatisfying as a viewer, but perhaps by design. You know, it's interesting because some earlier correspondents we got maybe last week or the week before about like, does it feel fundamentally fair to compare full episodes of Star Trek to what often happened in the Clone Wars, which is like it's a three parter effectively, or a two parter like this. And I think we came down on who cares. No, we came down on like, no, this is a computer screen when Austin airing your argument is stupid, stupid, you're dar on me. I mean, I think the nature of the thing, right is that we were like, now, this is what it is. It's one at a time, it's when it's released chronologic order. But you know, yeah, this is the first part of a two partner, so it has the sort of feeling of like, there's more to this story, but we got to end here, which is an interesting sort of space to be in. But spickes. So here's the official description. Well, let's do let's do the pot Summer. After suffering a series of disastrous defeats at the hands of General Grievous, the Republic's foothold in the Outer Rim is in jeopardy commission to protect the strategic world of but Thawi. Oh no, but Thawi's always say it, but Sawi, Yeah, I'm just gonna keep saying it the same way, and against Skywalker and
20:10 his wary battle group or all that stands between the system and the domination by the Droid army. And so what happens is R two D two is lost during a fierce space battle. So Anakin, along with the Soca and a replacement Droid R three S six, must find him before the separatists discover the Jedi military secrets locked in his memory banks. And that is it. So it is both about his attachment. He makes it that it's about oh well, I never like, I never clear his memory, which in and of itself is about as attachment. Right, He's like, I am attached to the friendship that is Destroid. Also the first time canonically that that rule is established, that that's a thing that happens that they I mean, you're right, and it's I mean, I guess in the past they've done the thing where it's like wipe three po's memory, Like this is what's funny. The prequel at the very end, like of The Revenge of the Sith, where like Baylor Gunn is like wipe three pos memory basically, but like, don't wipe R two, Jesus Memy, like like it's very much like, yeah, it's not, it's not. Both of them are not wiped. It's just three po yeah, because Lucas needed three po to not remember things that happened to the prequels. But R two you can't understand, so it doesn't matter exactly. So this is the first time canonically that it is like, no, for for good reason, we would wipe their memories because droids could be lost, just like now. But also the I mean the bet to
21:41 question what is the function of droids within fighters, because it's never really been established what it isn't that question now it's just like what I never thought about it. I was just like, they're just doing stuff. But this episode is really great because it by Goldie whatever Ahsoka calls him, she's fighting hard for this buddy. It's our three unit. It turns out that apparently our two unit's our three units do a lot. Yeah, they do a lot of stuff. They don't just like open doors and shit, like they help with navigational guidance and all the other kind of pieces of piloting ships, and yeah, they're not just there to get little bug droids off after ship.
22:26 Yeah, which has never canonically been established. This is what they do is just kind of handwavy because Star Wars to this point has really just been dealing with it's still that's larger swaths. It's about emotion and not like Star Trek where they're literally sending scripts to Kellum DeForest Research a company in order to like double check the science and make sure that things make sense. Do you think they sent it to them for this episode? They were like, can you double check the science of the Okay Corral? They did? Yeah, they absolutely did. What what is it? What? They sent every script and they were talking about the how how the IRPs and the Clantons were being depicted, because they're being depicted in a very specific way, with the Earps just being overall bad dees and the very interesting Yeah, I mean I'm pro that because a cap but if you do look it up, it is kind of funny. But also the Clantons are in alliance with the sheriff of the town, which means that they're still in alliance with the law enforcement that is happening also the IRPs or the earps or the town marshals. So now I'm wondering, what the heck is the law There's this proxy war that is going on within the Okay correl. But also this episode is not about that proxymer It's about our heroes and the tension of what the heck these people do. It's
24:04 it's a classic let's test these characters by putting them in a wild scenario based off of myth of their past, and they have to deal with archetype. I know, we're like skipping around a lot. We haven't even done our first impressions. I like both these episodes. I really like both of these episodes. I one percent do. I like the spector of the gun is. It's not just that they were sent to the Old West, and maybe this is for like budget reasons, I don't know. They're sent to like a sort of like just like the kind of like partial thing that you might see of like you're only doing outside shots on like a studio a lot of of a of a set, and it is actively like it's they call out that's like not even finished. It's sort of like this concept of what these these creatures are. They're kind of these not people, but like the kind of creatures that have put there, I'll say that kind of what they would understand it to be. And the sky is just this constant, wild, kind of reddish orange, and it's like the like the you know, like the dream sequence from Oklahoma before, like when it starts to get like scary with Curly, it's just like everything is like very abstract and we're doing like dances and it's like, ah, I love and it's like, no, Curly, it's like, oh, there's a store. It's quiet love.
25:33 It's you correctly identified exactly why the sets look the way that they do. Yeah, budget reasons. Budget reasons, as were established earlier by covering season three. The purse strings are even tighter on Star trek Let's tighter all across the board. They're no longer allowing over time on shoots, and they are crunching down on everything they can afford to go on location anymore. No Vasquez wrong, no Vasquez rocks. And so from the beginning of this episode, Matt Jeffries and the production team are like, we can have the sets like not have walls, and so the abstraction feeds into the abstract nature of how they're depicting the Okay Corral. And you couple that with the fact that it's canonical within the episode that this is like drawn from Kirk's memory, it's drawn from their collective memory. So it's not even a realistic version of the Okay Corral. It is this expressionistic version of the Okay Corral. And then you couple that with the dread that nothing works. They are kind of doomed to their own fate. Yeah, can I just yes? Can I just I already said yes? Are we According to Wikipedia Wikipedia becaul know that the majority
27:11 of editors and writers and articles for Wikipedia are men, non like that's right. Yeah, And in fact, it's actually actually a initiative. It's part of like the kind of Wikipedia groups and like the nonprofit to try to encourage more like dynamism and like of marginalized people and like kind of engaging with that very interesting dynamism. Fun fact, so Wikipedia, the conflict between the RBS and so other group, the Clantons, And I'm just going to make sure because I did read through it, but I want to make sure I'm getting this right, the Clantons were like at that point, it was still kind of like the term was cowhands. They were cowboys and like that's what they call themselves. And they were, uh, cattle stealers, like they would go down to Mexico and steal cattle and bring them back up and sell them.
28:11 Like they were nuisances. Like they were very much like lawless people. So it's not like they like you could be like, well, the herbs also fucking suck, which I'm sure they do, but like it's not like they're the good guys or like the herbs are the baddies, you know what I mean in terms of the actual history of the thing. According to these are the voyages from Mark Cushman and Susan Osborne. Uh, the Herbs, to the chagrin of Sheriff b hand and stated a gun ordinance in Tombstone exactly. Cow boys refusing to surrender their firearms upon entering the township were considered to be outlaws and subject to arrest. And okay, persisted they were like the lost carrig they persisted. That's why I feel about NRA members, noverless.
29:00 That's said by them, right, you know, right, Yeah, exactly. So it's law man against loosely organized group of cattle wrestlers and horse thieves called the cowboys. So just as a kind of clarification about it. And then by the time they got to it, like the conflict itself, like the shootout was just like seconds, pretty pretty wild, like it was so fast, and but then like persisted past that, like like they kind of kept going after each other, like the ones that had survived and stuff. So it's definitely pretty wild. A couple of other things like I learned from this, but you know, like the kind of reveal of Doc Holliday as being a dentist. He had been a dentist where he lived and this might have been from like Tennessee, and became a professional gambler when he moved out to the west, which was like an actual profession at the time, like oh, like the two BA gambler, and then became like a law man, you know, with the herps. There's just interesting, interesting kind of stuff to go with it. But so they had The thing that I'm trying to wrap my mind around is that I had sheriff. Did you have a sheriff? There's a marshall. Yes, I look this up. It's that Virgil Irp was the deputy US Marshall. So that's like we're presuming higher than the sheriff of the town because he's a US Marshal. Okay, so he
30:32 has higher standing. But he was based in Tombstone. Yeah, so yeah, because I mean, this happens in Tombstone, which, by the way, I've been there. I've been in Dumbstone. I stopped in Tombstone. Why is it called Tombstone hominous? It was called Tombstone before this even happened. Sure, I'm sure. Just yeah, beforehand it was like Lucky Clover I went to I went there and there's like one of those like silly little like kind of like haunted type of houses kind of things that you can like just like walk through and it gives you a little bit of like talks about the space and then like go let's come out. I fucking loved it. It is very touristy. I loved it. Tombstone. I'm not sure where he was where he's based, So yeah, it took place in Tombstone.
31:22 Of course, simmering feud. There's a lot of brothers in this too. Too many brothers. We gotta have less brothers in pop culture. Well we got to stop that. Really truly, like hackneyed, I'd say for them to all few brothers and father issues. More man should have mother issues and fewer brothers. Yeah. So anyways, Yeah, conflict portray with varying degrees of accuracy. It's an archetype for much popular imagery. Associate with the Old West, apparently is another fun fact. Again, I'm just kind of quoting Wikipedia, but just so you know, because maybe you like hearing it from me rather than reading it. It didn't actually take place, said the Okay Coral like itself. It actually took place in a narrow lot on the side of a photography studio. Gunfighting in the narrow lot. Yep. Not nearly as interesting as being in the corral itself. But I'm still trying to wrap my brain. And this is not important to the episode, not at all, because this episode is dealing with not necessarily the actual like historical accuracy of the thing. More like broad strokes, although they definitely look like them if you look at pictures, they really I mean like more or less right like they do. The guys playing the IRBs are like and dot Colit are great a so good. I love that the IRBs or the baddies in this episode is very novel considering that, I mean within our childhood. There were two
32:57 major motion pictures that were made about the gunfight, the Okay Corral Tombstone and Kevin Costner's Whiter Oh that's how I know that. Yeah, And so it persists into the cultural memory. But it's always that the Irths are the bad are the good guys? No, not here, herbs are the bad guys and the heroes are heroes. Kirk's block, McCoy, Scotty and Chekhov. Our cast is the badd's because that's what the Malcotians do. They make them the badd's and then they're I guess the Malcosons intent is just to execute them using a vision of their own violence, which is okay, So the earlier version of the script okay. Also, I just want to say, this is one of those situations where you know that bit in Oh my Gosh, Star Trek Mike tv awesos, you know that bitter Austin powers where it's like, why are you making us so complicated? Like like like the like Seth green Son characters just like just shoot them. I've got a gun, like, let's just shoot them. And it's like, why does it have to become so complicated? That's what this feels like. Truly, Well get them.
34:16 Yeah. In the original script from Gene Coon, I think you had already said that before he did. The aliens have isolated themselves from humans after intercepting ancient TV and radio signals from Earth. It is from these signals, news and entertainment programs three hundred years in the Earth's past, and the patterns of Kirk's mind, that the Aliens choose the surroundings characters to carry out the execution of the Unwelcome to Humans TLDNR. It wasn't just pulling from Kirk's mind. The aliens were scared because they've been watching our TV and radio and we're like, we cannot deal with these folks. And so to punish you, because we've been inundated with this pop culture, We're going to make you face clearly what you are all about. Here's this lesson? Why not keep that?
35:13 This concept, again, pulling from these voyages of Season three that late twentieth century television programming were causing alien rates to feel threatened by humans, was both clever and amusing. However, in nineteen sixty eight, the networks were under fire from activist groups and government regulators regarding too much violence on TV, ANDBC wanted to present a positive image of setting examples for America with its programming, not admitting how entertainment shows depict man is violent irrational reference to the alien's distrusting humans and believing them to be violent could stay blaming it on TV had to go Wow, that would have made the central metaphor a lot more potent as opposed to kind of drawing it loosely. Yeah, because as it stays as I feel like the central metaphor is kind of lost, as opposed to they're kind of obsessed with the rules of how do we get out of this jam? We're going to die? At five I did not feel the tension no there, which is unfortunate because the episode is nothing, but we're going to be adding tension on top protension on top of tension. But I think whenever you know that these characters are going to get out of this jam, sure you have to have something else going on. I mean, the most tense that God was having Chekhov actively die. That's that was interesting. I was like, of course you can't be really dead, but like, whoa fuck me? You know, yeah, you know I think the point You're
36:45 right that, like, it's the kind of episode that if it weren't so visually engaging to me, yes and just so weird, I might have been like, I guess it's phone time, you know, because it does sort of like lose its tension. There isn't much really bolster it truly. Well, then there are two questions that I have one or is a fascinating argument that could have been interrogated more because Kirk's mission is to engage with the Melcosians. Sure, that's his mission, and the Melcosians are like, no, go away, But instead Kirk is like, no, my assignment is to establish relationships with you. I'm going to do that. And so there's an imperialist question that is touched on somewhere in the episode after Chekhov gets shot of being like should I have done that? Should I have gone away? But then it just kind of gets hand waved away, which makes sense because it's nineteen sixty eight and they're not necessarily asking those hygh pollutant questions. Instead participating the exercise My second question is if it hasn't if it had been Star Wars, they would have been they would have been like, are we the imperialist Battis? Are we the Batis? And then the second question, and I think this one might be a little bit more intentional, albeit kind of simmering a little bit lower than the intention is is this just the satire of Westerns at the time? Not satires and haha, let's chuckle, but instead kind of interrogating the notions of because what is most popular on TV? Well,
38:21 this is kind of towards the end of the movement of the Western as a genre, and we have Gunfight at the OK Corral, arguably the most popular archetype, the most popular real life story that embodies the American Western genre, something that gets repeated often. DeForest Kelly, within These The Ways apparently was in three different things that were depicting Gunfight at the OK Corral, always in a different role wild. And then you couple that with Vincent mcavitie, who was picked because he has experience filming Westerns, and then Gene Kuhn who were in Also Gene Couhn's writing this episode. It's supposed to be a satire of television that kind of gets removed, but it's still kind of interrogating. Is this episode intentionally interrogating the Western genre because the herbs are the baddies, but the abs are rarely the baddies. This is cool. This makes a lot of sense actually that historically or so not represent would not be represented as the baddies. And what does this mean that they are here? Because they are very frightening, very specifically lit in certain ways. Vincent mcavadie told, at least the actor that played Whiter or maybe virtual or either way he gave the direction play these characters are law men as dead. Oh my god, they
39:58 feel that way. Yeah god, they feel oh god, they're like way that they're talking. It's it's it's one of those where it could be if you didn't if you weren't thinking about it, and you're just kind of coming in with a like store Trek is Old and dumb, you might be like bad acting. No, it's very I could tell. I was like, this is deliberate and too shirt eat bad watch Star Wars, and then another shirt that says star Trek is Old and Dumb, and then the Trek Wars logo on the back to me, I was like, these are very deliberate performances, and they're terrifying to me. Like it's an extremely stylized episode, and it starts from them being like our budget is cut, let's have some novel production design, and then from there everything just kind of goes outward.
40:45 Like it's like Sam Ray, It's like Evil Dead being so interesting because of having like not having a lot of money and making some of the most the coolest visuals you could possibly see. You know, I love this so good. People Dead, all the Evil deads, all the Evil deads. I haven't watched all the TV show. I've only watched the first season that was I had to muscle my way through that first season. It was hard times with this. I love ash Ver, I love that, but also Evil Dead Rise great. Yeah, that was a really good movie. Yeah anyway, Inspector of the Gun is a possible satire of Westerns people that are in the midst of the Western genre of being like, let's let's what are we what are we doing? What are we doing here? What making all these Westerns? What are we doing? Yeah? That is really it's really interesting and as someone who doesn't have a lot of context for what it might have been like at the time, like kind of being like everything at another Western Again, I want to reiterate, I'm not sure if this is an intentional satire, but also everything is so abstracted that I can't help but be like, are these folks saying something about the Western genre? Yeah, I mean it'd be really fascinating. I mean, let's pull it this way. Maybe they are, or maybe they aren't. Let's decide they are. What would they be satirizing in terms of what like the Western genre represents a cap Truly it is because the Clantons are depicted as the Clantons are our heroes, and
42:22 they are they are ostensibly our protagonists. And then not only that, but like the sheriff of the town is in leak with them, and our heroes are like, we didn't do anything wrong. Meanwhile, the the IRBs that we have lionized within popular culture are portrayed as these dead specters. More or less their gaze is all open, and whenever they try to negotiate with them, they're like, I don't care, We're going to shoot you at five o'clock. And then the only way that they can this is where this notion gets a little bit wonky because the end of the episode involved a spock very coolly mine melding with the rest of them and being like, just believe that the bullets don't exist, thereby breaking the archetype, and then oh gosh, in the original episode they were just going to have a big honkin fight.
43:19 Instead, Kirk fights one of them a little bit, and then oh yeah, the camera pushes in and it pushes back out, and then they star Trek by being like, we've grown past violence. They do. I like that they star Trek. Yeah. Yeah. The only time that that messaging the like sounds like the earlier the earlier script messaging of like are we encouraging violence? Like are we? It comes out there where it's like he he was so angry, like you killed supposedly Checkov, like I want to kill you, but then existed, and that does become the point of like well, and he even explicitly says like we've grown past this violence, which they have not, which is the great notion. And then in later iterations of Star Trek they will be like that instinct was never there, as opposed to this episode where you're exrely right, yeah, that instinct was there, but I made the conscious choice not to exercise that, so I guess to connect it with the satirizing of the Western, instead deciding to break these stories and instead being like, we are not going to engage with you. We believe these archetypes to be false. Westerns are inherently violent, like they're about rough living. Uh, they're about cowboys and they're about uh there oftentimes, or like there's a lot of like indigenous peoples who are also seen as savage, as there's a lot of death in violence, and it's like digging into that
44:52 the depths of like what it is to be human. We are violent inherently, like put us out into the West where there are no rules and suddenly we kill each other kind of idea. And there is an interesting like if we're saying we're actually doing this in the context of a show that is saying no, we can be more than this, that would make sense, which is interesting because this notion begins with Kirk being ordered to participate in an imperialism. Oh establish, but it's also saying that our imperialism actually is different now as opposed to a thing it actually embodied the notions that they purport at the end of the episode, they would have just turned the ship around and being like, you know what, they don't really want to talk to us.
45:37 That's why. Yeah, they definitely are violated very clearly set boundaries. Yeah, but also like we have to have an episode of Star Trek. It's true, Yeah, man taking part in an imperialism start. I I kept wanting to make a joke that was just like, do you think Anakin was giving into his likes baser instincts when he killed all these women and children?
46:21 I think so. I think, so let's interrogate that. Let's interrogate that. Actually, let's interrogate like, let's okay, can we talk about okay, so like a similarity of like systems of power like within like what's happening in Clone Wars and like what's happening in Star Trek. You know there is not to like pull too hard at this, but let's see what let's se where we get we already pulled really hard respector of the gun. Let's pull Let's I hope that our listeners enjoy us pulling and trying to make thematic sense and figuring out what this art means to us. Because I I loved this Clone Wars episode. I love them all attely Do. He was unexpected.
47:05 I mean, on top of the Clone. We've been talking, I have been talking a lot about we're setting plates, we're plate setting, and this episode feels like we're digging. We're digging in yeah, because we are exploring what Anakin's like. Anakin's connections to not just people, but also to his droid, his relationship with a soakap, touch of his relationship with Obi Wan, some fun action pieces, but Anakin, I don't know what I'm trying to get to here. But like they are representative, they're of a republic, but they are like they're chadhai art. We're peacekeepers until now we're engaging in this war in which we are now generals and we are effectively part of like a hierarchical structure that is enforcing order. That's going to be your ultimate right. We've got people below us. We have to have a hierarchy, we have to give orders, we have to go through this. Anakin consistently breaks that constantly, like he is he is not following orders. He is always going off track. He goes off track in this one, like the whole piece of it is they are like, we need to retreat, and he's like, no, Like at the very beginning of the episode, you know, like we're I'm going to make this happen. And I wonder about that in terms of like breaking of systems of power is the baddie, you know, Whereas our episode of Star Trek was a little bit about the interrogation
48:37 of power structures the way that we perceive them, and I don't know our idealistic power structure that's to picted in Star Trek, right, and instead deciding to reject violence, reject the tropes that have been put forth, and instead embarking on let's do this together. I know it's hard, but we mean, we really will choose to mean well even whenever it hurts us. And this episode of the Clone Wars, I think you're saying is to go back to our discussion about his Star Wars, a Western Anakin seems to be embodying that lone gun slinger attitude that Richie is. He always does and I always get a little time less. I'm so smart, You're so smart. No, you're just so mut Thank you for actually like putting into words what I was trying to say you're so smart audience, don't we think so smart?
49:31 No? Stop stop, don't make this sing, don't make this sing. Oh my god, No, it's just fine. Thank you for distilling that. I'm trying to get to it. I'm off a little bit like ooh boys. And it can go against my statement that Star Wars is about collective action by being such an individualistic person, but I think that is inherently part of it, like his individual choices do break from the norm, and they often and succeed, which is complicated because he is ultimately the bad deep but also uh to steal Joyce Holloway's wonderful notion of protagonist and is propaganda and also we we we want to be the lone gun slinger. Yes too, we do, and so an again, it's exercising it. But also at the what is so great about this episode is everyone even though we know our two, we love our two, Yes, seeing him in concert, seeing him alive, exquisitively all his albums, bought all of his albums, so we know R two, we love our two, And this episode is really good at making us much like a curious dog tilt our head and being like, it's all of this worth it. I mean, it is R two D two, but also I know he has just one droid, yeah, which as implications in and of itself about how we feel about droids who clearly have feelings and emotions. Hate it whenever Star Wars brings up droid rights because then it brings up so many questions about the movies that I love. Ahsoka literally
51:05 like says, there's this that Goldie the R three units. She's like, you hurt his feelings, and I'm just like, oh boy, I mean like we know, but you like actively called it out. Yeah, while at the same time being like, but R two doesn't matter that much exactly, but it's almost like they're treating him for what it's worth. In this I think there is a bit of a like he's just a droid, but there almost treating him like a fallen soldier, Like soldiers die all the time in war. Why should we care so much about this one? But the show has established up to this point that no, you do matter individually, Like even if you are just just a clone quote unquote, you're still a person who matters, or least has tried really hard to go out of its way to say that. So there's a little bit of both the ending here.
51:52 But is that individual sacrifice or is that individual gunslan your attitude worth it whenever you are putting other people right in such naked danger. Right, because the Gunslinger stuff works when he has an idea that works and everybody's got his back and it's clever and like we can all do it together. But what does it look like when it's like, oh, it never clear his memory? Oh shit, Yeah, and I'm or like, even if that hadn't been the case, I'm going to go after him because I love him truly. Yeah? Is that individual notion that is driven so much by naked emotion versus gunslinger routoos, which might be more wonderful thing that Last Jedi is able to subvert? So do we like the Last Jedi? Love Last Jedi?
52:43 Were you talking about it's my favorite Star Wars movie? Do we like I'm so sorry, everybody, We're not sorry, so you know, not sorry, and also attempt to try and like all of it because it's fun. But sometimes I just don't like things, uh like Rise of Skywalker movie? Whoa anyways, Yeah, sorry, Loan Gunslinger. I mean whenever Luke turns off his targeting computer. That's Loan gunslinger attitude. But also he's connecting with daff force, the force that's less based in emotion and more like, hmmm, I think this is gonna work balance as opposed to hear where it's so motivated by attachment disorder. Can we just clarify really quickly the way that the Jedi approach attachment is fucked, but you are correct and that he very much has a disorganized attachment disorder. Yes, that's a great clarification. I appreciate that you just genuinely for good reason. It's like, everybody's gonna leave me.
53:58 I'm terrified people I love dying for a good reason. Yeah, and the Jedi are like, get over it. Yeah, that's your job. Fuck is wrong with you? As opposed to being like, yeah, oh boy, we are all sad at all times. Yeah, Like, he's truly part of life. What does that mean for us? Here is how let me work with you to help you make peace with it? Because I am also sad. There are greater truths that we can access because this is part of the palace of life. You make a really good Jedi. Uh Yeah, aspen. Get over your attachment this way, that's what a Jedi would do. Knock it off. I know that you're sad, but Jedis don't get sad. Don't worry about not being said. Have you let me run this bike? You could just not be sad. You just choose.
54:52 You could just choose to. I know that you're sad, but I am not sad. So why are you not like that? Have you tried yoga? Have you tried? Oh? Nice yoga? Chardon? Okay, yoga. That's the little guy, right, the little green guy? And uh, what is it? Empire knocks off? I love Star Wars. Asking me any question about Star Wars, I'll answer it. Yeah. What's your favorite character from uh, the Phantom Menace? What's that to? Your favorite character from The Phantom Menace? Which one is that? First episode one? Oh? Yes, yes, Luke Skywalker love that guy? Sure, favorite character from episode one? Concept of Luke Skywalker's strong m hmm, what what's up? Downfall of a droid? Great? Uh, it's our three a spy. Yes, I mean I imagine, sorry, shit, I have seen these okay, but it's basically called out. It's basically called out.
55:51 Though in this episode, there is nothing more that I like than aspent reflexively just answering, because I've never seen these episodes so exciting. I'm pretty sure. Yes. And also in this episode, in the episode you can't back pedal, you gat to be the answer, R three is a spine. You can't backpedal. You said yes so confidently and then attempted to backpedal. Well, but like Grievous legit is just like, hey, the plant is working. The only way that plan would be working is if AR three got him there on purpose? What's the plan? Like, it's like, there, I don't know by this time, what is it. By the time they get to that episode, it's like he's gone. He's you know, used the cool hyperdrive ring. Everybody who gone through space found him. And then very specifically R three like you like, AR three can't be that shit.
56:43 Come on, he like basically h fucks everything up and then like gets him like drops the hyperspace ring, pulls him out of it, and then that gets blown up by Grievous and the ship and like won't do anything even he actually activates the beacon, and that's that's the point where Greeves is just like, great, this is the plan. So that's why I feel like I feel like it's like, come on, come on. If he's like the Beacon is part of the plan, then Arthree's gotta be a baddie, which he is, because you confirmed it. Goddamn it questioned? Is Arthree a spye? God damn it? Love it? I love him. I love it with all the joy in your face. Just reflectully so great.
57:30 There are a few better in this world than Aspen Webster. I gotta say, Ahsoka really pulls for him. And I think the only reason I remembered it so distinctly is because she was like, fuck shit, okay. I don't know. I think she's like it's funny because I remember the first time I watched it. I think I was like, why are you so on the side of this droid? And now I'm like, well, she's not. She doesn't care necessarily about the droid. She's worried about Anakin and is the loss so distinctly that she'sry to She's trying to do some parenting of her surrogate parent, which is a danger. Dude. Remember, Ahsoka is fourteen years old here, fourteen too young. I don't think anyone should be that young. No, I think it should be illegal to be that young.
58:16 Yeah, I think you should start off at twenty four. Yeah, right, just like and even then kind of dicey, yeah, I mean even know about that? Right? Oh, thank god? I think really a hit. Like when it was twenty seven, maybe twenty eight, I was like, Okay, we're getting better. Sure, So yeah, she's fourteen. She's also making major military decisions right, like, she's she's doing a lot of shit fourteen years old. She's parenting her older brother slash parents, I know, pretty desperate. There. There's a lot of really cool things that happen like that episode, just like Rules, it's a great app and it's given me the emotional depth that I've kind of been looking for. And I guess the Clone war so far, but you know, it's the understanding that the stuff will start getting deeper, the fur that we go on, and I love I love the complex characterization. Also the thing that the prequels and also Gandy Tartakowski I think was guilty of, which is did you know that Anakin Skywalker is going to be Darth Vader as opposed to the context here, which is just like, no, he's making some stupid emotional decisions.
59:24 He's just a buddy. They go they go to that like it's the ship that like kind of picks up detritus and stuff, and the like main dude is that they call They call him Lizardo for her what species that he is, But he's the same species as like a character in Bad Badge that is great Lizardo, which I'm pretty sure is a Bucker Bonds I wrath. Have you see that movie? Asmen? Now? Whoa Buckero Bonds is like Avengers Infinity War but without the bummer ending. And also in the eighties where you were just watching it, you're like, what is all of this? What is that? It would be the experience I'm show never having watched Marvel and watching Avengers Infinity War and you're just like, I don't understand any of this.
1:00:17 That's what the Avengers of buck Roup Bonds. I yes, it is wild. Jeff Goldplum plays a cowboy in New Jersey. Don amen, Uh. He's one of my favorite moments. So like what it was like they come up and they're like, you know, obviously not going to be like we're Jedi, and he calls he calls the Soka Pokems and I loved that, Like, he's just like Pokem's ears really sat on an R two unit. It's also the introduction I think of those. Is it the introduction of the assassin droids? They show up later, of course in Mandalorian, and this might be the first time. Oh yes, in general the IG eighty eight, Yeah, which is fantastic, It's really cool stuff. Oh I didn't like that decision? You didn't, no, because I'm stealing this from Star Wars Minute, which is such a rad podcast. But that notion in Star Wars that you see one thing and suddenly whenever you dig into the extended universe, Candon, you're like, actually all of them are this way as opposed to it's just a droid that happens to be an assassin, but all of those droids are assassins. That's really more of a quibble. But I just like the it's just I think, just like the prospect of IG eighty eight just being a droid that happened to be an assassin as opposed to a legion of assassin droids. Does that make sense? Am I smart? I mean for sure that makes sense. This came out before Mandalorian. So these
1:01:51 droids are like designated as assassin droids. No start, But there's IG eighty eight and Empire strikes back. Oh my god, you're right. I G e is the is the one of the bounty hunters. Oh my god, you're absolutely right. So you're you're right, You're right, You're right. I do I am with you. Then that it's like maybe that's just a droid that's a bounty hunter versus Oh no, they're all yeah, no, I'm with you. You're you see you see a Yoda and suddenly all of the Yodas from that plane a short. It's another thing that grinds my gears. I don't like that grogu is fifty something years old. Yeah, it does in terms of like I'm like, what does he do just like have a huge growth spurt, like over the next ten what happens? How does his development work? Yeah? No, no, no, you're right.
1:02:45 I had completely forgotten about Empire. Wow, slap my hand rast or whatever you want to slap my face, like my face, No, I'm like, I'm not. But you have that notion of extended universe canon where it like, you mean an accountant in the movies, and then you read the extended universe, and it's just like he actually comes from a planet of accountants, all of them. The whole whole planet is one big accounting firm. Oh wait, you mean what do you? Are you a friend to something making? I think? Are you saturrizing something a long time ago? Start dating this week? I quoted a boat, I dated a game, but none of them could work my drive into high birth space. The best of both worlds can meet in the second place, Captain slog on a Halla Kron.
1:03:52 I wanted a song. I penned a song seventeen more minutes advised and super high aboard the USS Enterprise dt F. Don't you take my walk lighter and clip it? Don't you take my wretchard buddy and nip it? If you spill the tea, I'm gonna snip bit a starship. What are we doing? Oh? Oh my god, I can't have to tell you something. Okay, you know the television program I'm actually on, Dropout. Yes, they just did this as like a shiny question like question, and it was basically they had to choose between they gave They gave a like a name, and it was either supposed to be like a ship, you know, name like a romantic relationship like Railo, or is it a a starship?
1:04:51 And I was like, that's ours. They stole something from Track Wars. Still, they clearly have listened. And if he come on the Poe anyway, Come on the Pope anyway, Brian David Gilberg, come on the Pope. No, I thought. I got so excited because obviously what we're doing is we're naming our favorite ships, starships that sail to the stars in our favorite romantic relationships. Well, the ships don't necessarily sail through the stars this week. That's true, That's very true. Oh my gosh, I didn't. I was doing so much shut around the Okay Corral, but I didn't even stop to think about this. Not only did I think about it, I wrote it down. Oh fantastic. You can go first, which starship I'm going to say? And this is going to create a great discussion on one of the most dynamic action scenes that they've seen, or the most novel action scenes that I've seen in the Clone Wars so far, the six leg at attes. Those Okay, that would have been mine. I did bucker love those things. Oh I love them so much because Grievous is the Republic is around the planet because they're trying to protect the planet, and Grievous is like we grievous in an allusion to the Star Trek two. Maybe probably not, It's more likely Folony just being like in filmmakers, not just Folony being like, why don't they just go Why don't they just go up? I say that all the time. Why don't they just dance? And the answer
1:06:23 is because it would be a strategic risk. Instead, we have to go through the rocks because it's going to give us more beat. It's just going to be better. We're gonna have more cover. Is riskier, sure, but it's going to pay off because the Republic would not be crazy enough to go through it because they can't lose forces. So put those asteroids looked like potatoes, that's all. That's probably because an empire strikes back. There were actual potatoes as asteroids in the background. I didn't that. Yeah, I'm so happy I did not notice that. I'm glad that you noticed that.
1:07:04 That's probably why I'm so happy. And so the Republic stations some attes along with clones on the asteroids, it's very cool. The Felony Zone revealed that again they have limited assets. They don't want to build new stuff, and so they had. What they did have was attes, which created a very novel action set piece by putting the attes on the asteroids, and so whenever Grievis's ship comes through, they start firing. It's very cool. And then you couple that with the fact that the atte looks really cool. It's like a little beetle it does. It looks like a little insect. Oh God, I love it. It's a great set piece. I absolutely love it.
1:07:53 It was a fantastic, fantastic battle. I have been looking up because I I did remember there was a ship that I was like, wowho, I love this ship. I just don't know the name of it, but maybe if I describe it, you'll know what I'm talking about, which is they look like Battlestar Galactic as ships. They're separatist ships and they just had such they're the ones I think they're the ones that were they were going after Anakin when he had come up on light light speed and like he did that fun thing where he had the missiles shot at him and he kind of like stopped and then all the missiles sort of like came together, and then he like shot at the missiles and blew them all up at the same time.
1:08:33 Was very cool. And there are these very specific kind of ships that were so battlestarted to me. They might have enjoyed try fighters that might have been like what they were, but I just loved the look of them very specifically. Do you know the ones I'm talking about? I do not know what the ones that you're talking about. I might have to scroll through the episode later in order to literally just see what you're talking about. Listeners, if you know what the ship is that she's talking about, please ride in correct us, just like Juilty partner corrected me on that episode of Star Trek Voyager, which I truly appreciate. Yeah, I mean a second second place is whatever the fuck that thing is At the beginning of the Specter of the Gun.
1:09:15 Oh, I looked, but I compared episodes. It's almost like it's like a booie out there that's spinning and I'm like, what is going on with anything? It kind of looks like a horrus earpiece but just doubled. Yeah, basically, the new version just looks a lot like the old versions, just like spinning, like a spinning top in space. I didn't really like that thing. Their goal with the remastered versions was to try and approximate the original versions as closely as possible, because also they were doing this in the wake of the Star Wars Special Edition, and so they were like, we can't change it too much, but also we want to update it. Yeah, the updates are really lovely. I just really like original stuff.
1:10:00 Yeah, I love gosh. I love the way that it looks originally. I know that they're worried about it looking rough and stuff, and I'm just like, this looks gorgeous. I love the grain texture on the ships. Yeah. Also, it just reminds me as a film dude to be like this stuff is hard. Yeah. Yeah, you were literally seeing the fruits at their labor because they No one had ever made a Star Trek before, no one and ever remained science fiction TV like that before there was other science fiction case in point, lost in space. But it just feels radically different. Yeah. I love it. I love it, But I mean it's the same reason I very much like the original Star Wars. Apart from all of the Great Man shit. You know, it's more just like I mean just said it earlier, Like if someone came in and was like, let's make these special effects an evil dead better, I'd be like, fuck off.
1:10:57 They're like what is created like has spirit to it. And like I again, I think the remastered Star Trek is very beautiful and they are definitely components of like the remastered Star Wars are beautiful, but there's some like real joy. Yeah. And also the difference with the Star Trek remastered is that you can go buy the original versions. Whenever you buy the Blu ray or shoot even on Amazon, you can go buy the original versions. The versions that are streaming on Paramount Plus are the remastered ones, but you can go find the original ones and a extremely high quality. Yeah. That's not the case with the original Star Wars. You had to go through different channels to go find things. And then the weird thing is that those original versions have those restoration efforts have gone to the fans. There's this fascinating ownership of that.
1:11:59 Uh. And that's why I ship fans. You ship yourself with the fans. Yeah, that's right. Yeah, gosh, I never want to ship myself at Star Wars fans. Okay, what's your what's your ship? What's your real ship? Check off in Sylva, Okay, you took it. That's fine, it's a good one. They really there's a lot of kissing. There's a lot of kissing and then check off at some points, like I gotta look if we're gonna go the distance, I gotta tell you I'm not actually part of the Clantons. I'm actually Pabo Chekhov, to which Sylvia is like, no, you're not, You're one of the Clantons, Aspen. Would you like to hear the gross thing that Jeane Roddenberry wanted this week? Oh my god, let me think about it for a second.
1:12:53 Okay, Jeanie Beanie can't help himself. Geenie Beanie can't He can't help but be disgusting. What do you want? Re check off? And Sylvia again from these are the voyages, yeap, grab onto your microphoneouncement. I don't want to excel us. Hit it. Yeah, just grab on. I've got a problem with hitting this microphone. Let's see if we can get away with making Sylvia about sixteen years old what, or at least suggesting she's just a kid. For one thing, this is how it was in the true Old West. And for another and make sure kind of special in ties in with the youth image we hope to get up check off and our young Russian would certainly have some interesting comments to make about how America's history included the using of tender young things for that age of such purposes. I quit, please, please know, I don't want to do this podcast with anyone else.
1:13:49 I gotta quit. No, please don't, please, don't go. Dear Mountain Berry's dead, right, yeah, very dead, very dead. Do you want to up as bounds and curse them that I follow you and do the after life? Oh my god? I like that multiple times, like do you know what Genie Beanie wanted to do here? And like someone was able to be like no no, no no no no no no no no no some of them, but it sounds like the worst of them people were like my, my dude, my bro. It's just way too often that Gene comes in as like what there's a sex thing? Oh my god, get out of here. It's so weird. And then also what's going to be great? And I hope that you can keep this in mind for way later down to the podcast history, but sex just kind of goes away in Star Trek. It just stops boring. I mean that's the thing. It's not like I want that kind of gross sex, but I want there to not be set x, you know, like I just wanted to be like not pedophiling. Well, the weird thing is that sex kind of goes away, but hot ladies are still all over the place in Star Trek. Got it, but it's just never talked about and then it's weird and gross.
1:15:15 So there's still sexualization. Oh yeah, just without agency. Cool you throw it away? Yeah, ah, cool, Mine would be McCoy and Doc Holiday shut up. McCoy walks into the sort of dentist space because he's looking for materials to to knock them out, and like you mentioned earlier, they don't. They're not working because this is about like believing in the thing. And back up, you haven't talked about the fact that they try to make a tranquilizer grenade. Yes, a tranquizer grenade. It was really rad, very cool. It's really cool, and it's because they couldn't like use guns or certain things. And goes in with this NBC tenet of we don't want our characters to be building like a gun, and Leonard de Moyer was like, I don't want my character building a phaser. He would be building a communicator or something, try and get us out of here. And the compromise was this rad tranquilizer that should have worked because whenever they're talking, McCoy screams, not screens, but McCoy's like, give me a mortar and pestel.
1:16:30 Oh, I wanted to ask you, I've got a question. Yeah, if you were to pronounce that word, would you say pestle or pestlet because McCoy says pestle and then Kirk says pestel. Huh, what do you want? What do you want? To be true? I want I noticed it. I noticed it so specifically I would say, I would say hand solo, hey, I would say Leah, I would say I knew someone I had. I would say look ski Walker in college named Forrest and the forrests so like spelled like Paris but with an F, but it was Forrest, and another one of my friends could literally like. I would be like, so, Forrest standing right here wants to go see a movie, and my friend would always be like, oh, Ferris is that what you want, and I'm just like, Forrest has said this, and he'd just be like Ferris, and I was just like, how is this possible? Like I don't understand how we could be doing this. You can literally just repeat what you were saying Forrest anyway. That's why I was just That's why I noted it is so funny, because I was like, one explicitly said pestle on one said pestle, and then I was like, I don't actually know hous pronounced mccoyday they're kissing. So he comes into that space to get the materials for this fun little tranquilizer like bomb which rules, and he's like he goes into the dentist's office basically and he's just like, oh, so soul work.
1:17:58 And this guy I was like standing there over someone who has god such a good reveal, like, oh my god, act just being like you're gonna chill in his barber chair and we're gonna put like a towel over you. You just chill. McCoy is just like looking at stuff and he's like, I'm gonna take some of those, you know, right, And he's just like is that okay? And the other guy's like it's not mine. It is and like the real being that his name is Doc Holiday because he used to be a dentist, and he like takes the towel off his head, gets up and just like comes in with that like dead man thing. But they're so close to each other, and I was like, you got a kid, you gotta keys right now, Electric energy, wild chemist, and instead he's just like they're gonna die. And I was like, ooh, ANIMI is all lovers. Never happened the last anyway. Then he got out like Okay, I'm just going to take the ship for no good reason.
1:19:01 Oh come by, thank you ador this ship. We did it. But oh we're not done. We're not yet done. As we go to the main concep of the podcast, of course, knock it off the all this artist's objective stuff. We actually both believe that art is objective, and there can only be one winner in the eternal fight of which is better. Star Trek versus Star Wars is once again we rank Specter of the Gun from Star Trek the original series season three versus Star Wars the Clone Wars Downfall of a Droid Aspen. Since I went first, daring a starship it. Why don't you go first with ranking? It's so funny. I Hi, you know what, I agree, it's freak funny. What's funny? I keep just giving all of these Clone Wars episodes like up in like the sevens right, and I'm like, oh, should I be more thoughtful about this?
1:19:58 But I think that they are just fucking gut. Yeah, dude, I'm gonna give us a seven point seven, seven point seven, just we can give it room to grow when it like nails it in the second episode. Yeah, I'm gonna get this one a seven as well. This is a great episode. Love the characterization, love them deepening dynamics, and then also we've got some great action in there. Yeah. That brings it to a collector total of seven point three five er Star Wars the Clone Wars Downfall of the Drive, but that's still anyone's game. As Aspen moves over to the Star Trek field, Aspen putting on their appropriate pads and gloves, getting ready to hop out on the field and rank Specter of the Gun. So I did tell you I love West, you will love us all. I love the weird surrealness of this episode. Not only that, but you texted me and I quote Kenny wild West, yep, I responded to Pepe you and then you went I immediately like this more than gangsters. I love West, which I responded with, and I believe this. You're high on yourself.
1:21:09 The gangster episode is a masterpiece. It's not it's a master piece. It's not good. If you are teaching a screenwriting class, go this A piece of the action is the greatest subscript that does ever exist in I quit like you. I'm out of here. I'm out here, I gotta go, I gotta go. I'm going to dig up your bones. I'm my cursing. I want to give this a seven. And here's why I'm not getting it higher. I mean, seven's good. It's because I think, like I said earlier, the thing that sustains it is it's extremely cool visuals, and I think if it had had a little bit more oomph like, it would have been even better. A lot of the episode, Oh gosh, what kind of suffers from the same thing that and the children shall lead suffer from, which is the audience is way ahead of the characters, and a lot of the episode is just waiting. We're not the Clantons, right, and everyone. They go to everyone in town to be like, we're not the Clantons. And the rule is established that they believe the town believes that they're the Clantons. So why would our extremely smart characters continue to go elsewhere to be like, yes, actually we're not the Clantons. Yes we know that, so why not participate in something else. It does feel a little bit like if this episode could have been thirty minutes, it would have been perfect. It has that sort of feel like it or if more were happening
1:22:43 in the middle of it. And yet, and the thing is that, like when the stuff does happen, it's so interesting, Like that ending is so cool. Like when they shot the shot from the back where you're just seeing you're seeing them and there's the fences, like the side of the corral presumably, and they're all standing there. They just start shooting at them, and the you don't see the bullets hit them or even go through because you're adjusting the fence, and it's just like all these holes in the fence and they all just here standing there, and it's such a cool effect. It is wild. It's so cool. The ending is outstanding. I love the ending, and uh, the beginning's interesting. Yeah, it's just that big long middle chunk where have real circular stuff. Because I love West and because I love the ending and you really love West or are you just looking around the room and just saying that you love West. I really love the wall.
1:23:45 I love lamp. That's why I'm like, you still get a seven from me, because I like weird shit. So yep, I'm going to give this one a five point nine. Wow, okay, because of the reasons that I said, little Doll. Also, I docked a down point one because I don't like West. I think all things in the West are usually boring as hell. Oh my gosh. I don't like things that are dry and dusty. Now is that a bias that prevents me from enjoying some masterpiece things like Fury Road and Furiosa. You bet it is. It is a huge bias. This is actually very interesting because I famously famously to me love the desert. You love Dusty. I love Dusty. If something is set in the desert, it is very much. It has it has like a benefit, like it is beneficial, like it could be bad. And I'm like, well, it was in the Desert. So yeah, like I genuinely wonder if I think, God, I'm like been really obsessed with the movie. No plately, I just like could watch that movie over and over again. There's a lot of reasons why that movie is so good or and Peel part of it going into hopefully, hopefully is Spielberg Years, because that last forty minutes of that movie, I'm like, this is Spielberg.
1:25:11 This is Jordan Peel operating at the horror realm. Anymore, he is operating in classic Spielberg filmmaking the way its horror. Yeah, but also you know in the last forty minutes is a Western Spielberg. I mean, the thing that classic Spielberg is operating with is that horror notion. But he understands that horror is thrilling. Yes, yes, Jurassic Park operates as a horror movie. It's just that the slasher is dinosaurs Jaws in them. But it's also an adventure. And also Jaws is like operating as the examination of small town politics, which is thrilling. Close Encounters the third kind operating with horror rules kind of, but then understands that central mystery not understanding and then you say sacrifice everything in order to go see the mystery. It feels like you're getting off topic, which is oh right, Star Wars Desert, Oh, no, desert, but yeah, the desert, Kenny, the desert. That's right, The desert wins. This week Star Wars The Clone Wars down three five s posted Specter of the Gun, which has a paltry six point four or five, which you know, I feel like is the correct ranking for that episode. Yeah, there are worse episodes, better episodes, true, very this episode is okay plus corral Uh. If you like those witness why
1:26:59 not subscribe to our paint on patreon dot com slash track Wars pod for five smackers a month, where you can hear earlier versions of our episodes and extended versions of our episodes. Aspin and I got into a little bit of Star Wars Diaclai and also Doctor Who at length, as well as a let any of other things. We love Doc love It, we love Shuty, and we love you. Patrons again Patreon dot com slash trek Wars pod, and you too could join the fine auspices of fine folks such as timbot Sosa, Emily, Bryce, love Heii Rogers Kevin Miller, Arizona, Mark Austin Aaron and lastly, but certainly not weekly Jolty Partner, who was the composer of this theme song. The theme song being a starship it our main theme was composed by mister Tustin Alifesso, which if you would like to hear more of his music, please visit the link down in the show notes below. Additionally, if you would like to see us react to things, go down to the show notes and hop over and subscribe to our YouTube channel YouTube dot com slash hopefully trek Wars Pod whenever we get the hire subscriber base. I tried to stay like more in my seat this time to be a more visually appealing person. Thank you, I appreciate them. Yeah. Uh, last piece of business. I would be remiss if I didn't mention that Rob Coleman directed the episode of Star Wars the Clone Wars, and Rob Coleman was the animation director of the prequel trilogy and also helped establish the lucasfilm animation. Wow,
1:28:31 that's pretty interesting, and also what was interesting is that he was not in the behind the scenes of the Polony Zone. I'm just interested. I want to know more of how Star Wars the Clone Wars works anything else before we call it a night. Aspen No, I love you, and I love you Aspen, and we love you audience. Thank you so much for listening to us and watching us. May the Force be with you and live long and prosper helish s
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Spreaker
RSS Feed