Empire Strikes Back v. A Private Little War
Aspen and Kenny dive into the depths of proxy wars and American jingoism. Are we the baddies, they ask? And the answer is yes, yes we are.
They're also joined by dead and made up guests alike, including Jeff Trekworthy, Irvin Kershner, the Lucas...
Aspen and Kenny dive into the depths of proxy wars and American jingoism. Are we the baddies, they ask? And the answer is yes, yes we are.
They're also joined by dead and made up guests alike, including Jeff Trekworthy, Irvin Kershner, the Lucas himself, and Francine the Popcorn Lady. What an ep, folks.
_________________
Get early, extended episodes on our Patreon at https://www.patreon.com/trekwarspod
Theme by Tosin Awofeso
Social Media:
https://www.instagram.com/trekwarspod
https://bsky.app/profile/trekwarspod.bsky.social
Want to ask us questions? Email us at trekwarspod@gmail.com .
And leave us a review! https://bit.ly/leave-a-review-trek-wars
0:27 Welcome to the Track Wars podcast, the Internet's exclusive outlet for all things trying to answer that one important question, which is better Star Trek or Star Wars by going through both franchises and chronological release order. I am Kenny Madison, the Star Trek contingent with me as for always. Hi, my name's Aspin Webster, and I'm the Star Wars contingent. And this week let's get down to brass tacks. Damn. I have to make that big go longer so that you have more of a reaction to it next time. Wait, what was the bit? You didn't notice my bit? No, we got we gotta get to this. Can't I even doing a bit for like a year now? The bit is that when you introduce me, I I like never actually just say who I am? Like I just like I make it like I do a dumb thing or make a weird voice or something. That's when I have I literally listen to every single episode. I listened to some of the episodes twice three times. Yeah you don't, you don't notice my bit?
1:26 Nope? Have I been Have I been doing the bit? Or have I just has it been a dream? Have I introduced myself? Normally every single time. Kenny, am I okay, am I having a stroke? That baby cool. I guess you just gotta get to it. Speaking of deep seated portrayals and uh, perhaps projecting images of deception in order to keep yourself safe and gardner control. Oh my god, we're just used you just using me as your segue. Speaking of is today we're covering the Empire strikes Back special edition versus a Private Little War The Empire Strikes Back famously star wars in a Private Little War from Star Trek the original series Aspen. How are you doing today? Uh, I'm okay. We just chattle that. So that was good. But now my back hurts. My lower back hurts.
2:31 I think I should probably stretch more. Probably should be a thing that I should do. I think when I was younger, I didn't think I would YouTube, and now I think I need to. Yeah, I think about doing some yoga, maybe maybe drinking more water, getting into yogurt, yogurt, eat more yogurt, getting into yogurt. Yeah. So yeah, I think that's I'm just like reflecting on that. My back kind of hurts. Speaking of reflecting, I think it's kind of to reflect on the synopties of these films for people that are playing the home game. My favorite thing is that the reason I think you're like, ask them we got to get to it is because in our Patreon part I was just like Kenny, we can't keep talking. We have to get to our podcast because it's late. We're gonna need to go to sleep at some point. And now I'm the one dilly Delly, but I gotta make jokes. Speaking and making jokes. The premisey is of these episodes is anything butto joke, as we take these two properties extremely seriously, starting with A Private Little War from Star Trek the original series, written by Teleplay Rather We're sorry, let me start from the beginning story by jud Crusis, teleplay by Gene Roddenberring, directed by Mark Daniels, aired February two, nineteen sixty eight, from an NBC press release issue January third, nineteen sixty eight. An inhabitant of the imperialistic planet Klingon is sent
4:02 to execute the takeover a peaceful, primitive neural, forcing Captain Kirk to wage quote unquote a Private Little Warrant on NBC Television Network Star Trek color cast of Friday February second, Kirk and his officers being down on Neural for a routine meeting, only to find that the Klingon's Kroll already has shared of trouble between the Planes people under the leadership of Tyree and the hill People under the leadership of Appella. Tyree's wife, no Nah, wants her husband to make use of kirk super weapons so that she can become queen. Resulting war brings about a costly peace. Cool sounds fun, sounds like a great time. If you thought that was a great time, you both you be right. Except see if you think that that was a great time, you my star trek Vane, I really love that discribe. You might really love the original series.
5:05 Do you like my new character Jeff Trackworthy? I do. You should just do that every time. Let's you a new segment, Live long and prosper. You might be trek Vine. Oh my god, I think I I think I'd die. You find yourself going along the planes looking for the hill people, then get poisoned by and move got to You got to? You might be a treking. I realized where I had heard move got to and seen it before, and it was in lower decks. Because I've never seen this episode before. It was five minutes of Mike. Let's strike that from the record. So instead of reading the description for Empire Strikes Back, because we all know what it's about, this is our third time talking about it, but of course we did not talk about the special editions. I'm going to read a Reddit post by someone who's deleted their account, but it's from three months ago and the Star Wars subreddit outstanding. I've heard a lot that the Empire Strikes Back has the best special edition because it didn't have a lot of the really infamous changes the other two films had, and overall was changed the least. I do agree that it is technically the best of the three, but the Special Edition of The Empire still makes some baffing, bafflingly bad changes. First off, I will bring up the one major change I really like is what they did with Cloud City. It's much more vibrant in the Special Edition, and it feels more like a real city. It's probably
6:36 the best change made in all the films. I also like the clean up special effects. However, unfortunately the bad change is still outweigh the good ones. And I'll stop there because we know what happens at Empire, but so what I learned from that is of the three, this one is considered to be the least bad of the three in terms of what is sign magnificantly changed. Of course, knowing that a lot of things are changed on a more minor level, like color grading and stuff that maybe you don't see as much, but when it comes to say like changing things but dialogue inserting unnecessary scenes, it appears to me that this one is considered the least offensive. Thank you deleted user from Reddit. And of course, The Empire Tracks Back Special Edition was released February twenty first, nineteen ninety seven. Story credit by George Lucas and screenplay credit by Lee Brackett and Lawrence Canstan and director by hold On.
7:42 I'm getting knocked at the Truck Wars door. Hold On, let me open it. Oh hello, oh, oh, it's me Irvin Kirshner. Did you I heard that. I heard that you were talking about The Empire Strikes Back, one of the films that I directed. I directed that after the Eyes of Laura Mars, but before at the time I directed Robo cop To. I didn't even know and never say never again. The James Bond film The James the very same. Oh my gosh, wait, what's your favorite movie you've ever directed? Irving? I think that it has to be most definitely with a bullet if the question happens to be that you are wanting me to answer which one of my films are my favorite that I have ever directed? And in looking at my filmography to answer your question of which one is my favorite? Are you looking yourself up on IMDb right now? Irving?
8:54 Robo cop too? Okay, rad, I've not seen it? Good? Oh oh wow, I just left all right? And again that is Empire strikes back director Urban Wow, Kenny, did you know God? So nice that he came by, especially considering he's dead. Wow, that doesn't stop people. There were two original versions of the film, the seventy millimeter and the thirty five, So some of the don't like that. How do you know that? How do you know that Coopleet accident? A complete accident?
9:43 How was it? I googled something and you googled something? Yeah, but it was yeah, but it was like it was like googling. I was just like, dang, why everyone's so in this film? You know? And then they were like did you know there were two original versions and far fewer people, of course saw the seventy millimeter, and many more saw the thirty five and some of the changes, and some people, I don't know if this is confirmed, but people were speculating that there are that the there could have been better quality sound on the seventy milimeters, So there's changes, there's dialogue changes that are actually in the seventy milimeters that were not in thirty five and are now in the remastered version. Isn't that wild? Yeah?
10:35 Yeah, Lucas's revisionism starts in the theater, in the theater where it should be sacred. That's what they were saying, even though this is not his film, Even though, as we discussed last week at length, this special edition experiment is part of highlighting the Star Wars saga, the Star Wars franchise, reminding us Star Wars trilogy good and also this narrative that this all kind of sprang forth from George Lucas has said, fully formed, it's a masterpiece. It's all one story. Get excited for the prequels. You wrote all of this down in a mythic document, Christ Almighty. As opposed to what happened, which is it's filmmaking by committee. Yeah, and it is filmmaking by committee. I don't know what you want from me. Tell me more, say more filmmaking, Say more things to make me grumpy. Sure, well, maybe don't. Maybe let's do first impressions both of these things.
11:46 What's the first impression theme song? There we go, that's the theme song. Well, Joel, if you want to make a first impressions theme song, you can do that. I watched the show, watch this movie. It was sweet. That's what they tell me. First impression. I wrote it. You can tell you the real talent is in his household. Ah. Anyways, first impressions, Yeah, strikes Back? Does it hold up? To say, Aspen? Does the Star Wars film that you ranked number one? Does it hold up? Does does a film where every single filmmaker that makes the sequel is like this one is going to be the Empire strikes Back of our series? Does hold up? Does the Empire Strikes Back hold up? Ah? Maybe I'll talk about it and the remastered. In terms of that, I think I agree with deleted subreditor, whoever you are out there that I was. I don't think the changes are as disruptive, and I think some of them are actually. In addition, there's of course that what I was talking about before of the color grading. Some adjustments that I do think are remastering and the truest sense of remastering, or we're trying
13:20 to get this up to standards so that it looks good for you on the various televisions in movie theaters to the movie screens you watch it from. That is great, and you can tell that there's good changes. When it comes to bigger changes, I do think some of them actually are good. I do think Cloud City, I think Bestmin looks lovely to me. It's a little I think similarly to most iiicely. I don't like the dumb dumbness of it all, but I do like the kind of bustling feel. At least Lucas has the good sense to not put a bay or Honkin ronto right swinging a Java around right exactly the time. It truly is just we're expanding the scope of what this place could be, as opposed to the theatrical where the Millennium Falcon and the cloud cars fly in, and that it's cut to the falcon landing on the platform right and I am. I obviously am perfectly fine with that, and I think it's probably clear I do prefer the very original versions, but if you are taking the tools that you have on hand, it is not a bad addition to make to make it a bit more bustling, to add in more detail. It feels very alive, and I do think of cloud City as being a very lively place full of people who are
14:54 working and are part of this place. Yeah, it feels very it feels very vivacious to me, and it felt even more so it feels very ethereally vivacious, if that makes sense, and feels a lot less empty, and that's lovely. Some other things, and again I'm very, very nitpicky, but these are the biggest changes. The Wampa. Actually, they added some Wampa scenes I noticed, and whoever was I don't know if someone was in a Wampa costume or if it was puppeted. I imagine there was a Wampa costume. Whoever was doing that was truly terrifying in the way that they were moving and I was. I think there's a lot to be said about not seeing the creature and the dread of was it going to come get me?
15:41 But I know the wamp is there, so maybe it rewards me as being a frequent watcher to have the camera cut to that wampa noawn on something with blood dripping off its face and then looming as it stands like I'm gonna getcha, and I was just like gonna, So yeah, I mean, those are details, So maybe it goes outside of the realm of first impressions, but far less distracting this time around. There are some pieces. I am grumpy, but still still a fabulous film to watch. Pacing is not ruined, unlike New Hope. Pacing, although there is that sequence at the end where Vader says, bring me my ship and then Luke and Vader shuttle are intercut, and it feels wrong. You mean when it's describe the scene Vader at the end, you know, or so is it where is it where Luke's like father and it kind of keeps switching over to Vader. That's good, Okay, that is great. Yeah, where Luke's just chilling at the bottom of cloud cit he hanged at the bottom of Cloud Stay and I believe it intercuts in betwixt yes, and He's like, prepare my shuttle, which
17:11 is different because I think before it's like, oh, all he says in the original is like bring me my shuttle or he'll like get my shuttle, and he's like fucking spits it because he is just like God damn it. But I don't remember when he says it. And then the shuttle in the special edition is the shuttle flies to the Star Destroyer, and it cuts the tension of Skywalker literally hanging yes with nothing but clouds. Yes, yes, yes, yes, it pokes a balloon because you just go back towards Darth Vader driving Kenny. I'll tell you what I was saying, Yes, Aspen, Kenny, Yes, Aspen. I think to night right, I think a lot. I'm just stuck in this old nug and all the time kunking, and maybe we said this explicitly. I don't remember clearly anything I say.
18:10 I said something else tonight and Joel was like, you've literally said that exact story or you've said that exact thing, And I'm like, do you know how many episodes of this? I'm sure I repeated myself a billion dimes. I only have so many things I can say, like I'm gonna tell you the same story over and over again. I don't like it, thank you, And maybe this is what we were we were getting it. We were dancing around this of that didn't hit on it exactly. Okay, Robin, I am dancing on my own. I'm in the car watching George Lucas bucket. Whoa, I'm the artist. God, what the fuck was I gonna say? Okay, answer that. It's that the idea that we have to be so explicit in everything we are showing and saying, as opposed to letting the audience be smart, letting the audience put it together, or letting their have letting there be a smodicum of mystery to it, and the desire to to simplify it at the at the cost of the editing and the storytelling and the feel and the pacing of it. And that's just like the thing I feel the most with these how fascinating and also it's fascinating to do this
19:45 with the juxtaposition of the new narrative of George Lucas, his new style of filmmaking where everything is quite plainly stated. As I have also said before, I think subtlety is underrated or overrated is overrated. You don't need to be subtle and also the changes I think, as you said, do you make things more explicit. It's literally revealing more mystery, you know, because Lucas wants it. And also we exist within a paradigm where there is no room for satlety anymore. Yeah, because everything can be taken out of context.
20:33 Which is a completely separate conversation as opposed to talking about the Empire strikes Back special editions, which so interesting within the Great Man narrative of George Lucas and what he wanted the Star Wars trilogy to be. But we're not into that yet. We're still in first impressions. Sorry, we're still in first impressions. So yeah, that was my first impression, these impressions. But also we haven't talked about that yours are a Star Trek yet. Uh. Private Little War interesting episode that might not entirely work. So go back to Empire strikes Back, No I do. Here we go, Let's go to deep. Let's go to deeper dive. Let's go to deeper dive. Let me, okay, we'll talk about no no, no, no, no, no no no. I tell my first impression of Private Little War. Oh okay, the same as you deeper dive. Here we go. There's a whole lot that I'm gonna be talking about in regards to a private little war.
21:26 Okay, but I just want to talk about Empire strikes back in relation to the great Man narrative that I've been I've been weaving into this and I want you to pipe in frequently because it's fun. What if I pipe in in character? I don't know what character? Do you want to pick a character? Yeah? I just be like, it's me, Fry insane, who's this? Who's this character? Please? Don't not talk. Please don't put this in your jfl audition. Real, don't do that, Fry insane, don't do that? What stopcord? Don't what? This is a terrible choice, A lot to make popcorn sugar Moreen Michael's is sitting there famously cross armed, and then she writes it down. It just goes. That's when Webster star. Oh my god, I love her. I just invented her.
22:15 She's so good. That's her only character trait fancy. She loves popcorn. Can you imagine? She made popcorns so many ways? But she has a paper. It's getting close to Lissa McCarthy's pizza lady. Sorry, I'll just chime it as myself the real character, because who says what a human is? Is this the face the character I present to the world or is it truly me? WHOA Okay? So on our Empire stracks back versus Star Trek two episode covered a lot of material, covered a lot about the development of this covered a lot about IRMA. Kershner is a different approach the special Edition and first and foremost is not an urban Kurshner approved project. Kersh as a Kersh the Kersh Yeah, fuck yes, Kersh is not necessarily on bad terms with Lucas. You were gonna see change changes. But he was like, he didn't sign off on these because it's George Lucas project. It's a lucasfilm product. Can I interrupt you real quick? Always aspen, always as myself. These people I'm paying tain like popcorn crazy. There these people who are not necessarily a bad terms but do kind of like dislike each other in
23:47 a little grum crumbs. Do you think they're just like because they're in the same like, you know, I don't even think Kersh was on bad terms with Lucas because Lucas went to Kersh because he was like, I'm a fan of yours. You were, if I remember correctly, Kersh And I think I covered this on the previous Empiusjack's Back episode. One of the three, one of the two. Kirsh was Lucas's professor, right, you did talk about that Lucas literally looks left Kersh but also still make changes on the special edition. But also that might be an explanation of why the changes are not so intrusive in a film that Lucas famously did not like he did it?
24:30 Did we talk about that? Have you told me that I'm not trying? When I googled why are these people so hot? Why didn't I say that? Yeah? I don't know. I just know that Lucas, when watching this film was like, this is not what I wanted. Let me try and cut my own version. What did he want? He what he made? And you can read allusions to this the Alan Dean Foster film Splinter of the Mind's Eye. Star Wars was going to go one of two ways. Star Wars was either going to go to where it went, which is the Empire Strikes Back way, an odd film that, instead of heightening the stinks, went inward, made the journeys, more character based, complicated characters, and interrogated the hero's monomith in an interesting way, and interrogated the real nature of selflessness. Ten out of ten love it? Then? Yeah, Lucas was like, what if we go the way of Indiana Jones where these are just individual adventures. I see, we all know that that second Indiana Jones film, Temple of Doom so good. He's monkey's brains and you can read, you can read? Uh do that guy and Francy would be best friends.
26:02 Yeah, Jeff Tracksworthy and Francie who eats bockworn our jfl audition real is gonna be so tight. So anyway, Splinter of the Mind's Eye, which if you have read it is no very much. I read it not as research, just as a fun thing because I was like, what was star Wars high in fiction without all the backage of Star Wars? And Splinter of the Mind's Eye was commissioned by George Lucas it being like, if Star Wars doesn't work, we can just make like a cheapy sequel, and that Splinter of the Mind's Eye. So Splinter of the Mind's Eye by Alan Deine Foster, it's this unused screenplay idea by George Lucas or Alanine Foster. Either way, unused screenplay idea, which is just them looking for the Kayper crystal.
26:59 Oh on mimban, like any kiber crystal, Like he needs to kyber crystal. Oh like there's only one? Yeah, because remember this is detached from the rest of Star Wars continuity. Sorry, I was like, that's absurd. There are multiple kyber crystals and you have to go find yours when you're a little padawat and so Han, Solo and Chewbacca aren't even in it. They're not referenced. It is Luke and Lea crashed on a planet and they're just having adventures. Cute. Do just Lea get a piece of the big guy Kiber crystal too. You're gonna hate Leah and splinter of the Mind's Eye and the event that you read it, because she's a real damsel in distress.
27:41 That sounds there's I have a literal framed art. I don't know if I've told you about this that is like a picture of Leah flicking you off that says resist and I need you to know that about me. Thank you. As response to that, so I think Lucas has had a complicated relationship with Empire strikes Back. Also, this is his last collaboration with Gary Kurtz, who is a producer, that it goes back to him on at least American Graffiti, important collaborator, and this is where Lucas starts aggregating his control post Empire strikes Back. That's why he's more hands on a Return of the Jedi. That's why a Return of the Jedi is a course correction because he didn't like Empire. He didn't like he didn't like it. It wasn't what he wanted. And also critical reception at the time was kind of yeah, and it's only through time that people were able to appreciate it. And so then now that people have been like because this is now February ninety seven when special Edition gets released, and now it comes from the mind of George Lucas.
29:00 He was Vader's father the entire time. He planned it as oh right. One of the changes is that the Emperor is replaced by a McDermott, as opposed before when it was played by a woman with chimpanzee eyes, which would be fine. Actually it's fine, like aligning it with I mean m this plan and uh return of the Jedi. So uh, that's a consistent change if you're going to do that, it's whatever. Uh they change the lines though, they change that. And it's when Darth Vader is having a skype call with the Emperor for the first time. Yeah, and he's just, Hi, can you hear can you? Can you hear me? Can you hear me? Ultimate? Well, I mean I run out of Wi Fi. The reception is clunky, so uh, they they change it.
30:15 And in the new one and they basically he changes it too. And I actually want to point, I want to actually say this out loud and get it right. Is that in the original he's you know, basically calls uh, you know, Luke like he's like their new enemy. Uh, and he and like he calls him Luke Skywalker and Vader's like, you know, he's just a boy. But in the updated version, he says their new enemy is the young rebel who destroyed the Death Star. I have no doubt this boy is the offspring of Anakin Skywalker in Vader responds, how is that possible? But like, I know, I'm sounding like one of those people is just like Memra. But it's like, it's just just so. It just feels like that's an example to me of this is not a helpful change that clarifies anything at all. It just feels like an ego move. It feels like it feels like George Lucas saying, look, I've been the genius all along. But it makes other things that Vader does seem weird and out of place. He refers to him specifically as Skywalker. He knows is Skywalker.
31:34 He's like, my name is Skywalker, and he's like, it's this. This guy also is Skywalker, who's nineteen years old. We understand that the action happened off screen. Yes, we understand this. We understand that he now knows. And you have to do mental gymnastics to make sense of that change. You have to be like, well, Vader was like play and twelve dimensional chairs and ship, and you're just like and it's just like, no, why what are you doing except serving the interests of one self obsessed mono, myth obsessed man, who, to be fair, did give away all of his money from the Disney acquisition to affordable housing two in fighting some Nimbi people who are like, don't build affordable housing in my area.
32:29 God damn it, Kenny, if you make me think complexly about human beings one more time, say this man is uh, he's a villain. He cannot he cannot be good, he cannot tea, he cannot have nu once and be a human being. That's really nice to know, though, y'all, Yes, that's nice, and so I don't think I think Kershner understands that this is a product, even though this is the highlight of his film career. Though. I haven't seen the Eyes of Laura Marsh or RoboCop two, but I have seen never saying never again. RoboCop two is his favorite film he's ever made. He just told me. I didn't tell He told me. I know. He told me that. Yeah, and you haven't seen it. I have not. Unfortunately, I'm so sorry he's seen his favorite Oh my god, my god. Wow, Jesus Christ. Kind a film student? Are you? I know? I'm so sorry you went to school for film, Kenny. I did I have a degree. I have a degree in sitting somewhere, so sure speak speaking of degrees in social work and academic work. A private little war of very interesting episode of Star Trek.
33:57 I also have a degree in International relations. Ooh so maybe ooh, and that's mandergrad degree. Ah, private little War. Perhaps you can shed a little bit more light on a private little war. The introduction of doctor Mabanga. Oh, that was the best part. And also I guess an analogy for the Vietnam War, and at least according to these of the Voyage of season two, the first piece of popular entertainment on television that was able to nakedly tackle the Vietnam War nakedly because everyone apparently was kind of centrist about it at the time. That's funny because this episode comes off as very centrist to me. In fact, it comes off as incredibly pro United States and pro proxy war and pro arming native people's. Actually it's entirely jingoistic. It's so fucking gingerous. Look at those backpadding liberals. Wow. Sorry, yeah, it's not interested at all. It's oh boy oh o my own, which means that it sacrifices everything that Star Trek stands for. But this is also okay, so sorry, this this script commission. This is a Roddenberry idea. Then it was given to writer Don Ingles, who had previously written The Alternative Factor. It's an episode that exists. It was gutted. I
35:28 forgot what happened at this point. There's oh what a Lazarus. That's right, but there's so many, so much media that we consume. That's correct. Sorry, I'm not about to have another crisis about it, Okay, go on. Basically, this is an idea from Roddenberry rod himself. I'll read you this, thank you. I'll read you this from jine Kun that I have famously gone to the map for. Because this is an involved script from all hands on deck and then eventually gets written by Roddenberry from Gene coun showrunner at this time. Captain Kirk and his men in this particular show episode are put rather in the situation the current day CIA, which has secret instructions to go in and overthrow a government. This is not necessarily a moral or a decent thing to do, but grab on to something asmen, it is something that must be done. I also think that it is I love that quote a because it pokes holes into Star Trek is a great liberal fantasy.
36:54 Now man, this is liberalism at the time. I mean it's a little bit of liberalism now, yeah, I mean it is. It fucking is, like you hear that same exact word usage. You see this from the president right now in regards to the freaking is the genoside the genocide? I mean, yes, and you it's these are necessary evils. War is not fair? Uh, where we are still living in a world of the desired black and white of World War two in which we are the moral victors and we are not. We are not. I think that is also an important context at this time, even though we are post Korean War, another debacle that ended in kind of a shrug. Yeah, though to be fair, I did not do my research in terms of the paths of the Korean War and the Vietnam War, what the perceptions are at the time. I only did my research on Star Trek and Star Wars and what I know from pop culture. So what is so fascinating is just letting me into the mindset of these I am assuming quite radical for the system liberals, or at least Hollywood liberals, and they're still just like Vietnam complicated. What you're gonna do?
38:22 Yeah, it's complicated. I make posts on Instagram about it. I mean the mindset obviously, if you were to put your if you were to put your head into it and be like, oh, kid, OK, we're just coming out of We're still in the Vietnam War. We're coming out of height of McCarthyism from the fifties in which many celebrities were implicated as communists. I mean, no one, I don't think is really like stating they're like kind of pro North Vietnam at that point, or kind of like the pro communist forces. But it is not popular by any means to be like, well, like, let's it'll just be fine. What is, of course unpopular, is this ongoing conflict that's continuing to kill people and for what really truly for what. But no one's gonna go out there and be like, I mean, communism's fine, still going to treat because we're in the midst of a Cold War with the USSR as being this power that we are terrified that could you know, come and overpower us and become the world power.
39:34 Still kind of sitting there over everyone's head anyway. That's I don't know if that's reductive, but it's also interesting just because we have the perspective of history and it seems like, at least accepted history that Vietnam was just bad, right, shouldn't have been done, and these folks were living in the middle of it and right again, at least according to the book, which this seems like a radical statement from Mark Cushman to be like, this is the first episode of TV to tackle the Vietnam War. But also what is interesting about Cushman's analysis and here is that he is very quick to be like, oh, yeah, no, this was a lie, this is a story.
40:15 I can't necessarily trust this. And so with that kind of commentary on here of being like, this is the first episode for me, holds a little bit more weight. So perhaps it truly is, if not the first episode of TV, which I find extremely difficult to believe. Yeah, at least this is I don't know, a little bit more naked. I mean, it puts it in we're speaking of stating things in explicit terms, and this thing literally states the twentieth century brush wars in Asia. Yep. And yeah, it is literally calling back to and saying it to me. That's why also was like, well, this isn't just Vietnam, this is also Afghanistan. This is any proxy war that was fought instead of between the United States and the USSR. Explicitly like, that's what it is. So it's very interesting that it's delving into Vietnam, supposedly allegedly from such a Europe from a US. It is it's literally saying the rush Wars in the twentieth century and the unfortunate truth that they just had to go on. This is epplicit.
41:35 It's explicit. It's explicit text. And if wil Makers Roddenberry the great bird of the Galaxy at this time is just like Vietnam has to happen this way because what else is there The centre is you can see the US as an imperialist power, yes, and the US must be an imperialist power and we must do what we have to do. That's what I think is very interesting because to me, we've talked about this. Star Wars is Star Wars. Oh yeah, oh my gosh, George, George, where'd you come from? Man? I don't want to say you didn't knock? Have you just been there the whole time? I don't want to say, oh you don't too shy, Oh you shy baby? Oh yeah? It was okay, Yeah he got a medal. Good for him. Everyone cared. Yeah, okay, under the bed behind the curtain, don't call look for me.
42:36 We can still see your feet, okay, ah yeah, soo war uh he. Of course, explicitly, the rebels are like the Vietcong like they they are the ones who have the least power fighting and they're fighting against the imperialist power. So that is of course the Star Wars side, the Star Trek side. And this this, this instance is the Federation. Kirk and Spock and the Enterprise are the US. They are like, they are the US imperialistic power basically, and they are saying that these people that have Okay, so the baddies, the Klingons who are the USSR have come in and they're supposed to be at a certain level, but they have armed them.
43:23 So wow, these poor noble savages that we are just like, we've got the good ones and they've got the bad ones, and what can we do except give them some weapons too, because you know, it's for their own good, not for our purposes, but it is, it's for your fucking purposes. But they play it off as if it is to empower them and that there is an exclusive baddies side. But to me it just comes off as being so nefarious. And we have of course years and years and years of history, and we have reflection on the structure of that and what it meant. I'm sure at the time it did feel like, oh wow, look at this. Wow, Oh my god, we're so good like at us. I mean, sometimes things are just hard and we have to do the hard things. So I mean, I think this the joys of doing this project. The way that we've been doing this project is just constantly calling the Great Man narrative into question and just showing these things as what they are, which is products of the time and products of human beings that are not right. It is so easy for us to look at art and go even if we are not cognizant of it, we just look at it and it goes truth. This is truth, right, This is a higher ideal because it's on a TV, and we ascribe TV or the movie screen as power, and so we think that there is just some higher ideal that they
44:57 are tapped into, some spirituals that they're at tapped into, as opposed to what this is, which is such a flawed product and just people with opinions and ideas and products at the time extremely well intentioned. That is also inherently boneheaded. It is boneheaded. That's the way to put it, uh right, Yeah, starting in the quote, and then not only that, but just other behind the scenes details. We've got Nonah in brown face. We've got the Klingons back in brown face, back in brown face. We have the well intentioned these these beautiful natives, which goes who are blonde, by the way, blond and beautiful and versus the dark ones and the badgies who are darker haired and more mean. I do I do like, and I hope that they do this in Strange New World season three. I do like whenever aliens are just big wigs. Oh, I do like that. Now.
46:05 I really like that. It's like real party city wigs right there. This week the costume budget is just wigs. It's just a bunch of wigs. It's like a whole bunch of wigs put on top of each other. It's it's pretty wild. Yeah, And I mean, and that's not even getting at the Nona piece. Okay, So in my brief research, because I read no biographies about gene Rodd and Berry, but I uh looked on Wikipedia and Genie Rod. Genie Rod. That's what I like to call him. Yeah, he loves that. I don't have a specific date, but divorce from his first wife, Eileen, was in nineteen sixty eight, the date that this episode. Yeah, isn't having an affairs, multiple affairs, multiple affairs, And there are stories that I've read and Deez are the boydgeous season two, I believe where Eileen. One of the things that I think Gene Couon and Geen Roddenberry budged on is effect that their wives hated him.
47:13 I think for Gene Couon it was because he was a workaholic, and for Gene Roddenberry it's because it was a duke. He was a philanderer, a philanderer who had lots of affairs and just I I'm sure that his wife knew, but at some point just couldn't take it anymore. Christ Anyways, Yeah, they're just people. They're just people, and so I imagine. Well, also there was the Lady Macbeth of it all, which was a da bath gene coun idea which we see that she is an incipient Lady Macbeth.
48:02 Uh we decided could leave a man confusance, disoriented as well as abmissive, and one of the next drafts, So that was the thing that developed over time. But anyways, I'm sure that there was a lot of divorce literature that was getting on the page just to ascribe some things. And you're talking about Nonah here, talking about Nonah who basically the way that this episode frames it caused Vietnam. Well, so I okay, I was curious because I would. I was like, ah, when I need a brush up on that history as in like, of course, the Klingons are supplying arms to one group, one like indigenous group. Yes, the black Hairs, the black Hairs, the blonde Hairs that Kirk thinks are goodies because he knows them personally. They don't have that level of weaponry, so they're going to be killed. Sley Nonah, who is not part of either of these groups but is married into them. She's married the leader, which is his buddy, presumably through which magic and also because she's hot. But she wants she doesn't want just that level of arms. She wants this higher level of arms because she saw the Phasers and she wants those so that they cannot die. So I guess by what you are saying, can you just explain more of like she's the reason, oh, because like in what happens afterward, which is
49:35 like in her depiction in the episode. Let's think about the depiction of the Klingons, which make no mistake, they're bad eats, they're the uss are in China and also in the episode are clean on quite calmly explains what the Flintlock does yep, as opposed to Nonah, who is duplicitous and is navigating and is conniving and scheming and even though Tyree is married to her at the same time, it's just like it's a living and Kirk was like, uh, it's a living in regards to Nona, and just like, man, this will be better if this woman wasn't here, right, even though Kirk at the end of it is just like Scottie, you beamed down one hundred serpents. So yes, so I think what I see what she was saying is like, this is a way for us to absolve ourselves of being of being this arms suppliers. It's like we're still supplying the arms, but it's because she's the instigator. She's made it worse, even though basically we're building to that point anyway, and Kirk was struggling because he's like, well, they've now been given this artificial benefit, so while we have to do it too, and now it's it just topples over because the fem fatale witchy bitch literally tried to which you like a witch bitch. I fucking love a witch
51:06 bitch. And I gotta tell you I loved this witch bitch, loved her. She was a weirdo. When she healed him from the Magatu poison. It was sex. I was like, what is she doing? I love this? It's great, I mean, and there is too then this is what I meant by like that noble savage thing too, right, because it's like, here is a person who is like of this earth using plants, and uh oh, there's two different things going on here. There is the proxy war Vietnam, two superpowers fighting this proxy war, right, and then there is the representation of the fem fatale, but specifically the witch, the witch archetype and witches are often women who are often very tied into nature.
51:58 They're able to find and medicines and salves through plants, and a lot of the history of witches is that women were traditionally healers. Uh but because they were the ones who were successful, and especially as certain like like different kinds of medicine advanced, we need to make sure we need to find ways to push women down so and to push them out of these spaces, So medicine, spaces, midwiffery, all of these different elements. It was it was midwives who were actually washing hands and delivering healthy babies because they actually had techniques that they had developed that then when they're pushed out and pushed away, there would be infections when women would when people would give birth, right because that same type of understanding was not adopted by say, like the male doctors anyway.
52:53 All of this is like the history of it, right, It's where ale wives come from. I've probably told talked about that before that women used to make beer and that's where they would have cats, and they would usually put up a broom over their ale wifer replate, oh wife's places, to say we make beer here, and the cats would chase away the rats and the mice that they didn't get into the grains. Anyway, all of this is all thank you. So this is why I love a witch bitch, right because traditionally that is what it is. Right, it's women occupying these spaces and then being pushed out pretty traditionally by the church then and men in power. And so when I see a witch, especially one that is literally designed to be like tied to the earth, presenting hypersexually, I see that archetype clearly and perfectly. So I have a problem with then, you know, I mean this, But then this is what happens, right, They are the other, They are the baddie like they are the are the Lady Macbeth who gets us into this problem. So not only is this episode like well, this is a justification for imperialism and proxy war. Also women are the problem. These witches are the problem. So it's doing too annoying things.
54:20 What could be what could be an interrogation of US imperialist interventionalism using participating in what is clearly a proxy war, using folks that are I'm gonna I'm not gonna talk out of my butt because I don't know the INCA Vietnam. All I know. All I know is that was wrong, was a bad time, And all I want to say is that we should have gotten out soon. Sure, we should have been there in the first place. And also I don't know what would have happened if freaking Soviet's just ran uh ram shod all over them? Is that a word sounds ramshodo, a word ramshod.
55:10 What if I meant a word run, rough shod, rampant, rampant and rough shod. Either way shouldn't have been done. Military are bad. And it's easier for me to say that because over here not student of history. What I am a student of is figuring out where the heck the influences are of these episodes at the time, And all I know is that it's these filmmakers just trying to be run a very fine line about saying that Vietnam is bad because they don't say that they are actually like Vietnam necessary evil and then they make escape a woman yep. Yeah. And just again also my very restricted knowledge as well. I mean, I know, at its core, Vietnam as part of these engagements that's saying, trying to trying to prevent the domino effect of communism, like that was the biggest That was why, right, and the fear being that, well, if we don't engage, then now communism is going to spread through the region rampidly, and what can we do? We must do this because we have to stop. And of course communism is just there's a lot inside of it, of course stand in for we won't be the imperialist power anymore, but empower struggle. So I imagine, and we agree horrific. I imagine if you're coming out from that
56:42 perspective of the time and your absolute fear is like, it makes sense you'd have I hate it. It makes sense that the perspective would be well, I mean, we know it's awful, but it isn't necessary evil. Given the implications are the fear, what would be to happen. I'm just I'm surprised I came to I don't know. It's like I said at the top, though, I think in its desire and effort to actually be so simplistic and so pro us, uh, it sacrifices what is interesting about Star Trek, or what Star Trek tries to be, or maybe at its best, what Star Trek is speaking of what Star Trek tries to be. And we'll do this before I get to my thematic connections. Yes, speaking of what Star Trek tries to be. M h A well intentioned, problematic show about backpading liberalism. Yes, Booker Bradshaw. You've heard of this name, correct, Booker Bradshaw. Why yes, Stephen McKinley. Uh. In the feature Stephen McKinley Anderson Book A Bradshaw, Book A Bradshaw. You might be more familiar with him as doctor Mbanga Dr mcbank. Here I was completing when we could have been talking about doctor mcbank Doctor Mbanga, I know it from Strange New Worlds and his introduction here. Yeah. Actually when he popped on, I went wait as second yes, which is why whenever they announced doctor Macbanka
58:16 in Strange New Worlds, I was like, huh, what how is this going to work? And then the episode and then the show turned out to be the best Star Trek period, and so it's like who cares? But here we meet doctor m Banka who interned in the Vulcan Ward and is doing doctoring stuff on the ship, taking care of Spock who's in a coma because he got shot by a footlock. Uh, and allowing Chapel and Spock to get into some shenanigans, even to the Chapel should theoretically be, you know, an intrie medical professional, but no, we introduced a second doctor, and so we meet doctor mcbanka part of Star Trek Lawer. What do we think of doctor mcbanka, love him, love him? Wild that he actually understands vulcan physiology, and yet it's always McCoy being like, I don't understand, I don't understand this. It livers where his heart should be. Although Joel pointed out he's like McCoy clearly does understand volcan physiology. He just complains all the time. Yeah, So, I mean it is not We should point out that it is a big deal to have a black doctor in nineteen sixty eight with authority who knows what he's doing and is an expert and is respected. That's a big deal. Yeah. Book Bradshaw played doctor Mbanga is standing in from McCoy and Sick Bank. I'm reading from These Are the Voyages season two by Mark Cushman. Okay, Bradshaw is only twenty seven, but
59:46 his scholarly demeanor made him a popular choice when a black actor was needed to be a doctor. During the same year, Bradshaw portrayed another doctor on Tarzan. He was in Banka here, Badulla there. Okay. So it's like hang on a second, aspect, hang on a second grab on to something, grab on to something now and now no no doctor mc banka, Bradshaw Booker Bratshaw, our actor here remembered. I was hired by Gene Roddenberry for Star Trek because I was quote unquote the most intelligent black actor in the country. Fuck me here we go, hold on a second, grab onto things. They said, we want to represent blacks as having a brain, so we'll wait, make him a doctor. Well intentioned, but parenthetical, But in parenthetical, I didn't want to play a doctor. I come from a family of doctors, and that year I played one in five TV shows, including Tarzan and The Girl from Uncle. If I had wanted to be a doctor, I would have gone to medical school. Bratshaw again is doctor mcbanka returned to Star Trek for that which survives? Fuck me reinforced it, are reinforced it, Kenny, Yeah, fucking said the exact thing. Well, of course that it would be like or you could have just put black folks like given black folks TV shows to do right and have them be pat them in positions of power. But or you know, the other that reminds me of is how like every therapist is always a black woman. Now, every
1:01:20 single therapist in a TV show or a movie like not everyone, but it's so often, and so you end up getting effectively black people in these positions of authority where they get to be like magical Negroes and stuff, and like they are Morgan Freeman esque and that they are very respectable and this this, like, and you can't help but be a little put off by the implication, which is exactly what is there, which is just like, well, you know, black people, so we need to like show that like some of them, the good ones are they can be smart, like wow, wow wow, whereas like, which is wild to me? Right with the way, because if you on the fucking starship, everyone there is smart, just put more black people on your ship in the first place. Anyway, give a horror more to do, have many people, like have people and done different planets, be black horror. Who knows just off the top of her head that it took Earth twelve centuries to develop the flint lock. Pretty smart? Pretty yeah, he's smart. But also there's only so much.
1:02:28 Again, it's about gestures, right, gestures. Jean roden Berry was in the right place at the right time for a good idea in this In this same chapter, they do an interview with assistant director Charles Washburn, who was the star Trek was the first series to hire a black person to work as an assistant director in Hollywood. Yeah. In this interview In the same chapter, he says, Charles Washburn says, I had interviewed to be an ad at an NBC affiliate because some production friends told me they wanted to hire a black for the control room. But they never called me back. Months later, I wrote to my friend asking who got the job, and he said, Charlie, they didn't hire anyone. They never intended to. They just wanted to be able to tell people that they were looking for a editorial note black person. It's all about gestures, yeah, and you know yeah, And I guess also it is all about gestures, and I guess. The question then becomes, it's a gesture, does it have an incremental effect positive effect? Like and I'm not excusing empty gestures. It sounds like you're excusing it aspen oh by by, But I am curious if there was kind of any lasting cultural like you know effects where it's like, okay, while watching a private little war as being like this episode is for folks like me,
1:04:02 this is not for anyone else. This is for white folks, right, Yeah, I guess I'm just thinking from an industry perspective. I mean, I mean, we go back to I don't know if we've ever even talked about this, but like that famous story of Michelle Nichols wanting to quit Star Trek and Lucille Ball being like, no, you got to stay, like it was very It wasn't me, who was it. It was Martin Luther King. Oh my god. Fuck. I Also, I should have said homie before saying Martin Lua, we're really going for it right now. Maybe I did know that, And I just like, I'm just confusing it with the fact that Lucille Ball, of course it was you know what, I'm confusing it with the intentions of Lucille Ball and DESI to I need to have this wait. I think it's the reasoning for them wanting Star Trek, and I'm sure that if I went back to the use of the just season one, I have a more definitive thing. But I think the reason that they wanted to have a science fiction TV show on at the time one they were doing a favor to Herb Solow, who's the executive that was attached to Star Trek. And two they probably wanted a space show because Kennedy had started the Space Race and they just wanted to be in vogue, and so Star Trek is the right place at the right time. I don't think it was about trying to say a greater thesis like so many things. It's just about we want to make money. So I'm going to remove the white lady from the
1:05:35 situation entirely. She's out. So Martin Luther King saying to Michelle Nichols important important person, extremely important person. If I could say, if I am to describe Martin Luther King, I would say a great man. Oh yeah, can you quote him? My name is Martin Luther King him. Yeah, that's a famous quote. Yeah yeah, I yeah. And he's the one that encouraged He's the one that encouraged her to stay and she did well. I I would like to append this, okay, because there is a story that is told where there was a young girl who was watching Star Trek and she sees a horror yeah, and she runs to her parents and she goes, Mama, there's a black lady on TV. And she ain't no maid. I believe that's a story from Michelle Nichols. That woman, that little girl was Whoopy Goldberg, who then went on to go be a cast member on Star Trek the Next Generation Wow and won an Oscar during that time.
1:06:51 So you're talking about that notion of incremental progress, right, and it literally inspired an Oscar winning actor. So because I think, fuck, I'm not I'm not a person of color. So I need to just say this that, like, I'm not speaking from experience of a person of color, and people have various also, like perspectives and experiences. So I just want to say I'm coming from yeah, just to sort of preface it. But they're like it's now, it's not enough, right, and also it's never enough, and things, these things are they persist to this day, and it is like the types of ways that people of color are treated still within the industry and in general are horrific and still and it's and I think that we need to be careful about being like, well, you know, it's inspires these you know, the good ones are the special people, or these kinds of things. It's more it has to be about that it is inspiring or that it is actually furthering the world for all people of color, uh and everyone. So I'm a little I'm a torn and I think, but I think I have to come down on the side of like, it's something as let me put a button on it. Sure, human beings, human beings cannot be perfect. We will never be perfect. Okay, However,
1:08:30 we can do the best that we can with the information that we have at our fingertips and be well intentioned and then be open to be wrong, right, being open to learning, be open to driving ourselves to learn rather self learning not and just doing the best that you can. Yeah, I do to say that. Yeahs trying. Yeah, even though it was stupid and bone headed. We also have the perspective of history. And then also they're existing within at this time, even though how they would is quite liberal compared to the rest of the country. M h. Still extremely if you have to deal with NBC, who is constantly fighting with being like, let's never say anything radical because we don't want to offend the Southern States. So I believe, as you said in last week's episode of Broken Clock is right twice a day. Yeah, so too, can A so too? Can this challenging figure. M have a vision of a future h and then galvanizes himself into the young great Man narrative. But then this then goes then bolish to purport a narrative of being like, no, we'll get this figured out.
1:09:54 We're humans, and then goes on to make essentially human propaganda and as being like humans are great. What are you talking about? Even though you do then have episodes like quote of Honor and Star Trek the next generation. We'll get there. Yeah, extremely bone headed, but no one can get it right all the time. And I guess if we look at it with the charitable perspective like that, which is to say, fifty something years later, we should be much better, like and we have to be we have to keep being better. And if we come at it with the and I guess I have to follow my own words. If we come at this with any kind of level of shame, shame in and of itself is a tool of and I'll just put this with like white supremacy. If we're like a mired in the shame of the thing of not getting it perfect and not say saying, oh, you know what, I messed up, Like, let's do better, Let's try to strive toward this then we're just going to be stuck in a space where even the incrementalism will save us. So my charitable perspective is that's that was an advancement and we've come a long way and we've still got more to go. I'm speaking of coming a long way. So that ways to go to a theme outic connection. Then I believe that I touched upon briefly in her last Empire strikes Back episode. Yeah, and it's interesting that it comes up again, that it comes up again and with this episode,
1:11:26 is that both of these pieces are about proxy wars. Yeah, it was the last time with the Private Little War obviously, as we've gone at length being about nakedly Vietnam, right the battles in South Vietnam, and then Empire strikes Back. Luke Skywalker is the proxy war. Also, Cloud City is taking a neutral power and taking advantage of it. Yeah, you know, seemingly neutral power, but far more automatically and emotionally, Luke Skywalker is the proxy war absolutely. Yeah. Yeah, the Jedi realizing that Luke Skywalker is the only one because Darth Vader is Anakart Skywalker, and so they have to go whole hog into Luke Skywalker, right, and being like, we have to train this kid because he's the only one that can do this, because we have to appeal to Vader's emotional side. Yeah, except there is another but which from that perspective just tightens my grumpiness about everything I've always I've already said before at length, which is my true frustration with the way that Yoda and Obi Wan treat him. This is where we start seeing the cracks and who the Jedi are, which we all we know my opinion on the Jedi. You love the Jedi famously, Yeah, sure, we do.
1:12:55 They become everyone becomes a whole heart of a lot more complex. Yeah right. The Jedi are speaking of boneheads, real bone headed people. And to quote Ahsokatano, I am an a Jedi, her famous catchphrase, her famous catchphrase, Jedi. Yes. Yeah. I find it to be very sad actually, from that perspective of like Luke that it's one thing to do. They don't see him as a human being, and he can't be a human being. He has to be a symbol, which is horrifying, like horrifying.
1:13:39 Imagine sorry, imagine like you're you're a kid who's thrust into a war and sure you wanted the adventure of it, but this is terrifying. Your friends are dying, things are scary, and you're being told your real human emotions are too much and are going to cost us everything, and you're being told that your friends are worth sacrificing. And then everybody's mad at you because you're acting like a person because you're not, and they don't want you to be a person. They want you to be a symbol. Fuck that. Oh oh, you just shuddered like you were genuinely sick, that you actually have chills, liutally upset. I feel really upset. I'm sick. My illness is hating Jedi, hating the types of values that are espoused by jedis, which is part of the reason they got overthrown, persisting, persisting in their philosophy. Yeah, that's a very very strong thematic connection, and there is that. It's just a horror to watch the people in private little war.
1:14:57 That's just like, well, here they are, and we fucked them for our own game, and like just these they don't get to be people, they get to be concepts. That's cool, that is cool, that is cool. Aspen, Yeah, what Aspen, what do you want asp What do you want from me? Aspen k You need to get out of dowur town, can get into shipping town. Mm hm A long time ago.
1:15:38 Start dating this week. I quoted a boat, I dated a game, but none of them could warp mine drive into hyper space. The best of both worlds can meet in the second place. Captain Slow on a polla kron I wanted a song, I pen a song. Seventeen more minutes advise in Super High dev for the USS Enterprise dt F. Don't you take my walk lighter and clip it? Don't you take my red schord buddy and nip it. If you spill the tea, I'm gonna sip it. My starship it Hello, Hello, it's Tibers. Talk about starships. Explain it to people that are starting with this episode. What the heck eyed starship it is?
1:16:43 Are gonna talk about starships, your favorite starships and and your favorite romantic ships. Here we go. We did it, We did it, We did it. Oh my god, we did it. So we start with our favorite ship ships, our favorite ships that fly through the sky. And I gotta say, Aspen, uh, the ships that are not on the board that you can say yes, you cannot say the executor no favorite, and you cannot say the towntown okay, no tonsan no no startup story. It's so funny last that that last episode. I also picked a giant star destoryer. I just really like big ships. Okay, there's so many to choose from in an empire. Uh. And we've had this combo before and I think this time I'm gonna go with a classic. And it is an at eight at eight Yes, otherwise known as the ad at sure all terrain at eight eight. He's a good little boy. You just want to scratch and behind the ears, yeah, you just want to He looks eighty eighties look like uh little dog turtles. Yep, big white dog turtles. Easily tripped. Yeah. I always am curious about their design of why that might be beneficial as a vehicle, But then I don't care because they're so cool.
1:18:14 And look, if you're asking questions about that, about why they had legs, I think you start asking larger questions about the world. Also, you just have to look at current military development and just be like, why are these things you can look at The answer isn't because a designer wanted it. Yeah, some person wanted it to be this way. That's cyber trucks, Tesla cyber trucks, except atats are much better. Love them. Love that I remember playing. I remember going to an arcade when I was younger, and what I know, I remember those arcades putting quarters in the machines, putting quarters and the machines, And I remember playing a Star Wars game where you're you could pick where you were and I picked Haf and like like flying an X wing and trying to shoot at AT eight's and it was terrified, like because it was one of those like you know, enclosed ones and it's like a really big screen. And I still do this where I just go ah the entire time. I'm like, I don't know. I did not win, I died, but they were scary and you're swooping around them.
1:19:29 It's just really great. It's beautiful stuff. Love an at eight excellent controversial choice. I'm gonna pick the Millennium Falcon. Have we not done the Millennium Falcon? Nope? Okay, yeah sure controversially at Brave for sure. I think the Millennium Falcon is cool. I like it because it's neat. What I like about it is that it flips around a lot, and it's cool. It goes, you mean to boot. I like the Millennium Falcon. It's like a space ship, and I like it because it's it's cool. What I like about the Millennium Falcon in my research is that I found out that it's cool and I like to look at it. What I like about it is that it is neat and if I have to dig into it, what I think is cool about it is that I think it's rad.
1:20:15 Oh man, do you think it's cool? I do like it. I think it's neat. I think it is very cool. What I especially like about it in Empire Strikes Back is that it's broken all the time. Yeah. Yeah, I like that Chef's kiss my guy. It it is good. And I like that R two D two fixes the hyperdrive eventually. Do you know how not to talk about strange computers? It's so funny? Yep? Well, good choice, Okay. Romantic ships ramantic ships a reminder, ships that are romantic don't have to be nice. People ship all kinds of stuff, so it can be a little weird. I'm just throwing that out there. So I'm in a ship. No, no, Kirk. Oh it is Oh do I like that that? No? Maybe we don't like it. Okay, nope, you can ship think oh no, because it's like a that's like a non con it gets the tag of non consensual non con No A Kirk. Yeah, no, a Kirk. But you just went to the mat of being like he doesn't have to That I got, And then I was like, wait a second, do I actually support this?
1:21:43 Yes? Sometimes sometimes because she does scratch him with a leaf. I don't know, maybe she does that with other guy, but she does kind of enchant him a bit. But they do have one of those kisses. And I think about out kisses a lot and movies and TV kissing where fan I'm a big fan, and I think I miss kissing. The miss kissing. I miss the kind of kissing that is like full body like I'm into this kiss kind of kissing. Uh. Someone once said, who's the actor?
1:22:23 That's when you're gonna have to be so much more specific. I can't. I can't supply what your guess is right now. I Oh, my gosh, guy from New Girl, Jack Johnson, Jake Johnson, Morris so Jack Jack Johnson, Jake Johnson, Jake Johnson, Jack Johnson, the singer Jack Johnson, Jake Johnson, Banana Pancakes, Jake Johnson. Someone has said this about him that like he kisses the way like older film stars used to kiss, which is like full, like I am in this like full kind of body kissing. And that's true. And that's I think what I saw here with these two. Uh, it is questionable at best due to the non con of it all, but it was hot. So and I know it's his buddy's wife, but you know what, we love a witch bitch and we love forgetting kisses. So speaking of your buddy's wife, yeah, uh, Kirk's wife Spock in Chapel, Oh have I not done that one?
1:23:30 I haven't done Spock. Well, maybe because I was shipping them before we started this game. I'm knocking out two big ones. I'm claiming two big ones. Again. I would have done them, but I had forgotten that we didn't do it. That are like fuck because they are an OTB one of them. I've got many one true pair the trio and them. We haven't seen too much of Chapel. That's unfortunate. More Chapel, and it's very clear from earlier episodes that Spock and Chapel are very much into each other. Yeah, and we get hints of that as Chapel clings onto mister Spock as he recovers in his Vulcan trans coma yep. And then you know Roddenberry exercising some kinks by Spock demanding Chapel slap him. Yeah, harder it because they have to fight their way back to consciousness. Yeah, it was pretty great. I'm fully I fully approve of that ship. You love that And it seems like I've won I Starship, but maybe I won't win this final round. Trying to answer which is better this week Star Trek or Star Awards, as we finally reveal once for all, which is better again?
1:24:54 The properties in question are the Empire strikes Back Special Edition versus a Private Little War from Star Trek original series. I will start first the Empire strikes Back robust eight. Well, sounds good. I believe I've said this before. Yeah, again, I don't my quibble quibble, and I wish it was a little bit more self contained. Maybe Okay, well that's like a quibble. Sure, well, I family want from me icon Empire strikes Back good movie? What do you want from me it stop yelling at me. Well, I famously gave this a ten the last time we talked about it, So I'm gonna give this a nine point five because it's a special edition.
1:25:49 Yes, which brings Star Wars Episode five. The Empire strikes back Special Edition down to an eight point seventy five, but it could still be anybody game. As we move over to a Private Little War, an episode which both of us famously warm on Private Little War, I'm going to give it a spite ranking a point five. We get some brown face in there, and I think that anything with brown face should be automatically discounted. At that being said, I think from an anthropological standpoint of where Hollywood storytelling was in nineteen sixty eight, a famously chill year in America, in views on the Vietnam War, in popular culture, in things that were not nakedly rebellious. Here it is right here. Even the notoriously left leaning Star Trek is pretty darn centrist right here. And it says that, then, I'm sure is complicated as supposed to. I think what popular history has said, which is we didn't mean to be there in the first place. I think that is fascinating whever, if you are just taking it on face value and taking the metaphors quite clearly, its explicitly stated it's extremely clonky patronizing. That's a good Star Trek episode, if that makes sense. No, Yeah, you can feel you can feel Roddenberry's touch over it. You can feel gene CON's touch on
1:27:24 here. Yeah, even though it is extraordinarily aboute headed Yeah, it's like it's funny if it is, it's like, this is a good this is a good Star Trek episode. I still give it a point five sweat rank. Yeah. And even if all the if all the problematic stuff are fixed, it will be a radically different episode. But it's almost like art doesn't exist in a good bad binary. It's almost or outside of its context. But it also but also I like to use my rankings as kind of a platform of being like, you know, there's I'm sure that there's so much better art out there that could talk about this stuff and far more eloquent terms than being like Klingons my god. So I know I've said this before, but it is wild. Here we go. Nineteen sixty eight, also the years of the assassination of MLK and and rfk MLK, who popularly was often mistaken for did you tuck me? Speaking of centering whiteness asthmen websters centering whiteness, and a famous story man. But yeah, it's a real turmoil filled year, which makes this all the worse. So I'm gonna give it a five, just five, yeah, for everything that you said. I'm spite ranking it as well, but they're not going quite so low just because I'm gonna give it some benefit. Mechanically it feels good. Mm hmm. Yeah,
1:29:00 mechanically in terms of like pacing you start, but you think about it for a second. In terms of the integrity of human beings, you're like, fuck me. I like screamed things and notes well, for what it's worth, it right in all caps, love a witch, bitch. But I did also write in all caps this is an argument for proxy war. Absolutely the fucking worst, get out of here. And also I screamed out loud. No attempted sexual assault, absolutely not. So it was not a good time for me, I can tell you that much. Speaking of furthering proxy wars, So it was this proxy war for star Trek and star wars perpetuated Aspen Aspen. You must be so pleased to learn that Star Wars episode five, the Empire strikes back the special edition. When's the week over a private little war? I'm sorry, I will let I will let this this win lighten my heart a bit. I apologize for becoming so dower and sad thinking about the US imperialism. I apologize for my countenance. Look, if you would like to give penance for your countenance, why not visit us over on Patreon. On patreon dot com slash track Wars Pod. We're at five dollars a month. You can get access to extended episodes and early episodes of
1:30:34 communicate with us. You can join the offices of fine folks such as Timbo Dessa, Emily Brice, Love, Hidie Rogers, Kevin Miller, Mark Bibbert, Ryan Nill, new patron Aaron Sigins, Thank you so much for your patront. Sweet you, we love you. And finally, last weep I certainly not leastly Jolty partner, We love you, honey. We can't wait for the pizza that's on the counter. Additionally, why not leave us a review? Hop on over to track wars pod dot com, click on the reviews tap and find the podcaster of your choice. Leave us prefectly. They are a four star. I fin a star review because we would like people to know that we are indeed charismatic and smart. And also you can find us on social media Instagram, Blue Sky. Uh, I guess we're on Twitter. Twitter won't die, but I don't want to engage with it because they're evil, nefarious actors and I wish that humans would just be better.
1:31:28 But luckily I am with the good human right now, with Asmen Webster. Asen, thank you for being the kind, empathetic soul that you are, and you know good on ye Oh, thanks man, I don't know. We're just trying our best. We are indeed trying our best. You're a good guy. You're a good guy, Aspen. I love you. I love you too, Listeners, we love you. What do you think real quick? No? I think I think we can do it. I think we could. I think we're got this. We got this. We're good all right. May the Force be with you A live long prosper
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Spreaker
RSS Feed