Interview with Barry J. Kelly (Supervising Director, Star Trek: Lower Decks)
We talked with a big wig (thanks to https://www.youtube.com/@AnimationFascination !)
We sat sit down with the show's Supervising Director and Producer Barry J. Kelly to dive deep into the creative process of bringing this fan-favorite series to life....
We talked with a big wig (thanks to Animation Fascination !)
We sat sit down with the show's Supervising Director and Producer Barry J. Kelly to dive deep into the creative process of bringing this fan-favorite series to life.
In this episode, you'll get insider insights into:
✨ Balancing the writing to cater to both die-hard Trekkies and newcomers.
✨ The age-old debate: Star Wars vs. Star Trek – which reigns supreme?
✨ What would the adorably menacing Moopsy look like in live-action?
✨ Barry's heartfelt gratitude to the incredible crew behind the series.
✨ The painstaking animation months-long production process!
Star Trek: Lower Decks is set in the year 2380 and follows the support crew of the U.S.S. Cerritos, one of Starfleet's least important ships. The fourth season finds our beloved ensigns facing new challenges and opportunities, all while coming to terms with their "lower deck" status for the foreseeable future.
Don't miss out on this engaging and insightful discussion that takes you behind the scenes of one of the most beloved animated series in the Star Trek universe!
_________________
Follow Barry for more! https://www.instagram.com/barryjkelly/
Get early, extended episodes on our Patreon at https://www.patreon.com/trekwarspod
Watch us!
https://www.youtube.com/@trekwarspod
Theme by Tosin Awofeso
Social Media:
https://www.instagram.com/trekwarspod
https://bsky.app/profile/trekwarspod.bsky.social
Want to ask us questions? Email us at trekwarspod@gmail.com .
And leave us a review! https://bit.ly/leave-a-review-trek-wars
0:27 We're super pleased to be doing this interview on behalf of Animation Fascination, and we're talking to Barry Kelly's supervising director, a star Trek Lower decks what even I think, even the crankiest of old school Treki's because I pay attention to the forums way too much, seem to absolutely adore. But you know, my relationship with fandom might be a little bit more different than yours, mister. I am very bad on social media. I've forms. I don't know why. I never figured out how to use forms or how to figure out who's responding to who. But it's good to hear that the feedback is mostly positive. I love that. It's always nice to hear like it's hard with streaming, right, it's not like the same as like old TV ratings, So I'm always like, who watched the show that doesn't know me? Or is buying a subscription that's like my you know, like it's like my aunt or something just doing me a favor. So it's always like a good relief to hear people love the show because we love it. I love it too, like it I read the scripts, you know, you know, I'm like the first viewer and it's like I fall in love with this episode, or like I see it perfect in my head, and then I'm like given this test where like I have to make it after I read it. I just I just watched it in my head, and now I have to make the show. So it's I hope people are loving it as much as I love it, because I'm trying to recreate that like first time I'm reading the script. I'm trying to make that enjoyment again for everybody else. Yeah.
1:51 I was a CBS All Access first a subscriber, and whenever I heard that Lower Decks was going to be much like the rest of Trek fandom, I was just like, sure are going to work, am I. I was so surprised at how well it worked. And then Aspen, your relationship with Star Trek is way different than mine, and you freaking up Lower Decks too. I'm more of a Star Trek fan now than I was. But when I I at that point, I hadn't watched a ton of it, but I did watch Lower Decks and at the time did not get all the great little Easter eggs, but was still delighted beyond reason. Constantly I adore that out people. I know that. Yeah, I don't even watch Star Trek love lower. Yes, that's so. Let's good hear though, because I yeah, yeah, I want it. I mean I know Mike wants it to work. My command, the creator, showrunner wants it to work too, for everybody, Like even on our crew. I'm like, I don't it's anytime I asked, like a new crew member, I'm like, you know, Star Trek, it's not a it's never a like you need to start. It's like it's more like how do I talk to you? Do I say ryme Milin Werberd or do I say bad guy shit? And it's so and but they're the side influence of people like I, you know, I'll be two in my head of like what's you know what something is in Star Trek or what's what was it? What was happening in a specific episode.
3:08 I'm like, well it has to be that way. And then like it's always those people outside that are like that does it doesn't need it? I'm like, you know, I never even thought about that. That's why I need these open perspectives because I'm in a bottle or I'm gonna I'm in a cave all day, you know, like a little star trek, you know, reuse set of a cave and in my little animation land here and I'm like, I love that that the East Riggs don't need to hit every time. As long as the characters are coming through and the humor's coming through and it's playing, that's perfect. I love here. I think that is the key point of it is that it's deeply I feel deeply character and relationship based. So good. I agree so much as beIN thank you so much getting You're so welcome, right, it is, it truly is. Which.
3:54 Yeah, so if you're not gonna get the you're not gonna get the joke of the thing, the deep cut. That's going to be wonderful for people like Kenny or huge truck fans, but it's going to still resonate with just people who love good stories. Yeah. There's always like a note whenever we're watching an episode or like an animatic, you know, we're I'm watching every hour, I'm like really watching a different phase of something, and I'm always like, this is a second viewing kind of joke, Like like you know, like you watch something the first time and then like the second, Like, I'm like, you'll get this the second time you watch it, because it'll it'll I'm hoping that like you like the show enough that, like you know, you either watch it again soon or maybe later on the I'm just gonna watch, you know, another another round of the season. It's on in the background, like you catch something you never caught before, or now you know the easter eggs that that come through that second But the second viewing is always in my head of like that's for second view, you know, not first. I'm excited for my second pass, my second view pass, I will I'm excited for your second past to you ask then, yeah, so I got some questions which you're probably not surprised by. Let's do it what you got, Okay, we'll get you started. So lower decks strikes. It's brilliant balance of simple character animation and we talked about this a bit, but simple character animation and extremely complex worlds starting from the pilot.
5:14 So this can make for an extreme hodge podge of an episode, but it still feels cohesive. So are you all just geniuses or is there method to the madness? Oh my gosh, I I would say I am trying very hard to problem solve and navigate every problem we encounter on the show, which is like I keem saying I'm not a genius, but I'm hoping that we all come off like them at the end, which was perfect. Well, that sounds good to me. Anybody making me. I have very talented people who make me look better, and then hopefully I'm making some other people look better and we all come off great, you know, like like geniuses.
5:54 But yeah, that first episode that was I was I took over season too, uh and that first episode for Piles get like especially this one, like we didn't have the ship designed, you know, by the time we were storyboarding. Like storyboarding is kind of like shooting in a way, Like if I compare it to live action, it's like, how are we shooting without the ship? So it's kind of like, you know, in storyboards, it's like, okay, if you if you need like a light switch, Okay, I just gotta make sure the character hits a light switch somewhere. But if you look at the boards, they might be like empty boxes or something. You know, they just I just need to know that I got to put something there, and then I know the background ers are going to paint it beautifully and they're going to make you know, a world around all these characters, and sometimes you just got to kind of like give the landmarks of where things are. But we didn't always The ship is that's in itself is like, you know, a character to the show, but it's a character that's in every episode and they're inside of it, so it takes it took a while to figure out the ship. I'd say, we didn't figure out the ship until, like, you know, we were halfway through boards in the season, because it's it's it's it's a it's a very you know what color is the carpet? You know what color is that space carpet?
7:00 But yeah, that first episode, you know, we were trying to get a lot across a lot of pilots, you know, are sometimes like the harder episode to watch of a show, yea, And I'm hoping that like the first you know, I remember reading the first few pages the cold open with Boimler and Marhyer and she's, you know, just like this ball of energy that's running around him and circling him around, and you know, he's she's swinging a batlet and stuff like that, and it's and it's a little like it can be overwhelming, but it also what I was always impressed by Mike's writing with is like I understood those characters like ree lines in like it was like the first page thirties I want it, and it told me that like thirty seconds into the show, anybody watching will know who these characters are.
7:42 And that was always like, you know that that's very hard to execute on a show, and Mike McMann is a freaking brilliant genius at doing that, like just nailing getting right to the point of who the personality is of someone and how you can easily like put them in any situation and you'll see the like you know, the the reaction and counter you know, like the all all just all the hygiens that they get to like right off the bat. But yeah, as as far as like complex worlds and simple animation, yeah, it's weird, like you we want it to feel you know, like the stakes and like the characters are just as real as you know, any live action show or any other you know, character or anything like that.
8:26 So like it's always weird to like think that we're simplifying things to big eyes and small mouths and stuff like that. But there is like there's a weird you know, they call it the Uncanny Valley. I think it still applies here where you know, you have like style and realism and like you're just kind of trying to find that like space between where it feels that you can believe that this thing is real and it maybe feels more real than something that's like over here on the realistic side but just not real enough or like you the drawing. You know, once the drawings get too realistic, you kind of it can kill the comedy or it can kill you know, a little bit of the believability of what is actually happening around them and finding that right balance. You know, we want to look like a sitcom. We want we want anybody to like look at it and who's into sitcoms and want to watch it and just look at like an appealing cartoon. But then you know, you watch, as you watched that season, we're slowly bringing you into like epic sci fi adventure you know, before you know it, and hopefully we're seeking you know, your you know, sitcom animation tunes into like a world where there's a camera and there's a cinematic, you know, scope to everything. That's how I'm trying to present it like that. It's more of like a sitcom shot with the camera. That's that's kind of in leaqual with my second question because you're talking about the uncanny value, you're talking about trying to make it a sitcom, and yet at the same time each image is extremely dense. Uh as an insane Star Trek fan, right, that's me. Uh I, I pumped my fist every single time that there's some obscure easter egg in the background. Uh just comes to my mind is to
10:01 and his eyes open, which is like such a deep cut Star Trek thing. How do you manage to corral everyone to jam the frame with so many things that are deep cut Star Trek while also keeping it completely accessible to uh just normies as we'd like to call them. And then also how often do you consult memory alpha? Well, there's always there was a there was a ground rule from beginning that's like you have to consult alpha. Beta is I don't know if it's really or not right, Yeah, the beta memory bit. You gotta memory memory alpha is a regular go to, like we have to we have like there's sometimes there's no other It's also like if you google anything, it's like the first thing that pops up, and then you just got to make sure that like, oh yeah, we click Helfa, not Beta at that time. Yeah, although I guess y'all pulled Titan from Beta canon and made it into Alpha Cannon, which is wild. That makes sense.
11:01 Yeah, that's they're very good. Are they arbiters? What do you call them, like the contributors or administrator? I think all three of those words apply perfectly to it. They're very very thorough. Yeah, they're very thorough. I learned brothers much more interactive with like just the fans on Twitter. I don't have an x account or anything, or I think I do. I forget, Yeah, yeah, I forget, So I don't really interact. I got on Instagram. I'm like, I'm slowly going to Kara, which is that new artist driven one. But I'm kind of in both so it's very hard for me to keep up. But it's back to your question, apologies, how do we keep those Easter eggs? I mean there's sometimes they're written in the script, like you're talking about that menagerie or not the menagerie, the the art gallery that the collector had, and there's tons of little spots to do. Like it kind of happens in every phase.
11:58 So like the script lists a few, then once we go into storyboards, the sorbers start peppering, and then once we get to backgrounds, like that's really that's the artist that's actually gonna make them make the paint for Like there's like they'll go to painters, bred artists that are involved at that stage that kind of all make the final color of that background come together. But at that stage, it's like when we're like, oh, crap, this is what's going to be real now, Like this is what's going to be actually on the shot, you know, like boards, you know, we could copy paste stuff script they can throw out anything, but pretty much once we get to that background phase, it's kind of like me and Brad and our art director Nolan Obena trying to nail down because it was we have like you know, menageries of animals we have we always have these like you know, or you have the the first contact what's the name of the the mountain that they have first contact that that we made a theme park. Oh my gosh, what is it? It goes it's Bozeman. That's something. Thank you, thank you so much. Yeah, like like what can we make a ride out of the you know, like like things like that, Like we're always uh, it's usually like every phase is like grip storyboards whatever, like someone is usually peppering something and then like oh we can keep that, that's good to stay. We got to change that one out. We let's pick something that isn't and then we you know, we have to do deep deep dives on like Alpha or brad Winterers or producer has John Van sitters on the horn and he's always like where would so and so be around this time?
13:30 Or where would this be around this time? We have to just make sure that that stuff's okay to put it in and it's not breaking anything major that's going to break anyone's brains or anything like that. And if it's something that's like a dupe, I'm like, well, it's just people make replicas, right, it's a dupe. They don't know, you know, they this this ur this is this collector got got duped. You didn't know you even know it wasn't the real sort of KALs or something like that. But yeah, it's it's every phase, everyone, every little bit, every little phase just peppers in a little bit and we just have to like edit it down as we get to the final picture. Essentially, what's an Easter egg and what's not? I follow this real quick. How do we feel about Moopsie? Just like emotionally deep in our souls, We've loved Moopsie since the start.
14:13 I'm so glad that that voice carried through because that voice is was our editor's son, one of our like dialogue editors, and he did it as temp and then no one wanted to change it by the time we got in and he got into SAG so that we could you know, use his voice and everything. I hope that we can use him again and some others. But he's the cutest thing. I hope we make you know sound by you know, toys or something of Moopsie. There is a Mopsie coming out. I'm hoping that they'll maybe be a very like a two point or wordever that has like the squeeze it and it says the name or something like that, or maybe thangs pop out. But I love it. I want to make like a photo real one have I have one, like a fan made one, but I wish. Part of me is like, oh, I want to make one that's like, you know, weird, like like real and like latex and like maybe it's I mean, I keep in my head, you know, I was talking about live action versus animation, and I'm like, I wonder what I do wonder what moves you would look like live action creepy, like look cute from a far and you get up close and it's like you can see the veins and the texture and everything in it. It's one of those like yeah, like don't go too close because then it'll it'll just like a white texture. It's actually teeth. It's just the whole thing is just molars. That's what. Yeah, it's a texture and it's just like weird. It's like calcle, I don't like, mister Kelly. I understand that you're giving a whole bunch of interviews because you are successful, handsome, and most importantly, very very important. All of those interviews could probably
15:45 miss all a lot of nuance. What or what what things are you hoping to get across that might not necessarily have gotten across in other other interviews. Hmmm. I mean, I'm always like I think I've always like thinking about the crew who who doesn't always get you know, I feel I feel privileged that I get to be interviewed by folks like you and by you know, uh brought in you know, and some of the commentaries and stuff like that. And I'm always like, I'm always thinking about like thars because what's what's weird is uh animation is a gig based It's still like it's kind of like like action, it's a gig based you know job. So like a lot of a lot of there's only very few of us who are on the show from beginning to end. It's like me the art director, our producer Megan, Megan Travino, and Brad Winners and a few others like our editors and stuff like that. So like a lot of times are our crew are some of them are are are in the like kind of like Mike McMahon show Family, where like they go off and make solo opposits for six months and then they come back star Trek lowerd ext Like I use a lot of like storyboard artists and character designers from that show. So it's there's there's crew that they get they they they're on the show and doing a ton of core work and then they never get to see the final product until it actually airs. So I'm always like thinking about I wish I could always shine a spotlight on them.
17:12 And there's like some amazing leads and like Marissa Livingstone's a character designer supervisor that that she's been on the show since the beginning. She's amazing. We have these like amazing uh animation directors up in Vancouver that I am I'm always hoping like I can get, you know, more credit and more because they they're they're saving my butt a lot of the times too, just like in some of the most amazing character amiss that they can do quickly and very efficiently. And I always want people to know like that there is a crew behind the show that really genuinely loves the show and uh that loves it just as much as the audience does. Like it's a rare thing. I think I've worked on a lot of shows. I'm uster shows barely lasting a season, sometimes they get cut, you know, Having five seasons of this show is really incredible. It's it's it's it's it's pretty rare these days. And what's also rare is you know in animation, at least the way we do meetings at Titmouse, that's the studio that I work for that makes Lower Decks.
18:14 We have daily meetings when we you know, we sit and go over everyone's footage, you know, if you have something to if you have something, if you have a shot downe Like, everything's broken down in the shots, right, it's like four un shots the show. And every day we're looking at show, you know, different shots from different shows. And you know, there's plenty of shows that I've worked on before. We're like, it's a job. It's just a job to people. You know, we're looking it's sposed. You know, we're watching funny cartoons. No one's laughing, and lower decks everyone's laughing at the show. Part of my French everybody is laughing on the show. That's that's actually a rare thing. I'm not used to that where you know, the dialogue is killing everybody in the room. Everyone's animation is killing everybody in the room. You know, it's like a it's like almost like an old The few times I really see that as like footage of like the Disney animators laughing at what they're doing because they didn't know each and make this kind of work possible, you know, and they're laughing about what they've been able to do. And I just something I always want to know is one of people who knows that the crew loves working on the show. They they put a lot of heart, a lot of love, you know, in the end, every back and so if it's appreciated, we can only be grateful for that. I'm glad that you brought up the crew aspect because something that I sell Mark and Aspen are so keen on talking about on all of our various podcasts is that this stuff is so hard to do. Uh. As someone that worked on the ABC TV show Secret Millionaire, Uh, the show, this stuff is super duper hard. How long
19:45 does it take for you as as a supervising director, from like beginning to end? How long does an episode take? I think episode takes eighteen months, so from script from scrip to finish, the writing phase is about three months, but then one we I feel like the past five years have been like starting boards in June ish May, June writing has already started like a few months before that, like March February, and usually like June, I'll be finishing you know, I started boards on season five around this time last year, and we'll be finishing up season four or season five, I'm sorry, like around September October something like that. Like like that's that's like the length of when like like the last episode, like we'll be done by then.
20:33 Like we're working on you know, all ten episodes kind of at the same time until like you know, one finishes, Okay, then we got nine left, and then we got eight left, and then we got seven left. But like right now we are right in the thick of everything. Like it's like I'm looking at stuff from episodes one through six at the moment, like every and all of them are in different phases. I'm looking at you know, sound stuff from one, animation from three, and compositing, which is you know that's where like you know together like backgrounds or merged with the animation. I'm looking at you know, for that for like episode four. Like every hour it's like kind of like a different every hour of my day is like a little bit of a different meeting where I'm looking at different aspects of different episodes at the same time. It's kind of yeah, there's a lot of overlap that's the thing. Like I say, it's eighteen months, but it's like once you are you know, you start an episode every few weeks, so you're working. You know, at a certain point, it's kind of like a you know, like a waterfall effect where it kind of like or I guess amountain like you know, you're kind of stacking them up and they kind of they're kind of delayed, and then slowly by the end you're kind of like tapering down, you know, And yeah, it just takes It just takes a long time. It's time and people, and it's like I want to make sure that the crew is happy and that they want to work on the show, and like it's a little hard to balance when you know, sometimes it's you got to push them and it's not you know, if something's not right, it doesn't mean it's not good enough.
21:51 It just means like it's not you know, we got to find the right you know, the right design for that one moop seed. You got to find you know, the right sound effect for that one phaser. You know, like it's it's it's sometimes it's uh, it's I don't want to push them. I don't want to, but I'm trying to like still get them to you know, you know, make a better version of what they want to see in the show. Yeah, answer your question. I kind of want to. Uh yeah, most definitely. The question was how long does it take? Oh you went, well all those things, uh, and then it takes what I got for eighteen months and it consumes it in like thirty minutes. That's what. Yeah, what I got from that is so like a great boss. Oh I hope. So that's that's on them, that's on them to speak. That's so we'll look after this. Yeah seriously, ye yeah, yeah, it's uh but you know it's funny you say that, like and then we consume it in thirty minutes. It's like, yeah, I remember like like we make big mouth here. Also that the mouse, and like I remember just like watching because it was kind of new, right, like there wasn't so many cartoons on Netflix, so that was like one of the first ones. And I was like I told because I wasn't used to the binging things were like just all of them are up right, all of them are up And I'm like, dude, I just watched two years of work in two hours. I'm sorry, Anthony that's Anthony Leoy's like the EP over there, and I'm like, I'm sorry, man, I just burned through that. It was great, but all that work was just boiled down to like, you know, three hundred and sixty minutes or something. Yeah, one more. Okay, this feels So it's a very important question. Question. We're going to ask a selfish question. So not
23:26 only have you obviously directed to Star Trek, but you've also Galaxy of Adventures. So the real I would like to say, the biggest question here is which is better Star Trek or Star Wars. Oh my gosh, you guys are gonna be my Star Trek. I have to say Star Trek right now? Crazy? What are you doing a month paramount? I get it. I gotta I gotta say, we gotta say the right thing. That's that's too tough. That's like it's so hard. It's like it's funny that like I I, you know, I went from working which that was an amazing project, to like to work on the I feel very privileged. I've touched both because I grew up with both and not likely do they have the same name or they start with star. You know, that's a that's a constant thing. But I you know, Star Wars is what forty years something now old, and I'm like, how about I double down and go for something that's fifty years old with fifty years of fans that are angry at me, you know, like for the end the other Star franchise. But no, yeah, it was it just kind of it kind of worked out that way.
24:25 The you know, I always feel like Star Trek Star Wars, Star I always feel like I compared the two like this, Like Star Wars really captures the kid in me, Like it captures like the wish fulfillment of wanting to be a hero and wanting to you know, to save the day and then really have an adventure. And then Star Trek you know, really appeals to the adult in me of having to admit that the world is harder and more complex than simple heroic adventures. You know that our escape is like Star Trek, you know, that has to make me. It's it's weird, it's it's a Star Trek is utopian, but it has it almost teaches me to accept reality and like Star Wars for me, like to escape reality in a weird way, like even though they're both sci fi for future reaching myth you know, mythos or universes that get to deal with. But it's my artistic journey has been so influenced by both Big Time Girl Up Only. The biggest takeaway from that is that on your next project you would be looking for a science fiction property with a longer running I'm excited to see the Doctor Who Animated show that you will be directing. I'll have to catch up. I will that will? Yeah, that will. That is a tough one.
25:34 Why why haven't they done that yet? They should? Why not they have? It's complicated? Oh really, Okay, I'm I'm clueless now, I'm I'm in new territory. I didn't know there was an animated one. You're you're busy, and quite rightly so I'm not, and I have no idea what you're talking. Well as well, we'll talk about this. We'll talk about this later. Talk about another cast that I will that I can tune in and I can watch and I can get caught up on the history of animated Doctor. Absolutely, thank you so much for being so generous with your time in indulging us. Hey, thank you for having me good questions. Really appreciate the chat. Good personalities. Thank you so much. Did you hear that we've got good personalities? Friendly, you're a great boss. Oh, we'll find out
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Spreaker
RSS Feed