Aug. 16, 2024

Plato's Stepchildren vs. Lair of Grievous

Plato's Stepchildren vs. Lair of Grievous
Plato's Stepchildren vs. Lair of Grievous
Trek Wars Podcast
Plato's Stepchildren vs. Lair of Grievous

Dr. Tiffany L. Knoell, author of From Monk to Superhero: Genndy Tartakovsky’s Clone Wars and the Transformation of the Jedi, comes to talk to US! COME ON!

We talk about the definining relationships between Jedi as mediative monks versus badass power...

Dr. Tiffany L. Knoell, author of From Monk to Superhero: Genndy Tartakovsky’s Clone Wars and the Transformation of the Jedi, comes to talk to US! COME ON!

We talk about the definining relationships between Jedi as mediative monks versus badass power fantasy. We talk about Parmen's fascist dictatorship within the context of 2024. We talk about Plato's Stepchildren's famous KISS. And animation is a medium, not a genre.

__________________________________

Get early, extended episodes on our Patreon at https://www.patreon.com/trekwarspod

Watch us!
https://www.youtube.com/@trekwarspod

Theme by Tosin Awofeso

Social Media:
https://www.instagram.com/trekwarspod
https://bsky.app/profile/trekwarspod.bsky.social

Want to ask us questions? Email us at trekwarspod@gmail.com .

And leave us a review! https://bit.ly/leave-a-review-trek-wars

0:30 Welcome to the Trek Wars Podcast, the Internet's exclusive source for trying to answer the one question, the most important question in fandom, which is better Star Trek or Star Wars by going through both franchises in chronological release order. I am Kenny Madison of the Star Trek contingent and with me as per always as the co host with the mo host. It's me asked in Webster, you're Star Wars best friend. But perhaps best friends might be at each other's throats today, but not necessarily under their own control, as we cover no step children, a perfectly normal and chill episode. So I start Trek the original series season three versus Layer of Grievous from Star Wars to Clone Wars season one.

1:17 Or as I like to put it, when I just was telling my partner about it, a totally creepy why oh sorry, sorry, are you looking at. Me like that? Are you looking at me like that? Guinny, why are you doing the dog thing? Oh? It's because it's Joel, my partner, my sweet boy partner. Today, I said, Layer of Grievous a super super creepy episode which I loved and played a step children, a super creepy episode that I was not feeling great about emotionally and physically. But something that we are feeling pretty dark right about. We have a fabulous special guest on our episode, the associate teaching professor from the Department of Popular Culture at Bowling Green State University and published author in the trance media of a Star Wars Universe. Please welcome doctor Tiffany L.

2:09 Noel to the podcast. You still have on mute? I can't. I can't unmute you. I can't. You gotta collect the on mute button. Doctor nolt you on mute? Wow, I can't believe still on mute. Listen, listen. This is Kenny. This is Kenny silencing women. So don't worry about him. Now. If you've got to mute somebody, Kenny, you really should tell them in advance. I'm going to mute you now. You're You're not wrong, You're not wrong in doctor. Oh my god, this is the coolest. Thank you so much for having me on. I am super poleased as punch, especially considering that first came upon your work because you are one of the few published authors that are bothered to talk about Gandy Tartakowski's Clone Wars in a meaningful manner. There's a whole bunch of people out there that are just like, did you know that there's actually the secret two D clone Wars TV shows that's actually like pretty good, And you're one of the few authors that is actually engaging with the tax and trying to drive some greater meaning of it, what it represents for the Star Wars franchise and what it represents for I don't know where Star Wars was contextually within the landscape of two thousand and three two thousand and four TV aimed for kids.

3:28 Yeah, now, before you get too excited about my contributions, I would really like to give mention to the editors of that particular collection, doctor Derek Sweet and oh god, we changed other editors in the middle of it all, and of course my book is in the other room. I believe his name is Dominic Nardi. We had a different editor, so I had to just say, okay. Can say it is right here. I've got it pulled up right here. Oh I passed. Look at that passed. Also, what a gracious thing to do, like as as part of the whole comprehensive effort toward the thing.

4:11 Well, Derek and I have known each other since the mid nineteen nineties, when we met in of all things, a Star Trek chat based role playing game on MSN YEP which then we had an offshoot that was also Star Wars related, And since Derek is much more Star Wars than Star Trek, well, they've known each other for a very long time. And I can honestly say that man is my obi wan. He got me through not only the entirety of graduate school, but like I said, we've been friends for almost thirty years now, and.

4:52 So it's to your responsibility that you're like, in order to preserve this friendship, I. Must have made you. Actually, it's not that at all. I believe in giving credit where it is due. Oh yes, this is good. This is good. That's better because I never give Kenny any credit. Its rightfully, So no, it's not true. I haven't learned it. No, he's wonderfully. He's wonderful. That is fabulous. So okay, wait before because this is glorious because Kenny's intro of you, uh, the fact that the way he said it is like, oh, this is one of the people who You're one of the people who's actually talking about Tartakovsky in a specific way.

5:34 But the very fact that you are getting to write papers and do any kind of research at all around star Wars or any of these things that we would be like, Ah, this is a nerdy joy of mine, I think is extraordinary. Like, well, then I'm going to blow your mind one more time. I am one of the few published academics who's done any work with animaniacs. Oh my god, we love to see it. Thank you for your service. We really appreciate it. And I'm currently under contract with Bloomberry Books or Bloomberry Publishing for a book called History and Temporal Tourism, plotting individual paths for the past. So yes, I write about time travel my favorite thing.

6:17 That's your favorite thing? Time travel is my favorite thing. Are you married? He's on my maor you're kidding me? Co' maried a time travel like ghosts time travel partner. Well, as it turns out, I've taught history in the coliseum, I've had lunch at Stonehenge, and I was photographed outside a rather recognizable large blue telephone box outside of a tube station in London a few years ago. So weird. So will oh just a police box, just a regular police box.

6:59 It was just standing out there with my trench coat. No big, we'd love to see it. Oh this is so, this is great, you are okay, this is a joy. Look at what we've done, what we've done, what we did. So that means I think, you know, typically we'll ask people who come on as Gas will be like, hey, you know, how did you first become going to with Star Wars with Star Trek. What's your experience? But I do actually think we need to start with the more important question, which is which is better Star Wars with Star Trek. I think because art is a binary and you have to pick one. Or the other, I reject your question and instead stick with the fact that I tend to be multi denominational, a fantheist, if we're going to put it in that term when it comes to the media, the media galaxy.

7:55 Oh yeah, Kenny, do you. Hear that. Is a very Star Trek answer. And I appreciate that doctor Nole is saying Star Trek in roundabout way, so thank you for that. Okay, it sounds like perhaps it's far Wait wait, wait, this is a Star Trek. It's a little, it's little, very it's Star Trek. There is Star Wars. It's a Delta. It's a Delta. Wait, do you have a Star Wars tattoo too? Do you have a Star Wars tattoo too? I do not, but I have a lightsaber on my wall that I received as a graduation gift from my gaming brothers. Okay, doctor Nols, me likes me better, so I like, this is about who you like better? Well, let me also just point out I am an emeritus member of the five hundred and first Legion. I had my Imperial Officer number and got out of that hobby when I started graduate school.

8:37 Sure were great time. We're having a great time. Yeah, So I would say Star Trek for something, Star Wars for other things. But I'm gonna be that right in the middle. I like them both. My secret responses love it us too. My official response is, oh god, how dare you? That's me out here? So in discord making things uncomfy, let's go, oh gosh, Okay, what did we start? What's your relationship with both properties? You grow up with it, come to it later in life, because I literally grew up with both of them to the point where I literally don't remember a first time watching it. That's where my start point is.

9:26 Where it makes sense for me. I grew up with science fiction just pretty much from the jump what my my father. My father was the person who introduced me to the gateway drug of night nineteen seventies. And no, it wasn't Star Wars, okay, it was Buck Rogers, that's okay with in the eighties. Was more of a heroin time, okay. No, I grew up on Buck Rogers and the original Battlestar Galactica. I watched The Empire Strikes Back in the Theater very good. I actually just got done doing a watch through with that with my son, my oldest. Now, I saw Empire Strikes Back in the theater just before my youngest sister was born, so I was there for that. And then when it comes to Star Trek, I really didn't discover Star Trek until the late nineteen eighties. So next gen ex Yes, I was a next gen kid. But in addition to all of that, I've done my fair amount of line sitting. In fact, if you do any research into author Brian Young, it's b R yam Young. Brian and I were in line to see Phantom Menace and we started and we started a presence there camp out

11:01 a month before. Oh my gosh, oh jeez, Louise. After that, when it came to attack of the Clones, we set up tents. We were there for about two weeks off and on. Now, please don't think I didn't just I was not just staying there the whole time. We swapped people out because that's the sensible thing to do here, very clever. But oh gosh, oh. Wow, yeah, I've I was at sea. I was at the original Star Wars celebration as oh that at that point, I was covering it for the newspaper that I was writing for at the time.

11:41 And yeah, yes, because you said, you this is your third career, you started, we're dark. I started at age sixteen as a freelance journalist. I literally walked into a field office of a mid sized daily news paper, gave them my sophomore era clips, and they said, hired, here's your camera, here's the word rate, here's your assignment. Go oh my gosh, Peter Parker. So there was that, And then in between starting as a journalist and getting out of the field and then starting college, I developed the skill set for working in graphic design and web development, and I did that as a business from nineteen ninety seven until twenty twelve.

12:36 Oh my god, nice, very cool. And in the meantime with all of that, I had three children. All of my kids are grown and gone, but yeah, they they they definitely had a hand in everything. So yeah, oh, and you said, you just got finished watching Battlestar Galactica with one of your with one of your kids, your son, and then when you have the eldest and then you have a live stream with your daughter, the eldest daughter, eldest daughter, and then your other any cool things you've done with your other child who's not a child. We also ended up adopting another one, so she falls in between the first two and the ys. Nice, Yes, I do have four children, but no, it's it's wonderful because I'm married a nerd.

13:26 Yes. In fact, he has his Imperial guardrobes and that wonderful, wonderful helmet. So yes, he was also trooping for the five of First and the Alpine Garrison, which was our local when we lived back in Utah. And yeah, that's our entire house is like this. Every member of our family, from the husband and the children to the house biking to everybody. Well, this is great, this is a gold mine before before we get into lay Grieves Versus place, make no mistake. We will you sure, we could just keep doing it interview. We will. Well, what I'm interested about is for folks set up not read the book the transmedia franchise of Star Wars TV, which I found quite easily on unfortunately Amazon.

14:17 So sorry, but okay, so that's cool. You don't. Sorry. I'll send it to you. I'll send you some money. I'll bet money. Right now, can you talk. A little bit about your about your piece that you contributed, which is titled from Monk to Superhero Gendy Tartakovski's Clone Wars and the Transformation of the Jedi. It's it's great, it's great. Well, this research paper started out in the same way that a lot of research papers start when you're in grad school. That's something that I was writing for a class, which I then took to a conference and the Popular Culture Association National Annual Conference. Yeah, there is such a thing.

15:02 It's fantastic. Oh my gosh, I was like not in these cool spaces when I was in grad school. Yeah, you're a fellow grad school survivor social work. Oh oh yeah, I was like, let me write some miracle, let me write some papers on abortion access. It'd be sad. No quite Frankly, That's how a lot of things start. So when it comes to this, I, in case you've not picked up on this, I also really love animation. In fact, my bachelor's thesis and my master's thesis were looking at Warner Brothers animation from the nineteen thirties as historical documents. So when you've got a love of animation and you've got a class where you're taken a superhero class and you don't want to write about Superman or a wonder Woman or Wolverine or any of that, Yeah, something that worked for me, and that was looking at the way in which Jendi Tarakowski chose to change the nature of the Jedi, reflecting a lot of what we've been seeing in the earlier prequel films in Phantom Menace an Attack of the Clones, where you've got the much more athletic Jedi, but then also being able to take that into animation and draw on his Samurai Jack experience, draw on some of the other works that he's done, and ultimately produce something that is brief, that is fast paced,

16:35 that is immediately attention grabbing, and yet it was also recognizable because audiences at the time were very familiar with his style. The fact of the matter is, you've got all of this going on here, but what most people wanted to do was to be able to sell toys. So these functioned as commercials in the sense, given that they were just about to have Revenge of the Sith come out, it behooved audience, or excuse me, behooved lucasfilm to not only keep Star Wars in the public eye, but also then to be able to start selling toys. Now, if they would have actually paid attention to the ladies a little bit more, that would have been good. But that's always kind of been Star Wars' problem.

17:26 Yeah, classic, I's someone who was a child when Phantom Menace came out. I was. I was a desperate toy collector at the time. I scoured those toys RS's and I was very I was glad to have whatever I wanted, but whatever I could get. But yeah, there's a reason that I made a point of gathering all of the female action figures that I possibly could for my youngest child, because they were not going to have the same access to characters that they could relate to. I mean they've since come out as trans but anyway, yeah, yeah, In fact, I had to do a bit of a cleanup on the shelf back there.

18:11 But if there was a female Jedi figure that came out, I picked it up. The only one I haven't been able to source yet is Joe Casten Knew, who doesn't have a Jedi librarian. I mean really love her. We also love we love her. Well, if it's not in the archives, it doesn't exist. Well, okay, so she was. She had a little bit of that academic arrogance, which but so much when she confronts Vader after Order sixty six has been executed. So, yeah, she this is in the comics.

18:52 It's in the comics. Yeah I haven't read that. Oh I knew about this. Yeah, she confronts Vader in the ARCA, just saying you're not supposed to be here. Leave. Yeah, she's she's really got she's got that fire. You never piss off a librarian. Yeah, God, it's like you don't piss off archivists either. They know where everything's buried. Jedi and a librarian. Come on, yes, well they know everything's buried and they can bury you. So, speaking of librarians, I think it's time that we dive into the text that we are talking about again, Plano's Snap Children versus Layer of grievous. I will give the synopsis for folks that are playing the home game, the.

19:40 People playing the home game, and people who are not playing the home game. Just to be clear, Kenny doesn't understand what the terms. I do understand people that are not participating in the main thing, and they're participating in the ancillary properties. All right, it's. A home game. You can't you can't go on the prices, right, and so you play the price is right at home. Similarly, people can't watch the things for some reason. We give brief synopsies so they could play the ancillary property. I think it scales perfectly. O. Good, Well, we'll see that. I think it scales perfectly. I'm a good little boy. Here we go.

20:20 I have a guest here, so I'm not saying. Anything interesting, so that that's a clear, clear indictment that I am very wrong. Anyways, Entertainment columnists and critic Steven ain't sure from his syndicated tvkey previews, as carried in the Wisconsin State Journal, Madison, Wisconsin on November twenty second, is synopsis for Plato Step Children Goes. Fans of this series who appreciate imaginative flights of fancy and their science fiction will enjoy this visit with the spurious worshipers of Plato. Actually, this group of beings are lovers of force rather than democracy, particularly when using the kinds of power they possess. All they have to do to assure their will over others is will it through psychotelkinetic energy, which projects their thoughts into powerful action. Tune in for Michael Dunn's fear of reprisal as Alexander the Plutonian's court jester, and for the imprisoned anger of Kirk, Spock and McCoy before they discover how to become masters of their own fate as grab on to Something, Oh okay, Leonard Nimoy grab onto something but excitedly uh. Leonard Niemoy also sings his own song Tonight Maiden Wine didn't realize there was this son not not just written for the show it Leonard. It's a bit of cross promotion for his fourth album my god, love that man. The sixties, you love it.

21:46 I love them with all of my heart. And soul is squeazy beautiful. When did it come out and who directed it? Aspen, I'm just curious. I'm so right, I don't even know who wrote it. Who wrote it? It was aired November twenty second, nineteen sixty eight. Writer Meyer Dolinsky, director David Alexander. When did so It's funny? I know a number of twenty second? Sixty three was a Kennedy assassination. Now I'm like sixty eight. When was the rfk MKA assassination? Notoriously, nineteen sixty eight. Eight is a chill year in the United States.

22:29 Yeah, we've brought this up before. I just heard November twenty second. I thought of assassinations again. That's chill, A. Chill time for everybody to watch. Plato Step Children, a very unchill episode. Excellent layer of Grievous, very exciting Star Wars, the Clone Wars Layer of Grievous, which I just want to say, I'm very excited to hear doctor and all year your take on Tartakovski versus this version of Clone Wars. Oh so excited. So I will say lay of Grievas. December twelfth, two thousand and eight, was when it was released. And then we have director at Sushi Teka Ucci. The writer of this is Henry Gilroy. I'm just gonna go with a little bit of a shorter from TV Archeologist on IMDb.

23:11 Thank you a K. Fisto. First appearance of Fisto on this version of The Clone Wars is on the trail of the recently escaped newt Gun Ray because this is the third of a three part arc, and joins up with this former padawan Nadar Veb on the remote planet of bask Unknown to them, they are entering the layer of General Gravis, who is being tested in his abilities by Count Dooku after a series of disappointments in Battle A Glorious, Glorious. Time for All and Atsushi Takauchi his only episode that he directs for Star Wars The Clone Wars. He is a development artist within Star Wars The Clone Wars and then also just a prolific artist with an anime. You might have seen some of his work in Appleseed X Machina and a thing called Ghost in the Shell. Y'all, Yeah, David Alexander, the director played a step children, was a first time Star Trek director because they are cutting the budget significantly and so they couldn't go to a lot of their original Star Trek directors, the ones that helped develop, because they were too expensive, and they went over and so David Alexander, they went to him and they were like, you got to get this in on time, and they still went over because again, just at this point, just to re establish NBC was to purposely torpedo Star Trek.

24:38 Great Reverend Time, Good Time. It's two thousand and eight. On the other side of things, just like to say. Both of these episodes are chill normal times. We're having a chill normal time. Can I just chose those thame really quickly? Slightly off topic about the year two thousand and eight or the year two thousand and seven? Bad years? Well two eight good for somebody's like thous seven. I feel like a bad year. Very anxious here, mostly just because we just watched the fourth Diehard movie and that one came out in two thousand and seven, and I just really don't like the odds. But that's just neither here nor there, so any so doctional very curious from you. I feel like I've been throwing in my little thoughts on these being not very chill episodes. What are what were your first impressions either of them? Or where do you want to start?

25:26 I was going to say which one do you want me to go with first? Which everyone feels like it's like you're feeling it in your soul. Personally, I think you should go with Layer of Grievous and then go to Plato Step Children, because right, is not just a worry about shape of show, because I worry about shape of show. I worry about your soul. But that's what I understand. Yeah, so Layer of Grievous and Plato step Field. Yes, okay, Well, as it turns out, I did actually watch all three episodes in that art, and we do. I could make certain well, yeah you did, because it's your job, but no, I did it because I wanted to ensure that I had all of the additional context that would go along with it, because that's one of the big things that I think Clone Wars was good at developing multi episode arcs, which is really funny when you've got an entire group of people who want fite size episodes you know, just here's an episode, and here's an episode not Clone Wars. They decided to do something a little bit different. Oh little arks, Yes, so here we go at Pisto. One of the things I really do like about the way that this episode starts is the idea of most powerful as he who controls his own power, right, and that is they were good to stay on that that entire weight through. I really liked seeing the jump ring along with the Jedi star Fighter.

26:58 That was something that we started seeing with Attack the Clones. Yeah, oh, let's see other thoughts on the matter. There were enough things like somebody should have said it's a trap. I have a bad feeling about this is there because who needs legs? But I would say that finding out that Darth Grievs had a Grievous excuse me? He wishes Well, that's the whole point of this episode, isn't it. Yes, are you worthy to be a s? And the answer is probably not.

27:42 Yeah. I was pleasantly reminded that Grievous has a dog or had a dot that big pet. Oh, yes, the big guy the things called gore Gore. Yeah, that's his dog. S far as I'm concerned, that it's supposed to guard the place when he calls. I mean, the only thing he wasn't doing was wagging a tail and trying to fetch except well, no, he was trying to fetch Jedi. It is very like Raincore esque in that it is like, not just your your your scary monster. It's also clearly a beloved pet.

28:23 Yes, also the sassy robot doctor. Oh my gosh. That doctor he needs. Specifically a doctor. They hate your doctor. I'm like, when I walk into my doctor's office and I'm like, can you replace my legs? I want them to be like, what are you doing? So I have to do this again? Awesome. I did find it interesting watching kit Pisto with his previous padawan and waking up to the realization that maybe his patawan didn't and closely enough. Oh my gosh, it was so interesting. Yeah, Kenny, that's that's it. What it's it's it's just an interesting dynamic.

29:14 I'm not sure that I have anything other to say about that other than the fact that I appreciated the dramatic contrast, and then also just watching the special feature. In regards to this episode, uh, I don't know. The GALVT, the the deliberate choice of being like, we're we're making this padawan very headstrong, and because I'm a smart boy, I couldn't help. But just think about it within the context of now and the the more action oriented, youth fulks versus the more patients let's practice patients, which was in the context of this episode. It's very much just like, oh, the Patawan is clearly wrong, but within our ticular climate of twenty twenty four, and that kind of thinking might just indicate that kit Festo is part of those sleepy Jedi that led to the downfall of the Republic.

30:12 It's an interesting it's an interesting point. I agree your. Interest. Uh, my primary takeaway from that was, and this is gonna this comes up later, So apologies for like thematically skippinghab but it comes up later with ah Soka. But we've talked about well, we've talked about this that Ahsoka boilers. You know, Ahsoka's fourteen years old, Yeah, and other Padawans like her, their first experience as Jedi is being part of a war. So what does it mean to I mean, effectively jo Ira cops, but like they are peace keepers, right, they are you know, ostensibly they're peacekeepers.

30:55 The sleepiness is complacency, but it's also about knowing that we have this power in the space. There's political machinations, but I wonder if there's a commentary here, at least the way I took it on. Now that you're entering into this, you're entering at a time of war. It's contextually it's contextually within the history of Star Wars and how Jedi have been depicted so far. We're in two thousand and eight, and so far, while we have had a large breadth of Star Wars text to draw from, Thank you Ewoks and Droids for your service, the Jedi are still kind of getting established about what the heck that they are in this notation of like now circa twenty twenty four, where they're like, yeah, they're definitely space cops.

31:44 But the definition of what the Jedi are is completely evolving. And so you're in the contrast of Kit Fisto now that I'm thinking about it, kind of driving from the Empire strikes back kind of Jedi, of being like Les practici patients. It's not necessarily about actions, not necessarily about the power fantasy versus not just keep bringing up doctor Knowles text, but also kind of the power fantasy aspect of the Jedi because you watched Star Wars Clone Wars, the Tartakowski piece, and you see Jedi being the bad badassiest badasses of all time, and also for for several generations of folks out there, they're like, Jedi are the coolest, most badass badasses of all time Circle two thousand and eight.

32:34 Now we're like space cops complicated, and the text has evolved with specifically with the seven seasons of the Clone Wars the rest of the Star Wars text of being like the Jedi were kind of full of themselves. Lucas intended that in the prequels, but it was hard to see through filmmaking language. Yeah, man, smart, good job. May actually I'm interested, doctor, because that is like, if I'm parsing out what you just said, he's kind of like, uh if Tartakovski is Jedi as superheroes, and then we kind of transition back into this as like Jedi as like it's almost like the Padawan is representing that greater power fantasy as opposed to the more patient side of it.

33:22 It's almost like we're pulling away from superheroes again and into maybe Empire asks, Am I am I reading that right? What do you think? Are we smart? Like guess like us? Are you a friend? Do I need to like fill out a note with do you like me? Yes? Or no? Can you give. Okay, I'm just going to say this for the bourb startup. I don't give grades, you earn them. We are in her mid thirties, yeah, and I'm in my late forties, so we're not part We're like, please give us a going to say? Is the thing about it is that Nadar isn't a padawan anymore by that point, he's a full on Jedi night of his own. So while he trained with Fisto, he's he's been, he graduated. Yeah, he's on his own now, and so the decisions that he makes are on him, and all Fisto can really do is look at it and go, well that suck. Moving on. Oh, I mean, there's really nothing he can do once his Once his former padawan makes that decision, he chooses to state.

34:47 I mean, he'll advise, but he doesn't materially throw him into get into his way, or he doesn't. He advises that he doesn't physically stop anybody. He lets Nadar continue on with his free agency, even if that results in his demise. So yeah, apathy, no, no, but sometimes you just gotta let the student do what the student's gonna do. M M. I circled this in my notes, using death as a motive based factor for pre existing desire because specifically Nadar is using Nadar wants to kick some ass. Nadara wants to get out there and wants to fight, and then yeah, he's he's mad, he wants he wants to fight, and he is kind of just to bring this with Lucas wanting to comment about certain things that were going on in the United States, well in pre Nixonian then also just within the context of nine to eleven and seeing Nadar as an example of using something that is actually bad to galvanize. I want to get to a fight.

36:12 I want to fight, and I'm going to use this as my motivating factor. We got to get them. I just thought that was great end of statement. I really did think that Nadar was coming from a place of grief because a lot of the lightsabers that Swiss Army Grievous was using were from other Jedi that he knew, ye h. I mean there were all of the Padawan braids in the trophy room, there were the lightsabers. So this probably really did tap into not only anger and grief, but maybe even a little bit of survivor's guilt.

36:55 So what are you going to try to do avenge those people who are gone this? So that's such an interesting thought because I yes, absolutely, And so if we were to go by what has been canonically or like at least textually presented of what the Jedi say is the correct way to kind of go about this, right is a lack of attachment. It's not to give into this anger, this fear. And I would say the kit Fisto piece about kind of being like sort of hands off about it is a respect of the agency of his former student. I also wonder if it's coming from that place of, well, you know, we have to let people go and there is a risk and holding onto them. But I think, ah, something I really do, And I think that perhaps, especially as they're being descended into what is actually a very frightening experience where there's war and there's battle happening all that time, that approach is falling apart, like it doesn't matter how we train in this space. You can't say to a person who's watching your people and your friends die all the time, well, just approach it with the lack of attachment, you know, just like let it go right.

38:10 Well, we also saw a little bit of that ego coming through with Luminara and Duley in the previous episode when she was saying, yes, Ahsoka, I understand you've dealt with this bog witch before. Yep, and that's a Soka's term, bog witch. I love it so much. Oh we can call I love ventures with all my heart. And she is just she's a real witch bitch and that's that is positive. Yes, yes, complimentary bogwitch complimentary, Yes exactly, Yes, yes. Luminar is the other one I was thinking of. She represents this a lot. She represents it later on with her paddle on too. Although it really did make me wonder during that episode why was she paired with Ahsoka Where was Parrots? Yeah, because the two of them have a tandem fighting style that Soka really didn't have access to, so why are you uncapping her? But anyway, coming back to layer of grievous, I love the I love count Dooku.

39:14 I think he is a fantastic character. And it's Christopher Lee. You can't go wrong with one of the inspirations for James Bond. I didn't know that. Yeah, Christopher Lee was cousins with Ian Fleming, Oh my God, and the care and a guy by the name of Major Guests Phillips Majors or Major's Phillips, Major Phillips. There was the full on inspiration for James Bond. But because Christopher Lee had done enough covert work during World War Two, dude also has his spy chops and just that feeling of a character an actor who is in complete control.

40:03 Dooku being in complete control. It's good. Have you seen that that story about how in Lord of the Rings? I adore the story. I think I know the one you're talking about. You know, it's just like he's say, he was talking to Peter Jackson about like, oh yeah, well if you stab a man from behind and like had like it was just like a little bit like an exhalation of breath and it's just like, because I'm stabbed from the bod. So yeah, which is I actually have to disagree. That's not the sound that a dead person makes whenever they die. Oh yeah, what is it? Oh when you stab somebody from behind? Yeah, when you stab somebody, they'll say that's what.

40:48 I would say. Fris, my oldest. Friend, comes out of Rise of Skywalker unscathed. My guy, yes, so yeah, the way that Douku just started up, admits, Oh yeah, I turned off your droids. Oh yes, I'm also testing you. Oh and you fail? Oh my god, you do better next time. He's like, you don't get an a C? Yeah? Tops is C? Yes? Yeah? Yeah, man, this that's funny. I love I love DQ too.

41:29 I also love Grievs. I am I just like I don't feel bad about loving Grievs. I think he's a weirdo. This episode makes me love him even more because I like that he can lose his legs and crawl around like a spider and it's so scary and I love it. Well. He also goes swinging through his house, not unlike Jean lu Picard swinging through the ship looking for breakfast in the episode of Next Gen where everybody devolves. Oh Jesus, Genesis, there it is. He's a seven of Next Gen. Boil boy asspen it gets weird. Oh so good though. Oh my gosh, that's like the only season of Star Trek, well or older ones or not season. It's the only Star Trek show I haven't really seen, so yes, I I really it's deeply creepy. Uh. The way he's represented this is also uh to kind of go as slightly on a grievous tangent to here. There are the statues that he has in the in that sequence where they're realizing where they are.

42:33 I adore it. I adore it as someone that doesn't. I'm coming to Clone Wars and I'm like, Grievous is just a guy. He's a he's the he's a he's a little guy who moves around his arms and in lightsabers and he talks with a Romanian accent. Uh. And then seeing those statues, I'm just like, this is this is the kind of world building that I very much enjoy war. It just makes me lean forward and ask questions without telling me what the heck is actually going on. And then the notion of Grievance getting all these cybernetic replacements just to be better, which caused me to write my brilliant note is Grievous Attack bro Aspen attack bro.

43:20 Oh a tech bro bro? Is he a tech bro? One hundred percent? He is one of those Well, he's like a tech bro from one of those films about the future where they're like, I. Got these cybernetic implants. Man, got magnets in my fingers, Like. You like magnets in your fingers? As the worst idea ever, ask why would you? Sorry, I've been watching a lot of Nick kroll Croll show. It's it's a sketch and curl show. That is not an original idea. That was Nick Kroll's idea. Sorry, it was very funny though, but you know, I'm trying to magnets, trying to think of a thom like you know, like that where like yeah got the stuff man, so yeah, and that kind of guy. Yeah. But also there's an interesting backstory on him that I've talked about on here.

44:10 There's yes, and I think there's even a few different kind of continuity aspects. Just like an eu version, there's other versions and in both versions though, he is a he's a warrior and he's a caliche. And the story I know him to be is that he was a warrior that was specifically targeted and brought down by them, by yeah, by Douku to then control him and turn him into this cyborg. And so, regardless of what story people follow, whether and whether you know that or not, to then see these flashes of these statues of what he was when he was a warrior is extraordinarily beautiful visual storytelling, I think, and creepy because it's a little you're in that like horror, like the like the like the Haunted House, and you're like.

45:05 Well, it definitely picks up on the show don't tell yes, And I love that, But if you're going to be reduced to a brain and an organ sack, you better have a much better trade off than what he's got going on. No, poor buddy almost makes me feel bad for him. Honestly, some days I wake up and I wish that I was an organ sack. Okay, capitalism, yes, right, I mean basically har am I right, we. Get in the in the flony on special features, we get filony. Being like George said, Grievous wanted to be a Jedi, he couldn't, and then editors note so he tech wrote.

45:47 Out, Oh now, I didn't realize that there had been a desire to be a Jedi. I thought he was just a warrior who decided upgrades looked acceptable once he couldn't really use his arms and lengths anymore. I mean there's the textual examples within EU and the rest of the Clone Wars, and then there's this special feature that is referencing what our lord above, George Lucas actually said that he wants Grievous to be, and just which I am sure that George was just like he just said it because he hadn't thought about it, and so he was like, does you want to be a Jedi?

46:31 Maybe he doesn't, so maybe that's maybe that's the story. And Dave foil Oni with his hat was just like, great genius. Yeah, I just. Realized I wasn't plugged in, and my it's okay, I got this, you know. I thought you got so excited and you were like, wait, I have a book. No, but I have been thinking about when we're talking about Grievous in this context, I wonder how it would read under a lens of disability stuffies. Oh extraordinary. I'm a cultural studies person. This is what we do full time. Yes, I mean I think there's so many different ways that we could could approach it if we appreciate with the the background piece that I'm familiar with, My immediate thought is on the if he were indeed, if he were indeed like shot down, and then they provided him with the cybernetics, like that is it? That is like taking his agency away and putting him in this position, of this position of like being marginalized for their purposes, which is horrifying. And that's like the first thing that comes to mind for me.

47:48 I mean, don't we eventually say the same thing with Darth Vader, because we're told over and over again that this was not done to relieve his suffering. This was to make a tool of him, and he Palpatine ensured that he could continue to feel pain so that he would never have a comfortable day in his life. Oh Christ, I'm going to use this as I think an appropriate segue to our Star Trek piece today, Plato step Children speaking of disability. Text and also lack of agency. Oh my goodness, Yeah. I'm having the same like visceral physical reaction even talking about talking about this that I was watching Plato Stepchildren.

48:31 Well, Plato step Children, I think is just kind of like a light, gentle episode where the crew of the Enterprise is just being like, why don't he eat some fruit and play the harp and steam minutes Kirk Spacha McCoy are just being like, isn't it great that we're star treking, and the Platoniums are just like, yeah, absolutely, well goodbye, it's great that. They're star treking across the universe. I was just thinking that same thing. Holdly going forward because we cannot find reverse. Yes, you've seen you've seen the cliff from Star Trek First Contact, right where they say the name of the show. No, yes, oh, there is spoilers for Star Trek. But there's a moment where the crew of the Enterprise E are downstairs on the planet Earth because it's a time travel movie, and they're talking. They're talking with the inventor of warp drives from Cochrane and they're like, homie, you got to make sure and they say that it's very inappropriate. They say, you need to make sure that the flight happens tomorrow or else all of all Starfleet Federation, all of the advances of Earth won't happen towards Zefrom. Cochrane goes, you're all you're all astronauts on some kind of Star Trek.

49:57 I like that, and I swear, I swear to you. Jonathan Frakes almost looks down the lens of the camera goes, he. Goes, You're you're like astronauts and some kind of Star Trek colon First Contact. Really, it's it's it's thrilling. It's thrilling every single time. I remember seeing that in the theaters, and it was I'm pretty sure that the whole audience went the traditional white person call up whoooooo. He said the thing he did, he said the thing that actually does sound very invigorating. It was very Star Star Trek First Contact, A good dumb movie, beautiful. Anyways, we're not here to talk about Star Trek First Contact. We're here to talk about step Children, a cool, chill TV episode. Uh, first impressions, Doc Nole.

50:53 Thanks, I hate it. So if we were talking in previous episode about the importance of controlling his own power, let's just say that there are a few things right off the bat that let me know that something's up. One eugenics. There's thirty eight specimens left specimens. Okay, cool, I'm now frankly seeing untrammeled power and how it completely corrupts was feeling a little bit more familiar than I actually wanted. Particularly we've got the audience, the audience surrogate of Alexander, and for me, a lot of the themes that were being discussed are just as relevant today like July fourteenth, twenty twenty four, as they were in nineteen excuse me, nineteen sixty eight.

52:02 Yeah, I wonder, I wonder, I mean not to not to, but piggyback while you're saying I as I was like, as I was watching, I fundamentally I felt nauseated genuinely, which I think is just going to come from watching people literally be tortured for ten minutes at a time. At a certain point, I thought this has to end soon, I can't and then it just kept going. But I wonder if part of me it was also having this feeling of this is too familiar, this is too close to home. There is a genuine feeling in twenty twenty four of yep, this is about this is it? This is what it feels like?

52:43 So yeah, very little bit. Yeah, it felt very well, for lack of a better word, aa shistic, where you've got that whole fascism angle of yeah, one way to go, and controlling not only Alexander but also others, manipulating them, torturing them. I wasn't quite expecting Spock to trample on Kirk's head during his little tarantella, but I as soon as we hit the point of the stop hitting yourself, it was at that point that there was absolutely no question about whether or not these people were abusers. Oh god, yes, And that was being written in nineteen sixty eight, which was not really a time when we were acknowledging that abuse was happening in homes in other spaces. And so by placing Kirk, Spock, and McCoy in a situation where they are first completely stripped of power and agency, and then all of a sudden, once they solve the problem, once they solve the riddle, and they're able to then assert themselves again, I didn't find that as satisfying as

54:17 I wanted. I feel like the leader guy rolled over so fast when he realized that he couldn't be a bully. Yeah, well, that's that's an end of the episode itis And I think that's just kind of uh, par for the course. In terms of Star Trek episodes where suddenly they're like, uh, checking the watch, being like we got ninety sex and draft this up. Cool. Yeah, No, I'm never going to be a fascist ever again. Thank you for letting me see the error of my face. But then of course correct being like, no, I don't believe you, which I wonder if you know how one you're watching a horror film and you're.

54:59 You know, you know, I don't watch this if I can avoid him, Oh well, I find a lot of a lot of it will happen sometimes for me in horror film like this, you know, ones that have say Final Girls for instance, where someone does say survive at the end. Part of it is that horrifying things are happening over and over and over again. You see your protagonists lose, you're so scared for them, and then there comes a turning point is typically when you can actually see the monster, where that person rises up and fights back and wins. And that doesn't always happen. It's not always deserved. Sometimes it doesn't happen it should. And this feels like one of the situations where I almost wanted It was like such an extended torture and sadism that I almost wanted Kirk to turn around and Final Girl It or one of the women to Final Girl It even more because they got pulled up into it too, or her and Nurse Chapel.

55:53 Yeah, and I'll tell you as a fan of Strange New Worlds, yes I am. I was looking at that spot and Chapel interaction. Oh no, my heart was just aching. Yeah, because with that that history and then seeing how their relationship continued to well, it wasn't really evolving. I would say it was just more at station keeping, so you know, just we are colleagues. But yeah, that was that made. It worse almost And there are there are episodes too, and cos if you if you recall where is It the Naked Time, Yeah, where she's just like I love you, misters Bock, I love you. And so even without Strange Worlds, which does create a lot of pain for me too, like you still have it. You know that news Chapel's in love with them, and so it's just like it's just one of those where it's, yeah, it feels horrifying.

56:54 Uh. Two things won the extent for the extent, torture, uneasy and also I think very indicative of the kinds of storytelling that is happening within season three of the original series, which is we don't exactly we don't exactly know what else to do, and so the characters are going to keep participating in these behaviors that are kind of out of character for the same characters from seasons one season two. They'd be a little bit more quick to the solution as opposed to for instance, and the children shall lead where Kirk goes to every single person is just like, surely you can't be brain controlled by these children?

57:39 Yeah, good ideas that are destroyed by a run time, I guess, or just yeah you other time. Nothing else to say. Because at some point, and perhaps this is truly sincerely not a bit this is my cis hat white male perspective, but the tension just completely deflates from the torture because it just keeps happening again and again and again. And the way that they heighten it is just to bring down Chapel and Aura and that that's how you heighten it. But there's nothing I don't know. It was also very interesting talking about that Asmond, because we're friends outside of the podcast. It's not just content friendship.

58:25 Friends, we're friends. I'm so sorry I moved away from you. It's okay. You deserve to be happy. My my legend. Thank you, You're welcome. You got to make sure that you're living in a safe state as opposed to Texas anyways. But also watching it through my perspective and I'm just like, this is a campy wild time. It is the the the control that they're having them do is just like Kirk becomes a horse, spots wild Spot dances to the Flamenco. I'm watching this and I'm just like, this is campy as hell, and asmen text me and just like this is horrifying, and I truly sincerely did not see that.

59:10 I was just like, this is campy as hell. Oh wow. Well, also, I had a completely different relationship to all of this stuff, to Star Treker to this, to Star Trek to and probably to Torture as well, because I'm just Hi, I won the genetic lottery. Maybe are you talking about just blue eye marginalized identity stuff? Yeah, yeah, yeah, like being marginalized people. Not to say that I was cheering for Parman over there, which make no mistake, he was right, I know.

59:51 And he's doing a terrible bit. Tal Girl was like Wow, what did I come into. Sorry doctor, No, I'm not a eugenicist, I state. That, but yeah, but interesting. But yeah. My perspective of this episode is that going into it, I'm like, cool, we're going to see Kirkus a horse. That's going to be something. We're going to see Alexander, which is who. Is a joy. Perhaps I engage in hyperboleague far too often, but I think it is one of the great performances of the original series. It is. Sincerely yes, I agree, Yes, that is the star that way too young.

1:00:33 Yeah, he died. At what thirty eighty eight. The actor is Michael Dunn, who you could have seen on Fred Freiberger's previous show that he worked on The Wild Wild West playing Doctor Lovelas. Now I'm just thinking about how they did Doctor Lovelace in the Wildlive West film, which was Kenneth Brand as a spider. Yeah, there is, there's there's just a beautiful dignity to Alexander. According to these are the voyages. He's the three by Mark Cushman and uh, oh boy, I'm gonna forget her name again.

1:01:17 I can't believe it's truly. Shameful by this point, considering that I've been consulting that Susan Osborne. Okay, unbelievable. Yeah, but Michael Dunn was also considered for the role of Spock because rodden Berry was like, let's we have to put another on the bridge, and this actor is very compelling and he's right. I it counter if he was not in this episode, this would be a very very weak sauce episode in terms of quality. But just every time that he is on screen, there's just there's an X factor.

1:01:58 M Yeah, he is electric. Yeah. And also Spock and Kirk do a tweel de tweetl dumb dance episode, Oh my gosh, after Spock is forced to cry and laugh for the delight of Parmen and the we come back from the act break and Alexander not exactly knowing Spock, there's this beautiful piece of acting, just background acting, where where Alexander just tentatively puts his shoulder on Spock's body just to be like I'm here for you, and then like it's just like, I'm not entirely sure if this is okay, but i just want you to know that I'm there for you.

1:02:50 Can I ask you so doctor know all you were talking about disability politics and yes, well a representation, yes, representation, and Alexander being a little person in this like I'm kind of curious you're And also the sort of when we're talking about agency and things being taken away and what it looks like, but like the marginalization of people who are othered like what I don't know, Like how is that landing for you? I think one of the aspects of Alexander that really just stays with me is that when kirk Spock and McCoy figure out that it's an environmental factor that's giving these the Platoniums that power, and he says, no, I wonder and I'm saying this as somebody who is neurodivergent ADHD division, a US division or people are you know, dealing with physical disability or basically existing in a world that is not made for people like me. M I look at Alexander and his unwillingness to.

1:04:28 What is the word. Is assimilate the wrong word participate, assimilate. That's a similar because he doesn't want he doesn't want to be that. He knows who he is, and he does not find himself defined by that disability except through others definition of him. Yes, the gaslighting notion that existed within the society until Kirk's back and McQuay come down, and that feels extremely relevant to now just being like no, no, no, no, no, we are serving for the greater ideals that you're great the loss for Plato put Forth.

1:05:10 And his coming out and being like I've realized it's not me, it's them. Yeah. Oh listen, I say that about as all the time. I'm the problem. Just think this way, say just remember, don't be part of the problem, be the entire problem. Yeah, I've made my south through. Yeah, I mean that is that is a message that I am like, ah, yes, as someone yeah, moving through the world who's not the like the norm like you know, like neurodivergins, these different kinds of like outside of like gender identity and norms too, it is pretty extraordinary to be like yes, right, ah, you know, so it's pretty empowering. It's a really beautiful moment.

1:05:57 And that's a really beautiful moment too, like coming internally and actually I actually do think the way that Kirk interacted with him and that kind of that line that where I come from, size, shape or color makes no difference and nobody has the power. Is. Like I think. I sometimes am like yeah, yeah, because I'm coming from this like angry perspective, but that actually, really I think from the way I watched that the way they interacted with each other did feel fundamentally respectful, and so it felt really full of like hope in true in truth and honesty, you know. And so I though it was really lovely.

1:06:38 It's beautiful and also indicative not to be this guy, but I'm going to be indicative of the white liberalism that was running the show of being like, hey, even though it was sis het white male, we and the ship is pretty much ran by sis het white males. We don't see race, color or creed orientation. It's all it's all good, and it's still Michael Dunn being given this. I'm patting myself on the back of being like, actually, Star Trek was problematic at the time, good job, but just also talking because I love to talk about the narrative that that Star Trek puts forth itself in its own marketing material being like the Great Liberal Show and to be fair within the context of like other TV shows at the time. Sure, yeah, also marketing materials.

1:07:35 He's segueing to the great, the great marketing moment. The great it's a great marketing moment, which is the maybe not necessarily a great marketing moment, but you know, the reason that this episode is famous outside of I think we've got a couple of meme moments that now permeate the internet for existence. For example, Kirk slapping himself classic gift that you can use, but alsome we'd have to kiss between Kirk and O'Hora. Isn't that something. If you were in the South then yeah, people were losing their marbles, Yeah, because of missgenation. But the thing you got to remember is that that was not the first interracial kiss on television.

1:08:20 Mm hmmm, yeah. Can he talks about this and like the way that when we say marketing, he's saying, like the messaging that's been put out is this is the first interracial kiss. Which, make no mistake, there were people behind the scenes that were very much pushing for like we want this to happen, and then Shatner purposely sabotaging alternative takes to make sure that the take that happened happened. Yeah, Shatner's has been so many things, but him like according to Michelle Nichols, like crossing his eyes during takes just to make sure, and NBC is just like, we can't go back and film more because that would cost money. Let's just use it, go go, go where the third season was and that's how. And then not only that, Fred Freiberger really pushing for this, the showrunner at the time, and then it seemed like that wasn't going to happen.

1:09:11 So then Freiberger calls roden Berry. It's like, you got my back on this one. Roddenberry is enough of a needle in the system of NBC to be like, yeah, let's make sure that this happens. And so they make sure that this happens. But yes, doctor Nol, you're asked correct that this is not the first injur racial kiss on TV. Please go on. From what I understand, the first one was on I Love Lucy. Yeah, because Ricky Ricardo was not a white dude. Yeah, but the Cuban man, Yes, Cuban man kissing a woman from upstate New York. Yeah, which Lucille had to fight tooth and nail just to make sure that Desi was cast on I Love Lucy, which is so fascinating, But then we also just don't consider it because DESI are and as is white passing.

1:10:01 At least I'm black and white. Right, And you know, I was thinking about this a bit because I think there's I was thinking about this sometimes. I like watch media and I like engage critically. Is it me am I the star wars. Am I the Star treks am I the trekker across the Stars? It's not the first interracial kiss. It's also not even the first kiss between a black and a white person. It isn't the it is like in the first like fictionalized one. Is that right? According to these are the voyage is season three, and please correct me if I'm wrong with Doctor Noel, But the first interracial kiss that was on TV was I think a peck on the cheek between Nancy Sinatra and Sammy Davis Jr.

1:10:53 Okay, so when you say interracial, you need to be very careful with the way you're using that term. Please in this instance, because you have a white woman and a black man, or as we've gotten Plato step children, a black woman and a white man. A big deal at this point is missagenation. I mean, when was loving versus the state of Virginia decided. Is that it was the sixties. It was in the sixties. I don't have the precise date, but that was that was a factor because at that point the pint we've also got films. We've also got films like look Who's Coming to dinner?

1:11:36 Mm hm oh that was the thirty fifties. Sixties. Oh, the sixties. Oh my gosh, I'm thinking Katherine Hepburn's how I went back. But well, no, Katherine Hepbern. But she's the she's the mother, right, she's I was thinking young. Oh no, no, no, no, it was her and Spencer Tracy as the parents. Yes, okay, so it's like in it's in the culture all exact right. Oh. Interesting, Yes, And this. Could also be part because I talked about NBC making a concerted effort to hire more women behind the scenes because they want the optics of look at us. We're hiring more women behind the scenes that do business with.

1:12:21 Us in the nineteen sixties, given the emergence of second wave feminism following up Betty for Dan and so forth. Yeah, that makes a lot of sense. Yeah, there's an interesting like I was reading, because it is significant. There's a reason why people talk about this in a significant way, and I wanted to see. I remember I was reading about Michelle Nichols's experience with it, and so I was thinking, what is her experience being in the thing? And she sees it as a highlight because for her it was so important and is a real joy to being like, I guess a kiss Captain Kirk, and that's probably She even says that she's like, I love you know, but this coming like what is her personal safety with the thing, like in her empowerment in it?

1:13:14 And that's valuable I think to remember and to think about what. Oh sorry, that just made me think O a Roddenberry line so great, I highlighted it in a different color, just to make sure where it is just like Roddenberry, you guy, uh from These Are the Voyages Season three. Roddenberry's later said Captain Kirk and Lieutenant Horace kiss was an integral part of the storyline, and it never occurred to me to question whether Kirk should kiss a black person or not. I had by that time achieved a certain clarity about those things. Dot as are a matter of fact. Long before Captain Kirk kissed Lieutenant Aura, I kissed her many times.

1:14:00 Oh wow, Oh I forgot about that. Oh well, now we're getting too The sexualization of white women and black women rather black women is what I'm gonna say, the sexualization of black women. And yeah, and. Let me just say this, as far as Michelle Nichols goes, that helped to get her where she needed to go. That is called using your assets. We do also need to acknowledge the rampant power imbalance that can go along with that. Yes, but I'm not going to shame anybody. Yeah, is a literal queen, you know.

1:14:45 Sorry, have we talked about Michelle possibly leaving Star Trek. What do you mean that? Mlka? Yeah, she was, She was going to go work in Duke Ellington's band and who can right? Yeah? Yeah, and that it was Martin Luther King who convinced her to stay because how important it was. Yeah, representation. Whoopi Goldberg was inspired to be on TV because she saw Aura on there. Yeah, it's a very it's a very tough kind of thing to watch because the context of the kiss in this episode is both of them do not have agency. They are being forced to do a thing, So it feels horrifying when it does not feel empowering.

1:15:30 Liberally us wonderful liberals can be like, look progress, but then the text also can kind of satiate the south of being like, isn't this disgusting? But then we can also have the other side of it as being like, look at us, we're hite liberals. We think those are a bad thing. And it's like, but what did it mean at the time? Yeah, and for what they're trying to do. I think something that we're forgetting here is that as that kiss was taking place, Kirk wasn't focused on a Hura. He was making eye contact with Harman's wife, who was getting very hot under the college. She was seriously I have seldom seen somebody that thirsty, but dear god, she needed a drink that.

1:16:18 I have had a dry period, right, he was. And another aspect to it that I do think is important is even though it was against their wills, I was actually so struck by how deeply he was trying to take care of her. Yes, like he which that is That is part of Star Trek too. I I feel like Kirk has always been so protective of Ahura and his all of his people, all of his people. He loves them very much, who respects them, And I think that's what he was seeing, and he was just like trying to give her this courage and be like, I am with you, I am safe. It is okay. I'm so sorry for this. And I did make it at least feel like there wasn't any like he Yeah, while we do not have this agency, we still have this like we are safe together, which softened it for me slightly.

1:17:12 Yeah, I would agree with that. But yeah, as far as the platoniums, yeah, they're the worst. Fuck not exactly, I would say not great. Also no fundamental understanding of Plato. Also that I was looking at that and thinking, uh, did you actually read Plato? Did you possibly read the follow up? You know? With Aristotle, they're like, we don't read sequels and we don't. Read the originals, can't use like the Sparks notes version. Now, obviously I've read all of Plato and Aristotle clearly, but for people that like might not have like read Plato and Aristotle like and and again, I can't clarify enough.

1:17:57 I've read all a Plato in Aristotle. I can talk very long and very articulate about both of those men yep uh. But for like Falk, I haven't read them. Is there any way that you could give like a cursory overview of like what their philosophies are and how the Platonians are not existing within that paradigamond are instead using those notions to pervert it into a fascistic nightmare. Nope, I can tell you what it's outside of my wheelhouse, and frankly, I'm more of a Socrates kind of girl anyway. Oh yeah, if you stop and think about what he must have said, just as his last words, I drank.

1:18:42 What that's really running? It's also a. Rip from the movie Top Secret starring Gal Comer. Oh of your rules? I mean, I can tell you right it's not which is what they're talking about there? I don't think there's anything. And I'll tell you who is an actual expert? Is my partner? Yeah, I'm a historian and cultural scholar. I don't do philosophy, philosophy and I don't do math. Can you bring Jolan here? We go grab like I'm here. I think maybe we'll grab Joel later. Later, I'll tell you what they're certainly not. They are certainly not you genicists who are just believing in a strange hedonistic way of life, or in the intellectual superiority or physical superiority of anyone there. It's it's if anything, it's about like what it is to be a person in the world.

1:19:35 I would like to give the cursory understanding a player from These are Voyages Season three by Mark Cushman and Susan was Born. You nailed the dismount You're good job, buddy. Uh number one, I'm an ally? What huh? You said you were an ally? And I wasn't sure if you were talking of out in Platonic terms Aristotilian terms terms. I'm just like such an ally, just like I you put it in front of me. I'm an ally, so. Like an ally to this stick figured. My niece made, uh like I'm an alarm?

1:20:23 Yeah? What are they say? Uh? The actual text here I go uh. Plano was an advocate of something akin to class snoppery in the Republic. Plano's ideas regarding the perfect society are put forth. Is described there as being of a tripartite class structure corresponding to appetite spirit reason. The appetite comes from the workers, the greatest number in the society. The spirit comes from those willing to die for the society. It's warriors. The reason comes from the philosopher kings. Those who possess the greatest intelligence, have a passion for the study and accumulation of wisdom in our best suited to government. The appetite and spirit. People of this type, people like Plato and Socrates, we're few and far between it, according to Plato, deserving of a higher class standing. And it looks like the Platonians have kind of eliminated, uh, the appetite in the spirit, and I'm simply gone to reason and are just looking for any reason to just be like, no, pitch, Poch, you're bad, so we're wrong.

1:21:24 It is kind of it's taking a concept and it's it's twisting it right fundamentally. It seems broken. Yeah, because it benefits those in power, because you can just say, oh, I'm smart's. Going to listen to this, and he's going to be like, Aspen cannot believe you. I just feel sorry for all the tables at your place because they're all going to be flipped. Whenever Joel hears this, he's. Gonna be like, here's all my Plato. Books in a lot of ways that divide that you're talking about reminds me very much of the film Metropolis from the nineteen twenties, and with the idea of the there must be a mediator between the head and the hands, and the mediator is the heart. So you have your triparthrite structure, not necessarily with warriors, but more with intermediaries, so you get a little bit of that, but you definitely have the reason and the appetite being represented there so being able to take that in from our republic era Germany. Another sci fi connection that we can pull in this is I like.

1:22:36 This tripart ideas because then there's also almost a touch of a uh Freudian like super ego in ego I hate. For it so much. Yeah, real, he's a shit, But I mean I'm just know just from a fairy standpoint, I mean yeah, but also yeah, and but or even like when we talk about well, we also talk about sometimes the like pathos et those logos. I know, we're talking about this in terms of class structure, like who is deserving of something? But I am I am very interested in these sort of different parts and it's always triparted of like who is dictating over another. You know, I wonder if one of the other reasons that they kept Alexander in addition to they needed somebody to kick around. If they didn't have somebody at the bottom of the pile, you don't have a pile anymore, right, Who are you above? Exactly? And as power usually looks for a way to elevate itself above another group. Yes, if you yes, you can't stand tall if you're all the same hype.

1:23:44 Yep. It's like that episode of Community where they kick. I was thinking the exact same thing. They kick peers out and then they start being mean to each other's they have to break feers back in so they can have someone to be mean to. Yeah, I mean he deserved that. But uh, to bring around into terms of commonality is what is completely unexpected is that both these episodes are looking at uh stratification for lack of another term, They're they're both investigating power dynamics. Star Trek being Star Trek quite almost almost literally, if not literally, by just going this is wrong and then coming in and trying to do the Star Trek thing and being like, let's wreck your society because it's wrong, and then Star Wars through action by grievous wanting to be on Sith, not being able to be a Sith and asking people and demonstrating just killing people because he's he's got a beef to quash.

1:24:53 And similarly, uh, the power dynamics between kit Fisto and ni Dar uh Nadar represent the new guarden a dar wanting a fight. Uh, power dynamics all around. Also, maybe feel deeply unsettled in different ways? Sure, one way positively, one way bad negative negative positive negative. Yeah, yeah, surprising. Sometimes we like struggle. I feel like for thematic connections. Weirdly, I did feel like, like, what is it agency and power power?

1:25:33 Yeah, Star Trek literally Star Wars through action. Yes, absolutely, Ah, this is what. Yeah. Well, we have a couple of other things. Are you still are you going to go a little bit past just to kind a couple more things? Oh? Have me as long as I am at your disposal of the season. Okay, well we won't. We'll keep You're out to. Get some like okay, a couple of you got a look on your face. Well I just noticed that Aspen's cheeks are getting a little rosy. Oh dam, Aspen's got some hearts getting into their eyes and as might askpen might be getting a little Twitter painted because because because.

1:26:25 Mhm, it's a ship time a long time ago, it's ship time. This ship a boat hated a game, but none of them could war mind drive into high birth space. Ship time worlds can't be that second place. Ship time captains talk on a hallo kron, I wanted a song. I penned a song for seventeen more minutes and thighs. In super hind ship Ships ship ship ship be ship ships. Or USS Enterprise dt F. Don't you take my walk lighter and clip bit? Don't you take my Richard buddy and nipit? If you spill the tea, I'm gonna sip bit.

1:27:20 My starship ask one. What are we doing? Oh, we're gonna play starship bit, which is where we're gonna name our favorite vehicles slash starship sets fly through the sky from either property either so you don't have to pick one from each in your favorite ships, which can be both like canon they actually happen in the show or your AO three fan fiction dot net desires either way, and there's no judgment. I feel like I've had chips where I'm like I feel like, I know this is fundamentally not good. But like I should uh. Previous examples of batships that asked on this pick include Rex with a jet pack, Stilvia, the Cat a Flying Leaf.

1:28:04 When I made bad of it, like I was, like, I feel like this is an abusive relationship. I'm so sorry. But yeah, and also asn't picked people, Okay, they. Went with other things, so we'll start with again. We say starships, but sometimes we don't see a lot of them, so it could also be a vehicle of your choice. We also, because you are I guess you get carte blanche of whatever you want. Yeah. You could also just tell us your favorite ships in general, and either. Because it's hard from the lair of grievous, I would say the Jedi Starfighter is my favorite. Outstanding, ah, the.

1:28:48 Yes and R six in the back. Yeah, that's all good. The Delta seven B eighth or Sprite class light interceptor before it, I that was mine too. It's okay, I'll choose a different one. But because I I'm with you, you said this at the top. I love the Hyperspace Ring so much, so good. It's like, what a concept. God, it's great. I will say The one thing that might be improved is what they did in The Acolyte, where they made the whole thing a wing. It's a big honkin wing. Oh, oh my gosh, that's so cool.

1:29:29 I'm still an episode one of The Acolyte, although I have made it through all of Aska, and so they use another hyperspace ring in that one too. Oh that's a big old guy. Oh that one's a monster. That's a big old ring. We love that. We love an even bigger erspace ring. Oh gosh, Oh, be so interested to hear. You'll remember in The Force Awakens whenever they were like, it's just like the Death Star, and the scientist is like, it's nothing like the Death Star and it's just bigger. A little bit. Yeah, but it's not the same for Ahsoka. No, because it's really cool.

1:30:09 No, I'm just the Force Awakens, a movie that I now like and have come around to. Yeah, there's just still some moments in that movie around just like that. That's we're not talking about Force Awakens, but we're talking about but but but I did just want to say to your earlier point, doctor Mill about not having enough like action figures or toys, especially for like little girls or like female characters. I my friend's daughter fell so deeply in love with Ray when she saw the Force awakens, and would is like dress up like her all the time. And I think about that every time. I'm just like, you know, what things might be like. I might be like, well, I have some criticisms of this, but like then I think of her and I'm like.

1:30:52 This is good. So as far as I'm concerned, no media is ever going to be perfect. Yeah, I just there will always be some Yeah, I know what I said. Sorry, I don't have challenges on Blue Ray yet. Oh it's a perfect film. It's a perfect. It's good that everybody has an opinion, don't you think. Oh my gosh, just like it's just so savage. My gosh, I feel the spice over here.

1:31:33 That's a beauty Okay. So that's a beautiful ship. That was it? Okay. So I have to think of a different I have to think of a different vehicle from either either in you two and you too? Oh I got one? Oh, you got one? What's yours? I gotta go last, No, I will give. Me you got it? Like you know, it's like when you're ordering dinner and you're like get back to me. Sorry, I have to go last. Okay, then let me think you. Can shape a show. Sorry, I gotta go last. Oh my gosh, you're the worst. What other ships were there as? Then we can like the same ship. It's a yeah, I will share. There are no rules, Kenny, there are no rules. We picked it the same one. We broke it. We broke it.

1:32:19 You know what, what it's not? Well, we'll achieve a comfortable medium because we've liked other Jedi star Fighters, but we've never seen this Jedi star Fighters. What if I just like the hyper what if I like the Hyperlink pistols, I'll take part of it? Perfect, Okay, it fits with the rules. Mine's Captain Kirk. Oh because he's a horse. Oh, there's only one thing I can say to this exactly Nay, nay, nay. It was. It was disturbing and distressing and frankly to see him saddled with that kind of behavior. I mean, I really have to wonder what was spurring him on as he was going through all of this. I mean, really, we go from from a main event to something that is simply clip clopping its way through the world of consent.

1:33:19 It's a pity but go on. Oh my god, I hated it, but I loved it. We'll get in there, sorry, Kenny. That was the best moment of this entire podcast. That we've ever had. Oh my god, man, he and my partner are really other. Long. He's the one who wrote the starship It song and he's brilliant. Oh my god, get it, stopp look at me like that. You wrote the starship song? Oh no, I stove that. Oh my god, he's really easily. Lost fun a little want to play, Yes, I will, I will rain it. Bring it in.

1:34:01 Okay, let's move on to ships, like romantic ships from either would you also like to go first? So I've already spilled it for me. It's it's Spock and Chapel. Yeah, a beautiful ship as. Yeah, because it's not just simply romantic. They cover a lot of ground over time. Yes, yes they do. Oh my gosh. Yeah, it's such a it's such a it's like a it's a real tragedy. Well. I also wonder if the Kiss would have hit as well if it had been Spot and Acora. Mmmm.

1:34:41 And the answer is no, I don't think it would have had the same cultural impact. Which they tried to do, because they were just like, can't it can't be Captain Kirk. Can we at least have it with Spock at least that's that means that it's not real, to which, to their credit, Fred Freiberger and Rotten like, no, it has to be Kirk. Actually I do. I have to read something really quickly about the kiss, because. You were talking about it. Also, go ahead, oh, now you're talking about the South. I just remembered apparently who said this. They were talking about NBC executives were talking about feedback, and they apparently got a letter from a white Southerner who wrote, I am totally opposed to the mixing of raceist misagenation. However, anytime a red blooded American boy like Captain Kirk gets a beautiful dame in his arms that looks like Ahura, he ain't gonna fight it, which as it's like wild kind of thing. But I think it's talking to what you were talking about, which is that it's like if it were Spock, he's also an other, right, but it's white hot American, like all American Captain Kirk, and that is a big deal. And so yeah, if it had been switched you wouldn't have had the same emotional impact because I think the Spock Chapel thing is so intense, and then because of what Kirk represents is interesting too.

1:36:06 Actually, can I change my answer? Oh? Yes, absolutely? Oh yes, favorite ship or in Scotty Wow, which is actually canonical. Yeah, you haven't gotten pulling this out of my elbow. This is Yeah, we haven't gotten around to it yet. I didn't know. I like it. Cute, We love Scotty Scott. I read Blooded Scott's. Also, I would be I gotta, I gotta seam smart here. I gotta. I would be remiss to point out that, uh, William Shatner that red Blooded American is a Jewish Canadian.

1:36:51 Jewish Canadian man. Yeah, we love that, love to see it, to see it lovely. Okay, my ship is I forgot what are their names? The two main Platonians. That suck Para and not Parman. Yes, partman and not Parman. Here's why, here's why, here's why. The way that so you brought it up, the like Kurtic looking at her like this, I really love me a you know, an enemy still lovers kind of relationship, and that seems like it was like a lovers to enemies to lovers. We've been alive for a long time and now they're and they're just like a apathy stage and like they're just waiting for something to get them inspired, at which point they will tear each other apart.

1:37:39 Kind of think that they're twenty three hundred years old. How great was it whenever her her name is Falana, when was like, go ahead and guess how old I am. Oh? I was not there for that, just like spots, it's just about to trip. It's gonna be that god thirty five. By the way, she was doing this like such as this like posh British accent man. But yeah, in that little moment, her little yes, uh, they were. I mean, they were despicable people, but they had that real like terrible vampire vibe going on for them because they were so old and like they're just like.

1:38:24 M kind of a Louis kind of situation. Yeah, and I'm just like, make me happy. I've lost sexual interest in my husband, you know, so I meant that's mine. Kenny. Y'all are sorry. It is a binary y'all are wrong. There's only one answer this week, and the answer is general grievous and his medical droid ate for d droid. Okay, I sick corrected, and I am proud to be corrected, thank you. Yeah. Yeah, eight four D is there to be like, yes, please tell me all the ways that I'm a stupid little bit.

1:39:09 So are you saying that the droid has some kind of humiliation king, I think. So he's a brady bottom with the humiliation. Okay, So now I'm wondering how close he would be to somebody like data, as in, are you fully functional? I'm sorry, I don't start sexualizing that droid. We're going to bring that into Uh. He is a medical droid. Therefore, if the medical droid has to fulfillate full range of medical behaviors, then I think the answer is yes. Well what about grievus? Well, and perhaps we should queer our understanding of sex here general queer vers.

1:39:57 I think that that fits in general. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, I'm I go with yeah, well until his untimely demise. Also, I gotta say the actor that plays that Earth's isn't it No, it's David Accord, who is basically Matthew Wood and David Accord work in the sound department of the Clone Wars. And. Whenever you watch the behind the scenes stuff, it's always those two that are talking about like some sound effects and development of that. And so they were like, who is grievous as number two? Matthew Wood's number two because matthew Wood plays General Gravis. Yeah, and then David Accord made the extremely smart call patterning a four D after nineteen sixties nineteen seventies actor Paul Lynde, famously sener Pollywood Squares and also the uncle from The Witch.

1:40:56 Yeah that makes sense, that makes sense. Okay. The reason I was picking up Tom Kenny is because he voiced Nadar. Yes, when he wasn't being SpongeBob, he was doing this. And then pit Fisto is voiced by Phil Lamar, who also voiced you got a hand up. I'm gonna respond to hand up? Did you want me to finish? Uh? Mace Windu from the Star Wars, Colne Wars. Uh, try Hermes Conrad from Futurama. Yeah, Stewart from Justice League. Yes, we were talking about this too. He also I was watching I watched all the Superstore and he just shows up in Superstore and I was like, oh, Hi, Hi buddy for like a single us MAD.

1:41:46 I was first familiar with him from Mad TV for several seasons where he was a main cast member, and so every time I see him pop up on something, I was just like, you're a main cast member on Mad TV. Let's let you be a movie star. Joy a joint. If I can just point out one other thing here, absolutely you can, please. I would really like to give a nod to Kevin Kiner, who was the composer for the episode, because at one point he ends up introducing a quasi imperial on Almost Mars by host music cue, so you can tell what is being implied. But yeah, it just made my musician brain very very happy.

1:42:32 Wait can you expand on that, like the implication versus like what like what what I was going for? Well, given that, let's say, oh no, I'm so sorry that is from the episode of bombad Jedi apologies because I've got notes on. All three of them. Oh my god. Yeah, but I think. But I also actually, as you were saying that, I picked up on the same thing. I mean, but also just in general amusing and this is pretty extraordinary, especially like this whole arc, I felt very thrilling to me. So I really have to hand it to the people who do the music for the animated series, rebels bad Batch.

1:43:15 This visions. I mean, really, it's I mean, we. Say this all the time, and I'm sure you have a similar kind of perspective of we think animation is severely underappreciated. We're saying it for years, we even up. Front, like I feel this way when it comes up with a lot of like there are a lot of Star Wars shows happening where I'm like, I don't need this to be live action because I had a perfect thing in my animated shell, and like I like to Soka live action. But I also I would have watched so many more stories with an Ashley Exstina Soka like forever, you know, and I would like to we'll have more of that. I just this kind of I don't know, it feels frustrating that we would still see animation as being solely the realm of for children, or even the very fact that something for children would be bad, you know, and all so well.

1:44:15 What you're talking about as a conflict that's been happening between the public, animators and studios since the nineteen thirties, Oh my gosh. And fact, in nineteen thirty eight, the producer of Warner Brothers cartoons, Leon Slessinger, was quoted in an article saying, oh, yeah, we totally know that animation is primarily for children. News flash, honey, it was actually meant for general audiences, which is why so much of animation from that era, and at least until we hit television, was really meant to appeal to not just littles, but everybody who was there. Once we got more of a diversification as far as the development of television, then we start seeing things that are produced specifically for children, starting with the cartoon Crusader Rabbit, which was on the Dumont Network.

1:45:13 Wow, I've never even heard of this. We can talk at length, I'm. Sure, doctor knowl We have got to bring you back when we get to Star Trek, the animated series, and. Oh please do I would love to. Oh my gosh, I'm here for it. Yeah. How interesting. Gosh. Well, this is Clonor's extraordinary, extraordinary stuff, and that's very interesting. As fascinating as this discussion is, I'm sorry, I've got to bring down the hammer. Yeah he does, because we've been having a lovely, amicable, nuanced discussion about how uh, all of these things are so complicated and even this beautiful the U with him Plato's step Children is so complicated, and the ethics within Layer of Grievous can also be complicated about how we combat fascism. But at the end of the day, art's either good or bad.

1:46:13 It's a binary. It's a binary everything. There is no spectrum, only binary good bad. And that's why it's time for us to answer the question which is better Star Trek or Star Wars by ranking both Star Trek the original series Plato's step Children versus the Layer of Grievous from a zero to ten scale. Right, Sorry, I don't make the rules. Actually you do make the rules. I don't make the rules. I'm an ally and I don't make the rules. Comes down from above. Someone decided, yeah, yes I will.

1:46:55 I will kick things off. You're going to go first. It's okay, yeah, shape a show, shape a show, show show. I'm going to give Layer of Grievous a six. Okay, So it was pretty good. Pretty good for a reference. We can get as granular as we want journal so we've got some that are like six point three five. Craves is pretty good. It's pretty fun. Uh. There were flashes of greatness, but ultimately finding it difficult to remember a lot of things from this episode outside of the broad strokes fascinating.

1:47:40 Do you want me to go? Do you want to go last? Gum? Yes, yeah, it's I find that it's helpful to go first for the starship it and lasts for this. So I'm going to give it higher than that for certain and I'll mena tell you, I'm going to talk myself into it because this episode has what I find to be very exciting, which is spookiness. I found it to be a true thriller. I like creep creepy Crowley spider walking, creep of Crowley spider walking. I genuinely these are things I enjoy. I also enjoy the interesting complexity of the conversations around power and agency. So I'm going to give it a sup of wain three wah.

1:48:27 You know you bring up the spooky And I don't know if you're aware of this, but there was a Halloween album released that is General Grivos talking to trigger treaders. It's amazing. I love it. I picked it up. God knows where god knows how long ago. But I have this MP three and it is literally called Star Wars Halloween. So if y'all are interested, I would be more than happy to share. Yes, please, oh my gosh, yes, please, yes, please, oh my gosh, yes, oh my god, thank you. You're welcome.

1:49:09 See this is what you get for getting a died in the Wold professional nerd on your show. Incredible. This is the best. The rest of our friends that come on podcast, yeah, not as good. They really phone it in. They don't listen to our past episode even. Whenever they do, and they're just like nice and smart. I'm like, no, sorry, you're dumb. You don't give me general grievous Halloween episode songs? What would you sound effects? But oh I love that, I would say for layer of grievous, and I'm trying to consider it on its own merits and not as the conclusion of a three episode art right, all right, I would say as a standalone episode, it's probably about a six or seven.

1:50:00 Just say it, six point five, just going just going right down the middle, six point eight. You do you truly do love to see it. You can feel it in your heart, you know. Well, the one thing that really disappointed me is that we didn't get to see Fisto smile. I don't know if it's because the Jedi dental plan has fallen off somewhere or just what's going on, but I miss that smile that we got in Tartakovski. Oh yeah, oh yeah, cut down on that dental plan that Palpatine. Yeah, of course, yeah. I do wonder. I do wonder, like what's happening to all the dentists as they're out. Well, because mouth bones are no longer considered necessary. They are a luxury luxury bone, a luxury bone, luxury mouthbones.

1:50:49 Speaking of luxury bones, Plano step Children. Oh boy, I. Think I'm going to think this a five point eight Oh my gosh, m As, these are the voyages. I don't know if you know this, but I keep going back to that wonderfully wonderfully establishes I'm gonna cut this out. That's gonna be I'm gonna look so smart, so smart. It looks so smart. Yep, yeah, Kenny so smart. He just like brought this up immediately.

1:51:35 As these of the voyage of season three has brought up. In regards to Plato step Children, there are a fair amount of tropes at play Landing Party separated from ship ship in trouble, Landing Party must save themselves and at the same time save the Enterprise. Other episodes that have covered very similar telecon control issues include where No Man has gone before, the second Pilot who mourns for Adonais and Return to Tomorrow also remove godlike and worship, and we also saw the story device in the Square of Got This cat Spot and Gamesters of Triscut. It's not an original episode. What they're bringing to it is pretty much just isn't this like really bad? And whenever it gets into those isn't that really bad stuff, it just feels tired and repetitive. Alexander is the shining example, and I wish that he was on a different episode that was allowed to have a more complex character that was not beholden to being controlled and just was able to let his acting muscles sing because he was an incredible character.

1:52:46 But other than that's a pretty sleepy episode. Wow ah Okay. Sometimes sometimes sometimes we do what do we call it speedy spy ringkings, And sometimes I can be like I can understand, I can like recognize certain elements and stuff and I can be like, I know that this deserved not in this case, a seven, but I'm still gonna give it it too because of like overt racism that wasn't good at verth you know what I mean. Like, but I think I'm just going to spite rank this one just because I just truly felt deeply uncomfortable and it didn't feel orf it. So I'm going to give it like a three point six.

1:53:27 Asthma, your spite ranking is still so high, and I. It's for Alexander. Alexander great character. Yeah, I just I just I yeah, it's tired in a way that actually felt. Cruel. I don't know. Did you know the BBC wouldn't even air this one because they were like, it's extended torture and sadism. It just felt a certain point like I was like, you can you can do this without a feeling without it dragging out for so long even though it has real moments. I think that could be that are interesting. IM spite ranking it good?

1:54:07 You love to see it, doctor All. One episode that was missed in your list is Charlie X. Yeah, Charlie X a great I'm gonna give this an eight simply on the basis of Michael Dunn's performance, because although Alexander was certainly being controlled as a puppet, he never lost sense of self mm hmm, not once beautiful. And while yes Harman and not Parman I'm sorry, what was her name? Felonia, Celia, Lana.

1:54:48 Okay. Although they were presented as main characters, it wasn't about them. Ultimately, it was about the survival of this yes character in a society that did not value him except as well a stepping stool mm hmmm, sometimes quite literally. So for me, on the strength of that, I'm going to give it a night cool. I'd love to see it. You do, you do love to see it, which means if my math is correct, because the math mathing, the math let me input this this.

1:55:37 I was gonna say, do you have an advocus you're working here or what are we dealing? Uh? If this is to be believed, oh my god, Well, because it looks like the spreadsheet malfunctioned at some point, and so I happened to add justice formulas here. But I'm thinking that we're I'm thinking that we're back on track. It's just if it if it's to be believed, it's just so clean, because my ranking of Plato step children was a five point eight and average together Plato step children with doctor Knowles eight aspens three point six, and my five point eight brings the ranking two five point eight versus layer of grievous is six point seven, which means aspen Star Wars, when's the week?

1:56:25 Yes? Yeah, right, because art is binary, and clearly Star Wars is better than Star Trek a. Guess like poetry, So if they rhyd. It's so silly. We obviously both love both. I was gonna say, every time you say art is a binary, I die a little inside. But I also understand that that's the central premise of this podcast. We have who am I to question? Listen, we have to stand behind something, Yeah, I. Usually stand in front of things that that works better I can see better. Yeah, well, we we're just bad. People, not a bit of it. But speaking of bad people being on the front lines. People that want to get early and extended episodes of this podcast can go right over to patreon dot com slash Trek Wars pod you for five dollars a month.

1:57:15 Like I said, you can get early versions of these episodes and extended versions of these episodes. I'll be cutting this together and dropping us on the Patreon bat pretty darn soon. I'm pretty pleased with that, and you two could join the fine offices of fine folks such as Timbochslsa, Emily Brice Love, Heidi Rogers, Kevin Miller, Yes, Austin, Aaron Signs, Arizona Mark and lastly, but certainly not leastly, Jolty Partner, who composed our wonderful I starship at theme song. Our main and ending theme was composed by mister toustin Elfesso, where if you would like to get more of his music, you can go to these show notes and click on the link below. Additionally, if you don't want to participate in any form of social media at all, why not shoot us any email track wars pod at email dot com, which I believe doctor nol Uh you shot us an email or we shot you an email. We connected quite quickly and Arnett was this was a dare I say it?

1:58:12 I'm gonna dare pretty darn. Good up fire fire, fun fire. Yes, what is? We would love for you to plug everything anything that you are doing, all of it, your books, your. Stuff, your streams, your kids. Yeah, your kids, your children. Your address, your social security. While I appreciate the requests for all of that information, I will say that you can find me over on blue Sky at t l nole. That's t l k n o e l l dot b sky dot social And as they were alluding to, I am one half of Silent Film Fridays, which airs on Twitch at seven pm Eastern on Friday evenings and then is available on video on demand not only for free on Patreon, but also on Twitch for the following seven days. As far as Silent Film Friday goes, Silent Film Friday is where the films are silent and the hosts are not. Each week we take on a different silent film and we go everywhere. From a lot of European cinema, We've got a lot of American cinema, of course, And the fact of the matter is silent film is usually considered boring.

1:59:40 But may I just tell you my Oh, okay, you know are going to have to have a chat. Because I was thinking about because some of those movies do feel like whenever I am like, uh, I gotta watch Castle Blanca because I'm a completist. And then I watched Cosa Blanca and I'm like, this. Movie's incredible, extraordinary, right, but. It has the aesthetic value of looking like homework because it's black and white. Similarly, I was thinking about you talking about Metropolism, where I watched that film within the last five years for the very first time, and I do find silent film a very hard thing to get into.

2:00:21 And I was just like Metropolis is. I was amazed, I was floored. It was an extraordinary watch that plays just as well now than it did back then. It's extraordinary. Well, what we do with silent film is first off, because a lot of silent film was packaged for contemporary audiences with some kind of a soundtrack for home video. That means that soundtrack is usually not in the public domain. But all silent film produced before nineteen twenty eight, excuse me, before nineteen twenty nine, it's all in the public And weekly my daughter and I get together, we stream a film and those who tune in not only have an opportunity to comment on the film while we are watching it together, but they also get a little entertainment, a little commentary, and a fair amount of education. I mean I am a film scholar. Yeah, among all things. So yeah, we can be seen, like I said, Friday nights, seven pm Eastern at Twitch dot tv Forward Slash a t K forty two games. And I also do put up advertisements for our silent film Friday viewings over on Blue Sky.

2:01:50 So join us, won't you. Ah, that's so exciting. I also have a friend who's definitely in a sil of films, and I'm going to tell her all about that. Oh you really should. The one that we watched last week was called The Patsy and it was an hour and fifteen minutes of I'm really not the favorite child the movie, and it was a comedy. I love it. No, don't get don't don't, don't get too fussed about it. This next week we are going to be watching another comedy from nineteen fourteen, this time called Tilly's Punctured Romance, which stars Marie Dressler, Charlie Chaplin and maybe Norman.

2:02:35 Incredible. That's so exciting. I love what we get to do. And given that I'm on sabbatical this year so I can write my book, rather so I can finish my book, I've already got about three quarters of it in the bag. Yeah, this is what I am doing in lieu of being in a classroom for the next Academy. Beautiful doctor Nol, thank you so much for coming on our little podcast. It has been an absolute pleasure. Thanks for having me. I can hardly wait for the next time. Yeah. Yes, oh my god, Yeah, we're gonna We're gonna be like please please come back and bring all your knowledge Aspen. Yes, I love you. Oh, I love you.

2:03:16 Kenny and listeners, we love you or you thank you so much for listening. Live long and prosper and may the Force be with you.