Return of the Jedi Special Edition vs. Return to Tomorrow
This week, "Risk is our business!"
Aspen loves the ending changes of Return of the Jedi. Kenny points out this week's human propaganda of Return to Tomorrow. We talk about being complicit in empire (both being residents of the U.S. and of the...
This week, "Risk is our business!"
Aspen loves the ending changes of Return of the Jedi. Kenny points out this week's human propaganda of Return to Tomorrow. We talk about being complicit in empire (both being residents of the U.S. and of the Empire). And Kenny talks about Lucas messing with the Special Edition leading to "this is not my Star Wars."
And Kenny makes Aspen cry by repeating a point she made in an earlier episode.
_________________
Get early, extended episodes on our Patreon at https://www.patreon.com/trekwarspod
Theme by Tosin Awofeso
Social Media:
https://www.instagram.com/trekwarspod
https://bsky.app/profile/trekwarspod.bsky.social
Want to ask us questions? Email us at trekwarspod@gmail.com .
And leave us a review! https://bit.ly/leave-a-review-trek-wars
0:26 Welcome to the Track Wars podcast, the Internet's primary source for all things Star Trek Star Wars comparison related, because that's the whole heck conceit of our freaking podcast. Dude, I am Kenny Madison, the Star Trek contingent of this podcast, and with me as per always is dude. Oh my god, dude, Yeah, dude, dude, bro, yeah, dude. Brow Is that like our podcast? Dude? Usually I nail these intros, but today apparently I phone to get in. You're not phone. No, I'm gonna I'm going to take a mulligan. I'm going to take a mulligan. Let me reintroduce the podcast. I really don't want you to. I want you to. I love it so much. Well, if someone is starting with our episode, I want it to be a little bit more professional, because this is a podcast where we go through both Star Trek and Star Wars in chronological release order, comparing and contrasting both franchises. What the heck they have to say politically, philosophically, sociologically, dare I say, religiously and romantically starship Ye, all of those things, fantastically. Speaking of fantastically, Today we are covering Return of the Jedi Special Edition versus Return to Tomorrow.
1:41 Return of the Jedi Special Edition of course being our Star Wars contingent, and Return Tomorrow from season two Star Trek the original series, Aspen, Yeah, and Return of the Jedi being our specialized versions. Since we have done Return of the Jedi before, it maybe just said this and I wasn't listening. We have done Return of the Jedi before, but it was the original versions as opposed to the newer versions. That is the one, Aspen. That is absolutely correct, and I'm so glad, thank you that you said that. Thank you so much. Shall we go into the synopsis For folks that are playing the home game edition of Trek Wars, they've gotten their boards out, they're putting the pieces there, they are not watching along, okay, because that's not that is the home edition to you. That is to me as opposed to Aspen, Yeah, which is that the home edition would mean they are watching along with us. So the people who are not the people who are deciding not to engage. Sure, And I will start with the synopsis for Returned to Tomorrow, first aired February ninth, nineteen sixty eight.
2:45 Director Ralph Senensky and credited writer of John Kingsbridge, with a rather story by John Kingsbridge written by Gene Roddenberry. John Kingsbridge being a pseudonym for John T. Dugan, and the synopsis comes from Stephen k Sure from tbke Previews. Here we Go Uh, first published February nine, nineteen sixty eight. Here we Go a weird and far out plot even for this series, but it's quite an interesting one. Summoned to a planet much like Earth, the Enterprise finds a highly advanced civilization that destroyed itself two billion years ago whatever. A few of its brain survived, and now they want to borrow a few human bodies to launched. Extremely worthwhile Project Kirk makes the initial and risky body alone, and naturally complications ensue. Although it is all a bit confusing, you'll want to stay with it and watch both Captain Kirk and mister Spock die.
3:38 That's returned it tomorrow synopsis that they put in the newspaper. Ah, yes, yes, indeed, it's good to get a preview of what the heck of your opinion is of this episode without you having to say a ward that's not true. Sorry, I actually really, really loved it, Actually fucking loved that this episode. I wanted to be on the record. No, I mostly was just like distracted, avite, trying to find what I wanted to read. Excellent, Since of course we've already given a synopsis of Return of the Jedi, this is of course specific to the special editions, and so I figure I found actually a Roger Ebert review from nineteen ninety seven.
4:23 I'm just going to pull out a couple of specific pieces because I'm not going to read the whole thing. Yeah, it was first release March seventh, nineteen ninety seven. Yep. And so this review is from March fourteenth, nineteen ninety seven. Here's his thought. I'm gonna end with I'm going to kind of pull this out, and there's a last paragraph. I'm going to just kind of end with with he said, if I had to choose, I would say this is the least of the Star Wars films. It lacks the startling originality of the first two. It's more concerned with loos end's and final resolutions. It was the correct decision for George Lucas to end with a trilogy and then move to another point in time for the continuation of the saga, because he's already starting to think of that's going to come next, because we're building up to the next trilogies that are coming. You've been in, Roger Ebert. Roger Ebert. Well, also because art doesn't exist in a vacuum, but E've been Roger Ebert, the most famous film critic period is taken with the meta narrative that Lucas is building George Lucas to end with a trilogy, when this has a different director entirely, it's Cosden and Lucas writing the screenplays. So Wild Wild, You're absolutely right. And then he kind of says, to return to these characters a fourth time, we destroy them at the structure of the story and turn it simply into a series one an interesting perspective, talking about inspired things. He talks about extended sequences. But I'll just finish with the last paragraph, which is, at the end, what are we left with? Marvelous sites, the two Death Stars, the lumbering war machines on the snow planet, space warfare, the Desert Monster,
5:54 buccaneering action, marvelous sounds, the voices of Darth Vader Jaba in the chirpy Little R two D two and an idea the force that encompassing everything may perhaps encompass nothing and conceal another level above or beneath. I'm guessing that will be the subject of the next trilogy, Medic Laurians. Yeah, I was just thinking this was reading that, and he was going, oh, actually it's pretty Laurence Clients. Anyway, that's a that's my we know what was happening in the Return of the Jedi. Yeah, the Jedi come back. The Jedi come back. Yeah, they rescue they rescue Han from jaba Uh and then they're like all of the Jedi. The Jedi has gone on like a weekend retreat to Bakersfield, and now they're back home and Luke has to clean up before the parents get back, right, He's just like, oh no, there's so many cops out. Oh man, they broke a vase.
6:57 So yeah, imagine Jenny, a really great eighties film if that were actually what it was just like. But also, yes, you're right, director was Oh no, it's how do you pronounce his name? Richard Mark can Richard Mark wand Mark Wand oh it's so funny. I've never said his name out loud. Yes, Richard Mark Wand and of course Lawrence Cosden and George Lucas writing the screenplays because of George Lucas being like, perhaps I should have a little bit more say in this film. We've talked about that the last time of him being more like part of the process, more versus Empire. Yes, Richard Mark Wand just a little bit of brief background was a British director who really wasn't that well known, had made some small movies. The very fact, the very fact that I just said never said his name out loud maybe on this podcast, but forgotten, like when that's a film not directed by George Lucas, but in our minds were just like George Lucas, much like Roger Ebert. Yeah, and this is where this is the one where Lucas I didn't do my research in terms of reading about the process.
8:13 But also I believe that we've litigated it on the previous episode of Return of the Jedi but where Empire Strikes Back, and we talked about this on our previous episode with the Empire Strikes Back special edition, and Lucas was unhappy with how Empire turned out, and I think still to this day he's like Empire is his least favorite, and so return to the Jedi. Like we said in our first episode, episode four, return to the Jedi is a return to form. Yes, it's a return to find Yeah, it's a return to form. In his mind, he's a little bit more hands on. I don't recall exactly. I believe he's directing some things, or at least people are like, yeah, he's basically shadow directing. Yeah, because he wants to, sir, sir, calm down. If I had a time machine and someone was like, you can go back in time do one thing in this time, I would not do what you would expect. I'd go back to nineteen eighty three, nineteen eighty two, and I'd be like, can you calm the fuck down? Yeah, I'd say, that's George Lucas and when I come back. Also, at this time, Lucas is tired of Star Wars. Oh well, maybe he needed to calm the fuck up.
9:39 I don't know. He's on the record of being like, I'm I'm done now. He was going through If he wasn't going through a divorce, he was about to get a divorce. Things he had, he was building the infrastructure for lucasfilm and starting to aggregate his power. Uh, and Empire Strikes Back was a self financed movie for the most part, and so he's just very tired of making these big honkin movies Hong Kong, and so he's like, Return of the Jedi at least in nineteen eighty three, I'm about to piece out, which is interesting because you can you can feel all of those things. You can feel the we gotta wrap this up kind of energy sometimes. Roger Eberts said, yeah, all those loose ends originally, well, I mean, of course, he was making all of this stuff up as he went along. There is another at least according to interviews within Secret History of Star Wars. Whenever I read it the first time, episode like the sequel trilogy, was going to be about looking for that mythical other somewhere else in the gallaty Okay, and it was not going to be Leah.
10:56 But then Return of the Jedi came around. He was like, I'm not doing this anymore. We're just gonna make it late. Yeah, it's Ezra Bridger. Yeah literally, yeah, cant in dearest. There are others out there. There's so many others. There's actually a few some. Now, the Jedi are all a bit extinct, except for like these fifty two one hundred that are over here off screen. Yeah, just a couple, just a few. There's a whole bunch of Jedi that could just like arise. Yeah, but they're not bucking skywalkers. I guess no, I yeah, that makes sense. You're right, you can feel it a little bit.
11:39 I obviously Return of the Jedi is it film, my love. I've watched this movie so many times, just like I was experiencing that in our like rewatch of these as special editions. Every single time it's done the like and then it gets goes dad, I am so happy. I'm so fucking Horror movies should start like a Star Wars or yeah, or they should have they should have some association with like the some fun thing to happen with the the production company and the music or something to kind of play around with it.
12:20 God, I love it. Yeah, there's just like such a kind of like a push and a joy to its. Here's why it's huge. Here's here's why the intro Star Wars is great. Okay, tell me as opposed to like, because you're talking about doing like fun things with the production company logos which lic and Raiders Lincoln Raiders. When it starts with like, it's like Paramount and then it becomes the Mountain. That's great because we briefly talked about this in our Patreon which you can listen to a patreon dot com slash track Corse pod. I'm thinking of you can Yes, I was thinking about Aquamanna the Lost Kingdom gross, I know, uh a bad, but the war not thinking about it. I'm probably gonna keep thinking about it. The Warner Brothers, like the Warner Brothers, loves to play with their logos and whatnot, make cool and make them different. Star Wars plays with it.
13:07 Here's why the Star Wars intro is one of the greatest. Has the twentieth century Fox logo. It's great. And then usually movies like kind of Guide You in at least Circle nineteen eighty three, they play their opening credits, Ah, yes, no, no, not this one. No, you get the Lucasfilm Limited logo and then silence and then the Chiron a long time ago in a galaxy far far away. True. Then it fades down. So now the audience's tense because they're going what is happening there because they're playing with sound. They're playing with sound. The sound has dropped out, and now we are just staring at a black screen. And then, instead of a slow guide back, blam Star Wars and it immediate breaks the tension.
14:01 And you weren't just confronted with joy because you were just like, oh, big Star Wark, you are guiding into this wonderful tension. Yeah, immediately told expect this. This is a fairy tale, okay, and then blam unless unless it's Rogue One, which is like, so fucking good because it's a war movie. Dude, Oh it's a war movie. Did you know that? Maybe everyone dies and that's what makes it cool. What's so good about Rogue One is like, there's never been a Star Wars movie that was about war, never mind the fact that the Ewoks are quite almost literal analogs for our perception of the Vietcong. What did I What did I text you?
14:45 I was like going through hold on, Oh I was I was talking about like, I was very grumpy. We don't have to get into it, but I was grumpy about how Rise of Skywalker disrespects not just the preceding movies, but also with this film because it doesn't matter that like the Emperor knew what was going to happen, that he plans it all and I'll just like gru but I wrote you like that he knew it. It's like the power of this community and this friendship and this courage and kindness and risking your life even though you could die for a better future. And then that's what actually like wins. It doesn't matter. So the fact that he would continue on is so insulting. But then I came back and I was like, friendshipless, courageless kindness plus the Vietcong. It's just like right, Skywalker.
15:37 A similar movie to Return of the Jedi and This sen is that both are course correction movies that are trying to get back to something else right, and also both of them being like the Emperor's mind at all, which is actually funny that I think. That's actually why I thought that that's funny. That's ha ha funny. Thank you for my solationous girl. Yes, yes, yes you've added it. Little freak Selacious crumb Slaicious by Crumb di oh and Papu Frick my little Freaks so good. Yeah, it's all hall funny, like a clown like a silicious gum. I was gonna say, you distracted me. I'm having such a good time. Oh that's I think why I actually made that connection because you had mentioned that before, and we had talked about how this is a course correction for Empire, while uh, Rises Skywalker is a course correction for Last Jedi. That's what makes it all the more ironic to me that Rise of Skywalker is so uh such a shame given Return of the Jedi. It also Rises of Skywalker is you can tell that it's operating a completely different paradigm as we're supposed to return to the Jedi. Where, yes, Return of the Jedi they were able to course correct based off
17:10 of Empire strikes Back came out, and then the filmmakers were able to sit down and be like, let's figure out what works what doesn't, or able to create something that, granted we do not have the perspective of to you and me, this thing feels fully formed. The trilogy can seem like one mass, and so it feels a lot more organic as opposed to Rise of Skywalker, which I'm pretty sure Abrams had like eighteen months to do. Yeah, maybe two years. I Well, no, it's no. I think it was eighteen months when did Colin Because Colin to Borrow and his writing partner Derek Connolly did a script that is so much much better than what we got.
18:03 Was a great no, but it was better than what we got and still probably would have been a disappointment as supposed to the calamity that Rise of Skywalker was. But also, like I do not like Rise of Skywalker, but also like Abrams was doing an almost impossible job of having to balance I'm sure Disney dictates from on high fan expectations and then also having to wrangle a Gargageman production, So like, like, dude, whatever, it's not necessarily his fault. Yeah, And we're not here to talk about Rices of Skywalker. We're not to talk about Return to the Jedi and Return to Tomorrow and return to Tomorrow, returns, returns, so many returns. That's the thematic connections that I found in these two episodes, that both of them return, both of them are coming on back a quick sort of you know, like this is our first impressions, since we are talking about the special editions versus just Return of the Jedi in general, I will be very picky about scenes, because I've been picky the whole time about like what I like, what I don't like, And I would say probably the way to boil it down is I love the change of the end of the the of this film.
19:40 It changes the music that it's a different it's a different music, and in fact, I prefer it the end of this film greatly to the original. This feels like more of an ending to the trilogy. Yes, as opposed to what we originally got with Yup Nub. It's yub nub. It's yup nub. It is the song is called Yeap nab and it's just them going yep dap, and it's just that. And I think I should I should actually look up what the piece of music is called, because it is glorious and beautiful. But it's yeah, it's victory celebration, like it's the end the the u Wak celebration. But I think I might have a specific name.
20:22 But not only that is it's you know, it's also then it expands out to the galaxy. So you see Naboo and you see Corussant, and you see people celebrating everywhere. You talk about Naboo. None in the ninety seven special edition. It's adding in two thousand and four the Gungans going we suf Free. Yep, you do kind of have to admire George Lucas and being like, you don't like this idea, we're gonna put this in retort of the CHET. I know you didn't like Hayden christians acting. He's in retort of the CHET. I now also Hayden Christensen being the first ghost. I now, at this point in time, I'm fine with it. When I was younger and I like, watched like a special edition, hated it, hated it. But now I'm fine. I'm fine with it. No though I say that, oh, I might take it back, because you're right, it doesn't make sense because I think there is this idea of who he could what he could have looked like, who he could have grown to be. And he was that age when he died, so being an older man does make more sense. It's not like they replaced Obi Wan with you McGregor, So okay, I take that back. I think I just am on a Hayden Christiansen deserves better kick. He does. He also had an impossible job that we'll get into right whenever we talk about episodes two and three.
21:48 So, and I'll tell you this, it's because I'm a deeply feeling person. Don't know if you know that about me? What I am? Starry? Why mothers fucker got some feelings? What are you to do? What was the last thing that you cried at? Oh? Oh god? Wait wait we were talking about Madam web again on the pageon. This was not the last thing I cried out, But I do just want to say that when she does like basically meet her mom, like in this memory, I did cry. He did cry so much? What was the last thing I cried at? I'm like, really, it's I mean, but I'm not sure that it's going to get better than you cried daring. Madam Webb genuinely recently cried. I did recently cry. I just can't remember what.
22:45 I don't think you answered my question correctly. I've cried a Richard of the Jedi lost Nime. So when I was younger, and I saw that for the first time, like when I come to the end of long books or book series or you know, anything that affects me strongly, And this is this is hours of like being with people. I cared so much about in the story. It's really hard. An ending is really hard, and I think the original one does not quite It makes me feel like there's no air in my chest, like there's not enough, and it makes me feel too sad and lonely. But the new ending makes me feel like it's they're part of something, They're connected. It is it was worth it in the end, and the music really helps with that. So but now what's so interesting is maybe now the Yebnab ending might feel even better because we're turning to the JAREDI is not the end anymore because the Force Awakens happened, But it's still the end of that story, sure, Like it doesn't just because I mean, obviously we have one wars and rebellions, only to see the same things happen again. You know, this is sort of like the March of history.
24:00 Litigate my disappointments in the Force Awakens whenever we get there, although that movie kind of nailed it, uh in retrospect, because I was like, when, so the Nazis just never went away? I know, I was like, that's impossible. So to finish out, my love for the ending changes is matched only by my deep, deep hatred for the changes to the Max Rebo band in Java's Palace, and interesting you think that those are distracting? Did I say that? I was going to just say the fucking worst thing I've ever seen in my life? Interesting? Interesting? So I think that literally that kind of balance pulls you out of the movie. I would say, big weird, uh, big weird lips in my face from the singer. That's not size noodles but the other one. But you get you get you get more bub or maybe this noodles. You get more bub with Fet though, Do I get more Bob? Yeah, there's more Buba Fat.
25:07 I get where I just have to say, I love that is just just dispatched like a clown because you know what, he doesn't matter. Bubba FET's nothing. It's a care Look. I know, I know. I like to have rich philosophical discussions about what these things are trying to say to us on a dare I say, on a spiritual level. But at the same time, Bubba FET's a clown. Who cares? Bubba Fet He's just a guy. He's just a tea man. He's just a He's a man with a tea. He just got a little tea helmet. And you're like, whoa a tea cool badass, He's got jetpack badass. And then literally literally he's standing on that sand ship thing and a block han solo, just Boba Fet and then accidentally hits into a sarlac pit. Apparently, allegedly, George Lucas had considered having a scene of Boba Fet climbing out of the sarlac fit. Calm down, Calm down, George. Anyway, So that's my reflection, that's my that's my hot take on the Return of the Jedi special editions. Okay, uh, Return of the Jedi a good film, true
26:38 great film. Yes, yeah, uh? Ask men. Let me ask you the question that I ask you every week except for the weeks that I don't AskMen. Do you remember this episode of Star Trek. I've never seen this episode of Star Trek? Which thing? Love cool? I liked it. I loved it. I liked it. I loved it. I liked it. Hey, hey, look at me, look at me. I'm the podcast host. Now I loved it. I don't know. Maybe it's because you like sargon and salsa and kind of and well, okay, I did. However, halfway through yell out wonder Woman nineteen eighty four, because you know, it's like, what is that? What are the ethics of being in people's bodies and kissing without their consent? Those bodies consent? Wonder Woman nineteen eighty four a good movie. I also think so people might disagree, but I will say this is a deeply problematic aspect of it. Yea, I think is actually should be considered more. We're sorry, litigate the great movie that is Wonder Woman nineteen eighty four. Sorry, I loved this movie. I loved this film and oh god, Jesus, I loved this
28:10 movie, film, TV show, Here we Go. It was great. I don't know if it's like because the last few have been fine or reprehensible to me, I'm not sure. And there was something about this that was just so interesting and clear and straightforward in its approach, beautiful characterization, interesting motivations, Leonard Nimoy getting to have so much fun. I can feel this script being like, this is going to be fun for the actors. Although well, yeah, we'll get into it more after we talk about our first impressions. Kenny, Yeah, boss, do you remember the first time you saw this episode? I'm the slightest no, it's probably in high school.
29:00 Oh yeah, because that's whenever I watched the original series for the first time. Wow, what a braggart, eggs Braggart. Well, the wild thing about my my journey with Star Trek is that I would whenever I would use the bathroom, I haven't, sorry, whenever i'd use the bathroom, I had there's a literal Star Trek Encyclopedia aspen mm hmmm. And I would just not just sit in the bathroom, but also like just elsewhere, and I would just read the Star Trek Encyclopaedia. Wait, sorry, you take that?
29:40 Can you can you describe this process? Would do? Would you where? Would you read this? Would would you take it out of the bathroom and then take it back to the bathroom? Or did you just stay in the bathroom? I wouldn't, I mean because it takes it take a while. Oh, it would take a while. That's so funny. Interesting, that's so funny. Other I don't. I'm so I was take people so long to poop. It does not take me a long time. That's because you're a good person. And I would just read the Star Trek Encyclopedia. And so it's this weird thing where I was probably familiar with episodes before I even watched them. M And we're starting to get into that territory of Star Trek episodes that just I liberally used the word iconic for the first season and a half because so much of it was so gangbusters. Yeah. Now we're getting out out of that gene Coon territory and which I was never really cognizant of, and we're starting to get into a whole bunch of episodes that are just like okay mm hmm, yeah, and it could I wonder if and this is this is one of those episodes and what is so interesting? So would you put the book back? Yeah, of course I would like where was the book on the bookshelf? There's bookshelf in the bathroom? No, oh, you take it with you into the bathroom. Yeah, I say yes, thank you, because I would just be looking at it all the
31:11 time. That in Star Trek magazine, what was the decorations like the bathroom? It was orange wallpaper, like a little noleum floor. There was ah for a while, there was just a hole like a cutting the drywall, a rectangle. I don't know why, and it was just never fixed. That's why all the Star Wars Star Trek Porn was hidden. Yes, speaking of Star Trek Porn. Oh what yes, well we we have possibly the most classic speech in all of Star Trek. Oh so you know how okay, here we go? Oh god, sorry, I just you know, when we're talking about years earlier, I and like certain things that I just like wasn't maybe was like during the Patreon part, I was thinking about, like when the years of things that happened in the significance. It only occurred to me in this episode when he was giving this iconic jfk asque speech that I was like, this is nineteen sixty eight, a literal year before we went to the Moon. Of course, of course, and it just oh, I might have actually cried at the speech. I think I started to cry because I started to think about that, and I started to think about hope, which is they have done what the speech is? The risk is
32:45 our business speech in Return to Tomorrow is Star Trek in a monologue? Yeah, the risk is our business and a risky business. Yeah. And it's weird because he put sunglasses on and dances out afterwards. It cuts the tension. It's so out of character. But I love that speech. It's a perfect speech. And also and also the crew of the Enterprise have done so much more dangerous things. I know, but I know, but this is the moment. This is the year before the Apollo missions, yeah, or the big Apollo mission. None of them were big. Only Apollo eleven was big. All the missions. Yeah, I mean, it's it's true, it is a funny place for it to be, but I think maybe there is something. Yeah, they've done many, many more risky things, but there is something to be said about like letting aliens inhabit your body. There's a certain type of a real visceral bodily fear around that. So I mean not to not to like litigate too much because I think I think you're right, but kind of in that way, I it's it is kind of fascinating.
34:15 Yeah, anyway, yeah, it's it's it's got I think it's has it has oh bad. The feeling I was getting watching this was the way that I want Star Trek to be. If the last episode was Star Trek at its worst, this to me is Star Trek at its best in terms of and I don't mean Star Trek the show truly necessarily, I mean the crew of the Enterprise actually making good on a non militaristic, exploratory compassion, and that's why I think it appealed to me so deeply. And then it ends up being an entire episode about what we do for love, what it means to be human, to be connected, which we know is my favorite.
35:02 What did you write human? It's human propaganda as opposed to war propaganda, which it often is. And here's here's why I'm glad that these two things are paired, because you made an excellent argument for Return of the Jedi in the previous time that we covered this episode. Listen, because I don't remember, I did not read listen, But this, this notion, this notion is stuck in my brain because it's so it's just such a powerful notion that I'm not sure that even the filmmakers were aware of, but it's it's there, and it is I think this episode is the embodiment just like you said, it's humor propaganda at his finest. You said that, you said this human propaganda. I read it off of your notes. You said this humor propaganda. Yeah, this episode of Star Trek. You said that this is the embodiment of what you want from Star Trek. I said that to a stream of propaganda. So this is a Star Trek distillation living its values through a non militaristic thing. This is what Star Trek, This is what the mid narrative of Star Trek perpetuates itself as. Yes, uh, whenever it is not looking for militaristic solutions just shooting people willy nilly and instead willing to give people the benefit of the doubt because we are human and we live to explore, and not through this necessary this need of conquest, but because we enjoy the act of exploration on its own. Yes, there is no
36:37 need to impose our values. Instead, let us just explore because we want to see. Yeah, oh no, I'm gonna cry again. Do it? And then Return of the Jedi. This notion that you talk about with the Joys, especially that last forty minutes, and the specifically the meaning of the text coming through through the editing techniques, the interconnected connections and everyone working in tandem to fight fight connection of friendship, executing that through action, not necessarily through text, whereas Star Trek is literally just grand standing through the monologue. Risks in our business. Return of the Jedi is demonstrating its values and the values of Star Wars like it does through action. Where Star Trek is telling you its values, Star Wars is demonstrating its values through action through the power. Where we cannot necessarily do it as an individual, we can't even necessarily do it as one big group, but all of these individuals working in tandem on their own, using to the best of their abilities, it can defeat insturmountable odds. Oh no, yeah, did I see all That is really smart of me? You said the Return of the Jedi bar Yes, okay, that's nice. Also put it beautiful words. You know, it's funny. I think that's absolutely it's it is. It is interesting to set these and also that's why I like to do this podcast this because it's funny
38:12 that the risk is our business thing comes Yeah, with the alleged end of the Empire, these are kind of in some way the theses of these franchises at this moment in time. I yes, and an interesting there's a sort of offshoot thought that came to me while I was watching Return of the Jedi. Nice, I know, and I think I think this is I think this is related when it comes to the idea of us having to be together in this that it's no one person And and I started thinking actually about like what is the benefit to being complicit in empire? And like we're complicit in empire right now? We are, and we are complicit in the United States Empire. And I I like, even by existing, we are saying, well, I mean what can you do? And an interesting thing in you know, Star Wars that's literally within a New Hope, right is it's like Luke even says, well, of course I hate like the empire, but like what can you do? Like what like what can I do? And I think most people, for whatever reason, do function from that perspective.
39:40 There are people who just don't have enough resources to people who have a lot of resources and don't want to lose those resources. But I think ultimately it's because the only real answer and FBI don't come for me Jesus, is actually violent rebellion, like it especially in a you know, and that is a terrifying prospect. And we have a very clear picture of this. I think within Star Wars, it's very easy to watch something that feels very black and white, but I don't actually think it is as black and white. When I really dig down into it, and I have these thoughts because I was watching it. I was like, why would you want to be part of the bureaucracy of empire if it's as dangerous? And then I was like, well, because most people are actually just on the planets, being middle managers.
40:27 Well, Lucas is interested in the optics. He's interested in the visuals because we go back to his original attent. If he wanted to do superheroes in space, that's what he wanted. And the moral grays, even though he was importing all this Vietnam era political stuff here, it was as we established in the Star Wars special edition story, it's in search. It is all to kind of help him exercise these asthetics. That is my argument to you, La, is that it is actually shades of gray. Sure, but also we are the baddies. We are the baddies. Maybe you know what actually might I might change what I just said. Maybe it's that we are the baddies, which he makes pretty clear, and it is black and white, and statements that are like, well it's complicated, just make it seem like it is shades of gray. Yes, And to acknowledge that and to acknowledge like what is necessary is terrifying and takes real movement, and I think for the most part, it's just like no, yeah, I mean it's much easier for me just to be like, well, these guys suck about it. I mean, we just got to live, right, And so what it takes to to believe so strongly in the betterment of a future
42:00 that it literally will take your life that you have to hope for something better, Like I don't think I'm brave enough for that. I'm not brave enough for that. Like I just want to like be cozy, you know. Yeah, so I and even Star Trek as a property argues, it truly argues that the goodness of what they have now came after violent rebellion. It's so interesting that you say, folks willing to die for this belief system. And meanwhile, within this episode of you're talking about that and return the Jedi. Meanwhile, yeah, within this episode of Star Trek, Kirk's back and doctor Ann Mulhall lover. We all know her, we all love her.
42:51 She's she's been here the whole time. She's the first science officer I've seen in Red and the first non Yeoman woman I've seen in don't don't worry about it. Don't, don't, don't worry about It's a TV show. She looks great and red dot don't she is a great Transatlantic ass accent. Look don't sorry, don't don't worry about it. I love her. I'm worried. I love her. Don't don't worry about it. The fatulous Diana maldarm who you will be seeing again. Really, Oh I know where I looked her up. Sorry, Yeah, in another episode of Star Trek, the original series. But these three people willingly sacrificing their lives to be like, let's give these faults a chance. Yes, Randon, it's different within the context of Return of the Jedi versus these faults, but they're willing to risk MH bodily harm to give these disembodied brains and jars a chance at a new life. Yeah, And obviously the stakes are different because you're saying, well, is this really a big risk? I guess ultimately it's it is just it is just the lives of three people. Yeah, it's quite it's quite small, and you feel it being a little bit overly for me, you feel it being overly grand. Yes, within the contact with the episode as
44:23 opposed to like the Doom Stay Machine where they fight it Doom Stay Machine, remember that yes, no, what Yes? Pretty big? Felt pretty big or pretty big? They could have done a risk as our business speech there. But there is some a real beauty to that speech being in this context of because you know, not to sound too much like McCoy being like, you know when that bit between in an earlier episode risk Bo's basically like you care far more about like individual lives and say if like a bunch of people died, like it's the smaller versus the statistic. They're personal versus the statistic that actually makes an effect on you. I don't want to sound like I'm coming from that perspective, but I think when you do take a story like this and you focus it so strongly on these three characters and they're sweet, scared caretaker, the doctor and Nurstappel, it does the greatness of a speech like that actually does feel really vast, because it's like in contrast to the size of the thing, almost as if to say it is even in moments like this that seems so small that actually we can achieve greatness, which I think it contribute to to like the idea of even though Star Wars in Return of the Jedi is dealing in many people, many soldiers or many rebels,
45:54 because I know other soldiers, but they're rebels working rebel soldiers and e walk soldiers on e York bus. Uh. I was doing a lot of identifying. I was just like, there's cheap chirps and I found I'm pretty sure I found Nissa. Obviously, Wickets there, where's your action figure? Oh, it's on the She's on the table in the living room. But I was like holding her the whole time. It's very sweet because for folks don't follow us on Instagram. As a little rat present, I've finished, then e Walks. I bought Aspen and I some Ewoks action figures from the Holocron toy store in North Austin. Thank you, And I have wicket Tea Warwick hanging up on my wall. Yep, that's great. I took her out of the box. I hope it's okay. Of course, it's literally you do literally whatever you want to. She's a little toy. I was like, you're mine. I took her in a soak out. I was like deep, deep, deep, deep, deep, move them arounds. So anyway, there is all these soldiers, but it's still very personal stories, right, and it is still the actions. It's all of our small actions together, you know, creating something better. So despite the apparent difference in the the stakes, I still think we're kind of dealing in the same the
47:27 same pond, if you will, Yes, that's a phrase. Yeah. It's so interesting that Ebert is crediting this holy to Lucas, which as a lucasfilm joint, he's a producer, probably functioning more like a TV producer on Return of the Jedi as opposed to Empire Strikes Back, where he was a lot more hands off. This one, he's more hands on, and you can feel the course correction aspect. It's also at this point in ninety seven, Richard Markwond is gone, gone, gone, He's gone gone. I believe he had passed away. Is dead Jim dead? Yes, he passed away in nineteen eighty seven. Oh wow. And so you know Lucas is coming in and being like cgi here, cgi there, we're going to add some no here some no yeah. The oh they no they're no ah.
48:31 Yeah. I won't go into it too much. Is this the moment, Sure does it? Does it work for you? Yeah? Yeah, A little bit of those a little bit of those changes once again. I you know, I I am least bothered by the changes in this film, maybe Empire at the fewest, despite some of the stuff that he put in there. And partly it's because of my intense love for the ending canceling out, my tense hatred for the Java scene. So everything else is just like, that's fine. There's a big establishing shot of some bantha and I love Bantha.
49:22 I will just see a huge herd of those things, and I love them. I want to give them little gisies. I want to ride under ditail backs. I want to brush their little hair. I love Panthas. So I'll look at as many cgi establishing shots of panthas as you want to give me, Like, there's no like Gungans dancing around on them being like we sawn banthas. You know, So it's okay with me, not yet, not yet, And that's a threat. Yeah, right, fingers crossed. And I think there was a certain there is a certain couple of moments where I was like, actually, I feel like the crispness of this is pretty good. This is going to sound so small, but I noticed when R two DC and C Threepo walk up to the door of Javis Palace, it seemed so huge the door. It is bigger, and it is bigger, and I just genuinely, like real like in that moment, was like, this is cool. I realize it was so big. And I do think that there's some clever things done in a way that is counter to how unclever some of the other things are, so I feel less personally offended.
50:42 Yeah, and that I'm thinking about it because there's so many fan fixes for Star Wars Online. I'm thinking about the stupid dumb scene thirty eight thing. Are you familiar with Scene thirty eight? No? So the Obi Wan versus Vader fight in a New Hope, Uh huh. Some Torp online made like a super charged, badass version of it. Why because folks are influenced by video games. I believe in modern action movie aesthetics, and I think are appealing more to the I want to understand it. Personally, I detest it, but also it just I don't I don't know, I don't understand it enough. I think it robs the thing. Basically, it supercharges that fight, but also just thinking about the special editions, and this is probably where fans began to get permission that Star Wars is a malleable thing. Oh huh.
51:58 Interesting, and so you see all these versions like oh what if you and McGregor was in the original trilogy or the I came along to this with like the Phantom edit and Attack of the Phantom, the fan edits that I currently have on my shelf of the Phantom Menace, that Attack of the Clones, because one fan felt entitled to be like, let me try and fix this so I can have a more watchable version of this on my shelf and also just let me share this. And it also helped me learn about editing, getting in late and getting out early, redundant action, those things.
52:40 It helped teach me a lot. But also this weird thing about Star Wars of being like this is not my Star Wars, this portion is not my Star Wars. This thing is my Star Wars. Oh it's really fascinating. I mean, it's so funny to hear you say it like that, because my sort of reaction is to be like ough, but I'm like no, I most certainly do that. I have literally decided, right, Skywalker isn't Cannon. I've literally decided that. I mean again, I've got my own complicated Harry Potter stuff. But after a certain point, I was just like this weird stage play shit. I read that. I read it as a book like The Curse Child. I was like, this is bullshit. This thing doesn't even exist. I can't even handle this. Goodbye and are like the Fantastic Beasts. I was just like, fuck you, Like I think I am doing this all the time. And so I wonder if maybe it's the word usage of like someone feeling entitled, because it's like, oh, I feel entitled to do an edit of this being a better fight, But like, is that any more valid than the person who made the fan added a phantom and being a better movie? Like I get to pick and choose.
53:57 I go, Nope, not that one. Oh actually appeals to me. And this goes back to the entitlement aspect of the theatrical versions of Star Wars no longer available. Okay, well, that's a different type of entitlement, Kenny, because we're talking about the entitlement of a man with so much power special editions. It's not my Star Wars theatricals are my Star Wars. Phantom Metic is my Star Wars. Phantom Menici is not my Star Wars. I see, yeah, yeah, I've decided. Yeah, originals are my Star Wars. Yeah. How interesting? It is interesting, and I don't like Rise of Skywalker. Also, I bet there's going to be a lot of great Star Wars tie in fiction. It's going to be based off of Rise of Skywalker trying to jump backwards, jump over so many hoops, being like, here's how to make sense of the political landscape of all of these things, just like some of my favorite Star Trek tie in fiction is trying to make sense of the garbage fire that is Star Trek Nemesis. Sure, I was not to say, I'm like, oh, you know, actually, I actually it a similar I'm realizing a similar type of thought though it's not like this isn't my Star Trek or whatever it might be. But as I was watching this episode, thinking to myself, God, I really love this episode, it occurred to me that I love the way original series makes me feel, but I am frequently very frustrated, and I wonder if that's why I love Strange New Worlds so much, Because it captures the same sort
55:30 of feeling, but sort of amends the pieces that feel frustrated. Strange New Worlds is the closest that Star Trek has gotten to the original series feelings. Yes, outside of like the first two seasons of Next Generation, and then at some point they were like, we got to take this Star Trek stuff seriously, and make no mistake. I love my bureaucratic conference stable Star Trek. That is my that is my favorite Star Trek. Yeah, I love it. Whenever you get Patrick Stewart behind the table being like is this right? Meanwhile they're talking about the forced relocation of yet another thing of Native Americans. We'll get to that in season seven and Next Generation oh so many, so many seasons. Yeah. And also, Strange New Worlds is able to distill what makes the original series great, all of it, all of it, the diplomatic stuff, the philosophical stuff, the sociological stuff, the science fiction and the stuff, and best of all, the goofy stuff. It is willing to be silly as heck in a delightful way. Silly as hack.
56:40 Yeah, man, And it's so interesting talking about malleability of Star Wars and then also thinking about Gene Roddenberry and his relationship to Starrek and what is real Star Trek and what is not real Star Trek, because at some point he was like, animated series of Star Trek not canon anymore, even though like his name's on it, and then it had almost everyone from the original series back, almost everyone from the writing staff back. It's essentially the continuation of Star Trek animated form, but the quality is debatable, and so roden Berry was like, nah, it doesn't count anymore as opposed to I think what you and me enjoy so much about it so much, which is all of it is the thing, right? I mean that sounds very It's good to know and interesting to know that Star Trek has a similar sort of what is canon type of discussion, since obviously those are huge when it comes to Star Wars of like what you know, legends being relegated to non cannon Star Trek Bensilver backwards. To make sure that all of it matters, even the Calvin Universe stuff, which is a hard reboot of Star Trek, is just like this is definitely an alternate universe and doesn't count within Star Trek proper.
57:57 So this is different is that the Star Trek movies, jj Abrams movies, and then even the novel universe aspen even the novel universe sure within Star Trek as opposed to Legends, where they were quite rightly they were just like hand waved it like doesn't care anymore. The Star Trek novel verse actually wrote a finale to be like, this is all a different universe. Interesting, do still all count? Don't worry? Well, I mean there is a sort of there is a sci fi element, right, there's already mirror universes set up or timelines set up within Star Trek. I think to mine from that, Oh yeah, there's not really an equivalent Star Wars sands over backwards to make sure that all of this count, right, which now is restricted now it does. Also, I wanted to talk about the fact that this is the last time that the Star Wars trilogy is the Star Wars trilogy, that thing that you and I grew up with. Yep, although to be fair, you watched episode one is your first Star Wars. But like, yeah, even though we refer to this as the original trilogy, like this, after Return of the Jedi, the next thing that comes out, I think that we'll be talking about next episode as man, next episode, freaking episode one. So this is the last time that this trilogy exists within the vacuum
59:31 of being. These are the three Star Wars movies. Wow, okay, wow, I'm glad that I had a really good close out song to complete my emotional journey through this thing. And then we're about to go into Lucas expanding it to films right, and then it's all about the tragedy of Darth Vader, which this film series, the trilogy became that being like Vader is actually secretly the most interesting character. But then the saga it becomes, it ceases to be the Star Wars Trilogy, and then it becomes the original trilogy and the prequel trilogy, the Star Wars saga. I wish. I don't know what I wish. I I also cried. I also cried when uh Anakin was dying at the end of Return of the Tether because I just was reflecting on it, even within just like the context of the thing of Mark Hamill's eye acting, and just the gentleness and the kindness of the thing is
1:01:01 just so truly wonderful. It's just so deeply, deeply compassionate, like and that is and has been my argument. Like you mentioned for Star Wars, I think it is at its qure, truly compassionate story, a very loving story about about like like we can always come back, you know, like we can always be better, even if it's at the very end. And that's a very hopeful thing, a new hope, if you will once again.
1:01:42 I feel like I'm feeling very struck between that is, like it's thematic whoops, though I don't know like thematic connections like that these two property is a Star Trek episode and the Star Wars return of the Jedi feel the most optimistic. And that's kind so having a time, having a time, yeah, a little sweet time. I don't know, Well, AskMen, what do you know a lot of things such as I know that you're nice, a real sweetheart, and I know, just like just a sweet, sweet sweet bowie. I give you a kiss in your head, just like I give a band I kiss on his head. I know that it's is it you're gonna play a song? Is that what's gonna happen here? Don't you take my walk lighter and clip it? Don't you take my redchord buddy and nip it spill the tea. I'm gonna snip it. I star. You did play the song, of course I did. What are we doing?
1:02:58 We're going tea? You play a start cheap beat the game that I well in relationship with my partner came up with. And yet for every my partners don't so you don't like you as much, and yet for every single episode don't prepare for But I did. I did. Oh, So what we're gonna do is we're gonna name our favorite ships from either or property, our favorite romantic ships from either or property. Yay, okay, can I can? I? Can I give my first? Can I give my ships so you don't steal it? Yes, absolutely you can. I'm worried. I've said this one before. I should have checked this redsheet. Well, I got the spreadsheet right here. My favorite ship. There's so many different vehicles and ships I could choose from for Return of the Jedi, but I'm going with the Lambda Glass Shuttle. Oh. I definitely was not going to steal that. I love them. I love that it's like they've got little wings.
1:04:06 It just kind of come up and do a little triang. I love the shape of them. I think they're very interesting. I love it. They're inherently evil. I love that they can't fit chewy. No, I don't love that. I wish he had more space for his big old long legs. But yeah, I just think they're a very interesting shape and I am very convenient. It makes sense in terms of the way that they fly and then the little sides come up when they land, and I love them. That's all that was definitely not going to be in my tries. Really, I really there's like a lot obviously, but that when wins, I know that it's not massive, but it's massive in my heart. So it works. I I was looking it up and I was trying to figure out, like what that's and it's a trihedral foil design. So cool. Oh my god, brutish imperial engineering. Oh I love it. Oh, I love it. Uh so, of course my favorite starship. What do you think my favorite starship is? Wait? I got this? Which properties are from? It's either Star Trek or Star Wars. Oh my god? Is it the elevator that? No, I don't know, it's a vehicle.
1:05:30 It was so amazing is how I've never seen something to go up and down before? Extraordinary technology? Cool engineering? You know, No, I'm going with the B Wing, dude. Oh that was gonna be That's my second one, is the B wing bad Okay, Well I got Lambda first. It's okay. B Wing was genuinely my second one. I was going visit well, it was going to be either or of the three Lambda, B Wing or ATSD. According to the behind the scenes on Wikipedia in regards to the B Wing, the b Wing Fighter was originally designed by Joe Johnston, who designed Boba fet uh huh, and Bill George for Return of the Jedi. The craft derives its name from the fact that the crew labeled the two new Rebel aligned star Fighter models and Return of the Jedi as a fighter a B fighter. Bill George has so much input into the starships development that his colleagues nicknamed it the bell Wing Fighter year. I love that being you know, the X wing looks like an X, the Y wing looks like a Y. B wing does not look like a bee. And the reason that it's called the B wing is because they're like, I don't know what we call it, like the B fighter what, I'm so tired, I want to go to sleep. So interestingly, the bee wing is actually it's they I'm remembering this. This is like coming up from like a deep memory.
1:06:54 But I'm pretty sure they it's invented during rebels and they fight did like it's like it's like made by a man calla Marii guy, and like that's one of the episodes, is like this prototype of the bee wing being invented. Yeah, man, because it rocks the b wing is so cool? Oh love Yeah, I think it came on screen and I went byeway Angel's like okay, who is who is still still my partner and the composer and seeing it and performer the starship, it's it's beautiful. Great, look at us.
1:07:39 We don't give a shit about Star Trek ships. We only love Star Warship. Well, there's really as per usual, it's usually just the enterprise, though. I guess we could have gone with the ships that Sargon and his compatriots are held within the giant globes, the giant, opaque white globes. I do you enjoy them? Speaking of relationship, yes, yes, between starkan Is compatriots Asthma. Who do you ship this week? See again, I should have thought this one through. I was thinking so much about starshifts, but I think about romantic starships interesting, I know, but I was in love with everyone very much. So sorry, you go first.
1:08:26 You can take the main one if you want. I mean, I'm going to just do it. It's it's helpful for me. Sargon and let's just be basic. Sargon's wife. Yeah, because it's a beautiful relationship Sargon and Sargon's wife, who has no other descriptor besides the fact that as Sargon's wife. Yeah, that's true. The Lisa okay perfect, I could Yeah, I couldn't remember her name. Who are you can tell that rotten Berry wrote it. Because as soon as they get bodies are like, let's do it kissing. We did not ask these humans for their consent to kiss, but here we are kissing, and they're truly Oh it's beautiful. It's beautiful kissing kissing. Yeah, they have a relationship that spans millennia, and they love feeling each other and they're willing to They would rather commit themselves to the void of nothingness as opposed to hurt these human beings any further. Yep, I I like that. Yeah, it's a beautiful arc. Sargun is very committed and he stays very true and she. I think it's very understandable that she
1:10:00 would want to stay in this body and feel and be with this person she loves. And then I also think it is admirable to then realize no, I can't do this, like we can't do this. I do think it's sacrifice. I do like, look, we'll get to your relationship in a second, but just a quick, quick tangent. I like that most of our discussion has because I was a lot cooler. I returned to tomorrow as you were, but really just talking about the notions of how this art is effective, how it works, as opposed to being like good or bad. And I know that we clown about everything exists in a binary of either good or bad, but like it's just delightful. That's all. Good job, good job, AskMen. Thanks. I felt very emotionally affected by this.
1:10:49 I think they really and what helps is a very uh like too, like a great variety of beautiful performances. I think her name ways truly having Oh my gosh, he is because he's not like even when he was because he's playing a bad guy and even when he was Mirror Universe spot, he's still like I'm still very analytical right, so to get to just be fucking bad. He's just like, like he's hot though he's so hot, he's like twirling his mustache, tie you to the train track. Baddie's like whenever uh first gets into Spock's body and flirting with Chapel, immediately, yes, it's it's not he ends up controlling her too much for it, but it's but it's yeah, He's immediately like hey, and she's like, oh my gosh, what me? Because she obviously loves fuck, so what a mind fuck for her? You know? But anyways, what's your ship for the week?
1:12:02 I don't think this has been done before. I was just checking to say R two D two and C three po. Whoa, yep, whoa. I can't believe we. I guess we've never done it before. We covered all of droids and we we had an R two D two K ten kt ten. I don't think we've ever had an R two three PO A classic ship, A classic ship. Now, Aspen, what about R two and three bo and this in Return of the Jedi resonates as pure sexual charisma. Well, I see humor as very sexy, and I see a sassy little droid making squeaks as particularly hot. Put them together and you get unmatched attention. But I but truly, though truly, I think it's like a obviously they continue, I get, and they are in other properties. I know they are before and after and forever and ever. But the worst like, sorry, the worst one. The worst one is in Rogue one.
1:13:18 Oh that's right, they're fucking it's so, it's so bad. It's so bad because they're your main characters and there like off to the left or three PO and R two like being there and it's so yeah. So I think I just I was just really appreciating because I think that there is actually one three P was exceptionally funny in this film, like in a way that isn't annoying. It isn't greeny. I don't think he's ever greenny. I love him forever, Okay, he's sometimes after two weeks, we're going to get to the most grating P. So sorry, I forgot, so sorry.
1:14:02 He's very funny in this one. Han is also so funny in this and I think that there's just a little dynamic duo his also his like I'm a scaredy cat fear so I think I'm focusing on three po here like kind of pulling its arc and then to like being a hero. And he does it because he has this, he has this companion. And I think that of all of Star Wars is the best love story CDP and R two D two balancing each other's Uh, I don't personalities so well, having each other's backs, like truly loving each other through it all, like the best the best boyfriends. So that is mine speaking of the best boyfriends being coupled together through the eternity of their franchises. So too is the Track Wars podcast committed to being coupled to eternity. With our main conceit of trying to rank which one is better Star Trek versus Star Wars. This we once again go back to the mat and rink return to tomorrow from Star Trek to the original series versus Star Wars. Episode six returns Jedi Special Edition. Uh, and I will go first because I'm pretty sure I went last last week? Sure? Why not? It's all arbitrary, it's all made up. Who cares? All made up? It's all made up. Yeah, I'm going to give Return of the Jedi seven, Okay, because it's good and I like it because
1:15:34 it's good and I like it. No, I'm going to do seven point five. No, I'm going to do seven point seven five. Oh nice, that's nice. No, I'm going to do some point seven six. Okay, very awesome topic here. It's like you can just get closer and closer to eight, but never actually hit it. No, it is not an eight. No, well I think it's an eight. Oh this movie, I don't think that. As opposed to Star Wars an Empire, there is not much going on script wise in terms of thematic cohesion. Both of those movies have some creative juice. The original Star Wars is a masterpiece in just populous blockbuster storytelling about superheroes in space, synthesizing a whole bunch of influences that George Lucas has into just uh a stone called masterpiece. The Empire Strikes Back is an emotional character based science fiction adventure that is bothering to take the hero mono myth, put it on its head, and going how far are you willing to go to be the hero? Let's get to the dark stuff.
1:16:51 Both of those kind of function in a diptich kind of way, and the Return of the Jedi wraps it all up. But there's not really that much to say in terms of grander thematics as opposed to I think, but you eloquently said through action, because this movie has so much juice in terms of that last forty minute. I don't know that last action chunk, yeah, which is just it's perfect. It is pretty phenomenal. Like there's a moment and also it shouldn't work, no, and and I think I have to go with it. It's because it's truly emotionally compelling, Like there is that moment where Lando just believes so calari he just he's like hand like Han's got Hans is going to succeed. Like partly it's because it's like you have to believe in that, right, but also because it's like he believes in his friend. And I think it's because everyone, while separated, is so tied together emotionally, so so fundamentally has to believe in each other so much, you know, And I think that's partly why it works so well.
1:18:03 It doesn't feel disconnected. It feels very very much like we're all, yeah, fighting the same battle literally but also you know, figuratively. Yes, So for that reason to give it an eight. Yeah. Uh, that brings me to you a collected total of seven point eight eight. But it could still be anyone's game. As we pop over to return to tomorrow, really we'll give it a six hmmm, and then will use this portion to bring up a couple of things from the episode that I did not touch on. You're going to say that I did not like It's fine, like it's an adequate episode of Star Trek. I think a lot of the juice is rubbed because this is basically characters that we've never met. It's their episode, as opposed to I want to watch the Adventures of Kirk, Spock and McCoy.
1:18:56 Yeah, the original version of this episode, that John T. Dugan version Stargun was basically going to be god boring. They allude to it, but this has made even more clear cut within the original versions where it says that two people left from their planet and it was basically going to be Adam and Eve. I was gonna say, I was like, I guess there is a real sort of like I don't know, Yeah, there is a vibe there is a vibe of whoever is in Spock's body. I forgot his name. Being very devil like very Satan asked, Yeah, that was not intentional. I think. Also, although there was a lot more sexual assault in the original versions, those were cut. Yay. This was director ral Senensky's least favorite episode of Star Trek that he directed, and he directed a bunch funny. I highlighted this quote. Shatner struck me as being like Bob Kolp, who I just directed an ice by both talented guys, but their approach to acting was not always as sincere as it could have been. They were more into being stars than being actors. And I think that's so interesting because I think Shatner gives a silly performance here, but it is not because he's not invested. He might actually be a little bit too too invested.
1:20:23 He's so into it, which if there's anything I reward, it is fucking commissioned. Shatner never phones it in. I think me Moy has phoned it in a couple times. Sure, he's probably done with Shatner's bullshit like everyone, like every but Shantner never phones it in. No, even in this silly episode, which is like, which is why why he can be a meme? Yeah, and also why like the more. I watch Star Trek. I don't like Shatner, but I fucking love Kirk. Shannon's really good, fantastic. I think he's fantastic. I just love it. I love that full body heart commitment. And finally, like I said earlier, and we'll get to your ranking soon. We don't have to, we we will.
1:21:15 It's the main conceit of the podcast. Oh okay. Geene Roddenberry heavily rewrote this script, which is why he's credit with the end teleplay. It went to attribution to the Writer's Guild of America. Roddenberry ended up winning the teleplay credit, and Roddenberry was so pleased by his own work with the script for a Return Tomorrow, which I think is widely regarded as just a episode that funny, that he chose it to represent Star Trek for consideration in this year's Writer's Guild Awards above the scripts for a Mock Time, Metamorphosis and Journey to Babel. In the rest of the great scripts that are here in this season, that's very silly. You gotta love it. I mean I understand stand as perspective as someone who really liked it. I mean, yeah, but I would not do that it's got that chuicy monologue. And also Diana Maldar talks about Roden Berrier being like Roden Berry was true original where Hollywood wants to I'm paraphrasing here, and of course all of this is from These The Voyages season two by Mark Cushman. Diana Maldar talks about how where Hollywood takes creatives and tries to make them commercial, Roden Berrier was a true creative out and out and was never worried about being commercial. He was always sticking to his own guns. Now, whether you and me can be like and I'm sure Diana Maldar because he actually knew, but some of that is driven by ego, but also there's just something nice about that. Yeah, that's all.
1:22:53 I don't. I hate it. I'll say you know what, I also don't Diana Maldar, Oh, God, the first she started talking, I don't care that I didn't know her, and I didn't care that I didn't know that the space being she passed. I was just like she posed she Immediately. I was just like, holy moly, she is by her accident. Yeah, the transatlantic thing, she's she's got like she's got the riz and this is why you write this episode sixteen. Yeah, it's literally all her. I'm gonna give it a seven point five because that's my opinion. Crazy that you ranked a piece of the action below this episode, which wait, I don't remember right up on a piece of the action the Gangster episode. I didn't like that episode, and no baffling. You're so much about sherannigans and that episode is nothing about shenanigans. Anyways. Returning to tomorrow is paltry six point seventy five as opposed to return of the Jedi Special Edition coming in at some point a eight, which means aspen, I win.
1:24:00 What's it like to be wearing that three? P hat I I win? I win? And it's not just because we're listening watching the original Star Wars fell because I myself personally am a winner. You are a winner, and you know who else is winners? Our listeners, our listeners, thank you so much for listening to the Track Wars podcast. We enjoy doing this podcast every single episode, not every week. Sometimes we do weeks off. We also don't enjoy it every episode. Sometimes we're like, wow, we're phoning it in, Like Leonard Nimoy, that's not true, we like it. Speaking of phoning it in, why don't you phone in your support to track warspod dot com leave us a review. Click on the reviews tab, go to the podcaster of your choice, and please leave us a review when you can. Additionally, if you'd like to get in contact with us, you can shoot us an email Track Wars Pod at gmail dot com. This up on our social media accounts both at Instagram dot com and blue Sky at track wars Pod. And finally, lastly, but certainly not leastly, you too.
1:25:11 If you love this podcast so much you want to give your heart or into cash in order to see starving so hungry artists like ourselves so hungry be able to pay for the infrastructure here, then why the heck not joinsober at patreon dot com slash track wars Pod, where you could listen to early episodes, extended versions of the episodes, and joining the fine auspices of fine folks such as Timbo to Sosa, Thank you so much for your patronage, Emily, Bryce Love, Heidi Rogers, Kevin Miller, Mark Webbert, who we actually got a comment from this week. Mark he sent us on our Patreon. He sent us three harthands for our latest Empire episode, and then also just showed us the text messages because we are friends with our listeners. It's just like, really good John and Mark. I want to say you're a good guy. He is a nice guy. You know. That's actually it means a lot to me because I actually felt a little anxious about that episode.
1:26:06 Really yeah, I you know, because I was editing it because you were in Mexico, and I was like, I sometimes I want so badly to get it right, you know, and when you don't want to, don't get a writer, you know, whether that looks like saying the right thing or a historical fact or like social type of thing. And I was like, man, am I just like talking on my butt? And so it's kind of nice to be like, nah, you know what. No, we're trying our best. People people appreciate it, and that's cool. Thanks, we are trying our best. Thank you, Mark. Also our other patrons, Aaron Signs, thank you so much. You didn't send us anything except for your heart in cash. Yeah. Finally, lastly, but certainly not leastly, Jolty Partner, thank you so much for your financial contributions and especially considering that you live with the co host of this podcast Asthma Western.
1:27:03 Uh. Thank you for your super bank accounts. Uh. Thank you for your song contribution with my Starship, and also mister Toast and o Fesso for contributing to Trek Warris with your theme song. Uh. I think you did it, man, I mean Lucas. Lucas is finally a toned with his father, uh realize. In Return of the Jedi, Lucas is finally toned with this complicated relationship with his father, realizing that his father is a complicated man uh and is able to win him over by becoming his own man and defeating the empire that is his father. But we'll be picking up on a brand new narrative next week star episode one, The Phantom Menace and Patterns of Forrest. Yay, asmen, Yeah, what's what's that? What's that you say? I love you? Asmen? You love me? Yeah?
1:28:02 Thanks. I will be to you. May the Force be with you and live wlong and prosper mhm.
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Spreaker
RSS Feed