Rising Malevolence vs. The Enterprise Incident
Our friend Andrea DiMauro-Walton joins us to talk AHSOKA. And Star Trek, too, I guess. Aspen and Andrea talk about the Romulan Commander. Kenny talks about how Anakin just seems like a guy now (and why that's GOOD). Andrea talks about her experience...
Our friend Andrea DiMauro-Walton joins us to talk AHSOKA. And Star Trek, too, I guess. Aspen and Andrea talk about the Romulan Commander. Kenny talks about how Anakin just seems like a guy now (and why that's GOOD). Andrea talks about her experience with The Clone Wars and how kids aren't stupid.
And Aspen talks about Star Trek as Regency Drama.
_________________
Get early, extended episodes on our Patreon at https://www.patreon.com/trekwarspod
Theme by Tosin Awofeso
Social Media:
https://www.instagram.com/trekwarspod
https://bsky.app/profile/trekwarspod.bsky.social
Want to ask us questions? Email us at trekwarspod@gmail.com .
And leave us a review! https://bit.ly/leave-a-review-trek-wars
0:26 Welcome to the Trek Wars Podcast, the one podcast that dares to ask the most important question in a fandom, which is better Star Trek or Star Wars by going through both franchises in chronological release order. I am but one of your co hosts, Kenny Madison, the Star Trek contingent with me as Per always is the co host with the my hosts. I am but Aspen Webster, a Star Wars contingent member of which we are Legion and Kenny can't stop us but to help bridge the gap and hopefully broke a repeat between our two warring factions. Is our guest today, Andrea Tomorrow Walton. Welcome to the show, host of Lasso Cast General badass as cool, Hey is nice?
1:23 Yeah? Do you have anything that you like about yourself? Oh? Gosh, has fine opines. I love Star Trek, Star Wars and books. What story like? I love her Cule Paro. Stop, look at that tattoo too. Oh that's good. I love her Cule Paro. I love Oh yes, my partner and I well, no, my partner mostly not. My partner is Joel Kitty as looks like a little puppy. Ah.
2:06 I don't know why I said my partner and I it was just my partner. He went on an entire he watched every poor Ro episode like the like that show. Loved it, like couldn't get enough of it. And so that's me right now. I loved it so much. I found there's an audiobook of all the short stories of Agatha Christie told by like the audiobooks read by the cast of that show. Oh, I love that. That's well lovely, that's such a good time. I actually directed a murder mystery show, an improv show that was like specifically poor Ro esque in that it was like or like a little bit of like Knives out Us, where it's like, you know, because he's always like happens to be like on vacation and then the thing happens and it's like, well shit. It was like that.
2:53 Anyway, if we want to do a poor road book, Yes, I am in for a poor opok asked I am in very cool tattoo. And I like ice cream as well. Oknny are you rolling your eyes? No, I'm just trying to ice cream. No, I'm just you talking about ice cream. Is sending a chill up my spine thinking about these two episodes and what happens. Oh, yeah, I guess we're talking about Sarar and the Star Trek. Indeed, two diplomatic incidences that could be the fate of the galaxy as we talk Rising Malevolence episode one or episode two of season one of Star Wars the Clone Wars. Correct almost didn't pull that one out, guys, Versus the enterprise incident of season three of Star Trek the original series. Especially in Star Series. Yes, great job, Thank you so much. Please spunch for folks that are playing the home game. Should we gives synopsis for what the heck these things are? I'd say, so, if you want it, should I go first? I should go first, because in a rare a bout of not being with it, I do not have it pulled up. Oh, in a rare bout of actually being what I got it, boy, I Wars the Clone War was yep, let's
4:25 see Rising Malevolence. Malevolence is italicized because it's the name of the weapon anyway. Air date October third, two thousand and eight. Director was Folooney. Writers Stephen Melching. Ah, I'm gonna read the official description here, creating panic throughout the galaxy, a devastating separatist mystery weapon terrorizes the Clone star Fleet. Anakin and Ahsoka race to save Jedi Master Plocun and his Clone troopers. In time, Jedi Master plocun Is squad really survive an attack from a mysterious separatist warship called the Malevolence? Can they stay alive long enough for Anakin and Asoka to find them? Who wrote that that's like repetitive copy? Okay, official discripsion. Someone's gonna find me and they'd be like you try you too, batter I got I got paid, Nichols, I got paid, Nichols oh Man. Yeah, that's speak speaking of getting paid. The Enterprise Incident directed by a former showrunner, John Marriedith Lucas and written by feminist icon Dorothy Fontana. Yes we stand on Guard for the from the syndicated column TV Previews, which was carried into Toledo Blade serving Toledo, Ohio. An unidentified critic wrote an excellent episode that combines enough of Star Trek's very best elements to add
5:58 up to a first rate and among the wonders on display tonight, the death of Captain Kirk, the love life of mister Spock, a siege of the spaceship Enterprise and an exciting espionage tale. When Captain Kirk suddenly turns on his crew and irresponsibly orders them into territory help by the Romulans, it looks like the end of the starship and its mission. Spoiler alert in case Andrea you didn't finish this episode, they get out of it. Yeah, And I know I was shocked too. I thought that this week, Sure, what's going to be Dad, I'm sure this was the end? That's right? Can you imagine it would have been so brave kill off Captain Kirk, just keep the season going. Imagine. I'm sure the rest of the cast would have been like, great, wonderful. Yeah right. I mean what's funny is the idea even of a captain's spock. That's what that cool Romulin commander who was really into him kept suggesting. I was into the idea of big time. Yeah. Can you please segue? That's so badly catty? Speaking speaking of hot unsaid tension, what's your experience with both of these franchises?
7:18 My experience with both of these franchises are these episodes franchises these franchises. Because you're a guest, and I mean, we like to talk about which one's better Star Treker Star Wars, but really is just a good excuse for us to gap about our favorite things. Yeah, and we've already talked about you enough, so we figure we'll talk about your experience with Star Trek and Star Wars. I'm a lifer in both franchises, watched both since I mean from as well as far as I can remember, I was watching Star Wars, Star Trek and Doctor Who, the Big Three, Yes, Chile, and I just love I mean, I love both of them for different things, and I hate when they're put up against each other and like a really you know, aggressive way. Not what you guys do. I think that is this podcast. That's what we do. Will There are times though I want to throw some of the things out the window and I get annoyed, you know, But I love I love them both. And yeah, so life for like I said, I saw, I was born in nineteen seventy three, Yes, and that's that's well into Star Teks running syndication, yes, and Star Wars, iscation of both Doctor Who. I've done with Doctor Who and start Star Horse Start is that the year and resigned it might be?
8:50 And then yes, then watching the original series on Syndication, the animated series on Syndication until the glorious year that TNG came out. Truly what oh, I'm so excited to just talk about Palette Setting with TG whenever that comes out, because that thing was controversial as hell. Ass my my god, so excited. Good for me when he says when he says we're no one has gone before instead of where no man has gone before. I literally cried. I cried, I wept tears. That's better than what I thought you were going to say, which is that people were very angry. I'm sure they were. They were they thought it was beautiful, they were There were campaigns who were like next Generation not real Star Trek because it's no Mayan, no Mayan. Yeah. I mean, well it wasn't Kirk Spock and McCoy.
9:43 Yeah. Well we'll talk about that like ooh, but this is very cool to have been like yeah, like to have watched TOOS and Syndication like be there as like these things began. Oohol. I mean what next Generation when a premiere? Whenever you are fourteen m I think it was fourteen, right, exact year Nixon resigned. Whenever you were born. We know that. Let's make a timeline important moments in history. Let's see Iran Contra was whenever you were seven or eight, nineteen eighty seven, I was thirteen, Yeah, fourteen fourteen, you're righty seven? Uh? And so whenever next generation came along, were you just amped for more Star Trek or were you just like, not my Star Trek? Sorry? Ron he resigned at seventy four, Please go, please go on. Nothing happened in seventy three. Nothing, just a collective nation just kind of looking at each other on the couch being like, did you say something nothing to watch on TV? No, Walter Cronkite, Sorry, you're I was saying, though, I'm so sorry, I totally what did you ask on? Uh? Well, just because you you might be old enough to well you are old enough because you talk about hearing where no one had gone before, has gone before, and that
11:18 being a moment, Uh what you were your feelings leading up to next generation? Just being like you just amped for new Star Trek. Yeah, It's just that's how I feel like, That's how I've always been. Like, it's so funny than the way people are like, oh my god, they're going to make a new one, and it's you know, like, it's not my star Trek, Like, what do you mean? It's fun? Like I love that there's a star Trek all the time, Like you know, yes, yeah, I mean it's baked into the structure that this thing could be anything that it wants to be. Yeah. Really, the only commonality is that all of these things have been set in Starfleeton. Even Card starts out as a lifelong starf leader, being like, I can't really opt written Starfleet anymore, can I? Which is a bold question that asked.
12:03 When I know that you're very excited about that premise, I promise you not tackled as well as you want it to be. I'm always interested in the idea of a militarized structure being the sole focused point of a proposed utopian future, speaking of a militarized structure of that being the central focus for a utopian future. What's your relationship with Star Wars? Just just liking it whenever the well, what do you think about the prequels? What are what stands out? What do you like about Star Wars? Well? So the yeah, so right, so we have established So I saw three movies in the theater of the original trilogy and loved and loved it. I was Princess Leiah for Halloween. For I was like Christmas and Christmas every day and you can't.
12:58 You can't be Leah you last day, Yes you care. I was actually extremely disappointed when the they never I always hope that the next trilogy, like the next three movies, were going to be Leah's story. I wanted Lea to become a Jedi, and that never happened, and that was, you know, broke my heart a little bit. Yeah, what are you talking about. She clearly trained Ray as a Jedi and Rides of Skywalker because she used, but we never saw her her journey as a Jedi. Yeah, so one brief training montage with Luke. I will say, I don't.
13:48 I don't. I won't say that. I I guess I I guess I would say in some ways I prefer Trek over Wars, but I think it's just because I feel like Star Wars gets stuck in itself. It gets stuck in what it's supposed to be, and you know, like I don't know, like it it won't come out of that world. Like I just said, I love Dareth Vader. I don't need to keep hearing stories about Dareth Vader. We can move on and learn about other stories and the Skywalkers, you know, like like I loved and or specifically because it had nothing to do Like I was really disappointed at the end when they you know that scene after the when they showed that, Yes, I was just like disappointing, we have to bring it back to this fucking story. Ever, we did not need to know what the heck all of their work was going towards, because it's just better if it's just empty work that we don't know what the function of it is. Yeah, so have I have a more complicated relationship with Star Wars, but I love it. I mean I can't say that it's bad or what ever. I just it's complicated. Who if if if Star Wars and Star Trek were embodied as human people and then they were forced together in a Gamesters of Triskellian situation. Wow, well, I think Star
15:28 Wars is tougher. Star Wars is the more scrappy tougher like you know, lean like hasn't eaten in a while, and it is kind of like right, the Star Trek people will be all like, well, you know regulations, unless there's Jane Way and which in which case it would order Star Wars back into the transporters so it could split it back apart. Oh wow, wow, I got that. I am going to ask, but i'd be allowed back on this show when you do two X Oh absolutely, A should be back in twenty years, so you can't come back between now and then ever again for I'm going to send you a list of episodes. I want to talk about Plate and I welcome it. Oh my god, that's a great episode. It's really good. And I'm not particularly a fan of Voyager, but watching that episode, I was like, they are really really going there. This is a good interesting philosophical question. And yes, the sky playing two X rules, he really does. He's really good speaking of rich philosophical discussions. First impressions of both Rising Malevolence and the Enterprise incident and Clas
17:00 I'm clapping Aspen. Had you seen the Enterprise incident before? No? What'd you think? Loved it? Way in so in I have to tell you a secret. I watched this over a week ago and how I'm like, what happened? I like looking at my notes and I'm like this is why you take better notes. That's been just in case. But sorry, I did the line I did right? Was is this episode the first to feature a female starship commander, though she still has to wand out fuck? However, I'm pretty cool with it because fuck is hot. That's so good to no, good to ow. I loved it. I was having a great time. It was great. She's the first, she's first commander who's not name Susman. Yeah, and it was great, great time. I've never seen it before, that's my answer. That's a hot app. I don't know if I've even seen anything in season three. I'm like, genuinely, I don't think I ever have. So maybe a couple if I had to venture a guest, You've probably seen Tholey and Webb, and you'll find out whenever we get there, you'll know. You'll know pretty quickly. You'll know.
18:18 Sounds like a boat there. No, it's it's good, It's it's good. Okay, all right, that silence and actually lengthened that silence, just bleep it out. Yeah, it's good, it's good. Oh boy, howdy. Yeah. Andrea first impressions with the Enterprise Incident, an episode that you've probably seen a couple of times. I have seen it several times, yes, but it was good to revisit it and that kind of, you know, being a little bit more critical of it. Right. Yeah.
19:04 The one thing actually I wrote down that I wanted to ask is why was she why was she shocked? Well? Can I ask a question? Or maybe I should just this is just froze impressions. I enjoyed it. I loved it. You do everyone ask a question? None of this is real? Yeah, this is all construct right, I knew it were a lot. Why was she confused about Spock being Why was she surprised Spock was on the ship? This is it was a It was the Vulcans and humans coming together and making Starfleet. Why was she confused? Is it just bad romulin like intel? They thought it was just the humans. Textually, he doesn't she looks really surprised. Doesn't he say something about the like he addresses it, and it might be something like there aren't a lot of them.
20:04 There aren't a lot of Vulcans at the time, but like, yeah, it still was the joining of Vulcans and humans. Humans. It wasn't a human endeavor solely, And maybe again, I feel like Starfleet because I think it's Starfleet, right or am I right? Right? Right? Yeah? Uh, that's an invention with Enterprise, not for the original series, and so what wait wait wait wait wait wait wait I don't. I don't I've never seen Enterprise. What are you talking about? Okay, the Andrea, I believe and correct me if I'm wrong. You are talking about why the romulent commander would not know that a Vulcan would be on board, uh starship whenever within the canon of Star Trek, humans and Vulcans created Starfleet and the Fed together. Yes, but at this point Vulcans are just dudes except for to bring into Powell. So I'm putting the history of what comes later on this, not what we actually know at this point. Yeah. I I also and it must not even just be in Discovery, because I also had that in my mind as a fact, so it must be in other properties as well as just now current cannon. Uh so yes, uh yeah,
21:37 it's it's pretty much all over the new Star Trek Strange New World's lower decks may mean that's it all of those things, because I watched all of those so much, so good Live for a lower decks. I mean, there are questions that I have about the competency of the romulent Commander in general. Yeah. Yeah, But also I'm like, this is kind of fun. I like how heightened this feels. I'm kind of just going along with it because it's fun. There's a certain low bar that I will say that the fact that she was never actually put in vasileine focus filled me with joy.
22:19 Like I was like, you know, what, what if we did it that bar? Never seen a woman who was supposed to be perceived as attractive on Star Trek not get that before. I was like, oh, I guess yeah, I don't know. There's probably some complexity to it that we could probably fit around and flit around with and figure out. But but I'm not You're You're not I'm not not with you? Is when I'm I'm not like not not not with you. I'm like but like a anti pro nuts the kind you naughty? Sorry, what's your take? I mean, I I think that this episode is nice, pulpy fun. Uh. There are better episodes as Star Trek, but I just better episodes of your face.
23:25 Yeah, and I think that I'm a pretty good looking guy, but like better, better looking at pictures out there. I'm sorry, I didn't. I didn't mean to explode that way. No, no, no, no no, in order to get your point across, and I think that this should be a requirement going forward. I need you to put other things down. I think it's required. No. This episode is like a fun, pulpy thing, ripped straight from the headlines, which we'll get into in a little bit. And I'm pretty excited because I didn't actually know that. It's pretty awesome. I know what you're talking about. Oh, thank goodness, will you? I don't yayho? Should we should? We? Should?
24:11 We? I think we're going to just go ahead and put because everything is a construct, everything is a constrict We're gonna go take the deep dive. Yeah. Yeah. This is the Enterprise Incident, written by feminist icon Dorothy Fontana's ripped from the headlines. Yes, what are those headlines? Is loosely I'm taking this from Wikipedia, to which I give money, so it's a nonprofit, just like it is loosely based on the Pebbelo instant, in which a United States Navy ship and its crew were seized and the crew held on charges of espionage for almost a year after the ship allegedly strayed into North Grew waters. That's kind of the basic of it. And so that happened.
25:06 What was that you said this would have been like, when did that happen? The incident itself, it started January twenty third, nineteen sixty eight. Sore, you go right at the timing. Uh. Yeah, The USS Pueblo, a communications monitoring ship, was attacked by North Korean naval vessels and Russian made meg Jet fighters off the waters of North Korea. When the Koreans boarded the ship, the captain and his crew were caught destroying electronic equipment a top secret documents. The eighty two Pueblo surviyors were then held prisoner in North Korea, where they were relentlessly interrogated and often tortured for eleven long months until the very end of nineteen sixty eight. And Dorothy Fontana naturally went, what a star trek, What a star trek? What a star trek did then what if my boy Spock, my boy, what if my sweet boy whose emotional state I like to explore? I would say that DC Fonta had such a read on like the female gaze. Well, right, yeah, I think so yes, absolutely wild. Okay, So two things. One, NBC was like, good, go get this episode into production as quickly as possible, because they were like, boy, I hope that Pueblo incident doesn't wrap up, because as long as the thing's in the news, we got hot up. I hope they don't stop torture. Yeah, And whenever this episode aired, the Pueblo incident was still ongoing, and whenever it resolved, they re aired the Enterprise incident as that that week's episode of Star Trek.
26:41 And that is spectacle right there. Remember that even protest under capitalist regimes can become endeared for capitalist means. And then number two, uh shocking, no one, Uh the romance subplot was not a Dorothy Fontana Well wait wait, wait wait wait, it's not that. It wasn't that, or maybe you know better. It's just that the original Okay, you probably have more content, but I do have the context that in the original script there was more like kissing and stuff and like kiss saying all over like shoulders. Yes, she did not put that in there. She did not put that and put that in there. No, Fred Freiberger put that in there. What the internet line to me? Oh, shucker. Either way, it was a man that put that in there, and Dorothy was like, look, I know that I don't work on Star Trek anymore, and like I did this on assignment. I'm not in the room, but like, yeah, guys, can you I'm not saying this like to be a jerk, but like I literally started with the show buggins, don't kiss? Can you like fix it? Can you stop? And they could do hand scissoring, which is that's canon. Scissoring is canon, right, I got to write that down
28:11 time. So okay, so sorry. So originally there wasn't going to be no it was just a commander, okay, and his name was that commander dude. It was just a replication of the Pueblo incident but with Star Trek and the logical inconsistency news that are in this episode were really not present in Dorothy Fontana's earlier drafts. But because the new showrunner doesn't really know Star Trek as much, and then also the new showrunner is acquiescing to other demands, TV demands, actor demands things. I mean, make no mistake, this is a this is a good app of Star Trek, but like the commander of the vessel is quite incompetent because her woman gets in the way. And meanwhile, the original drafted this, there's no romance, right, but there's also no woman. Oh yeah, I love it. Pushback come on as well? No, no, I mean, like, don't get me wrong, Dorothy is my girl every time. Every time there's an episode that she writes that sucks, it's because someone came in and destroyed it and messed it up, and her original idea was the best. I think it probably would
29:41 have been a very good episode, and I was very much the like, Okay, we can't just have we can just have our our like Starship Commander be a woman and have her just actually be a person, like why not? Come on? Yeah. So there is a frustration I have there that is real and valid, and it is a problem, and it's pretty clearly actually, like a dude coming in and being like, I really, she's a lady's sister. Got to be into someone, right, am I? Right? You know how ladies are with their periods, So they're going to set off there no clear weapons because of the appearance. What do they have?
30:22 They've got periods? I'm not people are with uterus have periods. I don't. I'm can you tell me what this is? I think it's important for me to know what you're talking about. So while she's not bleeding, I don't know. I they don't have the same reproductive cycle. Yeah, I want to know Dolins bleed. Now I need to know the Oh God, sometimes i'd be interested to hear what you you think, Andrea. I you know how there's like a sort of in the context of the time, it's just like there's a frustration. There's clearly something that's there's like a Okay, well, if we're going to have a woman like she needs to be a little dumb and be so taken by Spock watching it, I didn't get actually a feeling of like incompetence. I thought that she was actually angling for something very specific, and she just she her strategy was wrong, and like she she like she chose with the information that she had to believe something here is a vulcan who cannot tell us and based on like all the evidence that she was being given and kind of also but so she is both this person in charge and then also like someone who can feel very deeply. So sometimes I do get a little bit like in our current context, which is it's
31:56 always hard to navigate these different eras in time. I I there was a period of time with characters who are women who it was like you either had to be one thing or the other. You could never experience like romance or love or affection. You had to either be powerful or this other thing. So there is a certain kind of like joy to there's something very sexy in her power of being attracted to a very attractive person who we all like are like, yeah, we like when this guy gets a little bit like vulnerable, you know, right, it was complicated for me, you know, I agree, I think there. Yeah, there's definitely something with watching you know, even reading books from Yesteryear that it's hard, right, it's hard to watch. I'm just like, I remember when I was rewatching too Wes recently, I was just like, oh my god, like really every alien woman is just like fawning over Kirk. I mean, you know, he's a good looking guy, and I have to say I really liked him with the romulin. Oh yeah, he looked hot with the romulin eyebrows and ears, you know, secretly mulins. Yeah, we all just realized something about ourselves today. But there's you know, like I agree with you, and but there was she was showing something different, which which I think what Star Trek was successful in, even though it did fall into a lot of these
33:27 tropes, right like Yohara is there being fucking powerful badass that she is, right and having this Romulin woman, yeah, it's the same thing. I completely agree with you. Having her be nuanced was great, like she was a woman can be all these things. That was awesome to see. I completely agree with you. She herself was also very hot. She was in a very like power holding on this. I have a wonderful piece. The actress that is playing Romilan, the unnamed Romeian commander, is Joanne Linville, who is forty years old. Whenever she is playing this, uh you do love to see it? Yes, Like forty is like, but I'm like, yes, thank you, right, but insta in Hollywood, Yeah, she's freaking ancient. Oh my gosh. Oh. And so the original costume, designed by uh Bill Tye, was much bustier, and Joanne Linville said, this is not for me, and she took the fabric off the model and because it was in one piece, she pulled it over her shoulder down around her legs up around her waist, tied it and said it should be this, and Bill Tye made it just like that. He agreed to do it that way because he knew I knew Joanne the character more than he did.
34:55 He was going to have her be very sexy. Joanne says, well, no, wrong, what he got from me was a soldier. I feel like crying, Oh yes, bitch, yes, yeah, look yeah, And I do appreciate being corrected on that because I'm forgetting a whole bunch of like historical context, because this character is allowed to be If it was just a direct replication of the Pueblo incident, it would be good. But there is a particular deliciousness with the performance that is involved from romulent Commander that is just unexpected. Yeah, it's a compelling performance, it is. It's it's quite well written, well acted. And then Spock Nimoy gets to play something that he he has had show Mance's hand fucking hands. It's ok.
36:08 I'm gonna isolate that and use that as social media if everyone's okay with that, No, do not comply, understood, understood. But he gets to be he gets to be attractive, He gets to be sexy. I'm thinking of the other time that he's had romance, which was This Side of Paradise where he was under the effect of spores, and it was a different character because he's playing Spot with the Mautians and there's been with to Pring where he's so horny he wants to die. We're a late of is rough. Yeah, man, it does seem aw in this episode. Uh you get a Rami the commander, who is so horny for Spot and she's willing to jeopardize the cooking device, which, honestly, having seen him shirtless recently in the Nazi episode, I understand. Yeah, it's a force. The Nazi episode, Spock was so hot in the Nazi episode, he's he's a good looking man. There's a reason that Leonard Nimoy was getting more fan mail than William Shatner. I also would I don't know if you have like a read on this, but when I'm kind of thinking of the sort of female gaze too,
37:42 there is something in like the likest me. If I have a reading on the female gaze, I have comments about the female gays, I feel threatened by it. Good and you know these almost like regency esque kind of like like the sort of yeah, it's it's very it's very subtle in moments and kind of like a withholding but also pushed and his sort of like emotional with like the way he's mostionally withdrawn. I think is a little a feeling from like a someone who's read a lot of fan fiction. You know, you know what I mean as an archetype. Oh, I'm not surprised, You're just like I can fix them, right, I'll make him feel something.
38:37 I think that's why a Spock's not not to just hop in here. But I just I love that trait of thought, of regency behind it. That's why Spock is so compelling, because there's so much that he wants to say but he can't. And I mean going back to how eroticism is expressed in this TV show, true and touching that well, sometimes God's kisses if it's Shannery, yes, but not if it's back Yeah Shanner human Spock vulcan true, Right, I mean I think that whole idea, right, Like I think data is the next kind of idea of that, right, where someone who wants to wants to be or Spot doesn't want to be emotional, right, he doesn't. He doesn't want to be, but he's at having that war within himself, right, where like data is the next version of that where it's like I want to be more human. I don't want you know, I don't want to be a robot. I want to be human.
39:37 I want to have feelings. It's it's it's always a compelling you know, narrative. It's always a compelling story. It's always that character is always so interesting because they're battling their humanity, right Frankenstein, Yes, Oh gosh, we're human. I always say, like stories, I think this comes up in a lot of sci fi, a lot where it's it's the idea of what is it to be human? We talked about that and start like that's like one of the first things I feel like we talked about, Like I see is this if, like we you have to be taken to the far flung reaches of space to realize what it is to be human kind of thing, like to be so separated from it that you realize what it is that really makes us tick. And so thispock becomes this very interesting foil and that gives us insight into like the differences and what Yeah, what it could be. That's why vampires are so interesting. And also they want their humanity back, they want to feel the sun, they want to be alive.
40:42 And also because it's the achilli you you on your period, on your period. So he's up speaking of vampires and dark places that are thirsting for blood in general, Bravis, we gotta talk about Star Wars. Yes, let's talk about Star Wars. Yes, Soca Soca. Oh so our girl, ah, Soska, she is the best, do so good. I couldn't remember if in this episode we knew Oh in this episode that she reveals Plokon is her her oldest friend, Yes, my old Yeah, because I I guess it's must be revealed at some point in the show. But obviously entails the Jedi, right, Like I think, is it Chona tails the Jedi, that it's Plocon that goes to to retrieve her. It must be.
42:01 There are like flashbacks too throughout Clone Wars when you see him with her when she's very young. Yeah, yeah, so it's it might not be in the context when we were like doing super spoiler. No, but I think you know, Kenny, like, yeah, I've watched Tales of the Jedi. Yeah, and also I mean it's it's revealed in the episode that Master Plow is her oldest like he's the one that found her right right right right? Yeah, So okay, cool, cool, not a spoiler something that happens in the episode. Oops, it's been over a week and I don't know, wait, maybe also have so I've seen this episode before because I've seen all of Clone Wars. What I realized watching us by the way, though, is when we first started watching Clone Wars, it was kind of like on in the background, sort of like we'd have it on walk cooking and stuff, and you know, I'd be watching it, like watching it with Joel, my partner, and we'd be like this is nice and me we'll just like make this up. Yes that's right with them. Some people are cute and I married them. So it is like and watching it and so now getting to watch it, I've only watched it once. Most I watched some of them twice, but this one I watched ones watching it again and getting to really like focus in on it, I was like, this is so, this is so rad. So that's how I Yeah, that's that's my side of this. Yeah, I don't know how about y'all.
43:30 What about you, Andrea, what do you think of this? Appen? Hot app not app I love it? Well, I I I also I did not watch any of the animated Star Wars for a very long time. Excellent, give me that context. I was like, I don't. I don't remember what my attitude about it was, but I was just kind of like, I think I maybe even tried to watch one, and I was like, I don't know, like this isn't me, Like, I don't, I'm not getting this. Well, what was your relationship to the Star Wars prequels? Oh no, no, no, at the time, also complicated because I well, yeah, I just remember going in to see the first one, Yeah, feeling very disappointed initially, and upon rewatching it later, I've liked it so like I'm back in. But it was definitely I think that unfortunately, I think the bar of the original trilogy was so high.
44:29 Yeah, they he almost couldn't He almost couldn't make it, almost couldn't, you know, achieve what we all wanted. But not with his attitude. Then I was gonna say, but I think there's plenty of there's plenty of things he could have done to make those movies better. But I'm also a fan of you know again, Darth Vader, and I think I think his story is compelling. I think he's so interesting, and I thought that was told very well with the prequels, I didn't love, you know, there's things, yeah, especially that freaking especially that first one with the little kid version of Anakin and jar Jar. Yes, well, because Charge is a funnier character than we've had before. Is funny. He's like like he's the center of all this. He's the sad sad there's funny. He's not cute. He's not cute. He was always messing up. It's not cute.
45:28 It's not cute. I'm not a fan. I'm sorry. It is a Charge episodes coming up in Colone Oars. Indeed, it's very excited. Maybe I should come back for that one so I can rant about jar Jar and piss everybody off. No, but no Charge, we're being riddic. But so going back to this episode. So I'm going back to this So I yeah, so I did you missed out all the animated stuff? And then I was like, this is the ship, Like, this is the ship. This is almost better than any of the movies, Like I would rather watch not the original trilogy. Well again that the original trilogy is this thing of like it's its own thing, it's its own thing, and it was this point, you know, being a child and experiencing that, like we even saw we even went to see Star Wars in Argentina subtitled in Spanish, Oh wait is Argentina where the Yavin bass is no Guatemalas Oh yeah, yeah that's Guatemala because Oscar Isaac is Guatemalan. And so he talked about how it's like really fun like because they actually filmed then in Guatemala again with the roller basin. Was he born at the base? Yeah, he's a real rebel. Whoa whoaly Right, But it's almost like the it's almost like the
47:04 original trilogy has this like pedestal of memory and right childhood stuff that it's almost unbeatable and like, you know, it is what it is, there exists. I've been thinking about this more and more the further we go in this podcast. But there's this religious fervor that it's involved with Star Wars with specifically with certain sects of toxic fandom where you Star Wars and I guess Disney has kind of adopted some of this, at least with the things where it's like, here's our tent poles and it wants to hit that particular flavor of Star Wars because we tried to figure out what exactly makes Star Wars star Wars, and whenever all eyes are on it, no one likes it. But then Phone Wars just kind of happens in the background, and it's kind of allowed to do what it's allowed to have done because Lucas makes a hundred episode order and just lets it happen and no one's watching, and suddenly it's declared a masterpiece, which is very interesting also, and being allowed to do its own thing because no one was excited for an and or show and because of that it gets to do its own thing. What do you think about that take?
48:29 I had asthmen, cool, unbelievable, You're doing great, You're you're so smart. Shut up as you're like, I would say, glad to be here with you. I don't like it, and I like this attitude that you've adopted. I am just you are a bad person. Okay, okay, let's bring it back, guys, but bring it. That's why I'm here, right, I'm here to interven. So funny, this is the show we're putting on furiously, we have to fight. I agree, it is kind of funny that it does feel like the ones that sort of pass undetected, though I don't know. It might depend, but there is so much to the Clone Wars, like I I it is. It is very Star Wars Wars Star Wars. The Clone Wars, which it itself like obviously is very pre Disney like. It's it's the Eye of Lucas is upon it for a while pretty significantly. Uh, And I think starts out well, keeps going well, ends even stronger, ends phenomenally. I will never not talk about it, but that comes later during actually during Disney time.
49:55 So I don't know. I don't know. Maybe there's like some generalizations I think we point to and or a lot. It's like, well they weren't paying attention to That's why it got to be so good. But like some things I think, I I don't know. Sorry now I'm talking myself into it. I would say Bad Batch is a pretty extraordinary show, and I wonder if they're also not really paying attention to Bad Bitch. I could also be far of it. I read somewhere today that said that bad Batch was like and or for kids, and I'm like, hello, it's it's not just for kids, like it's just fabulous, like it's just good ship good yeah good. I'm sick of Star Wars being for kids? Yeah, right, Like whoever said that it was for kids? Like who would say that?
50:37 Who would say who would say that they would want to make something like that? Who would who would make Star Wars for kids? George maybe say it, George? Yeah, and not even about going about just Star Wars, yeah, just Star Wars. Yeah, that's why it's like yeah, I mean also it's all and the idea that swimming for kids have to be stupid, right, even that mentality it's for Stairbender, right, like come on kids, like kids are stupid, yeah exactly, and stop treating them like they're stupid. Yeah yeah, we yeah you have, Like I don't know, That's why I think about like with scary stories and kids a lot, like kids like want to be scared. We're like we want to like protect kids. And obviously if it's like overwhelming something, I can do that, but like kids want it, like there's like this thrill, this like in they're they're there and kids think complexly. It's wonderful. Yeah, we definitely undermine children children. Yeah, this reminds me whenever I made a concerted effort to hang out with my parents. Yeah, there's a lot to unpack with that. Never thought about that until just then. Uh yeah, I love you, I love my family. Anyway, is that nine years old they made the decision to start watching er with my family? Oh yeah, yeah, that feels a little bit that could be. Yeah. Well yeah,
52:09 I was just like, that's that feeling that I think that you're talking about. I think there is kids like a challenge. Yes, they you say this is an adult They're like, give it to me. Yeah, and that makes me watch Hunt for Red October at twelve years old. Oh, I was like, I'm going to be watching scary movies, all the Buffy with you, yeah, and all this is, you know, Warrior Princess. Well yeah, I mean I'm watching Exorcist way too young. Oh okay, well yeah but that's but yeah, is that movie is Yeah a lot. The was a lot, and it didn't I have I have no like it wasn't like a painful memory. This isn't a memory of like oh man, I saw that movie and couldn't sleep for three months. No, I watched that movie. I was freaked the funk out my fun Can I say, can I cuss your And I was freaking and I moved on with my life right here. I I'm like, I don't know it was.
53:17 It did not stain me in any way. Yep, because so smart, because kids got kids are smart and they want to they want adult things or rather they yeah, exactly what Andrea said, They're not stupid, No, not stupid. Case in point. There are some really superb set pieces in this because we're still kind of been we're still kind of been. Uh, we're just playing with the toys at this moment in time. Yes, And there are some really superb set pieces in this, beautiful set pieces. It's it's a great episode of TV man. It is a great episode. It's fas it's terrifying speaking of kids wanting to be scared, like it is horrifying as well, like because they are absolutely just destroyed by what is effectively an emp right, Like that's just that, that's just like the weapon is.
54:16 But then it's not just that, it's that they're then systematically killed off, un hunted, afterwards. That's what's so scary about it is you're like Sis two, Sis cis men, cis men, yeah, cists cis just trying to force something continue to continue. They're like, because the whole thing is that this weapon's out there, but then no one knows what the weapon is because no one ever survives, and so you're like, ooh, could have weapon be and it's just like blows people, dismotherings notst o o their power. Then they're blown to smithereens. And if anybody survives this, fucking Roger Roger battle droids, right, what about and just like let them float out into space and die horrifying shit like it, which is so funny because they're like doing their dumb little like battle droids like thing, and they're just like, oh, we are survivor and that it's like you throw them out in the space. Okay, horrifying shit. Loved it sticks so high everyone could die at any point. Look, people are mad at a Psoka and Anakin for for being big dang heroes and see. And I love that aspect of Star Wars. I love when Star Wars questions the Jedi thing more. That's when I think Star Wars is at its best when Star Wars, you know, And that's what why Anakin works so much, I think is right,
55:47 because the Jedi Order is so strict about emotion and all of that, and the fact that like, on one hand, he's telling Snips, you know, sick, he's doing nice, he's telling her, you know, don't you know, don't defy, shut up, you know, toe the line, and then he's clearly going off and you know, and he's just like, well, yeah, sometimes we have to you know, sometimes we have to do things right. Yes, And it's that nuance. It's so interesting. Yes, Kenny has something to say, Kenny, Yes, thank you've raising your hand. You're welcome. This is the first time that I processed that Anakin just a guy, Yeah, just a bro. You smart You smart folks know exactly what I'm talking about, because every single prequel thing Anakin has been like, but did you know that he's going to be Darth Vader one day? Oh tragic. There's just something so said about the fact that he's going to be Darth Vader as opposed to hear where he's like, hey, we can practice patience. Here's how to get what you want by going around the system. Kenny, Welcome to the Clone Wars. It's partly so sad is that he's going to be Darth Finger at some point. What's like, it's because we watched Tartakovski. We watched Clone Wars, which because if it's it was, I don't know if you you've probably seen it. It's
57:20 incredible. But like obviously it's like short has to happen really fast. He spends the whole time being like the Master, I'm so sad about this Master, I am ready to take the trials Massa. And so he is very emo and intense. So he gets Ye's great, good job. There are seven seasons here. Brannikin to just be a dude, just be a too. He's just in this episode Anakin gets a sandwich. Basically he's just like, I'm just having snacks and I'll know to him a shit, right and like teaching a soca Like it's there. Relationship is so cute, it's good and powerful. M hm yep, second only to A's so good and Rex besties, but yes, exactly, they're like it actually does and you can see it here like it happened in the movie. It happened in the first, like in the first episode, the technical first episode they weren't in it, but in the movie, and then in this one getting to see their relationship and how they work with one another. Uh, and yeah, it's it's very much teacher teacher student and like he's a little shithead and he's like a little shithead and a fun kind of way. Like the movie I was so focused on. I don't know, it's being a Star Wars movie.
58:49 What is this the various emotions that go on with watching a scene that is pronounced a Star Wars movie? And I feel like I lost right. I wasn't paying attention to a lot of the new character pieces I was supposed to hear where Anakin is an He's just a guy, you know. Yeah. And also Andrea, you are like speaking my language, and I hope everyone else is too that, Like we know the Jedi are fucking up, Like, yeah, they lost they lost the thread, like they lost the narrative. It's like the downfall, Like the rules that they have in place are arbitrary, they don't make sense, they're inconsistent. They made terrible choices.
59:37 I've been mad about it since Empire strikes back, Like the moment I was just like, what the fuck is Yoda saying? What are you talking about? Do you truly think withholding information is the way to do anything that's bad pedagogy? Absolutely not, And I think it's like a remnant of that, that like way of doing things. And even years later you can see, like we're assuming, of course prequels and everything that happens like that, he'd still be in that headspace Yoda would and Obi Wan. So I'm I'm very anti Jedi order like as it is structured, and so it is great to watch it get like systematically, like you know, like let's chip away at it. So there's a reason I love Vader, and I love the Sith, and I love right there's some some of those characters are so good, and there's so much better than in the Jedi in so many ways, and they're more interesting, and they're more complex, and they have feelings in they're they're like real people, right, and the Jedi sometimes they're like, oh, you know, like I don't know, right, like Jedi. And if we were like to put put it into like author context of I guess the Lucas perspective, it has always struck me as like a childish vision of like Eastern uh kind of philosophy, like a lack of a fundamental understanding of like what actual say, like like like philosophies of like not letting go,
1:01:08 but you know, like sort of like it's not about not loving people or not wanting to save people's lives, like you know, it's not that, it's it's it's it's more of kind of like understanding and like the sort of path of life that like death is part of the path as well. So yes, I gotta say, I gotta not to just attribute it to George Lucas. I gotta remind you, uh and please correct me. Listeners of track Wars go to patron dot com plast track Wars pod. Don't try it correct me. But I'm pretty sure Lawrence Kasnian was the one that brought the Buddhist stuff to Empire strikes back. So but so what about like I mean, good, good, great point, but I'm thinking of like even Origins and Star Wars, you know, except the Star Wars is more just like let go, but it's uh, he's using Eastern aesthetics to decorate his uh science fiction thing. And before he chose one of two ways to go with Star Wars. It could have been Indiana Jones type adventures, because we've got Splinter of the Mind's Eye, which is also just another adventure, a proposed possible sequel for Star Wars. It could have been just that the philosophy and the meanings don't necessarily get any deeper until Empire strikes well, so, so okay, that makes it. Also, I was just piping in just to
1:02:39 be like, remember, one of our mission statements is that George Lucas didn't do it. Least He's not the only one. I think though, by the time we get to the prequels. Oh yeah, oh yeah, oh, we can also be mad at Lawrence cast In. I'm fine with that. Yeah, I blame them all all. Now, obviously we we love Empire. Uh. Speaking of Lawrence Castan and the Big Chill, it's going to be a big thrill for me to present this deep dive. Here we go. Oh my god, my traverishes are getting sweatier and sweatier. I think that. I think the meats are getting better. I really like it.
1:03:30 Speaking of Lawrence Castan and Grand Canyon, let's see if we can jump across this canyon and land into a deep Die okay, Evil Deble, evil Asbin. What do you know about Dave Filoni and PLO Coon? Oh, I don't, no way, I don't. Dave Plocon is Dave Filoni's face. I mean, he's kind of mine. He should name them. No aspens, you don't understand. Really, he really loves him, to the point where in watching the special features it's on my Star Wars the Clone Wars, he's I need a DVD. Uh, you got to get a DVD.
1:04:17 I guess I could just watch it on YouTube. I'm sure it's there. You can also do that. Before he was even hired for Star Wars the Clone Wars, he was already building a cosplay of plo con fun. He loves plo Coon, which is why plo Coon is here. Why, I mean, I can guess. He's a little guy. He's just a little guy. Yeah, he looks like he looks cool. He does look cool. He looks a little like a roach. You look like a roach. It's fair. Hey, this is the last episode of Treck whereas I don't care Selicia's crump father favorite. Can you get more Star Trek sound effects in here? I know? Okay, but what is very cool about.
1:05:16 It's very cool about. It's a good one. Ploon is that his little mask thing lets him uh be in space? What is fabulous? Oh? Yes? Another note, George Lucas wrote Star Wars heard of him, doesn't understand Buddhism, thinks heard of him? Heart of him? George to David Felony was like, why can't Plowcun fight outside? Why can? Or why can't? Why can? Why? Why can't? How? How can he fight outside? How? George Lucas is like, how can to Dave Filoni was like, how can Plowcun fight outside? Yep? He's outside? What did you? What day say? I don't know. I feel like there, I'm like, there's like also you didn't write that down. I'm sorry you a moment. So I've got like a back of my mind memory of once being like, let's underneath Plokun's mask? Is there's something creepy back and like I feel like I I once googled it to see like what exactly?
1:06:34 So let's see beautiful he's a kel door and kel door. Yeah, I mean I think it's just like creepy face basically, I mean probably not creepy to them. They're probably like we look lovely and I'm probably like hot, Yeah, ripped. So there's sentience species native to door and in orders to five oxygen rich environments required to wear specialized breath masks that covered their eyes in nostrils. So they're wearing a mask already to help them breathe in, just like our atmosphere and common and like the atmospheres that I guess other people can. So I always assumed that's what it was, was that he's basically wearing a space mask all the time. So and he probably I don't know what the power of the force magnetized his little fe sis. Yeah, but I'm sure that George is like his skin's exposed to space. That's cold. Sure, but I don't know. Maybe, but also Star Wars, maybe kell doors have stronger skin. Andrea, what's your knowledge about Kell doors? Well, I did my senior thesis on Keil door, you know, in photography school. Again, it's like poetry. So if they rhyn I want to keep hearing this, But the answer is in Wikipedia, and I'm sure it's in response to this here we go. People just made it up. No, but I want to hear about your thests. No, I don't have anything. What I am very it's very easy for me to abandon reality when
1:08:06 I'm in the middle of fiction. I am not one of those people who's like that doesn't make any sense. I mean, there's certain things like if if the story doesn't go right, and it's just kind of like well, because you know, like they just like cut corners and like make decisions that really don't like they're changing the story and to just makes something happen. It doesn't fit. But at the same time, I'm not like, well, that would never happen. Like people who literally are looking up science stuff and they're coming on about Star Trek episodes and they're like, well, you know, quantum physics says, it's like really who no one knows and no one cares. I enjoyed the show also to answer the question like it already happened in another Star Wars. Remember there's a big space plate with Jedi right right, so that rule too. But it's radically different because this one's more as opposed to Gandhi Tartakovsky, which so many of his action scenes were just like numbers, numbers, numbers, We gotta just like all of these we're going to overwhelm the senses and the Jedi. One Jedi will be able to fight like a thousand of these things this episode. Jedi he has powers, he has unknown abilities. Well, he also has thick, leathery hide. It covers his Yeah, it covers his body. Allows them to survive the exposure of the vacuum space for a time. So they got goggles, they got
1:09:39 masks, they got the guests and listen. Also, I'm with you fiction if if like, unless it has sacrificed the integrity of the story or like the emotional stuff, or like it makes something out of character, I will forgive a multitude of sins because I'm just like, you know what that worked for me? Speaking of uh, for giving a multitude of sins. That end chase sequence were there in the Twilight, I believe it's calm and again in Ahsoka, your favorite character. Yeah. Uh. That did not get approval from George Lucas until it was like done cool because they didn't show George.
1:10:23 But then they just kind of did it, and George was like, Okay, oh, we're pushing back gently. Piece by piece, We're starting, we're starting our little experience of like what happens if I just I don't know what if I just didn't. Dad Dave Filoni much like a Dave Filoni, much like a box that you really don't want your cat to get into. Taking those first tentative toe bean steps into the box and looking around to see if Dad notices. Dad's like, yeah, that's cute. You could do that. Don't let that go very cool. Dad's like Fedora, because that's what the cast name would be, Fedora. Are you going to get in that box? Is like, yeah, yeah, maybe it's primarily an audio medium. No one can see you be like a really cute cat right now. Yes, although I am attempting to edit episodes for YouTube. What you can find and our YouTube channel trek Wars podcast. Why do you think I have a ring light on me? What do you think I have a ring light on me? I still don't worry about it. Don't worry about it. You look beautiful. We're just trying. Andrea. When's the last time I showered? I don't know. You look great, Andrea. When's the last time I went to a doctor? No one knows. It's not
1:11:54 a matter of public record. It's fine. Most of my toes are there. Andrea, when's last time can you pay to his parking tickets? Who's to say, wow, that have I been diagnosed by the State of Texas as halatosis? Have her? That might be real? Who knows? Who knows the known halatosis? Have her? Am I legally required to keep up fifty foot radios by the State of Texas. I would would have these rules. I buy into the story very much. Oh my gosh. Let else do you know about Texas? Andrea? Not a lot. I don't know a lot about You don't know anything cool. Neither do the politicians. Again, like poetry, so if they run, it's a dour state of affairs.
1:12:50 Speaking of state of affairs. Uh, Scotty shirt hook's in that cloaking device pretty quick. That's pretty awesome. Oh yeah, we were doing we're doing some really clear like delineation between the two and I. Yeah. I'm like, oh, that's right. We're also talking about star Trek we are, uh do you okay? Okay. Sometimes we like to explore a little thing called thematic connections against like poetry, so that they run fucking stop if they're at thematic connections to be had. I'll remind you I watched this over a week ago and remind you you are under oath counselor we can litigate this later. But objections matic connections, I mean definitely, well yeah, I'm gonna right, I think definitely the idea if you connect Kirk and Spock kind of going a little bit rogue right, like they were saying, like they were on their own, not doing star fleet business. Yeah, connecting to Ahsoka and Anakin kind of you know, skirting Jedi bidness. Yes, yes, yes, yes, yes bisness. Okay, who would be? Who is Anakin's bock or is Anakin? Anakin must be because he's got to keep
1:14:21 his feelings down. Hmmm. I think I think Anakin's Kirk. I think Anakin's Kirk. And that might be projecting because I love Ahsoka and I love Spots. I want that, but Ahska, I mean, okay, remember remember our archetypes are like ethos, pathos, logos. Yes, the Chandler and the Joey. Now that's the other thing. That's the paternal maternal observer and clown. We're going for the We're going for the trium. I can't do anything right, No, you're perfect, your face is No, I'm not you know what I am, that's true, the wrong am. I one star Trek sound effect the best one if you're gonna have one. Sol is from Navy and Navy had half day. I don't know his uh.
1:15:34 His texting sound is also moopsie, and I assume that he keeps his phone not on vibrate for that purpose alone, I believe I have changed it back to the vibration sound effect because Heidi, who's that? Who's Heidi? Who's Who's That's my partner? Yeah, people are in love, all around love. Actually, it's all that's right? Is it? Is it now? Aspen? Yeah, A long time ago. Start dating this week. I quoted a boat, I dated a game, but none of them could work my drive into high birth space. The best of both worlds kept me in the second place. Captain slog on a halla kron. I wanted a song.
1:16:44 I penned a song. Seventeen more minutes advise in super high dev aboard the USS Enterprise DT. Don't you take my walk lighter and clip it? Don't you take my Richard buddy and nip it? If you spill the tea, I'm gonna sip bit. I starship it as what are we doing it gets me every time, every single time, every single time. Have you been prepped for this? Kenny? What did you do? Kenny? I think I told Andrea loosely at some point what we were gonna do, so you never did used to come on the show and talk about these episodes.
1:17:36 Sounds like me, Yeah, this is all I should have given you a time, expectation. I should have given you expectations, Narry, Narry, an expectation, an expectation. But I trusted you so much, I just said, sure, whatever. I watched those two episodes. We're to do. It's called it a starship. So we'll just basically from either property. You don't have to do it from both. You can pick your favorite starship that like flies through the stars. Those kinds are any kind of vehicle like that brings you joy because like for example, like an ATS T or eighty like those count right even though they're not starships. And then your favorite romantic ship. So we ship it, stars ship it, we starship it.
1:18:30 Okay, start, I'm ready for that ship it again. You can do either. Ready, I'm ready, Oh ready, you want to go first? I'm ready? Yeah? Start us off? Yeah, okay, stocked in the Romulan lady. She got it, she got it's now and yeah, that's why I'm like, I'm going first, yes, because yeah, I take it. I love that ship that I don't know what it's called. Well, hold on, hold on, hold on, we got to talk. Oh I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I mean, I guess we've litigated at length how great spot in the Rock male Commander is. But have we missed anything? Have we missed anything? I think I text you to see this, Kenny. I was like, did they figure into their original plan that she would be in this spock or were they just like it's pleasantly surprised or they come into it being like, well, I mean, who could resist him? If I'm right, like, just because he's a hottie. I don't think it matters. But I like to think they were just like, I bet you everyone thinks you're hot. We'll just use that. I like it. Who wouldn't want to go on spot?
1:19:49 Come on? Right? I mean exactly, yeah, I mean, Kirk, certainly, does you know? Am me? Right? Good? Yeah? I don't know. I think they're hot together. It's truly a great pairing. It is truly a great pairing. I will go next and I will say Douku and Grievous. Oh, we haven't done that one before. We have not done that one before, because I don't think Douku and Grievous have been paired together as of yet. Correct me if I'm incorrect. Yeah, I wonder is this the first let's see, No, they've been Oh no, you're right, because no in Revenge of the Sixth so you can die at the top. Yeah, so you're right, this is the first time. Yes, And I think Douku is a man that is in charge a lot. Yes, he's in charge a lot, a lot. What he sees in Grievous is not only someone that you know, he can teach and manipulate, teach them the ways of the forest and possibly become his apprentice, but also someone that is just Pharaoh in the ways that Dooku wishes he could be, but he just can't anymore because of who he is, what he represents. And so Grievous comes into his life and he's kind of attracted
1:21:19 to that kind of quality, that kind of oh you got four arms that could be that could come in handy one day, Yeah, right, Like maybe when you want to collect some stuff for your collection. And then Grievous. All Grievous needed to see was that curved Hilton was like, I got the perfect picture in my mind. I like it. What you know what I mean? So that curved lightsaber Hilt was like, I know what you're working with. Oh it's a dick Joe. He's talking agains like poetry.
1:22:01 I genuinely was like, what are you saying? You have to be more explicite, be very obvious with your statements. Oh my gosh, Well, y'all are taking the good ones. And that's okay. That's fine. I will just think it through. What what about Anakin snips? No, No, that's not a romantic relationship, right, right, right, I know. I'm sorry, that's fine. I didn't pay attention to the rules.
1:22:44 I really brought the rules. That's okay. I gave you no lead. Yeah yeah, yeah, people that you're definitely like these two should get the good Andrea is like the younglings, the younglings together with like what we did have a hard time with the eu Woks. We're like we're shipping children, all the clones. I mean, I think a part of me I watched it write all of it together. Maybe I'll go for like a weird one that's like a plow coon and the clones plow coon and comes off that mask, comes off with the leathery skin. Yes, the shippy face, perfect lips. I mean this is like, is just multi person ship. You take the mask off and this handsome squid word. Yeah, Jesus Christ.
1:23:40 They're trapped in that small space. He is doing the thing that happened in the last episode where they're like, sir, we's just clones. No one cares about us, and he goes, I do I care about you? I care about you like I care Okay, sound like very penny wise, Yeah, I did. Like you know, obviously there's like a certain kind of maybe like paternal type of protection there, like he's you know, a general. But I propose it's a little bit more. Perhaps while they were in there being worried about certain death, they all were having conversations about what it was to be alive, who they are as people, and then maybe I was a little bit of a mask slipped off and they get a little bit of He's she was too busy teaching the clones about Order sixty six.
1:24:43 Meanwhile, placoons in that tight space teaching them Order sixty nine. I hate you. I hated it. Oh my gosh, that's just oh my god, Kenny. Also sorry, Not only was that a great joke, it's just reminded me again that there's so much good for you to find in this show. I'm so excited. I do it for my country. Cool ship ships, ships apply to the spaceship, and you could pick any ships. Andrea, I already know, I already know. Yes, what's your love Anakin's ship? Which the box and the t Yes, Lyne, the two sticks that come out of it whatever, Yes, Yes, it's great.
1:25:33 They got it in the movie. I got it from there. It's a great ship. Agreed. It's a great ship and not a ship that we have chosen yet, which means that you are the first and only person that can use the Twilight. Oh interesting, did I like almost choose it and then I chose a different ship? Is that what it is? Yep, you chose the You chose the Beta five from Assignment Earth got it? Oh? Yeah? The American tartists just to give folks, that's that's what I called it. Yeah, because make no mistake, Aspen, that's exactly what it is. I loved that episode so much. I would have watched that show that's beIN off every day my life. Who was American tartist? Yeah, that's good choice. It's good choice. Obviously I almost chose it.
1:26:26 Speaking of good choices, I don't exactly know what the name of the fighter is, but it is a three wing Republic fighter Sire. It folds up and there's three wings, and then whenever it flies, the wings fold down, and then the third wing goes from vertical above the fuselage to vertical below the fuselage. And I think it is a weird, wild design, and I wish I knew how to even try and search for that choice. It's a V nineteen Torrent. It was going to be mine. God damn it. Going last is hard? Well, thank you, I choose to be nineteen Torrent. I noticed that ship in the background. I was like, I like that ship. Christ I think I'm pretty sure. Right. It's amazing because there's so many great ships for you to choose from Mathmin Yeah that's the guy the US Center price is out there. We've already chosen, Yeah, which is awesome. Why it's like the ships can start to get hard, Like I can't do like I can't do like a McCoy kirk because we've done it. Things like that can be like r t D two and Cloud City. Can we start switching like switch right? Okay? I did have Okay, I did have. I think I don't think this one has the big fucking chip, the cream of Stuku ship. And then like the ship that has the e MP on it, that's not the nos the malevolence.
1:28:00 Oh the oh my god, that's what it is. The malevolence. The malevolence is my choice because I did say I did write it down as my first choice until I saw the B nineteen. Tourning got really excited because I went big ship, which I'm really into big ship. She likes big ships. Why, yeah, so that's fine. It's fucking big. It's really scary looking. It's got like a real vibe to it, like and they try to, you know how they like try to hide from it, like they like they turn off everything and you know, stuff like that, and and and it like they but they see them because they get like a signal and they're like hiding basically on the other side of it. And I was like, this is like a this is a just some Jaws shit, like it's so big and it could get us, and then it does get them, and you're in a big Jaws phase at this moment in time, which is really great. Yeah, in my Jaws phase. He means. I watched Jaws for the first time a few weeks ago and was like, this is one of the most anxiety provoking films I've ever watched. I'm scared out of my mind. I love this two pieces. And then I rewatched Nope, a film that I am deeply obsessed with, and just went, oh, this is Jaws. And then I was reading an interview today with Jordan Peele and he was like, yeah, I was thinking, how can he marry Close Encounters with Jaws? And I went, anyway, Jaws is a great fucking movie. It's so good, it's fabulous. There are times in
1:29:34 that movie We've talked about some patron but this is important. This part ofid movie where they're just sitting and they're just there's that whole story that that absolute maniact tells and everyone is just so entranced and it's so good, oh incredible, you forget it's like you're watching a model. You're just like, this is this absolute psychopaths real life anyway. Yes, Kenny, you've got terrified of water for years? Oh my god. Yeah. It's such basic screenwriting stuff, and it's so satisfying whenever you're just like, yeah, of course you're talking about Jaws and how they're sitting there and you need those moments where they're sitting there to exercise tension. Yes, And before we get to the main conceipt of the podcast, which is which is better Star Trek in Star Wars, Yes, I want to talk about the thematic connection with us, which is that both of these are exercises in tension. Great, it's super great, you're right, yeah, yeah, and like okay, yeah, so it's definitely like the Clone Wars episode especially, it's like the steaks are so high, you are absolutely terrified. You have been shown stakes that like, first there's the ship, there is the unknown, and then we see the thing and then we realize what it can do horrifying. We're trying to get away from the thing. We are found horrifying, and now that we're in a position where okay, are we safe or not safe? And then we see what can happen to us. Oh, and then it's like our Soka and Anna can get a stick around? Are they gonna have to leave?
1:31:04 Ooh, attention is gor wrass? And then the enterprise incident is are the are the enterprise going to get blowed up? I mean, I wish I could have said that far more articularly, that's it, Yeah, it's it's an exercise. Then will the enterprise be able to escape this? What the heck is going on with Captain Kirkton right to steal from? In proud terms? The platform has been completely tilted and our expectations have been subverted. And then turns out it's a complete exercise. And then the tension shifts from will they be able to get out of this? To how the heck are they going to be able to get out of this? And then Scotty has to get the cloaking device bugged in and fifteen minutes or last should have chosen the cloaking device. It Scotti, it's my shift, But you're right.
1:31:51 Can you imagine if someone ran up to Aspen and was like, take this European blender, You've only got five minutes the parties about to start. It would be bad. I'd be like, do I have to use electricity? I'm afraid of electricity, or to put it in even more star Tek terms, imagine that someone has comes up to you with a big pulsating beam of glowing light and someone's and they say this can turn everything invisible as to plug it in. Ah ah, I've never seen this piece of technology before. That good. He's a miracle worker. He's incredible. Yeah. Yeah, they like him trying to get it plugged in, like I was plugged in.
1:32:36 Was just trying to plug it in. I was just like, and I completely didn't bring this episode this point up speaking getting plugged in. Aspen McCoy was almost going to be in pointed ears too, I know. But then they were like, that would be dumb if he did plastics or around his own ears. I did read that, but you know it's not stupid. What central conceit of our podcast of course, Andrea, as you will, no art is a binary things are only good or bad, which is why each episode we try to answer the one question, the most important question, which is better Star Trek or Star Wars, as we once again rank the Enterprise incident from Star Trek the original series season three versus Rising Weleven Rising Malevolence rising malevolence from Star Wars The Clone Wars, episode two of season one.
1:33:30 You don't have to go for it, you don't want, I don't mind. Oh wow, Okay, we're on your side. Oh my god, we're on your side. O. Wait okay, sorry, wait, wait, wait, let's give you let's give you a scale. Okay, okay, okay, we typically go one to ten, right, but I guess something's really bad. You give it a zero rating both of them. I'm rating both of them and then separately. But yes, here's the thing. Because we're scamps, you can go zero to ten and you can do any variation therein, so you'd be like five point three. You can. Okay, we functioned by the Airbud rules. I'm gonna it's not. I enjoyed that episode. I'm going to give that episode a seven point eight.
1:34:28 Hell yes, wow great strong? Well hold on, sorry, I'm sorry, sorry, you're good. Someone didn't say I didn't set you up. She told me Jack, Jack shut up up? Can come? Can't come to my link at eight o'clock. Just click on it. Don't ask questions. Jesus Christ, I'm not going to have a shirt on you fine with that, and he's wearing a shirt. I'm wearing. Yeah, I'm wearing a shirt. Speaking of wearing a shirt, Aspen, what do you rank the Enterprise incident? Oh? Seven point six? Oh my goodness, love to see it. I liked it. You liked it. It's still gave the seven point six. I love it. Yeah, I don't know.
1:35:25 Okay, let me think about a little bit harder. What no, you know what? Thank you for saying that, because I was like, it's just been it's been a week over a week, right, So sometimes you watch other things and you forget. But I just thought to myself, Okay, well, of course I gave it seven point six. But then I was like, okay, what is my tent? My tent is City on the Edgine Forever. What is my zero and Assignment Earth? Assignment It's not a tend but I love that episode so much. I'm excited to finally read your fanfick whenever you finish your first season. You're right currently writing out the first twenty six episodes of Assignment Earth right now, Andrea, you're muted. I see your mouth. I would say, what would I call a zero star Trek episode? It's the ones, It's it's it's the ones that just like make you mad. Like it's not even necessarily the worst ones, it's ones I fill you with rage. Like which one filled me with the most rage? I can't remember. I think I have something like a two, So I don't know, should again really a zero? As I'm thinking about this, you know what, I had a great time watching this episode.
1:36:28 I thought it was fantastic. You're right eight point three hate point damn, hot damn And just as a reminder for aspen Bread and Circuses filled you with rage? God, I hated that episode. Okay, I think an He was like, this is a classic, and I was like, I hate this. Wow, and y'all have talked me up. I was going to give it a seven, but now I'm going to give it a seven point five. There you go. I was like, this is a good episode. I really really enjoy this, but y'all's positivity and then just thinking about how much fun this episode was. It is a romp. It is heightened emotions. You get to see Kirk be it a romulin with those thick as hell sideburns. Do you know why Breton's heir? Because this makes me mad?
1:37:26 I can literally listen to the episode to explain why it makes you mad. Here's an additional reason. Here we go, there's already a romanesque group and it's the Romulans. The fuck sorry, go on, I love we love our Romans. People love the fucking romance Romulans, the Centurions anywhere. But lest we see see aspens rising malevolent feelings go away? So too, should we go ahead and rank rising malevolence? Andrea, would you be so kind as to start us off? I think I'm going to give that one a seven point. Well, let me think, let me think. Here we go thinking ThinCan, I do think, but and I know we're not comparing at this moment. But just like it was a weaker episode, but like just the story was, it wasn't as completely told, but there were some There were some very like great moments in it again between Anakin and Ahsoka that were endearing. Their little relationship is so cute, pissed a lot of clones, Yes, exactly. There there was sex happening in the ship with wild sex and then yeah, and then some of the intro that was there,
1:39:02 so the intrigue you like that, I'm going to give that one a seven point three. Okay, yeah, seven point three. Love those reasons Aspen for the same reasons, but I'm just like slightly shifted up seven point nine. That's fair, and because I agree it's a little like not as like complete, but still yes, it's a great story. But like when you look at the two like and it is completely different formats, was a little bit unfair to take an animated show against you know, live action.
1:39:45 But art is a binary. Yeah, art is yeah, speaking of art is a binary. I think this episode is better than the Enterprise incident. I give this episode of Colon Wars a seven point six, so I think it exactly what it says on the box. We've got great tense action, some good character be It's nothing revolutionary, but we're slowly fleshing out characters, doing the mission statement of what Ambush set forward by saying we're gonna meet these different Jedi. And then we also get it Anakin in Ahsoka, Anakin teaching a lesson repiloting who Anakin is. We get a nice sod lesson, and then we just have some great set pieces. The outside fight is great.
1:40:33 I think sure it's apples and oranges. Comparing Star Trek and Star Wars. But I think this episode of the Clone Wars is doing what it wants to do better than what the Star Trek episode is trying to do for itself. Does that make sense? That does Oh gosh, it's so terrible that Kenny thought Star Wars was better than Star Trek. This is so bad for me. That's okay, because Star Trek still wins the week, and I won the battle. I'll win the war. Rising Malevolence at a paltry seven point six versus the Enterprise Incident's average out of seven point eight seven truly a huge victory. I think we're going to be seeing a lot of squeakers this season, and I am pleased as punch about it because the real winners are us.
1:41:31 We are, yeah, in Friendship, the real Star Wars, the Friends with Mail on the Way, speaking of the friends that we made along the way, Andrea, because this is a platform, we would love to give you a platform for anything that you would like to plug, such as I'm just going to so obviously say Coach Beard's book Club, which is a book club that if you have a passing interest inted lasso and any interest in actually great literature analysis, and criticism it is. I listened to Coach Beard's book Club. I mean also because you are my friends. I consider you my friends. But the reason that you became my friends is because I don't listen to podcasts that I don't enjoy, and I listen to every episode.
1:42:18 It's a great podcast. Thank you. Well. Everybody who's podcast you don't listen to is like, oh weikes, yeah they do better. Coach Beard's book Club? Yeah? Anything else? Can we follow you on any social media? Is? Andrea? I'm not I'm really not participating in social media these days, but I do have a Twitter, Andrea DMW. Yeah, what's that? I'm kind of backing off. I took it all off my phone and I I'll go in here and there a bit. Are you healthier?
1:43:00 I'm happier? Yes, I like it? Yeah, christ Well, everyone can follow you on Twitter and then, yeah, feel anxious about Twitter? Uh, Aspen. Do you have any shows coming up? Yeah? Yeah, people are people are in Austin. I'm gonna be in a White Lotus inspired improv show at the Hideout Theater. It's gonna be my last show in Austin before I move. Thank yeah, right, get out of here. Saturdays at seven at the Hideout Theater starting sometime in May a week or two from now. Yeis not next not this weekend, but next weekend.
1:43:44 That is when it starts. Uh yeah, so yeah, that's that's that's okay, that's a big one. Oh and also we're gonna I'm gonna play at your show that you have at Pinballs. Yes, hopefully probably after my show. We'll see if I could. Yeah, but yeah, uh please. My duo Kenny Rogers has a If you find yourself in Austin, Texas or you know around the central Texas area, hop yourself over to Pinballs at Lake Creek up by the Lake Line Mall, or just visit on Instagram. Search Kenny Rodgers Improv on Instagram, where you can find links to our show. Second Saturday of each month. We have a standing comedy show which we get another improv group, we got a stand up or some crazy talented person that we just really really enjoy what the heck that they do, and you know, my duo Kenny Rogers at the end, come see me do comedy.
1:44:41 I dare say that it's at worst good, at best extremely good comedy. Yeah yeah, I just thought I know where at the end of this, but just real quick, I saw a time I was just very recently in LA and so I was I'm like, I'm gonna go check out a show and I saw fuck this Month and holy shit improv and I, uh so I Fucked this Month. They were like great, like it was great to watch. But also I was like, yeah, this is just a pretty good show. And there is something really fabulous about watching like the most talented people I've ever seen just have a pretty good show. And I was just like, yes, yes, it is not like like absolutely like transcendent every time. And I was like, this makes me feel good about me, you know, And I was also still a good show. Speaking of transcendent experiences, why don't you go ahead and head over and over to our Patreon, Patreon dot com slash trek Worse pod where you can get early versions of these episodes and extended versions of these transcendent experiences because they get to talk with some of my absolute favorite people in the world and also Aspen each week, uh, which is absolutely delightful and that's five dollars a month. Uh.
1:45:57 And we do also engage with correspondence uh such me just we're out for each other. I'm coming for the cold. So anyways, we do engage with our patrons, such as this is canon. Arizona Mark commenting on our Star Wars episode three, Revenge of the Sith versus Breton Circus episode, Arizona Mark comments Barris and Lemonara are An episode two two that was five days ago. Asked, well, what do you think about that comment? Baris? Oh, they are, They're an episode. They are in Star Wars episode two. They are. He's right, they are live action. That's where they started. And I even noticed it this time around and forgot, so thank you for pointing that out. Yep, thank you so much, Arizona Mark, Andrea, do you have any I know that that's a controversial opinion.
1:46:56 Do you have any thoughts at this time, any thoughts at all embarrassing Opie being an episode two? No, I don't interesting. We might have to revisit that, because this is truly a troubled time in our nation. And uh, I think Arizona Marx contribution that barrisonfi are An episode two is right. I Asophie, I believe, I believe him. He's right. I can't remember quite what he was referring to. It might have been that we were like I was like tap oh. It might have been that I was just like, oh yeah, like Barri's and Luminar sho up and you were like no, but they're also they're in the actual the Clone Wars Tartakovsky episode. I was like, oh my god, you are and he's ading like and also there so too, just really dropping the ball all around here.
1:47:41 And I appreciate all of you. Thank you so much for keeping me accountable in these truly trying times. Yes, I think asmen is trying to say hashtag believe him. Yeah, believe him him too. Movement will think of them, You will think of the way speaking of him too. We thank Tim bow Desoso, who is one of our patrons, along with Emily, Bryce Love, Kevin Miller, Mark Vibbert, Austin, Aaron Science and lastly, but certainly not easily, Jolty Partner, who composed the I Starship at theme song. Thank you so much, Joel. We can't wait for the pizza at the table. We love you, Honey. Our theme song and our outro song was composed by mister tosin Elafesso, where you can get more of his work and sign up for whatever the heck that he's doing.
1:48:34 In the show notes below, just visit that. You can visit us on social media. We have an Instagram, Instagram, dot com, slasht trek Wars Pod, also a blue Sky We have a blue Sky account, and I'm trying to do YouTube just a little bit more. We're doing video versions of these podcasts. That's YouTube dot com. Just start trek Wars Podcast and we will be some sort of result. Because our SEO on YouTube is poor at the moment. I just do better and looking for the links that we will be posting to our social media at this point in time. Good to know we're building up our channel. It is small, but mighty. We did get a subscriber and that's very pleasing. Kenny is building up our channel. I'm having existential crises. He's doing a great job. Well, you deserve to have existential crisis. You take for whatever time you need. I'm good, Andrea. That's so sweet. I'm not sure I say this enough.
1:49:28 Not necessarily too, Andrea, but Andrea, I love that we talked so much, and I love you for coming on this podcast, and I freaking love you exactly for who you are thank you for being you. Write back at you and Aspen, I love you, I love you, I love you. Yay. Look at us and listeners, we love you. Live long and prosper, and may the Force be with you. S
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Spreaker
RSS Feed