March 22, 2024

Star Wars: Episode II - Attack of the Clones vs. By Any Other Name

Star Wars: Episode II - Attack of the Clones vs. By Any Other Name
Star Wars: Episode II - Attack of the Clones vs. By Any Other Name
Trek Wars Podcast
Star Wars: Episode II - Attack of the Clones vs. By Any Other Name

We talk about Attack of the Clones being both reactionary filmmaking and REVOLUTIONARY filmmaking. Aspen talks about the infantilization of women and how Kirk Drift might be wrong.

Also, we talk about how RedLetterMedia accidentally ruined all film...

We talk about Attack of the Clones being both reactionary filmmaking and REVOLUTIONARY filmmaking. Aspen talks about the infantilization of women and how Kirk Drift might be wrong.

Also, we talk about how RedLetterMedia accidentally ruined all film criticism.

Oh, and Aspen ranks the 15 best outfits in Episode II #slaysenatorslay

_________________

Get early, extended episodes on our Patreon at https://www.patreon.com/trekwarspod

Theme by Tosin Awofeso

Social Media:
https://www.instagram.com/trekwarspod
https://bsky.app/profile/trekwarspod.bsky.social

Want to ask us questions? Email us at trekwarspod@gmail.com .

And leave us a review! https://bit.ly/leave-a-review-trek-wars

0:27 Welcome to the Trek Wars Podcast, the Internet's exclusive outlet for answering the one question, the most important question at fandom, which is better Star Wars or Star Trek by going through both franchises and chronological release order. I am Kenny Addison, the Star Trek contingent of this podcast, and with me is the wickedly talented Delta Zeam just kidding. It's Aspen Webster, the Star Wars contingent here to talk about the prequels. Required of me? Yes, Ken, Yes, Kenny. No matter what word you use, the meaning makes the sense to me. Asked, required, forced Now a pleasure, A pleasure for me to be here with you. That's been A word? Is a word by any other name? Like a road, yes, or like a clone? A clone? An attack, an attack? That's right, we are going through Star Wars episode two, Attack with the Clones versus by any other name from Star Trek the original series, season two. Aspen, how are you doing today? Please answer in the exact way that June Diane Rapiel would answer. I'm fine, Kenny, how are you? I'm quite good today? Uh man, I'm apt to get to it. You're just like ready to go now I'm I'm I to am because you received an entire live

2:01 texting experience of me watching Attack of the Clones and then a little bit of me watching By any Other Name today. I think I was just grumpier today, so I said things like, ah, why get they just take the rock makers anyway, to which I'm pretty sure it was answered afterwards. They did. They did. That's still not how they win. We'll get into it. We'll get into it. Yes, let us Terry, no further, Terry, let us go right into the synopsis for both properties, starting with by any Other Name, first aired February twenty third, nineteen sixty eight. Written by DC Fontana and Jerome Bixby, Story by Jerome Bixby. My directing Girl by s Mark Daniels. Dec My girl, you can feel it.

2:49 You can feel you can feel the leftover input of Gene coun You can feel the leftover input, well, you can feel the input from DC Fontana. Just being a lighter episode, there's still some humor that's happening anyways. From the NBC press release, Captain Kirk answers a distress call which turns out to be a rused by a superior race to capture the Enterprise and it's crew. In by any Other Name on NBC Television Networks Star Trek Color Cast, Friday, February twenty third, what they just called it a Star Trek cast. A crew from an unknown galaxy which is disintegrating, was sent out centuries before to conquer a new galaxy for its inhabitants. The current descendants, under leadership of roe Jan, feel that they have found this new galaxy in the Federation, but their own ship crashes and they need the Enterprise to make the return. Captain Kirk employs a simple but powerful method to prevent to takeover by Roeja. Marbara Bouchet portrays Calinda, and Stuart Moss has cast as Heinar, two of ro Jan's allies. I looks her up, What do you want Cookie? Because she was so hot? Yeah? Man, and I can't remember. There was something very Oh she's in She's in Casino Royale. Uh, the Peter Seller's Casino Royale a bad film? What get out of here?

4:11 Are we really gonna litigate Casina Royale being a good movie? Are you for real? It's Peter Sellers. Yeah, Peter Seller is a terrible human being. I mean he could be a terrible human being, which I'm sure he is. I didn't know it's the best plot line in that movie. But that movie is bad ass. Man. Have you seen that Casina Royale. It's been a long time, but I had a lot of fun as been coming. What are you talking? What are you talking about? It's just it's just a one way tripp to Dollsville. Oh my god. I feel like I want to argue with you, but it's been so long that I can't remember. But I think it's probably good. It's not good, Well, you're wrong. I believe that this is going to be going on the main feed episode. Come on, I'm okay, yeah, great, wonderful, Pad Okay, great, wonderful. Just owned his kid. I didn't know that. It's real bad. Listen, everyone's bad, not g L g L. George Lucas. Ah, we call him jail now.

5:25 Yeah, he is bad, I mean sometimes not. But he's fine. He's fucking fine. He's complicated. He's just a just a complicated man. He's just a man. He's just a Maria. He's revolutionizing filmmaking with this film. Honestly, you know what, Kenny, You keep sending me these great little like many documentary behind the scenes, and I keep watching them because I'm interested and a good person. Speaking of good person, what is the synopsis for Star Wars Episode two, Attack of Clones? I am getting there?

6:09 What was they gonna say? Though? He's good. I've been watching them and you I am very fascinated. But we'll get into it. Obviously, we'll get into it. I'm very fascinated by just like the amount of work and like how ahead of everything they were in making us and how we look back on it. We're like anyway a Star Wars episode two Attack of the Clones. Director George Lucas, writer George Lucas, screenplay by also screenplay by Jonathan Hales. Who's that guy? Should I know? Wait? I got okay, okay. I just wanted to make sure. Oh god, that would have been very embarrassing. It was released, Jonathan Hales wrote, Citizen Kane, what No, I'm lying? That was a lot. I just lied to you. I did see Scorpion King and I couldn't process Scorpion King. I couldn't process one. I was like, that's he would be too young. And I was like the man who wrote Scorpion King roots I was like, that's not how that works. That's awesome. Okay. Anyway, I was released, Oh, two thousand and two. What was the year? Let me find it? I got this. You just said the year. I did say the year. I'm just looking for the date.

7:30 It's May sixteenth, two thousand and two. Uh. What were you doing May sixteenth, two thousand and two waiting for episode two to come out? Great? Great, great, great great great. Here is the plot synopsis for all of you who are not familiar with how this went. Wow, can you tell him? I had one picked out that I really liked. Okay. Written by Eric p on IMDb as. Now, Senator padme Amidala, because she has to keep her honorific, returns to Corussont to vote on an important senatorial matter. An assassination attempt on her life prompts the Jedi Council to send Jedi night Obi Wan Kenobi and his padawan Anakin Skywalker to protect her and find out who the assassin is. As this is happening, a rogue Jedi named Count Dooku leads separatists on Geonosis to rebel against the Senate Supreme Chancellor Palpatine moves for a vote for a Republic army to protect the Republic, as there has not been a full scale war since the formation of the Republic.

8:28 As obi Wan's investigations lead him to Camino, Detective obi Wan, he finds a massive clone It's me not this, that's my song. He finds a massive clone army being produced with a bounty hunter, the Last That's not True, the last of the Mandalorians No named Janko Fett as the Master Clone as he chases the elusive bounty hunter Django and his cloned son Boba. Leads obi Wan to Genosis, where he meets Count Duku and finds a startling revelation about the former Jedi. As Anakin has left behind to protect Padme, his feelings for her grow, and something more than friendship from Naboo to tattooin it grows into love for her. When a tragedy strikes Anakin's life, he began slipping away from the light side of the forest and perhaps from the force itself.

9:13 Okay, er close enough. I mean I liked that one because it did describe each thing very clearly as it went through, because it's a I was going through trying to find it, Like I was like, I'm probably gonna go to IMDb for the plot synopsis, but I was looking through the internet and the first thing I found was a Reddit post that was like, I don't understand the plot of Attack of the Clones. I genuinely need help. And I was like, that's really fair. What the fuck's going on? Oh, we've got some doozies up behind as scenes zenfo for this week. I love it. Love this movie so much. I loved it so much.

9:54 Are you crying right now? I can't believe. I feel like crying out of like shape. I haven't seen this movie in years, And I was like, why am I having such a good time? That's a great question. Oh, I'm having a great time. Though, we'll talk more about it. I do think the last twenty minutes is not that great, but the first twenty minutes is perfect Detective Obi Wan, So I think it kind of cancels it out and the rest of it's pretty okay. It becomes towards the end it devolves into it just kind of tensionless shooting at each other right without what the original trilogy was so good at, which is creating action scenes that further character beats and plot beats, yes, and also kind of starts telegraphing where modern blockbuster third acts will go, doesn't it Actually yes, like very I hadn't thought that until just right now this moment. Very marvel third act, you know, and you're just like, it's a fucking mess and everybody so it's just explosions and shooting and lightsabers everywhere. But also there's kit Fistoh so ah, so good, everyone's great. Yeah, I yeah, I'll tell you all about it. But uh, even even the Anakin

11:26 Padme parts, I was like, I'm not not having fun this. It's it's rough, it's but there's that hole. I understand. It's it's it's rough, but you know what it's speak. We were talking about music and the Patreon part of the episode, which you can get at patreon dot com slash Truck Wars Pod five dollars a month. You can get access to early episodes and vastly extended versions of these episodes. Sometimes we talk too much, yeah, uh but oh the music. The they're like their love like across the Stars I think is like their love theme. It's so good. Oh, you're telling me that John Williams did a good job. Oh, it's but it's like fucking phenomenal. Like, oh, you're telling me that John Williams is a phenomenal job. Oh wow, I know. Okay, well you know what You're welcome for that information. Yeah. Very rarely does he phone things in. Uh. I think we've had this conversation before where I then named things where he did phone them in. That's why I said very rarely. Harry Potter too, Harry Potter three. Nope, not Harry Potter three. He scored Harry Potter three, Yes, but he did not phone that one in. He phoned in Harry Potter two, Harry Potter three.

12:41 Very inspired anyway, that's my example when he has phoned it in, he has phoned it in. Did you know that the score for The Force Awakens? Again? I'm probably I think we've talked about this already cause I talk about this A lot. Was actually so unique and so different that it was nominated for an Oscar Like it was different enough and that it Yeah, it has beautiful rays theme, it's so good his themes are Also because it's different doesn't necessarily mean that it's not going to get nominated. Johnny Williams got nominated for Indian and Jones of the dial up Destiny, which, make no mistake, is a good movie. Thank you, Okay, it's a good movie.

13:22 Also a great example, though, of a film where the action scenes don't always further the emotion or like the character beats her emotion. And by the action scenes, I mean the one action scene where they're driving through Morocco. I still think they could cut that anyway. This movie is not bad, sure, I think it is quite weak. Fun yeah, uh yeah, I think it's bad. It makes me cringe. I don't say that lightly because Matrix's direction is one of my top fifty films of all time. So you know that my tolerance for things that should be refringe worthy it's pretty high. I think I'm gonna make an argument for this film, and I can't believe it. I can't believe it. I can't believe it. Shut the front door, I can't. I don't got it. It's fucking shut it. Take your front door and shut it. I'm home alone. It's shut and locked. I've set up traps, don't worry. One of them is My cat To is one of my least favorite films with the former president.

14:33 Ah, what's your favorite film with the former resident Contact. Is he really in it? Bill Clinton is in Contact? Yes? Oh, I thought you my am Okay, that's good to know. Got watch Contact? You got you gotta watch. I know everyone I know you said to me last night. Everyone that you know is telling you watched Contact. Every queer person is wildly It's like every queer person's favorite film. So I feel like I am really losing at something here, sorry, losing at something. You're going to give a defense of the romance plot of Attack the Clones, which is I mean, I'm not gonna give I'm not just for the film.

15:15 Maybe maybe that's okay some of these I was specifically the romance plot. You want me to do that right now? Okay? Just to let the audience know my letterbox list of Star Wars properties that I have ranked yep on my letterbox, which you can find at letterbox dot com. Slash theou Kenny Madison. You need to make sure that I put this, you know, in the show notes, go some footnotes. I have nineteen Star Wars properties listed on here. Uh huh. Attack the Clones it's number sixteen. It's pretty bad, pretty bad. There are two e Walks films that are higher than Episode two. Well I didn't. I actually I think I fail famously famously famously liked the Battle for Indoor, right, I can't even remember anymore.

16:06 I can go to spreadsheet Battle for Indoor while I go to the spreadsheet, why don't you make your half hearted defense for why I attack the Clones is the best Star Wars movie. Okay, here, I'm gonna I'm gonna try my best. As I was watching this film, I did not write this down. This is extemporaneous thought, which I'm famously okay at. Famously we're having a great time as I was. I think we need to take into consideration how much Clone Wars I have watched, and how Clone Wars retroactively makes Attack of the Clones and uh, Revenge of the Sith better in weird wild ways. I think because I have so much depth and backstory to it.

16:56 There's even entire arcs on Gianosis, yes, just kind of showing how the Genosins were, how they were taking advantage of There's even a piece in Rebels that's it kind of goes even further with that, So I think I probably have a bit of a depth here. I obviously have more of a depth to the Anakin Padme relationship because Padme is basically saved as a character by Clone Wars. So I think all the things that should have been done actually in Phantom Menace as a film, because I was thinking I was watching this movie and I was like, well, there's just not a lot of time for some of this stuff, and if they had actually just put it in Phantom Menace, there would have been time for stuff. I think like the way that they're kind of going and they're developing it, so I'm not doing a good case on like a case for but I am hey, stop stop it.

17:51 I'm thinking out loud, you're not doing a case for it, but you're doing a case about where you're pulling an ancillary Biopwalter. I know, I am just setting that up, setting the stage set. We're both so grumpy. We can't start poetry so that they rhy, we can't turn against each other. We're so mad about Casino Royal it. As I was watching this film, I got through the first part of it, which I have always thought was very fun. I think the film starts strong. I think the bit through Corrusson is great. I think it is exciting. I think character automatically. I got to push back automatically. The first line of dialogue is I'm pretty sure from Captain Taypo, which is, I guess you're right.

18:45 There was no danger at all. It's absurd. You know, he thought he has only one eye, and that's true. Danger usually only happens out of the left doop. You know, how is he to know he didn't know he's only got one on. Yeah, So it was very absurd because of course it is immediately blown up the ship. This movie has Rose Burn in it as her main handmaiden, and that's also a plus. I just want to say, she cries, beautiful crier. So I got through the first twenty thirty minutes thinking to myself, aspen as per the usual of the times you've seen this film, it's now about to get eh and now you're just gonna have to tolerate it. But instead, what was happening for me was I was still having fun as they went to Naboo and he was being a little shithead. I was still having fun, which was a wild experience for me. And as Obi Wan continued his adventure and visited his friend Dexter Jetster, true joy, a true joy of a not human uh.

20:04 He and then goes on his little journey uh and goes ultimately to the best planet Camino. I was taken by a lot of the scenery. I think I get very excited about large waves. I love the design of the Caminoans. I loved all of the creativity. I feel insane saying this to you right now. I feel like I am insane because this is what's going on right now. I was like, this is great. I kind of this whole bit with Django Django being like these different aspects of this makes no sense. However, having a great time and everything that was happening on Naboo.

20:47 That whole scene in that meadow is both absurd because basically he's like, I would be a dictator and she's like, what the fuck are you talking about? And then they're like a okay, go get go, and I'm was actually giggling too. I was like, and that part of me was like, you know, when I was young and someone said that to me, but I thought that they were hot and I was horny. I might might have ignored it too. Whenever I was anakin Skywalker's age, I was definitely right, just like you know, I guess there are some problematic advantages for affirmative action. We should just give it to the right person. This is okay. I'm gonna get into some other pieces of obviously how this would be better after the fact. Listen, you're not going to respond to what I said asmen. I got what you were going for because Anakin's bad. You're not going to condemn my actions. I listen. I'm twenty four in horny, so I'm here. They're cute, they're giggling. He's writing on a couch. Tick cow is what I meant, cow cow. I took cow the tattooing bit. Uh when he is literally watches his mother die in his arms, and then he looks up and then the music changes and it's like and then he murders everyone and then it fucking freaks out. That to me

22:18 was actually the way that he like acted afterward, was like, despite George Lucas's direction, it was fabulous anyway, basically loved it. Loved it. Got to the end and I was just like, oh, okay, we know we should have you tied me during the client action. We were like good news or just made a pot of tea. Uh, I'm starting to learn how to bake baked a pie. Uh. Got your tax is done? You called your dad were like, I think that we've got a complicated relationship, Jeff, when I understand, what can I do? Repaired your relationship with that? Uh? And then you still have like twenty more minutes whenever we came back. Yikes, man, we are talking about a magical fantasy world, right, Uh. They even like I even text you.

23:08 I was like, I forgot about the whole stupid factory part, and then I was like, you know what, that actually wasn't that long, which the factory is not bad. The three parts are. That's the worst that can die and get out of here. It is. It is part of the nadier Star Wars, which am using that correctly the later like no, not like the apex directly belove you directly directly both diametrically opposite the scene okay, yes, got it? Yes, yet the opposite well not the lowest point in Star Wars fandom. Uh huh. That of course goes to he's alone? Who are your people? You're alone? Yeah, I'm alone, which is so bad. I destroyed the movie theater that I was in and now that movie theater no longer exists. And then I went to the next movie theater that was playing Solo, and I burned that one down. I wanted for Arson. By the way, I burned down a lot of movie theaters that day. This is what toxic Star Wars fans do. This fandom is too much. Again, It's like poetry. So if they rhyn before you go on, I just want to just say that I texted you when they were fighting Count Dooku and then Yoda comes out, and I said, it's like poetry at rhymes if the poetry were about a guy you've never met before. Because I was like, this doesn't really matter to anyone because we're like I'm like, I get it to Christopher Lee, but who the fuck is Count dookub in this whole time. It's not like anyone we knew betrayed us. You know, so obviously this is a bad movie. But I

24:44 need you to understand how much fun I had. I need you to understand. I understand as I have this. I'm pretty sure I saw this three times in two thousand and two. I had it twice in theaters and then once in the Imax release, which was a different, shorter cut of the movie. I had a great time. That's great. I'm glad. I thought that was a good enough defense. The defense was mostly just me saying I had fun. Yeah, our subjective, I'm glad that you had a good time. George Lucas wanted you to have a good times. Maybe for oh my god. I mean, I'm not gonna watch it again anytime soon, but I just was pleasantly surprised, and maybe I was in the right mood. I don't know sure. I just think that it's emblematic of where Lucas is as a director at this time, which is not good. It was just not a great wish I could think a more articulated thing, but it's clearly clear that he is interested in the technology, interested in getting the as opposed to Episode one, which felt more fully fleshed out for all the good and the ill that is, I like apisone won a lot more versus Episode two, which feels like a connection point and uh all of the I guess the place setting that is more interesting in episode one after the fact,

26:15 I don't know, it becomes more textual here, and that's not necessarily nearly as interesting to me. There's not as much plicle machinations so much as I mean, we get the detective plot. That's unusual because they don't exactly death sticks. You don't. You don't want to sell me deathk sticks, and I don't want to see how I want to go home and rethink your life. I want to go home and rethink my life. You know, you got the detective subplot, but like that doesn't really get resolved. But that's fine because I mean, he does. You get the big battle, I mean he does. He does track it all the way back and you're exit all the way back to Dooku and he figures it out and like fucking he like discovers this entire army of clones. What the fuck? And we see the death Star plans you do, I don't really care about this much.

27:06 Sure, and then the Anakin padme stuff. Dah's it's it's it's done. So had you seen this week's Star Trek episode. I have never seen this episode in my life. Sorry to this episode. I do not know this episode. Uh, I think this episode's okay. And then whenever they get on the ship, the episode's quality elevates and it becomes pretty darn good.

27:48 That's pretty much what was happening for me. I actually had another one of those moments. So it's another like, oh, aliens that are more advanced than us, like control us taking us over kind of plot. So I genuinely almost checked out. I was like, whatever, I don't care. That's why I was actually really surprised him his DC fonsaticus. I was like, girl, come on, it could be better. Does someone fuck with your story again? Not exactly, but we'll get into it. Oh yeah, and I it does get better. I Oh, I no, you're fine. I think I was like, oh no, I I I.

28:36 The feeling of the feeling of oh, we've been here before really was kind of getting me for a while. But you're right. It then does change pretty considerably. There is no I don't think there are any original ideas that we haven't seen executed elsewhere. I'm better in this episode. Mm hmmm hm. There's a lot of beats that have been done before, for against like poetry, so that they rhyn but you know, oh god, it gets fun. It gets fun whenever they get on the ship. It gets really fun. Actually does lightful beats, Yeah, especially because the whole idea, I mean, the concept of, hey, what is it to be human?

29:21 We can engage with this, and it's like we win by uh leaning into our humanity. Deep budget constraints of needing your villain to be human, uh huh become a benefit whenever they finally ask the question, oh, these people have to be human, these these love Craftian aliens have to be human. Yeah, as that go along with it. That's interesting, although again a question that has been asked whenever other things have been forced to be human? Is there a Star Trek villain at any point that's like even more emotional than a human? Yes? Really? Yeah? Okay, because it always seems to come back to this idea of like, I mean, because this is the foil of the Vulcans, right, which is it's not necessarily a good thing to be solely logical. And we know because Spock himself is not solely logical. Uh, he's actually deeply emotional. I'm not sure that there's anything that is written in the text outside of blank Vulcans having more intense emotions than humans. But it is a very Homo sapien centric show, which makes sense. This is propaganda for humans rule. But I guess what I mean is like every time there's been oh you know what I'm thinking of, There

30:52 is that episode with the gods, and I feel like that there's a god forg out what that episode was, but that was who was? Yeah? Who worse is that one? I think actually is like rather than go the root of we are these superior beings who are like deeply logical and don't like we've like turned off our emotions or our ability to love. That was like way in the other direction, like hyper emotional, very intense, like you know, like desperate for love kind of thing. So yeah, but that goes along with kind of the status of that character as well, because it's God, and this God used to be worshiped as leader as opposed to just to co opt your argument or co opt your statements. Oh oh, because I'm entitled aspen because you don't believe in a firmative action. Oh I remember, I remember how problematic you were. Thank you, thank you. But I don't think there's shockingly nothing within the text of Star Trek which is like this this species is actually extremely emotional. Sure, I because yeah, And I guess the reason I'm asking is because this does tend to be the usual, right, because it's like, yeah, there is Like it's like when there's robot robots or whether there's machines. Basically Kirk has to argue with the

32:23 machine, and the way that we argue with that is by you know, breaking the logic or appealing to emotion. And that's it's like people. It's like aliens as machine, even if they're not physically a machine, you know. It's what makes humans special are emotions, and everything else in the universe doesn't have emotions. We get to win through what makes us illogical. Yeah, and what has also been the reason for our pain in the past. So which then kind of betrays the game of Star Trek, which is we rule because we're unpredictable. Right, We're different. There's a human element here. So if you came on along, we're like this, rates of people are actually more unpredictable and more illogical. Maybe Klingons clean up, yeah, maybe clean on the Klingons and next generation become more honor. It's about honor.

33:22 Oh yeah, but you're right. The Klingons in the original series, I feel like are sort of the other extreme of it. M hm. And it's like they they rather than turn to cooperation and kindness. I mean, we could say federation whatever, like exploration, it's about it's about control and conquering, which is of course the USSR the Soviets, but the Soviets. Did I say that the Soviets the Sherevich I guess like poetry so that they want fuck? Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, I guess.

34:09 I just felt uninspired by the episode. You know, it's I think, yeah, it's like fine and it's fun, and you're right, it's fun. Uh. Scotta gets drunk. Scotta gets drunk. I love us, drunk, Scott. They win the day by exposing them to the human condition jealousy, which is turning saints into the sea unlike something something lallabies choking on your alibis. But it's just the price I pay. Destiny is calling me. Open up your eager eyes because I'm what Kennyn jealousy. Sorry, Yeah, this episode gets fun. They get drunk, one guy eats a lot, another guy gets really angry, and then Rojian gets super horny. Well, hey, hey, hey, you sent me a text. I did send you a text. I'm curious about your thoughts. I think this fits within the article that we have talked about at length Kirk Drift from Strange Horizons and asks imposits in this text message. I think that Kirk Drift article is wrong. He really does kiss lots of ladies, which I'm so smart.

35:42 You know, you're probably the smartest person I've ever met. And I think the article digs into that and talks about that aspect because he is just kissing ladies left and right. But also, like in this episode, like in games Troskellion, like and what are the little Girls made of? He's using sexuality as a means to obtain freedom, not through crafts manipulation. I guess, I mean, you guess well, And every time he's doing it, it's obviously with a woman who is beautiful. What woman woman? She's a woman with needs, wants, feelings. Besides, you can't just tell her what you want to show her. If I'm sure, I might pause it coming. I know this is a perspective that is based in twenty twenty four Aspen who Aspen is it is a means to his freedom, and it assumes by that argument, you know he has less power. A great thing about this episode he has very little power and is freaked out the whole time,

37:12 which I loved, very rarely see him that way because he always has some modicum of power or some cool even in the worst of times, despite him being like in a space of say, like marginalization. In this case, the woman has a lot of power. In the case of that other bad episode with the witch bitch, she had a lot of power. Oh yeah, another episode which is yeah, well and Gangsters of Tuxellian. But I would actually argue, do they have a lot of powers? And not in the other one either not in not Caspa but oh cat'spa too, or the other one where ode with the the Proxy war, the proxy war episode the Side of Paradise. This nope, not garade time, you know with like, yeah, which bitch, who's been two witch bitches? That's right?

38:12 Private little war, Yes, private little war, thank you, thank you so much. Uh, it's all. Also, it's like women who actually have been robbed of power or come from a place of not having a lot of power and trying to gain it themselves. Then in this case it is someone who has powered but less power than someone else. But so what I'm saying here is that, yeah, it's about his freedom, but it comes at the expense of like that maybe the agency of someone else who might have less than him, even then within a structure. Sure, like so is I mean, yeah, it's true, it's true, but I guess it's still to me, is still about macinations, Like it's still about like being a trixy trixy bully. I mean, at the end of the day, this episode, this TV show is still ran by Gene Roddenberry who let me shift through my notes. Yes, Oh it's fucking horny, got it?

39:07 Yeah, right, just like padme is for Anakin, I gotta bleep mine bomb, don't do not. This is a moment. Yeah, but it's gonna be funnier with the bleep. You're right, do it for the comedy. We do it all for the comedy. Fu. Yeah, I'm not gonna bleep you, no little sailor, but me blowing out my levels on that one of them putting it deep over that. And that's funny. You know, it's even funny if we keep talking so funny. Yeah, that's fine, but then leave it uncensored. Not the Patreon, which you can subscribe to five dollars a month. Patreon dot com, slash truck wards blood Patreon's gonna be less funny. Sure, I'm not gonna. I'm not gonna push back against that just makes me want to reread the Kirk drift hard.

40:00 Oh yeah, me too. I can't even remember I read it, But I can't remember now that you're because I'm worried that perhaps I cannot remember anything I read after the fact. But yeah, I don't know. I because I was very much having I don't think seen any of these latter season two or maybe any season three episodes, and only having maybe seen season one, I was like, yeah, I season one. The first half of that season is pretty much just Kirk like bopping along, having some romantic tension with Rand and then they fire grace Ley Whitney, or she leaves the show because of sexual assault, Yes, very clear, I think so, or some type of terrible situation it's against her. It depends on who you ask, if you're asking her, if you're talking about the system something I'm not even doing. What about? Is it literally like Graceley Whitneys, Should I say alleged were going to get sued? Yeah? I think so, allegedly, And then Kirk begins to be a more sexual character after that hmm, yes, just goes into leading manisms. Yeah, chatnerisms, and that's where we have Kirk now where he's still you know, I want to be clear, I don't hate it. Uh. He did this little move in this one

41:32 where he like hit her, you know, because he hit her and knock her out because they were trying to like get out of that cave at the beginning. Uh. Whenever he hit her, did this sound effect happen? Should have? Yeah, the real crossover makonkey Man. Imagine if George Lucas has got his hands on those original Star Trek files, he'd be like, ooh set effects. That's some weird little guys in the background everywhere. Oh man. Ah, he like karate shops her, uh, like you know in that like spot where your neck meets your shoulder again the left hand side. So when it comes in and he's just like, did I I hurt you? I'm sorry, I'm sorry for hitting you or something or for hurting you, and she's just like, Okay, I have no emotions. I don't understand. Oh, something's happening for me right now. But let me get through this part and they'll come to it. Oh boy. Any but he does do this thing where he's just like, is this what do I hit you? And she's just like no, it was so actually over here, and then he like kisses it, and I was like, oh oh my, oh wow. It was a real Indiana jonesman like, well where doesn't it hurt? Kiss me there kind of thing. And I was just like it was such a gentle kiss to you. And I was like, okay, well I'm not mad. I'm not mad. A sexy little moment, okay, but here's what just happened for me as I was thinking about this. Sorry you're familiar with the film Poor Things. Yes, I did an entire thing in our Patreon episode where I went through how it perfectly can

43:08 you can get on Patreon, slash truck, horse pod, I don't know, Chuck course and pay money check cosset pot yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah how I mapped it all to like the heroin's journey whatever. Thank you so much. That's really nice, because I was like, I am talking a lot kind of you. What am I gonna? Was I saying? Thank you? It's really nice? Uh. Part of what Poor Things, in my opinion, is saying, is men are prefer this like woman this like full, like fully grown bodied woman with like the mind of a child.

43:52 Uh. And that is so for anyone who's like this is an it, it's like, yeah, that's the point, and like it's like an exertion of like her like trying to like exert a certain power throughout it. That is part of the plot of the thing. Like that's exactly so, which I think it does great. And I am thinking about this character for this actress who's in Casina Royale, and yeah, how it's almost like she's not just misunder it's like she has to be much like these others, like taught how to love. And I think it does appeal to this like ooh, I'm into like a childlike innocent, virginal woman. So if this woman has power, she still has to be Calinda. Thank you for parting that in the chat. No one knows we have a chat. That's how you tell me all the secrets. Calinda is her name, that's how. But that's any like a lot of these women, it is very much like this appeal of this kind of woman. So again, even if she has some she has this like something that she can be taught and so she feels younger.

45:07 She feels more like a child, and so that is not particularly appealing for me. Well, Aspen, I think on that note, it's a perfect time to go into the deep dive section. Here we go, There we go. Was I hitting on something that's like because you were making that little face that you make, like that little smile, like you're like, well, have I got something to tell you? Here's a classic Gene roddenberryism from, of course, the one book that I read for my Star Trek research, which, to be fair, this is like the most comprehensive book of any TV show that I've read. You don't have to make an excuse.

45:53 We all know what kind of research use. The Voyages tos season two from Mark Cushman Aspen grab onto a pillow and get ready to throw it. You writing anything down, nah Man. Some of Roddenberry's ideas were added in as well, uh in regards to descript by any other name for Jerome Bixby, including more drama concerning the crew slash slaves being forced to mate. Kirkus is specifically instructed to have sex with a female crew member named Lieutenant Leslie Thompson. Obviously that did not make it to air either way. Rudd and Berry just being obsessed and being like, can the crew have sex more? I think that's interesting. The crew never has sex. I just want to be clear. There's not even like fun consensual sex, not even once. They're too busy working. That's all I know. That's boring. They live there, they don't work all the time. That is something I've thought of a lot with Star Trek, which is Star Trek is like I feel like you have to be on call a lot. Yeah, that sounds like of Armor.

47:07 There's not too much interesting behind the scenes for this week as outside of just Jerome Bixby did a lot of drafts on this through Gene coun and John Mary de Lucas just basically he worked very hard. But the reason that this episode like doesn't kick off sooner is also because NBC wanted Planet shows and a great team. Deal of time is spent on Stage ten, otherwise known as the Planet set to pacify the network. The cameras staying on the planet while we were told about the Enterprise being taken over, so they're on the planet in the cave jail. That's because NBC literally just for some reason like once more Planet action, I want more planet action. It's why the film Star Wars Episode two, Attack of the Clones is so fun. They go to so many planets that are so interesting. Big Waves, Bugs, Sand, an entire planet that is one city. It's one big city, one big city. So I get it. I get in BC. They're like, we want some poline it shit, what did you know? Wow? Did you what? George Lucas's rough draft of Attack of the Clones is dated March thirteenth, two thousand. Filming would begin just two months after the rough draft was complete. That sounds right. They started filming May of two thousand,

48:45 like the very first version of it as in was done. Can you, as someone who understands the process of filmmaking better than me, how long typically would script writing take? That's a great question. It truly depends on project to project. I have a sneaze suspicion that the Marvel machine compressed things to where pre production, script writing and pre production was happening at the exact same time. There's a lot of collaboration. But before all that, scripts would just finish and then you know, get the green light, and then you would go into pre production. So, and I say this, you compare this to the first Star Wars. Yeah, and Empire strikes back in Return of the Jedi a little bit, where I believe the scripts were finished more or less. The structure, the bones were finished a great deal of time before artwork and stuff started, much less shooting. We're talking about like two months beforehand. That means that sets are being built and they still don't have like a locked in script. That's okay, rare, well ah, necessarily anymore, but like at the time, that's weird. Got it? What?

50:14 Why do we think Because George Lucas he said it himself, he doesn't enjoy writing, right, and he's gone to all of his other friends and they don't want to write it, and so he's had to do it. And also maybe because he is the control person that he is right, because we don't know those conversations, but like he just has to do it, and so he just did it. And then like the original Star Wars as well, where Lucas got the idea of Darth Vader from a painting Ralph McCrory did, that's where Darth Vader happened. Because all of this was made up.

50:57 George Lucas did not have it planned out in his head can't restate that enough. He is going to the art department and being like, I think I want to have these sets. They draw the sets, then he goes back write some stuff in because he's inspired by all the work that they're doing and vice versa, and it is it's kind of a circular process where he is going in there being like, I want this. They provided that provides him with ideas that he can then go back to the art department and do that. Additionally, the way that he describes the shooting process that he shot most of the film, it seems like over the course of sixty days, which considering the pipeline for this is wild, considering that they are doing things that on this scale, no film, like no film production had done before.

51:57 From what I understand this side, they Lucas and Team commissioned It wasn't just that they were the first like big budget film to shoot on high Death Aspen. They commissioned cameras to be built. They yeah, they built cameras for this from Panasana Consoni. Everything I've seen obviously, like documentaries I've seen, have you know they're they're being greenlit these kind of behind the scenes pieces huh, Like what documentaries like the From Puppets to Pixels for this one kind of smaller documentaries. Did you watch that? Yeah? Oh fucking god damns.

52:59 Yes, you keep accidentally doing research aspen. But that one, which I greatly enjoyed. I greatly enjoyed the part where he had to decide what Dexter Jester's head was gonna look like, and they had just made a whole bunch of models, and I was like, this is so fun. I'm having a great time watching this. Like there's a lot of like art. I'm gonna be honest, like true creativity in this whole process. When I was a kid, I looked at the the the VHS for the widescreen version of Star Wars Episode one came with its own teeny tiny miniature version of the art of Episode one, and I looked at that book so many times.

53:44 And then not only that, but your god, Dave Filoni, the padored one himself, not my god. You worship him every single day. I worship his hat, But that's a separate entity from him. Sure, Dave Filoni is just a man. The hat kids more than a man. He's a symbol. Yes, obviously, Pilford from previous art, so much pre production art and brought that and made that stuff canonical. The freaking Ghost is based off like a discarded thing from the millennium Falcon, the datha Mere Witches or the Sith Witches that are in the episode one book. Yes, it's so much fun. And they talk about it at least within the Secret History of Star Wars by Michael Kaminski, which is another piece of thing that I'm reading talking about that as like it was pretty now that they had built how these systems had worked on episode one in an expanded way. Now they understand it a little bit more and they can use it to their advantage if that is conducive. Can't imagine because that sounds extremely stressful for people who like need sets to go shoot on and also these things, Oh there's so much blue screen and stuff and like it's yeah, like this is there were more practical shooting on episode one than there was on episode two. Now you have YOUO McGregor and Secrets of the Force. The Oral History talks about like the process

55:16 sucked. It sucked for him because he wanted something to act opposite against. Because it's and you can feel it, and you can feel it in the ones that come out of the prequel is completely unscathed. Are Chris Burley, m and Ian mcdarmott. Yeah, Sam Jackson, you can't even find he's doing the best that he can. Sam Jackson, who never who always manages to get bare minimum a good performance. His charisma is so tamped down. Yeah, even Yoda fucked over. But also fuck Yoda. Yeah, God damn kid. Fisto comes out great. Luminara great until her weird things that she does in Colin Worth and her weird Jedi stupid perspective. It's a whole thing that caused it starts a whole thing thing, I have to tell you.

56:20 Nice uh yeah, And it's very disappointing, especially when you do watch some like behind the scenes of you and McGregor in the first film having the fucking time of his life, like doing uh like uh like practicing for uh like the lightsaber fights, like the final battle with Maul doing it like and you can actually see like the behind the scenes of him, you know, filming it and having like a fucking great time, And so it feels very disappointing to kind of even have gone from that to sort of Yeah, basically monologuing to yourself, which is not great. It's wrong, it's difficult, it is. But also I think it can't be done because you see Christopher Leed doing it well. And also I will say, for when it's worth, I think you McGregor comes out of those unscathed, Like I think he's fine. Yeah, I do. I think truly, like no one was like false at him for this by any means they destroyed Hayden Christiansen and Natalie Portman. Oh yeah, who didn't she have to get like a letter from a previous director to try to even get like cast and stuff again after these films, probably I forget who? Right? Uh? And you know that they're good, like I remembered seeing Have you ever seen the movie Life as a House? Uh? No, no, I have Kevin Klin. Yeah, it's got Kevin Clain's got Hayden Christensen in it. Obviously he plays a

57:52 really great moody teenager. But like I thought, he was so fabulous in that. And I do think that Hayden Christiansen is actually very talented and so it is just a real farmer to watch it happen and watch people kind of be brought down by these things in these moments. With all that said, can I just say sure, just yes please, yes, it's gone. I there is something kind of magnificent and almost like unimaginable about how it that it actually worked, Like they must have had the unless there was a lot going on in the background, but the way it just seemed to me about timelines and having to meet certain deadlines, that people met them, that they got things done. So is there like a project manager out there who's like a wizard on these films that just made it work? Is that what happened?

58:40 Like a secret person who was like, I'm gonna make everything fucking happen, because it did. Honestly, it's got to be Rick McCallum. Maybe, yeah, the producer. I don't. I mean I probably production, actual production, like the production manager. Yes, what are you talking about, Rick McCollum. I'm just here for fun. But I say that, And it's just because there is what you're talking about, the idea of things are being inspired by each other. Art creates something and then that inspires something to happen, and all these things. You can imagine a lot of people would be like this is too chaotic, and yet it seems like it was actually fairly ordered. And again I'm making I am making presumptions based on documentaries that are probably pretty and nicely packaged for me to be like, this looks great, but I don't know, like obviously they got done on time.

59:37 So which is why listening to the blank Check episode digital filmmaking back in their Star Wars days and listening to j Damano talk about how revolutionary this is, because we can't folks that haven't listened to this and are listening to this episode like we are now used to this filmmaking right. We have seen so many behind the scenes videos, but this is where it starts. It's one not only that they're building a brand new pipeline. In a Secrets of the forest, Rick McCallum is talking about how it just with something that is this big and they want to do so many effects shots, it didn't make sense to them to have to film all of it then scan all of it mm hmmm.

1:00:22 And they wanted to shorten the pipeline, which is why they went ahead digital and commissioned. Apparently, the cameras have been in development for seven years trying to get the technology working. I will never forget that. This is when it was all digital. Yeah, I will never forget again. Can you tell uh now that you've said it, you don't feel like I can because you told me. Yeah, so I thought about it, but normal people won't notice. Yes, I mean there's a lot of shots. You know, there's moment it's like that when obi Wan hugs Dexter Jetster, my best friend. Basically they like talk about like animating it where they keep Ewan's head, but then they have to animate the rest of obi Wan's body to be able to hug this creature and just like how wild that is? Again, you're right, like now we're like for sure and at the time, like god, like all of these people so so talented, like so talented.

1:01:30 Oh it's not it's not a good movie, but like you can't fault like these like, oh magnificent, great job people, absolutely absolutely wild, but it works. It's not a good movie. But also just like, don't understand the magnitude of what they're doing, because whenever a movie works visually, like you're never like it just works and very rarely are you just being like I looked hard? Yeah, And also it's really easy for us now to just be like they did it with computers, because there's none an understanding of how complex it is, as opposed to I think whenever optical printing, those kinds of special effects, the things famously of the nineteen eighties, you know, like opticals, yeah before that, but like every time like a like a special effect shot happened there, you're just like, how how did they do that? How? Not computers? It's like this reminds me of every meme that's like me sitting on my couch watching bake Off and being like Barbara, that's a terrible bakewell tart, you know, and like I can't do any better than that. Aspen, Yeah, Aspen. They they received the prototype of the camera, the final prototype of the camera, right two days before they began shooting. My god, whoever was project managing was very stressed out. Production manager was very stressed. Also, this is this quotes

1:03:06 wild from George Lucas. We had water left over from the perfect storm, so we licked the water thing. They just got that the assets from the perfect storm and just made the water for the perfect storm water because we don't think about that because companies build assets. Oh my god, and I just trying to think of when the water happens. Is it on Comino? Yeah, so every like every single time, we don't think about this either because we're just like, oh, computers, but just like it's still computer animation, which means that all it needs to be created. But for some reason we watch traditional animation and just like this is look at the labor that's involved.

1:03:47 Wow or just amazing and computer graphics for some reason, I'll speak for you and me and the world as well, whenever we just see CG we're just like, yep, computers, but like it still has to get built out. All this stuff still needs to get built. Yeah, it's not. It doesn't make it. There are things that are possibly easier about the process, the fact that you don't necessarily have to go uh literally hand draw it and instead can rely on keyframes key frame animation, where you can literally drag assets and great movement just by uh coding it into the computer. M computer stuff your stuff. Cool. Yeah, and also obviously we've said the Civilian times, we know all these things. If it just had an even slightly better script, like in better direction, it would be really good.

1:04:48 You can feel, as we said, people know as we've said in the Phantom Menas episode M this this is a course correction, This is reactionary. Still less jar jar you can feel him course correcting on that one, you get, even though at least according to Secrets of Star Wars um what's the exact quote? Let me here we go, what's the quote? Bubba fet was always tied to the Clone Wars, as was revealed in a banth Attracts issue from nineteen seventy nine. Uh. What so the bubbafests in this one?

1:05:41 Bubbafet Bubba? Where here bubbafets in this one, bulbafets in this one? Uh? And it feels weird because it this feels like, well, this is just a more amounts of action, feel like reactionary things to mean, although it's truly impossible to figure out what is and what isn't reactionary. Yeah, the only thing that we know for sure is that there's less jarj aar in this one. That feels like Lucas being like, I cave okay, Kenny, I'm destroyed by this because once again I'm like, you know, I don't hate the bobas on this because there's this really great bit in Clone Wars fucking back, I know, but I don't like the pandering.

1:06:29 But also I don't hate it. I don't like is it because you just grew up with it? I you know, I watched this I was thirteen. I do remember being a lot less enchanted by it. I was a lot less enchanted by it. I think by the time I got driven into the syth, I didn't like immediately see it when it came out, like it's not maybe like a week or two like in or two three, you know what I mean. Like, I just it was a little less enchanting for me. And in fact, by that point, I think my Star Wars stuff at starts it's sort of fade because I was like, this is fine, and then I might have been I remember i'd still watch like the original series, but then it wasn't. I remember watching the original series, Wrong Franchise RHY, the original trilogy, well I did. I did watch the original series in my early twenties, and then I do remember moving to Austin, so I was like about twenty four twenty five and watching all the like red letter media things of all three of them. Now I'm like, and I mean this with all my heart fuck those guys. No, well yeah, why not. I'm not going to defend them. But also I think there was a time and place for that kind of criticism. I think it's very boring. Now, sorry, it smells gonna hate me for those

1:08:01 still really likes them. It's not their fault. The culture that rose up from them, that's what it is. That's what it is. Because you look at their YouTube content. Sure, I bet if you dug down into their politics it's going to be dicey. But it's not like they're churning out all these video essays. If anything, they're like, let's elevate all these extremely niche vhs gems. Sure, and then every like once every several years they'll put out a video essay which is wild. It's not them, You're right, I think it's like a culture that rises up around them. Feels really weird. I under I understand your discontent. Yeah, but unfortunately so many people will influenced them at being like this is how we analyze films.

1:08:45 They were like, No, very clearly they they pulled the wrong message because very clearly them doing this as a character as opposed to them being themselves, right, them being themselves make the criticism real them doing the same character. I think there's an there's an understanding that they know that this is stupid. Yeah, because they're caring way too much about something. There's also the weird fucking bits about like that are like gross and creepy in character. That's like I should go to the mat for the red letter media stuff like and I get that, Like they're better now. I have a lot of hatred for that. I like remembered being like cool and we're fast forwarding through what the fuck is this? I'm just here for some I don't know, some film analysis anyway. I mean it's really smart for them in the first ten minutes of their episode one review being like, describe these characters without describing what there is. Everybody quotes everybody quotes that now, and I think that is a really great tool to use. That's a good tool anyway, Bubble that bub that he's here, he's here and true. Okay, I'm gonna kind of like thematic connections this a bit between these two per roperties. Yes, like poetry, So if they want except we don't know any of these people.

1:10:15 I'm really I'm kind of stuck a little bit on the infantilization of women piece actually, because I do think if if it is, I'm not going to go to bat for this romance, like my has so much more to do in episode one and it's just and she does. It gets worse and worse, and episode one great. Episode two still pretty great and like in terms, but it's like great in the way that like someone would write a strong female character kind of great, like you got a gun that makes herus tough, but and she's also like I'm in fucking charge. But it's like, you know, So there are those pieces, and then by the third one she's like simpering and it's weird. And the fourth one she's dead. And then she's dead and she's pretty great. In the Clone Wars she's yeah, and and I and I think if this had been written by anyone who actually knew how to write human beings, uh, and wasn't just a horny kid from a desk, not horny kid honestly not literally the opposite of Jeane Roddenberry the like least horny. Episode three does become that one line from Mean Girls, if you have sex, you will get pregnant and die, Yeah, exactly, and it does, it does start to become like Lucas was the opposite of rotten Berry in that regard is name yes, yes, is like what if sex saves the human rights? Everyone being so bangable will be able

1:11:49 to achieve warp drive hat and yah, Lucas is like, no, thanks, Oh I don't think so, I don't think so. Vietnam RT. How do we talk to girls? We tell them are massacred an entire Yeah, yeah, I mean, and there's such a there's such an element there too, And I was like, man, that emotional labor, like the idea that she would be like, let me be present for this person who's sufferings supposed to being like a red fleck. She does feel very much like she is occupying strong female character like like spaces where she does have she like ostensibly has a lot of power which she shows but then in certain but then when it really comes down to it, but bam, right, like she's has no real agency or she's taken in by something very easily, and she feels very like young when she's not. She's been she was a queen at fourteen. She is still young. Yeah, she is young and she but she's made but she's like also we don't know the rules of the star.

1:13:00 We don't like, well, we know the rules that you can become Queen of fourteen and be so beloved that they want to make you queen again. Elect you don't don't don't think na v Navoo. I know. I was just like, interesting, are we really against his fascistic ideas? When you have a weird monarch but you also have a republic. Look, George Lucas currently delivered like the final script to along with the cameras two days before they started shooting, apparently, And so but she feels naive is what she feels like. And so I do think there is a sort of like childish because this movie is navigating the pieces to get it all ready for episode three, right, but like, and people have done this for ages, But I just I do think it's interesting. Like, imagine if you had a story that started more in media as of like you already had, or you had him an older at least like in the first one, that you had more time to develop like a romantic relationship. For the beginning of a romantic relationship, you bet you had this space meat Anakin skywalker here and he's basically a brand new character. And then not only that, but I remember from I think listening to the audio commentaries that that scene of Obi Wan and Anakin the elevators are reshoot. So that's not even like they didn't. That's that's your palette setting of what their relationship is, right, I don't exactly know what was there beforehand, but like, oh, it's funny too, because they

1:14:31 have a great I mean, they have like a complicated but very interesting relationship in Clone Wars. Let's post this movie that's after this. Yeah, that's that's Lucas being in response to all of it and being like, what else didn't I do? Right, and then also taking the lesson that he didn't employ here, which is work with a collaborator, And it just so happens that he lucked into a collaborator who was like, You're vision is sacred, it's true. Now let me kind of yes and that vision and expand on that and do great things with it, and with someone who actually like understands emotions and dialogue and like character motivations a little bit better. But there is a clear we're not talking about Clone Wars is yet. We'll do that like a month or so, I I mean, I think there is a constant sort of push and pull of like what does power really look like, especially for women or for minority or like marginalized people, and these properties, Like I think it comes up a lot with women like it, and it to me, it always looks like and Star Trek. It always looks like these women have power, but they don't. And they are the ones. They're childlike and in that way they are more appealing. They have to be won over and then taken care of. And I think it comes from Yeah, I think it comes from a place of paternalism. And I think it's exactly

1:16:03 what happens to Padme here, which is just such a shame, because she is a fascinating interesting character, could be you know, and you could tell and you could have a complex relationship, but like, if you don't know how to fucking have relationships and write them, then you're not going to make it. And here we're starting to touch on I think the commonality between these two Proper Days are these two particular episodes, which is both of them being about emotions driving you right. Oh, yeah, I mean that's again, and we know how I feel about the way Jedi emotions. Yeah, I mean, I think Jedi view emotions the way Vulcans like, like, we know my feelings on Vulcans too, which is that they're like no or like spos version, which is like you know, like no, and it's like but you're so driven by it, Like you're so driven that in fact, because you say that this thing, we are like adopting non attachment, which you're not not a good version of it, like you were actually truly dominated by the thing, like if you actually were, like, feelings are fucking real, Like of course you'd want to know that your mother is okay, she use your mother and you take a child and you're just like forget about your mother, like what the fuck? And then just like you have you watched this Star Trek Discovery season three, No, there's first off, I think you should watch it, Okay, I think I think you'd be okay starting with Star Trek Discovery season three and then like watching on and anytime you

1:17:34 have a question, just like ask me uh because it's a pretty hard reset. But also they do something that is very interesting with the Vulcans. Cool in that season and good it changed, It changes the game in a pretty interesting way. Anyways. Yeah, but yeah, both of these things being like emotions will be the downfall of something. In Star Trek's case, it's well emotions, well, emotions are pretty help the day and then they learn how to manage it. Here, emotions are the downfall of Anakin Skywalker textually, even though extra texturally you're like, no, the systems set them up to fail and all of these things, but the movie is telling us it's because he's got these attachments. Well, yes, that is what the movie is saying. You're that's what even though Clone Wars probably says that's not necessarily wrong. No, I mean it's it's it's what Lucas is saying. And then if we kind of take it, I do think that there are ways, like just taking this as an individual film. Before I even watched Clone Wars, I had this rant about like man as an individual movie, this, this, this is bad this plus I mean this plus you know, like that it's got stimulus the prequel trilogy in and of itself, Like my my rant is always he was literally set up by the Jedi to fail, Like yes, their whole approach is like they're the ones that helped fuck themselves

1:19:15 over and this approach, this idea of like a prophesied kind of savior and then to still persist in their philosophy in a very particular case, like it's not that he's too old, it's that he literally was raised enslaved, his mother remained enslaved. He had very legitimate feelings and emotions around the thing, and nobody gave a shit and nobody was actually truly like present in it in a way that mattered. Of course, he's not mall it's because he's not, because he's not malleable exactly, and and that that's very damning, right because the Jedi suck like and they do set him up to fucking fail.

1:19:57 This movie would have been much better if there had been even more, if there have been like way more stuff with him in Palpatine, but actually is like a person who's engaging with his emotions and talking to him about his mother, and you know what I mean. But did you like it when the Calvins turned the crew into rock people? It's a little rocks, Yes, I did. I wish that there was more to engage with in this episode of by any other name, I know I mean, but there it's just as already said, it's the same thing. The rocks are pretty cool. He does crumple up a yeoman. He turns her into a rock and then crumples her up and kills her. It's Grossu's a rock. At first, I was like, oh, he killed the black guy. Nah, black Guy's still alive. He has one line, but at least he's still alive.

1:20:47 Good black guy. It's pretty wild. You get one like every ten episodes. Yeah, and then Rodenberg gets to pat himself on the back right right, right, So yeah, I did like the rocks. Actually, when I realized they could turn them into rocks, I was like, oh, and I was like, but I was also still like, they still don't seem like they're that Like you truly could just get the belts. I don't see why this is so hard. Well, it's because they can freeze them. Okay, they can frae them. They can press their button and freeze. Can you remind me what happened? I must have looked away or something, because they don't they get Kalinda's belt when he karate chops her when he kisses it later, don't they get her belt? Sure? Yeah?

1:21:31 Why not? Or something? But then it's like, oh no, we can't like freeze this guy, right, and then they take and that's when he like kills the yeomen and stuff. But it's just like, why is this so hard? Anyway, I'm fine, I forget it. It's because it creates tension and this is the conflict and I'm not gonna not gonna split hairs. Sure. I think that's pretty much everything that we have to do in the podcast, right, Yeah, I think we get into it there. Probably unless you had a better idea a long time ago. Start dating this week. I quoted a boat, I dated a GEP, but none of them could work my drive into high birth space. The best of both worlds kept me in the second place. Captain's log on a hollow chron I wanted a snog. I penned a song seventeen more minutes advise in super high def aboard the USS Enterprise DT. Don't you take my walk lighter and clip it? Don't you take my wretchered buddy and nip it. If you spill the tea, I'm gonna sip it. Starship it mm hmm A long time

1:23:04 ago. Oh that's right. We have to do Starship every single time. Aspen We've been doing this podcast for more than a year now, been doing I Starship It for not that long, but enough of a sizeable amount of time. Uh huh, you know, yeah, your partner what? Your partner what? Who jowel your partner? Comedy? Okay, starship it. Although you had a proposition, I do have a proposition. Okay, we're going to do both. We're okay, have this. We're gonna go.

1:23:48 We're gonna sip through this. We're gonna whip through it fast. Uh. I still want to do I Starship It, so we'll talk because I have to talk about this ship. Okay, round spaceships, romantic ships. And then I am for sure when to quickly go through the fifteen outfits padme, Amma dollawares in this film and rank them. I have the list already, Okay, Okay, can I not to steal something from you? I don't think this is we don't have time, Oh god, oh god. Okay, I'm going to read a text. This is our podcast, and we can go as hon as we want as long as we've got no time.

1:24:29 We have no time to tarry, no time, So I do have to read. I'm going to read a text to you, because I think it describes exactly how I feel about this ship. I can't find it. Basically, It's what I said was oh, I actively moaned when they showed Dooku's Solar Sales ship definitely not my ship. They shoot off of Geonosis and then out from the front of his ship erupts this beautiful solar sail. It looks liquid and then it just expands outward and then it just carries them through and I literally forgot that it happened, and I out loud went, oh, I love Solar Sales. I just love the concept. I love the idea.

1:25:26 I love how it's put there. There's another one there's and it's like it's almost like it's not the ship itself, it's the sail. And I also feel this way about Obi Wan's like sort of like like hyperdrive like assist that he uses, like he like puts his little ship into it and then it uses. It's not like part of the ship itself. Oh, that perfectly segues into my ship, which is clearly superior ship, the Jedi Starfighter. Fair. I do fucking love a tryangle. It's a little it's a little star destroyer. You know, visually indicating the slow into fascism with pre existing knowledge, right, but also like it's tiny and little, and he goes to, you know, have a sweet fight in the asteroid belt where they're playing with sound in such an absolutely wonderful, spectacular, beautiful way.

1:26:14 Oh stop, oh my god. We actually I just have to talk about that real quick. That to me is worth everything in this film. The like weird like sonar grenade things like the sound grenades that Django does, and then Boba does that weird little evil laugh. Fuck, it's so good. Ben Burt got his paycheck that week. Oh my god, Oh my gosh. Great, love that and love that ship. Nice, excellent, excellent, But we don't have time to Terry and the Jedi start fighting the ships. Go me, Oh fuck out, god, you know what, Kenny, here we go. I'm going to do it. You know what I'm going to do. You know what I'm about to do? Right, it's Anakin and padme a bad man. Yeah. If only for the music, if only for the theme. The love theme truly, to me, one of the most beautiful love themes I've ever heard. I think it is just as good as the Han and Leyah love theme. And you know what, our ships aren't always healthy, they're not always great, and I think I ship it. I weirdly do. Maybe they deserve each other. I don't know. Yeah, anyway, she does that cute thing where she like they roll around in the grass and then she's on top of him and you're like, it gets a uh speaking of unlimited power himself. She Palpatine and count

1:27:46 Dooku sheep every time. I always forget his name is SHEIV don't don't act like you don't think that Whenever they get in quarters uh huh they fucking Dooku likes to get strapped in that spinny thing and she just keeps going, do it do what? Do? What do you act? Do? What do you? Played by the incredible chrisphal Ly, who look Lucas is famously not an actor's director. And Chris really is able to sell all this terrible dialogue. Yeah, he's pretty fabulous. He is able to be The line where he runs into Obi Wan is like, please, there's been a terrible mistake.

1:28:30 Apologize, And there's like actual character decision and wit behind it, Like there's actual performance as opposed to I think every other single line in the movie, and you're just like, oh, hello, so someone's doing some acting here, which is not anyone's fault. Just might be Lucas being like I respect you Christ really, you do whatever you want to. I think it's why even though it is a little like who the fuck's this guy, it still works because of his grind atass. Yes, like it's kind of fabulous, you know. Anyways, Douku is obviously the biggest boy in the room. Watson gravity is so whenever he meets Sheep Balpatinas like yeah, this like this, he thinks he can tell me what to do. Yeah, real enemies to love our strope. And I think that Doo is probably a real like bratty bottom, you know, perfect, I love it. Okay.

1:29:27 Plus he's got a curved lightsaber hill like a penis sick sick, Oh, just like everybody's penis. Yeah do you think everybody's Can you vamp while I quickly go to the doctor real fast? Okay? Uh, speaking of penises, let's rank compare. Well, I'm not nearly as good as those segways as you are. Okay, we're gonna whip through this. Speaking of penises, we're gonna went through the whipped this out. Obviously, this is not a visual media, so this is gonna be nearly as interesting, but I will do my best. There are fifteen outfits in this film that Padme wears.

1:30:15 I'm gonna start with number fifteen. Corossant apartment nightgown. It's fine, it's very cool. She's mostly sleeping and then almost getting bit by weird books. It's mostly just kind of like a billowy thing she wears. That's fine. Great. Fourteen in a deleted scene, there's a family visit gown where she's wearing like almost like a jasmine thing, and it is it's pretty hot, but it like it's like too much. Is it's too weird, it's too weird. I watched that deleted scene earlier today. It's weird. It's too weird, weird outfit. Yeah, it just doesn't it doesn't work. I don't think it's like almost Yeah, it's like two jasmin in a way that feels bad. I'm cleaning from an assassination plot and obviously went back to my original home. Yeah, right, who'd find me here with my parents?

1:31:04 Right? No one will find me here. It's fine, it's fine, Okay. Randon nightgown robe. It's when she comes out when they're like and he's like meditating and he's like had scary dreams. And basically I put it here because it's lovely. She's wearing a pretty robe. Fine, oh yeah, if the hair were part of the outfit, it would be higher ranked. There's so much hair. It is luscious, it is curly, it is gorgeous. Okay. Twelve Genosis Arena Battle outfit. It's pretty fine. It's okay. I don't actually don't hate it at all. I think it famously becomes ripped off so she can get a little bit of belly in there. So but pretty good, pretty solid like it. Then I said, she's got a cape, the cape, So what actually makes it?

1:31:48 I would say that's what makes it a little bit like higher than the others. Number eleven the Naboo Pilot disguise. Pretty good. Looks like she's about to go ride a horse, which I'm into, or fly a plane. She might do that. Her hair is like really well braided. You're like, boots are good. It's like a beautiful red. The pants are love it like deep brown leather. We like it. We have a good time. Ten the tattooine cape dress. So she wears this like beautiful blue dress when she's staying with the Lars family, in contrast to the family pausic gown, which is like a white kind of greenish blue that's no, no, no, thank you. But this is like this deep rich blue and has like beautiful embroidery all over it. Oh loved it. Fantastic cool. We're halfway through. Can you take this out faster? Nine? The black corset fireside dinner gown where they're like, we can't do this. I don't think it's as like visually, I think there's something about it where like it's really sexy and it doesn't make any sense that she's like wearing this to just chill out, but like it's so hot, like it like cinches in and it goes up and it does this like she's got like this choker thing happening.

1:33:11 Beautiful, beautiful. I'm doing this all from memory. By the way, that is a weird the fireplace outfit, Yeah, that was famously that was the only outfit that was actually designed by George. Looks really near lying lying, you're not lying, lying. I should have put a little bit lower than but I think I liked that it was. I think it just it seems a little dommy, and I like that, you know, I like that cool. Oh wait, I might have like confused a couple I've got okay, no, you know what, I've got tattooing poncho dress on air.

1:33:51 I might have confused some. This might be I might have confused. I've got a cape dress and a poncho dress, and I can't remember what the difference was. I be that the multiple outfits on Tatooine, the poncho dress might actually be the beautiful blue one. I'm because I was surprised they put that so low that one actually might be that one. And it might be that the cape dress is like whatever she's wearing when she they first get to the lar's place. So that's probably it, and it's the We'll say the poncho dress is the eight, which is this beautiful blue thing that's like got great seven wedding gown. Love it, beautiful lace, it's got a pretty veil, has a great time. She touches a weird metal hand with it. You like it? I like it. I think it's lovely.

1:34:31 I think it's like well suited to like getting married in Italy. Basically I like that. It's lazy, Okay. Then we go to there's this deleted scene that's like her like talking to the Senate. She's wearing this wild outfit that's like very reminiscent of like Episode one, stuff like very luxurious, very beautiful. So I'm putting that one at number six. If you're not familiar, I can always send a picture. Then after that, it's like she comes in and she's talking to them, and she's got it's like the Loyalist Committee, like purple Senate robe one. So in that one, that's the one where she's got the hair that's slightly questionable, like because it's a little bit like what's going on here, but it's like it kind of pulls back and it's got like that big kind of flat bun thing. And it's when she comes in and talks to Palpatine, like she comes in after she's almost died, and it's just like this really cool, she's a lot problematic, she almost died, she almost died. H Then the meadow picnic gown is number four. Beautiful. We love it. We love her little like Leah esque kind of like weaved things around her hair on the sides, like those little bulbous things that are like like netting. Love it. We love that it's it makes her glow. She's clearly an autumn. She's like a soft autumn. She looks great in this color, looking great rolling around in the grass. Love it three packing gown where she's packing, and she's also got like the wild hair, and it's like silver, and it kind of has like almost like a corset that's like straight down like almost like this older like like I don't know what like years it would be, but it's almost like

1:36:03 straight down corset. And it's when Anakin's like complaining to her and she's packing, and she's just like, oh wow, sounds hard, bro. That gown sounds hard. Bro, I am packing because I almost died. Yeah, exactly. Lot. She's got to get down to like a bunker. Yeah, I know. She's got shit to do, like go visit her family. Second travel refugee disguise. Ooh my dude. It's very benadjuster. It's very like what Lady Jessica ends up in like and like done too. Like everything she's wearing again wearing like a gold type color. Beautiful, looks fabulous on her she glows. You'd think I might make this one lower because it's not actually like very like flashy because she's a refugee, right, she's traveling. Something about it is just glorious to me, and I love it.

1:36:56 The moment I saw it, I mean, I've seen it before, but the moment I saw this time, I was just like, oh, yes, which brings us to number one. The lake dress, also known as that I hate sand dress, the one that's like beautiful and flowy and like pink and blue and it like comes down and it like sort of comes up but like along her chest and kind of like is on her arms. You know what I'm talking about. Yes, of course I do. Of course you do. Of course you do. That is the number one had my Amidella outfit from Attack of the Clones, absolutely glorious. When I was thirteen years old, I drew that dress like I like would I would sometimes be like a draw dresses and stuff that I really liked that one. I was like boh, sketch book time. Loved the way it flowed, loved the way it folded. Anyway, there's my ranking. Do you still like me? I don't love you as you kidding. Cool up, thanks very, thanks very letting me do all that. Well, that's not all I love. As we finally go to the main conceit of our podcast, which is better Star Wars or Star Trek, by asking which is better Star Wars Episode two, Attack the Clones versus by any other name? Aspen? Yeah, starting with by any other name? Out of a zero to ten scale, what do you rank it by any other name? Five point eight?

1:38:29 Five point eight? I think I'm just I was just a little bored. I was just a little bored by it. I understand it was fun, it was fun. They did some fun things. I just I gotta go with my heart as well. You should, because art is not objective, it is subjective. I am going to give this episode six point five for I believe the exact same reasons. But I do think that it picks up quite nicely in the end and we get some good shenanigans. It feels much like a It feels like a week first season episode, the beginning of second season episode. It feels like a weaker version of that. Yeah, yeah, that's that. But we move on to Star Wars Episode two, Attack the Clones Aspen on as you're to tail scale. What do you rank this puppy? O kitty? Who am I? Who am I? Who's always a great way to start off ranking one of these things. What did I give the phantom mess? Last week? You gave it a six point four and then in the first time that we ranked it six point five. I'm giving this here we go. I can't believe I'm doing this no way aspen us six. That's a gentleman's sex. You're like, it's certainly not a gentleman, perhaps a tramp on the street. Sure, I'm gonna give it a two point eight. That's fine. I I there's some cool visuals,

1:40:08 but please do not misunderstanding. I'm not using this as a to adopt the parlance of the children today. I actually cringe during some of this dialogue because it is. It pains me. It pains me. My soul is an agony. I can't I believe. I can't believe. Yeah, but like say it say with the boys, use the boy, use the voice. It is, in my very thoughts, haunting me. It definitely sound like you're from you from little Italy in Toronto. I don't know something about the way it talks as just like I killed them. I can't do it, my impression, but the women and the children, the children, it's not even his mouth acting. I am I'm thinking about They cut to that scene on the sofa, and I genuinely am instantly cringing. Oh, it's great because just thinking about it. So they've cut to a scene and they are just it is instant tension where you're not, oh, it doesn't make any sense. Non're we doing? What are we doing? Yes? And that scene starts at an eleven in terms of emotionality, and it's very uncomfortable and

1:41:42 not in a way where it's Lucas being like, it's I'm challenging you, I'm challenging the status quo. I love it. No, it's just yes, because they believe Lucas is he he is not good at this writing a simular of what a love story is. Because what was I doing while I was watching this movie? I mean, I was just watching this movie. I wasn't distracted. I know you made that funny joke. I wasn't distracted. I just was having a good time. That's good. I'm glad. What the fuck was happening with me? Great question? Anyways, Star trek whin's the week? Oh fine, it's fine, I'm fine. Yeah, that's how I feel, too, GREENO. But perhaps your spirits would be lightened by opening it up. It's the track Wars mailbike mailbacks of course, Arizona, Mark, my Arizona. Mark wrote in Mark Vimper The Whole dough Maneuver podcast, who are running the Imperial March Badness bracket all this month in March twenty twenty four in regards to not necessarily our previous episode, Well, no, it is up on the Patreon at this moment because we talked about Mark liberally in that episode, and Mark Vimber comments, Mark Vimber sounds like

1:43:12 a cool guy, at least going to the way you all talk about him. I agree, yeah. And then in regards to our animals chat from the previous episode and the mail bank uh, Mark also writes Tobias was my favorite Animals character by the way, I still remember him getting stuck as a hawk, and that in animals terms, that was called anthlet ah lit. I'd forgotten, I'd forgotten. And if you two would like to contribute little tidbits like that in a little private channel that's not our email or social media, sign up for our Patreon Patreon dot com slash trek Wars Pod, where for just a measly five dollars a month you can care early access to episodes and extended versions of episodes and joined the fine auspices of fine folks such as timber To Sosa, Emily Brice, Love, Heidi Rogers, Kevin Miller, Arizona, Mark, Ryan Hill, Aaron Science and certainly, lastly, but not leastly, Jolty Partner. Thank you so much for your patronage. We genuinely appreciate it helps us keep the lights on and keep us using this soundboard.

1:44:16 What do you have to say about that gredo? No, I don't that you could have said anything else there. Additionally, if you don't feel like contributing money that you have sweat, leaden and toiled over, uh, you can email us trek Warsplot at gmail dot com or visit our social media handles on Blue Sky and Instagram at trek Wars POD's on Twitter sort of if you want, I don't know whatever, It's fine, don't whatever. I don't know it. Sometimes I know everyonans I know. I have to go to Twitter to hear if allegedly Kate Middleton is dead or not? I don't know. So you don't know because you haven't been on Twitter. What's happened anyway? Go on? Uh, well, if you're trying to ascertain what the heck happened, why don't you visit our website track wordspod dot com and figure out all the latest stuff that's happened. And while you're at it, why don't you click over to the reviews tab leave us a review on the podcatcher of your choice. Our theme song was written by the great toastin Ouri Festo, where you can get more of his work in the show notes, and our I starship theme was written by the marvelous Joel tea partner and the co host with the host of course is Aspen T. Webster. That is true? That is actually my Oh yeah it is, isn't it? It is? Tea of course stands for do you want me to say it?

1:45:43 For real? Oh? You do it literally whatever you want? And Aspen yeah, let me would you this final quote? Yeah, he's in his own world. Mark Hamill observed in two thousand and five he's like William Randolph Hurst or Howard Hughes. He's created his own world and he can live in it all the time. You really see that in his films. He's completely cut off from the rest of the world. You could see a huge difference in the films that he does now in the films that he did when he was married. Marcia would tell him when he was wrong. No, he's so exalted that no one tells him anything. And that's why it's important to have friends like Aspen Webster in my life. Yeah, all those times I tell you you're wrong, like about Casino Royal Right, Aspending, it's a bad movie. Whatever, am I dude? Whatever? I love you anyway.

1:46:44 I love you too, Aspen. Uh, live long and prosper. And then before it's beak with you, it's we love you, Ma Conkey Maconkey