Feb. 16, 2024

Star Wars vs. The Immunity Syndrome

Star Wars vs. The Immunity Syndrome
Star Wars vs. The Immunity Syndrome
Trek Wars Podcast
Star Wars vs. The Immunity Syndrome

MACLUNKEY!

Kenny gives a tiny history lesson about where Star Wars comes from and how it takes a village to make a movie.

Meanwhile, Aspen REALLY likes the episode where the Enterprise fights a Space Amoeba™ (thanks in part to her boyfriends)....

MACLUNKEY!

Kenny gives a tiny history lesson about where Star Wars comes from and how it takes a village to make a movie.

Meanwhile, Aspen REALLY likes the episode where the Enterprise fights a Space Amoeba™ (thanks in part to her boyfriends).

And we dive deep into the Great Man Narratives™ with Gene Roddenberry and ESPECIALLY George Lucas as the Special Edition serving as major historical revisionism. Can he ever be stopped?!

_________________

Get early, extended episodes on our Patreon at https://www.patreon.com/trekwarspod

Theme by Tosin Awofeso

Social Media:
https://www.instagram.com/trekwarspod
https://bsky.app/profile/trekwarspod.bsky.social

Want to ask us questions? Email us at trekwarspod@gmail.com .

And leave us a review! https://bit.ly/leave-a-review-trek-wars

0:27 Welcome to the Trek Wars Podcast, the Internet's primary solution. We're trying to answer the most important question in fandom, which is better Star Trek or Star Wars. We're going through both franchises in chronological release order, and today boil boy Man, old Man, Guy, Oh guy, I think we've got a humdinger of an episode. I am Kenny Madison is the Star Trek contingent of this podcast and with me Esper always must be. Uh, George Lucas, I just want you to know that I'm so proud of this new remastered version of my film. Every frame is packed full, uh, and the poetry is still rhyming. It's it's so dense, every single so much going on. That's right. Of course we're talking about Star Trek, the original series, the amenity syndrome. Yeah. Also just kidding. I'm so sorry.

1:26 I know I totally fooled you, but it's me, Aspen, it was it's me. I wasn't George Lucas. Did did I? Did I? Did I get yet? Yeah? I was confused the entire time. Wow. Wow. And also I guess we are talking about Star Wars the Special Edition? Well, yes, that famous episode the Immunities Syndrome versus Star Wars A New Hope remastered. That's I guess technically nineteen ninety seven, but whatever it was on Disney Plus, so whatever ten billion other remasterings they've done since then, that's true. I believe there have been four different versions of the Special Edition, Yeah, because with each one they tighten up the gredo han shooting even more, and then you're like, really shot first, Well, it's an important question of my life. Well, yes, okay, so let's uh huh, let's get into it. Oh, let's get into it because essentially we're much like Community season five, we're repiloting. Yeah, do you know who's a pilot? Did a really good pilot, like like a great pilot, like such a good pilot that they literally just let him fight immediately with like no reil back check. Look Skywalker, looks Skywalker, look Skywalker. They just like put him in an X Wing and they're like you sure you can do this? And I was like, yeah, I

2:58 think. Goodness the Internet didn't exist in nineteen seventy seven, or else it would just be intolerable. I would be insufferable. I have a thought every time I watched Star Wars every time, I'm like, because I love I love. Sorry just to tell real quick, I fucking love Star Wars. I don't know if you know this about me. Well, yes, allegedly, allegedly, I have to say allegedly, because you can't because of that, you can't legally hold it against me, right right, right, right, right, right right. I've heard that you're the Star Wars contingent of the podcast I am. And I was crying at the end of Star Wars and New Hope. I was just like, looking at the friend. I get that they could have died and they saved each other like sobbing, but all I could think was a love you, Luke, my sweet little boy.

3:53 And I was thinking. I was just like, eh, dude, a kid. He was just like a little kid from Modesto. Oh, I mean tattooed and and he did it. And then I was like, but fuck, ray, am I right? Anyway? Yeah, that's right, it's fine, it's fine. I'm fine. Stop looking at me that way. I'm fine. Didn't literally stop it, stop it. I see it. You're worried about me. That's right, it's fine, Yeah, that's right. I'm gonna be okay speaking of fine for people that are playing the whole version the home game, rather of the course podcast. For this repilot, let's provide some synopsis for dmunity syndrome, and in the unlikely event that someone has not watched Star Wars, those synopsis for Star Wars. Sorry, star Wars episode four a new hope. I have a better idea of reading something off. Maybe we can replace this in posts. But what I'm going to do right now is I'm going to play the audience reactions to seeing the special edition of Star Wars at the cinema in nineteen ninety seven. Get ready as the curtain came up and the new and improved Star Wars was finally unveiled. The one family talked to it was anything less they make stick.

5:11 It was awesome. It was great. The new special effects were great. Everybody in the audience notices them, and everybody screams, and it's so much fun. You get to see Bigs and and uh Uke Skywalker interact. That was something new. Once you get to see all the whole fleet fly out towards the Death Star. Very exciting. Sound was so loud. I could actually feel the vibration. I never thought I were experiencing anything like that. This is great. This was just I mean, I knew the ending, but I was right there at the end of my seeing Your scenes are spread throughout the movie, so it's not like in one's part of it, and it's great. It's just great. The sound picture, the quality, the negative, the way that everything was nice together. Oh my gosh, go see the movie is on. You're welcome. I love that. Can you please send that video to me? Drop it in the chat because that is fabulous and also important context yep were how the special editions were released at the time, because the special editions helped put Star Wars back on top in terms of financial gain. Yep. And it was at least the first in the re release was gargantuate, right. It was funny because well, and we'll get into this. In ninety seven, I was seven eight years old and I famously, as what I've said on this podcast before, had never seen Star Wars and I did not watch them. I had no idea that was happening too. I was too focused on the Spice Girls and being moved around to various places as a child against my will. And it wasn't until,

6:45 of course, nineteen ninety nine when The Phantom Menace came out that I saw Star Wars for the first time. So I was not aware of this as an experience, unlike that child who said that it was so loud that she could feel the seat shaking. But that is how I felt watched the Phantom Menace. It's worth anyway agree that's outstanding context. So this was whenever you got around to watching Star Wars for the first time. These were probably the version, well, at least the ninety seven versions were probably the versions. No, because I got the videos from the Blockbuster and they were the originals. You remember this well because I it wasn't until later in my life that a fucking scene with Jaba like you inserted that. I remember watching Star Wars later and that's showing up and being deeply like confused. I was like, this is not I never saw this. What is going on? Yes?

7:46 So I that to me, And there's a couple of other things says to me. I watched the original versions because I watched them on VHS, and I think in nineteen ninety nine, it stands to reason that they wouldn't They might not have those like they might even they might not have you know, Yes, I yeah, I feel like the videotapes came out. They must have come out around my birthday, which is in September, September twenty fifth, the same day as Mark Hamill's, just because I remember that happening with Star Wars. Either that or I'm wrong, which is entirely possible. I do do research, but sometimes I'm wrong. Yeah, Blockbuster already has Star Wars. Why would they want to buy new versions? Right? But that's money that they don't have to send, and I yeah, absolutely, I just I have to tell you I had not watched the actual remastered versions until yeah, later in life, whenever I might have gotten DVDs or bought them or I don't know, yep, genuinely, because I just remember it being bewildered and then immediately being like, how can I find an original version of this that is not this? Yeah? Yes, uh real quick, I want to get this on the record. Was just some quick synopsis just because of the structure of the podcast, right, well, that was a synopsis.

9:11 Oh, that was my synopsis. That's my synopsis. Okay, that's my smittal for synopsis for this episode, because because everybody knows, you know, what you're right, then let me counter okay with The Immunity Syndrome Star Trek Star Trek the original series. The Immunity Syndrome written by Robert Savara, directed by Joseph Pebney, Joseph Pevney's final directorial credit for Star Trek the Original series. And this episode was definitely released, which is great. Sure, yeah, that's true. Yep, I liked it. I can't self your frozen or you're just waiting, you're just letting that one just lie there.

10:05 Released on January nineteenth, nineteen sixty eight. Cool and from a TV Guide synopsis published January thirteenth, nineteen sixty eight, and The Humanity Syndrome, The Enterprise assumes the role of an antibody as it penetrates a oneself organism eleven thousand miles long. The energy draining Invader has already annihilated an entire Star system and is about to reproduce like Me on Thursdays. This episode features psychedelic special effects created by Frank Vanderveer. Thank you so much, tv Guide, also uncredited polished by John Meredith Lucas. So thank you, Frank, Thank you, Frank. Wow, we don't recognize our VFX artist nearly enough. We truly, truly do not. Especially with Star Trek Star Wars. I feel like the VFX folks are a little bit more famous, but like a little bit but like Star Trek, tell me outside of Frank Vanderveer, tell me who did the special evcts for it. I don't know, but I want to thank whoever made Pizza Rock I want to thank them. Thank you, Pizza Rock Man, thank you or or lady or probably or Lighty or Lighty but probably not. Yeah, unfortunately no now, Aspen, Yeah, Aspen,

11:39 No, Kenny. We have had it brought up in the past before. Why did the podcast this way? Ah, it's a thing that we've litigated on this podcast before with each other. Yeah, why why do it in chronological release order? Why do this? And the answer is that you kid have weird, weird connections between a random episode of Star Trek and yeah this and then Star Wars A New Hope remastered? Is that the main reason? Yeah, I think serendipitous connections, Yes, sandipitous connections. And also it's fun to play the mental exercise of what the Star Wars being in its just pulling a random number out of my head, like sixty third installment and Star Trek being in its sixty third installment, and for some reason, both of these creators, both of the people in charge of both franchises just sitting down and being like, Okay, this is the sixty third story we've told.

12:39 It has to be this type of story. That's funny. And then also we have actually run into that before where we were like, why on this episode are they telling the same story like the Freaking Cat's baw versus the other the ewok Halloween episode, and we just incidentally happened to do that. Yeah, it's weird whenever that happens. Yeah, and also funny when there are now two Star Trek episodes that are basically Star Trek the Motion Picture or Star Trek the Motion Picture is those two episodes. Yeah, but that's does have to do with comparison. That's just me making a statement I do. I mean, I can't initially find many thematic comparisons between these things. But if we are, if we are repiloting this podcast by cleaning our palette of e walks androids, I have to talk to you about something. Sure, here we go. I'm so glad we went. We went through e walks and joy no, hear me out. I'm here and you're out. I'm so glad we went three walks androids. What an experience, What a completionist kind of experience to have? Which is your cup of tea? Are? That is? If someone would be like, describe Kenny, I'd be like, cutie pie, completionist. If you're wondering if I'm gonna buy a ticket to go see Madam Webb, your darn right, I'm gonna buy a ticket.

14:09 I gotta finish it. Got it? You're gonna say it twice? Yeah, because the first time I have to watch it because I'm experiencing the visceral thrill. And the second time I gotta be like, now it's time to take it in. Oh my liabi, I'm not I'm not quite a completionist, which is probably you know, it goes with its own benefits. But I respect you and your vision, and I'm also my Lucasian vision. Yes, yes, Lucasian God. I hope that's that's it. It's real. It's real. Word. I'm so glad we're done waits and joys. I'm so glad we're dyed. Yes, uh, and we are entering into the new phase of Trek Wars where we are basically we're basically what we're repiloting.

15:13 We're repiloting. We're repiloting, much like the Star Wars franchise basically repiloted itself. Clever, clever, look at us, we're the same. Yes, let me talk about my experience about watching the special editions freaking act you kidding me? Get to see Star Wars in its theater. Star Wars was literally the first movie that I ever watched on this planet, videotape of all three Star Wars films, and then my mom will grow do things in the other room and just kind of put Star Wars on twenty minutes at a time. Free love Star Wars. There's no time where I don't remember a time having not watched Star Wars so too, and then growing up and hearing the stories that my dad told about watching the original in a very sparsely attended theater with his cousin Jeff, not Jeff Webster, that's my dad different Jeff. How does he spelled his name with a jay or g j wow, not the British fancy why oh oh alah. But hearing my dad taught to tell the story about watching Star Wars and no one being in the theater and then the freaking Star Wars logo explodes on the screen and both of them just being like, what is this movie? Immediately? And I wanted to experience that on the big screen. And then for my freaking ninety seven so I would have been in January of ninety seven, so I would have been eight years old, yep, and all just hearing that there were new scenes for Star Wars.

16:49 You kidding, make new special effects, The Outrider is going to be in it. I got it real quick. That you were talking about and other people are talking about actually doesn't remind me a lot of except for the seeing it on screen part. The special editions of the Lord of the Rings films, which I was rabbit to get my hands on when they were released. Rabbit and I dare say the extended editions Lord of the Rings don't necessarily stick out as much of sore thumb some of the changes here in the special edition, but we'll litigate that later on our other podcast, watch Lord of the Rings ten minutes at a time. Yes, which compare Lord of the Rings to something later, but We're not talking about Lord of the Rings right now. We're talking about Star Wars special edition amped for these movies. Yes, I saw it, remember waiting in line, friggy loved it, watched it. It got the box set things too. You know, my family seeing me for the dork that I was whenever I was growing up, and just getting me Star Wars stuff. Uh, freaking love to these things.

17:59 And then, as all clitical teenagers and do growing up, realizing that George Lucas had hidden the original theatrical cuts from us? How dare he criminal? Robbing us of our cultural heritage? How dare he ruining my childhood? But I was using much more severe language because I was a teenager. Ooh, like what give me an example. I genuinely don't want to say it because it's repugnant language. Were you like fucked deck guy? Oh? No more a salty fucked that guy a lot? Yeah that's it? Yeah, yes.

18:42 And then watching the special editions now as a thirty five year old man, Oh, I like the kids probably like it. This is funny that because I do remember very ferociously, like I told you, like I when I forgot to play the first impressions scene. Oh there we go, like I do. I obviously repugnant language, it's not appropriate, but there is something to like the anger of having something hidden from you like that for you and me. Yes, it also I'm ninety five percent sure that the general audience is like you mean, there weren't Peter graphics in the original, but like I find like most of them A probably don't watch the original Star Wars anymore. Well, yeah, because it's like you have to find it like we do. Which is is it actually hard? Right? Use like wayback machine or something I can't remember? We haven't I got I've got resources, right, I'll send you Google drive folder. But I feel like I also had my sources when I was like time to rewatch Star Wars, and I very deliberately would find preah, yeah, the like pre specialized editions because that's what I wanted to watch. I it's it feels very much to me like

20:17 a predecessor to the media and the true digital and non physical age of of like editing and deleting and changing, and it feels very death feels very dangerous and nefarious to me because you know, then we can't trust the media of we can't trust the media, but we can't like trust even the media that we love to even be there forever, because what if it's just wiped clean from fucking Spotify or Netflix or Max. You know. Well, it's it's interesting because Lucas posits that it is his ability as an artist to be able to do something like this, fuck you, fuck you you absolutely no, sorry, Wow, that was that was a real genuine reaction. Well, and also there's the cultural obligation, because it's not it's it's not like we're talking about removing Police Academy five from the cultural lexicon. I'm sure there's someone out there very matty, oh excuse me, excuse me. Michael Winslow would be mad. He's like, that's the where I did my best sound effect.

21:36 Wait before you go on, just really quick, though, I just to like, because the things that you are talking about right now are like well, he's like, well, one, it's like, well, I have like it's my right to be able to do this. But also but if it's coming from the perspective too, of being like, well, this was what it originally would have been, Like this is my like vision of what it would have been. But like I read something about the whole dumb Greto scene. Right, yes, let me read this to you. It's my sources Wikipedia. Yeah, yeah, sounds like you did a little bit of research. Aspen, you're always clowning on yourself about how you never do research. Sounds like you're about to read a little quote. Okay, that's what mean that you did research? It is on This is humiliating. This is me reading from Wikipedia, which it itself has numerous sources. I will not be going to each individual source, but do that students at home, All, okay, expect your essay by five o'clock at the end of the week. Yes. So in the this just to use an example, in the ninety seven that's the one that alters the scene. So Grito Shirts shoots first, and hans Head is literally digitally pivoted away from that. But then in the two thousand and four DVD release they shoot like almost simultaneously, and

23:08 then it was shortened even more on the twenty eleven Blu ray and then modified even more so. Right, so there's like a lot here. Here's the paragraph. The original version of the great Ive scene is considered iconic, while the alter version is one of the most controversial changes to the film. Fans have coined the phrase Haun shot first to protest to change of course, which which, according to polygon alters hans moral ambiguity as fundamental character. It is pretty fabulous. Lucas has stated that he always intended for Grido to shoot first. In twenty fifteen, a replica of an early script for Star Wars was discovered in the archives of the University of New Brunswick Library. In the script, dated March fifteenth, nineteen seventy six, only Hans shoots. So tell me again, George Lucas, which your original vision for anything is like this is we started to get into some tricky business where we started to get into a little bit of Joean territory of tweeting shit like that wizard's ship in the halls. Let's not compare Lucas to Joe, and Lucas is, at least as far as I know, far better than Joe, and uh ever ever will be well because one is the muck scum devil of death and the other's just a guy. How long, look at me eating Chinese food in them all? Which I respect that picture right, It's oh, I love it.

24:41 George Lucas at one point. And this is why I'm thrilled, because there's a wonderful narrative that's starting to play out with George Lucas over the six films that we will be covering note as much in Clone Wars, and I guess the Clone War gandhy Tartakowsky that we will be covering as well, because Anakin Skywalker is part of it. But an interesting This is probably going to be me looking too much into it, but also that's what I love to do of a filmmaker, of a creative, of a businessman. Yeah by the time that he's more businessman than creative at this at this point, more businessman than man. Yeah, and uh, the Prequels just jumping ahead, But it's an interesting look at a person because I think I finally cracked the Prequels on what his perspective is on that, and I'm excited to get to it. But we're not there yet. Now we're here in special edition territory, right right, Uh? And I like special editions at the time.

26:03 I think they're well. Now that I have access to pristine copies of the originals, I don't find them as offensive, but also you have to go dig for them. But also emp you dig, you can find it pretty darn easy right at this point in time, you know, And for what it's worth, there are some like there are a lot of changes that are lovely, like it real like you know, there's some color grading that's a little bit better. That's like there's like the twin sunset piece that feels like there's the whole scene in the canyon on Tattooy that like the sharpness of it is like kind of heart. It's heightened, so it actually looks very beautifully.

26:47 There are lots of invisible changes and that there are moments where the computer graphics stick out like a sore thumb. Yes, God, yeah again, beautiful moments. I truly do love the BIG's Luke scene. I love that scene, which it actually were in the original. Then there's stuff where I'm like, this looks so bad, like the Stormtroopers on those do bacs, and like on Tattoo You're just like stop it, just stop it. Yeah, and it's or the hon hon uh sorry a jaba. The Hut scene.

27:27 My literally's favorite thing that's ever been put on film anywhere. That scene is not great. It's there's a reason that it was cut from the seventy seven version because it's repetitive and all this stuff's already been said. It takes away from the impact the reveal of the Millennium falcon YEP and the reveal of Java Yeah, which is a wild, big deal that you find out that this this guy, this this uh uh leader, this gangster is actually the big fucking Look. Sorry, okay, I'll stop, i'll start, I'll stop, I'll stop. I'm calming down. I'm calming down. So here's important. Okay, I think it's time to go into the deep dive.

28:11 Okay. I do just want to say really quickly before we do get into this, that the immunity syndrome is an episode that happened. The immunity of syndrome is an episode that happened. And I think there is is what I am enjoying about this episode and the thematic connections here is that I think immunity syndrome is indicative. It's gonna sound like a bit, I assure you it is not a bit. It is indicative of a Star Trek episode. We're going Star Wars. This is what Star Wars is, and this episode of Star Trek is the cruit of the Enterprise, being on the enterprise, encountering something unknown and trying to reckon with what they do, with the responsibility of encountering a brand new life form that is so previously unfathomable to them, and reckoning with the moral quandaries of how do we address this? Do we have the right to extinguish this life? And they have to make some hard calls.

29:12 I have to tell you something, Okay, I actually really liked the this episode. What's kind of I did? I was like, this is like I will get to it obviously, but I was like, it's a solid seven, you know what I mean? Like, I genuinely was like because I was such a grump even though that last one was fun, I don't know something about being back in this environment that felt very like coming home. I was like, this is good. We got some Spock McCoy banter, we got more spuck. Yes, yes, yes, it is a It is a solid episode of Star Trek. Yeah, it's great feeling, the feeling the John Meredith Lucas of it all, because I do feel it's weird reading this book. Oh you are the Voyages my Mark Cushman Season two.

30:02 Yeah, I really am feeling it the bounce between the different showrunners in a way that I just have it before, where the stuff is still there, all the all the classic Star Trek tropes are still there, but there's just we're starting to cover well worn territory already we already alluded to it, but the fact that this is yet another dry run for what is basically Star Trek the motion picture. Yeah, it's not like we haven't had similar episodes before, and there's nothing that's really new. No, there's nothing new that's true except watching Spock and McCoy. Are you over Who's going to die?

30:49 M That's fun? Yeah, it's it's the it's most truly the most sexual tension I've ever seen them have, which is deeply important to me. I would say Priorities number one doesn't have blackface number two. Is there sexual attension between Spot and McCoy. Now, in my research, what is interesting because things get ironed out, things kind of great taken out, and the initial genesis of this episode like the Bible. Yeah, exactly like the Bible. Hold on, let me play my let me play my deep dive whistle.

31:30 That's my deep dive whistle. The original version of this episode. Obviously they're attacking a cell. They're addressing the cell, the big bad, the badding the Enterprise is going up against a giant amiba that is literally sucking the energy out of it. And then the and the script was going to end with the reveal of that basically, all wife functions as antibodies. All life in the Solar System, the galaxy is functioning as antipot is. That's what the function of life is. That's cool. I like that. There's the idea. That's the yeah idea. It is an unsettling idea to me. Yeah, I like that reckoning with Oh, that's our function to fight selves that are invaders. That would be God. That has like a that has a Twilight zone feel to it, which is cool, And that would give the thing some juice, yes, and that would give it a little bit more Star Trek. What do we do with this information? How do we make sense of this? And NBC and I think Bob Justman, associate producer, were like, I guess either NBC or Bob just Someone someone in the room was like, we gotta take that out. No, it's too weird, boring. Could have had something, could have been a contender. Yeah, whatever, and that's yeah. I think that that is a lot more interesting

33:02 philosophical quandary as opposed to how the community syndrome worked, which, as you said, good app straightforward adventure episode where they're investigating the unknown, trying to process something that they've never processed before. I love Detective Spock. I loved him like Detective Batman, but Detective Spock. Imagine if spun like Batman, do you think, Yeah, if Spuck we're around, like we're like we're around, then I mean, well, Batman would exist and he could read the Batman comics and watch the movies. And then what if he were like I'd like to partake in this exercise of dressing up and he dressed up as Batman? Oh my god, wait, I'm sorry, Scott. The Spock's got some singers in this episode two. I also in researching for this episode.

33:59 Listen to our first episode as well. Wow, I did a sizeable amount of research in this episode. I looked at Wikipedia before. Before you think ill of me for doing the barest minimum, just know I give money to Wikipedia. So every time got it. Every time you go on Wikipedia and and they're like, please give us money I'm doing. And they're like, if every game you have us three dollars, I'm giving your share.

34:45 So I just want you to know, thank you. I appreciate it. So I'm making this possible. Great job. How were we? Were we funny? Yes? Yes we were? Are we still funny? Are we still funny? No? I think we lost it? Anyways, So Star Wars, Star Wars, heard of it, heart of it? Okay, suck? Yeah, Yeah. I bought a little book called The Secret History of Star Wars by Michaelkaminsky. Is it little or is it normal sized? It's a big book. It's so dense. Every single page has so much going on, talking about where Lucas is coming from, giving a little bit of a biography on Lucas. I think it is a great snapshot while also being able to go pretty in deep about the influences TLDNR George Lucas heard of him born in Modesto, a little bit of a desolate place, at least according to my friend Aspen Webster. Yeah, the whole part of California, from Stockton down to Bakersfield is no thanks has been. I can't wait for you to move to La Just you can be obnoxious about California references. I'm excited about that I've driven through all of California and that part is boring and has a lot of I had to spend the weekend in Bakersfield, and honestly, it was like spending a week in Ato, Oakland. Nowkland. It's

36:15 cool. Now, It's just a lot of cows and it's there's a lot of poop and a lot of conservatives banned. Uh So Lucas whenever crafting tact queen looking for desolate imagery and basing a lot of this upon Modestine. What is so fascinating? Two things? Uh, well, many things. Lucas Lucas has daddy issues, growing spoiled. That'll go, that'll be important in later episodes spoiler alert. But two things. One, George Lucas loves comic books. Does Lucas love comic books so much that he actually owned a cop bok shop in New York during the nineteen seventies. He thinks, maybe, like Flash Gordon buck Rogers, all of these things is the art that he gravitates to. That's no surprise. What I was surprised about is that he really valued it in high esteem. And also had a financial investment in selling conics. He takes the stuff very seriously. Two, he's a student of anthropology, seriously considers studying anthropology. Whenever he's going to college, obviously goes into filmmaking. It gets hooked up with Francis Ford Coppola, mentor figure of his. And so it's interesting whenever you're not only talking about fathers, but you're also talking about mentors who betray you a little bit. What because Francis

37:47 and George had a falling out, because Francis Ford Coppola has an extremely large ego, But at the same time, George looked up to Francis basically like a Surica father. Whatever. He was coming up not at USC, but after he graduated from USC basically worked on He showed up as part of the Warner Brothers intern program. Whenever Warner Brothers was basically folding. Francis Ford Coppolo was directing a Fred Astaire movie called Finian's Rainbow. George Lucas was hanging out being like, I don't know what to do, and Francis like, what are you doing here? And George Lucas went, I'm supposed to be here and that's what I'm doing. And those two were the youngest people on the set by far. They struck up a friendship. Francis Ford Coppola was making a filmmaking collective at San Francisco. George Lucas went to go do that.

38:44 George Lucas was also a little bit of a wonder kind. I want you to bookmark that. Write that down. We're going to talk about that in episode one. Oh my god, Okay, write it down. Okay, you know, Oh okay, I'm all right. Wonder Knned, not wonder kid, wonder wonder kind, thunder kinned. You know, wonder Kid is just the English translation of wonder Kid. It's actually wonderin anyways, that's me referencing Nate from Ted Lasso. Man, you remember that, anyway? Go on, sorry, boy, do I remember that anyway? George Lucas is involved in the San Francisco the filmmaking scene. We've talked about in previous episodes about George Lucas and his college films, making tone poems, non narrative pieces.

39:53 His student film out of USC is a highly claimed film called THHX one one three for e B. He is able to with the help of Francis get that made into a feature called THHX one one three eight, which goes over like a sack of breaks. Is not people like, this is pretty good, but it's also a classic first film of people being like, there's some potential, but it's not that great. Francis challenges him to make a war movie. He makes freaking American Graffiti. A masterpiece. Don't called masterpiece a war movie for sure, a warm movie a war movie also, although at the same time, and this is critical for the narrative for making Star Wars, George Lucas wants to make Apocalypse Now. Apocalypse Now is George Lucas's film, and he wants it to be kind of a satire on the Vietnam War and so Vietnam obviously being in the zeitgeist, but not only that, very much in the forefront of Lucas's mind going into Star Wars. Obviously, he doesn't make Apocalypse Now. Francis goes to make Apocalypse Now, and after American Graffiti, Lucas is like, you know what, me, wanted to make a movie about issues kind of went over like a sack of bricks.

41:20 American Graffiti did pretty well. I think that's what the people want. They want a warm movie. Can I pause you sorry, that's real quickly you can. Sorry, Sorry, I didn't realize this. So so Apocalypse Now was it was written by Francis Ford Coppola. Yes. Do. When you say that he wanted to make it is like he wanted to make the film or he wanted to make an adaptation of Heart like Heart of Darkness. He did not want to make an adaptation of Heart of Darkness. Francis Ford Coppole's version of Apocalypse Now is completely different. I think the only commonality is that they both talked about the Vietnam War, just in radically different ways. George Lucas's vision of Apocalypse Now is much more cinema verity, documentary approach, satirical.

42:02 I think Doctor Strangelove got it an imagination of all this Okay, okay, thank you, yes, cool. And so Lucas is going in and being like, I think I want to make just like let me bringing up because this is key Okay, I'm sure ready. He wants to make superheroes in space for kids. Yeah, that's it. He did it. He did it. Fuck yeah, and all of this stuff, all the Joseph Campbell stuff, the Vietnam stuff, all all of these things to pull through the text in my research, is Lucas just being like, I need a story so I can blomp these aesthetics onto it. Okay, And by aesthetics, what are you referring to? You referring to the themes or you're referring to the aesthetics of superheroes in space. He wants rocket ships, he wants cool ships, he wants superpowers, he wants nights, all of those cool things that he grew up with, right, like in his comic books.

43:13 Yes, exactly, Okay, so the things that make him feel excited. Yeah, and so that's why he steals the story from a hidden Fortress, because he's like, this is a story. I'll do this, and then it morphs over time into something that is not resembling Hidden Fortress. Right, He steals from a whole bunch of different sources and then synthesize and then synthesizes it into something completely different. Yeah. Yeah, Listen, I just yelled about George Lucas being a jerk face and almost like Joe Anne, He's not, but I don't know if I am am I off and being a little resistant to the word steal. I think people very rightfully are like obviously like was from this and stuff, but like artists are adapting and being influenced all the time. Yes, And if he has synth and if he has synthesized it into something new and different, does that qualify as like I just wonder sometimes we're a little bit too harsh on him before it, you know what, as I think you're correct stealing a much more loaded word as opposed to what my intention was, which is, you know, he's grabbing from a whole bunch of different influences and he's looking for something that feels right so he can exercise the aesthetics that he wants to play with. Is do we think that based on this? And I'm sure there's even more to it. He

44:45 kid, did it? Dude? Did it like this? It's funny too, this idea of you're saying, like, it's not like he's deliberately going for Joseph Campbell hero's journey. But I think, by by the way, that's the whole fucking point of the idea of the hero's journey or any type of thing, of any type of story, is not that anyone sets out to do it. It's just that a lot of stories end up being similar in structure. Didn't at least in my research, and I'm sure that there's some other versions out there, including from Lucas himself. He didn't even encounter Joseph Campbell until the third draft of Star Wars. He happened upon it as opposed to I think what the great man narrative of Lucas is, which is he was influenced by Campbell. All of this just came out all at once.

45:27 Meanwhile, you read even interviews from Lucas around this time and he's like, yeah, it's bouncing it off like Brianda Palmer and Francis Worcoppla, John millius A, Gloria Cassell or Hike folks that he was just hanging around his wife. He was constantly getting feedback. And then the reason Darth Vader looks that way is because he was like, I want a guy in him. Ask It's because Ralph McCrory just drew it that way. Yeah, and then Lucas was like, that's cool. And then the backstory Darth Vader happened the way that it did. I mean that sounds like the most exciting form of storytelling. Yes, to take what are the things that are exciting for you?

46:13 And they it excites you and propels you, and then you work with your friends and other people to create the kind of visuals and story you want. That to me sounds like a dream. I don't fault that by any means. And then, oh no, there's more. Also, I just have this image of George Lucas being like me, a great man. Well we cut to ninety seven. Oh, and the marketing for this is George Lucas finally realizing his vision of how he always wanted Star Wars to be Kill me, and it's it's a portrait of a man in two very different parts of his life, where the seventy seven verse is being like I did Star Wars's Superheroes for kids, Superheroes in Space for kids, Yeah, which is what makes me cry. Yeah. In this the special edition is functioning essentially as marketing for the new movies that he's doing yep, right, capitalizing also on the twenty year nostalgia cycle. It wasn't it too like proof of concept?

47:25 It's like, yeah, we can do this, We're about to do this, and look how cool and interesting and new, and like these special effects are going to be great. This is what you're gonna see when it comes out exactly. Yes, it's Lucas playing in a familiar sandbox, exercising with these toys, because he starts writing episode one in ninety four, actually sitting down to write it in ninety four, Wow, nineteen ninety four, and then he had done the Young Indiana Jones chronicles, had started playing with CG in that regard creating just getting his hands on it and creating a framework for him to be able to use it. And then he uses this on the Special Edition, which is essentially a dry run on all of those things that you said asmen, as well as just testing the waters of what the interest is in Star Wars. Do people still like this? Do people still care? Yeah? Between between between eighty three and ninety seven, Star Wars was kind of in a dead zone, even though we had Ewoks and droids.

48:37 I'm even though we had ewalks and Droids which everybody watched sematically and keeping with the repiloting of our podcast, so too was George Lewis's kind of repiloting what Star Wars is and kind of being like, this is what Star Wars is remember the trilogy, ignore all of the other stuff. We're starting from scratch. I mean, ah, to use myself as an example, my father, who obviously adored Star Wars like he he like the fact that he did not show it to me as a child, I think is actually indicative of it dropping off in popularity. Yeah, and needing to be reignited, because it just like again when it came back like he like he he's one, as I've said before, he's the one that took me to see Phantom Menaci. He was pumped, like it was like something had happened, right, and then I became rabid. I take a freaking marketing push that it's started. They tested the waters with Air to the Empire in ninety one, just kind of as an exercise from lucasfilm, being like, is Star Wars still cool? That movie zips up to number one on the New York Times Bestseller They're like, oh, there's still a market at the lead. They push out new action figures in ninety five ninety six. Those sell like hotcakes.

50:05 Shadows of the Empire happens in ninety six kind of as a dry run for how do we market a Star Wars movie and is there excitement, Shadows of the Empire performs like Gangbusters. It's everything except for the movie and then freaking the special editions come out and it's just more of that stuff. Again, all of this has been building up to episode one. It feeds up into the hype and the fervor that we get into in May of ninety nine. Yeah right, which was me, yeah, losing my mind. Yeah, well that was a true true tale that you wove that I can only assume you also got from a paragraph on Wikipedia. Oh yeah, I can send you the paragraph. I it's it is so hearing those people who are genuinely obviously that's just like, uh, you know, the people that they picked out. But I could imagine that seeing it, like you said, like in on big screens again with new stuff added, it was like an absolute wild experience, Like even if it was sort of intolerable, and again, it wasn't intolerable at the time, right, Well, it's just being intolerable over time because we were like, we can't get the original classic flavor and then not only that, but then uh, the freaking not to just

51:36 comment to you this discussion, but I find it so fascinated because this is where I love to talk about the green Man narratives, especially in juxtapositions with Gene Roddenberry and Lucas as well. It's not like seeing like great man great man narratives. It's not like the same. It's faults being like uh in the fabulous Jesse Gender video about the Decaying Monomath in regards to Star Wars and pulls up a specific example of talking about George Lucas as a fabulous editor, which he is, or rather he was, and also in that the same piece, it kind of eradicates the contribution of the three editors that won Oscars for Star Wars. And I always heard recentering it about the sole author of all of this is George Lucas. It's not the contributions of all these other people helping to synthesize, because Lucas was just like I just want to play.

52:32 That's it. I always heard by the way that it was his ex wife who was like that, Like that became the strong narrative at least, that it was his ex wife as editor of Star Wars. That helps to make it so strong and cohesive. Yeah. Absolutely, But b I guess a lot of people, aren't that That is not the broader narrative. Maybe to most people, it's like this thing is solely a Lucas vehicle, and he been an empire, you know, and so on, where he's like not directing it, it's still the Lucas vehicle. It came all of this the trilogy, which was directed by two different directors as well, Urban Kurshner and Richard mark One. But all of this came fully formed from George Lucas.

53:15 It just like Athena from Zeus's head. And you freaking hear this about the sequel trilogy criticisms being like, I wish that one person was in charge of that all of this. That's not how it works. Yeah, but what if it happened Ryan Johnson. Yeah, he's so good. It's so good. No, but it would be so good because Ryan Johnson recognizes the contributions of everybody, especially his actors and other people that are part of that creative process. But it's neither here nor there. Ye, well, that's boring. I hate it. George Lucas has become the mono myth. He is the myth. As you really watch the five and a half hour the Jesse Gender decame on a myth video because not only just because Jesse Earl is a fabulous YouTuber, but also it's just really well executed piece of criticism.

54:14 Okay, okay, let me get my brain together here for your weekend. Let me just let me just think about this, all right. Maybe I'm going to get away from George Lucas for a touch. This is all obviously about him, but it's all always about him. But I actually do, genuinely think that some of the biggest, biggest additions to this film as a film and the remastered version are bad. Yes, they are bad, and it's not just because people couldn't get their hands on the original. They're bad. The addition of like the changing of the Hon Grido scene is absolutely unnecessary. Uh, it is masturbatory, like ridiculous. Uh. The han the han Java scene is absolutely absurd, no reason for it to be there by any means. It. Maybe it's just because I've seen this seen the original version now so many more times than the special editions, but that han Java scene, it feels like the film just comes to a stop because it's it's literally he is saying literal lines that he had just said to Grido, Yeah, so what are you doing here? There's a reason why editing exists, Like, no, absolutely not, We're done, And like we already mentioned, it just takes away from all the wonder of the reveal of Millennium Falcon

55:44 and then the later reveal of Java and then you see then you've seen George Lucas's kind of new directing style, which is shoving stuff in the frame. Yeah, so then he starts, Yeah, he starts just filling the frame with different creatures, different things happening, which on a certain level I was a little like like they're most islely and a part of me was like I can actually see what you are going for here, which is to say, this is a bustling spaceport. There are lots of people, There are lots of uh like aliens, there are lots of creatures. I don't hate it when I kind of see it from that perspective. I hate the weird, like bad physical comedy of things, the goofy shit that's like inserted in that feels very out of place with like the tone of the thing, just the yeah, the replacement of certain like there replaces like the wolf Man and the canteena scene and that's fine, it's whatever. It just feels a little like that's okay. So well, yeah, there are a whole bunch of those invisible changes who are which are just in there, and you're just like eah.

56:52 But then there's like flying robots inserted and things, which just clearly steals my focus from what I should be, right, it steals your focus. There's a real purpose. I'm like, what, like in the original like filming of it, I can only assume it's like where you want your eye to go right, And so I maybe in the same sentence, are in the same rant. I'm going to say both. I think it's fine, and also it's annoying for me because it's like it does feel as though someone had a really beautiful picture that they drew and you were like, great, I love that it's done, and then they were like, wait a second, I've got a Lisa Frank sticker set and they just put stickers all over the beautiful painting that they just did, and you're like, okay, oh boy, not the Lisa Frank is bad. It's just different, you know what I mean. So, but at the same time, at the same time, what you just put in the chat Mona Lisa Frank Earlier, you put Spice felt adition because I was talking about the Spice Girls. There you go, uh yeah, uh. The other pieces are but then there are elements that I well, there's the one primary. Well, they're like the small changes that I do think are better. I do love the addition of the big scene. It does give like more kind of it gives more like it's nice, It's okay that it's there. I like it. I like

58:24 any kind of thing that bolsters the journey of Luke, that this is a person like other people that were his friends had similar goals and look at what lick where they are and then he fucking dies and it sucks, you know, Nike's a little bit more devastating to see like it. Actually, I wonder if it made me cry a little bit more because I was thinking, here are all these people putting their lives on the line, and just how desperate and terrifying it was, and so few came back. The only ones that come back or Wedge and Luke what sorry if like a counter? If like a counter? Oh oh yeah. Rogue one is the first Star Wars movie that feels like a war movie, though, Oh my god, you're so right. What I like about Rogue one is that it feels like a war movie, you know. I What I really love about it is that like you realize, like everyone's gonna die, because like that's just like what happens, you know, in war. Freaking like that, Darth fingers finally a badass, like finally, like he was never scary before, and they like let him be scary. Also, the only Star Wars movie that I've seen was the theatrical Clone Wars movie, so I've never actually seen Darth Vader before, but like, finally, it's a badass. Totally a bad ass.

59:51 I didn't see him choke anyone in Empire Strikes Back, or he's so scary and he's so scary in a New Hope or freaking cut off his son's hands. Oh my god, he's scary and all of them, Oh my god. Fuck that. Yeah. Anyway, Sorry, just ramble, ramble. But there are some things that I think are wonderful, some things that are unnecessary, you know, almost, but I think the wonderful feels a touch like a broken clock situation being right twice a day, versus it actually like being for any good. So, yeah, that's my take. And then there also exists to go off on a short tangent, the Star Wars Revisited project by I believe his name is Adiwan that exists, which takes the intent of special Edition and super charges it by fixing every continuity error, adding little easter eggs in that don't steal from the focus, but like make the saga coke here, like inserts like battle joys in the junk in like the Jahwa junk thing. Yeah, that's fun and I like that, and it's just like, how and how do we try and make this George Lucas's grander vision, Yeah, without kind of destroying what makes Star Wars special. And that's fun because it's a little fan project. Yeah, and also the cultural

1:01:21 obligation because Star Wars is such a transformative piece of art completely changes the film industry. And it's weird that you can't exist you you can't acquire that version legally. Oh I got so mad again. Fuck that. I just think that's so irresponsible. Would you think that that is bad? No, He's squeezing my heart and squeeze it back. I'm so mad, Like where does it get off? It's well, it's speaking of it's speaking of, Yeah, you are the myth. It's fucking power and control. It is control.

1:02:10 It's control over the process of and the uh what the experience of this thing. And these are the moments that I start to like teeter more into like conversations around death of the author, which which of course is like the idea that once you've put art or work into the world like it kind of now it belongs to the consumers of that I mean not legally, but like in terms of the way that it is interpreted or taken in right that in my best example I always use is besides Harry Potter, U, the best example I always use of this is actually from Fleabag, where in season two, where the hot priest can see where she's breaking the fourth wall and talking to the audience. And I interpret that specifically personally to me as moments of her trying to dissociate and him capturing her and bringing her back. But Phoebe waller Bridge met that very deliberately as a he's closer to God moment, and I am like, thank you for your contribution. That's not how I took that, aspen. I have to stay, uh huh. You told the exact same story in our first episode. Are you joking me? Oh?

1:03:27 No, God, well that was like a billion years ago. Sorry, I can only say aspen, Oh my god, it's like poetry. I'm gonna die. God, I can't believe it. I can't believe. Well, you're welcome, everybody, welcome to our rebrand. Okay, I'm going to engage with it. But yeah, we are back to it. We are back to He doesn't get but like, he just doesn't get to do this, you know, like you don't get to dictate the experience people have of work, especially when it wasn't just you. It's not just your vision.

1:04:12 So it's thirty years later, So let's talk about another twenty years later. Let's talk about another science fiction property that added a whole bunch of computer graphics too. It's original product Star Trek. Yeah. Actually, that's a really good point because I was thinking about that as I was watching. I was like, I'm watching remastered versions of this. I'm curious what the original looks like. But the difference is uh huh. Yeah. You could go buy the original versions, right, you can go buy them on Blu Ray and you can also buy them on like Prime Video, right, you can go buy the original versions because they are treating that as voluntary engagement. It also helps that the Star Trek Special Editions came after George Lucas remastered, sorry, re edited. Remastering is different. He recut the Star Wars trilogy, it added other things. Remastering is a different projects where you're trying to make.

1:05:18 You are trying to enhance what is already there and kind of bring it into your literally fixing film elements. You're fixing things like film scratches or actual maladies that are in the film. Yes, which I guess technically is what they're doing on like the two thousand and four remaster, right and stuff, And not only that for the Star Trek Special Editions. The kind of the dictum from on High, if I'm using the term dictum correctly, is let's try and stick to what was there originally. What's not make anything too fancy.

1:06:01 We're gonna just try and stay true to what was there, right, And so like they pretty much do. Every once in a great well, they'll throw something in that's a little cool easter egg or fix something that is literally a fix that's been in the product for at that point forty plus years, and so they're like in the Naked Time at one point, Scotty's firing a phaser at a wall to try and get into a door. But you don't see the phaser beam. They put that in there. They put k on the blu ray. You can go back to the version that doesn't have the phaser beam, right. You get to decide what your experiences because Megalomaniac didn't rob you of it legally. Yeah, wow, I'm so mad.

1:06:55 Although Jean Rottenberry engages in great manisms as well, especially next Generation, which we'll get to in many years. Kenny, let's stop for a second. I don't give a shit about these old white men. I don't give a shit about them. Like, I'm so glad you created like this great stuff that I'm engaging with, and also other creators too are as well. And it always comes back to the thing where it's like, well it's people. I mean I say this as a huge Star Wars and Star Trek fan, I'm like, this is great. And also you're not fucking gods like and there are plenty of people that were not white men that have given the chance, did create things or could have created things like if it weren't for your status in the world, and that's fine, and I can also love and appreciate the things that were created. But I guess this like idea of pedal pedestaling and lionizing these people or them doing it in their own heads because they get rich and old and lonely. Maybe that is one of the reasons why as opposed to another fabulous podcast that is the similar premise Trekking Through Time and Space, which is Star Trek Versus Doctor Who by a friend of the show, Jacob Paul and Why Trent Boy. What is interesting to be about Star Trek Versus Star Wars is that both these science fiction properties make the claim that these basically sprang fully formed from one head Geene roddenby George Lucas. Meanwhile,

1:08:31 you look at five memos that were sent out from the time and you realize it takes a village on the immunity syndrome. Rodden Berry didn't write it, he didn't direct it. He might have given a couple notes. Dude was busy trying to get other projects going, and he was just like Star Trek is a project at this point in time, and also much like Lucas synthesizing his own life experiences and synthesizing things that he liked at the time to create something. And that's he wanted to just see some aesthetics, right, And that is okay when we get into the problem where you are then reshaping your own narrative as opposed to what is even more beautiful about the creative process of being like it takes a village, especially filmmaking filmmakers, for the amount of time that we as consumers process this stuff. It is not fair the amount of work that goes into it, so much blood sweat and tears, actual blood sweat and tears. Yes, people will literally put their lives on the line, marriages, relationships, and because these people are having to work at least twelve hours a day, five days a week hopefully, if not, like Kate mulgrew talks about when filming Star Trek Boys or she's doing fourteen sixteen

1:10:04 hour days, five days a week for seven years. Oh no thanks, And then to have the gall to be like, yeah, this came fully formed from me, This isn't me. That's what have happened without me. Get out of here, absolutely, get out of here. Have the humility to say I was in the right place at the right time. I had some good ideas, and then be quick to give credit where it's due. It's not an invalidation of your value. Because, make no mistakes, Lucas did did the work. Star Wars is his hands down. Yeah, Star Wars rules. And also he had so much help. That's right. This is an analogy for successful people in the United States. They're like yeah, or people who own homes, like I bought my house. How'd you do it? Oh, my parents gave me some money. That's you, George Lucas. Wow, I didn't think this would make me mad. Because also, make no mistake, I started watching this Star Wars the other night, and I went, oh, gay, I love Star Wars. That I texted your Star Wars is so good. You mean Star Wars episode four a

1:11:34 New Hope, which is yeah, Star's episode for a New Hope. Because you were texted me this re editing. It wasn't it didn't even start aspen Yeah, literally in the theaters. Lucas was already changing this stuff back in ninety seven. Well, you listened to the If you watch the movie in mono versus watching the movie in stereo. An Breu's lines were completely dubbed by a different actress. What yeah, man, I do remember reading something about they like changed it so that she sounded more worried when she said, yeah, it's got too much of his father and him. Yeah yeah, like well right, well from a certain point of view. So okay, I am going to so just because this is this is very essential, and I wonder the work that he says ism clunky cunky, thank you. That was my question, Well is being said thank you so much? Here's my biggest kid. I watched the original special editions. You can't watch the ninety seven special editions, right, That's what I was. That's another thing I was like as I was like, oh, we can't even get our hands on like ninety seven, I guess unless we were to find an old like VHS or DVD, right, like, oh the DVD, no, because probably at that point it was already like that's more for special edition, which is out of here, get out of here. I just don't like this again.

1:13:00 I don't like the idea of just media being constantly changed and the older versions being disappeared. Media is going to constantly change because with every with every release, with every iteration, unfortunately, there are going to be some changes that are introduced into it. Slightly different framings, slightly different audio mixing. It's just going to happen. I want to get you to but we should be able to have access to the different versions. Hopefully you have something that is trying to emulate the original version as it was seen by audiences whenever it made an impact. Right. This reminds me so much of how like bear with me here, like supermarkets or other companies, like, I'm so excited to see how this connects. You know, they just throw out food, right, like perfectly good food, or how other companies. It's like I was reading a thread about things going down to like a penny and employee being like, oh, I could take this in like the you know, I you know, buy them or whatever, and the manager being like, no, these need to be destroyed because under capitalism you destroy these things like they can't be reused, they can't be up cycled, they can't be given away.

1:14:27 Obviously with food and stuff, there's something specific to that, but it's all under this capitalist structure of actual destruction of goods. And this is the same as getting the tax break for like the new like Looney Tunes movie or Batwoman, right, like, these are all that's what it was, right, Yeah, these are backgirl, thank you the Coyote versus the Latest Victim. Right. It seems that studios wanted to purchase that movie, but Warner Brothers just seemed bent. There was videos that main offers and Warner Brothers was just like, nah, they'll destroyed anyways. Destruction. So it's literally destroyed for the tax right off, and which, by the way, that then means we're funding it, so fuck you. But like the like under a late stage capitalistic structure, any kind of capitalistic structure, this is destruction of the goods is actually more profitable than the distribution of them, like and that just feels like what we're talking about here and is it's the destruction of the work of a whole bunch of different people by claiming soul ownership, thereby invalidating their work. Because whenever someone watches the movie, whenever normal folks watching Empire Strikes Back or Return of the Jedi, they'll be like George Lucas directed it so good, I feel like I feel so enraged right now and This is the pivot from George Lucas, the artistic stick filmmaker, the experimental filmmaker who

1:16:02 is making abstract stuff, to the businessman that he became. Oh, this is making me. I've got so much. I was trying to rank Star Wars because you made me, and I was thinking about how I have so much affection for the prequels. And we're going to talk about that on Patreon dot com, slash trek Wars pod. Okay, in the in the pre show chat, you'd sign up five dollars a month. But anyways, George Lucas being a business man is so foul foul. I agree. That's why I said it. That's why I repeated it is foul. It's smelly, it's bad. Okay, I'm gonna calm myself down here. I'm gonna call myself down by finding another similarity between the immunity syndrome and Star Wars, which is at the very beginning of the immunity syndrome, Spock suddenly is like and then he basically is like I wrote down. I wrote down an altered quote, which is it was if millions of Vulcans suddenly cried out in terror were suddenly silenced, trying trying to save a planet from a super from a super weapon. One is a mechanical super weapon. One is an organic super weapon.

1:17:17 And whereas the scrappy underdog rebels that are fighting a mechanical moon, uh, they're kind of being emblematic of as Lucas intended at the Vietcong against the United States. Right. And then it is in Star Trek it is the mechanical that is trying to dominate the organic. Wow. Trying to like so much of Star Trek, a little bit of the manifest destiny of we are frontiersmen. We are trying to conquer the frontier and make it ours. You know, I never you were earlier you were saying there was going to be this interesting idea of like we are anti matter or like antibodies, rather we are antibodies. Oh yes, I wrote down what Kirk said, Yes, an die bodies. Can I see how you wrote it? Can I see the spelling and the spacing, andie you wrote this is a bottle episode.

1:18:25 Great it is, except for it, Yeah, you do see the shuttle the Lazarus, except that the shuttle pre existing asset. Yep, It's true. It was like it had already been like those shots were reused. So but I actually maybe I stopped paying attention or something, or I missed it. But it didn't seem like there was much struggle or it wasn't like as soon as they found out that it was a living creature and would reproduce, they weren't like, what does it mean to destroy this living thing? Like they immediately were just like, we have to destroy this before our reproduces because it's going to literally kill us all, which I respect, I respect.

1:19:06 Listen, it's already killed all shit ton of people in vulcans. But it didn't feel like there was any struggle in the idea of what kind of life is if there is like a more meaningful right to life and living of that, you know then for us even not particularly so much as kind of alluding to what the script originally was about, which is anti bodies and kind of instead of the existential dread of finding out that the purpose of human existence is to function as antibodies for the galaxy, so cool, instead you get the fun idea of, hey, we could be any bodies. Now, look at us breaking through membranes, blowing shit up. Yeah, real heroes.

1:19:59 You know, one point, Kirkslitt says, this is some good Star Trek shit, which that was unnecessarily meta. Yeah, but you know, sometimes you got to break that fourth wall. I think that's really interesting storytelling. I'm so excited for you to watch Star Trek first contact I and I and I just didn't. I liked it. I don't. I don't dislike it. It is definitely one of those where like interesting ideas get thrown out there, but never like deepened. Like but if we were to carry this theme along that you were going with, which is like Star Wars scrappy rebels against great mechanized oppressive power. Like just throwing it out there once again, that the Federation. It's not like it's just some nice little thing. It is a militaristic, hierarchical power and it does decide that it has authority over other beings despite its stated Oh yeah, and I just do want to put it out there. Absolutely, I agree. I hold my hand up there.

1:21:09 This is a form of military propaganda, hands down. By portraying this clearly United States analog, the color schemes are very US. Instead of red, white and blue, it's red, yellow, and blue, but it also then has a moment where that has one of the best exchanges I've seen, and by best, I mean I was deeply confused by it and had to go back through and try to like figure out what it was saying. And then I was like, Joe'll explain what was happening in the scene, which was the exchange between who my sweet partner, which where Spock and McCoy are talking, and he's He's just like, well, how could you, like Billick Spack, how could you feel the death of like so many vulcans?

1:22:03 Four hundred vulcans? Right? And it becomes this conversation that ultimately boils down to human beings are far more concerned with the death of like an individual than like the statistical deaths of many chilling and if perhaps and like he says, like soft for the death of thy neighbor, like would you actually like would you like expect us to do that? It's just like, well, maybe if you actually did feel the pain of so many people dying, there would have been less bloodshed in your history. And I find that to be Once I figured it out what the fuck he was saying, I thought it was badly it was like a weirdly confusingly written scene just throwing that out there too.

1:22:46 As soon as I realized what that exchange was about, I was like, ah ah ah, that could be an interesting theme, right, and but once again there like it doesn't quite like follow through on it this. I like, there isn't a sort of like struggle of well human beings are as again and we're still perpetuating this as militaristic structure of like, well, we do get to decide who, like the Great Many die or something, and we get to do it with impunity despite this being another living creature for instance. I also think Star Trek will be making more allusions to that kind of morality the further that we get into the original series, because rutten Berry just keeps taking more steps backwards and other showrunners come in and being like, what is Star Trek again? Oh? Fun, Yeah, I mean it could have been. It was just a very interesting, thoughtful thing thrown down at the top of an episode, and it's followed through as in Spock making a sacrifice which they are devastated over, but he sees as the needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few. Now he doesn't say that explicitly.

1:23:55 That's clearly what he is going for. So he's fulfilling his own personal belief system. But like in terms of a thematic piece for the entire episode, perhaps not so. Yeah, I don't really find this episode of Star Trek to be that thematically rich and trying to make a big honkin statement so much as Again, so I established at the beginning of this episode that we're recording our repilot. We're doing it, God damn it, the or a special edition as it were. Yes, it is. Immunity syndrome is just indicative of what a Star Trek episode, yeah is Yeah, mechanically right, not a knough it's just not a knock what it is. It's just what it is. And that's all just the powerful image of the big honkin enterprise coming up against a cell. And it's one of those images where I'm just like, Star Trek can do anything. Yeah, I mean it's yeah.

1:24:57 Wait, can I ask you was it ever explained what the uh like zone of darkness was? What did they call it? Zone of darkness? Mm? They never say what it is. They're like, well, it doesn't actually have to do with this like cell. And then they just never explained the zono doc. I don't just stealing energy. I don't know. Maybe that's what it is, is that it's like, yeah, this like cell is it's it's literally absorbing so much energy that it's absorbing the space around it. I guess maybe that's its implication. Whatever, Okay, I don't want anything else from you. I never ask anything of you. I will never ask anything of you after again. Hey, hey, but you know what I will ask of you? Ask when are you teeing me up? Or something? I will ask of you, are you teaing me up? Something?

1:25:46 Fuck? I will ask you what do you ship? M h A long time ago start date? This week, I quoted a boat, I dated a game, but none of them could warp my drive into high berth space. The best of both worlds kept me in the second place. Captain slog on a Holla kron. I wanted a song. I penned a song seventeen more minutes abviise in Super High dev A both the USS Enterprise DT.

1:26:38 Don't you take my e walk lighter and clip it? Don't you take my wretchard buddy and nip it? If you spill the tea I'm gonna sip it my starship It what a good song. Thank you so much, Jolty partner for the I starship a song. What is this part of the show? Best part of the show, best, best, best, We're gonna buy some What is this part of the show. It's the best part of the show. This is the show. The last hour and a half has been leading up to this moment. That's right. It's where we're going to say our favorite starships, which we can in this doesn't necessarily have to be vehicles, though it can be a vehicle if you like. And our best romantic ships. I am pomped, I have I have, I have mine.

1:27:26 I think I definitely have my my ship ships. Oh I got mine too, my romantic ships. But yeah, okay, you start, you start, what's your favorite? Let's start with the ship this time. I talked about this earlier in the episode. I'm back around. Yeah, it is just to prove that I'm a Star Wars man. I'm picking the Outrider, Baby, the Outrider. The Outrider dash rendarship from Shadows of the Empire makes an official appearance in the Star Wars Special Edition. Whenever it's flying over Massie Lee Outrider, which is basically the Kmart version of the Millennium Falcon, the one that your mom says, we have the Millennium Falcon at home, will too is the Outwriter. Now. I got to mention it because for real Star Wars fans, Yeah, dash Rendarship had a sweet toy that I really wanted, and instead my parents just bought me every other toy. Uh where it's it's the cockpit is I mean, it's a classic Millennium Falcon configuration, but instead of the work on the end, it's just smooth saucer. But the toy could function like a gyroscope and you could push the cockpit up so it became completely vertical, and I thought that that was cool. I've got no design history on this. I'm sorry to really disappoint you on that disappointed.

1:28:50 I just think that the Outrider is cool, and that's why I think it's my starship for the week. I you better know stlen that one. No, you obviously a reminder that you get one starship steal a year. Okay, well, good to know you could have stolen. I've stolen yours before. I have to be very deliberate about which ones that I steal because you only get one. You only get one a year. God, yeah, what's gonna be the one that we actually take? But it's just like, no, I'm stealing this. Yes, I have one, Okay, I do have one. It's also from Star Wars. Because we don't have we can do it from we can. It's not like we have the big one from Star Trek. We have the Lazarus. It's fine, and they mayba I had the shuttle craft called the Lazarus. I thought it was the same one, is it not? Uh? Oh, well, I didn't choose it. I truly don't know. Let me check memory alpha. And while checking memory alpha, you go ahead and talk. So I so my favorite one and I had to look up the name of it specifically is the big ass giant ship the Cruiser, the star Cruiser. At the very beginning of the film, of course, we see Leah's diplomatic ship. And I was just thinking about this again, that that iconic first shot of you see

1:30:25 the ship and you're like cool, and then you see so huge and it goes on forever, and of course it's you know, we have like the parodied and like spaceballs and stuff, which is great. But it is like shockingly massive, absolutely wild, and it was called the Tantiv four is the name of the ship. So it's the like biggest ship of course, opening shot and is without all these goddamn news special affrict is beautiful and it has been since the beginning. Uh so, yep, that's it outstanding. So the Tante four, otherwise known as the Rebel Blockade Runner, yep, did you know that it's a consularship? Yep? Let me back up. I actually do genuinely want to back up and do this. Okay, here we go. I got the wrong ship, so that's not the right name for it. I was like looking up specifically what it was. I do.

1:31:29 So the Tanti four is the diplomatic ship. So that's the one. Well, that's the diplomatic ship. Yeah, where is the ambassador? Where where is the ambassador? If this is? And was like, no, no, no, it is, So I don't Actually I guess the other one, like the Imperial star Cruiser, is the one I do want to choose, the one that's chasing the Tanti four. That's what I thought. Yes, I just don't know, so I guess they assume it's just an Imperial Cruiser. I mean it's it's I'm starfairs, right. You can read a Wookipedia entry about how not only was it a star destroyer, it was actually the first star destroyer that's ever built, and Darth Vader took a liking to it. Yeah, and it's actually secretly the most important star destroyer that's ever existed. I think, so, yeah, So I am. Yeah, I'm a little bit torn because now I am thinking Tanta four, because it's obviously I have a lot of faith. I love these two ships. Which will I choose? Yeah, you know what, I love sizable things, but we're gonna get other sizable things. Sorry. It has been as the nineteen ninety eight release of the US Godzilla confirmed size matters. Size matters.

1:32:47 Yeah, you know what. I'm going to go with Imperial Cruiser, chasing chasing the Tanta four, which itself is a beautiful ship. But I'm going to go for big over beauty cool speaking a big over beautiful uh huh, I'm gonna ship it. Yep, Uncle Owen and Aunt Brew all all together, even as charred skeletons, and he has pronounced skelingtons. I don't know. Everyone goes to Han Le and Luke and like, you know, the classic ship, so no one talks about, you know, these two married farmers moisture farming out in the middle of nowhere, making the best of it.

1:33:33 Bruce mak Her a little blue milk Owens being like, I gotta go well, Harvest is when I need you the most. And he's looking out for Luke Skywalker because he doesn't want bad things to happen to him. It's a you know, he loved him and they love each other. Yeah. I it's interesting reading the original literature and then trying to be like, okay, so what is the past that we can assume was originally intended and just talking about how in the original version of Star Wars pre Vader, even being Luke's father, it was just kind of like Owen, Obi Wan and Anakin just knew each other at the time, and we never really we get to twoish scenes three scenes with Alcalo Owen, And it's just I love a good scrappy character actor first off, sure, and uh, I don't know, just would love to dig a little bit more into that in a more meaningful way. Yeah, I agree, I as a kid, I mean, obviously I think there their relationship seems very sweet and loving and supportive, and they've got a good partnership. The as someone who and I'm sure I said this on our first episode makes us who? Also, I was so taken,

1:35:08 of course by Star Wars because I too wanted so badly just to like explore and get away. And I know that Owen just wants to protect Luke so so desperately, but he he's also not letting him explore, and I get that it's dangerous because his only options are basically be a moisture farmer or go to the academy, which is the Empire's academy. So now I'm kind of talking myself into it that maybe he's trying to keep him from like being part of the academy, being part of the empire, isn't it's it would be the academies for the Empire, right, Yeah, Like yeah, that's the only opportunity rights either, like, here's your opportunities. You're a moisture farmer, you're you're you're a rebel and then you're gonna die just like your dad did, or you're part of the empire, which is evil. So okay, I just stalk myself into Owen being a little bit more. Why he is being so restrictive. Okay, I'm done, cool so Owen and Beru. That's my ship, aspen wet your ship. It's uh, it's have I done? Okay? Shit? Have I done this before? Can I do it? I want it? I want to do Spock in McCoy.

1:36:16 I want spock in McCoy. Well, it's okay. We've got bearded Spock regularly McCoy. We've got a Kirksbock. We've got Eline McCoy, We've got McCoy and that one gangster that calls McCoy blue eyes surprisingly looking at it. Yes, hot diggity dog fuck, Yes, that's what I've got. This one just boiling with the sexual attention. The boy howdy are you? Are you correct? Oh my god? Debating which one should get onto the shuttle? Oh my god, the like little snippy like it is to me the perfect setup for a like I mean, they're not true enemies, but like a real enemy still ever sitch, which we know I love you do, but like is to snap be like you know you wish me luck.

1:37:01 And then when he's not doing well, he's like, tell Dr McCoy he should have wished me luck and I'm just like ooh, or that one part where he's just like, don't come for me, and like McCoy is just like, shut up, spuck. We're trying to rescue. Oh my god. Oh I love it. That's all. And I don't think I need to say much more except that they love each other. Outstanding, spok ocoy. You do love to see it, Aspen. And not only do you love to see it, you do love to get to the central conceit of this podcast, The Truk Wars Podcast, the Special Edition the way that we intended it, YEP, by finally answering the question, once for all, which is better this week, Star Trek or Star Wars, as we go back and rank the Immunity Syndrome versus Star Wars Episode for a New Hope otherwise known as the Star Wars Special Edition, on a scale of one to ten, one being the worst, ten being the tip top tippy top best, Aspen, what do you so of the community Syndrome, the immunity Syndrome.

1:37:59 I'm going to give the most solid seven I've ever given anything. It is just a seven. It is a seven, and I'm going to steal a phrase, and I'm going to say that it's a gentleman. Six. Yeah, that's that's probably a little bit makes actually in this case, six might actually what it's fine. Seven was the number that came to my mind, and I was like, I definitely I did. I think I was in the mood for this episode. So that's why it's bumping it up a little bit for me. So it's an extremely solid episode. Yeah, that is it. That's it that brings the collective ranking to uh six point five, But it's still anyone's game. As we rank Star Wars episode four A New Hope otherwise known it's Star Wars Special Edition Acid, what do you rank the special Edition? Baby Baby? You know it's funny. I was looking back at what I okay, that's okay, what I had ranked originally a New Hope, and I had ranked it an eight, which is too low.

1:39:00 That was the very first thing we'd ever ranked, because I did like eight nine to seven, which now I would, yeah, empires like to me, like, now that I know my rankings, it's like a nine point eight to ten, it's a ten, you know what I mean? Yeah, So I would starting from the point of New Hope is like a nine. It's so fucking good. This one should actually be the eight. Now, Paul cobyat this as but yeah, ranking the special editions not necessarily Star Wars No, I know, I know, but I'm saying that like I would actually say not special edition. Original New Hope is like a nine, which I would say this special edition drops it because I don't like those scenes.

1:39:45 They're not great scenes. They stick out like sore thumbed. So I'm gonna say seven point eight. You do hate to see it? Mm hmm. It's me mad, you do hate to see it. I was so happy to get to watch Star Wars again and so mad that it was a special edition. I still dont ranking at nine. Okay, it's great, of course the changes are bad. But at the end of the day, I'm still at the edge of my seat being like this Death Star Trench Run is an impeccable piece of filmmaking, so good, incredible, incredible filmmaking. The filmmaking that is here, it is so masterful, improves that once upon a time George Lucas really did know how to how to make a movie.

1:40:33 At the end of the day, it does take a village he was the ultimate arbiter of all of these things, and all these things just came together as a perfect confluence of evats to make a perfect piece of popcorn entertainment. It made me cry as well. I should maybe I should pop it back up because of the big scene. Sorry popping it back up? Date? All right? That means when that popped up, that means that the Star Wars Special Edition is at eight point five versus the beautity Syndromes paltry, paltry six point five, which means that, Aspen, Yeah, when chill lean close into that microphone, Oh I'm here, I'm here, baby, Star Wars wins the week. I would like to think not George Lucas. He's been thanked enough. Yeah, Aspen, I thank you, and I also thank our listeners to the trek Wars Pod. If you like to leave us some thanks, please hop on over to trek warspod dot com, click on the reviews tab, click on the podcatterer of your choice, and preferably leave us a five star review. It is always appreciated. We survive on word at mouth as well as you know, money as well. Additionally, if you don't want to leave a review. Perhaps you just want to get in

1:42:04 touch with us, why not send us an email? Track Warspod at gmail dot com. Uh, what as it? We've got a couple of comments here from actually the Patreon which you can see over at patreon dot com slash crack Wars Pod and sign up for the five dollars tier where you can listen to early episodes. You can listen to greatly extended versions of episodes. And this comment is in regards to our last episode, an elogy for Ewoks, where we compared a piece of the action versus the last episode of Ewoks Prettie e Wok versus Malani the Warrior. And it is a user feeliat which I believe expounds on the term idiot ball and includes a link to TB Troupes dot org. I guess Robbing Joy partner of agency over ownership at that term.

1:43:02 And thing goes on to explain the home game idiom that we use every single episode. As I know you read this, No, I have actually read this prior to recording this, and I will read this on the air right now. Okay from Jolty partner. I've been quiet for so long, God damn it. Okay, but I need to respectfully disagree with how Ken Dogg I'm assuming that's me has always used the home game idiom To me, the home game quote unquote has always meant you play along with the show. I e. You watched the episodes trek Wards, do it was watching it? Because parenthetical to me and parenthetical not to playing the home game and not watching the episodes feels like parallel opting out parenthetical in terms of language. Ultimate question?

1:43:55 Does can he think of playing the home game as an alternative to playing the quote unquote real game paranthodical watching episodes? Uh, to which I say yes. That's one of the reasons why I like to provide a little bit of synopsis. And I know that we can get into the weeds a little bit, but episodes like this where we're covering Star Wars and broadstro I like to do a little bit of a synopsis. And I assume that most people haven't watched you walks along with this, uh. And so playing the home game means that hopefully you just get to show up and not do the work. Can I tell you a secret? Absolutely? You can. I should I cut this out because it's a secret. Should it be test for you. You just like big old beep over my like minute of speech. I also I also consider playing the home game to be watching along and falling along at home, like watching it with us and so. But you've been saying it the whole time. So I just was like, this is this is what it is. It's like how the word it's like how nonplused people now mee use it to mean it's opposite, and that's just what it is now.

1:45:02 I guess, Well, personally, I'm nonplused by that reaction asmen incredible, so interesting. People that are playing the home game means that they're watching it too. Yeah, so it's like for people who are not playing the home game, you got to give them a synopsis. For people who are not playing the home game. Yeah, though in my mind, as the user of the Idiom Home game, I am saying it and then introducing the synopsis for people that are not watching along with the episodes. So it's okay, that's fine. Look, you know what, we'll leave us up for debate. Ah, do I want to die on this thill? No?

1:45:44 I think there are other things that I would be willing to die on, such as for our lovely patrons that help contribute five dollars a month and help us freaky the lights up on to help us pay for Zencaster, help us paper spreaker, help us paper hosting. Genuinely, genuinely really appreciate your patronage for fine foal suggest Tim Botersosa, Emily Brice, Love Hi Rogers, Kevin Miller, Mark Vibbert, Ryan Hill, Jolty Partner in brand new patron what we got a new patron Aaron Science. Thank you so much for your patron attroney. We love you, We give you keys. This oh so nice.

1:46:28 That is so nice. And again you sign up at patreon dot com slash trek Wars pod for one more juicy content after than anything else before we go. Nope, I love you. Oh look at this Phantom Menace is returning to theaters. Actually saw that. I'm really excited clear off here on May Thirdantom Menace together. Baby, I will, I will, I got to stop calling you baby. That's bad gender politics. And speaking of bad gender politics, someone that practices good gender politics, mister Tolstin alifesto, thank you so much for your theme song. And Jolty Partner, thank you for your theme song and Aspen Thank you so much for your co hosting Dame song Okay, yeah yeah, I love you so much of you. I give you little on your nicely shaved eyebrows. Thank you, and listeners, thank you so much. May the Force be with you and live long and prosper Moopsie my conkey