The Empath vs. Gungan General
We're mad about The Acolyte getting cancelled.
Also, what does it mean to be an empath? Is Obi-Wan Kenobi compassionate? And where are Kenny and Aspen in our love of these fandoms?
All these answers and more!
__________________________________...
We're mad about The Acolyte getting cancelled.
Also, what does it mean to be an empath? Is Obi-Wan Kenobi compassionate? And where are Kenny and Aspen in our love of these fandoms?
All these answers and more!
__________________________________
Get early, extended episodes on our Patreon at https://www.patreon.com/trekwarspod
Watch us!
https://www.youtube.com/@trekwarspod
Theme by Tosin Awofeso
Social Media:
https://www.instagram.com/trekwarspod
https://bsky.app/profile/trekwarspod.bsky.social
Want to ask us questions? Email us at trekwarspod@gmail.com .
And leave us a review! https://bit.ly/leave-a-review-trek-wars
0:27 Welcome to the Track Wars Podcast, the one podcast that dares to answer the most important question in fandom, which is better Star Trek or Star Wars by going through both franchises in chronological release order. I am Kenny Madison, the Star Trek contingent with me as Per always. Is Aspen Webster, Star Wars fan. Here, nice Star Wars fan, good Star Wars fan, Lovely Star Wars fans person. I'm a nice person. You are a nice person, someone that has a great deal of empathy for others, including a general gun Gan do attitude. That forced segue means that we can only be covering two episodes. That's right, Star Trek, the original series, the m Path versus Star Wars, the Clone Wars Season one, the Gungan General, and boy, oh boy, Ashton. I think this is the truest thing that I've ever said for any podcast episode. These are two pieces of episodes.
1:25 Oh oh no, okay, I mean, oh. No, that's not That's not a statement of quality. We've got two episodes. It is we have to make no mistake. The true thing that you and I can both agree on it is that we are about to talk about two episodes, two long running science fiction franchises. Well we could, we could counter that maybe actually Star Wars is more of a space opera fantasy. Star Trek is a space opera science fiction. Oh yeah, I guess Star Wars is. Well, what I'm saying is, Kenny, is is there really any ultimate truth? Is there really anything that we couldn't dissect until we get bored, uh and or angry? I disagree. There is an ultimate truth in the sense that our listeners are the greatest listeners on the planet.
2:10 That's true. I shall not dissect. You are indeed truly beautiful. I gave you. And before we proceed on to our analyzes of both of these episodes, we have some housekeeping to take care of. Okay, if you would like to come over and wash my dishes. No, that's not not the housekeeping that we're talking about. Instead, we're talking about what our Patreon Patreon dot com slash track Wars point, where we put up early versions of our episodes, extended versions of our episodes, like last week's episode A Week of an Eye versus Doukud captured, where on our Patreon you can listen to a forty five minute extended version of that episode. What if we even talk well, because we always have our pre show chat.
2:55 And then I also caught out an additional five or ten minutes from the main episode as well. Just for what. Yeah, you know, you're you're a beautiful editor. You're you're beautiful man. Just for flow, Just for flow, anyways, just for flow. Arizona Mark talks about how we talked about our experiences by doing forty eight hours of improv in a row. We did forty eight hours of improv. That's what we all away and you can listen to that Patreon dot com slash Struck Wars Pod Premierzona Mark, which I could have experienced your forty eight hour improv in person. I gave Sylvia a kiss like you asked. Sylvia is his dong Aspen. I also tried to watch Walker for one season, but couldn't even make it through the full first season.
3:38 So much, Arizona Mark kind a kind gentleman. Extremely kind gentleman, A sweet. Star Wars fan, a nice Star Wars fan, a. Sweet Star Wars fan, a nice Star Wars fan. Speaking of sweet and nice Star Wars fan, Austin Aaron writes into our email address truck Warsepod at gmail dot com Hi, Captain Kenny and Admiral Aspen. It's a literally gonna I'm gonna have to talk about that to my therapist anytime you even obliquely mentioned toxic fandom. I want to have a huge conversation about the cycle of enjoyment, disillusionment, refreshment and fandom and why some entitled fans get stuck in disillusionment. But today I was just wondering which phase you each currently are in that cycle regards these two franchises. Wow wow?
4:27 And what was the series movie that moved you into your current phase? Wow? Personally, the Clone Wars was a refreshing influence from my Star Wars fandom. The Ahsoka series too disagree a not. Personal toll, Kenney, our fans are perfect and also Austin Aaron is wrong. A non irradiated seaman. Austin Aaron PS. So proud of you both for your forty eight marathon run. I really wish I could have been there in personally and Kis Kiss Kiss, So the question is, uh, where are we in concurrently in our fandoms for these franchises?
5:07 I will tell you, Okay, it is funny. I did I I uh, because I think we had I had planned to talk about the Acolyte getting canceled. Yeah, I think this is a perfect seguay for talking about the Acolyte, because my my, I'm extremely disillusioned with the state of where Star Wars is going, and I have nothing to look forward to except for and or season two, because I know what to expect from Star Wars this point. It's funny, I am not in disillusionment space with Star Wars.
5:48 You could just say that, but a little bit more dead, that would be great Star Wars. I think it helps. I think it helps that what I have looked forward to six more seasons of Clone Wars and all of these pieces to frankly rewatch and love like I was as we were right before I watched the episode for this week, I was looking through the rest of the episodes of the season and I just kept going, Oh, my god, that's right. That's a banger. This is a banker, this is a banger. And I'm pretty sure that across the board, people typically maybe like rank Season one as like the lowest, like just in terms of the Clone Wars seasons, and that's probably true. But in the same way that you're like, well, I'm reading all these great books, and like that one just happens to be my least favorite because I was, like, it's full of extraordinarily good episodes, Like I.
6:39 Kind of say, I got to talk about I'm reading this terrible Star Trek book. Star Trek the Next Generation, indistinguishable from Magic and the Star Trek Verse post Nemesis is exquisite. Yeah, it is so good, except for this one trash novel, which is just like everything that is the worst instincts from quite frankly Star Wars stuff where it's just like this thing that you recognize, blam, this thing you recognize, blam. Are you wondering how these things got there? Don't worry about it. We don't need to do the emotional neckwork because you just like these things. It's really frustrating. It's so dead on the page.
7:19 Yeah, I anyways, Yeah, I mean that's I do have a slight fear that that is the way Star Trek will start to go disagreement. I don't think so. I know, I think the canceling of Lower Decks was a problem. Prodigy is a problem. Those are like I would understand, except I think five years for lower Decks is probably a good run. I could feel in season four it's just like I feel like it's starting to get a little bit thin. Even though, make no mistake, I still add to it. And if I'm looking for some Star Trek in a pinch, I'll go to it because it's it's exquisite. And also the two shows that we have on deck I'm there excited for the state of Star Trek.
8:01 Is the Starfleet Academy show, Sure, which is not just hopefully if it's done right, It's not just another we're just gallivanting on a ship again, because we've done that so many times. No, this is seems to be a different perspective. Yeah, I'm just telling you, I'm afraid Sure, because I think it almost has what we can get into it. I yeah, Star Wars. The Star Wars is not to interrupt you, what's the other thing that's coming on? I interrupted you too. The Starfleet Academy thing, the Section thirty one movie, which I think could go. I'm very wary of it because whenever folks are playing in the section one Section thirty one, Bailey Wick, that is not the writers of Deep Space nine or to a degree, Enterprise, They're like okay, cool. We think this Star Trek stuff is corny and hack section thirty one. Section thirty one's badass because that's a moral gray and we know how to write that set and they just make it action and stuff.
9:09 That's like sort of like CIA esque thing that happened in DS nine. It's black Ops, Black Ops, right right, so so secret that the President of the Federation doesn't even that's about it. I remember that now. Yeah, those folks were talking about things like that. That was brought about because they wanted to talk about what it takes to even though you have this completely benevolent ideal empire. They're talking about it with Federation and Starfleet being analogous to America, trying to interrogate the notion of no matter how good your ideals are, how are you perpetuating it? God fucking love D nine versus like a Perfect Discovery where they're like, Section thirty one is the Secret Bad.
9:57 Days, the Secrets Bad Days. That's not that's not good for strong enough, But the trailer for it did kind of make it look like Star Trek Guardians the Galaxy, which, to be fair, is Star Trek Prodigy. I'll give it the benefit of the Doubt and then also the weird tawny newsome justin Simeon show. That's right, that's the one that actually excites the ship. I mean we've talked because I'm like, this sounds so out of left field, and I'm like, right, cool, great, because I don't need another TV show like old Old Fuddy Duddy. Star Trek fans are like Star Trek Legacy, do that show, which is just like more of the same, more of the same characters. And but that's not that's not good for your general audiences who they want to experience their thing for the first time.
10:52 Oh, I mean, that's an interesting notion. I don't I don't think that they know that that's what they want. Of course, I just have to look at Dead Poa and Wolverine, which made so much money, but also that movie is not That movie only succeeds because of its cameos and its references to Lore, not fundamentally as a good story. So the Star Wars piece, I like this discussion. This discussion here, uh is you know there's two kind of this is so reductive. I feel like part of my like my fear with Star Trek right has to do with this first element, which is what Disney and Lucasfilm is deciding is worth their money to put out there.
11:45 And my I guess my fear might bringing that up of like, well, I'd have this fear around Star Trek, which is that like when you do start to get into what feels like a redund dent sort of treading cycle of like, well, we know that Deadpole versus Wolverine will make money because of these cameos and this sort of like tongue in cheek ask like that's I see that. I recognize that. I recognize that as opposed to like I'm leaning into the emotionality of a new type of story whatever that looks like that is. I think that there is an element there of the like we just keep doing what works, what works. When it comes to the Acolyte, I do not know. I know that every episode it costs a lot of money to make.
12:32 Let me, we're talking about the Acolyte getting canceled. Let me let me start. Let me start place from a very neutral perspective, and then let me actually like really lose my mind neutral perspective. Star Wars is a franchise. Star Wars is a fucking franchise. I don't know what they're toy I don't know what their toy selling looks like. I don't know if they didn't even make any Acolyte toys because they have been neutral. Sorry, sorry, I don't It costs a lot of money to make each episode, and I do know, I know that viewership, Like I'm actually not sure about their viewership versus other shows. I neutral have a suspicion that it actually isn't very low comparatively.
13:17 But you know, one of the things I'd say is like, Okay, well, then why don't we have a new vision for types of budgets that you put out for these shows? Like there are different types of stories you can make that don't cost twenty million an episode, Almost. Like there should be transparency. We exactly have the money that their shareholders and stockholders are giving them, right as opposed to what I'm sure they're not doing, which is spending it, you know, on themselves. Because Disney is notoriously a great company. To work, You're bringing up another actually really interesting conversations. I don't know. I don't know this industry, but if it's anything like any other type of corporate industry of yeah, being subject to your shareholder expectation as opposed to like the quality of content or material or widgets being put out there, the expectation the perception of a thing. Stocks are complicated, No, fuck that, they're not whatever. It's mostly about perceptions and.
14:19 It's all snake oil. Yes, it's just that it's almost entirely snake oil salesman shit. So like, I don't know, I don't think it is as simple as you know, like money and money out I think there are like perception elements within this. This is where I'm going to stop it. Neutrality, thank you, please. Go on now. I was about to be like, uh, screw neutral because this is emotional and like it's freaking yet again whenever there's an economic downturn, rather a perceived economic downturn, because it just apparently everyone just decided that the economy was going to downturn a little bit. And who gets punished not all of the folks that look like me, right.
15:02 To be sure, and so that everybody knows because this is typically an audio medium. Although I can subscribe to YouTube dot com slash Act, Trek Horsepod, but. YouTube pers a sweet little bearded white boy, hey know, yeah, and yes, and it is people of color and gender expansive people and women and lonstly women and women of color and queer people fucking always. So this is where we'll get really mad. This is the Acolyte. Not a perfect show, No, you know, it's not a perfect show. Hilariously, I ended up becoming deeply invested in it because it was a show that felt so different and fresh and interesting and things were happening. But I was like, I don't ever really get to see this type of wildness in a Star Wars thing.
15:55 So far. The last time I felt this is kind of like weird frankly sexual tension and pieces like that was a Han and Leah and I have yet to feel it sense, you know, like those types of elements are interesting because they are human and dynamic. It is a show that head writer is a queer woman, It was headed by a non binary black actor, and it had it has a cast of it's like a coven of people of color, of witches with and its queerness everywhere. They may just seen so all of these different elements. An actor who is South Korean just like absolutely tremendous, right, It's a very it's a different type of story and a different type of context. There's plenty you could talk about, but I'm.
16:41 Just so few member barriers as well, so. Few member barries. And also so again, I don't want my emotionality to get in the way of what I'm trying to say here, because I think there's so many There's so many different elements though of like why I'm so mad about this one is the blatant racism of the thing. And this is not just an alcolyte piece a Mandelistenberg started getting horrific comments and racist comments before the show even came out, like absolutely terri like just like terrorized Moses Ingram from that's her last name from uh Obi Wan from the Kenobi show, Moses. I'm trying to cabi someone else, but that you know, the woman who played the badde in Kenoby. No. I only watched the first three episodes.
17:21 Us, so she was tremendous in that show. Just really quick, I want to make sure, yeah it is Moses Ingram new quisitor Riva. Absolutely just like barrage of racist and sexist comments because she's a black woman. Of course, all the way back to John Boyega before the Force Awakens even came out this like anger that he could even like because I think he was like holding a lightsaber, right, just like, yeah, we're talking about we're talking about just like pure unfiltered racism, sexism, uh, queer phobia, transphobia, any kind of thing. That is what we are talking about here, just to like lay the groundwork and then yeah, you know, that's a core of it, and then there's the other elements of what it takes, like the space that stories get to explore and expand and be the kind of story that they can be. This is a common thing I thread that we're hearing. I think people are really starting to talk about a lot now, which is like I thinking about the Clone Wars thing, It's like, well, this first season, even though I'm like actually think it rocks.
18:29 At the time, it was like you. Know what, oh one, Like, oh my gosh, it was a complete affront to everything Star Wars. And then, like anything, you give it time, suddenly people are nostalgic for it, and then you can see the value of it detached to what your expectations are. Yes, and also just it's quality itself. It had the ability to breathe a character like Ahsoka gets to grow as a literal character like that we get to start a certain way. The whole thrust of Western storytelling is that your characters change, so that means they have to start here, you know, and then they get to grow and become something. If they were static the whole time, what would they be, So they can't just get to start at like yeah, you know, like you need to give them time. You need to give your storytime, your ideas time. And perhaps the cost structure of the thing is actually a problem here and it's been. It started when we started doing like Netflix, like take it all in at once and have eight episode shows and it's a mini series and that's all we get these days.
19:36 Like maybe that's part of it, But I think too, like when you have this type of structure, so there is both the structural problems of the thing that they can come out and they could be like, well, it doesn't make sense for us like to throw this kind of money at a thing that's like actually not that very right, and it's like, well why. And this goes to the Rolling Stone article is written about it, which is talking about how Star Wars fans, the worship of Star Wars fancy to fucking get over the themselves and die already. It doesn't say that, but that was what I took from it. Uh, go fuck yourselves and throw yourselves off a cliff. That's what I'm saying, you absolute knobs. But but but yeah, but like why would any creator who is in a fucking Zack Snyder white boy want to even like commit any time? Like why And they're they're they're just going to be tokenized and then thrown out, like that's what's going to happen. And then you're like it's more than just like Okay, well yeah your show didn't go to second season. It's like, well then you also your actors weathered terrorism like against them. Your writing is like you yourself are like you have to like I can't even imagine like the emotional strain of the thing, right like and then yeah, and now you're fucked and now you have to like go, you know, now go find another job too, And like why would any reader who isn't just a white guy want to even go near Star Wars?
21:04 And then because of. That, you're gonna get boring ass stories banned. You are going to keep getting guys in helmets. Star Wars's helmets. Folks with deep fake faces of things that you love. Goddamn yeah, because of this loud faction of fans who need it to be exactly the same as whenever it grew up, as opposed to and I think the problem with Star Wars as supposed to wear his Star Trek is now they're not telling stories for story's sakes now, uh huh Star Trek lower decks. I think people really like now. But whenever it came out, every Star Trek fan was like, including myself, no, that's not Star Trek wild really but then yeah, no, it's not Star Trek, but then what Star Trek. Yeah, Luckily. I think this is also indicative of the medium of how Star Wars existed, or at least existed within the cultural mind for so long.
22:14 They are these movies. There are these three movies, and that's it for at least for these all suburban white kids that are growing up and watching the original trilogy over and over and over and over and over again, so that gets locked into the mindset and it can't be anything else. Star Trek has the benefit of being episodic by its nature. Even the original series, every single episode could have a completely different tone. And while Next Generation definitely had its detractors whenever it came out, because they're like Kirk Spock and McCoy, No, it's not Star Trek Picard, he's bald. Why Luckily, the Internet did not exist in the way that it does now, and by the virtue of how the thing is delay, Star Trek gets the benefit of being whatever it wants to be.
23:04 So whenever they announced this new Justin Sibby and Tawny Newsome show, which is a multi cam sitcom or no, maybe not a multiicam sitcom, but it's they've said it's a sitcom that exists canonically within the world of Star Trek, I'm like, yeah, let's do it. Let's go for it. If it fails, at least I know that they are trying. Yeah, because there's no way that a paramount would just be like, let's put this in development, because that is weird as hell to do with like one of your biggest franchises. Except and Disney is like stupid at the Mandalorian on the big screen.
23:44 Well, I mean, yeah, yeah, yeah, sorry, I don't mean Disney's doing thatx Disney, but never but they are being like, yeah, let's do this different story with like creators of color and stuff. And then they're just like fuck you. Yeah, because I mean, we are paying attention to within the season three meta narrative of Star Trek. Behind the scenes, they want the optics of being progressive without actually being like threatening anyone in the South, as they explicitly state within These are the Voyages season three by Mark Cushman and Susan Osborne. I yeah, I mean I guess that's interesting. Yeah. Star Wars can slightly get the optics of being like, oh sure, well, we like gave you something, and in ten.
24:34 Years people will be nostalgic for acolite, And in ten years people will be nostalgic book a Bubba fet and all of these other items of Star Wars. And then and we won't realize how good we had it because it would have gotten flattened out even more. I have to how are you doing asthmen? I feel so upset, Like I genuinely feel so upset. There's there is a conversation here around like should something keep going? Maybe it should stop? You know, Like like I said, I I do have stuff to look forward to in Star Wars. I have all of the Clone Wars, I have rebels, I have. Film, I have a radical as hell show that somehow managed to exist. But I mean it probably helps that the creator is a white dude. The star of it is a white passing guy.
25:27 I mean, yes, I do. I do want to call out that, Like Dolna is a his strong Mexican accent and that is a big deal, and like it's noticeable, like I know people who are like talking about how their parents watched, Like that is the thing about Rogue One, right that like I will always give it, which is like people walked in and were like, that's my accent, you know, but but but but you know, yeah, it's made by like what a British white guy. It gets to fly under the radar too. It's an extraordinary show. You know. What's so funny though about and Or I don't think it was you why said this, because I don't think you would have said. Those people are like, well maybe you did. I don't know. So one was just like, well, you know, it just like doesn't like look like Star Wars, and I'm like, but it does though, it does though, Like that's what's so funny to me is I'm like, I am, I love Star Wars. That show looks like Star.
26:20 Wars, like that person's expectations of Star Wars, like so much of fandom is so narrow. It's wild to me. Like I'm like, I don't. But that's the question I want to ask people. I want to be like, what do you what do you think it is? Then, like do you think it's like a sort of cartoonish aspect or like a kind of a bigger, broader, like bigger than life kind of thing. I don't think of it that way that that show captures the feeling of Star Wars to me perfectly, Like it just does. I remember speaking of the marathon years ago at like im pro marathon we both did years ago, at like four in the morning, I did a Star Wars show.
27:00 It was like the most grounded like star It was just like a Star Wars, a straight Star Wars narrative for forty five minutes, and it was like it worked right, Like there were lightsabers and stuff, but it would have it's a kind of story you would have seen an and or or the Acolyte or something, you know what I mean, Like no noticeable like main characters just like the vibe of Star Wars, and like I remember thinking like obviously everybody was a group of extraordinary people, right, and like it just works so well. And I was just like, because we know what Star Wars feels like. We know it's settings, we know it's it's sensibilities, Like I don't understand what you mean, doesn't look like Star Wars and so and I don't think people do either.
27:46 And you do know what some people think, Star Wars doesn't look like to them, and it doesn't look like black people, you know what I mean? Like for some people, Star Wars is solely that one scene in Rogue one where Darth Vader lights up his lightsaber, or that one scene of The Mandalorian where Luke Skywalker fires up as lightsaber. I just you know, I'm not going to be able to fight lucasfilm. I'm not gonna be able to or fight Disney, you know what I mean on this, Like there's nothing to be said, like there is to them, like this is how this is, This is capitalism, This is the neoliberal to fascism structure. That is the wild like the wild one to one of what Star Wars is showing. And then what's happening in the real world, which is like, that's this is why I don't actually think it has to do with cost. I think it really does have to do with cawling to like what you like. From a capitalistic perspective, I'll tell you who wins, and it's not marginalized people, you know, so it's short term gains, it's not long term investment in things.
29:02 Well happened. What would have happened if they allowed the acolyte to cook and then the filmmakers were allowed to respond to good faith criticisms yeah, within the text right, and then be able to build on their strengths, and perhaps those issues wouldn't have gone away, but there's no time. Well. What actually makes me think of too, is like it's occurring to me that I was so intense about the accolyte and defending it. It's almost like I was like, sorry, I don't have space to actually give good faith criticism because the bad faith criticism is so much louder. Can it becomes a dog wessel whenever You're just like, the acolyte has issues.
29:44 Right, well, and I'm like yeah, because I'm like, oh boy, Like, even if you do have good criticism. It truly is good criticism, Like those voices are so loud like and there and it is bad faith like and so it's like imagine, yeah, a space where you would be like, here's my very good criticism for this, Like here's some ways that we could like, yeah, maybe it did chase a mystery at the expense of like true emotionality. Like those kinds of things are very real, So you get the space to create an even better story later, like you exactly like you're saying, But like I, as a good faith critic, couldn't even feel like I could engage in that because I was just like, no, my actual good faith criticism is going to be drowned out by everything else.
30:28 While as well intentioned as Dave Filoni is, colony got time to cook to find clone wars, he. Really did get time to cook. And that's the other thing when we talk about, like when we talk about things like like affirmative action or being mindful of like who we're putting into positions of power, Like, the difference is often that white guys just got time to cook, Like they got they get the time to make mistakes and fuck up and get better and better and better and like women, people of color, marginalized people don't. It's like you have to comment and be fucking perfect immediately. And also you didn't get all that time to like cook and get better at your saying. You immediately had to be good no matter what, and like, oh, you didn't do it perfectly, and you know, it's it's actually maddening, Like it makes me feel insane, like absolutely insane. Yeah, I feel so upset, and I you know, I don't know.
31:23 I also want to just throw some conspiracy theories here. I think they're trying to make everybody look bad. They started doing that thing where lejiuon Jai Master Soul, they were like, oh, well, our first choice was Keanu Reeves before him, Like they started being like, look like it's almost like they're trying to like undermine everybody, Like that was just really said. They're like, well he wasn't even like our first choice, and I'm just like, fuck you, what are you trying to do right now? Like this absolutely phenomenal powerhouse of an actor christ because I think he expressed frustration or sadness around it, and then they came out. With that yeah, like you know, absolute nightmares every single person works so hard on.
32:06 These things, right right, Absolutely. At least below the line, and also actors showing up and that can be extremely difficult, writers, directors, producers, and there's like a handful of people who have the most power don't necessarily do the lion's share or have the lion's share of anxiety. And even then, I'm I don't know, just speaking of my experience as being a former under the line person. Man, this stuff is harder than we will ever imagine, right right, So you're feeling pretty nihilistic about Star Wars franchise.
32:46 No, I'm not, actually like that's the thing I don't well franchise. Yeah, I'm the forward direction because outside I'm interested in Skeleton Crew because I watched the trailer of that and I'm like, this feels really different. My initial instinct is be like, that's not Star Wars. And because of that, I'm like, interesting is what is? What the fuck is star Wars? The is it? It should be to be anything? Also, copyright law is bullshit. Yeah, I have so much Star Wars. Like I have it. It's mine, you know, I have so much of what I absolutely adore beyond reason. Like some things I don't like as much some thing as I do. Saying for Star Trek I wonder if I mean Star Trek is, as you pointed out, is kind of showing a different path here, but like, yeah, I mean the like Jesse Earle talks about, like in that like declining the metamath of Star Wars kind of thing, like it is by nature this like it's like we it itself represents this sort of like that neoliberalism and then like a descent into fascism, like it like the kind of that process itself and of like the making of the thing. So my reaction is to be like I wish you'd just stop. Yeah, just like don't let it. Just like what you are
34:17 doing to it is like it feels deeply exploited, exploitive at this point, right, You're you're exploiting marginalized creators at this point, and I'm fucking down with you. Like that's the vibe that I'm having. So so, but Star Wars means everything to me. It's like it means everything to me. I'm not disillusioned with Star Wars, Yeah, you. Know, so disillusioned with the process of creation in twenty twenty four. Yes, the fact that you have, you have to fit within the bumpers or else. Yes, Yeah, I'm not a f fan of actors and creators getting horrifying messages wishing them their death, like let.
35:11 Me just tell yeah, yeah. Oh that's that's what I made Listenberg and Moses Gott like telling them they should die. Like so, yeah, I think I think we're talking about a lot of things sort of overlapping on each other. Yeah, the state of creation in twenty twenty four, the sort of like the culture online culture, a lot of like what you're hearing about. When people start to talk about, like the radicalization especially of like young white men in spaces and as people that do not look like you gain power, you are fed the narrative that they're not enough resources and these things are being taken from you, and this is one of the responses. It's always been the response, and now we just have louder spaces for it. Yeah. I think it overlaps strongly into everything you see in political like politics.
36:11 Every time someone's like we're such a divided nation, I'm like, shut the fuck up. We're talking about more than being a divided nation. Like, we're talking about a lots of things that are going on that are mostly to do with racism and sexism and misogyny. So and what we have constructed, what powerful people have constructed in terms of a narrative around haves and haves, not classism too, obviously like this are all interlapping, under overlapping with one another, interconnected. So anyway, Oh, so fucking bored. Of it all? Uh? You love you? Do you need to take a break? None, I'm just gonna to drink my fizzy water. Okay, Well, why do you drink your fizzy water? Why didn't I go ahead and start the work of talking about this week's episodes, The Mpath versus the Gunk in general. I'll do my synopsis here, Yeah, dude, starting with The Mpath first air December sixth, nineteen sixty eight, writer Joyce Muscat director John Erman. From the TV Highlights printed in the December sixth, nineteen sixty eight edition of The Saint Petersburg Times, serving Saint Petersburg and Tampa Bay, Florida.
37:29 Two hours away from where I grew up. This critic wrote, Star Trek is a bit rough to watch tonight unless you have a statistic streak. Yeah, it's about a girl who has the unusually the unusual ability to absorb the pain of others, a kind of physical esp She is being used experimentally by two aliens, and her captors must have laboratory animals to torture so that they can discover her secrets. The animals in this case turn out to be Kirk, Spock, and McCoy and I will say. According to the Nielsen ratings, this was the second highest rated third season episode, following Spock's Brain the season premiere, and placed first for the night in its just ratings period of it's timeslot.
38:16 Did you know this is one of the episodes, along with Plato Step Children, that they just like wouldn't show on the BBC because it was so violent? I did after reading this, because yeah, going into this episode, much like Wink of an Eye, I was like, this is gonna be another one of those sleepy episodes. It's unlike Lada. We'll talk about it, obviously, but I found Plato Step Children, as I noted, to be unnecessarily violent or like not necessarily violent. Obviously. It just felt awful to watch. Sure, actually that long this time around, I was like, this is this at least feels like there is an intention toward it. It feels very cruel, but not cruel for the sake of cruelty, like cruel in terms of how actors are like how these characters are acting. So it felt slightly different for me. Sure it was still hard to watch.
39:11 You know what wasn't hard to watch? Actually it was for me the gun in general. Really it was hard for you to watch. Oh my god, I was like, I'm having a great time. Someone enjoyed the Gun in general. It man, you just don't like jar Jar Probably you just don't like jar Jar Man, who this time is voiced. By philm I will say that bomb Bat Jedi was a better episode than this one. You think, so, oh. Yeah, there's a lot of shenanigans in this episode. Jedi had tonal whiplash. But we'll get into it. It worked for me. Well, it's fine. You don't like him, it's fine, it's fine. It's fine, it's fine, it's fine. We'll talk about this later.
39:52 It's fine. I was growing up, but like, I can't even remember what the show is that we're watching. But in the show, where did were it was? When I was growing up, Like it was like some some sitcom or. Something, and well, where did you Where was this Florida to the nice beaches of Florida. Must be nice that you get to wear Mickey Mouse. Here's every single place that is actually legally required. You rich fascist? Yeah, me from small town central Florida, I am so they general. From this guy that grew up in northeast Oklahoma. All of Florida is Miami to me. Oh man, did you know?
40:37 I didn't go to Miami at all until I was like nineteen or twenty years old. And it's because I like, it was because I needed a It's the whole thing. I was flying, the whole thing. I was flying to Santiago, Chile. Santiago, Chile because that's where I started abroad. And I went back to Florida first to see my mom and it was so much more, like it was so much less expensive to fly from Miami. And I was like, I've never been in Miami, and she was like, let's go to Miami. And it took us five hours to drive there, because that's how far away Miami was from from where I grew up. She was from, She's from she was from South Florida. So she was like, i'aat pastries and let's have some Cuban sandwiches. And I was like, I can't, I'm a vegetarian. She was like, so anyway, what was he saying? January ninth, two thousand and nine is when it was released. It was directed by Justin Ridge and written by Julie Siege, with of course Henry Gilroy as series writer, in Scott Murphy a supervising writer, and Luca is always there to give his thoughts randomly. What if what if we tied them together?
41:54 They could be tied together? What if they were just tied together? They could be tied together? Written by TV archaeologist Oh we wanted Anakin are now hostages along with u q at Hondo and Augustan hold on Florum. We expected that. Right, although I was like, didn't you switch out? It's fine, they're now hostages. Delegate jar Jar Binks and Senator Carus arrived with the ransom and a battalion of troopers, only to find there is treason within the pirate ranks. It's trees and then it's treason. Then yeah, yeah, there's another pirate who's just like we are going to get We're gonna get dish splode We're gonna make.
42:36 Damn pirate. That sounds like Jason state them. Yay, there's this how did this get made? But sorry, keep getting distracted. I was very upset for thirty minutes and now I'm like a little loopy. Sure there's this how did this get made? But I can't remember who was the guest, But it was just like it was like the movie they were watching. Jason Stathum is in it trying to sound like he's like American, but he still keeps sounding British. And so the whole bit is that it's Jason Statham Angelina, and it will just be like, that's right, it's me Jason Statham Angelino taking the four O five one O one on tears like oh fullip and houses over and that would would. Villasion so good? Glass had box.
43:18 Anyway, is this Jason Statham birt Ah? So he yeah. Anyway, it was an episode, you know what. It was a Shenanigan's episode where Anak and Obi Wan and are are tied together by some kind of roupe, yes, and they keep trying to escape and then getting caught, which is so funny on paper. First first impressions Gott to play the first Impressions, Theme songs, theme song, First Impressions of the Gungan General on paper, sticking Dooku, and again Obi want together with the big honkin laser chain. Great premise for an episode. Great premise.
44:06 It's going to be nothing, nothing but character interaction, juicy, delicious, maybe even reached some sort of tenuous understanding with each other, even though episode three dictates that these characters must remain in a form of stasis. Right. Uh, you like this episode a bunch? I mean, I'm not. I mean I think this is your favorite episode of all of Star Wars. You got me, this is It's the last Jedi, is the gung in General. Yep ten out of ten. The Book of Fat then Empire. Yeah, yeah, I had fun in the episode, and that's the truth of it.
44:49 They could have. Dove Dove Dove and Divin Dove farther into exactly what you're talking about, which is like, actually, like if you have these three people together, what does it really mean? And mostly they're just sniping at each other. And there's one distinct moment that I wish we could have spent even longer on, which is like they like pull THEA onto this onto this uh side of the wall, and like Anakin's holding on, he's like supporting both of them. And then the pirates shoot and Dooku starts to plummet and Obi Wan saves his life and Anakin is like, hey, just drop him. But that's it and that's the end of it. And I think that that's more that should have had more than that moment. These types of things are actually far more fucking interesting than I think the episode gave it time for.
45:46 Oh yeah, And that's my big criticism for this episode. Sure, if there hadn't been a lot of if there hadn't been a lot of other stuff happening, and I don't dislike chargear. Again George our antics, that's fine. But in the two Jarjar episodes that we've gotten so far, hey, Jorjar has been employed much better than he was in episode because Felonio and crew are more capable filmmakers than George Lucas was. Yeah, into the two episodes that we've gotten have been tonal masses that have been detracting from something else that's funny. I I just find it well for in this case, my opinion is that what was going on with the Ovian Anakin Dooku was very similar in tone.
46:33 What was happening with Georgiar and my actual desire? Yes, am I, because I think they were fucking Shenanigans. They were shenana getting all over the place. They were like up and then they'd get out, and then they get caught and they'd be like, now. We're back in the cell. Sure it was tonally similar in the sense that both of them were forced into tonal similarities. But like it's but one of those, one of those plotlines have been taken out, then the other one I would have had space for the character to grow. Well, I would have been able to luxuriate in the feelings, and maybe we could be like ah Doku, a noble warrior, even though he is fighting for the side of evil and his intentions now have been twisted for evil. Well, I think there's a seed, a seed of what a just man might be.
47:29 Right. Instead, No, we've got charge r who's shooting stuff by accident. I'm not I don't want to split hairs here. Do it. I don't think that split hairs. I think My my ask here is I wish they had actually committed more to a tone, like to actually dive. I'm with you, like they should have done more. I'm not saying, but what I would I don't agree with is the idea that like, oh, they. Try to try to wish, don't he didn't. They don't. They're not they're not matching tone. Like I think swinging between the two would have been fine because I actually, again, if someone who really liked Bombad Jedi, I actually thought it worked to be like because it actually I think it doesn't go the other way.
48:14 I think it affords more depth to the to the Charjars stuff. Interestingly, with the charge Wars stuff. The fucking senator dies, he's clearly very upset. There's a lot of like seriousness given to it. The way that he's like jumping around fucking things up actually feels like it's charge are understanding his own like clumsiness and like making it work for him, as opposed to it being like true fuck ups. I think that like there could have been I think you're right and that they should have spent more time really digging into that trio and they didn't. That was just like bandon Internet like and not because of jar Jar, but because of it on its own.
48:57 It was that way That's what I'm saying, and it should have been better. So what you're saying is that I need to divorce my expectations as opposed to what the episode is on the page. Yeah, I guess. Yeah. Also, I don't know why I'm defending Targe. Do I just don't? I just don't dislike him as a character? Do it defend jar Jar? I? Yeah? Phil lamar in here, missing Ahmed, Missingmed? Do you please? Yeah? I was finding I was finding the performance of being like this is yeah, he's not he's not getting there. But also what I'm at best is doing is so extremely specific. Yeah, it is extremely specific.
49:37 You can only do an approximation, which I wasn't even aware, yeah until we got BJ Fields here, b J Fields right? BJ Fields? Yeah. Yeah, It's one of those episodes where I had fun, and of course, on reflection, I'm like it could have actually what a like opportunity that felt a little wasted, like to really, instead of us griping at each other and continually getting caught over and over again, why not be like, whoa, what does this mean for us? And really dig into that moment of like like, can you imagine Anakin being enraged? With Obi Wan for saving Duku's life. Yeah, how interesting would that have been?
50:20 The war could have been done. There was a really like not true like I think serious like if there had been a real, a real tonal shift was at the very end when he's clearly so fucking mad when he gets out at the end, after all the power has been turned off because of Jar Jar and he comes out to like get his ship and leave a Dooku does and he just straight up like force chokes that guy and like he like, oh he takes the pirate. He force chokes and brings him up, forces him to shoot the other pirate, which I don't think we see that a lot right, Like it was actually like the music was pretty scared, like he was like the rage like and so it was kind of wild to have a like Shenanigan's episode and then to have this starkly like horrifying moment at the end and then for that to be it right, And I would have I would have I wouldn't have not liked to have a whole episode of feeling that way, you know, just like what does this mean for us?
51:24 You know? Yeah, so you know what I'm with you? Whoa did not expect that I had fun. Oh dear, I had fun. Oh yeah, what do you do? Now? What am I going to do? My entire identity was based into the anger that I felt against an Aspen for liking this episode. Now we've reached the comic agree. I still liked it. Don't get me wrong. Well I didn't like it. Well there you go. No, we're back to disagree. Bah brah. You didn't like the Star Trek episode either. I thought the Star Trek episode was pretty darn sleepy. It was weird, wasn't it. It's weird? There are there are aspects of this episode.
52:04 The EmPATH that I adore, right, the fact that the name the name one. I get to share it with my friend asmin of it. Oh my gosh, not. About La. Everybody should be about tel a hang out with me. I let me visit first, Let me bring all my friends to live with me. Yeah. Uh. Number two? Number one, I get to share it with one of my best friends in the whole wide world. Ask me a webster. Number two. The whole episode is one big black box theater. It is. They put up black curtains so theatrical.
52:48 Which, funnily enough, in doing my research and reading These are the Boy in the Season three by Mark Cushman and Susan Osborne. Was something that was on the script. It's what she wanted the writer. It's what she she wanted to before Joyce. Muscat. Yes, was just a person that was working in TV. YEPO in theater. Yeah, yeah, worked. Wait what do you know about this episode? I know that I know that she was a Star Trek fan. She just got and she yeah, she was working on TV and she was yeah, I mean that's it. She was working at theater and she she made the script and it was like inspired by the I like an earlier story I remember the name of the story, but like the idea and Egyptian mythology of like someone speaking for the like judgment of someone else, kind of anyway.
53:40 Muscat was further inspired after reading about an ancient custom of inviting a person to speak on the behalf of another who was being judged yep, an early version of a character witness, and that this person was known as an answerer. It is apparently an Egyptian concept. She seemed grad and also based off of the HG. Wells or the science fiction novel The World collide right. I think I got really excited because I find it. I have found there is a pattern of women characters being treated with a lot more complexity surprise in stories written by women. So I was curious about it. And I was curious about the sensibility of it as well, because it was extremely theatrical. Yes, and the moment they woke that woman up, the way that she like moved and was like dramatic, I was immediately like, I'm fa, I'm doing Fossy.
54:41 It's like because Aspen and I are friends in real life. Upon watching this episode, sent me the video of Christen Wig as Liza Minelli from Saturday Night Live Fossy. She even looked like Liza Minellie. So little short hair Wig. Yeah, yeah, yeah, I felt it. Perhaps this is my male gilt showing. But I was just like this, this is I found this. The execution pretty sleepy. Sleep kind of did the exact same beats several times, which is frustrating.
55:22 It is, and then you are teaching this character who seems to inherently have empathy. Yep, even though that is you know, it's the name of the episode. But this character whose name Jim not to be confused with Jim Jim no one, no one, no one. But also at this point in production everyone was really sleepy because making a star Trek. Is hard, hard to make a star Trek. And also the making of this episode was surprisingly difficult. Right, and like went over a day or two. Day and a half. Oh, I also saw this. It was because it was because uh, Shatner and Memoy were being a little little twerps and they were like, this is how you should direct this, and she's like, go away, get it out of here.
56:10 Sure. This was also after at least with the contact that was provided within the book. This was after Is There a Truth No Beauty? The episode with Oh Boy. The the the. My goodness, I Am such a big start, the medusin Yes, and Doctor Doctor Miranda Yep. Another an episode I truly did like. And another one where I. Was like, oh wow, this episode and also fantasy, as we talked about in our in There is There in Truth No Beauty episode, Geene Roddenberry added the itdict to sell more things through his things and so just according to the book, Bill Shatner, that's what I call him, and because we are, yeah, he's weird to be friends with a ninety five year old Questrian. Anyways, I believe that their hackles were raised and DeForest Kelly too, at least according to the book, their hackles were raised enough because they were like, what's going We want this show to have a little bit of integrity.
57:17 Yeah, there's a lot about the episode I did, Like I think I could tell. Sorry, it sounds like you found the quote. No you didn't. Still still scrawling look on your face. There, I could tell. And based on what I read that, like the writer of the script, like the script went through a lot of different shifts and changes. I would have been so curious to see what its original form was because my guess is her the path for Jim was made more sense, like in terms of what was being done. Yeah, that's my guess, because you're right, like it is a very strange and it's like it doesn't logically make much sense. Like you're just like, yeah, this character who has fundamental to her literal being is empathy for others, and they're like, we need to teach her and also prove and make sure for the sake of her entire people if they're worth saving, because we got a teacher that it's worth it for her to give up her own life for someone else, And I was like, what, Like, you can see how it has like the beginnings of such a good idea. And my guess is the good idea was there to start with and got slapped out of the way.
58:37 Yes. The quote. Alan Bergman, who plays one of the two alien overseers, said delicious and describe Star Trek to a team. Given the minimal sets and the ludicrous pajama like costumes of the regulars, the episode was quite successful in text and production. So funny where he's wrong, counselor telling me where he's wrong, it's not pajamas. Oh so that's the other thing. The set, the starkness of the set. I really did like that. It was like a black box theater. I actually thought that was extraordinary. It reminded me a lot of the like that Old West episode with like the OK Corral one where it was like that one obviously was a much more interesting set, but was still very stark. It was very dream like.
59:20 It was very strange. It felt like this episode felt like watching an extended dream ballet, which of course helped that she didn't speak, She just she was clearly like a clearly a theater like a dancer theater actor. From what I can tell, I didn't look up the actor, but she the way her movements to me were very studied, and it was That's why I made I mean and truly very exaggerated and fossy esque. Uh. And I just thought it was very interesting, like everything to do with her and her facial expressions, everything that was focused on her was interesting as shit. That the core things got messed up. I didn't understand quite where we were going, but and but I was. I was definitely despite being sleepy, I was definitely like engaged.
1:00:13 The whole time or some very interesting things. Because I was pretty horrified too, Like it's like watching a horror film. And like horror again, dude over here is like it's just a sleepy episode, not even processing the extreme amount of violence just because I feel so Oh I was, and that's unfortunate. I was deeply uncomfortable. And then also, I mean, the central lesson that they have to teach this person, they need to be willing to die, but you already have someone that seems immediately emotionally open. Yeah, feels torturous. Yeah, it's actually it's pretty it was pretty horrifying. I mean, yeah, it's torturous. It's horrifying.
1:00:59 Again, you were the original ending of this had Jem just saving McCoy, and they changed they not Joyce Muscat, but Fred Freiberger and Arthur Singer and supervising producer Robert Tussman, and rod Berry had his hands in a little bit. I want you to know roden Berry was happy to know that another woman writer was working for Star Trek, and also the production was excited because she was not a member of the Writer's Guild, so that means that Star Trek saving money. And also the way that Jem was described in the initial version, the men are startled.
1:01:40 The creature on the couch stands. It has the body of a girl woman clothed in a gossamer material that sparkles like diamonds, dead white skin, curled hair, and large expressive eyes that shine out against the white ness. That feels a little bit more Tim Burton esque, a little bit more chilling. Yeah, yeah, like she's kind of like a little creepy. Yeah, she's clearly trying to like make her less like Vassilene Lens pretty lady. And if we are because I think this is an episode that is doing a lot of telling you that the thing needs to happen as supposed to showing because Jim the character cannot speak, can't speak, I know just what she is thinking and have no reason don't tell me because it hurts but to start, even though it's simple, but it is an easy fix of just having this person seem more like an other. Yeah right, I mean, or I don't know, just make it like a sadistic general that you need to teach empathy to someone that is trained in war, or you.
1:02:50 Start her out as a cold other that doesn't want to help, like you actually have a change for her. That is where it becomes confusing. I in fact not realize. I spent the first half the episode being like, why the fuck is she here? Because nothing is pointing toward her. You're just sort of like she must be part of this, And then finally they're like, she must be part of this, and I'm like, I know. The explanation of the why the episode is happening is within the last ten minutes of the episode, which is the problem whenever you're trying to stage functional storytelling. Yeah, don't mystery box it, right, Try and have your motivations laid up front. But also the arguments that we are positing have us trying to sympathize with the victory with the captors as opposed to the actual tortures experience that the that Jem must be going through, and then Kirk argues against because those folks have inherent both planets have inherent value.
1:03:53 Yeah, yeah, I by if I were. Doing this, if you were writing the empathy. Yes, if there's a lesson for Jim to learn, like basically what I think there's a certain level of it, like rubbing me wrong, because that's an EmPATH I woo, No, I it's it's like you said, and like what what what can we assume based on this? It's like she already starts out like this is what they are as people? They like she.
1:04:33 Starts out in terms of empathy, I think that was that an accident? Was that an accident? Are you just like happy to start talking? I am happy to start talking? Are you right? Folks? God Christ Almighty, go on, get it out, get it out. In terms of empathy, Jim starts out pretty much as an eight, and her only drawback is that she doesn't want to die. For someone else exactly exactly, which is exactly it's it's they're basically holding people hostage and being like they'll die if you don't die, yeah, which is uh, stupid, pretty stupid, pretty.
1:05:18 Wild, it's pretty dumb. You're right, it's pretty dumb. Like it it's and I think this is where it starts to like, let's as a person raised as like a girl in a world that expects that kind of level of like you have to be very aware of everybody's needs at all time and provide for them, like making her already like a woman or girl, she's like she is, she's presenting in this space, you know, like. And you're saying that she's a stone cold hotey.
1:05:58 She looks like my yeah, she like to even start there and to then have so much expected, that much more expected of you, like put it into like a current state translation of it basically to say, and I feel like we see this a lot with see with women, with girls, see it a lot with mothers. Right, It's like you. Should literally be willing to kill yourself, like to die for someone else, to like destroy your entire life. And it's not because you are a good person or morally good it is because like that is your duty. Like, and so I think the whole, like the whole structure of it feels like it is leading towards that, And it can't be dissociated from the fact that she is like a delicate woman.
1:06:45 Yeah, it's crunchy. That's a crunchy premise to begin with. Mm hm Yeah. And also there, just as you're saying that there is a possibility of something very delicious within that kernel, just you can't unlock the potential within What would happen if this woman's self sacrifice, inherent self sacrificing nature was pushed to the authomat test for the survival of her species, right, But it's from the perspective of Kirk's block and McCoy or yeah, the easy fix just put it through her viewpoint.
1:07:26 I was gonna say, when you experienced the terror, Yeah, I mean that is like, god forbid we have it from that person's perspective. Like it's like the same thing of Ranberry being like, well, good, we got another lady just for the sake of having old lady. Yeah, as opposed to like, well, what is the actual experience that she's going through? How would she feel about this as opposed to as being a thing that's talked about for the purposes of these other stories. Yeah, it's it's frustrating. Also might just be baked into it. But also there's just belittling things that I'm pretty darn sure came after subsequent revisions. For instance, they wanted to literally make her hotter. Justin Bob Justman, supervisor producer, says, I feel Jim as described in the story outline, will not be as physically attracted to the audience as she ought to be. I think she ought to be ethereally beautiful and saint like in her quality. She should be gentle and pure and good and sweet and virginal and keep a kosher house.
1:08:35 Yep, yep, saint like, saint like and virginal. Okay, then you have done. That's stupid, Bob Justment dumb. Though his little his little mustache that he has is really cute. It really is. Buck is mustache. Whoa. And Also that's just like bad storytelling because you're starting the character off already. You're already the character, yes, but the journey you are hiding the journey of this character. You're going what is going on yep, you feel bad for her whenever she is suffering, and then you find out what the function of that suffering is. And then Kirk defends her as opposed to and Kirk being a slam dunk Allen being like, Jim, what do you want to do? And Jem is easy fixed, Jem speaks, even though that could be ablest in itself because you don't get very mute many mute characters serious.
1:09:34 If she's like an impath, why doesn't she like he touch him and he can like feel what she's feeling or thinking, like why not go the other way? It doesn't have to be speaking. I genuinely thought that's what it was going to be. Like I was. It was, Oh, I'm sorry, does this not happen this way? She only. The journey. The journey should be You don't have to self sacrifice, Yes, it can be. What they are doing to you is not adequate. Instead, Kirk does argue for that, but it's Kirk arguing as opposed to being like for her, what do you want? Why couldn't she have grabbed them and translated that to them? Of like, the lesson she actually learned is like like we should be inherently valuable, But it doesn't.
1:10:18 Feel like the episode is about No, it's not about about that torture. It's it's about Kirk, Spock and McCoy continually getting hurt. Yes, and Jim has to be like, yeah, I mean it's not folks that aren't watching me on the YouTube channel and walking up like the she touches she touches them and the special effect. Oh, it actually is really good. It's like like whatever, like scars on them, she takes it onto her body and then it goes away. Yeah. Yeah, she has no agency and therefore it has no I mean, she's sort of does, but she doesn't actually personally, it's just an it's just for the story. And the plot. It is.
1:11:00 You're right about our boys who are also once again doing what they always do. They are also aren't changing, like they're like, well, of course we'd sacrifice ourselves for each other. Well, and you're like, Okay, a pretty good scene where they are trying to fight over who is going to go get sacrificed. That is a great scene and Spock, but what's the different about Kirk is suffering from the bends, which is such a weird specific detail that I really really liked. I didn't like that too, and I wish would come up other times that they are deep in deep in the core of a planet. Ye, But then Spock and jax Kirk, no, McCoy and jax Kirk with the thing so he can get over the bens. That means that Spock is in command. So Spock makes the call to go sacrifice himself, and then McCoy's like in a pig sign and shoot Spock. And then McCoy goes to make the sacrifice. And then we get the closest that we ever get to d Kelly being Tariliss.
1:12:00 Oh yeah, I was like, wow, Wow, what cut his shirt? What cut his shirt into those chains? Those chains he was hanging from? Oh? Gotcha, gotcha? Gotcha? God? I here, okay, here's a question I want to ask. Oh gosh, I love answering questions. What here we go is like, what are they defining in this? Okay? This is a thematic sort of moment here, like of what in terms of like what are we defining in terms of empathy or like in that episode, I.
1:12:42 Think the bottom line thing that our villains, the Vions are going after, as Jim can signify that her race is worthy of saving if she allows herself to die for these strangers. Okay, that is empathy, That is empathy through that notion. Yeah, that means that every person on that planet should be willing to sacrifice their own lives for someone else, no matter. What, no matter what, which makes them worthy of saving. Yes, as opposed to the selfish ask that they are making, as opposed to just making our call because it's it impossible, they should just you should just save them because it is life, right right.
1:13:30 I mean, I think the sort of weak thing that was brought up is like, well, there are multiple planets that we could save, and we have to decide which one is worth saving, and. Let's just make more trips. Yeah, but also that's not the function. The function of this is a moral quandary that is actually, I think, at the end, an unjust artificate, an unjust Yeah. A question that is being opposed to this to. Jim, what do you how you identify empathy? Like, how do you describe it? You sense other people's emotions, you feel, you feel with people?
1:14:10 You yeah, yeah, yeah, because I think of empathy, you know, there's that sort of prober neighborwn ask like description of like the sympathy versus empathy, where sympathy is could be like a, oh, I'm feeling I see that, like you know, I feel I'm sorry that you're experiencing this pain. Empathy is sort of like the ability to put yourself into someone else's place, which I think they are actually Interestingly enough in the episode, the like strongest signifier of that is the like I literally am taking on your physical malady Like It's almost like the truest manifestation of empathy that I like, I'm like if you were to say to me, like I'm having a bad day, like sympathy is like, well, I'm sorry to hear that, versus like me being like let me hear about your day, and like I when you say like, well I got into an argument with a friend, I am like, I know the pain of having an argument with a loved one and how that can feel that way even if I, like have never had it. I could be like, well, I know the pain of feeling scared that I might lose something or whatever it looks like right like I am I am like present in this with you as a form of like my own like I can feel like this feeling that you feel, and that is that kind of distinction of empathy. Here's where I'm here's my question.
1:15:36 I appreciate that clarification. And that's that's just me. It could basically anybody, Like I'm sure other people have different definitions, Like I think. I think empathy is pie. Yo, tell me more apple pawe pumpkin pie, blueberry pie. Wait, if that's what empathy is, what sympathy cake? So my next leading question is liked, at the end of the. Gungan general of its here we go.
1:16:17 One, there is the the move that there's the move that obi Wan makes to save you Ku, and then there's also the move at the end to not like take the pirates end to not like arrest Hondo, to be like hey, like we have no more quarrel with you, We're letting you go. And also just the. General like idea of Jedi and like the like, well, we have compassion. It's like explicitly said textually of like it is important for Jedi to have compassion. So I guess, like, then, like, what's the difference between. That even though obi Wan didn't save the other prisoners. Right next to Annago. Oh my god, my god.
1:16:58 Yeah, well that seems very cools go. But also this episode is with things that strike me as the Jedi have to be this powerless because the plot dictates right, because the rules to the rules wildly vacillate of how powerful the Jedi are. That's I truly think that that is fine, because what are you going to do? Whatever? But and also whenever the episode is not working at an emotional level for me, then I start going into those logic plot holes. Of course. Yeah, I'm the same way. I'm like, well, if you're not actually proving it to me, then I'm preoccupied with the fact that, like other things don't.
1:17:41 Work because I just think that the episode just was not there but. Badically so so are is what you're saying, Like it's kind of a moot point because like it didn't kind of make sense, like the kind of compassion that he was presenting, because it felt like it was more for a plot as opposed to anything that was emotionally oriented. Yeah, because it definitely felt like it was moved because we need to have an ending of the episode as opposed to an extension. Like the saving of Duke. Why include that because it's great I have. And also it's a micro moment as opposed to a big character beat, because that's the structure of this episode. I think it's just a lovely detail that indicates character.
1:18:25 Well, that's and that's what I'm getting at. I would argue that Obi Wan you would. I would argue that Obi Wan is a fundamentally compassionate person. I think probably what Obi Wan and other Jedi are missing is like an engagement with real empathy. Yeah, he's not a fundamentally compassionate person, or at least maybe he's a fundamentally compassionate person within the context of Clone Wars. But this one line, I undo your entire Erard okay in red to Obi Way, why do I get the sense we picked up another pathetic life form?
1:19:06 Well, he was also, I mean, I think there's also a space for them for he is a character to grow as a person. I think he becomes more compassionate over time. I think the older he gets. I think he was a dumb old, dumb dumb. Then do you think that Felony will ever make a cartoon show that bridges episode one in episode two? Maybe why just seeing more Obi Wan and Anakin? Maybe I actually wouldn't hate that. I do love their relationship. I think it's a. Little boy and becoming. Yeah, the compassionate person trying to become person as opposed to the more hard edged obi Wan.
1:19:49 And I say that extremely lightly because the textual examples of how we get Obi Wan and episode one are so threadbare. Yeah, I mean, you didn't watch all of the Kenobe's show. That's the show be Kenoby showby that's an extremely empathetic or not empathetic still, actually that is an empathetic Kenobi as opposed to like like. I think he is really like But I think the reason he is able to tap into that is because of I don't think this is necessarily true. I don't think you need to have like experienced trauma to be an empathetic person. By any means, you don't have to even have experienced like the pain of someone else to get to like be like be present.
1:20:36 You can find like it's But I do think by that point Kenobi has gone through a very huge change in that he felt like he failed everyone and he has survivor's guilt, and I do think it is easier for him to tap into a real ability to like feel a similar type of pain to others people. So let me say this, well, okay, okay, at the end of this week's episode The Gung in General, starring George Arbinks as himself, Yes, yeah, it is tactical compassion. Yeah, I think that's all we want is employing. That's very true because it's definitely a political move because you absolutely would get the support of the Jedi to be like, you're going to bring these people in that poisoned you off camera? Yeah, yeah, absolutely do that. But he's making a tactical point to be like, just be aware that we're compassionate. You're right, and do do is going to come back? You're right.
1:21:48 But I do think I do think that is not to interrupt your point, but I actually do think that is the one of the character flaws of the institution of the Jazz, which is that it's like, it's not actually real compassion. I'm like, it's it's a sort of approximation of for political purposes. Sure, yeah, yeah, but the episode isn't necessarily interrogating that so much as it is. And I will repeat focused I. Was interrogating it. I'm here. That's because you're a smart person. It's because I'm an empathetic person.
1:22:30 What what I have never once seen you share someone's emotion, not ever, Okay, not even within this earlier episode. Okay, all right, all right, if that's what you think, that's fine. Oh he looks so concerned. It's interesting to think to talk about these notions of empathy within the context of Star Wars and Star Trek, where I don't know, both episodes have their own frustrations. Sure, Star Trek is interrogating something I feel an aesthetic level just to say my catchphraise, and Star Wars is just kind of focused on having shenanigans, which is absolutely fun.
1:23:13 Just get frustrated in this situation. Yeah, but not always. Yeah, so often it's really truly like having a conversation. I think we've proven that now with many examples. Don't look at you like that Star Wars is better. Star Trek is better. You as you Walla Sean, you. Gotta bleep that. What do you say episodes having common aspen. I mean, that's what I was trying to get at. Sure you're trying to you're trying to bring it home before our next segment. Yeah, I was trying to one.
1:23:57 And it's like less of commonality, more of a like what are the levels of like what we recognize as human connection and empathy, sympathy, compassion for what purpose? Like driving pieces of it. I mean within the paradigm of Star Wars versus Star Trek, at least within the version of Clone Wars. And perhaps that's an extension of the uh Dave Filonius and George Lucas's worldview at this point in time. But perhaps compassion is a little bit more tactical as opposed to how it is in Star Trek, which is that compassion is a basic that you start. You start from the baseline of everyone is compassionate. Yeah, at least when the paradigm of Star Wars in a post nine to eleven world, Perhaps even your heroes deploy compassion in ways that are disingenuous. Yeah, they have to. I mean, even your heroes from episode one on are flawed at their core.
1:25:01 I got I got a little secret for you. Every time Kirk, Captain Captain Kirk, or Romance as a lady lately, except for in some not every time, just a few times now, it has been tactical compassion. It does a lot of fucking tactical sh I'm just here to say that perhaps the utopian world of Star Trek is not so utopian. The world itself, the earth below you might be, but the the militaristic structure of the Federation. Isn't wait has been. Don't don't take the applause button away from me. Please don't do that. Oh I stole it.
1:25:43 I came into your bedroom a thousand miles away and I hit the button. I'm here to scorch earth. All your faves are problematic. Excepts Night. It's a perfect show in every single way. You know what. Faes aren't problematic, but. A long time ago. Start dating this week. I quoted a boat, I dated a geek, but none of them could warp my drive into higher space. The best of both worlds kept me in the second place.
1:26:30 Captain slog on a halla kron. I wanted a song. I penned a song. Seventeen more minutes advise. In super high def. Aboard the USS Enterprise dt F. Don't you take my walk lighter and clip it? Don't you take my wretchered buddy and nip it? If you spill it, See, I'm gonna sip it. Starship it great. Time for us to name our favorite chips that fly through the stars and our favorite ships that fly through our hearts. Wooshohom, I have a first ship that is not a ship. It's actually a vehicle.
1:27:24 Here we go. It's a moving vehicle. It certainly is. It is the sculptors. Oh, those little rhino delos. Those Rhino Delos from the Clone Wars episode The Gung In general, I loved them. I loved them so much. I saw them. I saw them bouncing on the horizon during the episode, and I wrote down and I circled it, and I'll try and put it up on the cameras for all to see. I said sheeps, you said sheep. I was hoping that we were going to get some space sheeps this week. You got space rhinos. Instead, we did with you know, I don't want to, don't don't want to, you know, great rhinos. So we didn't talk about the fact that there's acid geysers.
1:28:09 Oh they are acid geysers. Yeah, there is, like there's acid guysers, but also there's mist in the air, which would imply that there's acid hanging in the air, which means that the atmosphere. Don't think about it too much. I won't. I don't listen. Yeah, it's it's a fun little bit where they like hide in the geyser and then Charge is like those beasties when they run, we have to run, and then you're like okay, and then I immediately run. You're like, got it. That guys was about to blow a very clever though connection with the natural world that our Gungan general has. Uh yeah, I don't know. They're just really fun. He's just like, I have an idea classic classic Charge are because so they ride on the back of them. But then the pirates start shoot at them, and I got really anxious. I was like, ope, they don't hurt the rhinos. But then I was like, I bet they have a really really thick skin, and I bet be Okay. They're so nice to help, you know.
1:29:12 I love them. That's mine, I asked. And I'm gonna need to call in a favor from you, as the Star Wars expert. I wrote down. I wrote down because I don't know what the actual word for it, and it didn't say anything in the Filoni Zoni the bombbat clankings, Oh oh. The clankers, what were they? They these big honkin tanks that look based off of some pre existing ships in there and then also mixed with for some reason, I want to say in Apache helicopter and big honkin tanks that the pirates were flying in on the ground, they were very, very cool. They were very enjoyed them.
1:30:00 I do not know what they are called, right, and we can we can look it up later, because I really liked them too, and I just yeah, I just don't know what they are. We'll have to look them up, but we can call them bob bang clinkers for now. I believe they are called the w l O five speeder tank cool because I typed them bomb bag clankings in Duct dut Go. I was presented with the episode with with the you know, with the thing, the speeder tank. Gosh, it does look so cool. It's a very pirate tank.
1:30:41 Pirate tank. Whenever you say that out loud, aspen pirate tank, that's very cool. You know it's cool pirates. No one else is cool. Tanks plumped together get a cool piece. Of hardware, bricking and tank. A repulsor tank with heavy armor and weaponry used by week Way Pirate game. I'll bring out of the backworder plane of florum. So this is this is what they use. Yeah, and they don't talk about it on the Filoney zone in terms of but like, I wouldn't be surprised, but what you're talking about is true that they like borrowed visual components from others, And I guess you could also assume that they themselves probably pieced together from other uh, from other like things like other equipment that they've probably pirated for sure, which is cool. I love that as a concept.
1:31:24 Speaking of a hirted aspen, what are your favorite examples of getting booty? Oh jeez, Louise, my fun goofy answer is gem and therapy. I even had a dumb answer like that in a while, though. I just feel like she's gone through a lot, and you know, when you're a truly empathetic person, what you have to do is you have to really develop some strong boundaries of what how much of your energy you're giving out and kind of stuff. You know. So like perhaps I'm like therapeutic work would be really helpful for us, and I really I really ship that, sure, but my real ship is Obi Wan and Doku.
1:32:15 Let's go to the board, Palpatine, Dooku, Yoda Doku, dou greet it, no Obi Wan and Doku good job asmen. Thanks. I just think that there's I think it's the equivalent and maybe all three of them, but I think Anakin was like a little out of this one. I think it was definitelyn Obi Wan Douku thing. It's the equivalent of the like the the like oh no, there's only one bed, like we're tied together by a laser rope. I do wish that we had gotten that scene where they needed to go to sleep yep. And because it's smacked up in the two thousands, there is some pretty big lines of homo eroticism, but at the same time they're like, actually this feels kind of nice.
1:33:01 Or sorry, homophobia not homo I wish, well, you know. You wish that there was homophobia. I wish it was, oh, weirdly hand in hand in different ways. Ah, people are weird. Yeah, that's mine all right, under sniping at each other, you know, I like those enemies still nevers. It's so interesting that you said Anakin was out of this episode because my ship for this week, and I wrote this down in my notebook, was Anakin and Douku. Well, what I mean is. Why. Here's why Anakin says so many things that seem to just irritate Doku. Yeah, and I think Doku is so irritated by it. But at the same time, it's very is that he kind of wants a brat. Yeah.
1:33:54 Well he sees how powerful that little Brad is and it's like, I don't know, maybe I could use him, Maybe he could be Braddy at me. Oh my god, like he's so against it. But at the same time, he's like, you're petty a little bit, aren't you. It's true. I guess you're right. I was thinking of a different sort of like I don't know, a different type of dynamic and Ana can. I'm still so caught up in the catching him. I'm still so caught up, and it's just like drop you know. Yeah, anyway, it's nice. It's nice. I feel I feel a touch, like we ignored Star Trek. Maybe I can also ship those two weirdo dudes.
1:34:36 See I you can reminder, we're about to exit this segment, so you can only make one more change. Maybe I'll ship them instead. I can do. You're gonna you're gonna you're gonna say, oh, we want to do coup for later. Probably you know what, that's a good you know what, Let's let's ship these two guys this you know what. Okay, Yeah, let's let's say it this way, Okay, because I need to give star Treks some attention. They're here, they're like doing all these experiments. You can only imagine. They're like down there a lot, like long hours, like who knows if there's any more of them. In my mind, these two are more than coworkers. They air lovers.
1:35:24 They're co people. They're co people, you know, and like it really pains them to have to really do these types of experiments, you know, and like wait thirty minutes to reveal why it's really rough for them. They probably like after this situation, we're like, wow, Fred, the other ones like Tom Lal and Sam Fred Tom, that's not. What I said at all, Freddrick. Thomas, They're like, it's really rough, you know, I think like doing this kind of work. And then Thomas is like, yeah it really is. Then I gosykeasy.
1:36:04 So that's instead all right. Well, now that that's locked in and the segment is absolutely done, let me play my exclusive segment is done sound effects, we get to the central premise of this podcast. Right now, we have been dilly dallying for an hour and a half, two hours if you're listening to the Patreon version. Yeah, well for what's twenty minutes of that was us being very angry about something else, entirely. Completely angry about nothing else. But let's not let's not dilly dally, no serious shift. Serious stop as we try and find out which one is better Star Trek or Star Wars by ranking the Mpath from Star Trek the Original series, season three versus the gun in general from Star Wars the Colon Wars season one. And I will go first, starting with the EmPATH, and I am going to give this episode a five.
1:37:02 Wow. I found it quite sleepy. I found my attention wandering. As I said before, we kind of cycled the same beats over and over and over again. It's unfortunate. It's also frustrating that there is a better episode there. But I try to just take a thing as it is as opposed to how I want it to be, and how it is is pretty darn dull, with a lackluster central message ye that we've definitely seen in other Star Trek in a more potent form because you don't make it about this other character. You make it about our central characters learning that they're secretly racist. What we'll get to it.
1:37:47 Oh, okay, I'm gonna go five point eight because while I agree with you and you kind of you talked me into this, a little bit more might have given it a little bit higher. I really think it is elevated in part by doing something a little different in terms of like the production of it. The production design is extraordinary. I adore it. I wish that more shows would push it to be this strange. Yeah. At one point, we Kirk is looking out onto something that we do not see, and the lights just suddenly turn on as if he is finally seeing something. Yeah, it is straight up expressionism.
1:38:37 It's very cool and I like it, and I like that I forgot not name, but I liked the main actress, the one who does play Jim. She Rule. You can tell that she was like, what a what a wild character to get to play, Like, what a very expressionistic thing to get to do, and to like make this very theatrical and dance kind of like very instability to kind of feel to it. And so I think that's what gets it higher for me. But everyone's talking true, you're talking about Catherine Hayes. And Catherine's lover, she was wonderful. Uh, that can't be possible.
1:39:18 Five and a five point eight. What's that I'm saying? Six point two six six six. Oh, that's that's the devil getting into Oh you know what it is, averaging B and C column. I supposed to just t yeah, Oh, I'm going to need to change some stuff on the spreadsheet. Uh. Oh, it's a five point four. Yeah, it's a five point for but it's still anyone's game aspen. Yeah, we move over to the Gungan General and I will rank it first, and I think that I'm just going to give it a four point five. Okay. Oh, And that's just how feeling this week. Sure, that's how I was feeling about it. Too many Shenanigans, which I find with Shenanigans. But the Shenanigans didn't feel all that special. There's nothing new about the Shenanigans. It was just shenan against for Shenanigan's sake. I felt pretty uninspired.
1:40:19 And what adds to my frustration is that there's a very inspiring thing. Actually, both plot lines have something very inspiring jar Jar possibly taking agency as opposed to like bomb bad Jedi, where he kind of he does become slightly redeemed, but that's a little bit of an accident as opposed to him making the purposeful choice here to represent There's a wild somber scene that George really liked and wanted to include, which is whenever the senator, the other senator on the ship dies, jar Jar has a funeral and is quite somber about it, and I think that that is touching. Yeah, and it indicates a greater emotionality that is only hinted that and never really seen for the rest of the episode. And then similarly, having didn't even talk about the start of the episode, which completely disregards the brilliant ending from Duke to Capture where they're just like, just happened, and then you start the episode and turns out uh An and Obi Wan we're not smart like you just saw. They were actually stupid and got poisoned anyways, so.
1:41:25 It was kind of wild, Like I was like, Okay, what happened like this? Anyway? Yes, that's dumb, and I. Don't like that. A fun fact is that. You learned too from the felony Zoni is that there's a little easter egg, and that the staff that the senator had that that Jarger kind of puts into the pile his death file is the staff from Raiders of the Lost Ark. It is fun. The staff you know that I forgot it's called. But the one that Indian takes into the like that underground space to identify the stuff is stephf Raw is the stuff for raw.
1:42:07 Yeah, it's fun. It's just an eys dragg. It doesn't mean anything. And I think that's cute. That is cute. I enjoyed it very much. Six point four two minutes later or six point. Four, Yeah, everything's true. I also liked it. I liked it more than you. I had fun. I think that there is a touch of I like the agency of I liked little. I liked. It's one of those where it's like not more than the sum of its parts. It's like, yeah, for something, it's like the pieces of it were really fun as a whole could have been more. That brings the total to five point four five for the Gong in general versus the MPs five point four and what could be argued the slimmest victory by a margin of point zero five has been satisfied. That Star on the Week.
1:43:01 I didn't mean to do that. I meant sixth I. Meant that Star Wars one is the week. Oh my god, barely. That's wild. It is wild. I mean it's an empty victory, you know, but a victory is a victory nonetheless. Yeah, you're like, yep. Guess you won? Did it aspen? Great job? It's all me I would say, especially at a situation where we do, in fact give it scores. There's no object objectivity at all. That's absolutely correct. I'm like, oh my god, I won? Oh my god, how did it happen? I was for what it's worth, going to give it that no matter what.
1:43:50 Sure, but certainly we don't make this show in a vacuum. And well, we can give each other accolades, so too, must we give those accolades to our fearless patrons, of which we love them so much. And for five dollars a month, you can get early versions of these episodes and extended versions of the episodes. And for just a dollar a month, we'll just say your dang name on the podcast. So nice, It is pretty nice. We just want to say your name, because we really like you, and you too could join the fine auspices of fine folks such as Timbo De Sosa, HEII Rogers, Kevin Miller, Arizona, Mark Austin Aaron and lastly, but certainly not leastly joelt Partner, who composed our I starship at theme song. Our main and ending theme was composed by mister tosin Awa FeSO.
1:44:38 You can get more of his work in the show notes. Just click on the link that is right next to his name. If you don't want to reach out to us via our Patreon, you can send us an email track Wards Pod at gmail dot com. We love reading all of your correspondence and more than likely we'll read it on air. And if for some reason you don't want any of those things, follow us over on Instagram, Instagram dot com, slash truk Wars Pod and over up Blue Sky Uh just search trek Wars Pod. And also we have a YouTube channel so you can see Aspen makes faces such as this. Wait wait wait wait wait. Yeah, sorry audio listeners, you can't see that. You gotta find it at YouTube dot com, slash at trek Wars Aspen as always. I freaking love you so much. Love you and listeners, We freaking love you. Thank you so much for listening. May the Force be with you and live long and prosper.
1:45:57 You know what I miss a is Moopsie. You even played moops. You know what? I played it during the episode I forgot. Have you seen Alien Romulus yet? No? Can you see it so we can talk about it? Fine? Yes, Okay
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Spreaker
RSS Feed