Sept. 27, 2024

The Hidden Enemy vs. The Mark of Gideon

The Hidden Enemy vs. The Mark of Gideon
The Hidden Enemy vs. The Mark of Gideon
Trek Wars Podcast
The Hidden Enemy vs. The Mark of Gideon

The Hidden Enemy changes the game for the Clones.

And The Mark of Gideon is an episode.

Aspen loves Detective Obi-Wan and Detective Anakin. Kenny loves bureaucracy. Aspen has a big crush on Asajj Ventress.

And we wonder why Mark of Gideon didn't...

The Hidden Enemy changes the game for the Clones.

And The Mark of Gideon is an episode.

Aspen loves Detective Obi-Wan and Detective Anakin. Kenny loves bureaucracy. Aspen has a big crush on Asajj Ventress.

And we wonder why Mark of Gideon didn't lean into any of the many ideas it brought up.


__________________________________

Get early, extended episodes on our Patreon at https://www.patreon.com/trekwarspod

Watch us!
https://www.youtube.com/@trekwarspod

Theme by Tosin Awofeso

Social Media:
https://www.instagram.com/trekwarspod
https://bsky.app/profile/trekwarspod.bsky.social

Want to ask us questions? Email us at trekwarspod@gmail.com .

And leave us a review! https://bit.ly/leave-a-review-trek-wars

0:27 Welcome to the Trek Wars Podcast, the one podcast that dares to answer the most important question and fandom, which is better Star Trek or Star Wars by going through both franchises and chronological release order. I am Kenny Madison, the Star Trek contingent with me Esper always. Is Aspen Webster, Star Wars. Lover, and today we are both loving both of these episodes from Star Trek the Original series, Season three, The Mark of Gideon versus Star Wars the Clone Wars Season one, The Hidden Enemy. I respect your segue considerably, but I disagree on principle. Yeah, go on, please, No, I mean, we'll talk about it, but I can tell you one of these episodes is good.

1:12 One of these episodes was so boring. I must fell asleep. Boy. I wonder which one. I mean, here we are, here, we are. I just wonder which one it could have possibly been? What you were talking about, an episode that is definitely just so passionately written. The Hidden Enemy. That's right. Goddamn god, damn. This season, this season three of Star Trek. It's getting pretty sleepy. I'm just fucking tired. I'm getting a touch of the like the way that I felt with like some e Woks episodes where I was like, come on, come on, nah.

1:54 Speaking of Rush in the trip, someone that wanted to rush. The synopsis for the Mark of Giddy, which was, of course released January seventeenth, nineteen sixty nine. Writers George F. Slaven, Stanley Stanley Adams, director Judd Taylor, who just directed Wink of a nine. Good for him, very good for him. John Crosby for her syndicated Calm TV Scout Okay, wrote, Joan, give it to me. There is never a lack of confusion on Star Trek. That show is no exception. Captain Kirk has beamed down to a planet and he disappears. But that's not the case from Kirk's outlook. According to his experience, everyone else on the ship has disappeared. Actually, he is being held in communicado by an alien society that enjoys their space isolation and they intend to keep it that way.

2:45 Okay, Okay, cool, Thanks, Jude, Joe, Joe, June, John Joan, Yeah, and dadd a little bit more detailed to it. He's being held in the surprise of it is that he this this society. They never they don't die, so they're looking for him to infect them with the virus. That's fucking weird. We'll get into it, I guess. Yeah. Well, but just just for some context that Joan didn't give despite her syndicated. Column, she nailed the synopsis of the Mark Gideon.

3:27 Yeah, well, and we'll talk about we'll talk about some like immediate reactions. But one of those episodes where you're like, cool, concept, what the funk's going on? What is going on? What did you what? What? What? You had more than six hours to write this episode? This is what you came up with that says that we paid for sub sandwiches for this writer's room, and this is all you could come up with. We got you the good coffee, folgers, and this is how you could come up with. This is what you could come up with. Je Taylor, you just directed. Let that be your last battlefield. This is what you come up with. Clearly, Yeah, it's just a very bewildering situation for me in that, but once again proving that some Star Trek episodes should just be thirty minutes.

4:17 What a bewildering episode. I am deeply bewildered by everyone's actions. Let's talk about the hidden Enemy Star Wars The Clone Wars The Hidden Enemy released February sixth, two thousand and nine. It was directed by Stewart Lee. Great jobs, Steward Steward, written by drewsy Greenberg Brian Larson as Steph or writer. Yeah, great job everybody. Oh gosh, sorry, I just was like at the IMDb and it was like, that's right, A sage of interest was in this. Just a beautiful episode of just all your faiths and I got an obi wan discover evidence of a trader amongst their ranks while attempting to lead republic forces deliberate Christophe's's from a separatist siege, and this, much like Jones column, doesn't go into much more detailed, but it then leads to investigation by our faves Rex and Cody, which I this is yeah, as a real Rex and Cody have the app which is fabulous to try to wead this person out while they kind of go on a bit of a They go on a little bit of adventure, do some fighting and message.

5:28 Massage venture is more is more like it? Not to immediately dive into things, but do you see do you see what I've been hinting at for the like every time Massage Ventresses has popped up in things, how I've been like, I ship her with every single person that hates her. That she she's so horny. Yeah, this is like one of the episodes where she and Obi Wan are flirting so profoundly that it's I'm that it is one of those moments where you're like a kids show, Like even Alter Dear at one point, he's just like, you know, lovely to see Deerppe. Also, I will say I was being a little bad with this episode. I had it on while I was watering the plants. Hopefully I didn't miss anything. I really needed to water the plants. How dare you the so many so anyway, So that's that's it. It's been a great episode.

6:29 Hope to see all soon talking everybody. Thank you so much. I love you. Let me take any live long and prosper. I like that you assumed it would win. Let's not be around the bush. One of these episodes is bound to elect you as a mayor of nap City. The mayor of Nap City, and here I am and my friend disorder businesses. The hawk sho me me me yeah, yeah, yeah, okay, yeah, I don't know how you feel. You want to start with the one we hated, the home we liked, let's start.

7:16 Let's start with the one that there. I think there are worse episodes of than the Mark of Get In, but really disappointing about this episode. I think what is even more disappointing than an outright terrible episode or a catastrophic episode is the fact that it is so mid yeah it is. There's oh my gosh, so much potential. It is obfuscated by an unnecessary mystery box to give you the illusion of tension as opposed to at the central theme of the story is something that is pretty powerful politically bold for the time that it's being released in nineteen sixty nine and the throes of uh in the throes of Vietnam. And certainly there's a clash, but between conservative and liberal ideals, No much more than the round of I don't know which way feminism, but talking about outright contraception in.

8:09 This oh yeah, yeah, actually, let me check my notes. Oh no, life is sacred. Dumb dumb, dumb, dumb dumb. Then I wrote iuts in birth control are not abortifationis. But I wrote that in all capital letters will get to it. Well, but the very fact that Kirk is like sorry, birth control like is a very normal, common thing, very like obvious, like or like yeah, or any kind of procedures at all anyway, Yes, yeah, good points, good points. Yes, but it all of these things are completely like I said, obfuscated. For yeah, something that is extremely similar to the episode that we just got like six episodes ago, Wink of an Eye, where Kirk is isolated on a ship with another woman, Lad and his crew is not available for some reason, and surprise, it's this convoluted thing because they need something. Whereas in Wink of an Eye they needed his kirk juice, here they need Kirk's blood.

9:25 May they literally need his blood because they need the dormant virus that he had then was called vegan something around. Let's get let's get to it. The central mystery of the thing is not that exciting. The prem the themes that they're trying to examine are extremely exciting, but the episode is not interested interrogating it outside of the kind of the lip service that they're paying to it because they understand that it's a Star Trek and they know that, like philosophy was important to the show at one point. Yeah, and then they just kind of get back to the shenanigans. The bureaucraus part is kind of interesting to me, but also there's diminishing returns on that with just suck attempting to navigate bureaucracy and speaking bureaucracy successfully right, the frustrations they are in. But it's not really examining that so much as it really feels like it is filling time because they understand they have to deliver an episode.

10:22 There's like a billion things that they could do. It could just take the risk and be like, yeah, let's not mystery box it and let's just confront it head on and deal with repercussions. Literally take him down to the planet, start watching people get sick around him. What does that look like from like an emotional perspective? But just can't do that costs money, right. Because yeah, there's people and that, Yeah, you can't pay those people. So if you've got the shoestring budget of twelve dollars, you can't do that. You've got to have them isolated, like no extras, even you're just on the ship alone. Okay, Well, if you're working with your constraints, constraints, we got to see it Marini thing here, why not then lead like, yeah, lean into the horror of the thing, right, which I'm always going to be here for Like at first it was deeply creepy. Why not keep it so creepy?

11:11 What's the one episode we watched? Oh, the EmPATH? Like the way that the EmPATH the production design of it, right, like, that's a very similar vibe. It's extremely creepy because you are very much in a space of discomfort, Like it creates a sense of discomfort, which why not do something dynamically with your ideas there if you're not going to actually interrogate anything at all. But no, we don't even do that. All of a sudden, we just run into another dancing lady. So here we are, uh, and we've got a lot of talk about diplomacy and bureaucracy that to me felt like we were filling space. I was deeply, deeply bored annoyed by it, like like I just am like at this point, I don't know what you're saying about diplomacy anymore. If you're saying anything of note interesting that once again, to me, we're being really hateful of or we're being down on a way of solving conflict that doesn't look like violence, which seems at odds with our way of the sort of our values here. But all right, they also work with in such a bureaucratic structure like fuck you, you know what's up?

12:25 Which there's something interesting about that because I mean we allude to Starfleet and the Federation being this larger system, but because the show is more interested in talking about this group of individuals as opposed to the system that it fits into at large. Sure, except for like commodores coming in and being like I actually outrank you, Well you're going to do something that you disagree with. I think consistently Starfleet gives an order that they go against because the order is the wrong order. There's a very like kids on Bikes esque to that, where they're just like, our parents aren't going to help us, so we got to help ourselves. And I know, I get caught up on the concept and the idea of the like well, they're supposed to be like proponents of this like beautiful note system and stuff, but they're never they're always individualistic. But you would have a show without it.

13:19 So and this episode isn't interested in interrogating. The lack of value within a bureaucracy is widespread, as widespread as Starfleet or the Federation, because it's just directing. It's it's directly interacting with this one planet. And the weapon of bureaucracy is interesting, but they're diminishing returns. And also I just feel compelled to say, not every episode has to be about something, but right whenever you are bothering to make an episode that really isn't about something, you have to make sure that it's supplanted with something, something interesting, some sort of substance that pops. Yes, in this episode, there is. It is like it's like wet salar.

14:03 What well, cellary's pretty wet. No no, no, no, no, no, like wet salary, Like it's just been like sitting in the refrigerator for so long. Yeah, so thank you, soggy salary. And you're like, there was a promise here and you are telling me that this is salary. No, sir or or legend? I did it's either that's the three genders, sir, mam or legend. I am a little curious. I don't think the episode cares about this, but you know what, I care.

14:44 About this good job asmin Why are we. Trying to get a planet the Federation that doesn't want to be the federation? Central question like what what are you trying to do Federation? Like I understand why the planet would want stuff from the Federation. Yeah, but at the same time the contradiction that this planet also wants to be staunchly isolationist, which I don't. Look, the rules of what the Federation is at this point within Star Trek is extremely malleable. Yeah, sometimes they are an interventionalist force that is coming in and telling you that your way of governing is wrong. Sometimes it is like in Mirror Mirror, where it's just like you don't want to dialect. Hum, nope, consider that, we'll just leave you alone. Right And this episode, for some reason, they're pursuing something with these staunchly isolation as folks that are at the same time we're dealing with overpopulation.

15:42 But whatever handwave in the way, we need an episode to happen because there's fifty minutes in the schedule and gosh darn it, we got to make it fill. It was something so you so, yeah, that makes sense that they that the negotiation would be we want to be part of the federation, but we also want to stick to our own rules for sure, which is its own kind of interesting question around uh what that like that kind of like what we've talked about in the past of cultural relativism or absolutism or you know what is say appropriate, like a different kind of cultural rule within a context, right, like what are we we know?

16:25 And then like the negotiation is saying like who gets to decide? So that in and of itself could be interesting. The real reason they wanted is because they wanted to get him because he had this disease when he was younger, and they want to snag him. And then they want to be like, now that you've fallen in love with my daughter, come down and live there and continue to infect people because we have an overpopulation problem. Cool, fine, okay, you have an overpopulation problem. Okay, why do you have an overpopulation problem? Because we love life. We love life value. That's it. And magically they all live forever because they love life. Their socks dudes, well, and.

17:08 So yeah, like that is like like the implication. Okay. So the other thing is that like when Kirk was like, hey, there are ways to so Okay. The implication, by the way, is just people are pregnant all the time. All the time, all the time, all the time. That's what the real horror of this is, Like people like presumably presumably women that that's a bad presumption people. I don't know, I don't know what the like, what it looks like down there. People are always pregnant. Also, just need to clarify, it's not just women that can get pregnant any like, people are pregnant all the time.

17:49 Everyone on the planet is pregnant at all times. Yeah, every single every single person. That's a real horror of them. Maybe they have like bijor and and it's just like really nice all the time, and it's like the birth is actually a lovely experience and everything's been great. It's just been great. But at the same time, so I because that is the implication within it. And so when Kirk's like, hey, like I because I think what he was asking about wasn't necessarily like a birth control it was maybe like getting your tube sied, or getting vasectomies or like something that would be like an actual surgical procedure. Because then what's his name is, like, no, the body's just like undo it.

18:33 It just like fixes itself. Which is why I'm wondering if the like, well, why would a virus work like would like if they threw themselves off of buildings, would then the body fix itself? Like what what are the rules? They are rules? What are the rules? There are too many world building questions to make this as successful. Yeah, episodes and look. At me, I'm looking. I love a great handwave. Whenever you're just like right, whatever, shut up. The episode just has to happen if. It's valuable and if it's supported by good emotionality. But then the world building questions at the center of the episode are so juicy you could hang an entire episode on it. And also this is an episode that was filmed in nineteen sixty eight, and so they're pushing at the limits of what they can talk about and they're having to fit within the confines of what is acceptable.

19:27 And what is interesting is that in previous versions of this episode, the mystery box was not there, like the themes were out in the open, and then at some point they were just like, we have to have more action or something along those lines, and so the central themes just kind of get scaled back, and then also with budgetary concerns, you scale those things back. And now we're on yet another episode that is locked on the Enterprise and Kirk and some other person the only two people that are bouncing around, and then you've got one set that is the alien planet, and then the chilling image of opening to the porthole. I will say, the very people bouncing around. I recall that image very much within my head whenever watching this episode because it's a chilling image. But it's out there and our characters are in here, and it's all it's really difficult to dramatize these things whenever. I don't know if you know this audience, but Aspen and I teach improv comedy what.

20:34 Wow Wow. Legends, but as teachers of narrative structure and narrative theory theater. Sorry, calling it comedy is an affront to the medium. Like we're not like just trying to be funny, because that's like what fools are. Make no mistake, We do improvisational theater for you to be compelled. The central tension. It's about tension and so leap. What is comedy. It's a commitment. The only comedy that I like is Comedia del Arte, Nasquort, mask Stone, heard of him, heard of him Aspen. I think this maybe our greatest episode of Trustlers yet. I'm going to really enjoy listening back to this one. But anyways, I'm talking about you cut, you cut the window, you cut to Kirk and o'donna where you best believe that the writers of this episode were listening to the radio and they're like, got it great, We've got four more hours to write the script. That's not true. There is is worked very very hard, and everyone worked very very hard in this episode. TV is abysmally hard and a lot of people suffer, So we can just inhale it.

21:53 We're not talking about that, talking about they're they're looking outside and the window of people because there are so many people on the planet that they are just everywhere. Its creepiest shit. But unfortunately, oh, Kirk and o'donna are watching it happen outside. Yeah, And there's a different kind of dramatic tension whenever you're watching it happen to someone else versus our main characters, and our main character suddenly has to experience the horrors of overpopulation. But as consistently something that is told, kind of shown, but never dramatically experienced, and it fails on I mean, this episode fails on so many levels. I mean, can you imagine if this next question, yes, okay, how are you good?

22:40 How are you great's actually doing really well. I got a lot I caught up on a lot of sleep over the weekend, and it makes it fantastic. I feel very good, fantastic. Okay, back's my first question. Well, no, here's my thought. If they had the budget, if they had had the space. If they had fourteen dollars as supposed to twelve episodes and a tunis out sandwich, and yeah, a couple of cents. What do you mean there's not You mean that this entire crew and cast have to eat this one tunis olid sandwich, have to share it? Cut into the rules. You gotta ask, mister paramount of me. Is The paramoun was like, oh, well, you would have gotten your wife to make yours and the mouse run up the clock and that's you're the mouse.

23:32 So I like my cigar. I love your cigar work. You can only see that cigar work YouTube dot com, slash at trak warspond. So like a good neighbor, like a good horror film or good horror like you can if the idea is what is just right outside of space, Like you can see this being like okay, what do you do with the medium that is given to you or the restraints that are given to you. Okay, we're in here, and it's terrifying, Like we don't know what's happening. We're actually a little scared. We're trying to be like she's more scared.

24:13 All of a sudden, Yeah, we open it up and then there's faces and there's this, and there's a swarm. It's terrifying, and it disappears right and then it, like the monster of any good horror film, grows and gets until it's you and then it is upon you. And now we're in a space where like I can even imagine the scene of like Kirk being like no, no, no, just like surrounded by humans, just like packing him into like a space and like maybe like the room would be completely black and dark, and then it'd just be like faces flashing in front of him as like the light hits it horrifying, horrifying, and then he's like pulled from the space and it's just like that's the reality of our. World, right, and then suddenly you have an interesting question of being like, sure, this planet did something that is abhorrent to Captain Kirk, but at the same time, your character is just experienced and now they have an interesting moral quandary or they're like, too, right, sure a crime has been committed against me, but also the experience that I've felt is so abhorrent.

25:11 Yes, and everyone's pregnant. It's awful. Every single person. Every single person is pregnant. It's so dense. Every single person on the planet has so much pregnancy. Then I feel like it starts to feel like it has more weight as opposed to like him being like, here's a solution, then being like oh no, no, no, no no, we really love life. And then you're like, what are you talking about? Dramatize that? Yeah, what are you talking about? Is it that? Like it? Like because love it? Like I mean, it's hard not to have my own personal like current view like looking at that, like if that were to happen now, I'd be at touch, Like I'm sorry, are you being like are you being like inside abortion rates on this like or even says like the value the life of a feet and I'm like, Hey, a condom has no effect on a fetus, Like my dude, like I utes have no effect usually on a fetus, like these are not a border patients. Also, abortion is great, but you know, if we're getting abortions, great, but if we're getting into the details here, we are getting into because the questions yeah, well yeah, as briefly stupid questions. It's asking pretty okay.

26:25 Question stupid questions, great questions, but then the episode is just. Like being stupid about it. Yeah, we could be with Kirk and Odonna in an empty corridor watching them and traumatizing. Again. This is this is where that Kirkcter stuff I'm like, no, I I do like. Season three is where everybody gets the idea of Kirk. Being like, ooh, yeah, I think you're right. Which is interesting because as we've covered in These are the Voyages season three by Mark Cushn and Susan Osborne, and this was the season where there was a more concerted effort to do quote unquote with quote unquote with me AskMen women's story stories, which is so interesting that whenever you assigned the label of women's stories, suddenly the stories get more boring as opposed to what the women loved, which is stories that were themselves.

27:18 Yeah, stories that are like about characters engaging with one another and having feelings and exploring emotional things or like in the case of like a Spock, you know, managed like dealing with those deep seated emotions and with that like his implications p M. That's why the DC Fontana episodes are so interesting, Like people who just genuinely understand them as characters and know what drives good story. Like, Yeah, I'm I'm all for people kissing. Believe me. That's not a fem like women like kind of story. That's an everybody's story. People loves kissing, but he just loves kissing. You might have read about a Los Angeles theater getting burned down after showing Twisters. That was the screening that ashmen went to. When you threw a Molotov cocktail at the screen. Whenever Glenn Pollin Daisy Edgar Jones is that her name? Yeah, whenever they didn't.

28:08 Kiss Kenny Madison. The fact that those two did not kiss is an actual travesty. This isn't a Twisters podcast, Aspen. I'm enraged, Aspen. Please don't burn down this house. Cowards, please, don't burn the cowards. Steven Spielberg is a coward. You heard me Anyway, I like the one people kiss. I don't like boring bullshit. Let's talk about something that's not boring. An example of good dramatization and compelling dramatization and throwing a wrench into the conceptions of things that we had previously understood as just kind of existing in one certain paradigm, which is the hidden enemy, as we talked in earlier episodes, specifically cloak of darkness, whenever we had a senate commando go rogue within the felony, zoning within that felony went it's too early for clones to turn, and this is a story that they are entertaining. And now to invoke uh, definitely a Star Trek term. Checkof's gun.

29:12 Yeah, Star Trek really totally Pabo Checkoff's gun. You're right, check off. But now we finally we got the problems has been filled, and now we've got a Clone that is functioning in an individualists terms. Suddenly our concepts of the Clones as perfectly established in the two thousand and two I'm going to say it, asterpiece Attack of. The Clones, a masterpiece I mean not as. Bad Anakin's over there saying I don't like Sand. Well, I do like sand. That's how good Attack of the Clones, which is.

29:56 We're doing great. It's this episode is great. It's so dense. Every single image has so much going on, and. No one's pregnant yet yet. It will be in three years and it will be padme. No one else be pregnant. I there. It is very interesting, very compelling. They don't quite Okay, well, first we'll start with the you know how we talk about Detective Batman. Something very fun about detective. Detective Detective Batman. Yeah, the world's greatest, the world's gatest detective.

30:40 Hold on, yeah, hold on, let me access the Mattrius Batman moving whenever he can't figure out is the he is the world's greatest detective. But clearly the clue that the Redder left in a city that famously has a Batman stool pigeons. Yeah, definitely something that is within the lexicon of the film, a movie that I gave four stars on a letterbox because it's got good vibes. We're talking about the patents in one right, yeah. Yeah. And at the same time, there's forty minutes of real Estate. It seems like dedicated to my stool pigeon Wild still better than Batman v. Supermanton of Justice, a movie that Arizona Mark love.

31:28 But also, you're right, Batman, the vibes are so good, so. Anyway it works. Sorry book Detective Batman. And also Detective Obi Wan, another famous detective. It's really nice to watch the dynamic duo of Detective Rex and Detective Cody, our favorite clone commanders. Cody commander yet are still a captain? Are Rex still a captain? But they they're basically what's fun about Rex and Cody is that they like basically each They're like attached to obi Wan and Anakin, like Rex as Anakin, Cody is obi Wan, which is fun. We like that. It's nice to see them together having to be like we can't let them know, you know, we need to solve those oursoves, we need to figure it out, you know, and going through that and the sort of questioning and the tension that's building of like who it could be and like the Chases, very noir, very cool, very like thriller.

32:24 So yeah, no, should I should I know who Cody and Rex are? Let me think about that by this point you would know Cody. I mean I know Cody because in the three yeah come on, Cody, take my life, sayber and he's like, you got a boss. Yeah, live. And then it is Cody that receives like you see him explicitly receive Order sixty six, which is devastating once you've watched a lot of Clone Wars, that. Is, and I know Rex having been someone that has watched all of Rebels and Right, because you know what he's got that Cody doesn't have. Friends A great big bushy beard, a great big bushy beard and big muscles.

33:12 Yes, yes, Jim Broadband, great big bushy beard, jugglers, crusty jugglers. Yeah. So of course yeah. Rex comes back into playing Rebels spoiler, very close with Ah Soca at this point. I think this probably is your biggest This is like the biggest Cody Rex episode. This would be the one for you to be like, these are characters I give a shit about. Rex is in the movie. He shows up, he has interactions with a Soca. They like they become as you know, because of Rebels, very close. Cody is there. But I think this is the first like their episode, which is very cool to reflect on that. I enjoy that.

34:01 Very cool. It is. Listen, here's my analysis, my critical analysis. This is very cool. Listen. I'm just having a great time. I was not having a great time otherwise. I was said about the success of Vibes, the oh, the what vibes, the success of oh, the. Success of vibes. I think, I said the successive, and I was like, a successive, like a. Succession, about the succession Vibes, succession Vibes. I was like, well, wow, my father, my father Django Fett. Yeah, yeah, there's uh, there's a fun and there's like a fun sort of like they're the same, but there's a touch of an A plot B plot happening that's really compelling, Like it starts with a battle that's really interesting in which they are clearly like they know all of what they're like, all of the steps are taking, and it's it's good, I think to watch them fail, really good.

35:04 I think for for storytelling, and it makes for good storytelling and there's a reason for it. And that leads to something compelling, which is, what does it mean when we do have a trader in our ranks? Like what could be the motivation for that? A trader in our ranks. That's I didn't realize you added that while you were talking around. Oh my god. Yeah. But to start with that, to start with a failure good because we wouldn't too much, you know. And this is these are war their battles and ventures can't lose every time because I need her to keep her job, because she's too hot to lose it.

35:48 As recent poet Laureate Chapel Round would staff one, yes for sure. Asage is h O T T O g o. Oh, you can take her on to go venturous. Yeah, when we get to I starship and I'm just gonna think of a random person. To ship Massage in that tree that she passed. Right, like she can be with anyone. It's just hot, and I swear to God venturess in her own arms. Yeah, goddamn, I love that. She's like time to fight with a body, I am, I right.

36:33 I mean it's a pretty good episode. Yeah, I mean it's a fun episode. It's fun A spoiler alert. Is definitely better than Mark of Gideon. Clone Wars is definitely getting into its own rhythm. I'm very much enjoying it. It's very fun to watch. I look forward to it every week. What is also interesting about this is the fact that the A plot is the Clones, and the B plot are Anakin and Obi Wan, which is great. It's great. And also I don't know, maybe I'm just giving the show too much credit, but it's changing what Star Wars is. Give it credit, well, well, this is whenever Dave Filoni used to try, and that's pretty good.

37:17 Okay, calm down, calm down, get out of here, oh my god. But giving well, and also this was a George. Story, George story. George was like, what if what if what a clone was was a Benedict Arnold? What if? What if that were true? George, how would you play that? Uh me, oh would you? I mean, I meant, how would you play that out? But I put a little helmet on? Yeah, a little well, little tiny.

37:58 Arm George is Star Wars just helmets. The So so George actually pitched, you know, as, what if the clones were there's a clone that was a Benedict Arnold. And so initially we went to Ralph McCrory's designs. I made a planet that was a big Benedict Arnold. So that wasn't exactly quiet, right, And then it cuts to chilling and plunket and He's like, what was interesting about this? Go on? No, what was interesting? Irish? Irish? What was interesting about this strange is that we'd never done texturing of a Benedict Arnold type planet, and so we actually had to pull from previous assets in order to kind of make the new texture fluid but at the same time having some sort of lived in quality.

38:56 And then and then George said, what did the planet's one bit bended at Arnold? You just make it like a planet? And I went, that would have saved us so much time. George, what if you just had a one man show and it's just called the Filonisi And then Matthew Wood's like, Hi is me, Matthew? Would I do a lot of voices? George pitch to us it would be fun to have kind of different kind of voices for the clones, and so we pitched. So we made a whole planet that was voices, but they.

39:37 Were all still deep. Bradley Bigger, that's true. And again I want to reiterate, I'm liking Dave Filoni's work here, and I like the way I like the way that Star Wars is changing. I like that. This is finding its own identity, even though it's frustrating from the pre existing knowledge that I have. But whenever I bother to take it on its own terms, Yes, is doing some interesting things. That's right, Kenny. Do you know what that means? I'm a winner. The pause sounds so when we started this podcast, I said, you know what's better? Star Wars? I'm telling you.

40:20 You know what I said, and I said, the Star Trek's better. I said, you're wrong. We should try to prove it solute and we're right in a space where I'm right. Is what is also interesting about that I don't for some reason, the Battle of Christopsis is just locked in my mind, and this show is not afraid to play loose with chronology. This is an episode that is definitely taking place before the movie. Soka's not even on the table doesn't matter because structurally, for the journey that we're taking all of these characters on, this makes more sense to put it towards the last third of the season as opposed to at the beginning. It sets a completely different timber. If you have a clone to betray you at the beginning versus towards the end. We're going on an evolution from We're having a whole bunch of space adventures and win the audience over with the fact that we can do a Star Wars animated TV show. And now I'll start taking it. Let's tilt it by two degrees and then three degrees and the five degrees and suddenly we're going to get into some new territory.

41:31 And can you tell me more about why you think it is special that the Clone story is the a. Story you ask a Star Wars fan in two thousand and nine what Star Wars is about, and it's going to be like the tragedy of Darth Vader, because that's the dead marketing point, right. It's about the Skywalkers. You got episodes, you got episodes one through six. No one ever talks about droids, walks whatever. No, And for all of Lucas's flaws as a dramatic storyteller, he is not light on ideas that are challenging your notions of what Star Wars can be. Yeah, I mean, and this is this is an idea that comes This is an idea that came from George.

42:27 You so much felony, where's your hat? A wampa ate it? Oh? My god, I'm so sorry to just skin that wampa for taking it. Yes, next question, how are you and Dave Filoni is the good kind of yes man where it takes George's idea and is able to fashion that into something that is dramatically successful. Yeah, absolutely, because it is. It isn't It is a good idea. And this were only like Dave Filoni existing within a vacuum, maybe it would be just a little bit too reverential. I don't well.

43:07 I'm also thinking about Gendhy Tartakovski and how those three seasons of Clone Wars that he made fit into your preconception of what the Jedi were before we got the prequels. They're superpower badasses and you're textually see episode is now putting more dramatic import on the Clones versus ostensibly Who are your two stars of the prequel trilogy? And that means something and yeattle. I wish man. That's rule one is Maskie and the other ones a smooth Shorty.

43:54 Maskie and Shorty Shorty. I I I think that. Oh sorry, that's so distracted thinking about smooth Shorty. I'm sent astray by setting up jokes there is I'm trying to think of like the like his compelling reason for the betrayal, and I'm trying to think back on it because there's still a lot of countering. Like He's like, I mean, basically at its core, the way I took it was like, we're just being thrown out there to be killed, and whose war is this?

44:34 Which has been galvanized brilliantly. We got another banger ending where the Jedi kind of walk off to more adventure on the clones are just kind of left there and it's a little bit of a bitter sweet, not even bitter sweet, a bitter ending because these clones are blindly following orders. Yeah, and Slick has a point, Yeah, I. Mean this is they are a They are not droids. They are human beings, and they are you can't deny that. There's a touch of almost like there have to be like some brainwashing in there. Right, You're raised with one purpose and that is it. So what does it look like when you do a different, like when you seek something else?

45:19 It depends. We don't exactly know what the systems are as of yet. We just know that the clones are grown in big blue jars. They have some lunch they learn in front of some screens and then at some point they're given a gun to fight. Yeah, and you see that, like we I think we've already seen with Rooky. Nope, Rookies doesn't have it. There's an episode later where you actually see like training actually that same group, but it's like pre rookies. You see them training and what that looks like. And yeah, but absolutely, But I mean there has to be something kind of inherent to it, right, I mean, whether I'm not saying it's brave New world asque while in vitro brainwashing, it's more like you are raised with a purpose and that is your whole purpose in this world. So of course it's going to be interesting when someone's like I both love my brothers and I'm also very contrary to this, and I am like, I, you know, I can't really look down on it. They push back really hard. They're like, you're hurting us, You're hurting your brothers by doing this, and it's like, but he's seeking justice on a grander scale, you know, And I, yeah, I can't. I can't hate it, you know. I think it's a great pushback. And also two things can be true. This can be unjust and also I love you. I love you so much.

46:46 This season at first laying the groundwork for like good Space Adventures, and then we're peppering in, but like who's the real Bad Days? Who are the real Bad Days? Two episodes that, in their own way interrogating some sort of system or bureaucracy. Sure, calm down, I mean say both of them were doing it well. I didn't even I was just like how. At first, I was like, what are you talking about? And then I was like, oh, the other apps, you know, I check episode that we both railed against or were being dramatically functional list. I don't even know how I was questioning bureaucracy. It's just like, because it's clear enough, did I fall asleep?

47:29 Maybe maybe possibly one of those things where you watched the episode and then at the same time your brain was like, I don't I can just check out for thirty minutes, right, Maybe I. Mean the bureaucracy of having to go through the diplomacy and have negotiations, I guess. But so I guess in that way, there is a sort of respect for the agency of a group of people and the I mean, ostensibly it sounds like the Enterprise crews coming in just being like why the to be this way, like just fucking sign the thing and get over yourselves, like stop having your own like beliefs, like ugh, diplomacy just prolongs a crisis blah blah blah blah blah, nor which is absurd by the way to be like why are these people being so like difficult.

48:17 About this, which Star Trek can be if it just like wakes up on the wrong side of the bed and suddenly it's just like, ah, they're stupid. But then the next week depends on how White presenting that they are. Quite frankly Star Wars with Star Trek Star Trek, Yeah. I'm thinking about like the Apple where they seem to have a benevolent god and Kirk's like, nope, y'all have darker skin yep. And so I guess in that way, if we're looking at systems that there's a real similarity and the Jedi Order and the Senate just being like, yeah, what is your agency? You don't really have any You have the purpose and that's all you live for and that's all you die for. Were like who are you to this?

49:03 And just get over it, like get over the bureaucracy. Like the bureaucracy or like there is, we. Must preserve the system. We must preserve the status quo. And the preserving of the status quo means your body is forfeit basically. Which is my least favorite John Mayer song Your. Body is Perfect. You're pregnant all the time, pregnant on the time? Boy? Do we have anything else to say about these episodes before we move on to the next segment?

49:44 I will tell you is that. I mean, we talked about thematic connections, right, that's our thematic connection. We pulled anything else, though not particularly. I imagine that we'll have more to say during the ranking segment, but until then, A. Long time ago, I date this week, I quoted a boat, I dated a geek, but none of them could warp my drive into high birth space. The best of both worlds kept me in the second place. Captain slog on a hollow chron I wanted a snog. I penned a song seventeen more minutes addies in Super high Depth aboard the USS Enterprise DT, don't you take.

50:42 My walk lighter and clip boobs? Don't you take my wretchered buddy? And if it. If you spill the tea, I'm gonna sip boobs my starship it. We shall now name favorite ships that sail through the sky and our favorite ships that sail through our hearts. Year you are are from either from either episode? I don't know, then can I go first? U? Yes, I will permit it, but tread Lightley counselor you're on thin ice. It's funny, ipe, that's our joke forever. Thank you, jesse errel.

51:28 Uh U. I don't know what ship this is, and I should have gone back and checked, but I presumably it is the ship that Assage ventresses on that looks like a giant virus. Do you know the one I'm talking about? What am I crazy? I saw it in passing. There's so many ships in this episode that it's like a veritable feast, but I was like, holy moly. Also once again proving that even though this is my segment, I never prepare sure so I can look it up if you think, well, you think of yours, but I just remember it being like that ship is so cool?

52:10 Is it the fan Blade ship? No, because that's her regular ship, which I've already loved as being one of my favorites. Maybe it wasn't her ship. I thought it was a ship that she came down on. It looks like a giant it looks it looks like a it looks like a virus like it kind of comes down and has like a sort of end here and then like the legs come out. That's like reddish m hm. Anyway, it's rare. While you examined that and see if there's a more specific name. Although I've written a sage ventriss Viroship, I'm kinda put an oldie but a goodie. Yes, the stap what's that? So you see this?

52:51 Famously, this was the very first toy that was released for Star Wars Episode one, which was a battle droid on his flying little bike really just kind of like a flying but it was before Segus exist. Oh yes, yes, there's a scene in the episode where they like jump off and they jump on the one like they like just throw the droids off and it's very funny. Yeah, that's called the step. And also, I mean I really enjoy that design, possibly just for a nostalgia's sake, because I remember that. And then the Mace window action figure. Those two were the first two toys that you could get for episode one and play with those, and they were they were so endlessly fascinating from my then, uh what that was nineteen ninety eight whenever those toys started coming out ten years old, right, nine, ten years old, and they're interested in that. So the step is mine Ship of the week.

53:43 Love it. That's a great one. When I find any of this thing, I'll tell you, But just believe me. It was really cool. That's when I believe you. I didn't just make it up, right, Like, it's just like in my brain, Like the. More that you say that you didn't make it up, probably it was starting to sound like you made this up? Did I dream this? Did you dream this ship? And just go I'm like so obsessed with viruses. I think that you had four warm milkshakes because you were so excited at the fact that you were having milkshakes, and then you went to a classic warm milkshake dream where you were just dreaming about the bacterias floating around in the warm milkshakes. And because you fell asleep watching Ahsoka for the fifth time.

54:32 Oh yeah. The only thing that would have improved that is if Aska had a helmet. Yeah, and it would have been because Star Wars is helmets. It's fine, I've given up. We'll pretend it's real anyway. Emotional ships, emotional emotional relationships. I'm going to deliver on my promise. Here we go, and I'm going to pair Massage Ventriss with someone. Here we go. I've already put her with Anakin. I've already put her with Obi Wan. So I can't redo those. I can't. She's gonna put her with any random battle what oyah?

55:15 I put her with someone? Someone put her with a battle droid. Oh oh, I put her with uh the leader that he's the head of the he's part of the separatists. He's like one of like the lead separatists. He's like that lead droid guy. You know what I'm talking. About, Wow, droid guy. Man, I've got a lot. I'm saying a lot of things that don't have any details. Not one of the Pneumoidians. No no, no, no, no, no no no no no. Let me see what's his name? I got you. There's tactic is it the tactical droid? Is it? Maybe it's just a tactical droid. Okay, I'm putting I'm putting I'm putting her with tactical. Droid, massage ventress and the tactical droid. What do you want from me?

56:04 I want everything from you? Can I just can I just just expand just slightly. Yeah, I guess disappointing. No it's not. And I want to hear more asloge of interests, just to talk about this has chemistry with everybody, hm, every droid, every Doku, every DOCU, every obi Wan Ahsoka. But right now Ahsoka is too young, so we got to keep her oud of it. She has she has chemistry with everybody. So what I'm just demonstrating here, which is the fact that you could put her with a tactical droid and it would still be hot as ship.

56:49 She'd find she'd make it work. Sheould make it work and it would be a little messy anyway. Kirk and Adonna. Why because they were like Kirk was like, you have hair, pretty sexy. He does grab the back of her head in a very attractive one. It's true, it's very gentle and sweet. But what is not gentle and sweet is the central conceit of this podcast. Of course, art is a binary. It's either good or it's bad, and so do do we become the arbiters of justice as we assign a numerical ranking to both of these properties. Again, the market getting from Star Trek the Original Series season three versus Hitten Enemy from Star Wars the Clone Wars Season one Aspen.

57:31 Why don't you go first with Hidden Enemy? Hidden Enemy? Man, I think we're just like still in the same space of just like it's a banger. It's like a seven point six banger. Seven point six banger. Yeah, I mean it's solid, it's interesting, it's got the animation is getting better and better off, fabulous, interesting storylines. Love to see characters get more highlight, more to do, interesting stories coming forth, beautiful, a glorious time, ventest my girlfriend, great time. I think I'm going to give this one like a six point. Six Okay, weird.

58:12 It was good, and I still find myself it's just like, wish there was just a little bit more judge to it, that undefinable thing that, of course being objective critics of art, Yeah, I can't get chem assigned to it. That objective is what I'm looking for. Needs a little bit more, you think, so, Yeah, I think maybe you need a little bit more. Well, you know what else needs a little bit more judge the market Gideon. And I'm just going to hop in with my ranking here. I'm just going to give it a four. Yeah, I'm gonna give it a three point nine, just because I'm feeling bitter. Yeah, you sound like you're in a bad mood.

58:53 I made a pretty good mood today. I gotta say, it sounds like you're feeling mean. But the discussion of the mark of Gideon, it's just it's disappointing. Sure, it is much much like a passive aggressive father. I'm not mad. I'm just disappointed, just disappointed. I mean, I'm a little better. I'm a little mad about the mischaracterization of birth control and the fact that everyone is forced to be pregnant all the time just to live. Just to be clear, the implications of their stupid world. It just presumes that people are popping out babies. Do they have resources for people? Do they have resources for those children? People are presumably living in absolutely horrific existence. What do you mean you love life? I know that's what it's leading them to this, Like, well, now we need to kill people off kind of thing.

59:38 I get it, but like, fuck you, you don't fucking love life. You love the idea of life. You're just like any shitty person who doesn't support abortion. But it is wondering about my opinions. You don't actually love life, so get out of here. So it actually does make me grumpy from a fill's offical point of view. Anyway, what's my drinking? I know that women's rights are important, but like, what about the Star Trek episode? Oh? Sorry, well, you know what I'm gonna do. Spite rank it? Hell yeah, oh ooh you do love to see it?

1:00:19 Ooh makes me feel good. You'll have to see it. I guess I should spite rink a Star Wars one eventually to balance it out. But I don't. I don't, I don't. I want to smart. Okay, Star Wars, while definitely being guilty of orientalism and just exoticism of cultures that are just not white. Uh, you know, the original series is a lot more brown face, which means that Star Wars wins the week. Great color me surprised. Hidden enemy is seven point one versus the mark of Gideon's paltry two point two. You do love to see it?

1:01:01 Ask you fuck you, which is certainly not a sentiment that we would wish to pass along to our patrons. At Patreon dot com slash track wars Pod, where for five dollars a month you can get early versions of these episodes and extended versions of these episodes, and just for a mere dollar a month, we'll just say your name. We've got fifty slots available for you. We'd love to say your name, and every single bit helps, and you too could join the fine Auspice as a fine folks such as Timbo de Sosa, Heidi Rogers, Kevin Miller, Arizona, Mark Austin Aaron and lastly, but certainly not leastly joelt Partner, who was the composer of our I starship at Team Song. Our main and ending theme was composed by mister Tosin Alrofesso, where you can get more of his works within the show notes. Just click on that link and go visit these things. If you don't want to get in touch with us via social media or Patreon, you can email us check Warspod at gmail dot com, and if you do want to interact with us at social media, hop over to Blue Sky our Instagram at trak wars Pod.

1:02:01 And lastly, but certainly not leastly. You can also visit us at YouTube dot com, slash at track Wars pod and watch Aspen wildly gesticulate in versions such as this. Aspen gotta say that's some good gesticulating you welcome. Any Any final. Thoughts before we call it a night, Uh nope. I love you and Aspen I love you too. An audience, we love you sincerely. Thank you so very much for listening. Leave us a review while you're at it. May the Force be with you and live long and prospering