Nov. 19, 2023

What Does it Mean to Be Culturally Humble?

What Does it Mean to Be Culturally Humble?
What Does it Mean to Be Culturally Humble?
Trek Wars Podcast
What Does it Mean to Be Culturally Humble?

Friday's Child (Star Trek: TOS) vs. Hard Sell/A Warrior and a Lurdo (Star Wars: Ewoks)

Three mid episodes. Aspen talks about cultural relativism versus cultural absolutism. Kenny talks about a writerly POV becoming diminished. And we both struggle to...

Friday's Child (Star Trek: TOS) vs. Hard Sell/A Warrior and a Lurdo (Star Wars: Ewoks)

Three mid episodes. Aspen talks about cultural relativism versus cultural absolutism. Kenny talks about a writerly POV becoming diminished. And we both struggle to talk about this week's episode of Ewoks.

__________________________

Get early, extended episodes on our Patreon at https://www.patreon.com/trekwarspod

Theme by Tosin Awofeso

Social Media:
https://www.instagram.com/trekwarspod
https://bsky.app/profile/trekwarspod.bsky.social

Want to ask us questions? Email us at trekwarspod@gmail.com .

And leave us a review! https://bit.ly/leave-a-review-trek-wars

0:27 Welcome to the Trek Wars Podcast, the online Internet's favorite source for trying to answer the most important question fandom, Which is better Star Trek or Star Wars. I am one of your co hosts, Kenny Madison, the Star Trek contingents of this podcast. With me as always is no Moopsie, you get down. I'm I'm keeping him as a pet just in case, just to turn him on my enemies. But no, instead it's me ask been a webster who loves Smoopsie and Star Wars. Speaking of loving Star Wars and me loving Star Trek, we may or may not love these episodes today Friday's Child versus hard Sell versus a Warrior and Alerto Kenny, two things, Two things to start. One, did so did you like figure out like a little soundboard thing? Is that what's going on? I don't know what you're talking about, heps, because this is also the first time like typically I just add like the music and after the fact and you just played it and it just like oh and then we rocked out, and I just feel like this is one of those moments where we were like, wait, this could be easier. Yeah. Well, to be fair, zen cast made me upgrade.

1:49 Oh, because I guess the two that we were on no longer exists, and by upgrading I get a nice little soundboard, so pop. Oh my god, I love that. This makes a lot of sense. Two. Oh, was I gonna say? No? Two? We need We will typically like talk to each other or text about something or like have a reaction and at each other. We have not talked about any of these episodes at all. We have not talked about first oppressions. I have not. I did not text you anything around not liking it or liking it. But you're already nailing it, just throwing it out there. I'm so glad that I can help you nail this. As we dive into three, we could ostensibly be described as episodes. I would say you could buy their strict definition of them. Actually, no, we'll talk about it. I don't.

2:46 I didn't. I didn't hate them. I didn't hate them. That is correct. There are a lot of good. There's a lot of good and all three. Yeah, there are worse episodes. Yeah, there's just like things that annoyed me. Yeah, a lot. Look, well, we'll get into it as the researcher. I've done my research. Oh good, because I had a lot of questions. I'm excited. I could have myself researched them, and instead I just decided to rely on you. I like to be reliant on sometimes. Yeah, no, thank you for being there for me. You are the researcher. I am the angry one. Well, speaking of anger, I'm going to force you to give us the synopsis for our two e Woks episodes this week. All right, all right, we weren't prepared for this because we were talking about Jamie Bell. Well I was. I have the synopsis pulled up right now. Okay, Well, this is why you're the researcher and I'm the angry one. So so the first episode, this one, of course, is a double hard sell A Warrior and Alerto. God, just two episodes of competition and commerce and a lack of resources, and I'm so tired of it all. I'm just so let's see, we'll see. Really is October twenty fifth, nineteen eighty six, very spooky and always and see let's see. For the first one we have both directed by Dale shot the A Warrior and Alerto written by Michael Dubo

4:25 and Michael Reeves wrote hard Sell. Yes, and I said oh Batman, how fuck me? Every time? I'm like, am I supposed to know? What? These just white men? Not particularly Michael Reeves has written some other episodes of Ewoks right at least one other episode of Ewoks, and also wrote an episode of Droids and then went on to go write some other things. Surprisingly enough, I found that he wrote probably my favorite episode of or at least co wrote my favorite episode, my favorite episode of the Star Trek fan film series Star Trek New Voyages called World Enough and Time, which stars George to Ka. It's it's really good. And then Michael Dubil apparently just worked on two episodes of Ewoks and there's nothing else about him, which is so fascinating. Speaking of George de Kay during this Star Trek episode, there's a lot of really good uh Sulu moments, and out loud, I was just like, it is like, I am so grateful to be in a world of George de Kay. I think he is just a good you know, just just a good one. I mean he's it's like your grandpa and sometimes you posts weird shit, but like that's nice. It is just nice.

5:50 So heart cell. Brief plot synopsis Wicked t Boat Lettara and Nissa compete to trade for eat on tusks. That is basically what the episode is. I don't even know if I want to add any more context to it. It is just a competition between them always and the girls as they try to engage in trade. It's some shenanigans. There are some shenanigans. There's a lot of which seems to be the theme of all tonight, which is a lot of unconsensual and touch. We'll get to it. Aspen jumped the gun, I mean it's in this one too. It's Ben, it's in this one too. Don't jump into the contary yet. I'm just I'm just describing an action. A warrior and Alerto t boat fails wickets warrior training, but he is asked by the tiny Temples to chase away a blog water creature.

6:50 Also pretty much exactly what happens in the episode. But I want to point out that this water creature is called a blog and there's a tiny baby tamble that's actually pretty cute. Speaking of blogs, blogs help put newspapers out of business, which is where I have gotten my synopsis for Friday's Child from Star Trek. The original series let's see. Last week's episode was written by DC Fontana and directed by Joseph Pevane. This week's episode Sure also written by DC Fontana and directed by Joseph Pavane. Interesting, man, I gotta keep I gotta stop ruining your jokes. I thought you were genuinely just like confused.

7:32 They're like, oh, who wrote this? Like as if you didn't know? Sorry? From Steven ah shure Uh from the News Journal out of Mansfield, Ohio on December first, nineteen sixty seven, Sure wrote Friday's Child a good adventure tale. Tonight, trying to obtain mining rights from a planet inhabited by primitive tribes, our heroes find themselves in direct competition with the Klingons, an unscrupulous rival of the Earth Federation to which the Enterprise belongs. The fighting here is with boomerangs and bows and arrows, but the day is saved by doctor McCoy's gill in psychiatry and astatrics. Also editor's note on my end, there is also a woman named Ellien who is basically the fourth lead of the episode. Ellien Eleon didn't hate her. I don't know man, all right.

8:31 First impressions, First impressions. Uh. One of the Ewoks episodes, the uh the Bartering the Hard Cell episode had one of the funniest moments of any Ewoks episode I have seen, and perhaps any Droids episode. I'm going to describe this, but it's going to be like describing an improv scene after the fact. It will not fine, So everyone prepare accordingly. Uh So Latara is Latara and Yousa are trying to uh trade these weares so that they can win this competition. And Latara does that thing where she's like, no, let me show you how to to sell this. And this like a little like whisker whisking machine or something, and so she picks it up and she starts doing this dramatic sort of like lady walk and she's just like, hello, would you like to take like buyer or trade this little machine?

9:39 Girls love a man who can like use this, and she's doing it to this like lizard tree creature and she's it's so it's like so over the top, and then it just takes it and it just eats it. And it was so funny, so funny that I cackle aft and didn't stop for a while, and I would say that was the best part of the evening. Otherwise I was bored, all right, So I can tell listeners to fast forward to this point that one moment. And maybe maybe it's because I watched the EU Watch episodes after I watched Friday's Child, but I was just That's usually how I consume my I do it the other way around, typically sense yep I start with Star Wars I and I think despite Friday's Child actually being structurally a good, good episode, which it was a episode, absolutely a grood episode with some really fascinating uh dynamics in it, I think I was just fucking pissed off. I think the word of the day you hit it in the beginning of this episode shenanigans. That's the word day. It's the all three of these and not to just completely jump to common themes, which I believe there are others, but these three episodes are episodes where things happened,

11:15 not really much more deeper going on unless you just look to the politics of the time. My true opinion is that I actually do think Friday's Child is trying to do something interesting I actually do, but does not achieve those heights. There's obviously I'm the Star Trek contingent. This episode never really stands out for me, and watching this episode again for this podcast just makes me remember why because this is a mid level episode that is the equivalent of room temperature water. I like water quench? Is my thirst really thirsty? Right now you get some good McCoy speaking of thirsty. Oh, there's a lot of funny interesting moments in the in the episode too, like different all of it's like component, like weirdly like the different parts of it. I think perhaps it's like more than the sum of its parts kind of thing. But I just think it it what what is the point of it? I think is that's actually something Joel said? It ended? Who is h He's my partner. He's a sweetweet bowie. He just he just ended and it just went what did we accomplish? And I was like, I don't have to

12:48 accomplish anything, but it did feel really bad. I mean I guess, if anything, I guess we accomplished some type of I mean, I think we did accomplish something. Ah, there's at least okay, can I just can I just get into my feelings's let's let's get into our deep analysis. Okay, here's the thing. Here we go. I'm gonna start from this point of view that makes sense. So I'm gonna tell you, like sort of the background of what I'm coming into this with. Uh probaby that you're wearing the hoodie that I'm wearing. It is so comfy. It's so comfy.

13:31 My job gave it to me, which is going to be a bummer whenever I quit, and it still has my job on it. And I'm like, but I liked this hoodie because anyway I was going to talk about jobs, I have to focus Weirdly, it's not annoying yet because it's so cuir, it'll suck the bones out of you, just like just like a lack of bodily autonomy and also commercial culture those will also suck the bones right out of you. The baseline here is that it is a warlike tribe that they are trying to negotiate these mining rights with. There is a leader.

14:16 He has a wife that he literally points out as being a young wife to bear him a son. This leader is killed by like another person in this tribe. And I'm gonna call them tribes because I think that's what the episode's going for of and at least everyone's white, so it doesn't get weird. The tribes were a synthesis of Arabic influences, English influences, and Native American influences. Oh my god, I don't fucking like it that like, yeah, god, okay, sorry, So that actually gives even more depth to this, which is, oh my god, so he's killed. But this wife who's pregnant and about to give birth is like, they've got this whole culture where it's like you cannot touch these women. You can't touch them, and that's because they are clearly own owned their property. It's not because of their own internal sense of agency. McCoy is like, I have to help you have this baby, and I have to be able to lay hands on you to be able to help you. It is weird and it is complicated, and it is a true violation of her bodily autonomy. And I'm not about I do not care to dip into cultural relativism here. I'm not saying

15:50 that this is any better than anything. I'm coming from a perspective of like, let's okay, I know, okay, let me just okay. Let me come at it from my perspective of being a social worker, I might come into a space l U l ms I was an LMSW. You never got to be an LCSW because I quit, But I am in fact an ms W and have a degree in social work. Uh, there's a lot, there's a lot of talk about what does it mean to be culturally humble? So to come into a space and I recognize that in this this circumstance, we are having to think fast. We could be dead, we could be dead, we could be killed. But like a good doctor, a good medical professional is not just going to be like this is for your own fucking good just let me do this and literally slap you. Although the slapping was a fun time. Uh, it was wild. It was fucking wild.

16:42 I did not expect it. But it's it's It is neither saying that like cool, Yes you just like dying and have to suffering suffer is good enough because that's what your culture says. And it's also not saying, well, what I say you should be doing is better. It is it is finding the ways to work with one another and to work with a person to respect both and a cultural expectation so you can be able to fucking help them. However you need to write, and so obviously that's not going to be in the context of the Star Trek episode. But what it did is it ended up dipping right into like a lot of yeah, non consensual touch and weird shit and a lot of strange dynamics that just felt so squaky to me.

17:30 And I'll tell you what it reminded me of, and then I'll stop my rant here about how old am I? Fourteen Webster, what what you go with this wonderfully articulate, empathetic I'm not trying to come with this with cultural absolute as I know, I understand the nature of cultural relative is and that's one thing. And there's complicated gender politics at working. Certainly want to be able to have empathy and understand the times, but also at the same time, it's very complicated to watch this as a human being. Now see you see these complicated dynamics at play because I have a certain relationship abusers in the world. And then the next point I was like old a mine, Oh don't mind. Well, thank you for going on that joke because it reminded me of how old I was, so that I could then do the math. I see you. Thank you so much for making me look good.

18:33 Uh. About thirteen years ago, I did research in Chile, Chile on therapeutic abortion, abortion policy to go to therapeutic abortion. It's just what they would call the only way you could have an abortion. I think they've relaxed it now, but it was basically that means you can only have an abortion if you're going to die or those medical issues. And I was talking to a doctor who had written a whole book about it, and he was there on the front lines when abortion was criminalized, and one of the things that he talked about doing was women would give people would give birth and they would immediately insert IUDs and he was like, this was saving lives. We did this because now we're giving the protection right and they would be doing it without like I don't know if it was specific to him, but like that was a practice that was done typically without the consent of most of those people, maybe while they were still sedated. It's right after giving birth. And so I tell that story because while it might have had, you know, in his mind, he's like, I was saving lives. And also you violated a bodily autonomy by not receiving full consent, right, And I think It just reflects a paternalism of how we see doctors that they know better and they know more about your body than you do, which is the kind of

20:04 thing that leads to things like black women not being believed when they're pregnant and giving birth and having hugely high maternal mortality because they are seen as not understanding their bodies enough or seeking like painkillers, and it is it's that type of tradition of paternalism that literally gets people killed. That's the end of my rant to peeback on that this is going to make it sound extremely silly, but I think the metaphor stands. I think this episode is the equivalent of commenters on YouTube going you don't have to wear makeup. There is a point where there is a point where McCoy is just like she talks about how on the planet the children belong to the men, and he says something like, oh, they take that away from you too, as if he's a night and shining armor coming in and like actually helping her to achieve equality or it is justice. It is a group of men that are telling a woman you deserve to be empowered. There's even a part later where she like runs away, and they're like, they think that she's gonna give them away. She doesn't, by the way, because she's a badass, and fucking Spot's like says some shit about virtue and I was just like, fuck you, all of you. Spock was kind of out of character in this episode. It was

21:36 weird. Yeah, especially consuming that the episode was written by DC Fund. Yeah would you would you like to know? Okay? So yeah I would. I was watching this episode because I wildered. I am. I am more interesting in the read on Ellie En because the episode is insensibly essensibly becomes about her. The first quarter of the episode is about learning the Kapellan culture and that they just love combat. Combat is better than sex, which sounds like a rotten Berry line because Roddenberry is the horniest man on the planet. Gross. I saw a tweet about how he would when people would be like, oh, well, there are a lot of women officers on the Enterprise, and someone was like, yeah, so that he could sleep with them and not be found out by his wife, And I was like, yikes, is that true? Probably? Oh god, yep, okay, probably probably not. The Lake also, Majel, he divorced his for his wife.

22:40 Ah the surprise, surprise. I don't know what the timeline is. I think they got divorced during the production of Star Trek. Majel must have known, sure and just went Okay, are you ever so exhausted by everything? Yeah? Maybe? Maybe I'm also just having a hard time because there's Jenna side happening, So I'm just like, fuck it all. You know, we're not here to debate we should if Majel knew or not because roden Berry was a woman night handsome. Sure, what we are here to talk about? Yes, it's Star Trek. And also, I'm just really interested in getting what the hit on this episode is from Ellien, how you feel about her as a character, what we like about her, what we don't like, and what we like about the politics. Because I got what DC was trying to get to with this episode right here, and I think it's fascinating. You're gonna do that thing again where you ask me what I think and then match it up asphen what do you think? So, despite everything, I liked her very much as a character. I thought she was the most interesting part. She goes from being in a position where she is has a shit ton of power while not having a lot of power, like she gets to as the wife of this dismain guy tell people what to do.

24:11 She is part of a cultural system and that's all she's ever known. Again, not saying it is good or bad or anything. I mean, I am saying it's bad, but Maana, but you know, I whatever. And she does not want to have this baby. She doesn't and I can respect that because it just ties her it. I mean, if the concept is that, the idea is that it doesn't even belong to her at all, because she's just the carrier of a thing, then having a child is just part of this structure, as opposed to like something that's part of her, that has anything at all to do with her. So of course she doesn't want this goddamn baby much likes Bach who when McCoy tries to hand him the baby, he just goes, I'd rather not, which is I was like same, And she finds comfort and connection in McCoy however that works for her and clearly has a strong bond with him, is able to give birth and then tries to protect them because she can change and wants to live and wants to live the life she deserves and truly tries to protect them and save the day, and is able to like engage with this child afterward in a

25:44 way that I think is trying to be like I get to decide and like this can this can be for me too, and I can keep him safe. So as a character, I love her. It's everyone else that sucks. So DC Fontana wanted her pseudonym to be used instead because she hated this episode. Yep, because Gene Roddenberry and Gene Couon came in and softened Elien. Fuck doc, you can tell DC Fontana. Her quotes are the following. I'll start off with this first one. She wanted to write a story about quote not all women are mommies. Yes. Yes. From the original version of the script, Ellien's baby was conceived out of wedlock and she was executed for adultery. Oh my god. She did not ever like the baby, yeah, and was willing to sacrifice the baby mm hmm so she could stay alive. I meant company are captured while attempting to rescue the infant.

26:53 In the end, Alien actually out foxes herself and is executive for committing adultery. I mean that's kind of rad, isn't that red like I like it. I did genuinely think by the way, that McCoy was going to take this baby and then it was going to be like adopted in like you know, on Earth or something. I genuinely was like. The thing I did not like is that at the end it's like, oh, this is my baby now, because I was like boo hoo, Like she didn't want the baby. Yeah, Allien's baby was left to be raised by the grandfather until old enough to rule the tribes that would have been rad And also, Dorothy Fontana says, in a way it was sort of a women's lib story, but I didn't mean it that way. That's a classic because she was more just interested in writing a story because she wanted to see a story about a woman being herself and having exactly like you said, she didn't want the baby.

27:52 Yeah, the entire story. She didn't want the baby. But then roden Berry was like too dark. Oh and then Jeane could h rodden Berry out of the slap, roden Berry out of the no touching Alloy allowed Jesus. By the way, I do want to just note it's interesting when people of certain time periods and now, well, okay, complexity here the phrase you know, I didn't like set out to right. It was like a women's lib even though I didn't intend it to be that way. I have a lot of kind of like empathy and respect for that, especially if, like Dolly Parton says like she never really she was like, you know, feminists left me behind. And I actually have complex feelings about that too, where I almost feel like the what we decide as feminist is actually too white, not queer enough, not inclusive enough of different people of different genders, and definitely not people of color, and so it is like, by the definition of it, it is not good enough and has left people behind despite actually engaging with the real tenets of what feminism should be right, And I almost wonder if that's a little bit of maybe where DC Fontana is coming from.

29:11 But probably, Yeah, it has to suck to have the burden of I am the woman writer god book it, Yeah, as opposed to I just want to write a story and suddenly you just want to write this story that's featuring an interesting character, but then it becomes a representative of feminism as opposed to Yeah, I guess I really just wanted to write an interesting story. But people that look like me have that luxury where I can write about anything and do whatever I want to and it's not a political statement, right, but anyone else it becomes a political statement just by virtue of existence.

29:56 And like in this personal is inherently political because it has been politicized. Yeah, I mean it does by necessity become that, because it is so fucking out of the ordinary or against heteron ordered convention to even suggest even now that like if you were a woman or a fem or whatever, that you wouldn't want a child. Yeah, even now, and this is the sixties. I mean it's at the basis of God. I mean, all the autonomy pieces. I mean, this is like a basis of well, one of the bases of abortion rights. And so I'm not surprised that is exhausting.

30:42 Yeah, you just want to write fucking stories and everyone's just like, looks like this is about this, and you're just like, yeah, these like sis straight white dudes just get to walk around like telling their stories and no one's ever like, ah, yes, the story of the sis straight white man and his pressures the world. Like, I have a lot of feelings right now, So what you're telling me is that you haven't read my story about being a twenty something growing up in New York City. Every story is about that, Kenny. That's the joke. I know, every story. I swear to God, I'm actually that makes me feel a little bit better. I was watching this episode and I was like, this had to have been destroyed by Dean and because it ends up the I mean to be fair, can't read the earlier versions. However, it doesn't seem like there is a What is great about Great Star Trek is a strong political statement and it feels even the character of Elliann aside, it doesn't really feel like the episode is about something so much as the word of the day sherannigans. There are things that are happening, and Ellien is a spitfire character uh played by Julie Newmar. It is a mid plus episode. Yeah, it's got okay bones but and I hot bones, but more than okay bones. I did like

32:19 that it's it seems to be a McCoy forward episode. Yeah, I mean for that reason. The reason I was like immediately was like it started out fairly strong and what I liked that Kirk directed a lot of frustration at McCoy, and then he apologized. I think there's also something to be said about attempting to observe cultural relativism and this culture that reverers combat so strongly, and attempting to communicate with them without a patronizing attitude. But like so many original series have, that goes by the wayside in favor of cultural interventionalism. By trying to save Ellie Ann, who is gladly willing to give her a life because she understands. That's the way that it is. That's exactly what it is. What you just said is exactly what it is. You start with something that could be interesting and it just evolves into cultural interventionism with no real thought about what that might mean or the implications. No, granted they're deeper observations that the episode isn't interested in. By unpacking probably the patriarchal decisions that are endowed with the society like that that values strength, and then also the notions that they would well late to the Klingons more, the Klingons are what did I write down? Didn't take too many notes here, but I wrote

33:50 down only the strong could live, the sick should die. That in itself could be an interesting examination of what exactly that means. But that just kind of gets put into the background, right question, Yes, you said this. They were based off of a combination of it was like English, Native Indigenous people's and Middle Eastern in what ways like in look or an inspiration. I'm wondering about their how they're seeing this. I'm forgetting exactly I know that for some stupid reason. Yeah, the producer was like, why are they speaking English on this episode? That was an unpassable point. We're on the second season of Star Trek yep. Well, granted this was supposed to be episode thirty of the first season, but either way, you're twenty nine eight episodes in. You commissioned, this is your thirtieth script, and now you're asking the question why are they speaking English? That's not a conceit that we need to answer. By this point, we've already understand the rules. But apparently it was enough of a sticking point for everyone involved that they had them adopt a stereotypically Native American way of speaking English. Yeah. Yeah, I

35:28 mean I think I think if I were to guess, because I am assuming worst intentions and I don't care, I will that like the look was more like medieval English plus as I said in the Patreon part of this, a combination of Mad Max plus Abba uh lot of fury shit and but the sort of tribalism and the military, like the violence of it. I can one hundred see as Middle Eastern and indigenous equals this, Yes, which is what stops me from like like it makes me that's like, that's a complexity, knowing that it's probably where that is coming from, that where I'm like feeling a complication of Like, that's when we start getting into like the cultural absolutism relativism. Like I can look at something from my cultural perspective and I can objectively say that, yeah, something actually is wrong and also recognize that the creators of this are fucking racist and see it as deeply absolute and that these like savages are horrific because they don't look good and like pretty blonde girl kind of stuff. I can hold both and hold that anger. So so that's cool. However, let's talk about the high point of all three of these episodes. We get the return of one of our favorite characters, Aspen.

37:04 You know you love him. One word, five letters one Ry. Larry is back, baby, Larry's back. Larry. He believe I hired a skywriter to write Larry's back. I am out so much money. You know how expensive a skywriter is, But I'm dedicated to it because the world needs to know Larry's back. Baby. I can't. I believe I missed that Larry's back. Hilarry is back. I saw him and I actively yelped lay back in heart cell. What was funny too, is he came right after the CA Gulls and I fucking hate the key gulls. Now, why do you hate the CA calls? I don't like their teeth as I have cakel teeth. No you don't, I do. Look at that. No you don't. You have cute little teeth. Thank you? Do you not?

38:07 I don't like them. They freak me out. They freak me out the way that like some muppets freaked me out. And I just like some some like you know, Jim Henson, Frank aus shit, just like leaves me feeling very uncomfortable, like doctor Seuss bullshit. And I just don't like the feel of them. And I don't like commerce. Sounds like you're being a cultural absolutist about the cakeles. Probably I don't like them, but you know what, I love Larry. I'm so happy he was great. And then he also, uh maybe like duped them, not duped them, he he was he He basically got a blanket for free by being like, I'm just it won't hurt it. I'm gonna be so cold alone in Tebow's crying, and I'm crying because I'm so worried about Larry. I'm like, Mary, can I give you a blanket? I'll give you anything you need. I'm sure he's got plenty of blankets. Well, now it's true. It was a grand return of Larry. Sometimes we can count on Ewoks episodes to be little parables and teaching little lessons about how to conduct yourself. No, yep, sometimes I don't canny. Can you help me? Yeah, I'll play

39:38 the moopsie sound effect again. Hold on, there I go. These were passable episodes, perfectly, perfectly fine, look like fine. I had one of the funniest moments. Why am I so mad? Maybe it has to do with the fact that now we are starting to get in this algic about times whenever there were twenty nine episode seasons of TV. Meanwhile, we have yet to really reckon with the exploitation that is involved with the entertainment industry, and you can sometimes feel the exhaustion of the page whenever you can tell that the writers just like, we just need to get something out of the door. We've got to do something, and that leads to products that not necessarily everyone is proud of, even though everyone is working not even just that an eleven out of ten, but like out of a twenty three out of ten.

40:30 And then not only that, but these mid episodes are then meddled with by producers who feel like they need to throw their producerial weight around because they have to feel like they need to justify their title or justify to a higher up that they're working hard enough, and so they just make arbitrary changes because they need to prove themselves, and it doesn't really benefit the story. It doesn't benefit the lessons that are trying to be imparted, and kind of muddles even the writerly waters of folks that are coming in with a story and a point of view. And sometimes the producers just like one of these pants were orange, but it was critical that the pants weren't even pants. They were a metaphor for a mother literally the giving of herself, giving a dress that would be such an embodiment of this one item of beauty something. I'm just angry. No, that's it. Maybe I think that's actually exactly it.

41:35 I think you can feel exhaustion. I think we're five episodes away from the end of you watch, which I'm throwing five six, six, six. I mean maybe I thought i'd like just counted them because I was like, how much longer do I have to do this? We're so close, We're so close, And then check the six and check the spreadsheet because I just put I just put some stuff on there. Okay, pretty pretty amped. We're whenever we get out out of Ewoks, we're going to be in some great territory Aspen were. So we were just talking about we were just we always started talking about clear points of view perspectives, how Killers of the Flower Moon three and a half hour long film can feel like it flies by because of a clear perspective and commitment and uh, you know, like often love for a thing, right, And I do think that we can feel Maybe that's it is like I can feel the exhaustion of these episodes, much like I can feel the tension and the frustration of Friday's Child. Do you know what I mean? Yes, just Friday's Child. Mean, it's based on that poem, but more than anything, I hope it's based off of Lady Madonna by a Beatles Lady Madonna children at choirs, wonder how you manage to

43:07 feed the rest? And he goes through and it's like Buddy's Dad, you know wow, which if you're going with the original end egg, what a bittersweet episode title because Friday's Child is loving and giving? Yep, I think actually truly. Uh wait, sorry, now I'm caught on this. How does it go? How does the what is the the Friday's Child part? Go? On? Lady Madonna? Friday Night arrives with out a suit ca so it's not the child, but it's just Monday's child anyway. I guess that's sounded it at all. I got it wrong. My dadd used to play it on the piano. I'd come in and he'd be like Burner birder Bird. Thank you. Jeff Webster. Yeah, yeah, Friday's Child is loving and giving is the poem. And what it says makes me feel sad.

44:07 Yeah, makes I feel really sad, especially if like you call it Friday's child when the whole point of it is that she does not want this. It just kind of becomes, oh, that's a clever turn of phrase as opposed to something that is potent and meaningful and filled with dramatic irony. Right, Although we do get Bones looking really delighted and as you love it when he's delighted, you also get the line a classic formula of I'm a doctor nada with I'm a doctor, not an escalator, which is which means that escalator still exists in the future. Right. I genuinely was like, you're just interested in old tech or are there escalator? I'm a doctor, not an escalator? All on Basquez rocks. It's interesting that we're right back to discussion about Frida's child, But sorry, we can go back to Ewoks.

45:09 Not too terribly much to say about both hard Cell and a Warrior and Alerto. So one really hot chipmunk lady. Oh yeah, she was real hot. Actually, we'll get into it, like for Starship. But I got thoughts interesting, well, I do have. I did have some interesting thoughts around it. I genuinely was thinking about it, which is I think we often get into resource scarcity and ewoks we do he look sprised like ewoks is. I know it's a lot of trading and bartering, but the implication within hard cell is that a lot of people don't have the sources to be able to trade. They are I mean, Larry, I think, is playing them. But like what if he genuinely doesn't have anything and he's just trying to get by and they give him the blanket Wick. It's clearly upset about it because he wants those fucking horns and he's just like angry to have to to give this away. And I just was thinking about he is a fucking torp, whereas Tiba is a sweet little boy who feels a lot of empathy and then he's crying buckets and then in an oarrior and Alerto, he it's actively this blog has dammed up this this water, this river, so

46:43 the other creatures can't have the water as they need it. And it's literally about the the greed and the selfishness of hoarding resources, and in that case it's water. And I just think there's like an interesting sort of that happens so often within these Ewoks stories, to the point where you made a whole argument about it. Maybe there's a shorthand to know. I have no justification for this, but if the episode becomes preoccupied with acquiring resources, you're going to be in for a bad time, I think. So I felt mad about it this episode the Friday's Child starts off or talking about mineral rights on Capella. Also, oftentimes any type of like marginalized people don't have there's no justice, they don't have power, their voices aren't as strong. It is often about the false sense that there's a lack of resources, like so oftentimes you have you know that, like it makes it seem like only so many people can have this power, so there's like the chosen few. So white women get to have this power and they don't want to share or bring up black women because there's this idea that there are not enough resources to go around in terms of that power. So there's also a lack of resources in terms of gender dynamics as well, in addition to mineral resources. So yes agreed,

48:19 and a warrior an alert who he's hoarding all that water? She don't know the gender blog A monster seems like a hippo with a blowhole, a flat top blowhole, a flat top blowhole. It's name money improv. Oh my god, are we about to start an improv team? Call it flattop? Nothing would more just a little dooh of us. Yeah. The resource the resource pieces. I wish there's just not what is there politically about these eloks episode? As opposed to both of these episodes, it's kind of being about either bartering with resources or hoarding resources. One is trying to sell resources.

49:15 One is trying to prevent someone from hoarding resources. Also, not only the verse the first one about selling and trading, they're also competing for these horns and the creature it's literally had those horns cut off him and he returns at the end of the episode supposedly, I guess because it's funny. They're like, oh, you did all that and you don't even get these horns. And he comes back and they're like because they're like, who gets the the eaton? Yeah, the eton tusks? Who gets the tusks? And they're like, I should get it because this happened. I should get it because this happened. And then the eaton shows up at the window with like gaping holes where their tusks should be and I was just like, what, no, what the fuck? This is a really sweary episode because I'm mad because the Walks feel entitled because they were exploited by Mouth who has a cold?

50:21 Can't just take the day off by exploited, I mean, you know they wanted they want them tasks. I think there's a message here about how exploited and oppressed people's if they are deprived of their own resources and then placed into other situations, will also then use the tools of the oppressor to deprive other oppressed peoples of their resources. Yeah. I think that's exactly what the children show the Star Wars e Walks was saying, yes, yeah, four clock Cole still preoccupied with uh, Palestinian is really conflict as well. You should conflict, JENNISI ipe everybody is where I should really, I should really release a statement. The Tambles, Yeah, there's a tamble baby. That's a connection. There are babies in these episodes. The table baby is actually very cute, and then Tbo just kicks it on accident. Hold on, hold on, Aspen. It looks like the Tamble mother makes the Tamble baby go walk out there to get Tebo's attention. That's how I read it.

51:37 So she's using this baby. Yeah, I wrote down Tambles using their child as bait to conscript another child to participate in a proxy war. The Tambles are a metaphor for America. Maybe we're mad because we're mad at America. Maybe that's what's happened. All these resources available to us, and the best thinking that we can do is, what if there was a square truck?

52:21 Oh my god, duh. All of these resources and it just goes to making life worse than just making billionaires richer. Oh no, let's pull ourselves up out of the noose dive. No, that's when we got to pull ourselves up out of the nose dive. Okay, okay, I think we talked about common anlyts between this these three episodes. Yeah, I think it's time to cast our kades up from the ground and look up to this guy. Ready the stars. I think it's time to starship. It's the next segment. That's it's a starship. It a long time ago. Start dating this week. I quoted a boat, I dated a game, but none of them could warp my drive into higher space. The best of both worlds kept me in the second place. Captain's log on a Halla kron I wanted a snog. I penned a song seventeen more minutes, a guise in super high depth aboard the USS Enterprise DTV. Don't you take my walk lighter and

53:59 Cliff, don't you take my red schord, buddy and spill the tea. I'm gonna sip it. Starship it incredible, absolutely incredible. Once again, thank you to joelty partner. He wrote that he just like sat down and just started putting together words and then just like wrote it in like thirty minutes. To be fair, I think that's Joel's opusly talented and also I'm pretty sure that's how all songwriting right works. Yeah, sure, for sure, sure for sure. I'm not a songwriter, so I can only assume, uh I starship it. So start with our favorite vehicles, then move into our romantic ships. I thought about the romantic ships. I think about the vehicles. A great question. I'm doing quick research to make sure that my mm hmmm ship has been said indeed the first appearance of it. I am also curious because I have one, and I'm also not sure is it the same one? Interesting maybe maybe not. You go first, Okay, uh, the Klingon bird of prey. It's not a bird of prey. It's

55:30 not Is that a romulant thing? Right now? Oh no, it's a bird of prey. Yeah, it's bird of prey, but not in a candidate but like it will eventually be right, this depending on which version. Okay, if you're watching the Blu Ray none altered, you get a tiny little green box. No, but if you watch the much more common remastered version, you see the first appearance of the Klingon D seven D seven. Okay, I'm right, So it's not quite that, but that is the Klayton thing. Yeah, you see it. It's it's pretty fuzzy, but it is pretty unmistakable if you are familiar. And I was very delighted by it and excited. Also excited because proving that Scotty can indeed captain the ship.

56:25 I'm like, what, I'm like, what we were worried about in the last episode. I was just like, you can fucking do this. But yeah, it was that little b plot of Scotty and the rest of the crew being diverted off path and kind of drawn away from the planet and then yeah, seeing the Klanyon ship, I was like, ooh, that good is It's a great design, also designed by Matt Jefferies. And like we talked about last week, keep it that don't design philosophy because it understands that the the cells need are extremely powerful and they need to be far away from the fuselage. Mm hmmm. Oh yeah right. And also you need to instantly identify that it is not Federation, right, not Starfleet, and so you get that thing that What is interesting is that I believe the first appearance of the D seven, and listeners please write in correct me if I'm incorrect the first appearance of the D seven it's actually in the third season, and there is an in universe reason of why it looks the way that it does because it looks a little bird like mm hmm. But the Klingons don't have birds prey yet. I think we've even seen one of their ships officially, if we're watching the non special edition versions of it. Got it.

58:00 It's a thing with the Romulans. We'll get to it later. Got it either way. Aspen's picked for this week, it's the kling On battle cruiser. Mm hmm. Well they got to pick something else. God, dang it had it been done before? Oh? Man, not that I'm looking at the spreadsheet. No, oh, what were you going to pick the cling on cho? Yeah, of course I was your ding dong. Oh it's okay, sorry, you could have it. That basically was yours. I could pick the other one. I feel like you. No, you're gonna pick the waterfall. The waterfall and indoor. Oh my gosh, because they write it do yeah wrong, beautiful? Was there anything else? I don't. I don't don't think there was any other. Oh, they do ride, they they they there's like that pig thing that they wrestle at the beginning, and it's kind of like there the top of the rounder the that does that count? He's he's on it for a second. I don't know if it counts. Is the vehicle if you're not going anywhere? Sorry, the rules are weird. Also something that he did like in Hard Sells that at some point maybe Michael Reeves wrote this episode because his kids were having to

59:31 sell things door to door. Oh and he definitely at some point, Yeah, they just kind of stop with the pretense that we're selling and just kind of adopt the common parlance of kids fundraising from door to door. At one point, Wicked is just like, we're trying to raise money for a trip, and the door keets really fun. It was really funny. There's a lot of good t Bocenan against too. That film me with a lot of joy. If you're so in love with Tebow, why don't you just ship it? Ship it? Ship you and Tebow? I do? Oh is a child? Who do you ship this week? Oh? I do? Oh ah Wait, I had it and I've genuinely forgot what I decided on.

1:00:19 Fuck you go first. I am going to pick the Tambles. Oh, they're a sweet They love each other and they're you know, mother Tamble and father Tamble are clearly in cahoots and willing to use their child. That's true. They've got a really good little dynamic going there. They must love each other in order to be able to conscript child soldiers into their proxy war with the blog, right, Yeah, I mean that has to you have to really really good partnership for that to work. I'd say, like to be able to use a child solid foundation. Yeah, speaking of which, I think I ship the like. I don't like this. I don't like anybody. I like Ellien in this episode of Friday's Child. I like her so much and I like want to like do that annoying thing where I'm like I ship her with her own fucking self, you know what I mean.

1:01:37 But I feel like that's cheap. That's me not actually committing. You have to commit, like I ship her and Freedom, I ship her and leaving her child somewhere and then going off on her eat prey love trip or is she like figures out her shit. I'm going to write it down, Ellien and Freedom, thank you, thank you got your ship. I guess if we were going for like what would I secretly read and fanfic even though it makes me feel a little bad, it would be McCoy and her McCoy and Allen, Like there is a touch of like it felt like a weirdly like kink filled episode, like she slaps him, she slaps him again, he slaps her, and she very like I was sitting there going this is weird.

1:02:37 But I'm looking for an in episode in universe way to like think about this. And if they are a culture that really values violence, she probably was like actually deeply respected it. Oh yeah, and so and there's like a touch of like, well, it's a little abrupt and violent, but some people are into that. I think I'm into this as a ship. So my my real ship, despite you know, because sometimes you ship weird weird things. It's not it is, it is McCoy and Ellen. All right, yeah, I'll put it. I'll put it down. Thank you. But also Her Freedom and Eat Pray Love. Uh. Speaking of Eat Pray Love's time to rank this art. You tried so hard and got so far, but at the end it doesn't even matter. You're really good at Segus. Thank you. Speaking of Segus, it's time to get to the central premise of our podcast, which is better Star Trek versus Star Wars.

1:03:45 As we attempt to rank both Finding a Child from Star Trek the original series versus hard Sell and a Warrior and Alerto. We could not stop talking about hard Sell and a Warrior and Alerto. I don't know how we're going to be able to rank all of this. Uh. I will go first, starting with Heart Cell and a Warrior and Alerto. I'm going to give it a five point five interesting not uh, not actively bad, no kind of entertaining. Yeah, yeah, that's really all the commentary that I have. Whish there was more meat on the bone, wish it was more than just shenanigans. But you know, you get what you get. You get what you get, and also when you're in a mood. Yeah, i'll give it a five. So five, Yeah, right down the middle. I can't say I disagree with you, so I won't. Thanks, You're welcome, chill. Speaking of chill, Friday Child left me cold, which is why I think I'm going to rank it a five points seven one, No, five point sixty eight for nineteen sixty eight. Yeah, it's not the worst episode that I've seen, but it's just I found my I watched the

1:05:20 episode earlier today and even just later today, I find it very difficult to try and recall what the heck, how the heck this episode ended? Weirdly, it just evaporated out of my brain. Yeah, well, because what what was what do we accomplish? What do we accomplish? McCoy saying wikuchi ku ujiji Gucci, and that really great moment of I'd rather not. I genuinely just just to say this, when he tries to hand Spock the baby, he literally said I'd rather and I thought he was going to say die, I'd rather die, captain, which is so funny to me. Speaking of handing the baby, I hand you the rains to rank Friday's child.

1:06:09 Weirdly again, I actually thought the bones of it weren't bad. I don't know how it ended. I know, I think actually it had a really strong A and B story. But I just like, I'm gonna pull a Kenny, and like if I even if I'm like it isn't technically bad, I'm still gonna be like it was bad because of how it's leaving me the taste in my mouth. So I'm gonna call it a four. Oh you do love to say it. Ooh what a squeaker this week. That means with the paltry four point eighty four versus Ewoks robust five point two five. Oh my god, Ewoks kind of wild, doesn't you know, exhaustedly limp to the end of the marathon, but it like finishes, but all the friends don't care enough about it to clap it on. It's just like, okay, it like started shitting halfway through the marathon. No, because at least that would be a glorious fail. Like this episode kept pace. One time I ran a five K and it was extremely hot, and I probably pushed myself too hard, and right as I got to the end of the five K, I threw up. And there's like a picture of me right as I'm about to throw up. That's like, not what this is, because it's too boring for that, but that's what I reminded me of.

1:07:42 Yep uh. Speaking of throw up, we got a comment for our patron Okay on one of our our most recent episode, our Journey to Babel versus Gone with the Mimsen the first Apprentice otherwise notice but talk with Kenny from Jolty partner himself. Aspen said that Amanda's hair looked like she was from Whovill and then a few minutes later I set the hair's heart. Sarah Hart grew three sizes that day, Askedhen, would you care to retort? My partner is very sweet and very funny, and that is indeed exactly how it went down. I agree, and if you too would like the ability to leave us pithy comments on early episodes and extended episodes of this very podcast hop over to patreon dot com. Slash trek Wars pod joined the five dollars a month here and you two could be amongst such auspices like Jolty Partner. Thank you so much for your patronage. Honey, we love you, Timbo De Sosa, Emily Brice, Love, Heidi Rogers, Kevin Miller, Mark Biberts, and Ryan Hill. Thank you so much for your patronage one and all again.

1:08:51 Patreon dot com slash trek wars Pod. Additionally, if you would like to support us in non financial capacities, hop over to trek wars Pod. Do click on the reviews tab and leave us a review. We love to hear from you. Also follow us on social media either Instagram or blue Sky at trek wars Pod, and if you don't want to be on social media, send us an email. Check Warspod at gmail dot com. Our fabulous theme song was composed by one Tellson Ofso thank you so much for your themes song for us, We love you. Anything else that we need to plug asthma before we get started, And by get started, I may get ended, get started going to Betty bye. I don't know, I'm trying to think if I had a new like final thoughts beyond what we already said and I think, Look, there's there's like over six hundred and fifty pieces of Star Wars that we got to watch. There's over nine hundred. That's the Star Trek. No, all them are going to be winners, right right, And they shouldn't have to be. I think it's always the good thing to members. They shouldn't have to be. They shouldn't. It makes the nice ones stand out even more. It's it's kind of the fun of loving something entirely unconditionally, to be able to see the flaws, see the weak spots, being like, yes, I accept this, which sounds so bizarre whenever

1:10:23 I say it out loud, because corporations never look at me and be like, I owe you something. But also, Star Trek is a member of the family for me, and for that I will always love it unconditionally, just like I love AskMen unconditionally. Oh I think I love you too. An audience, we love you. May the Force be with you and live long and prosper oop see