Whom Gods Destroy vs. Defenders of Peace
Aspen hates Whom Gods Destroy. Kenny loves Defenders of Peace (and so does Aspen).
Is the Galactic Republic a strictly American analog? We also discuss the nature of conflict. Also, Uhura, Sulu, and Chekov are constantly undercut. Why is that?...
Aspen hates Whom Gods Destroy. Kenny loves Defenders of Peace (and so does Aspen).
Is the Galactic Republic a strictly American analog? We also discuss the nature of conflict. Also, Uhura, Sulu, and Chekov are constantly undercut. Why is that?
__________________________________
Get early, extended episodes on our Patreon at https://www.patreon.com/trekwarspod
Watch us!
https://www.youtube.com/@trekwarspod
Theme by Tosin Awofeso
Social Media:
https://www.instagram.com/trekwarspod
https://bsky.app/profile/trekwarspod.bsky.social
Want to ask us questions? Email us at trekwarspod@gmail.com .
And leave us a review! https://bit.ly/leave-a-review-trek-wars
0:27 Welcome to The Trek Wars Podcast, the one podcast that dares to answer the question of which is better Star Trek or Star Wars by going through both franchises in chronological release order. I am Kenny Madison of the Star Trek contingent with me as for always a cup of tea in hand is. Aspen a webster. I did need a cup of tea to be able to get through this tonight. Speaking of having a cup of teas Aspen is a Defender of peace. Ah, yes, goodness, gracious, you are a real comedic. Genius, certainly, but I'm not a tactical genius like Garth of Izar is today. In our episode whom God's Destroyed from Star Trek's The Original Series Season three versus Defenders, a piece from Star Wars The Clone War season one, ending a two episode arc from what I Understand.
1:21 Yeah you got yeah, you got it right? I mean, what else would they do? You know? I felt like they're just roll away. There's like an entire third episode and it's just a rolling time. That'd be fine. They're going to collect rings and all that. Yeah, band, that'd be fantastic. It's just a crossover. It is just a crossover crossover with. What's his name. Son? Yeah, Yeah, that's the guy I'm talking about. Uh. Well, speaking of guys that we're talking about, Uh, the people that I'm talking about are patrons who love to keep in touch with us via patreon, dot com, slash Trak, Wars pod and so too. Do we have a little bit of correspondence from our Patreon specifically Arizona Mark Sweet from our extended episode Dooku captured versus wink of an Eye, Arizona Mark clocked Nice, April Lavigne skater boy reference.
2:19 As Oh okay, thanks. Good job. How do you feel about that? I really appreciate that we're all on the same page when it comes to our ages and what we value most in our our princesses of punk. I'm doing great too, all right. I feel like you started and you were like, I'm really tired, and I was like, it'll be fine, and I'm like, I've got some time to get colchy. Yeah. I believe that character arc that Aspen is going to go over in this episode is starting off at like kind of cozy yep, and an hour and a half later just going to be in like three different blankets.
3:09 Would be incredible, just like it'll like cut back to me, like and I'll be like in a sweater. Yeah, how that happened? Just like magically happen all sudd I'm like in a sweater. And then it's like you see me again, and I'm like, why why do you have like a Parka. Uh instead of instead of a were wolf? It's Angela lands Wary. I really appreciate you. Hope you know that. Thank you. Sometimes I'm like, I hate this. I understand when. You do that, but also I respect that. It's a real skill set I just don't have. And what I've probably just been experiencing is jealousy. Uh.
3:51 Speaking of jealousy, that's one of the Arizona Mark has on this next episode, the extended episode of the mpath Versus Gonna General h already Aspen's missing a breakfast tacos an exclusive maybe not exclusive, a Texas delicacy flap of Tortilla sounds like a punk rock band name. Okay. See, Mark is just really in the punk right now. That's what explains it. And speaking of punk, in regards to Zack Snyder, Arizona Mark says, because we were scared that Arizona Mark might actually be a diehard. We talked about Zack Snyder at length in our pre Patreon chat. Arizona Mark says, dang the deepest dis ever, even thinking I'd be militant for the likes of Zack Snyder. Really not a fan of him.
4:41 I think I have enjoyed maybe thirty five percent of his films. Would love those percentages? About which thirty five percent that you love? Like maybe like the middle chunk of Batman vs. Superman Dawn of Justas. That's what I'm thinking. I'm like, I don't know if the numbers work out that thirty five. They spent their looking for the White por Portuguese in that movie. No, I didn't watch it. Okay, I've watched it too many times because I'm fascinated, because I'm wondering, how can anyone like this movie? They spend the first hour of that movie looking for something called the White Portuguese. What is that? It's a boat, Okay, because Zack Snyder is trying to double down on Batman being the world's greatest detective, and so they spend an hour on trying to look for this boat. Whenever, really they just need like a piece of kryptonite because they got to fight the Superman, and then and then they finally find the kryptonite on the boat because they find a boat, and then they don't bother to show the heistening of the kryptonite. They have spent an hour of real estate emotionally getting us to try and care about how hard it's going to be to get this kryptonite. We are doing all of the work, all of the work, all of the work to try and find it, and whenever they get to the highest part, they just cut to like an broken open glass jar.
6:07 Do you think this is the thirty five percent that Mark likes? Yeah? I think so. He's like, Wow, this is real filming. It's gonna be so sad. No, you're better than that. Sorry, mak A. They don't even show it. They don't even show id not even have a three hour ultimate edition. I couldn't imagine like hinting at a heist or setting it up and then just not following through on the promise, the promise of the greatest thing that we all love except for like murder mysteries, not you most people spoilers. Zack Snyder does that again with lackluster heist and Army of the Dead a bad movie. Anyways, we're not talking about Zack Snyder. We are talking about Arizona Mark and how great he is. Thank you, Arizona Mark. I'm excited to check out the Patterson cut of Ahsoka and excited to check out your interview with Kai Patterson over on the Whole dough Maneuver, yay and last pieces of housekeeping.
7:07 I want to talk a little about a little bit about Star Trek News and Star Wars News. It was it was fun to talk about. Maybe fun is the right isn't the right word, but you know, let's see what happens with this segment, our new segment, new segment. I know number one Starfleet Academy in production. Cool. Imagine if I wanted a Star Trek TV show Starry Holly Hunter and Paul Giamati, I do. I do too, and so they are now in production. Now. Hopefully this means that Paramount will not suddenly shelve it at the last minute and why never get to see it. I'm very excited. Sounds different, sounds different for Star Trek, and I'm very very excited. Are you excited for the Starfleet Academy show.
7:52 I am no, I mean absolutely, how could I not be. Well, there's a lot of reasons. You don't anymore, you only like making your own paper bound books. Oh god, that would be wait, like a person much cooler than me. Yeah, but you know, you make your own paper, you make your own ink. It's really the only ethical way of media consumption because you know all of the hands that are that it's coming from. It's just mine. Yeah, it's just mine. I'll put seeds into the paper, and when I'm done writing the book and then reading the book I wrote, I'll just put it back into the ground and grow a tree. Truly a tree of knowledge from that point.
8:34 Yeah, So that would be why I wouldn't be into it, i'd say. But apart from that, very that very specific reason, I'd say, I'm pretty excited. I mean, just feels really cool. Yeah. And then we got tig Nataro being a regular cast member tig Nataro cast member of Army of the Dead. But also a cast member in Discovery. Yeah. Yeah, she's playing that same character jet Reno. Which is okay, okay, so it was the same character. I was going to say, playing cool, cool, cool, very nice. Uh. And then I think we touched on it last week briefly in terms of Austin Aaron asking us things that we might be excited about within the franchise, with the franchises that we're covering. Uh, and we touched on it a little bit. Star Wars, Skellington.
9:20 Crew, skelling Skellon scale. Skellington Crew. It is Skellington. I'm saying it the exact way that Danny Butiterman says Skellington in Hot Fuzz. Okay, yeah, yeah, yeah, I don't think uh hot fuzz. I don't know nothing about No. Skellington's, by the way, not hot fuzz. But there is uh. It is the like twentieth anniversary of Sean of the Dead's release Wild. There is absolutely formative film for high school Kenny. There's a theater in Burbank that changed their little bar area to look like the Winchester and that's and I want to go, like I know that because Edgar Wright tweeted about it and I was just like, Okay, I'll go I live here. Not that's cute. I like it.
10:12 I will happily go see that in theaters. But sorry, the Skeleton Crew. Yeah, skeleton Yeah, I'm pumped for it. I'm in. I don't listen. What can I say? Well, you love kids on bikes. I love kids on bikes so much so that you were in a show that was initially called Kids on Bikes. It was actually never called Kids on Bikes. It was called How I Saved the World over Summer Vacation, and every single person called it kids on Bikes, thus angering the director. But he would never actually like say that, Like every once in a while he'd be like, that's how I say the World over Summer Vacation. Would be like, sure it is. That's very funny. Should we call kids on bikes? Just faster to say?
10:55 I love kids on bikes? Talked about it a lot. It's a it's a trope that I love. I think it's fantastic. I like the idea that parents and adults are not there to save you because they aren't what it's. True they should be. That was just trauma. No, let's uh, let's not unpack that any So did you did you experience the same tonal whiplash that I did whenever I watch that trailer? Probably not be Actually you haven't seen the trailer. You haven't watched the trailer? No, I haven't. Oh fascinating, no intentional choice. Yeah, I don't know. It happened too with the Acolade.
11:37 I actually held out for a long time. I know. I think that there there might be a little bit of a fear thing that always happens for me, or maybe as we get closer to it, I can like get my hope feeling strong. Oh oh, this might be. This might be revealing some things about my like fear of things I like getting canceled immediately by Disney talking about Oh, by the way, sorry this is off topic, but on topic of things we like getting canceled, Head Boy Detectives got canceled on Netflix, and like, I just really loved that show. I was, I was genuinely like that that could have this could have been like one of those shows that were like really kept going and built steam and got better and better and better.
12:25 And how many seasons did it get? One? It got one single season. And someone brought up the fact that Supernatural, a show that went on for fifteen seasons, also almost got canceled after one season. One of the fifteen seasons and had like a dedicated, huge fan base, right, it's like, let these things fucking breathe. And the reason I I'm so sorry the term that we landed on last week. I know that because I listened to the episode yesterday. Uh, you gotta let them cook. Gotta let them cook. We gotta let them cook. We gotta let them Yeah, we gotta let them cook. And I'm just bummed because actually that show was fun. It was a fun time. I really enjoyed it, and I liked the characters so much so. It's also a show with queer characters, and I'm just like, man, you're just destroying shit, huh with like black women and like lead you know, whatever, whatever whatever anyway.
13:24 But well, personally, I hate Netflix shotting. It's woke identity politics down my throat. Instead, I'll just watch the latest Joe Rogan Live special. Yeah, or the Dave Chappelle special. Truly interesting material. Anyway. I guess that gets a soft topic for Star Wars and Star Trek things. But I think it's going to be fun and I'm excited. And I'm also excited for apparently them trying to fight for the Acolyte, which apparently they're doing so Oh, we'll see what happens. Yeah, outs the Danning. I had not heard that about the Aclyte. I mean it, it's one of those where it's like, is that a real serious thing? You know, but it like it's like the vibes people are like, I think the actors are fighting, right, you know, we'll see, we'll see.
14:07 I would not be imagined. I would not be surprised if Mandelastenberg was just like, no, I'm good, I'm good. That is actually what I. Was thinking is I was like, why would you do it? Why would you actually fry for the thing when it's like they're pieces of shit? Parlay the notability from playing two different roles in the Acolyte into something else that can be more challenging than you know, getting verbally abused, getting death threats. Let us let us tarry no further and talking about the death threats with him being a Star Wars fan, and instead try and celebrate these two things that we love. We do fucking love them. We love them because we're real Star Wars and Star Trek fans. We're not like these others. We're not like these other ones. So ignore when I'm gonna really hate on the Star Trek.
14:52 I love it when they slammed their woke identity politics down my throat. Gobble gobble, as. I got to say, gobble, yeah, I want to do some factoids and descriptions absolutely. Speaking of Gobble Gobble, Star Trek's latest turkey is Whom God's Destroying First aired January third, nineteen sixty nine, director Herb Wallersteen. You might be familiar with this work from being a last minute replacement on the Tholeian Web A writer from an initial idea by Jerry Soul's story by Lee Irwin and Jerry sol teleplay by Lee Irwin, and our synopsis comes from Judy Crosby and her syndicated column a TV key previous as carried in the Corpus Christy Times, January third, nineteen sixty nine, Judy Crosby wrote, Captain Kirk and mister Spock become prisoners an intergalactic asylum where the inmates have seized control and now planned to rule the universe.
15:54 Of course, there is a woman in charge of the planet. She is gorgeous. That's I understand that. That's Yvonne Craig, who plays Marta, and she uses her feminine wilds on Captain Kirk these scripts are sounding like leftovers from the Man from. Uncle's series that's in it. That's funny. Also, Marda is not the one that's in charge of the planet. It's Garth, Garth of Iyzar. You can hear him screaming from the next apartment over if you're living in an apartment complex. Yeah, I was genuinely worried that people next door would be like someone. Dying speaking of people dying.
16:36 Wait, other other joke I wanted to make, but he said, like, uh, not borrowed. It was like something about the like an earlier story idea or something, and I was just going to be like, oh, and also borrowing from ideas of what was it, like the Knife of the mind or something. Uh, there are similarities. I think they might also just literally be using the same chair from that episode, but instead of the neural neutralizer being overhead now there are points on the side that are circling around, which, to be fair, that's a cool chairs chair. What was the other thing? It reminded me of something so strongly? Do I write it down?
17:20 I'll just go to the assessment And these are the Boyages season three from Mark Cushman and Susan Osborne. Star Trek had visited Pino Colony and Dagger of the Mind and had seen a shape shifter in The Man Trap and a duplicate Kirk in both The Enemy Within and What Our Little Girls Made of. I think it was duplicate Kirk stuff. Yeah, that was probably it. It's like we've had other It was definitely one of those where I was like, we'll get to we get in our first impressions, but it's definitely one of where I was like, we've seen this before, every single part of this except for like some minor but major pieces and done so much better kind of thing. And then Star Trek had tried two other times with the altern factor in that which survives a future episode, but with duplicate Kirks so much so as we've talked about within this show, Trek wars that Stan robertson their NBC executive that's being like, hey, do a little bit better, folks, had to be like, y'all just keep doing duplicate Kirk stories.
18:20 Knock at all. Right, this one is and it just feels boring, although it does get. Hold on Kirk. Just because you and I agree that this episode is boring, we shouldn't spoil the fact that we both think it's boring. Let's save our opinion of us thinking that this episode is boring for our first impressions, where we will then reveal. Talk about how boring it is. Yeah, because make no mistake, you and I are both on the same page. Okay, so episode is boring, but let's not spoil the shape of show. Speaking of shape of. Show, speaking of shape of show, speaking of the shape of Kirk. Defenders of the Beast Star Wars Clone Wars released January twenty third, two and nine. Are we doing January. Twenty Probably taking an oap?
19:01 Probably? Yeah, me too. Uh, let's see. Defenders of the Piece was directed by Stewart Lee, who, according to the Folowy Zone, he really liked Hong Kong action films. It was written by Bill Canterbury yep, and of course series writers Henry Gilroy and supervising is Scott Murphy. But Bill Canterburry the writer of this episode. Here is our description from miamdb, our favorite TV archaeologist who seems to be all over everything that's. True for seeing a synopsis for something else, and it was attributed to the TV archaeologist. What do you do all the time? It says your job, oh. Might be great, a pretty good one. You have to just like watch a bunch of shit where I guests go to Wikipedia.
19:44 Or now Chat, GPT. Maybe TV archaeologist is a Wikipedia writer and likes to go and do all that stuff and then puts it into IMDb. Okay, do you think that he wears an Indiana Jones hat? Probably? I hope so. I hope so. And he's got a little pick act or they just oh, my gosh, am I a sexist? Yes, I'm going to write it down. Then I'm a sexist. Yep, he's write that in my notes. A separate displeat led by nimboidan lock NERD arrives, which for the longest time I was like, you're not saying turd, are you. They're not. They're saying TRD arrives on Marudin to test their new Defoliator weapon, which destroys organic life but leaves machines intact. Unknown to them, three Jedi and two Clone Troopers are stuck nearby. Of course, from the last episode, they were still staying there because Anakin had been hurt, as we recall, and he the Lerreman were getting him better bringing back to health. Three Jedi and two Clone troopers are stuck nearby without a means of transport off planet.
20:55 When the Lerman village becomes endangered by the Test, the Jedi rush to defend it, despite the injections of village elder tt CO. That's pretty in description, thanks TV archaeologist, pretty well written. You didn't get main facts wrong like someone Corpus Christy did so yes, Uh, one of these episodes was boring. One of these episodes was not. We didn't spoil anything, so can people guess which is which. We'll leave it up to you. Whereas I think we talked about it. You texted me, you said, asked them as Clone Wars is and you just did the emoji for fire, holy cow went it up and then great ending, and I said, on the flip side, the star Trek is and then I put an emoji on ice cube.
21:47 We are clever, We're so funny. We are comedians. Againess like poetry, so if they rhyd anyways, yeah, our first opressions we think that whom God's is really boring. And I also think that Defenders is like, oh yeah, this is what Clone Wars could do. Oh, it is fun, It is interesting. It made me think about how I had been providing commentary and assessment on the idea of like, oh, clone Wars offers insight into what it must be like to just be people in this galaxy as opposed to like our main heroes.
22:29 But it actually kind of pulled me into a little bit more of an assessment around but the separatists represent which they are primarily composed of, like dangerous capitalists and like mechanists and like, which in and of itself is like it's it's a it's a it is kind of a true separate force for power, separatist force for power as opposed to like maybe based on maybe based on truer intentions. However, I mean, I don't take back things I said about like the complexity of how other people might take it in and see which sides they belong to. But that did I was thinking about a little bit more because ultimately they are about colonialization and resource destruction and stealing and so which is what capital so anyway, not really caring about living things, really just doing things for the bottom line. But also the episode has George de Kay and that is great.
23:29 Yes, which I believe is our first actual tangible link between both the Starchek and the Star Wars franchise because both of these episodes this way, I found a commonality between both these. Both of them had George de Kay and them both of them George, they do yeah, the other one does too, right, Yes, it does, it does? Yes right. I hated the episode I have know ideone has. I'm pretty sure that. That's the unfortunate thing, uh, because I definitely know that Kirk's black, McCoy and Scott are in it. But then I have been Sulu is not really a character. He's a guy who is like of course laid in, sir.
24:15 Right and Santa checkob lately too. Yeah, they're just like not people anymore. They're not characters, so hurrah too. She gets to give like notifications of things. Sometimes she gets a little bit more to say, but like giving up her quarters. They're not really characters. They they are recurring folks that you know their names, and they're not they're not yeah, yeah, you know, you don't really know what they stand for. Sula's characterization in the beginning of the show is way better than it is here in this oh at this point, the same with Aura. Yeah, yeah, there's nothing happening. No, Yeah, Sulu is a guy who liked to try a whole bunch of different things and had friends, and this was a lady ownership and was just like you know what's great singing?
25:09 Yeah, and also both beautiful and capable. Also strikes me as someone that kind of signed up to do military service because it was something to do, but it doesn't necessarily want to be there. Yeah, because she's I mean in her introduction, which I think is the man trap where she's like, if I have to hear Haley or if I have to hear uh whatever, Spot says one more time, I'm going to go out of my mind, which it's my kryptonite. Whenever people are like, you know this space stuff just the tired job Star Wars, they'll start treks. In this case, I I've got I've got some It pulled some stuff for me, some actual interesting like thematics, but you know, I whatever, because yeah, while this episode was while the Star Wars episode was a rollicking good time that brings up interesting questions about what's worth fighting for, like or also kind of going back to what we were talking about last week when we were talking, because we were talking we were discussing the first episode of the arc, of this sort of diplomacy that is necessary of like a few things come up that I would love to get into a little bit more about, like Sakura talking about like we can't force anybody to do anything, like we have a responsibility to protect, but like it's
26:43 almost like they find a way to keep them safe without necessarily like violating until it really becomes desperate. And I think that that's very interesting. I mean, in the Jedi are you know, damn big heroes in this one, but like to word that learnman, and I just think a lot of interesting ideas come out of it. Meanwhile, in the Star Trek episode, that's just so offensive and boring. Like if it were just boring, it'd be one thing. If it were just offensive, would be one thing. But it's offensive and boring. So frustrated though I did like the guy. I did like Garth screaming a lot until I didn't you know what I mean not.
27:24 Asking you might be talking about character actor Steve Enot, who died three years after this after a killer Yeah, it stressed his blood vessels. Let's play one of America's favorite games. How old is this actor? Kill? Let me think thirty two? Excellent? Guess? Okay, are you are within two years of some in some way?
28:06 Okay, let's go thirty four? Right on the head. This actor was thirty four years old, about to be two years younger than me. Yeah, by playing esteem? How old was Shatner here? Right? It's always moments like this that I invite everyone to come and see us on camera and just how beautiful are skin? Looks? It's true, we're just like glow in our thirties, you know, yeah, probably not smoking, going to therapy. William Shatner was born in March twenty second, so this so they were filming this in nineteen sixty eight, which would make Shatner he was born in thirty one, which would make him thirty five? What make Shatner thirty five?
28:55 In this actor? There's thirty four whenever this was filmed. So this great fleet captain that Kirk had to his fleet strategies were required reading at the Academy is actually younger than Shatner, but looks it looks twenty years older. It looks so much older. It's like a rough time, you know, it's like a real rough time. Did you know that the air was just smoke back in the sixties? We did, actually remember nice the movie Nice Guys, which we love. Actually we have talked about this. We love Nice Guys. I mean a big part of that is there in Los Angeles pre catalytic converters being put into cars, and like it's one of the biggest things. One of the things that I'm saying was I'm talking tout I asked, but I imagine it's one of the major feats that reduced fog and pollution. And like just actually having any kind of regulations on air quality, It's almost like regulations are actually.
29:53 Good, enforceable government regulations can actually lead to, you know, the better quality of life on this planet that no one asked to be alive on anyways, whoa hold on all in a second, this is what happens. This is what actually happens when we're when we're tired. It's like not that we become necessarily like uninteresting. Is we get like a little too personal, you know, like a little too mad. It's a freaking offensive episode. I actually find it to be so lazy that they are.
30:34 It is. It is an extremely mid episode not boring enough to be exciting, like, oh boy. Oh I don't remember anything? What is some hot bad catspaw. I'm like, this is so campy. I'm I'm delighted because everyone's going for it. It's such a big broad episode a cat How can be mad at that? Big old cats? As opposed to this episode, which is, you can't argue that a cat spot has been done on Star Trek again, but this episode, you've done it earlier though granted it hasn't rerun at this point in time. Well, but also like they've done the prison thing and but it's also kind of an inmates running in the asylum thing, and.
31:23 But this time around the idea, the idea is that they are criminally insane and it is being played. If it's for like current times, you'd be like, oh, this is like the Joker and Harley Quinn, but without like the fun of the thing, like and without any agency or power being granted to them. It just like feels very weird and shitty. It feels like a lot of gosh. I just would have rather they just not even engage with it at all, like like, oh, that was what I was thinking. Space Seed is the better example Space Seed and Wrath of kN because it's the same kind of concept of like a sort of a megalomaniac type of character who wants to take control of the galaxy.
32:14 But at least with kN he's coming from a it's a perspective of well, but I am actually genetically superior, Like I do deserve this thing. I mean, it's there's a lot of pieces in there, Whereas this is like a dude that if I were to sit down and be like, oh boy, am working in the in the in the hospital right now as a certified therapist, a thing that I was not in a county hospital though, like and I was like, this is your this is your patient, Like I'd be like, okay, well would I like, I guess we're Like it just feels it actually, this is one of those examples where it feels like it's been done before better in terms of like motivations and just to be like, well, he's crazy. It's so lazy and so offensive it drives me up the wall.
32:57 I will't say in this episode's defense, No, in this episode's defense in regards to like Space Seed versus this episode, and it's not a Star Trek versus Star Trek podcast, that would be weird. But in regards to this episode, this one doesn't have brown face, so that does give it an edge over yea space also, And it's really interesting to hear the Star Wars fan really defending brown face in regards to this episode being worse, and you're like, what makes Space Seed great? Ye or it's racial politics? Could you put this in the notes? Could you write a racist?
33:40 Yeah? You gotta dude right under Kenny says, I am a sexist. I am a sex So we we fixed racism and sexism and then we just this is a Chris Grace joke. We talked about Chris Grace's show and the Patreon and one of the jokes. He makes, which you can find at Netflix. Nope, I was just kidding. It's that's where you'll find everything like Dead Boy Detectives that's canceled. It's on Dropout, drop Out Television. Our Patreon, Chatton.
34:24 Dot Com, slash Chuck Corse Pod. I thought you here curious. I want people to know where to watch is special. One of the things is. Find out if you listen to the Patreon. I'm talking about trying to punish the capitalist pigs that are trying to force us into being into these different bagged holes and and no, we're trying to all your money. Drive get over the Patreon. I am pretty tired. I gotta pull back. It's pretty aggressive, he makes is. He's like at one point in the show, I'll fix racism and then I'll reinvent it. I was just thinking that, like you fixed it and reinvent Ah. Yeah, yeah, you're right, you're right, you're right, You're right.
35:12 Now I agree with this is a pretty mid episode. But it's not just me. It's it's it's like I do feel fundamentally and like offended by it, Like it just is God, I don't know, man, it's just shitty and it's stupid. Like the way that Marta, So the way. He behaves Marta, what a shrill character that well has nothing going on. She's like and it's like but again the direction to her and to him as well to no one else they basically just blumber around is like be as like a fucking psycho, right, like just be a cycle. Like the way she just sort of likes all over him and like ficks out, and the way he like has his sudden turns like it would just but the things we've also had this before, it'd be much. I was just like, well, what if you were just like a megalomaniac obsessed, like a capricious person who turned. But we've had that with like gods before, right, so it's like already, like I just I feel that it is frustrating and reductive in that way. And then to have her as this sort of simpering strange again, the worst version of Harley when you could do where someone was just like, you know what, I hate women, and you know what I think is funny, like mental illness. Like, don't get me wrong, mental illness is hilarious. But only if I make that job only people with mental illness, this is gonna make sense.
36:39 You don't get to make that joke I did. But even then again reductive, Yeah, she's she's shrill, simpering, she's shitty. The best thing she does is she tries to get with She tries to get with Kirk and like be like, I want to get you out of here, and then pulls a knife on him, which I actually thought was d I fucking loved that because I was like, yeah, I don't know, I'm not putting this enough into words excepted to say I hate it. I'm not. I'm not. Like I think that they're like I'm trying to think of representations of mental illness that are not perfectly offensive, but like who or that, like. It's going to be it's going to be slim Piggins in nineteen sixty ns Well.
37:23 I mean like I'm thinking of like One Floor of Cucka's Nest, right, which is a fundamentally empathetic movie and book as well. Yeah, and the baddie, the baddie of One Floor of with the Cuca's Nest is the person who's apparently not does not have me on mental health diagnoses, you know, she's the cruel one, and like these are like people. Yeah, anyway, but it wasn't until recently that I found out that the book One Flew Over the Cucko's Nest was actually from Chief Perspective. Yeah, it is. And that's seventy five, by the way, which is a movie, bug nuts, It's a great book. It's a great fuck. So I've heard from our friends over at Coach Peer's book club. I mean, I think you've laid out your point of the fact that they they there are other portrayals of mental health that are far more kind and constructive.
38:17 Whenever having this discussion, because this the plot of the episode is that our characters get thrown where the inmates run the asylum twisted. Ah okay, then what is the function of that plot? What are we looking at? Star Trek a typic very often a thematically rich show where you are taking a look at something a little bit askew, and it's asking questions. This episode feels like it is asking those very offensive portrayals. You're just being with those characters for forty five to fifty minutes. Yeah, and you are. You are not really exploring anything, which also, I mean you reading these are the voyageous season three by Markushman Whossborn. Uh.
39:07 You find out that this episode was like good enough whenever they bought it, and they just needed script sure, and so they were just like, we're so far behind, we just need something. You know what they should have done. They should have done. They should have brought back that guy, and they should have done the American doctor who they should have just started another episode of that day. It's been not every new episode of Star Trek can be a follow up to Assignment Earth it just can't happen. I want to sign on Earth. I want I want to now, I want to sign on Earth now. I loved it. I want it. Sorry, Yes, just the script, It's just a fucking script. I got you, I got you. It just needs something the time. Well also because why I make a story about Sulu whatever?
39:51 You I mean? So true? Uh, but you also feel the further that we get into season three, the stories just get thinner and thinner and thinner and covering other material. And uh, according to the research, apparently they hadn't even watched Dagger of the Mind, which is I recall a more interesting episode that's inquiring about the punitive system. Yes, I the punitive system in general. I'd have to go back and listen to that episode of track Where's again? Do you hear our insightful thoughts on Dagger of the Mind? And so you are left so it's not really interrogating anything, Okay, So then so then what are you left with? Surely we've got some delicious performances to hang our hat on or something that is. Whenever you remove thematic inquiry, whenever you remove ideas, then you have to supplant that with like.
40:46 Relations any kind of relation. Ship, and it's hard for both of those things. Yeah, yeah, and it's I mean, our main characters are basically Garth and Marda because Kirk and Spock are just kind of there in holding the entire time, and so they're they're sidelined and okay, So then if we're functioning within the classic Western storytelling molds that great stories or change, then what are we exploring with these characters that we are following And the answer is not really much. And the performances are I love a great over the top performance, but as I've said on this podcast before, you never and I'm stealing this from Nicholas Meyer, director of Star Trek two, you never want to show them your top because once you've shown them your top, they see that you've got nowhere else to go.
41:53 Yeah, And because it's the equivalent if you can't start at eleven. Yeah, exactly. And Steve nat if he were better directed, I think could give him more compelling performance because he's got an outstanding top, but the direction's not there for him because there's no there's no shape to his performance. In fact, it has the he has the flow of Yeah, it's like, well, I will say there the stakes actually don't feel very high until Marta gets blown up talking about changing. I will say, we got a clear, clear goal for Garth.
42:36 He needs to figure out the answer to Queen's to Queen's level three. Right, that is one single point in this episode's favor, very very clear. To be able to see he needs that to be able to get onto the ship so that they can know it's Kirk. So he's like, I got to I got to get this out of Kirk because. Garth can also change. Oh right, another point, Garth just learned how to be a shape shifter. Yeah, that's that's kind of cool. That is cool. The story of that is that he got into like and I guess the origin of his what will call psychosis also like happened because he got there was a terrible accident, he was cared for, learned from these I guess, like another species on another planet that was caring for him, how to change they were doing something else, and he figured out from that how to do it. But so there is in sight of that also the origin of where the start is so it's presumably from like a traumatic experience or had drama whatever it might be. That he actually went like he actually he did. I mean, I think the implication here is that it's not that he had this was like a part of him that was kind of developing over time as he because he was a military strategist. And this is actually a point that I do you think is interesting, which is the idea of the need for war and horror versus the need for peace and what the demands are. That is a thematic connection that I
44:07 do think is interesting. It's like a nugget. It's a slight nugget within this badass, bad bad ass of an episode, not badass of anc but no, what I was gonna say is like, it's it's that I think the implication is that there was a literal accident that caused us, which makes you feel even worse. Well, that's to get back to your point of his backstory, Revered Fleet Captain. His strategies are required reading at the required reading at the Academy. He did something at a place called Axon r And then within the episode textually, Kirk and Garth are having arguments of being like Matt, we got a Garth is like, obviously because he a crazo.
44:54 He's a crazo. See you can make that, you can make that joke because it's funny. Yeah, that's right. Captain Lord Garth is not well, hopefully say crazy, and so he is going we got to prepare for war, where Warhawks and Kirk gos like, no, we're exploratory fleet. That's that's what we do. Also laying out one of the paradoxes inherent within Star Trek is that it's an exploratory, exploratory fleet that also has weapons that can literally, as we have seen, level population. In a military structure.
45:35 And so the easy fix for this episode is that Garth the Warhawk is a victim of this new mission of the of Starfleet in the Federation because he's this dude that as a hero that has reasons are required readings at the academy, and he went crazy because he sees the inherent paradox therein you you call yourselves a benevolent fleet. But he can't reconcile it because he has let he had blood on his hands. Yeah, he goes, he goes, how on them can't he can't? How you know? In two thousand and one, what makes how reactually does is said he has a fundamental inconsistency in his programming, and.
46:16 So why didn't they just like, it's a hypocrisy, Why don't you just press the button off and on again? For Yeah, I mean that's a good point. Yeah, that's exactly what David does. He turns how off. Yeah, but he didn't turn them back and along. No, I don't think it's the button. Don't you remember the whole scene where he had to go into the thing, then he had to go and then he's like, DAYO, that's his eye. It's not a button. I love that movie. Okay, two thousand and one, good movie. No one Else is also a surprisingly good movie. Twenty ten, The Year We Make Contact. Oh cool, it's just not two thousand and one, but.
47:03 It's also a really good movie. Twenty twelve, twenty twelve. I'll take your word on that as well. I don't know I've ever seen it. Just thinking of movies with movies. With I'm Back, We're Back Defenders a piece. Yeah, great as we unless we have more to say in regards to who God's destroy and the possible interesting thing of interrogating a warhawk during peacetime being driven mad by knowing the cost. I think that the strongest amount of connection we should get into like actually talking about it, about the episode itself and some of the details of it, like how Sakura is so cool, like so cool. There's one point where they do the defoliator, like because the way that the defoliator works is they shoot it off like a rocket and it lands and it just destroys any living thing so it doesn't affect droids. And a couple of the Clone Troopers and by the Clone Troopers, it's like Ret. It's Rex before he was like Commander.
48:09 It's Rex in the end the Commander and they're running and one of them falls and they're like Sikora. And then they're up in a tree. And when I want those big trees, sacra like lightsabers through a vine, jumps down with the lights with the with the vine, swings picks him up before the you know, the line of literal fire can get to him and swings him up in the tree. And it was so cool. When the Lumire brothers were inventing. Movies, this is what they were thinking, This is what they were thinking about. Yes, whenever Benjamin Franklin harnessed the power of electricity, a thing that I'm sure that he definitely did and didn't just kind of make that up because he was a drunkie.
48:55 This is what he was thinking of. This is what he was thinking about. When George Washington cut down that cherry tree, because he definitely did. He definitely did that and then could not tell a lie. This is what you're. Saying when Christopher Columbus definitely discovered America and made friends with the with the Indians. This is what I was thinking, and me is a race when the Pilgrims had one peaceful dinner with Indians in friendship and fellowship and certainly not to be used as a cudgel to try and subjugate those that dared defy the majority religion. For hundreds of years they were thinking of this.
49:54 Episode, we go into it. Yeah, it's a banger, uh not just in terms of the action. Choreography is unhinged. At one point, Anakin Skywalker, you know, our best friend and hero buddy, floods a droid and then it's just like I'm too tired to walk over there, swings it over to him and that slices it and it's really cool. There's another part too, where when the Luremans they like the kind of small contingent of them is like, we have to fight because the way this has gone down, they take the battle droids and they tie them all up and they're in a circle, and then Ahsoka just goes around in a ring in a circle, just lightsabering them all. It was cool.
50:48 It saves time, you know what takes time fighting these darn Clone Wars. I've got to think of ways to kind of uh, you know, your business flow. Yeah, you gotta like be a disrupt. Ahsoka has a grind set mindset. She has no work life balance. She is the work. Don't talk to her before she has had her coffee. Don't talk to her before she's had her morning cop Ahsoka, no crumb Sleigh ahauts the house down. So yeah, not just with dynamine action, but there I literally wrote down, where is this day feloning?
51:35 Where's this day? Where is this version of day filoning? Yeah? Because this episode is so rich in examination of what cost peace and the end is what prevents it from being a didactic mess. Yeah say, okay, so I just listened what I like to do in order to try and inform my tape on the Clone Wars because I am a new to this show. Yeah, I like to listen to a more civilized age and an incredibly smart read on these episodes that are looking at this from political standpoints, from philosophical standpoints, from a multitude of standpoints that you and I are definitely looking at, but they also have just the the historical knowledge and trying to fit this within what we think that the filmmakers are trying to say as at least as best as the More Civilized Age podcast, can't they Obviously they're like, yeah, they're they're using Asian orange and napalm, that that's what the Defoliator is, therefore drawing the Vietnam parallels even even more, and really one of the first things that I've kind of disagreeedled with them on because I just love how aggressively leftist they are within reading of Star Wars and also like
53:07 clearly loving the source material while also interrogating what this means and being playful with it at the exact same time. A perfect tone, because you can't take this stuff too seriously or you're going to end up flix the Star Wars Theory YouTube channel a TWERP. Anyways, a More Civilized eight podcast is looking at this and they're going, well, the metaphor gets muddled because, as the extra text says, as Lucas has said, the Republic is America, the empire is America. Yes, okay, sure, yes, that is very true. And also and their big criticism with this is that they're like, well, the occupying force needs to be the republic and not the separate.
53:54 Tests thine, because that's kind of what I was talking about at the top here where I was like, oh, I think this episode is challenging all the things I've been saying interesting or but I think I also I think there is more nuance to this. Sure, yes, In fact, I think. The nuance I know you have a thing to say, Can I just say real quickly, please, I think the nuance is actually informed by the as I've mentioned many many times, the Jesse Earl neoliberalism to fascism pipeline. So but please go on. I would have forgotten. Actually, can you elaborate on that more? I will. I will definitely return to my point in regards to the Jesse Earl kind of the circular model myth story. In regards to this.
54:35 Episode, well, in the well actually, and in regards to the fact that the Republic is not the empire yet. Yeah yeah, and if like, let's this is perhaps dangerous, but let us apply the concept of that. I mean this, actually this is it. The neoliberalist agenda and framework is applied to the Republic. So we are in a state of neoliberalism right now. We have not yet fallen into fascism. We have not yet entered into that space. That space is the empire. I want an asterisk explicit fascism. They're still yeah, yes, yeah, there's yeah, there's just.
55:18 You know, if you ask Balatinia if he's doing a fascism, you might not necessarily do a fascism, but like there there are fascist overtones that are leering over everything. And as they say in the More Civilized Age podcast, you are challenging the republics unchallenged supremacy. And all these separtists have to do is just be like I'm and they're quoting Osama bin Lauden in regards to this. If they just start a fight somewhere, they will place a military base there because they can't have the image of the Republican challenge. But also this is a show for twelve year olds. Anyways, Well, I think and I think this is what I was is actually exactly what I was talking. I'm glad that I'm not the only one who was thinking about this as, oh, this is muddeling, this is muddling the metaphor for sure. If we think of the separatists as perhaps in some ways still like providing resources, like you know, being an understandable sort of off like this, we can see that they might be a viable alternative if like the Republic is actually doing things for the look when actually they are doing things out of like a kind of neoliberalist power of like, well, if we actually move into these spaces to protect you, are we actually protecting you or we just exerting additional power over these spaces. That's a big piece of it, right. But I think if we do start to break down the separatist movement as being composed of I'm going to call it,
56:55 I mean like almost like sort of like the other the other side of the coin of this kind of strictly capitalistic powers, which is a theory in and of itself and an application that is kind of overlaps with neoliberalism. But you know, you can see it in you know, what we are doing here is we are literally destroyed, we are defoliating, We are destroying for the purposes of colonization. So they are themselves colonizers, but in the way that capitalism more explicitly colonizes space and extracts resources, like and like it's it's the businessmen themselves coming out and their lawyers and doing the damage as opposed to the more the more structured sort of like we're hiding behind the fact that we're actually doing good in our geopolitical context.
57:53 Does that make sense? Yes? And I think that notion is encapsulated, encapsulated beautifully by the ending. Yes, So yeah, tell me about the endings. You really liked it? It's brilliant, Like what about it? Did you really like? I guess this is what I'm getting at. It's our overseer within the episode episode the leader of the lurement is going, yeah, sure we survived, but really, what do we give up? And it's it's not just that three republic ships appear overhead. Yep, the star destroyers yep. And it's the notion of surprise. Unlike unlike the prequels, unlike the two d Clone Wars, you've gotten to see Anakin be a character and these are kind of whereas the prequels were constantly yelling, did you know that Anakin's going to be Darth Vader one day and the Empire is coming? Yeah? Clone Wars has been so far for me, it is felt a little bit more strategic and deploying these things. And this is a beautiful like piece of I hope I'm using this correctly. Dramatic irony, Yeah, because he's h it's he's trying right, he's right, and the Jedi are and who who really here? The Separatists were
59:26 well specifically uh oh boy wrote his name. Lock Dirt played by George de Kay. Sure, sure, he wants to test as defoliator and uh, it's it's fun to be evil. Uh, it's cathartic to be evil. Uh. Ask people that were torching villages in Vietnam. Uh, they they were achieving something, granted, then it asks questions of droid personhood. But also Lock Dirt enjoys being evil. It is well he and he wants and he wants more power. Yes, that's also torching villages and hurting people and killing them its power.
1:00:07 Yeah, sure, yeah, it's it's fun for it's fun for him to be evil. Uh, And then the Republic is functioning within the confines the Jedi are functionings, and some of them believe that they're fighting for that notion of peace. Yeah, but because and this is also the brilliant stroke of individuals that are functioning within a corrupted system, and that can also be dicey because within the modern reading of this, but not necessarily within the context of this though, as we've talked about at length, they are introducing the notion of gray within who these Jedi characters are. But they're still kind of straightforward heroes mostly mostly Yeah, so much so are they straightforward heroes here in this episode? And then you pull out and we understand that the Jedi can't function within the Republic, their system can't function within the Republic because something so bad is going on that they literally can't use their sick awesome Jedi powers. So what separates them from being a Senate commandough that would make that Jedis are blindly serving without interrogating these notions, defending the neoliberal status quo. If I'm using that notion correctly, and that ending shot is a perfect encapsulation of it's
1:01:41 they they still they still are pulling an imperialism, even if it has the mask of benevolence right on it. And also, I mean the metaphor gets muddied by the fact that we don't know that if Dick Cheney was funding both the United Dates war efforts as well as the Taliban war efforts or or I mean using that I Rocky insurgency war effort. But it serves great as a symbol of that ruling class because ultimately, both as we talked about in our last episode, in the Jedi Crash episode, ultimately it is it is not an actual war of ideals. It's it's a simulation of a war, and they're using their their they're fighting because right because the tax could make it a little bit clearer that out of rim systems feel excluded from the Republic there and they feel beholden to be operating within the Republic and that they think that the Republic is a little bit out of touch. Yeah, and so they are doing this.
1:03:01 Those are those are good ideals, and we're starting to see them in Clone Wars. But within the movies wasn't really articulated because it was busy with other things, and Lucas was wanting to well, specifically with episode one, where it feels like Lucas was just wanted to like do its adventure, I. Just wanted to do a Star Wars, which is fun. Fine, Yeah, I mean this is just such a textually rich episode and it is the sure yeah, okay, well your metaphors muddy, but also that's extra textual analysis as opposed to looking at the episode for what it is, and I think the metaphors still pretty darn clear. As an occupying force and you have to fight the occupying force, what does it mean to actually be a pacifist? What does it mean to practice non violence? Is being non violent a coward? And also I think there is an actual nobility that the Jedi are just like, y'all keep doing what you're doing. I'm going to go fight for you.
1:04:04 You don't have to join me. That's that's a key difference that I really vibed with because they see it. Yeah, and even though Ahsoka and Rex called them out for being cowardly, I think last episode, in this episode, oh, in this episode, I mean that's. A yeah, pretty classic. Well that's that's what I meant by that's real diplomacy and negotiation, right, is you are like actually listening to the needs and desires of individuals in a community instead of just deciding what is best for them. It is a deeply difficult thing to be, Like, like if you were to literally have people do what they did with the Luremans did, which is say no, we're not going to fight, we're not going to defend whatever, and then you know for a fact they're about to get slaughtered. Like the choice that they made and the choice of do make for folks who haven't seen it, is that they get they they're able to steal some shield generators and they set up a strategy and they're like, you don't have to fight, We're just going to defend you.
1:05:14 And then once we've gotten the strategy of sort of like having them use that and we can pull them in, we will defend you. You don't have to fight. And then Anakin says, what ask, let us do this for you, right something along something along those lines that's much better written and not paaraphrase off the top of my head. It's it is so compelling. Yeah, and I and I just feel like, ultimately because the curs says that I think anakins like, we can't make them fight. We can't make them do anything. No, like and I think it, And that's a fundamentally respectful perspective.
1:05:54 People are willing to die rather than raise arms? Why why is that cowardly? Whenever they are that, let go of their egos and still firm and their belief. Yeah, but I you know this, well maybe they haven't necessarily like their ego of the darn thing does still kind of see it? This does that? This Okay, this leads to some other kind of like big big thoughts, which is sort of like I think something that star Trek's fundamental sort of like thematic clash like brings to light too, which is like the inevitability of conflict, but like is it truly inevitable?
1:06:40 And like even in a we talked about this funny, even in a society that presumes like a utopia, there is still inevitable conflict. There's still inevitable war or uh war just as a concept. I don't know it. I think I too would like, I mean, I think modern conflict is often it is it's kind of generated by means of you know, like made up boundaries and ethno estates and people seeking power and money grabbing and resources and marginalization of others. Like that's modern war, right.
1:07:29 That's just wars that are based in nations, and exactly right to talk about corporate war, right. And I and you know, of course, like historically, I mean some like a lot of similarities. And so I can't you know, it's it's a real horror to to say, to take that. Do you ever watch or play Fallout? Watch the Fallout show? No, I don't play video games, and well the show is really really good. I watch TV and it yeah. No. Famously, only films, movie. Films, pillums, there is a I. Know what what I like about movies everything. There's twenty four frames a second.
1:08:14 All twenty four frames every single second. Every single or twenty three point nine to seven six or twenty five if I'm across the pond, gov bit bi bit bipe bit, Oh, twenty five frames, isn't it? Oh? Why? Why? I don't quite know. It's just the way it is. Rad there's just a bit there's you know, ultimately, Fallout is about It's about corporate and capitalistic interest crafting off of the you know, the perpetuation of war, because war is always inevitable, and there's a kind of hard to that of, you know, because I think you could could you perceive a like a current modern world in which which like that wouldn't like that so many things are fueled by that, right, so many wars and so much bloodshed, not everywhere and all the time. It's a huge reduction in generalization. I know there's a lot to this, but.
1:09:14 Well, now now I'm just thinking about just to blow it up even more because we're talking about well, you mentioned about how Star Trek posits that that conflict is inevitable even if it's at the other end of a benevolent space nation. Yeah, that is still going around and still getting in fights or whatnot. But that's also to continue to couple it in with Jesse Earle's fantastic Mono myth video and the perpetuation of the hero's journey, and the fact that in order for Westman storytelling to exist and within franchises to exist, the status quote keeps needing to reset to some sort of new conflict. And it reminds me here we go ask then of I think it's the season five episode of Community, second to last episode where they were like, did we fix everything about Greendale?
1:10:06 And then they have that existential crisis, and then the camera just kind of like pulls out and then just kind of looks down an empty hallway. Yeah, and then just starts cutting around places in Greendale because like there's no more problems. Yeah, basically begging you to be like, this is what TV would be like without conflict, without problems. But I can't remember that super well do you remember that? But do they panic? And like it's because now it's like, what's the point? Uh, subway comes in and it threatens to close the school, So conflict happens, right exactly? I don't. It's also been a hot minute. I need to rewatch.
1:10:47 Community because I have this, I have this feeling of like, without there being a conflict, it's you know, there's yeah, with community, it's of course that it's always the metast but also it's like we can't function without there being a problem or something to fix. And our learning, well at least at the beginning of it, are both a going we can exist, we can't. I've been existing. We don't need your war here. Outside Yeah, outside of the bounds of both the internal storytelling and also the external like meta narrative of what we do in shows and film. Yeah. Absolutely, Yeah, there's like a sort of inevitability in both, like there's always going to be more and you know, I mean I would really love like what does it mean like this this idea of like is this something like there's is there a need for this for conflict again, not just for the storytelling, but for like the actual functioning of people and characters.
1:12:07 No, you and I both know the answer is no. But I think within the society and the way that everything is set up, absolutely, and it's going to and then it's going to keeping. Because achieving achieving goals is a disruption of norms, right, you have not you do not possess this goal. Therefore you will do things to achieve it that requires effort, that requires displacement of resources. And I guess, yeah, there's always going to be a power, desire for power, And however that looks, however it is disguised, it will still be that. Just it just looks different in different ages and eras, different contexts.
1:12:52 But did you like that Garth was loud? Though? Let's tell you what I did. Like here we go. When he is pretending to be Spock after Marda tried to stab Kirk. He says Aspock, she's worked out an infallible method for ensuring male fidelity, which is very funny that you just kill him. Also later he says to Kirk, you could serve as human sacrifice for the ceremony, and Kirk just looks because the whole episode has just been like what, And in that moment he just goes, No, I wouldn't enjoy that had at all. It's just so funny.
1:13:38 It was genuinely funny to me. You know what else that you would probably enjoy what. A long time ago started dating? This week, I quoted a boat, I dated a game, but none of them could work my drive into hyper space. The best of both worlds kept meet in the second place. Captain slog on a Holla kron. I wanted a song. I penned a song. Seventeen more minutes advise in Super High dev aboard the USS Enterprise dt F. Don't you take my walk lighter and clip it. Don't you take my wretchird buddy and nd bit. If you spill the tea, I'm gonna.
1:14:40 Sip it my starship it. What do we doing? Ah naming our favorite starships? That starship to this guy and starships that are ship and chipping relationships. Do you know how often decide this being something that I want to do? And I started, I forget. Find a ship asp Dan Webster, it's Humilie, right, yeah, could be if you wanted it to be. Could be texting what your middle name is. I don't want to say, yeah, okay, don't need to know it. I'll set you right now. I did it. I texted you.
1:15:24 Do you like it's close? It's got five letters. They both have vowelves. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, you go first. Oh, dear, we'll start with our we'll start starships of course, the big Honk and eight ship that the Separatists fly their droids down. Oh, it was so big, which look, it's an iconic ship from the Phantom Menace, their troop carriers. Oh, I'm thinking of later when they set up a whole big structure. Is that what I'm thinking of? Probably because they have it, because it's like they've got the ship itself, and you're like, cool, we'll go up. And then later on they're like looking out there and they're like, that's like they've set up a whole military compound. And I was like is that is that another giant that must be like a bigger ship.
1:16:13 My wrong, I don't recall I've only seen the episode once, and this is one of your favorite TV shows. I'm gonna have to ask you to provide your own clarifying whoa, whoa, So sorry. I know that I own Star Wars the Clone Wars season one on digipak, but there are limits of my knowledge unfortunately. Anyways, the Big eight Ship was thinking about this because one of the just the delightful things and the thing that I just enjoy about great starship design in general. I subscribed to the Rick Berman thought of designing spaceships, and I'm sure other people too make it to where like a twelve or thirteen year old can be able to draw this thing and one of the great things that and iconic things about the silhouettes of Star Wars, like great Star warships, the Millennium Falcon, the X Wing, the Tie Fighter, they have very clear shape that you can draw. Guest Star similarly the Trade Federation ship. It's like a death Star, but with a doughnut around it. Also like the Naboo, the Queen's Naboo Cruiser, just just like an SR seventy one Blackbird the Naboo star Fighters looks great. Pod racers kind of gets a little bit more difficult, a little busy, but still got the pod and two engines. Similarly, you got the big eight ship. It's a big H. You got your X wings, you got your Y wings, you got your H ship.
1:17:40 This is the ship that you're talking about, right, Yes, okay, sweet, that ship is so cool. It's so cool. It's just a cool, big H. It's fantastic, fantastic. Yeah, you're fantastic, thank you. Uh oh, I didn't prop I was so busy being annoyed. Let me think, there aren't really any ships in the There aren't really any ships in Star Trek episode. Huh Nope, there's like zero. Oh, so there's the Enterprise.
1:18:21 That's that's it. That's it. We just have the Enterprise as per usual. I'm gonna go I'm gonna be a little stinger. I'm gonna say it's uh Sakura because she's a vehicle for rescuing a clone trooper the Vine. Listen, I'm tired. I'm tired too. I'm tired. I'm tired. You did take the really cool ship though. There there's a Trade Federation tank with a big honking cannon on it. That was sing about one too. I really liked that one.
1:19:02 But I think a vine is funny. Vine. Yeah, the they have a bunch of Really we didn't even talk about George. We no another thing. Yeah, what I mean, he's having a he's just having a great possibly more lines in this one episode than possibly all of his episodes and all of his appearances, and see the three put together in this one episode. It's fantastic. It's it's it's a very delicious performance. The design of the Nimoidian, who they talk about on the follow rezoning, is like, you know, there's it's it's a third design that they make. And there's another one in a character that'll show up later that looks a lot like new Gun Ray. So they went with a different shape. And he's a jubby guy.
1:19:55 He is a big boy. He's a big bo the big hat. It actually took me a couple of lines in to realize it was George d Kay and I just got really I got really excited, and I yeah, he's having such a good time. He's truly having a like he's doing that, he's doing the like chew the scene work kind of thing. As a voice actor, I just think it's fantastic lock dirt. Not to be confused as I did during the episode with Lot Dodd, another voiding character. Yeah, or confused with block Turd, which is what I thought. They can't say, which. Is wild and a lot Dodd was named after the then GOP Senate leader in nineteen ninety seven, Trent lot An attempt to directly connect the Trade Federation's characterization of Motus with that of the Republican Revolution that occurred in nineteen ninety four.
1:20:46 Yeap, that is neoliberalism too hardcore? Is that is? Because that's where it started to kind of you know, get the contraction and then it reaches its sort of apex with uh, you know, a rock and Afghanistan like it's it's full execution through Cheney and anyway a fun times. Speaking of apex relationships, Uh, you know you know that Garth and Marta hooked up? Yeah? I guess what do you mean you guess? I mean they definitely did. He blew her up? But also this is a good ship because ships don't always have to be nice.
1:21:26 No. In fact that you know that they banged had a good time, and Garth was like done, I'm done. I know what everything looks like now I never need to care about anything ever again, ch I don't mind. Men are gross. I am gross. Okay, I don't know if that's hopeful. He the character is very very gross. Yeah, does that strikes an in character thing that would happen with Garth of Isyazar, famed captain hero of Accnar. Yeah, you're treacherous cow. It's really funny though.
1:22:08 Oh that's why Gartha byes are impression. It just sounds like uh, one of the Monty Python guys doing a lady. Oh yeah, you're absolutely right. That was like kind of my one because I'm feeling because I feel like we've done Kirk and Kirk before, right. Asphen I don't think so okay. During Kirk and Kirk, Kirk and Gartha's Kirk fantastic real real, like specifically Gartha's Kirk, not just Garth and Kirk, Like it's when he looks like him, because there's a whole Oh yeah, again, once again we need to talk about this where there's this whole like stupid moment at the end wrisk box like they do the whole like there's two of them, and it's like, Spop, I'm the real captain, right, You could literally ask any fucking question, like anything at all, Like that isn't the question he asked, and like you could get an answer. It could be like what did I like tell you yesterday morning about like my favorite you know what I mean? Like you could have said anything, and instead he just like lets them go at it.
1:23:28 And what did I make you for breakfast this morning because we slept because. We slept together. Yeah, it could be anything, and like he's just like, what what's the maneuver we used in this fight? And he like says one, and then real Kirk is like maybe real Kirk maybe not like and it's just like you know that that's like a very common one. It's just like, yeah, ask a different question. It's so stupid. And later and then they get to a fight and eats one of that's the whole thing. And later when he's like why didn't you and he's like, well, I was just gonna like wait it out and see, she's like what the fuck? Anyway, while they're fighting, it's actually a very impressive like fight scene, like truly with it being two Kirks it's actually probably that and Marty getting blown up are the two surprising things in the episode where I was like, oh, okay, something's happening.
1:24:17 I don't know. It's pretty sexy, that's all. That's what I'm getting at. Sexy, sexy cool. You know what else is sexy? Rating things because they are objective. Nomberds, No umbers, dude, going back to the central conceit of this podcast, which is better Star Trek or Star Wars by putting a numerical value from zero to ten on both of these episodes, to finally, without any bias, without any of these pesky emotions getting in the way, It's about cold, hard data. So let's supply our emotional rankings for these again. The episodes Whom Gods Destroy from Star Trek the Original Series, Season three versus Defenders of Piece from Our Worst The Clone Wars Volume one. I will go first, and I will start with Defense. No, I'll start with whom God's destroy and I will rank whom God's destroyed a sleepy four points zero yeah, four, sleepy, sleepy, sleepy, sleepy, sleepy.
1:25:19 I wish the performer that was, I wish the episode was better written and I think the actor that was playing Garth could have been great if it was just had a better structure to the whole darn thing, because the thing starts off emotionally at an eleven and stays there, and that's really frustrating. I think probably the same for the actor for Marta too, Mike. You can tell Yvonne Craig good. Yvon Craig, who famously played Batgirl in season three of the Adam West Batman Show. I was so, I was not far off, and I was like calling forth Joker and Harley Quinn vibes. Nope, that's wild. Actually, so Harley Quinn didn't exist. I know that, Kenny, just.
1:26:01 To be a boy about it and tell you and accuse you of not knowing comics? Didn't she first appear in the Batman TV show that I loved growing up? Was that the first time she showed up? Yeah? One written by the same guy who writes Who's to write for? He walks? And also that Clone Wars episode? Yeah, Paul, that's right. I did it. Thanks. I'm glad I could prove myself to you. Uh sure, yeah, you know that one fact. But do you actually recomment? No, I don't sorry, Okay, yes, so I also going to give it a four because nope, I'm gonna give it like a three point eight because at point to say it, that's that's me being that's me doing a spight ranking. It's both bad and a spy ranking excellent.
1:26:51 I hate tore it. That makes Whom God's Destroy a robust three point nine, but it's still anyone's game. Who is how we feel about these superb defenders at piece. What a great episode. Maybe there was something in here that you found offensive and you're gonna spite rank it. I don't know. I mean there you could talk about the fat phobia that's involved with LOCKDRD, and I think a more civilized age brings up some great points about uh Niemoidian depiction and casting George ta Kay as a flamboyant, overweight Niemoidian. But I you know what, I dug the heck out of it.
1:27:37 Actually had a thought where I was like, Linimoidians are like they historically have had such an offensive Asian, like weird Asian accent. It almost felt like it was like making up for that to be like, hey, let's cast an actual Asian actor, yeah and have him to speak the way he speaks normally. I think to be to say that it's offensive bea because George de Kay is playing a lock. Dirt is taking agency away from George de Kay. Possibly he made a choice. It's not like the dude has to do Star Wars. No, you can say no, he's the guy's got he's fine. Yeah, you know what else is fine? Defenders of Peace. I'm giving this one a nine.
1:28:18 Wow. I adore this episode. I think it's so thematically rich. I think the action is superb. I think it is asking a lot of good questions, raising even more questions, and ends the episode on a pointed question of who who Who are the real defenders of Peace? Although I think by having that ending it comes down on a conclusive answer for me, but also it could be left up to interpretation. What is great also is that you can have different readings of this episode. You can think that the metaphors are muddied because the extratextual evidence has been clear, and at the same time, whenever you are interrogating those metaphors, it can bring up new readings in the text, and that makes it a really wonderful piece of Star Wars for me. This is this is what I love. This is what I love whenever I can keep thinking about something afterwards and can get the passionate conversations about what the heck does this mean? What does this mean to me? What is this saying? Yeah, it's it's outstanding. It stands up there with Asha from Ewoks for me.
1:29:27 Well, that was a good episode, such a surprise. I'm but it's still anyone's game. If I gave the other one three point eight, I'll give us one eight point three. Interesting. I am more bullet tronic this week's Clone Wars than you are. Yeah, I mean I still really really love it and leave all of it a space because I uh and there's is more more to to play, spaces to go. Yeah, No, I mean it's an extraordinary episode. I don't think so extraordinary episode, So uh you know what else is extraordinary? Asthen Yeah, I take my hat off, hat in hand and I say, Star Wars, when's the week?
1:30:18 Thank you? I'd like to thank god. That is many weeks at this point where Star Wars has been winning handily. I think we have to go back one. Two, three, four, five, six, seven episodes. This is the age seven episodes, The Age of. The York, The Age of Man is in the Age of the York has begun. I'm the Ork Star, I'm New York interesting. But you know who aren't Orchisian appearance are patrons. Like we've mentioned many times in including the beginning of this episode, you can go over to patreon dot com slash track Wars and for at least a dollar.
1:31:02 A month did you will also go to Netflix and drop out and watch streaming television. You give a plug to Netflix. Netflix a great business model and there's no consequences for it. Oh god. So for a buck of month you can join our Patreon. We'll literally say your name uh. And for a higher tier you can get access to early versions of this episode and extended versions of these episodes, so you can join the fine folks such as Timbo Tososa, Heidi Rogers, Kevin Miller, Arizona, Mark Austin, Aaron and lastly, but certainly not weekly, Joelty partner who composed the I Starship at theme song. Mister Tosin Aurifeso composed our beginning and end theme.
1:31:49 If you don't want to get in touch with us via our Patreon, you can go to our social media Instagram dot com, slash at track Wars Pod, or find us over on Blue Sky. And you can also just send us an email track Warspod at gmail dot com. More than likely we will read your correspondence on the air. That's the kind of folks that we are. Aspen, thank you for being the Star Wars contingent so I can watch this fine, fine episode of Star Wars. You're welcome. I did it. It was me. You're welcome. You did it, it was me. And also you can join our YouTube YouTube dot com slash at trek Warspod where you can see Aspen playing with her cheeks for the past forty five Aspen, I love you.
1:32:41 I love you too, and listeners, we love you. Thank you so much for listening. May the Force be with you and live along and prosper s
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Spreaker
RSS Feed