Dec. 2, 2023

Wrath of Khan v. Empire Strikes Back

Wrath of Khan v. Empire Strikes Back
Wrath of Khan v. Empire Strikes Back
Trek Wars Podcast
Wrath of Khan v. Empire Strikes Back

It's a competition of second chapters with Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan VERSUS Star Wars Episode V: The Empire Strikes Back!

Kenny and Aspen are joined by noted Ron Howard lookalike (and good friend) Ryan Hill to discuss his personal experiences...

It's a competition of second chapters with Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan VERSUS Star Wars Episode V: The Empire Strikes Back!

Kenny and Aspen are joined by noted Ron Howard lookalike (and good friend) Ryan Hill to discuss his personal experiences watching these two films in the theater when they premiered. We also explore questions like: Do Jedis really embrace Buddhist philosophy? How can stories help us deal with the uncertainty of the world? And why the heck does Ryan like Rise of Skywalker?

_________________

Get early, extended episodes on our Patreon at https://www.patreon.com/trekwarspod

Theme by Tosin Awofeso

Social Media:
https://www.instagram.com/trekwarspod
https://bsky.app/profile/trekwarspod.bsky.social

Want to ask us questions? Email us at trekwarspod@gmail.com .

And leave us a review! https://bit.ly/leave-a-review-trek-wars

0:27 Welcome to the Track Wars podcast, the Internet's only source for answering the one question, the most important question and fandom, Which is better Star Wars or Star Trek. I am Kenny Madison, the Star Trek contingent with me, as we always to the co host with the host, ask my webster, and you are here, but you also represent intersectional post post third wave feminism. It's me representing Star Wars. Hey, you asked me, and you are correct, and we will get into all of that. And speaking of getting into all of that, we welcome. I guess so we've been scheduling, coordinating with for a while. We're very pleased to have you. Uh what what are your credits? Player in the band Fragile Rock, I do father lover frand future future therapist with both of you future therapists. That's right, Thank you remember that. Oh listen, I've been through it. I know you have. We havenaid you're your cautionary tale. Oh no, Ryan

1:57 M. Hill, thank you so much for joining us here on the Track Wars podcasts. You're welcome. I'm happy to be here. I feel so so so lucky that I'm here for these two films, Like I mean we spoilers, but we kind of coordinating these films for you. And also we're just pleased as punched to be able to talk with these as we pull a theme out of comparison episode as we talk Empire Strikes Back versus Star Trek two The Wrath of Khan. I genuinely think that this is like the cream of the crop of both franchises. Like for me, this is like probably the best of both franchises. So I mean, it's I don't want to make it be so absolute, but these two films are very high in either franchise for me. My dude, my dude was watching My guy, my Dudoni.

3:01 I was watching Empire rewatching last night and I just went, fuck, this movie is so good. And I'd watched I'd watched Rathacon a little bit back, and I also in the middle of that, went this is so good. So when I heard you guys talk about the motion picture, I have a huge soft spot for the motion picture, for Star Trek the motion picture, and so when I heard you guys talk about it, I was like, no, it's really awesome. I love that movie. And I was, and I was because I do, and and I was going on, and then when I was, and so when I kind of went into Rathakon, I watched it today and I was kind of like, eh, whatever, and oh my god, Wrath of Khn is so good good, It's just so good. And an Empire is like my favorite piece of Star Wars too, So yeah. One, and also I need to like, since you guys said you represent this, you represent that. I don't think I represent either Star Trek or Star Wars super strongly, but what I care you, but what I do is a bite. I know. I love it when you guys say that because I know because I know you're both that you're saying it with intense sarcasm. I love it when you guys say artist and binary. It's fine because even like Kenny, even when you do your

4:31 ship on Facebook where you're like rank your top blah blah blah, I'm like, I'm like, this is so fucking stupid. They all have different qualities. They're all you don't rankings are dumb, Like, I don't you know? That's that's me? Can you do that over on Facebook? He just texts me, I don't go on Facebook, so that's not why you just text me that I mean I can text you my rankings. I mean, well, no you you know all the time he's like, asks your top ten, this as your top ten, and I get it. What it is is it just a way to talk about the different qualities of the movies, and it's a weight and it's cool. It's fine, it's fun. But I think we can all agree that our subminary stinky dudek Rise of Skywalker was which one the last one? Ex Yeah, that's my favorite of the new ones anyway. Yeah, sorry. Star Trek two I really was released on June fourth, nineteen eighty two. Oh my god, I love this.

5:35 It was released when June fourth, nineteen eighty two, the famous You're in nineteen eighty two, That is right with nerd properties freshman year in high school, right, And that's that's something else I wanted to say. I definitely represent the like I don't want to say o G Star Wars Star Trek fan, because I don't want to be thought that I thought that I'm an asshole. But but like I saw Star Wars in the theater with my father. I saw Star Trek the motion picture in the theater with my father. I got familiar with Star Trek the original series, because my dad would watch it in syndication and I would sit next to him and watch it and like and then and I and I saw Rise of Skywalker in the theater with my dad sitting next to him, and that was like the last movie we saw together. So there you go. Oh fine, fine, I guess you can like that movie because of your emotional kind ofction. Pull up, It's okay. We got complicated feelings about things. Yes, art is sometimes subject and that's kind of like something I've been thinking a lot about when I'm thinking about talking to you guys, is that it's impossible for me to separate my experience of all these movies from the context of my whole fucking life. I mean, Star Wars taught me about interacting with fiction. I mean it like,

7:14 that's like that was what I grew up with, was Star Wars. Like when I first saw I waited in line for hours to see Empire Strikes Back on the day it came out nineteen eighty. Yeah, I was twelve years old and I waited for hours with my friend Sean o'reiley and he's little Irish and we and I was devastated at the ending, and I was shocked that Darth Vader was Luke's father. Oh sorry spoiler, but this is really helpful. I want us to keep talking about it. I was actually thinking that as I was rewatching it, because you know, I'm obviously seen it billions of times I was sitting I watched it once before. Yeah, for this podcast. Well, I was thinking about it because I knew. I knew Ryan that you had you wanted to do these films because of seeing them in the theaters and like seeing them with their dad and seeing them with your friends and how they struck you at the time. So I was very I was very specifically watching it thinking what would like baby ryan be feelings, And when he said no, I am your father, was like, this must have been the most incredible moment. Nobody I knew. It wasn't like now when there's like leaks and fandom and shit. Nobody fucking knew. Nobody knew.

8:37 Some people but not many people knew. Some people knew, and it it. I think I might have heard it before the film and not believed it. And then like, because Sean o'reiley, aforementioned friend, he was like any level of film geek and he actually Kubrick would have directed it better, exactly so, and I think Sean might have like read it in a fanzine or something that it was a rumor or something, you know, because and so anyway, but yeah, it was mind blowing, mind blowing. Ever seen anything like it before? So, yeah, this is great.

9:18 We'll talk, we'll talk. Yeah, we're we'll talk more about that. But also, real quick, real quick, your experience, your it's just just can you do quick how you felt if that was like mind blowing to you two years later when you watch Wrath of Cohn at theaters? How was that to you? Did? Okay, so this is the way Ethic con felt to me at the time, and it felt very different when I watched it today. But I didn't see it with my dad. I saw it on my I think. But uh, the the biggest thing in Wrath of kN was Spock's death. That was the biggest thing. Like that was the oh my god, Spock died, right, And that scene, of course is just like blow the top of your head off, right, but iconic scene. But I was actually, god, it's so hard to remember, you know, how fucking long ago this was. Yes, And I was fourteen and now you do math and that's why old I am, and so I think so to me. At the time, Ratha Khan felt thank you.

10:31 So to me. At the time, Wrath of Khan felt like like the motion picture felt very heady and very esoteric and very which I have a soft spot for. I love that stuff, right, and I love the long shots of star fields with weird music. I love that ship. Although I no longer do drugs anyway, But the most picture is a vibes movie, yes, and I love vibes, and so I felt like I think at the time that Wrath of con was a bit was a return to like fun action, which was simultaneously kind of cool and kind of a disappointment.

11:18 And it actually reminds me of more recent things in the film franchise where they where it's gotten more militaristic and more action oriented and less heady, which I do feel like is sort of a betrayal of the original Star Trek. But anyway, yeah, I know, but I have my own opinions. It's very odd sait, do you have okay right now? Right now, we have to do this thing. We have to do a real quick thing. But do you have opinions on the militarism and Star Trek. That's complicated, as I'm sure you're aware, Yes, so excited, and it's so weird too, because like, just through listening to this podcast, I feel like I have my appreciation for Star Trek has gone up. And and if I'm gonna be honest, like I was, Yeah, I was much more of the Star Trek Star Wars contingent when I first started this listening to y'all's podcast, and I feel like it's kind of evened out. Okay, well, Ryan, I've had to watch so many Walks episodes well and and okay, and I'll tell you what. I was really pissed off when you guys even deigned to include the Holiday special at all. Sorry, it's like the Cannon, It's ship and why would you include it, because because it's too it's

12:52 a part, it's part of the story of Star Wars, part of the story of Star Wars. You're right, because but I'm taking up too much space ahead, No, you're not right. You're great because the greatest film has retro actually been like curating parts of the Cannon. But like's at one point, like all of it was on the table, like all on the table, and Star Wars has been able to change so many times, and for me, the anthropological study of that, I hope that I'm using anthropological correctly. Probably not, but we're always but the Star Wars fandom is constantly trying to go back to that feeling in nineteen seventy seven. Constantly. Yes, Star Wars has been so many different permutations and permeations, but then it always always attempts to go back to that feeling in seventy seven. Yes, And that's what I love about knowing people like Aspen and my friend friend Cindy Page, who you also both know, because these are people women that a month they happen to be women that experienced Star Wars in such a different way than I did and later and and I love them both, and so when they talk about Star Wars, I have to like, like, it's like, I have to realize that my experience of Star Wars is not the only

14:24 one, you know, So it's yeah, so it's uh, it's it's cool to Cindy kind of taught me that and then listening to you guys on this she you know, we would have conversations about Star Wars and she would be like, Okay, let me tell you how I got into Star Wars. And she would talk about like the animated shows, and she would talk about comic books. And because she's lot, you know, she's like twenty fifteen, twenty years younger than me or something, and so so I had to like she taught me to like, oh not everybody like saw it in the theaters when they were ten years old, you know. So yeah, so yeah, yeah, and that my experience, even though it's very easy because you know, I saw it in the theaters when I was ten years old. It's very easy for me to like say that that's more valid somehow, but it's not. So you know. Yeah, speaking of valid, I think it is valid that, even though we are a ways in, I think we should do some quick synopsies and give some credits for these two pieces. Yeah. Yeah, I saw what was the when I was about to Okay, I didn't rewatch Empire because I've seen it so many times.

15:31 I wish I had, but I have two small children and I don't have time. But the synopsis was something like there was a two sentence synopsis on the Disney the Disney streaming thing like something like Luke Skywalker trains to be a Jedi. That was the second the second one. The first one was like the Rebels flee from the Empire and Luke Skywalker trains to be a Jedi. That showed me where, show me where it's wrong, actually where it's wrong. Very a very succinctcinct summary. Ah, you know, okay, I'll go ahead start well. Star Wars episode of five, The Empire strikes back, as you mentioned, a released June eighteenth, nineteen a d h RG director Ervin Kirshner and of course writers Lawrence Kasden, and the screenplay was Kasden and Lee Brackett, and of course the story by George Lucas. I'm gonna find there's a good one in here. I liked. I've gone so long with summaries by just whatever IMDb gives me for Ewoks that I'm just so pleased to have this back from Evan Almindo on IMDb. The legendary saga continues as the Rebel Alliance faces increasing challenges from the powerful Galactic Empire. Luke Skywalker, Han Solo, and Princess Leiragana find themselves confronting new trials that tests their courage, friendships, and beliefs true. The rebel alliance has estap a hidden base on the icy planet Apoth, where they hope to regroup and plan their next

17:03 moves against the Empire. Luke Skywalker receives a message from a familiar source, prompting him to seek further guidance and understand his connection to the Force. Han Solo and Princess Leia's journey takes him on a perilous path as they navigate through a galaxy under imperial control. This is funny. It is so vague you could rate this and literally be like what happens in this movie. Their actions and decisions lead to unforeseen consequences that will impact the fate of the rebellion. Meanwhile, the dark presence of Darth Vader looms as he relentlessly pursues the rebels while dealing with inner conflicts of his own. How fascinating. I wouldn't have thought to put it that way, Evan. Okay, it probably was why this's little wre specific, but I think we all know what happens and empires to expect. Indeed, Meanwhile, over here Star Trek two, The Wrath of Khan released June fourth, nineteen eighty two, directed by Nicholas Meyer, credited screenplay by jack Bie Sowers from a story by her Bennett jack Bie Swards, and uncredited Nicholas Meyer on that as well. From my plot synopsis by from Variety. Star Trek two is a very satisfying space adventure, closer in spirit and format to the popular TV series than to its big budget predecessor.

18:15 Story is nominally Squeal Go Ahead. It is so funny because it's literally based off of So was the first Yeah, well that's what I mean. I mean, sorry, Russia picture was actually Conn is Ryan Conn is like the continuation of an episode. Honey, We'll get into it. Story is nominally a sequel to the TV episode Space Seat, with Starship Reliant Captain Terrell Paul Winfield Commander check Off Walter Kannig incorrectly landing on a planet on an exploration mission. This allows the evil Khan Ricardo Montaban, who's around there with his family and crew fifteen years before by Kirk Walliam Shatner, to take over the Reliant and bow Revenge h Kirk Admiral Kirk is cooked to take command once again of the Starship Enterprise on a training mission, travels to the regular Space Station on the rescue mission doctor Carrol Marcus B. B. Beash and her and Kirk's son David Merret Beatrick. I've been working there on a Genesis project to convert Barren planets and the even sources of life. Cohn has stolen the Genesis effect equipment. Also, in the Final Realized, a classic of emotional manipulations, Spockgun hesitatingly calculates that he must sacrifice himself to say the Enterprise crew anyways, I start trek to the wrath of Khan. Anyway. That's it. And Ryan saw both of them in theaters. That's cool. I saw first release.

19:37 I saw Empire on a little VHS tape from Blockbuster and my tiny little TV. And that is also fucking cool. And I'm certain it really is. I'm certain that I watched both of these movies whenever I was like a newborn, right. I didn't see Ratha Con I think until my early twenties because my family had the the first five TS movies in a sick box set and those were just on rotation. And then not only that, but we had the Star Wars trilogy on one VHS tape and whatever. My mom would need to go do something of the other room and like take a shower or something, she would just put that on and I would watch Star Wars.

20:19 Star Wars the Star Wars trilogy was quite literally the first things that I watched. A you guys, my computer is unplugged. I need to stand up and it's gonna be a thing. So give me a couple of seconds here, Okay, we're gonna note it. We're gonna note it in the time. We're gonna note it. You noting it. I noted it too. Thank you, aspen Kenny. Oh my god. Uh so you being the Star Wars contingent, Uh you watched Star Trek two a while ago. In preparation for this episode, I did, what is your what is your history with this? With this movie? Uh? Yeah, I'm almost certain that I watched it in my early twenties. I think I've mentioned this that I came in to start right Star Trek because I was living in a lovely little home with four of my friends in Summerville, Massachusetts, and I we all really loved watching original series Star Trek, and so it must have been that in that time we watched we watched Wrath of Kahn, so I would imagine I was probably twenty three or something, but I so I remembered watching it.

21:47 I remember things as I was rewatching it. I remember thinking, yes, I've seen this before, and then I also remember thinking, damn, this is good. So that's mine. You. Yes, like this movie. I love this movie. This movie is I mean obviously im biased, yeah, but there is. I I'm very excited to talk about this movie. So I talked about this movie and just position with Empire Strikes Back. It's a stunning movie. Stunning both stunning. Both are what is interesting in doing the research for trying to find it for a synopsis for this movie. And I wanted to go back to see to just find a synopsis from back then. Yeah, and I pulled this from Variety. And what is interesting is to see critics at the time kind of dismiss it as standard popcorn fair.

22:47 Meanwhile, now in the current landscape of Blockbuster sin about this feels like water in the desert. Yeah, because of how articulate it is. I'm talking about starts, but also this could very much be applying to Empire Strikes Back in terms of how character first they are character forward, all of these decisions motivated by character decisions. Yeah, unless you need like a couple plat conveniences. Whether an empire is just the forest or Star Trek too, you just which is just like Genesis? Yeah, like things happened to be there because you want the characters to get back together. But other than that, never like a matt It is just wild that Star Trek two gets the formula right and is also a meditation on aging out of relevance. Dude, Okay, I forgot that that was the intense focus of this movie when I was watching today. I'm fifty five years old it and my dad died a year and a half ago. It was so intense, and my five year old boy was like coming in and out of the room and sitting down next to me occasionally while I'm watching it and seeing little parts of it and asking me about it. It was so intense watching it today, just because I forgot that it was about aging and facing death. It's about facing death. The

24:18 movie is it's like they it's the words are spoken and and it's about you've never faced death yes away? Well yeah, and it blew me away that. And it's also about fathers and sons, just like Emperor strikes back. Is it just general or you know he could even you should it should be generalized more too, just generational stuff, but it was. It's just it's just so fucking good. I'm gonna be very inarticulate. I'm just gonna be going like, it's, oh my god, they're so good. They're just so good. Look, I'm gonna jump to the thematic that is most common for me, the thing that first jumps to my mind with both of these properties, and both of these pieces are deconstructions of the formative piece of media that they are based on. Hear that again, Yeah, both of these pieces. Star Trek two and Empire are deconstructions of the formative media that these are based on. I don't understand what you're saying. I so if I let me see, let me say I got this. So if you I see so, they're so, they're so. Empire is a deconstruction of Star Wars of a New Hope and and Star Trek two is a deconstruction of the original series, or of you correctly being like, this isn't encapsulating the TV

25:52 series, And to a degree, you're right, what It is sequelizing. It is sequelizing the concept of Star Trek. It is taking the episodic formula of Star Trek and going those seventy nine times that Kirk flew away at the end or seventy eight. Seventy nine is the one Pike episode. But the seventy eight times that he flew away were actually him making mistakes, right because he never stuck around. Yeah, I agree, they are. I agree, And I think that's why they're both so successful is because they took the original thing and they did something more with it, and they and that's why I that's why I dislike so much of other parts about these franchises. But go ahead, Oh, this is really funny because can I just tell you, as I was rewatching Empire, and I wasn't thinking this is much for the Wrath of Gon because we don't have a well, I was thinking about it with Wrath of Gon because I was thinking about lower decks and how lower decks very purposefully. The whole point of it is its second contact. So it's after first contact they actually come back and there's a lot of kind of humor in the what has happened after first contact? Worthy effects so there is a commentary on it in the future. So I was thinking about these movies and current day, current day parts of their franchises and how they are then commenting on them, which they themselves were commenting on earlier forms of them.

27:25 And I do think that there's an interesting conversation though, and so those kind of things like lower decks with this and others. Of course, that's playing with it and making fun of it. Frankly, last Jedi is in a deconstruction. I think of a lot of stuff that happens in Empire, and so I do really like a deconstruction because I want to know what you believe in. I want to know. And I think that especially with something like Star Wars, it has that we have a tendency to wax on about the space opera grandness of it. And I think that we've talked we've talked about this when we're talking about Empire before. Of like it made people feel uncomfortable. It was not so precise in terms of it's nice, like kind ending and part of our hero's journey. It was it hurt. You imagine imagine imagine baby Ryan, Imagine twelve year old Ryan going to see that movie after being a humongous Star Wars fan. He is twelve years old. He sees the end of that movie. I was I That's why it's so hard for me to separate it from its context, because it had such a huge influence on me, Like I was so hurt and confused and just like didn't know and then I and then I ended up loving it, Like, oh, can you say more? Okay? Yeah, what did that process look like for you? Oh? God, it's I don't remember all of it, but let me let me see if I can, baby Ryan Baby, Yeah,

28:59 right, plus years ago, Ryan. And it's hard to remember things for that long ass when you don't know that yet, but you will. I mean, I don't know. I have like an eighteen year old in my m BROV class and she was saying stuff and I was like, I have no idea what you're saying to me. And I just watched you do a cart already weird, aren't you? Are you in your thirties? Yeah? Can you try the same ash? Okay? Are you guys like mid thirties? Yeah? Okay, all right, thirty five, thirty four okay, okay. I got about twenty twenty years in it. But so, but it's also wrapped up in all this. Like I was in high school and I was studying literature and I ended up getting an English degree, and so I'm like, well, this is when I yeah, right, this is when I become the part of Kenny that I find so annoying. But I'm just kidding. I'm just kidding, but this is when I but like I actually study the hero's journey in English class, like and so you know, all that all that stuff that supposedly George was so into and everything and so the which now I study in psychology classes. But anyway, it's it's so hard to I like, I think the most the like sort of least generous to myself interpretation I could give of that process that you're asking about,

30:30 Aspen is that I had to like Star Wars and so I figured out how why the Empire strikes back was awesome because I had to, And it stuck, and it's stuck with me my whole life. And that's why it's impossible for me to separate out context. Like I still to this day have a really hard hard time with happy Hollywood endings. Of course, when I was a kid, I loved them right, and I think the Empire stracks back was the turning point was when I started to appreciate something other than happy Hollywood endings. And and also when I started to see, God, this is this is getting big. But when I started to see that life was not a happy Hollywood ending, that you could lose your hand and find out your father was an asshole. It was it was like you that it was.

31:32 It was so big in my in the formation of me that it's like so hard to like, yeah, anyway, you look like you really want to speak, so no, no, no, I'm just having a lot of emotional reactions. It's just it was so big, like I I and I don't know that that like I do, like I said, that's the least generous interpretation to myself that I could give, and I don't know that it's true, like one hundred percent. I think that's definitely part of what was going on. It could also be argued that, like I was just maturing and recognizing that, like recognizing that happy endings kind of leave something to be desired. It's like they're just not like they're not it's easy to relate to because life is not a happy ending. You know it's like that's and so that's why Empire was so formative for me. I mean, I think this speaks to the intent of both of these films, radically attempting to emotionally ground the characters and something that is less space opera ish and more make them real.

32:44 Yes, I don't want to say make them real, because realism is not necessarily emotionally honest. But that's just me interesting hmm. Okay, we'll have to have that conversation emotional things that feel emotionally honest and mapping things you are correct to things that are a lot more emotionally recognizable Aspen. You sent me a Textbasters, and I've been eager to dig into this because not only are these pieces deconstructions of the formative pieces that they are based on, but also another reason that I wanted to pair these two things together, along with being far and away considered the best pieces of these franchises by Rubes like Ryan, I know what I'll take it. I'm totally fine with it. By the way, for people that are just listening to it, Ryan has a big honkin dunce cap so weird. I actually do have on a shirt that says cotton Head and Nie Muggins right now, So there you go. But Aspen you texted me, and I also just wanted to talk about this because in our first episode of Empire, where we cover Empire versus where no man has gone before, we did not cover the fact. And we can talk about this in Juxtpie with Wrath of Khan. Both of these films, the people that are in charge of them, that are driving them creatively, are

34:16 not the creators. They are not the people in the chart. They are people who, in Empire's case, create a control was delegated, or in Wrath of CON's case, the creator was pushed out of the room, literally pushed out of the room. Was executive wasn't even executive producer on it was like an executive consultant, yes, which ultimately means that like they sent him a script, well, he gave some notes and then they just didn't them. They did take some of them. He did give a note about things being too militaristic, and they dropped things like salutes and because of him, because he for what it's worth, there were some like there were pieces that while he you know, has his own opinions on things like he's looking toward that optimistic future, and he's saying, like, if we portray it as a militaristic organization, like it's not like truly so like I mean beyond what has been done already, like we've talked about in so many episodes, but this one codifies it. Yeah, bring brings the military stuff to the four so much. And also Roden Berry and the TV show is very much cherry picking how much of a military is true because the thing is a paradox word is both anti authoritarian. Yeah, and also there's a rank structure that is so rigidly followed unless it doesn't fit. I constantly complain about it, and

35:50 they intentionally set it up as a conflict. I mean, this movie was about a conflict between the military and a civilian you know. True, but but it was but interestingly it but it was a false conflict. It wasn't you know, it wasn't like like at the end, David says, you know I was wrong about you, you know, and it's a beautiful moment about your dad speaking dads. Yeah, so oh yeah, surprise, Dad won't even get me started surprised, and I realized I got off of Kenny's a little kind of topic a little bit, but yeah, it is in the sense that really truly, all Geene Roddenberry had was the fact that he could give some notes and they could take them if they wanted. And because the motion picture was forty four million dollars financially, it did okay, but to that point it was the most expensive film that had ever been so in order for Paramount to justify its success, it needed to be a colossal hit, and it was just a hit. But they wanted to do something Star Trek related, and so they were like, thanks, goodbye. And then they brought in TV producer Harve Bennett, who was like, for the price of the motion picture, I could have made five Star Trek movies. It goes to watch every single Star Trek episode is just like, what makes us

37:22 think tick? The answer is the triumphrate and con and then brings on Nicholas Meyer, who was like, oh, this is Horatio Hornblower in space and is able to recognize all the influences that rodden Berry had while also bringing in their own history and are able to distill it into a two hour piece that feels like what the populace at that point felt like Star Trek was this intangible thing what Star Trek. Yes, and it also took Star Trek, like you said before, it took Star Trek to a whole nother level. It deconstructed it. It showed that, I mean, Kirk has a son, Spock dies. It's like, you know, even even Chekhov, like you know, isn't he Chekhov his first office around a new ship. It's like they all these all these things. It took it to a completely new new level. It does feel very much like Star Trek in a really great way.

38:30 And then it also is like a whole nother thing, which is exactly the way Empire, well, very similar to the way Empire feels towards Star Wars. So the weirdest thing is that the like what this is closest to is stuff like pardon the comparison, but like returned to Gilligan's Island, I cannot pardon that com That's okay, okay, sounds great to me. There is no reason that Star Trek two should have exists the way that it does because it's a TV It's a campy TV show, like styrofoam sets and actors that were kind of type cast as they were, and then like the closest analogy to something like that happening to that point, it was like TV movies where they get the cast back together and things are different, but they're trying to recapture the old magic. Compare that to this. Okay, Okay, now I get it all right, welcome. I mean this is a far more literate, articulate, emotionally impactful version. I think I watched Return to Gilligan's Island, but anyway, I mean, honestly, who didn't. Yeah, Losers, Losers Island. Whatever, it's great, not important. The point is is that we got something that, quite honestly, is probably better than we deserved by having something that is looking at the archetype of something that

40:00 is referenced frequently and making up materials is Sherlock Holmes and who is Sherlock Holmes without a mystery? So too is this story looking at James Kirk being like who is Janes Kirk without a space Adventurer? And then they dare, yeah, they dare to age the characters, they dare to change the status quo. Do you think this is a measure of not being so precious about Okay, Yeah, it's like Jane Roddenberry is precious about his characters, his stories. George Lucas precious, could be very precious. I mean at the time, I'm sure was just as much precious about his character, his stories and what does it mean to come in and respect that and then as been we'll remembering George Lucas well, That's what I was. You pair this with the fact that Lucas was kind of involved with the Holiday special but not really.

40:57 Yeah, and then exactly where you're getting to ask, but the fact that Lucas was kind of like, I care about Star Wars, but I care about this other stuff more. Yeah, Lucas and Runberry both seem to me to be like, and this is true of almost everyone. They need a team. They're so much better with a team, and like, on their own, they'll screw it up the like I mean, you know, Star Wars was saved in the edit. Everybody knows that now, and it's like they so it's almost like this huge and it's not saying anything bad about them at all. They're these amazing visionary creators, but it's kind of like a CEO or something or terrible analogy, but they need everybody around them to to to They're only one piece of it, you know. I think that's a really good analogy. Actually, Like Kenny and I were just talking CEOs well, I mean, and you should well, Kenny and I were just talking about it. He was asked me like, how do I feel about uh, oh my god, help Kenny? Why is he? Why is star Trek? He was about Star Wars? Uh sorry, Clone Wars creator, a SAC creator? Why the world? Yeah? Sorry, say it again, the chief creative officer for Star Wars. Yeah. And I was saying, you know, I think there's plenty of stuff we can say. But what I started thinking about was the fact that, you know, we look

42:30 at a lot of art and we just see, okay, those creators. We think about tours, We think about people who are like directorals and the actors and stuff, but things are a lot more like the way an organization runs, right, Absolutely, And so I'm actually pretty pros s Dave Filoni. Things. I'm like, listen, you also go for people who are easy to work with, who will listen to other people's ideas and maybe shift and use lots of things. Right, So I actually do think thinking about the way that these things are made more in the way of like a CEO and managers and stuff is actually really helpful to understand it better, you know what has So I'll sit and watch movies with my five year old. We've watched a lot of Studio Ghiblie of course, because that stuff is amazing and so and so we sit and watch that. And Dylan, five years old, loves to watch credits. I don't know exactly why. He can't read, but he sits and watches credits and he asks me to read names and I'll read Japanese names, which is hilarious. And he and I told him, like, these are all the people that worked on the movie. And there's hundreds, thousands of people. It's not it's a huge undertaking, and it's a I mean, it's so collaborative. It's amazing that it even comes off as well as it does. It's and just seeing him, you know, teaching someone who knows nothing about this kind of stuff that it's taught me like, oh, yeah, there's thousands of people working on these They're huge

44:04 organizations. They're they're companies that you know, last for five ten years to make a single film. Yeah. Anyway, yeah, well, no, I do. This is a fascinating comparison because we talked about Phantom Menace versus Motion Picture, right, and I think that is a true example of the two creators coming back and trying to kind of reclaim this thing up theirs. And this is sort of this is different. This is Jane being pushed out, and this is Lucas being like, yes, you know, these are too well made, excellently made pieces of IP management. Yeah they are, and they're I think they're the best and most thoughtful pieces of IP management in each franchise. I mean. And because they had someone that cared about storytelling from the outside. Yeah, because it's really easy to try and make an argument of well they brought someone from the outside, that's not it necessarily.

45:13 Oh, sometimes an outsider is exactly what you need, almost definitely. But whenever it's an outsider that is also given the room to tell a story that they care about using the toys that you like, then you were able to get you were able to synthesize something new and meaningful. Hey that'spen mark the time. Uh, I want more time with you guys, and we have thirteen minutes, I know, can we like maybe continue this another time, Like, it's just just something to think about. Yeah, I think so I've barely touched. I know you've barely touched. It's hard when there are three people or more than two people. I found it typically has gone way like like at least up to two hours or at least an hour and a half. So I would be okay with that anyway. Yeah, just something to think about. Yeah, yeah, well, let's let's make the most of our time until nine o'clock and then we can continue the discussion and then we'll discuss. Right, you have to go do improv and then we'll deal with that later. Okay, can I can I call back? I don't want to get off this if you're not done with this, Kenny, I just want to I'm so fascinated by both properties being these stories that are telling us that our heroes maybe aren't perfect, that our stories are hard, that

46:49 maybe they don't always turn out great. And of course the right kind of does turn out pretty well at least I'll a hero. But but Spock dies, and yeah, that's rough. I mean, it's the two archetypes looking out on a blossoming galaxy or a blossoming planet looking at the possibilities that are available towards them, and Kirk's final line of young, I feel young because this sensation of loss is new to him, the way that this loss, yeah is And not only that, but both of them put both stories. Where Wrath of Coon is a deconstruction of the Horatio Hornblower Charlotte Holmes, at least within the contributions with Nicholas Meyer, deconstruction of that archetype, so too is Empire Strikes Back, and we touched upon this on our first Empire episode, but deconstruction of the Joseph Campbell mono myth type hero and also, from what I understand writer Lawrence Kasdan, a thing to bring in more Eastern philosophy, specifically Buddhism, within building out what Jedi and the Force mean to it, and from a Western perspective, because Ryan, perhaps you could talk a

48:21 little bit more about this, but this this as an actual Buddhist, as an actual Buddhist, this notion of trying to certainly no more than certainly no more than me. But like Aspen talked about in the first episode, it's really difficult to be like, you have to let go of emotion, you have to let go of all of these things. Oh, I am literally even I've watched Empires so many times. Every single time, I'm like, this is fucking stupid, this is wrong. It is still because you're a that's because you're a trained therapist and what I mean, that's part of it, but just because yeah, it's it's an it's a stupid, inhuman thing to ask people to do. And that's interesting being called an actual Buddhist.

49:10 I haven't meditated in so long. You guys am like embarrassed. But anyway, well you do have two children, thank you. I appreciate that. It's that is such a great all purpose excuse, by the way, But uh so seeing this when I was twelve years old, seeing Empire when I was twelve years old, when you were twelve Empire, yes, I did interesting and the so as the I am your father was mind blowing. The cave scene was incomprehensible right and terrifying, to be fair, it is a very dark scene, very physically goddamn. But but the whole it's like, even now I think about all the possible things that that scene could mean, you know, I mean, it's like there's all kinds of different and of course as a you know, a twelve year old, I'm like, what does it mean? Because it's got to mean one thing because it's a binary, but you know, and it means all kinds of things. But the so Buddhism, you know what, It doesn't take me to Buddhism so much, although I do, I have really appreciated Aspen you representing the whole side of like as a human being, you can't let go of emotions. That's it makes you inhuman, which, by the way, I don't know if you're aware of this, but that's a big theme of Star Trek as well,

50:45 the uh, the uh and in fact, God, this brings up so much for me. My brain is going all over the place. But the one I'm gonna go back to Star Trek the motion picture for that, I apologize, Yeah, I don't know, but we're going back to the motion picture. You can't you can't reference It's not like I've literally referenced everything else. Besides so the scene where Spock goes you know, times his space suit and everything and goes into Nigure right and in my and this was the scene that I remember my father's reaction to the best and we spoke about it afterwards, and his reaction to it was that Spock determined that this thing Vegre had no emotion, that it was like perfectly logical, and it was and that was bad. Like, so Spock was questioning his whole philosophy, right, That was my father's interpretation of it. Uh and uh, which I h I wanted. I haven't watched the motion mixture and along time, I'd like to go back and see because because fuck's like laughing after he comes out of Vegure, if I remember correctly, he's like what he's he's smiling and he's going I should have known. Yeah, he's crying. Yeah, he's

52:16 feeling, and he grabs he grabs Kirk's hands and he's he goes this this simple feeling. It's beyond Veature's comprehension exactly. And so my dad, well, my dad interpreted that as you know, things without emotion. I think the youth word he used is worthless. You know that it's not you know, and so, which is a very like God, I could go on, we don't want to get into me and my dad, but very valuated. But yeah, too much so that that relate to me, relates to the Jedi and how like you are, and also to Buddhism in that you can't if you detach yourself. There's a wise way to detach yourself, and there's an unwise way to detach yourself. That that is what. That is what my favorite Buddhist teachers would say. That's what tik not Han would say, who is like his whole thing was engaged Buddhism. You know, you don't if you detach yourself too much, you've lost your humanity, you've lost your connection. And Star Wars is all about that. Like Darth Vader, I mean he's literally lost his humanity. He's made of mechanical parts now.

53:37 And Luke loses his humanity a little bit because he loses his hand and it becomes because that's the last scene in Empire is where you see his mechanical hand right, which takes me to Tolkien. And like in Token, the symbol of everybody having to pay a price is losing losing an appending some time. No far I took it too far. In our very first episode of this podcast, I accidentally said Peter Jackson instead of George Luke very similar. That's it, but you could also I mean yeah, yeah, I can pull in Harry Potter or two if you want, but we don't have to.

54:20 I I I this. Yeah. I complain about this constantly because I think it is a bastardization of an idea of of Buddhism and Eastern philosophy, of the idea that Buddhists are completely detached from their feelings is false, That is not that is an unwise way to be detached, And any good Buddhist teacher will tell you. I mean, I wonder if these notions that were being weaved through Empire were far more subversive at the time versus now forty yeah on, oh yeah, definitely. Well, I'm no, I'm forty three years on where it is just now baked into the text, and so we are able to project whatever, don't you dare say, forty three years on?

55:12 Forty three years years? I mean, you're certainly right, Kenny, and I think a lot of times what we are talking about is what was this like in the context of it when it came out? How was it? I'm sure it was. I mean again, you were you were there, Reagan was president. Reagan was president. That makes it. No, he wasn't president yet. Oh it was eighty one. Eighty one. Oh oh, this came out in eighty President took office in eighty one. Okay, no wonder the military stuff would have been foregrounded so much in Ratha, and no wonder that the notions of trying to uh have a victory for the collective versus the personal victory, which is what Luke is fighting for or fighting, not fighting for but fighting against. Star Wars is a catharsis a personal victory that has happens to be tied into Luke's desires for personal growth and that happens to just tie in with collective growth. I just don't agree with that, though, I genuinely do think that Star Wars is about collective acts. I think you're correct. I think that's what it becomes. Absolutely Yeah. Here's here's one of my big gripes with Star Wars and why stop it, stop it? I love You're gonna get your bone sucked out? And why I love a film that I can't remember the name of at this at this very

56:42 moment because I'm very I forgot dave name Star Wars. Star Wars. Uh. My second favorite Star Wars Rogue one. It's Rogue Thangue one. Thank you. Yeah, I know you don't like Rogue one, Kenny, but you're wrong. So the the reason why I love Rogue one, and one of my big gripes about Star Wars is that it it so many people die in the wars that happen in Star Wars. So many people suffer, and all of the focus is on these few people, right, these few heroes who happen to have the Force or something like that, you know, or whatever, and all these other people who die are ignored. And that's why Rogue one is so awesome is because it shows the people who die so that those other people can be heroes. It's amazing, the whole thing, through and through every bit of it. I agree with Kenny, But what you're talking about is an idea, right, is exactly right? Thank you.

57:47 I knew, I knew you. I knew, but I don't like rog Okay, well, we're gonna we're all gonna, we're all gonna continue this later. I remember where we stopped with was me starting to get into the background of urban Kirshner. Okay, yeah, why didn't you give us a little Irvan Kurshner, give us like like a touch of the touch, like give us a little bit of a curseh. Just a CURSEH. So like Nicholas Meyer coming in and like Harve Bennett coming in, Lucas burned out and it's focused on the business acpect of things. And so he goes to Urban Kirshner. I believe it was his old professor from USC cute, and it's just like, do you want to direct to Star Wars? Do you want to direct to Star Wars? Exactly like that, and curse is just like me, you want me to direct to Star Wars. I forgot that was his voice. He just talks like that, This is right, that's right, that's right, because last time we talked about this, kiddy, we were like, we should do a show where it's like one of us is George, the others cursed. It's me. I'm Urban Kirshner. You might have seen one of my films, Empire Strikes Back, perhaps Never Say Never Again or Robo Cop too, a little bit of the Yeah, yeah,

59:22 that sounds I really appreciate your work pretty great. Go uh so anyways, wait with the James Bond movie. Yes, correct say Never Again? Fine? You know what I really want to know how did the script get written? How did the script get written? Uh? They Lucas writes out a story out and I'm pretty sure brings in Lay Bracket, who is known for such films as The Long Goodbye, The Big Sleep, and from what I understand, UH is also just a writer of Western She's a classic Hollywood writer. Uh, and has brought in to work on the first draft or two, and then she gets sick so she cannot finish work on it. At the same time, Steven Spielberg and George Lucas are working a Ragers of the Lost Ark, and I have their other guy, Lawrence Kasdan, in the story conferences, which you can find the transcripts for that was Kasden sound like Actually he kind of sounds like Ryan. That's not even a bit huh.

1:00:32 Oh my god. This is their new stage production Kirshner, Kasden, and Lucas. Everybody says, I sound like Ron Howard, so it's uncanny. Actually he didn't. Okay, oh I got it. Well, I was saying it like the rest, I got it. I guess, Oh, actually he didn't. You do have a Ron Howard vibe to you, kind of like, well, yeah, I'm also a ginger like Ron Howard. In high school. My nickname was rich Genningham Bice by the by some of my fellows. So there you go, fellows. It's cute. Yeah.

1:01:13 Actually, if i'm if I'm completely honest, the black guys from pe Glass they called me Richie Gunningham, So there you go. Yeah, very directed, you know, it's right, Okay, it was, but it was nice. So that interludes allowed me to do a little bit of research on Lawrence Kastan, who was a working screenwriter and had written a script called Continental Divide, which is made by Ryan's favorite actor or eventually gets translated into a movie Strying. Ryan's favorite actor John Belushiu and Steven Spielberg likes that movie so much, rather likes the script so much he brings Kasdan Inn to work on Rags to the Lost Arc with him and Lucas, Right, and then from those story conferences are going so well, George Lucas says to Lawrence cast and asked them, what does he say, do you want to work on this movie? Yeah? Exactly, the next the next Star Wars, the next pect Star Wars, Yes, the next pick War of the Stars. And that's what happens. I mean, Kastan writes a scription and then Irvin Kershner and all the actors are very much just like he. They're talking around it, but they're like, this is a better experience. They're working with George Lucas, because where on the first movie Lucas is kind of cold and distant, and his direction was faster and more intense, nothing really more articulate than

1:02:43 that. Kersh that's what I call him, and that's what they call him, works with the actors to build up more naturalistic rhythms and you can see that, and it's obvious. So I finished watching Empire today and I got it. I mean the moment when Luke when Vader says he's his father and Luke's reaction, I mean, it's really good. The way Mark Cammeil reacts as really good. For Mark Hamel's it's really good. Oh, it's fabulous. I'm totally with you. There's a lot of exchanges that, like, even like the Han solo stuff, Like everything with Harrison Ford in this film is just exceptional. Oh my gosh. I totally forgot to mention that Carrie Fisher did an uncredited pass on all of the dialogue of course she fucking did that is my mom right there. She did what Cary Fisher did, an uncredited pass on all of the dialogue. Oh so she she had input on all the dialogue. Yeah, oh that's awesome, which makes sense because uh yeah, she's a fabulous writer, so good, a good puncher upper and that it says a lot. It's like you can feel it. I was all of the Dieu. That was another thing I noticed again on this billion three watches. I was like, this is so naturalistic, so human, so funny. Oh god, so yeah, it's very funny. It's very funny. And of several of the things I noticed on this, one of

1:04:15 them was holy shit, Haunt Solo was a creep. That one that one I saw more clearly than I ever had before, because you know, in like eighty whatever it was eighty eighty two, eighty eight eighty when this came out, like you know, it was all just like oh, especially because I was a twelve year old boy, but like it just wasn't like seeing it now is like so grating. You're just like, dude, stop so annoying. Another thing I noticed was the the funniness. But the another big thing was so many gigantic firsts in this like first appearance of you, Hello Yoda, first appearance of Boba Fet, Hello Boba Fet not first appearance, yes, fuck, that doesn't count first appearances. Absolutely, it's a really good cartoon. It's like one of two things in the holiday special letter, Good well, Ryan, you're a fan of heavy metal. What is great about the cartoon? I don't remember that part, but I'm the story, the story of the Faithful Wookie is that the designs are very much inspired by

1:05:46 Immobius. It is a wild looking cartoon. Cool. It's like, I'm so glad for you. Wow, it's like pulling out that there but stuff again. He's just like that sounds like something you love but with your mother. But like but like just you know, Boba Fett, slave one, Chasing Hant, like all this iconic shit that. Oh and something I wrote in my I wrote in my notes was the the hybrid drive on the Millennium Falcon not working never gets old is a bit fault. They totally abuse it too, they use it so many times. But I like that way.

1:06:40 We went from being like we have to be so specific about the cordinets because if we just like jump who knows where we could end up, and now we're just like good to forget here. Another scene that was huge for kids at that time. You briefly see the back of Vader's head right right without his helmet, right. Yes, And at the time that was such a big deal because honestly, I'm a little bit embarrassed. But like, we weren't even sure if he was like a robot or not. We didn't know what he was. We didn't know who he was. Why was this imposing? You know, we didn't know he was anakin. We didn't know any of that shit. And so to see exactly so to see that he was a human inside that suit, that's the first time you realize that he's a human. So yeah, for sure, so good. It's like absolutely fabulous.

1:07:32 And it's like you can see even like the officer who sort of sneaks a glance and kind of is like whoop, you know, like I've seen something I shouldn't have seen. I think, Ryan, there might be a slight lag there is, okay, but there I'm there's especially a video lag from you guys to me. But but that was that wasn't fairly in But yeah, you guys are lagging a little bit to me. But oh, and first appearance of Yoda. I mean, I hope he wasn't in the Holiday special, but you know, just amazing that the mind blowing like and when and you don't really I mean, I think I had heard beforehand from like my film savvy friends about what Yoda was going to be like, but like, there were a lot of people who went into that movie and they didn't think that the little green guy was anybody until the big reveal came that he was actually Yoda, you know, So yeah, yeah, that's so like h because it's so funny because having seen a Phantom Menace first before I saw the original three, right, I knew right, and like I knew these things, and I knew about Anakain and stuff. I just can't even obviously, there's so much that was a joy like a first view, but I can't even imagine like that being such a huge like these being just these wild moments. It's also so thematically relevant because way are Star Wars. The motion picture is an affirmation of the hero's journey. Even though it is indirectly

1:09:09 lifting from Joseph Campbell not consciously, it still fits into that mold and then Empire strikes back. Is okay, you were the hero, but now everything is some sort of subversion of how yeah, if you are truly serious about wanting to be on the selfless path, if you are wanting actual strength, here's what it looks like. Case in point, Yoda's size is relevant to the themes that Empire is talking about, which is that's great, that's fabulous.

1:09:51 So I actually while I was watching, I was feeling mad for you, Aspen for the same because the same happening to Luke here that happened to Anakin in the prequels, the same thing. Like, it's a totally reasonable human thing for him to want to do, to go off to save his friends who are being tortured for the purpose of bringing him there, and and basically Ben and Yoda ask him to sacrifice them. They basically are like, you know, if they die, they died, this is more important, And he's like, fuck that. And it's a very strong argument that he made the right choice, you know, And even if you look at how the story plays out, he still probably made the right choice. Like he goes and he takes care of his friends who are in trouble. You know, like they're asking for a level of detachment that I think is like inhuman you know. And that theme, that theme about the perfect that theme exists as far back as Arthurian legends. The same thing happens in the Nights at a round table, the perfect Nights. I can't remember who the perfect Night is, but the Perfect Nights are so perfect that they're not human anymore.

1:11:03 They they'll make they'll make the right choice, but it seems incredibly cold and distant because it's pure morality and there's no there's no humanity in it. I mean, you take that's textually what this movie is talking about, just as Star Wars two, and it would be it would also be interesting because it does eventually end up being the right decision. And also, like we talked about in a Return of the Jedi episode, uh almost a year more than a year ago. Actually, uh, that movie is of course, correction, because this movie went over like a pile of cold rocks a little bit.

1:11:48 Ah, yes, a pile of cold rocks a very classic, very classic phrase. Uh yeah, well okay, oh sure, this is again a Dans saying sorry, I'm interested in a couple of things here. Sorry, that's why I short circuit it. One is the uh, I feel like I don't want to I don't want to get too much into Like I know, I already started this by giving comparisons to last Jedi, but a strong comparison here happens for me where it? And again we should just do a total episode on that comparison. But it's very hard to watch your heroes make mistakes, yes, and I don't. I love watching heroes make mistakes me because because then I can relate to them. Yes, then they're a fucking human being, exactly and exactly, and I'm not a hero. It's why I don't like Superman because he never Okay, that's that's a whole nother thing. I don't want to get into it. I don't want to like it my favorite. But it's like, there's these heroes that are so heroic that they're not I can't relate to them. It's why I shipped marvel In not DC. But anyway, can I choose DC not Marvel? And but you're wrong, so you know, except for you know, the Snyder verse for you, No, I it's very much like and I don't even think that Luke leaving is a mistake, because I've said this plenty of times that

1:13:21 this is a failed pedagogy. Uh, Yoda's a terrible teacher, and this is not how we do this, Like you're getting excuse me. My driver's ad teacher taught me the exact same way. I gotten a little backpack while I was driving a jeep around high school. He told me to close my eyes and feel, don't think, and so I eventually I'm but Aspen, Here's the thing. Though they did let him go, they like they warned him against it, but they also kind of knew he was going to do it, and then so it's kind of like how you know, well, and they made him feel shitty and like he's not supported and can he actually turn to them, which is its own kind of thing. But I do think I do think that there is like maybe like viewers in general, if you're thinking about this hero's journey and you want your luke to be infallible, and I feel like you see it happen now people don't like these stories because their luke is not infallible, And I'm like, I'm sorry, did you see the same character that I did? Like that's a person who but also to even say that love isn't it makes you fallible? I mean it does.

1:14:40 I mean that's part of it is that it's exactly like you're saying, is that I want you to be human much like Star Trek, right, I want that. I want the experience of space and its isolation to show me what it is to be a human again, to go through the humanity and what it means to experience these things. The Empire eventually becomes the best Star Wars by popular consensus. Y Star Trek two is pretty quickly viewed as the best Star Trek period, except for a smattering of critics who are just like, yeah, this is you know, it's shlock lasers. Yeah, uh, I'm wondering through this lens of power fantasy. Because one of the things that have just made more aware of through larger media literacy is while US US three rubs are watching movies and wondering how we can engage with them, what it means, what it's saying about the world, a lot of people just watch it and want escapism, which Star Wars provides so plentifully, so pountifully, and they want their characters to kind of exist as ciphers, so they can exists as power fantasies. Yeah, and I just why superhero I've just been so popular, especially since nine to eleven. I just reject I

1:16:14 just reject all of that though. I just can't. But it's true. If a hero is not it's like if your hero is not fallible, it's not. I mean it goes all the way back to the Greeks. I mean you, the hero had to have a flaw, right like you. I don't with you. I agree with you. We are not fighting right now. We are not fighting right I agree with you. We've got John McClain, We've got Indiana Jones, We've got Neo at least in the first Matrix, our favorite heroes, Freaking Skywalker, Han Soolo, these are great heroes. Princess Leah, Uh, Captain and Kurt. They're all making they're all making mistakes left and right. And then you cut to you cut to just to be in vogue, uh Marvel, where any mistake is kind of cut through with some sort of quip based off of the template that iron Man sets, because iron Man's coping mechanism is humor. But that quickly gets adopted everywhere, and suddenly even whenever your character is making a mistake, they are

1:17:44 still above the situation, which is able to connect with a whole bunch of people because the character is in charge at all points. Yeah, I disagree with that. I think that in the Marvel you know, like I'm a huge defender of Marvel, but I think that they do make real mistakes and there are real there are real consequences, Like I'm just I'm just looking at it, uh anthropologically, Yeah, that'sologically Wait wait sorry, yeah, Kenny, what what do you certainly not saying that it's right or wrong? Just noticing audience trends are and you're are you noticing it in the way that people are absorbing it versus the way it is being presented. Yes, Going back to Empire Strikes Back, where Luke Skywalker and Hans Holo make big honkin mistakes.

1:18:35 They trust the wrong people. They whenever they are making active decisions, Han Solo chooses to go to uh, I kind of tune at the last third, he goes to the Lando System. Don't really know what happens after that, damn it. Luke chooses to leave the training, which contextually, within the content text of just Empire Strikes Back, it was viewed as a wrong decision. Eventually, it's right. Those are failures, and the Joy of Empire strikes back that this is a movie that is about failure, and these characters fail fun they I mean, the ending of Empire strikes back.

1:19:15 I told you guys before, the Ending of Empire strikes back. For me, when I was a kid, was just brutal. It was brutal. It was like Luke lost a hand. Han is in carbonate. But you know, there's also this beautiful, little hopeful thing when Lando and Chewbacca go off, and I mean, you know, we're apparently just like a few days out from the beginning of Jedi, a return of the Jedi. You know, so how far away did they have to be from that galaxy to be able to view it the way they were viewing it? Eighteen You know, I've I've I'm just looking at it like that. I wondered about that myself, because it could be there are I'm about to nerd out there are are you guys feeling? With the large Magileanic Cloud and the small Magellanic Cloud, which are actually small galaxies that sort of are attached to or orbit the Milky Way. So my theory is that they're like that that's not the whole galaxy, that that's maybe like a small you know, but yeah, they would have to be like so far away to be able to be able to see it like that. But I don't know. Maybe the Star Wars galaxy is a small galaxy. Oh oh my gosh. Yeah, maybe it's like that galaxy and Men in Black that's inside the ball and the cats very small, very a galaxy. You remember that reveal that maybe rocks I love I've been a black. We're talking a lot about Star Wars. Yes, we

1:20:51 talked a lot about Star Trek in the first half. Okay, yeah, that's what I was thinking. Oh good, I think good that this is good. This is my episode, everybody, this is my time to shine. I mean, we could get into I mean we've touched on the thematic commonalities both films and both servicing as deconstructions. The primary property is that they are calling from so so the the way you use the word deconstruction, like I'm sure it's like accurate in the from like the perspective of film or literary criticism. Then the anthropological sense, so theological logical sense, but the way but the but like, to me, if you're gonna have a one of the things I dislike about Star Wars is not as the same story gets told over and over again. And what I want is and what I love about Empire is that it's an evolution. You know, you call it the deconstruction, but I think it's like the the best way for the story to move forward, like let's do something new, Like let's do the the logical you know, continuation of the story. And that's not just do the story again, which is how I felt about Return of the Jedi. I felt like it was it was a new hope again, you know. I mean, well, Ryan, you're not wrong. That's exactly because Kenny is the one

1:22:24 who brought this up when we originally covered Empire, which is that it was actually an answer to this the feedback or the that, oh, this is not something we feel comfortable with, it does not end happily, this is not what we wanted to be. So they actually went back and basically did the same, right, Yeah, the same thing. It's it's very it's very safe. Well, and I felt the same way about Force Awakens. I thought I felt like Force Awakens was yet another retread of the same story, and then Last Jedi probably at Last Jedi probably fel it fits more in with the deconstruction of I think it's still evolition of but it is doing more of a deconstruction. And then fucking Rise of Skywalker comes in and just does it all again and such a violent course. Course It's like it's like, while Return of the Jedi I think is still a good film, Rise the Skywalker is like, why did I like the last one? I don't understand.

1:23:23 The last one is freaking has wedge antillities in it and that rips dude, that does read remember all those there's freaking horses on the stin Destroyers. That's awesome. I think it was. I think it was because the I was very I was disappointed in Force Awakens, and I was mostly confused by the next one, and which is what Rises the Skywalker, Last Jedi, Last okay, Last Jedi and then rides the Skywalker's the episode nine right or whatever? Yeah, So and so that one felt it felt more, It felt better to me, you know, brings well, it sort of brings it back to familiar territory. My my theory on this or so far away from this thing. But my theory is that, uh, Last Jedi makes people feel uncomfortable because it's severe. It's a lot of failure, it's a lot of like literal deconstruction of what it feels like. It's like, I wonder I like it. Well, no, it's Last Jedi. And then Rise of Skywalker is like, listen, it's gonna be okay, we'll bring back everybody you know. Well, imagine if in Return of the Jedi, Yuh Yoda came along and is like, not only is Darth Vader not your father? Yeah h he didn't actually know any of us. Yeah uh,

1:24:54 And he's actually a robot because because that's what kids on the playground were saying, So you don't have to worry about anything, and you are actually made of light tapers. Right, here's a question for you, please, as someone who saw this as a kid when it came out, sorry to call you out again. Empire, right, is that what we're talking about? Yeah, Empire? And then presumably because I pulled the comparison here, you saw Last Jed I as an adult when you watched when you watched Empire, and it made you feel those things I think I might have already asked a similar question of like what did you do with that? Like what did you take forward with that? Like you were just feeling uncomfortable or was it like I think, I think I did ask you this before and you're like, I guess it was just this is the story. And maybe what I'm trying to get at is like there's this really good quote. It is quote at Brendan Lee Mulligan. I think you know Brandley Melligay is on Dropout. He does to mention twenty stuff, but he talks about stories, and he's like, why do we tell stories to try to make sense of a world that could be terrifying and enormous? And I almost wonder if like let's say we watch you watch a movie where you're like this is scary, but there's still some hope. And as a child, I'm thinking to myself, this is

1:26:25 a way Like if my heroes can make mistakes and can go through this terrible stuff, maybe I can too. And there's and it's the same for like Wrath of Cohn too, Like my heroes weren't a terrible place, but they can get through this. They can move through this, like Spot can die, but we can figure this out, and I don't know what I'm going for. I think maybe I'm like, h like this kind of experience of just watching these properties independent of like like just being twelve years old and watching a property and being like, what is the story telling me? Versus say, being so involved in like the long history of a thing. What everyone on the internet is saying, you know what I mean, like my making sense? Yeah, and we didn't have Yeah, and there was so much less discourse about it because the Internet was twenty years off, so like the or ten to fifteen, so the but you just talked to your friends at school about it and stuff. Yeah, and the there was something I wanted to say, maybe it will return to me. But yeah, I think my experience of it was it's sort of I mean, the whole thing like colors my just my growth and how to appreciate story that it's like can't like

1:28:00 it's impossible for me to like separate it. But I think you make a good point and that maybe the way I could sort of make a good comparison is by comparing it to the last Jedi. You know, my experience with that. But see, the thing is like Empire, I feel like it did some weird things. It did some scary, uncomfortable things, but it's still but it but it, But it made even more sense in the world as I perceived that, you know, the Star Wars universe. It was like, yeah, that fits perfectly with Last Jedi. I did not feel that. I felt like it did a lot of uncomfortable stuff and it did not fit in the I was just like, that doesn't feel right to me, you know, And that could just be because I'm my age and I experienced these in the way I did. You know, who knows so, but I don't know. Go ahead, Kenny, Well, this goes to that thing that Ashton I love to talk about. I think Star Trek doesn't have to do this, but that Star Wars feeling thing that, yeah, every single person about to make a Star Wars movie has to go. We're gonna try and get back to nineteen seventy seven the way that you saw it back in the day. Yeah, exactly. I was supposed to start exactly where whenever Next Generation drops. No one liked it, and to be fair, those first two seasons are rough, and also the orders from on High

1:29:34 were no references to the original series. Don't do it this has to stand on its own except for a brief you see McCoy a little bit, and there's like one sequel to an episode. Other than that, Mentioning the original series is so difficult. So whenever the show got good, then our definition of what Star Trek could be was allowed to be a lot wider. And you know how that the fact that Star Trek has seventy eight different episodes seventy eight different types of stories or seventy nine depending on who you ask, and then the movies that and that fits sort of with the overall world building of each franchise, because you know, we got a long time ago in a galaxy, far far away, used future. You know, all those those iconic things that you associate with Star Wars, they feel more like to me, a you know, repetitive. This is this is about the way human beings have always been, no matter where they are, no matter what time it is, Whereas with with Star Trek, it's about a utopian future and it's about like we're going to move forward and we're going to and things are going to be different. So I feel like the storytelling and each franchise is kind of followed the mythos of each franchise trench even then, so the show it does become it's always pointing towards the utopia. That's correct. That is one of the things that I love so much about Star Trek. And also

1:31:09 how many times does Star Trek violate that notion of we live in a perfect society, but it achieves that Star Trek feeling like Star Trek two not exactly a picture of utopian ideals. But most everyone is just like, yeah, it's the best one, because you know, even though Star Trek six is my favorite, my favorite film of all time, I can't really argue that Star Trek two is probably a better made movie. It's six. Six is the one where they are basically space Chernobyl explodes and it's basically a space We finally clicking on that one. Okay, yeah, okay, all right?

1:32:00 Asked, have you seen Star Trek six? O Kenny so exciting? I discovered country a couple of years. I haven't seen it, so I wanted to. I wanted to. Just I'm going to say one more thing about my my experience as a child seeing the Star Wars franchise, which I was much more invested in as a child than the Star Trek, Like I kind of lost track of Star Trek on Next Track Truck. I lost track of Trek on Next Generation and then got back into it later the But for Star Wars, one of the things that happened was like Return of the Jedi, Like you all said, it was a course correction or it was kind of a going back to the original. And I think the complain of many people who were my age at the time, like we were teenagers and we were trying to be grown up or we were trying to be like you know, and so like the Empire strikes Back was like, oh, yeah, it's so dark and cool, and you know, like, oh he got his handcut off and all that. And then when Return of the Jedi came around, you know, happy Hollywood in everything turns out perfectly. And and also there are ample merchandising opportunities with Teddy Bears in it, you know. The the complaint that's the complaint is oh, they kitty fight it again. But the funny thing about that is that but it was the kitty the kitty fight elements in nineteen seventy seven that got us in in the first place, you know. But then in the mid eighties it was like, no, well, you know, it's so it kind of I think one of the complaints about that people my age have about Star Wars is it didn't grow up with

1:33:33 me. It started to, and then it didn't. You know, so yeah did grow up. Yeah, and Star Treks was people because it did. You find it. The storytelling matures a lot, even though the franchise is still basically people parading around in some version of space pajamas. But because Star Wars there's seemingly is so much less of it, even though there's not. Uh, the economics of it dictate that it consistently goes back to that nineteen seventy seven feeling, and then it becomes recursive because people ultimately get too scared. Even Lucas post Phantom Menace, even though there's stuff maked into Phantom Menace where he's like, that's poetry. It rhymes well. I like, even in episodes two and three he tries to go back more to basics a little bit and does, of course correction and stuff. What do you think asmen? It's not like Ryan wanted to say something, oh thank you, Asmin, I was gonna say, you're gonna you're gonna not like what I'm gonna say, but we're gonna fight. But but we're not. But but Droids and Ewoks those two shows, like, I've never watched to them, I don't think, and I didn't like them because they were a kid's cartoon that was based on Star Wars, which at the time pissed me off,

1:35:09 I know, right exactly, and that and and as a and as a you know, late teen who it just pissed me off. It was like, what are they doing to my Star Wars? And of course the answer is, what do you mean? That's what they've always been doing, except for like maybe Empire and so chill out. Like Kevin Smith said about the holiday special, it ain't Star Wars, but what is? But what is Star Wars? Because exactly what I was just thinking, ok, Droids and Ewoks came from George Lucas, it's Star Wars. This is what he thinks Star Wars is, and the audience and then eventually Lucasfilm were just like, it's not Star Wars. I think we can all agree that it's well, maybe we can all agree that it's all Star Wars. It's all Star Wars.

1:35:55 Or at least I can. But the shit that I mean that that is the fun with start whenever fandom is going correctly, and then you get to play the games of how do all of these puzzle pieces fit? And that's a lot of fun. And then you cut to Star Trek two, which is such a more grown up version of the TV show it is, but it's it's still Star Trek, yeah, except that this time McCoy's going here, I got this robul and al aboord afraid of that brings it in every once in a while, and Kark's like, what's this clean on aperdisiacs.

1:36:43 I'm very fast. I'm very interested in the betrayal of something not aligning with the seasons of our lives, you know, like when you love something. Oh yeah, I want to have a conversation with you that's been in twenty years and hopefully I'll still be alive that I want just just do a I'll be seventy five, but just to see, like how your relationship with Star Wars has changed as one's going to be like, Ryan, You're right, last Jedi is the worst one. Yeah, I see it. Rise of Skywalker a genius piece of cinema. I also liked it because there were horses on that hall. Yeah, because I've sort of said this a few times. I don't know. It's almost like, yeah, Star Trek is to exist outside of the expectation of getting to grow with you, but Star Wars has to. And that is my suspicion too of why when people returned to the sequel trilogy years later, it's like, well, I want this to have grown with me. Look at these people who are the same age as me now or even older. And then if it betrays you, it's like, I feel like, what is this thing to me? It's just a It's just a curious piece of like I I mean, the best also best to comparison I have for myself is Harry Potter U, which fucked Joeyhan, but like I literally read the first Harry Potter book when I was eleven years old, the same age as Harry Potter. I read the last Harry

1:38:14 Potter book when I was seventeen eighteen years old, the same age as Harry Potter. In that book, I think Dean's about your age. I think I think that the same age. Yeah, yeah, yeah, it's wild. It aligned perfectly with me, so we even like went through things at the same time. Like it was wild. Uh that doesn't happen for everybody, you know, And and that was intentional, from what I understand, she did that on purpose, I would sink. Yeah, she tried to age. She tried to age the like maturity level of the storytelling with the age of the readers. So yeah, and interestingly, now you know, I would back when I was less mad, you know, I found myself like the fifth Harry Potter book, for instance, was my least favorite for years. I returned to it as like in my early thirties, and I was like, uh, oh, is this the best book? What just happened? Because it was like the actual clear representation of the real threat of which is not necessarily the big bad, but it's the it's the structures themselves being on the side of it, and you know, like effectively like oppressing individuals and it's not necessarily who you might think. And I was like, oh my god, because I'm like in the midst of like Trump presidency shit, and like now this thing is actually very much making sense for me, and now I can't read any of them because but yeah, perhaps Joe Anne's

1:39:54 living in a culture where we're just more aware of how the audience communicates with these things. And then just to bring it back on the theme, how interesting that both of these things are allowed to grow into something that is more emotionally rich without the direct involvement of the creator overseeing the day to day. Yeah. Sure, that's kind of amazing. Yeah, yeah, I wanted to say, this is something that's been in my burning in my head about. I know, it's called Star Wars because they fight and start trek because that was right, because they voyage, right. I know you love the prequels Aspen, Do you love the prequels? I love the Star Wars prequels.

1:40:45 Okay, okay, yeah, so and I I was like slightly disappointed in the prequels, but I wasn't like on the like I'm never on the like extreme fandom train, Like I never like, I'm just like you people need to calm the fuck down. But but but something that the prequels did do, like that I thought was amazing was they brought like they made watching the original trilogy so much more intense, like when you like, I've seen these these things on YouTube where they cut scenes between the prequels and the original, like the original Star Wars, like you know, well, your father was killed by a young Jedi named Anakin Skywalker. And then they show the battle between between Obi Wan and you know, it's like, and the look on that person's face that they did in the movie that came out in nineteen seventy seven looks like they know, but they didn't because nobody knew what was going to happen. Nobody knew what with the prequels were going to contain.

1:41:49 George might have known a little bit or had some idea, right, and and and it's just amazing, like the way it all fits together, and like I can watch I can watch a New Hope now and it's so much has so much more depth because of the prequels and because of everything else in Star Wars. It's like, oh my god, you have no idea all the stuff that's going on there. And and I think the thing is is at the time you kind of felt that like, oh, there's a lot going on here, because they were implying that there's a lot going on here, but they didn't know exactly what it was. And then later on they you know, it's like, oh, well, here's what it was, and that just works so well, well, if you're interested in that, can I interest you in the Clone Wars? Actually I actually started. I've watched. I've watched a couple of seasons, but I got I got bored of it. So there's there's a lot that is yeah, so you're like, okay, cool, and then there's a lot of it that you're like, this is peak television, right. I think you probably just skip to Star Wars Rebels because that's what I did. Rebels was good from the get go. Are you you could watch uh, you could watch arcs of Clone Wars that are very specifically good. I started watching Rebels with Dylan. We watched a few Star Wars episodes before he yeah, before he got tired of it. But yeah, and then it's it's like, you know, and sort of the culmination of that whole effect is the last episode of the first

1:43:25 of this I guess it's the second season of The Mandalorian where Luke appears right and you're and you're you you're the top of your head blows off because it's like Luke Skywalker at the peak of his powers, you know, suddenly appearing in context in the right and it's just like, this is amazing. So but I know, are you say you like that this is but by Kenny Kenny, I'm kind of with you, Kenny. But it's funny. I want to make space for the fact that like that probably did affect people way differently than it affected us, and like it sounds like it affected Ryan and a like fuck yah kind of way. We had a reaction, Okay, but really it's so funny because my reaction was, oh my god, this is so awesome and so amazing, and like I'm in tears, like because it's so beautiful to me. You were talking in our Patreon episode, which you know, you can find a patreon dot com sast truck horse pod for five dollars a month for how much? How much am I five dollars a month a month talking talking about Spielberg being a manipulative filmmaker, and make no mistake, he is. I buy into that. But whenever I see Luke Skywalker at the tail end of Mandalorian, I'm going, oh boy, they are manipulating the audience into having an emotional moment that that is not earned.

1:44:47 Based on the soul merits of Mandalorian, as a TV show total, Luke Skywalker serves no he there is no emotional connection between this as opposed to like, imagine if a character that we had met with in the context of the show had come in and saved it, and you were cheering, But there is an emotional connection if you're me, Kenny, this is like what I was arguing to you about all of a Soca. Right. What Ryan experienced is like what I was experiencing watching a SOCA, And now I have a lot more empathy. And what you watch and what you watch first, what you watch first and what pulls you into the franchise has a big effect on how you view the rest of the franchise and how it feels to you.

1:45:40 And so like we all have to like have we all have to have like tolerance for our different experiences of the franchise. Yes, Star Wars was the first movie I watched on this planet? Is that true? Yes, a new hope. Star Wars Empire Strikes Back in Return of the Jedi were on a v HS that my mom kept in perpetual circulation. I wasn't even a year old. I'm talking about newborn status. Well, that's why he couldn't remember anything, Kenny, So like those movies are like, Kenny, it sounds like what you were trying to say is art is a binary Yes, that's right. And what we're trying to say is art is subjective. You know, it's either good or bad, Kenny. If we ever know, if we ever do a podcast together, Kenny, which I think we are destined to do sometime down the road because we keep like toying with it with things like this, But if we ever do a podcast together, it's going to be we're gonna We're gonna dig into the the whole. We're gonna make some sense of the whole subjectivity, the whole subjective experience of art thing that's or of media thing. That's what we're gonna do. I mean, art is totally subjective, of course it is. Well, I guess while you're having that podcast time, I'll just go fuck myself speaking. I'll be busy

1:47:15 speaking of fucking myself. Yeah. I think it's time to play our podcast favorite game, I starship It. I've been thinking about this, you guys a long time ago. Start dating. This week, I quoted a boat, I dated a game, but none of them could warp mine drive into hyper space. The best of both worlds kept me in the second place. Captain slog on a Halla Kron. I wanted a song. I pend a song. Seventy more minutes subvise in super high dev afore the USS Enterprise dt F. Don't you take my walk lighter and clip it. Don't you take my red shirt, buddy and nip it. If you spill the tea, I'm gonna sip it. A starship it it's so good, it is good.

1:48:27 I'm so impressed by that. Now that's been What is so good? What are we about to do? We're about to give our Oh shit, I hope I wrote this down from last week. We're are our favorite ships as in the ships that fly in space and in the sky, and also her favorite romantic ships from both properties. And this is any vehicle, right, Yes, it could also be any vehicle, which is an intendant. We had to add because we've been watching Ewoks. Makes it easy, I think, right, because it could be anything. You could do a haunt on. You know, it can be anything. I'd say that you're you're you're writing, but actually I say it was easy. But this is incredibly hard because there's so much iconic shit in both of these films, I mean, every single going on. It's so difficult to choose. And I and you know, I've been listening to past episode yell and how Aspen always kind of cops out and makes some cheesy thing about the relationship, like like the character and freedom or the character and themselves or something like that. Yeah, that's right, I wishy wash, she spit me out of your mouth, just giving you just just as they say, taking the piss Aspen, but giving you shit. But British friends of ours. Yeah yeah, but uh yeah, I've been thinking about it and it's hard. But who's going first?

1:49:58 I wrote down stuff, and I'm like, where did I write it down? Okay? Wait, what excellent question? Where did I? Where did I write it down? Everybody? Did you write it down in an X wing? Did you write it down in the Millennium Falcon? Did you write it down on the on the Enterprise or on Chekhov's little ship whose name Reliant? There we go, Reliance. Okay, I do know what it is for Empire. I do have mine, and it is the Executor H, which is Darth Vader's ship. Ah, it's scary. I am like often very overwhelmed by the size of things, you know, just in general and the size. They do a good job in the film of showing just relative size too, because it can get lost, right, it is so massive, it is so huge, huge, and also like the design of it is different than other destroyers Star Destroyers. It's incredible, yes, Kenny, I mean it helps that our first moving image in Star Wars, the motion picture that is not the scroll, is how large that first Star Destroyer is, and so whatever you see is bigger. It's bigger. Do you think that George Lucas whenever he was in the design phase, he was like, uh, can we get a bigger triangle? Yeah, I'm sure it

1:51:30 was. That looks like it's got to look like there's like a whole city on the triangle. The whole triangle is one big city. It is one big city, like Coroissant is one big city. The whole planet is the whole. That is an excellent choice, Espen. I'm really glad you chose that. And just just for some stats on this, of course, it's Execator class start dreadnoughts. So the ship is over sixty two thousand feet in length, has britspiled by thirteen colossal engines and Class one hyperdrive. Oh more than a mile long. More than a mile long, has over five thousand turbo layers. Oh my gosh, I can carry more than one thousand vassals.

1:52:10 Oh my, well, just be aause it's a mile along. Doesn't mean that it's better than me. True. You know what, guys, as as I think we know from Empire strikes back, size matters or not. As ex girlfriends have told me, size matters. That is such a cheap joke and everybody makes it all the time. But yeah, you know, I'm sure your penis is nice. That's very kind. That is such a very sweet to thank you, thank you, it's great, is very nice. And I'm sure your vagina is lovely as well. Thank so much, Thank you so much. You're welcome. Speaking of nice penises, Ryan, what is your best starship? This is so tough, okay, an Empire. It's so so to difficult because we got we got fucking Luke's X Wing being used as his personal ship for the first time, like as opposed to like it's a fighter he flies to. You know, it's like this is the ship that he gets him around. Right, we've got the fucking Millennium Falcon, which is like the most iconic ship in all of science fiction.

1:53:30 It could be argued, maybe not be the Enterprise, Okay, don't pay attention to Kenny's face, but I was. And then you've got cool things that are like only in Empire, like the fucking snow speeder. First appearance of the cool snow speeder, right, and then you got the much the the like I think it should get more attention is the Transport. That's a cool looking ship, the Transports and oh the big the big white poopy. Yeah, it's it's pretty cool. Come off of that they're running away with from hawth right. Oh yeah, also for what it's worth to A and ATSDS. But oh my god, no, I know I made a list. I made a list. Could you not now? The little cloud city ships? You just confused me. It's too it's too difficult. But I think, but I think I know what I'm gonna pick. I think I'm picking uh Tonton's. And and the reason why is because as I was watching it this time, with the noises they make and everything, I figured out that they are cold weather, big riteable pugs. So which is nineteen you know, so I and they and they and when and that scene when they cut the one open to put Luke in to so he can survive.

1:54:55 That I mean, very clever. Yeah, so I'm I'm going with Tonton love it. I love how Kenny. We've been like struggling and suffering with this for months and now we're like, we have too many choices. There's there's so many in this in these both of these movies. Yeah, it's true, we're just picking, I mean, not to many. In Star Trek two, we really have. That's a good point two ships in a space station. However, the Reliant, which is my choice NCC one eight six four, good choice, critical piece of ship building. And here's why, folks, outside of the animated series, this is the first different federation, different starfleet starship that we've seen in live action period. Yeah, you're right, every single other ship, because making science fiction is expensive, we have only seen other at the time, starship class ships, I eat, other versions of the Enterprise, right, And the producers were like, Okay, the Reliant is Starfleet, but it has to be different so we can visually track it. And so originally the design was delivered, but it was delivered with the engines above and instead it was delivered to them where it was upside down and they're like, yeah, good, And so that's how we got the design of the Reliant's cool. It's a tiny, scrappy ship.

1:56:32 And also one of the things that is difficult about the Star Trek design is that, as opposed to Star Wars at some point, I mean, Star Wars is so good at being able to indicate scale. Star Trek's ship design ethos is that things, at least at that time, is that ships are smooth because you put because and the thinging is Matt Jefferies was like, if you put anything on the outside of a ship that is going fast, faster than light, if it breaks off, it could kill someone. True, which is why that everything is smooth and so reliant. You see bring in some aspects of Star warship design, and there are some things that are able to add scale and detail, like the little roll bar at the top that has the torpedo launcher, just different things. It's a smaller ship, scrappier ship puts up a heck of a fight. It's fabulous. And also what is great and I love about star Trek because they love to pinch pennies.

1:57:40 That the bridge of the Reliant is just the Enterprise bridge, just painted blue. Yow, that's cool. I love it as supposed to Star Wars where they have their money cannon. They're like, there's a problem money cannon. Well, and I think that brings Another great thing about about Ratha Conn is that you get to see two Federation starships in combat with each other, which is fucking cool. So yeah, it is true in a nebula, which is fab Yeah, trite them. Oh gosh, so good. They'd do a submarine fight in space. It works. Speaking of you, should you should watch Greyhound if I haven't told you that already. Right, it's a new it's a Tom Hanks movie. He adapted it from a book and then he stars in it. And it's only available at Apple because it was released right, it was supposed to be released at the right about when the pandemic happened. But I remember this, I remember that movie coming out the classes ship that my grandfather was on in World War Two, So it's like kind of cool to watch. But anyway, go ahead, I picked that ship.

1:58:45 I picked the ship that your grandfather was on. Oh, that would be the USS Ross, a Fletcher class destroyer that is the only destroyer in US destroying World War two to survive two mind hits. And my grandfather was on it for both of those and he came back and as my mom says, he never talked about it. So there you go. Trauma, yes, trauma which which got passed down to me in weird ways. But anyway, moving on, liking Rise of Skywalker, the correlation, no wonder you're not anymore. I have clients come in. I'd be like seeing you movies lately, and they'd be like, I love Roque One. I'd be like, you're fucking idiot. I like one because it's like the first Star Wars movie that's actually a war movie. Fuck you. I never said that.

1:59:54 Sounds like you've got some intergenerational trauma fucking on you. Rogue one. My Star Wars rankings go Empire Rogue one, Rogue one is two. So there you go. All right, now, let's talk about some romantic ship. By the way, are we supposed to do in each franchise? Each of us is supposed to do an each franchise? How did you get one shot? You get one shot? You get to pick either of them. I think I still chose correctly. Good. Yeah, yeah, no, no, no, no, I I thought Kenny might have picked the Reliance, So I think it's I think Kenny was supposed to pick the Reliant. I think that's what it needed to be, and Kenny was the guy to pick its. So now we got to do romantic ships from either of them.

2:00:43 I know there's actually a lot to choose from. There were a few, well, I mean Jesus, christ Lea and Han, you know, like, yeah, I just we're just gonna forget that huge one, you know, or have I have Han? No, I think no, because whenever we did our first Empire, we weren't doing our starship. No, I don't want it because part of the reason why I called you out cheesy cop outs on this one is because I'm going to do a cheesy cop out. I'm going to do me and Star Wars. That's my sort of my name's Ryan Hill. You want me to do, I'll do mine right now, I'll do Okay. So mine is because and this actually could apply to either franchise, but because both of these franchises make me think about my dad so much, whom I lost about a year and a half ago. Is Mine is all the relationships that these two franchises facilitated, all the real world relationships that these two franchises made better. I know, right, I knew you like that, And Kenny gave me a thumbs down. Yeah, because it's not an answer. I like it, But every time, every time you did it what I've been calling a cheesy cop out Aspen, I've been thinking about what I'm going to do, and this is the one that like stood out for me because these two things mean so much to me because of my dad. My dad took me to CDs and you know my daddy, so

2:02:18 is my dad. Let's see I Mine is Land Han, well, fuck it should be listen listen and this is the movie where you have to do it because it's the first one where they really start getting into it when they're in that little space. Oh my god, he's so fucking creepy. And like I think we've talked about this before where I like feel like I have I'm less frustrated by it, and because I think she has such agency and she's written with such agency, so it makes me feel like it's less creepy because there's like a rather than him having more power, she has a different type of power. So that's why it works for me. And then also it's just like she's like, I happen to like nice men. He's like, I can be nice, and he like grabs her and he kisses her, and I was just like, hoh dog. But as I said in the first Empire episode, Han Solo's first lines of dialogue is him trying to get to say by de lay and Lea's like see it. And so Han Solo is the one that's but her because he's he's got so into her, he's got feelings, he's so under her. She's she's stunning, and I mean Carrie Fisher is smoking hot, and then she's like incredibly strong and independent

2:03:48 and like how yeah, yeah, I actually have on my wall. I have that like what are they called when you have like the pics sure of the silhouette and profile silhouettes, Yeah, silhouettes and profile And it's like two pieces, like the one is like a land it says I love you, and on the other side, I have Han it says I know, oh, I know. That moment is so hilarious. My dad laughed out loud at that moment. I remember it, and he just thought that was so funny. It's so in character. Yeah, my dad wanted to think that he was Han solo like so many men. But yeah, you know, so yeah, okay, So if I was going to pick a real relationship from the movies, it would be Kirk and David. So like, I mean, I know it's not romantic, but again, it's like, I love how David is like fuck this guy. From the very beginning, he's like, fuck this military piece of shit, and then at the end he's like, I was wrong about you. I mean, it's it's awesome.

2:04:56 So it also seems like he doesn't know that his dad is Kirk, Yeah, which is fabulous. And then apparently that conversation just happens off screen. Happens off screen. Yeah, and if David sees a man broken at the end because he's their interaction is Kirk saying, uh, would you like a drink? I just poured myself one, And he's trying to compose himself because he's just thrown his broken glasses down and he's trying to read a Tale of Two Cities, and David's very sweet to him, like David. He's not, He's not He's real with him. He's like, you've never really experienced death to have you know, you've not really faced death, and but you know he's good to him though. It's nice. And the fact is my Dean, David is my Dean to to to Captain Kirk. If I'm Captain Kirk, then David is Dean. You know, Dean is my open thirty two year olds. Then Dine ling A Lang, Dane ling A Lang.

2:06:04 Yeah. The fact that whenever they hug, it is just the most awkward hug. I know, it's it's so powerful. I've heard that. I've heard that Shatner has like a terrible relationship with his daughter as well. I'm sure. I'm sure. I'm sure. Do you know who shows up in Psych as one of the character's dads and he's also a piece of shit in that show? The character not It depends on who you ask, I'm sure. Anyways, most people, Hmmm, I can't really ship Kirk and Carrol on the the they have such a wonderful chemistry. Why not do what?

2:06:51 Okay, I'm gonna ship Kirkan Carol Marcus, Yeah, yl Mark, who wonderfully did not appear in her underwear in this film. The huge frustration I had with the modern one with Carol Marcus. I mean, Star Trek into Darkness is a trash fire, basically the risest sky of the Star Trek franchise. But yeah, what is unfortunate about how great they are together is that fandom kind of took that and went Kirk and Carol Marcus they are a couple of goals. They are true loves to each other, as opposed to how it is here, which is they are very much just like we have a mutual understanding. Yeah, they are adults. They understand that their lives are not compatible. But I think they still have a great amount of respect for each other. Yeah, were we going to be together? Were we ever going to be? I wanted him in mind devastating line, and then Kirk is going, how do I feel? I feel? Old? Worn out, tired? It is it is too much bread? Yeah, and he says that he says that line, Yeah, I love a good Lord of the Rings quote. And then Gandal puts the Genesis device in an envelope until

2:08:22 comes back and he puts it away for seventeen years. Gandal says, keep it secret, keep it safe, Safe, I'm trying to help you. The Kirk can care I mean again Star Trek two. It's a very grown up version of the TV show. And what is so wonderful about Shatton's performance throughout is how worn out he is and the button at the end of him feeling young because he's just never felt lost like this before. It's really beautiful, how fascinating that for Kirk, the experience of the failure, the loss, the challenge that maybe making the wrong choices or whatever might look like is what reminds him of like a life worth living, which I feel like ties right back to the idea of like The Empire is a hard film and what does it mean to be like we can make it through this thing. That's what the stories are for, speaking of making it through this thing. I feel like we are finally at the end of the episode. Wow, Kenny, do you not like it when Ryan and I talk about things? No, art is a binary. Also, we're just like we are going bad.

2:09:48 I took him nap earlier though, so just so you know, I took a nap. What we gotta rank this. We gotta rank this on a scale of one to ten. We do again. Uh for a reminder, the properties again are started to the Wrath of Khan versus the Empire strikes Back and uh Ryan, uh, animal's discretion. Would you like to start us off? Yeah? Boy, So we're supposed to rank it one to ten. Huh yeah? And which one do you want to you want to start with? Yeah, let's start with Empire, starting with Empire? Nice. I'm so reluctant to give anything a ten because and don't because because there well I recently heard you guys give something at ten. I can't remember city.

2:10:41 Yeah, which is perfect well played. Although I have my issues with Harlan Ellison as well. But uh yeah, some of his some of his short stories. Have you ever read I have no mouth and I must scream and tell me what you think of sounds metal? No? I read oral History is about mad Max Ferry wrote not yeah is uh he Yeah? He can be so dark. But anyway, let's see. Do I want to give Empire strikes Back at ten? Yes? You agree with me? AskMen? Right? Yeah? Yeah, you should give it a ten. Just give a ten to give it a ten? Do it? Yeah? Do it? Do it? Your coward? Nice try. I know I'm a coward that doesn't bother me. Let's see nine point I'm gonna give it a nine to seven nine point seven because things can always be better, and I could think of a you know, it's like yeah, so yeah, but it's yeah, but it's but it's definitely the best Star Wars film. So yeah, there you go. I'm gonna give this one eight. Yeah, I'm giving it an eight good movie. Perfection doesn't exist. I'm giving it

2:12:11 a ten. Huh. I like that because I was like, perfection doesn't exist, therefore I can't give it a ten, and you're like, perfection doesn't exist, therefore I will give it a ten. Yeah. Nice? And do you have I don't. Well, we'll get into it. Start Trek two, uh Emmi Emil Hill, Oh God, poor ride. You guys are used to this. Oh but I still do this though, I'm like, huh oh, why didn't I think of this beforehand? Like a stupid improviser, I didn't prepare right? Okay, as as God, it's so good. I I and even on rewatching it, like the how long after the first time I saw it? Fifty no, forty years after the first time I saw it? More than forty years after the first time I saw it, it was it was even better. It was like better than I thought it was going to be. And the media that grows. Yeah, but I still and the weird thing is now now I like it.

2:13:33 Forgive me now, I like I came into this being more of a Star Wars person than a Star Trek person, But I actually now I like it at least as much and maybe more than Empire. But back in the day, I definitely like Star Wars more. Jesus, I'm and having said that, I'm going to have to give it a nine point eight. It's just so good. Yeah, I'm gonna give this a nine point eight as well.

2:14:13 Wow, that's that'll be. That'll be the most precisely that our tastes have ever aligned. Kenny, ten, perfection doesn't exist. Well done, well done. I love it how you gave both of them at ten. That's great swing for it. Uh. For me, I feel like Wrath kN Obviously I'm biased for Star Trek, but I feel like Empire Strikes Back feels like an incomplete story fundamentally versus Wrath of Khan, which is a complete thesis. But there is still better Star Trek out there. Which means what a squeaker This week, folks, squeaker. The Empire strikes back with a very robust nine point two three, which compared to our initial ranking of just an eight versus Star Trek to the Wrath of Khan coming at a nine point eight seven, which means love it quite satisfied for this baby boy. Star Trek wins the week. I think that's I think that's accurate. Star Trek should win this week, but just barely. And they're both very highly rated.

2:15:33 Just barely. Yeah, Well, I think the real winner this week is us is the friends we made along the way? Wow bye? Remember remembering Rise of Skywalker where Chubaka dies, Oh god, but then turns out he was on another ship that was identical. Yeah, you remember when C three po lost his memory for three minutes? Why why are we bringing this up? You know? Why are we clowning on our great friend Ryan? Ryan? We love you, you know. I I will admit that I that my evaluations of films are very gut level. They're very like, oh I love that, how dare you? It's not dare you? Just enjoy things and it's when I hear people and it's one of the reasons why I like, I deeply appreciate like your your study and of film and of media and everything Kenny. But then also I find it like you know, like eh, I didn't like it or I liked it, you know, which is also outrageously valid because at the end of the day, these things are are made just to entertain. Even art is a binary. Absolutely, Brian, you said that you appreciate Kenny's like study. Do you just appreciate me for being funny? Oh? There are so many feelings. I'm so sorry.

2:17:09 I didn't want to. Did that come across as that I didn't appreciate you. No, no, no, not at all. No, no, no, no no, I just wanted you to say something nice. Oh, okay, I appreciate. I appreciate so many, very many things about you, so hard to it would be hard to like enumerate them all. The tallest person I've ever met, I'm very average. That's that's what's great about Aspens, the tallest person I've ever met. Whenever I speak to Aspen, I feel very seen and I feel very connected to her, and that is that is the greatest thing about Aspen to me. So well, folks, it's been a great podcast, Ryan for folks that are fans of you. Are there any places that you can direct folks to go see more of you? Listen to more of you? Boy? Uh, not really.

2:18:03 Oh, Fragile Rock my band, my crazy stupid band that I'm in, which is an emo puppet band. We are about to record an album in the next couple of weeks, congratulations, that will be coming out soon. But you could also go see our tiny disc consert. Just look it up on YouTube at Fragile Rock on you know, tiny desk and yeah, so and you'll see me in the background playing guitar. But that's kind of my main thing these days is that's like my main creative outlet is Fragile Rock. So yay. It's very talented and very kind and wonderful. I hasn't got anything to plug oh besides this podcast. Yeah, well yeah, two shows as they come up, people could cut. I mean, if people are in Austin are listening to this as it comes out, I guess there's a show I was on that was Tim Burton Themes that gets a bonus.

2:19:05 Yeah, yeah, coming out on the I'll be on the sixteenth. Yeah, just hanging out, you know. But I'm also like teaching, I'm prov I'm I'm very proud of the Christmas lights I put on my house over the last few days. So if you I'm not going to tell you where I live, but if you happen to drive by my house, they're pretty cool where you live. My children are adorable? Yeah, yeah, okay, all right? Outstanding And uh, folks, if you are eager to get into the conversation with us, shoot us an email. Check Warspod at gmail dot com. Additionally, uh, if you just loved this episode you're eager to get even more, hop over to our website, trek warspod dot com, where, if you are so inclined, please leave us a review.

2:20:00 Click on the reviews tap at the top of the page and leave us a review, or follow over to the podcast of your choice leave us a five star rating there as well. Also, if you just love this so much and you want to do even more than just leave a great review, when'd you hop over to the Patreon Patreon dot com slash trak wars pond where for fight dollars a month you can get early versions of these episodes and extended versions of these episodes and talk with us such as we got a comment aspin is it my partner again? Yes, it is comment on our episode what does it Mean to be Culturally Humble? Otherwise known as our Friday's Child versus Heart Cell, slash a Warrior and Alerto. The comment goes Friday's Child two things, number one McCoy the crypto Catholic confirmed and number two Mama Maya.

2:20:58 So I really appreciate that insight, no idea, and you two could leave comments like that if you hop over to our Patreon, Patreon dot com, Last Truck Coarse Pod, and you could join the wonderful auspices of fine folks such as Timbou, Dessa, Eily, Bryce Love, Heidi Rogers, Kevin Miller, Mark Vibert, Ryan Hill and oh that's Ryan Ryan. I like the Ryan that's on you, This Ryan I have. I have Patreon, like I think at least the last like five podcasts that Kenny has done. Oh see, just Air is a very good supportive front. Well. I also just like the content a lot. So I can I can ride my bike and not be bored and it's like I took a couple of friends on a bike ride with me. It's really nice speaking of bringing a couple of friends on a bike ride. We brought two friends on this bike ride music wise, and that is Jolty partner delivering our I starship at song and Awa Fay. So thank you so much, Ryan, Oh my god, such a good job. If you need, if you need any music done for anything, I recommend getting in touch with do. It's like Tostin does.

2:22:15 Like yeah, the music for all of our everybody, all of our friends, podcast entire Austar and improv community, anybody who does the podcast Tosawa Music. So Ryan, thank you so much for doing our podcast. You guys. I love you, buddy. It's so good, true, it's gonna blast. I love you buddies, both of you, buddies. I love you both. Please tell your respective partners or dating peoples that I said hello, same to you. We'll do. And your children, Yes, my beautiful children. I meant to tell you. You remember the light up unicorn ball you gave to Dylan for Christmas a few years ago? Do you remember that? Do you remember that? You don't? You got Dylan? You got Yeah, you got Dylan. You got Dylan in the Secret Santa and I but I did I also give him like an Elmo. You gave him a lot of different things, but the light up unicorn balls was very popular for a long time until it died. Oh my gosh. Well I just I hope you know that what you gave me, and that's a good Santa's also belove it. I'm like, I can say what it is. You have to say what it is. It's a remote control what's can I can't?

2:23:24 I remember his name? Do O. It's do O. It's a remote control Doo. The Rise of Skywalker the best part of rises. There we go because he's like, don't touch me, take you no, thank you. He's up. I have him up on like my my shelf of stuff and he's there. He's up there. I want I wanted to report on him. So yeah, I sometimes drive him around. It's just and freak out my cat. Sorry, audience, audience, we love you. Yes, Live long and prosper, and may the Force be with you, amen, amen, and also with you